A Study On Causes For Deaths and Injuries in Construction Sites in Sri Lanka
A Study On Causes For Deaths and Injuries in Construction Sites in Sri Lanka
2021
This Research Project was completed as part of the BSc (Hons) Quantity
Surveying at Liverpool John Moores University. This is my own unaided work.
Where the work of others has been used or drawn on then it has been fully
attributed to the relevant source.
Date: 25/05/2021
[i]
Table of contents
Abbreviations ..................................................................................................... ix
[ii]
3.4 Sampling ........................................................................................... 19
[iii]
4.4 Questionnaire survey ........................................................................ 51
References........................................................................................................ 64
Appendices ....................................................................................................... 69
[iv]
List of figures and tables
List of figures
[v]
Figure 18: Percentages of consequences of accidents in Sri Lankan
construction sites during 2010-2020 ................................................................. 34
List of tables
[vi]
Acknowledgements
This thesis is the final resultant of a long and coordinated effort that comprised
the contribution of a fair number of people. So, it is my duty to make at least the
briefest remark on those persons, without whom, I would not have been able to
achieve a plausible outcome.
[vii]
Abstract
The construction industry is important for the social and economic development
along with the national fiscals of any country. However, on the other hand, it has
been recognized as one of the most hazardous industries in many counties
around the world because of the nature of activities and tasks performed at
construction sites. Similarly, present-day construction industry of Sri Lanka
prioritizes and considers safety as a primary, complex issue due to its high
frequency. Accordingly, the aim of this study is to identify the causes for deaths
and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka and identify actions to mitigate those
accidents. Consequently, four objectives were developed so the research aim
can be reached successfully, and those are: to identify the various types of
accidents recorded, to identify the resultant deaths and injuries, to establish the
specific causes for deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka during
last 10-year period and to recommend strategies to minimise the accidents
resulting from the identified causes. The data collection was in the form of
documentary review, semi-structured interviews and questionnaire survey. This
study found that the 9 most prominent types of accidents that have occurred on
Sri Lankan construction sites include falls from heights and scaffoldings, falling
debris, materials or objects and machinery accidents. During the last 10-year
period 2,135 accident have been recorded in the construction industry, among
which 311 were fatal accidents, accounting for 37% when compared to other
industries. Usually, most of the accidents at a construction site are due to the lack
of safety at site, working without PPE, risky behavior and unsafe act, poor
housekeeping, inadequate training and lack of supervision. Further, it was also
observed that recommend strategies to minimize the identified 9 prominent types
of accidents and to improve construction site safety. Findings of this research
could help towards reducing the accidents in construction sites and developing
safe work environment in the construction industry in Sri Lanka.
[viii]
[ix]
Chapter 1 - Introduction
1.1 Background
[1]
2012). De Silva and Nawarathna (2014), identified that when paralleled with other
industries, the construction industry is the most vulnerable due to the recorded
number of yearly accidents in between 750-900, among which 50 to 60 were
fatalities. Furthermore, according to De Silva and Wimalaratne (2012), more than
30% accidents were symbolized by this annual figure which was approximately
13 times greater compared to other industries. Therefore, it is clear that, a plenty
of accidents have occurred at Sri Lankan construction sites. However, it is
mentioned in the NationalrInstitute ofrOccupational Safetyrand HealthrAct, No.
38 of 2009 (b) of Sri Lanka, that advises to the government on preventive
measures for accidents and injuries relating to occupations at work places as well
as research, investigations, surveys and study programs in occupationalrsafety
andrhealth, willrbe supplied byrthe institute.
Construction industry has set a higher accidents record which result in lower
productivity levels, absenteeism from work, delay in completion of project,
damage to plant equipment, increment in expenses, loss of reputation of the
constructors, permanent disabilities and even deaths etc. (Fung et al., 2005).
Thus, construction sites are usually labelled as dangerous, unsafe or hazardous
places of work (Sherratt et al., 2013). Usually, most of the accidents at a
construction site are due to the lack of attention to safety at site, unawareness of
the safety precautions and lack of training (De Silva and Nawarathna, 2014). This
is due to the fact that most of the construction workers are hired on a temporary
basisrand manyrof themrare unfamiliarrwith construction processes. Also, human
errors were emphasized to be a leading root cause for accidents in construction
sites (Hinzeand, 2000). Ahamed, et al. (2011), informs that risky behavior and
unsafe acts of labours owe to 90% of accidents. Further, Somasundarawaran, et
al. (2005) recognized that lack of safety at construction sites, lack of
organizational commitment, poor technical supervision, working without personal
protective equipment and limited legislation requirement for safety of workers at
construction sites as the primary explanations among causing factors for
construction accidents in Sri Lanka.
[2]
face also change. Therefore, prevention of accidents has progressively evolved
to be vital aspect in the construction industry. Consequently, all efforts to identify
and discoverrpossible waysrof preventingrand controllingraccidents shouldrbe
sought after, henceforth the need for the study arises. In this sense a
comprehensive assessment and serious analysis of accidents at construction
sites, are of importance, leading to the mitigation of them and enhance the quality
of work environment and quality of work life of employees. Accordingly, this
research was conducted to study the causes for deaths and injuries in
construction sites in Sri Lanka, and was based on the data documented by the
Sri Lanka Department of Labour, Industrial Safety Division. The data regarding
accidents in the past may be of use to create predictions about the impending
numbers and types of accidents that are likely to take place. In addition, with
these findings, efforts could be taken to form operational accident prevention
programme in construction sites in Sri Lanka.
What are the causes for deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka and
how to mitigate those in future?
The aim of this study is to identify the causes for deaths and injuries in
construction sites in Sri Lanka and identify actions to mitigate those accidents.
[3]
1.2.3 Research objectives
2) To identify the resultant deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka
during last 10-year period from objective 01 above.
3) To establish the specific causes for deaths and injuries in construction sites
in Sri Lanka during last 10-year period from objective 01 and 02 above.
Once a proper foundation for research aim and objectives was established by
reviewing relevant literature, the documentary review was conducted by
evaluating the statistical data sourced from the industrial Safety Division of Sri
Lanka Labour Department. This review was intended to achieve the first three
objectives of the research study. Then semi-structured interviews were held with
the selected industry professionals and a questionnaire survey wasrdeveloped in
orderrto verifyrthe informationrgathered onrthe firstrthree objectivesras wellras to
reach the fourth objective successfully. The data collected were then analyzed
and entered in graphs, pie charts and frequency distribution tables etc. for
representation purposes. At last, the findings from the four objectives were then
utilized tordraw uprconclusions andrrecommendations tormatch.
[4]
1.2.5 Research methodology road map
[5]
Chapter 2 - Literature review
2.1 Introduction
This chapter will study literature relevant to the causes of deaths and injuries that
occur at construction sites. The purpose is to form an understanding and a
foundation for the four objectives that will be later be instrumental in achieving
the research aim. The review will progressively flow from understanding the
occupational accident; to understanding the world’s statistics of construction
accidents; to reviewing the records of construction accidents in Sri Lanka; to
discovering the general factors contributing the occurrence of construction
accidents; and then finally to discuss the impacts on construction projects that
on-site accidents have. Literature reviewed, was excerpted from research
papers, conference papers, books, articles, reports and journals. The same will
be studied cognising the similarities, common themes, differences, contradictions
and criticisms.
[6]
the normal responsibilities of work in the post or job that they were employed in
when the accident occurred. Incapacity that results from occupational accidents
can be permanent or temporary. Instances of permanent incapacity for work are
the cases in which occupational injuries forever barred the victim from performing
again the usual tasks in the post or job that they were employed in when the
accident occurred (ILO, 2017). The International Labour Organization (2017)
further clarifies, Instances of temporary incapacity are cases of worksite injuries
where the victims were not able to perform the usual tasks from the day that after
the accident, but with time were able to perform again the normal duties of work
in the job or post that they were employed in when the accident occurred. For an
injury to be classified as a temporary incapacity, the worker should resume in
their job within a year from the day of the accident (ILO, 2017).
17%
Construction - 60,000
Other Industries - 295,000
83%
[7]
Furthermore, the ILO estimates that in industrialised countries which employ
between 6% to 10% of national workforce in the construction sector, 25% - 40%
of the total number of deadly occupational accidents may be reported from the
construction worksites. When it comes to health, in France, 20 percent of
diseases that come under work-related diseases according to the workers’
compensation system, are originated in construction worksites. In a European
survey carried out in 2000, it was pointed out that 16% of workers in construction
sites, were exposed to toxic chemicals for 50% of their employment, which
exceeds the exposure in all other sectors. It is speculated that 10% of bricklayers
in the UK give up employment yearly, owing to allergic dermatitis that results from
handling cement (ILO, 2017). Also, from 2017 to 2020 period in the UK, 2.8% of
the construction workforce underwent an injury and this is statistically higher than
the all-other industry rates (HSE, 2020).
The US Bureau of labour Statistics 2019 point out that, a total of 1,061
construction workers lost their lives, citing the highest fatality rate among the
industries in the United States. And also, according to Ling, et al. (2009), the
numbers of occupational accidents in the construction sector in US and
Singapore show the highest rates of death among the 24 to 34 age group, 80%
of skilled manpower, and 50% during or just before the tea break. Moreover,
according to Shao, et al. (2019), from 2009 to 2019, approximately 7,275
construction employees in China died from construction-related accidents, with
an average of 1.99 deaths per day. 1,116 occupational accidents were reported
[8]
during the period from 2011 to 2016, from construction sites in Malaysia. Among
which 37.85% - 51.50% of the incidents caused permanent and temporary
disabilities, and deaths (Ayob, et el., 2018). Unfortunately, more than 6,500
migrant workers have died in Qatar while working on the construction of stadiums,
airports and other facilities for the FIFA World Cup 2022 (The Guardian, 2021).
The data have been complied since Qatar won the hosting rights for the football
world cup in 2010, during that 10-year period there was an average of 12 deaths
per week.
When it comes to South Asian construction industry, which carries the highest
numbers in construction accidents regionally, Kanchana, et al. (2015) found that
the Indian construction workers make up 7.5% of the total global workforce and
have been victimised in 16.4% of fatal global occupational accidents. According
to PBS 2014, Pakistan employees 7.3% of the workforce in the construction
industry. However, its accident rate stands at 14.1% which exceeds all other
industries. Whereas every year 150 workers died in average, and thousands of
workers were injured due to on-site accidents in Bangladesh construction industry
(Ahmed, et al., 2018). Further, back pain and muscular-skeletal disorders are also
common in the construction industry. The ILO has estimated that 30% of
construction workers in some countries suffer from back pain or other
[9]
musculoskeletal disorders. Being exposed to asbestos is also a generic risk faced
by the workers in construction. Despite its use having been discontinued and
prohibited in some countries, many buildings still comprise of asbestos and
construction workers may risk being exposed to the dust created from asbestos
during refurbishments or demolitions (ILO, 2017). Additionally, MEPI (2017)
found that, fatal injuries sustained during constructions cost the United States
approximately $5 billion each year in lost income, lost production health care and
reduced quality of life. These are alarming statistics which underscore the
urgency for a coordinated effort to create, implement and assess novel
approaches to effectively solve this issue.
The Ministry of Labour – Industrial Safety Division in Sri Lanka, is the only
organization with the jurisdictive power to regulate occupational/industrial safety
and health. It is also the primary agency to provide occupational safety services
in the country. Even though there are few other semi-governmental organisations
such as Occupational Hygiene Division and Industrial Service Bureau and
National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), they do not have
the legal authority to administrate the law related to occupational/industrial safety
and health (Dissanayake, 2016). However, the Ministry of Labour lacks
institutional capacity to resolve these problems by itself, while the burden of
mortality and morbidity caused by occupational hazards have to be undertaken
by the Ministry of Health (Darshana, 2017).
Darshana (2017) stated that according to the recent statistics of the Labour
Department of Sri Lanka, it is shown that from 2012-10-01 to 2013-09-30, 392
employers reported accidents. However, the 2013 performance report of the
Labour Department of Sri Lanka shows that only 3.5% employers have reported
accidents. In the same duration, the Accident and Orthopaedic Service of the
National Hospital of Sri Lanka had 11,047 patients who sustained occupational
injuries. This is from a total of 105,217 patients. The number amounts to a
percentage of 10.5% from the total. From these accidents it was revealed that in
2013, 30% of the total accidents were from construction industry. The percentage
was about 25% in 2004 (De Silva and Nawarathna, 2014). Not only that,
[10]
Darshana (2017) found that, in 2015 the Accident and Orthopaedic Service of the
National Hospital of Sri Lanka treated 102,321 patients, among which 12,322
were victims of occupational health hazards. That is a 12% from the total number.
Out of the fatal accidents, a staggering amount of 50% were from the construction
industry. Further, Weerasinghe, I. (2013) stated that as per the ICRA Lanka
report, the construction industry contributed 27% to the national index of fatal
accidents in 2011.
Also De Silva and Nawarathna (2014) mentioned that the construction industry in
Sri Lanka has an accident percentage that goes well beyond the same rate in any
other industry (accidents that resulted in minor to fatal accidents are included in
the rate). However, these numbers do not attest to the true context, since only
less than 60% of accidents were recorded. People tending to get treatments by
themselves, limited coverage of reporting procedure and lack of awareness of
legal reporting requirements etc. were recognised to be the factors contributing
to the reduced reporting rates (De Silva and Nawarathna, 2014). It is evident
here, that the site safety of Sri Lankan construction industry, is a matter of grave
concern.
[11]
2.5 General factors contributing to construction accidents
[12]
workers are the most causes of accidents that occur in construction sites. Al-
Kaabi & Hadipriono, (2003) found that, poor site management, work in highly
elevated positions, lack of skills and experience of the executives, insufficient
worker training and equipment failure to be the most frequent causes of
construction site accidents in the United Arab Emirates. Udo et al. (2016)
revealed that the most common causes of occupational accidents in the Nigerian
construction industry were the lack of personal protection measures while
handling and lifting materials/objects, slips, trips on objects, collapses during
excavations, operating damaged equipment, being stricken by moving
objects/machines/equipment, and falling from heights. Haslam et al. (2005)
stated that accidents are resulted by lack of coordination among workers or work-
teams, malpractices in storing materials, poor housekeeping and lack of personal
protective equipment and machinery. Incompetence of the construction design
and method, economic effects faced by clients and owners, improper project
management, lack of safety education and training and risk mismanagement
were also identified to be the major disruptors by Haslam et al. (2005). An all-
inclusive study was conducted by Ogwueleka and Chinweude (2013) to analyse
the causes of construction accidents. It was pointed out by the research that the
most influential factors were safety awareness of top management/ project
managers, managerial commitment, insufficient machinery safety management
procedures/ practices/reviews, training or expert knowledge and negligence or
faulty judgement. Tsang et al. (2017) identified working conditions, environmental
factors and management actions as the three main types of factors that contribute
to accidents in construction sites.
[13]
workers and the medical expenses. Similarly, Chim et al. (2018) mentioned that
delays in project completion, bad reputation of the organization, dissatisfaction
among stakeholders and penalties from authorities are the most serious impacts
of construction accidents affecting the construction organization.
Figure 7: Negative impact of accidents to the construction companies (Chim et al., 2018)
Okolie and Okoye (2012) emphasised that the importance of protection measures
in construction sites and the safety of construction workers can never be stressed
too much. They argued that when accidents happen on-site, they cause many
human tragedies, demotivate workers, increase overall project cost, delay project
progress, disrupt site activities, and affect the project productivity. Furthermore,
Mthalane et al. (2008) distinguished many economic impacts that site accidents
have on the construction companies. The more prominent effects were the loss
of productivity, damages to plant/equipment/completed work, disruption of
current work, training cost that entails employee replacement, medical expenses,
costs of compensation, cost of rescue operations and equipment, loss of function
and operations income, expenses incurred in settling injury or death claims, legal
fees and increased insurance cost. In Hrymak and Perezgonzalez’s (2007) study
carried out case studies on twenty construction sites in Ireland, and it was shown
that there was a plethora of negative costs and effects to the employer in terms
of financial, that arise from on-site accidents. The study identified that payments
for alternative workers or overtime payments, retaining costs, repair costs,
expenses for increased supervision, production and productivity losses,
compensation for injury claims, quality failures, disputes and litigation. Moreover,
[14]
Li and Poon (2009) revealed that Hong Kong had an extensive number of lawsuits
regarding monetary claims for victims of non-fatal accidents that occurred in
construction sites. The construction industry in Hong Kong was also identified to
have suffered the following consequences; the time loss on schedule, conflicts,
adverse effects on worker psychology and legal issues. Trinh et al. (2018)
revealed that the construction accidents had remarkable interrelations with the
quality of the final outcome of a construction project. The study identified loss of
scheduled time, cost overrun and employer dissatisfaction as other results of
construction accidents.
2.7 Conclusion
[15]
Chapter 3 - Research methodology
3.1 Introduction
This chapter focuses on the methodology by which the research aim and
objectives were achieved. It introduces the criteria used to select which
participants should be included in the study, explains who the participants were
and presents the method of sampling. The research design that was chosen and
the reasons behind the choice is described in the chapter. The data collection
technique and the procedure that was followed during study are also explained.
Furthermore, the researcher discusses the data analysis methods used. The
ethical issues that might arise in the course of research are covered in the end.
In conclusion, through this section the reader gains a thorough understanding of
how the research study was approached from start to end, and how the required
knowledge was gained inrorder torconclude therresearchrstudy.
The research design is a framework of processes that will together form the final
outcome of the research. Qualitative, quantitative and mixed methods are the
most popular approaches used by the researchers in collecting data to design
their studies. Quantitative approach is useful when a researcher needs numerical
values to prove their theorem. Here, the respondents are asked to give statistical
answers. When there is a need to collect opinions, suggestions or ideas from
resource persons with distinctive expertise on the matter, qualitative approach is
usually used. A composition that is inclusive of both quantitative and qualitative
approaches is called the mixed approach. It is used where data is required both
numerically and suggestively. The mixed approach facilitates a more diverse data
collection for the study, which will in turn enhance the probability of delivering
suitable findings at the end of the study.
The mixed design approach was elected to be ideal for this study, because both
qualitative data and quantitative data are required in data analysis to achieve the
research aim successfully. According to the research objectives, quantitative
approach is required to identify the various types of accidents, their impact as
[16]
well as their specific causes during last 10-year period in construction sites in Sri
Lanka. Similarly, qualitative approach is required to recommend strategies to
reduce accidents that occur originate from the above-mentioned causes, with the
help of the perspectives of project managers, health and safety officers, site
supervisors and the like. It is understood that such data cannot be obtained
through a numerical study. This provides adequate justification as to why mixed
approach, which complements the interconnection between quantitative and
qualitative data, is ideal for this research.
Identificaion of Methodological
Research Literature Framework to
Problem, Aim Review Fulfil the Aim and
and Objectives Objectives
Conclusion and
Recommendations
[17]
philosophies: pragmatism, positivism, realism, interpretivism. The appropriate
limitations to the philosophy of this project were established with cognisance to
the research question, aim and objectives. Since this study has the mix design
approach selected as the method of collecting data, the philosophy of the study
was led towards the pragmatism approach. Furthermore, the study involved a
combination of deductive and inductive perceptions that would collectively form
the design.
Once a proper foundation has been laid for research aim and objectives by
reviewing relevant literature, objective one, objective two and objective three was
achieved by collecting statistical data from the Industrial Safety Division of Sri
Lanka labour Department. The collected data was used to gain a fair
understanding of various types of accidents, their resultants as well as their
specific causes during the last 10-year period in building construction sites in Sri
Lanka. Once a fair synopsis of the first three objectives is reached, the
questionnaire survey was developed and interviews were conducted with
professionals of the industry. This further verified the initially collected information
on the first three objectives, as well as in order to achieve the fourth objective
successfully, which recommended strategies to minimise the accidents that
resulted from the identified causes.
[18]
3.4 Sampling
Data was collected, analysed and evaluated to establish the aim and objectives
of the research. The type of data collected was “primary”, which means the data
was collected first-hand and be up-to-date. Sharma (2017) has opined that
primary data are relevant to the research, making such data very accurate and
useful. The research technique to be discussed includes the sample of
respondents that were utilised in the data collection process, the methods used
in collecting data and the analysis process. The subjects were further discussed
hereunder.
The three objectives which are; to identify the various types of accidents recorded
in the construction sites in Sri Lanka during last 10-year period, to identify the
resultant deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka during last 10-year
period, and to establish the specific causes for deaths and injuries in construction
sites in Sri Lanka during last 10-year period was achieved by collecting statistical
data related to building construction projects from the Industrial Safety Division
of Sri Lanka Labour Department. The data collected was then analysed and
entered in graphs, pie charts and frequency distribution tables etc. for
representation purposes. Mean score analysis was applied to compare data in
the analysis process.
[19]
3.5.2 Semi-structured interviews
The participants were asked to rate the level of effectiveness from 1 to 5 degrees;
which are no impact, low impact, moderate impact, high impact and very high
impact respectively. Depending on the structure of the questionnaire, there were
[20]
close-ended and open-ended questions. Furthermore, it was designed with a
maximum of 20 questions, so that the participants do not feel like the survey was
consuming too much time. This also expected to encourage and increase
participation in the survey.
Arpilot studyrwas launched before preceding the main data collection, to assess
if the questionnaire survey and interview questions designed were successful in
extracting required data for analysis. Castillo-Montoya, (2016) has opined that
pilot interviews further bolster the protocols as they can help identify limitations
and flaws within the design of the interview. That way there is chance to
incorporate necessary alterations to the major project, before continuing. The
pilot interview for this study, was conducted collaborating with the representatives
of Sri Lanka Labour Department and the research supervisor.
Data sourced from the Sri Lanka Labour Department was separated into key
themes based on the objectives and extracted information (e.g., various types of
accidents i.e., fatal, non-fatal etc.). Then the data was recorded in tables with the
use of MS Excel to ensure that analysis and appraisal are easier. Firstly, the most
commonly occurring types of accidents in construction sites of Sri Lanka in the
past 10 years were singled out. The research study then progressed based on
the same. Using the data tables, charts were created, and a ranking system
developed. To rank the effectiveness of the preventive measures that were
proposed by the industrial professionals during the interviews, therRelative
ImportancerIndex (RII) wasrused. As mentioned above, the research participants
were asked to grade the efficacy of the recommendations from 1 to 5. Based on
the formula given below, the scores were then turned into important indices. This
was instrumental in determining the relative ranks of the recommendations
prescribed.
[21]
"W” denotes the weighting, ranging from 1 to 5, that the respondents gave to the
recommendations. “A” (i.e., 5 in this context) is the highest weight that can be
attributed. “N” represents the total numberrof respondentsrthat participated in the
research.
∑𝑤
𝑹𝒆𝒍𝒂𝒕𝒊𝒗𝒆 𝑰𝒎𝒑𝒐𝒓𝒕𝒂𝒏𝒄𝒆 𝑰𝒏𝒅𝒆𝒙 (𝑹𝑰𝑰) =
𝐴𝑁
Also, content analysis was used to analyse the data which gatheredrfrom
interviews and questionnaire survey. This simplified and made the collected data
more edible, while producing results that may then be measured using
quantitative techniques. This was expected to make the results clearer, so more
accurate conclusions could be made. The end goal is to develop practical and
pragmatic recommendations from the achieved conclusions.
When conducting this research there were certain ethical issues that required
careful consideration of the researcher. Informed consent of the participants was
the most prominent one. Accordingly, all participants were made aware prior to
the surveys and interviews about the purpose of this project. Additionally, written
consent was obtained from all respondents. The identities as well as the names
of the organisations they are employed in, were held in strict confidentiality, in
accordancerwith therrequirements ofrthe universityrcode ofrethics. Therprivacy
and confidentiality policies of all of the companies were considered and
respected. Finally, all the information collected in the course of this research
studyrwas onlyrused forrthe academicrpurposes, andrnot misused in any way.
[22]
3.9 Summary
The chapter discussed the research design that was used at length. Following
the design, the methodology integrated for the research was also described. An
amalgamation of qualitative and quantitative research approaches was used for
this study. Documentary review was the data collection method in order to
achieve the first three objectives of the study. Addition to that, a series of semi-
structuredrinterviews andra questionnairersurvey werercollectively form the data
collection to achieve the fourth objective successfully. For both interviews and the
survey, the population sample was determined with ‘selected sampling’. The
primary findings were cross-referenced with the data collected, as a method of
analysis. Preferably, this enabled the research aim to be attained satisfactorily.
[23]
Chapter 4 - Argument and evidence
4.1 Introduction
This chapter analyses and evaluate data collected through documentary review
from the Labour Department, semi-structured interviews and questionnaire
survey. As discussed in the previous chapter, this was instrumental in achieving
these four objectives: to identify various types of accidents recorded in
construction sites in Sri Lanka during the last 10-year period, to identify the
resultant deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka during last 10-year
period, to establish the specific causes for deaths and injuries in construction
sites in Sri Lanka during last 10-year period and to recommend strategies to
minimize accidents resulting due to the above causes. Furthermore, the results
were displayed in tables and graphs for visualization purposes and to derive a
final conclusion.
[24]
4.2.1 Various types of construction accidents
One very common risk that the construction workers and passers-by are
susceptible to in working environments where work is being carried out at
elevated positions, is the possibility of being hit by falling debris, materials,
equipment or any other objects. Falling objects, materials or debris, can cause
devastating and even fatal accidents onsite. The type and the degree of injury
sustained may vary, depend on the weight and size of the object, as well as the
height from which it was released. The only potential victims of such accidents
are not construction workers. When there is construction being done on a building
near pedestrian walkway passers-by could be also in danger. The Industrial
Safety Division of Labour Department has pointed out that falling
equipment/material and debris account for around 17% of all occupational
accidents sustained by employees of the construction industry in Sri Lanka.
[25]
working around such powerful machinery comes with large attributable risks. In
fact, accidents caused while operating heavy-duty machinery have been
speculated to be one of the most common causes behind occupational accidents
that resulted in bodily injuries and even deaths. When heavy machinery is being
used on a construction project, the risks posed are not limited to the onsite
personnel. All persons in close proximity of the operation, including the driver, is
in the zone of possible danger. According to the Industrial Safety Division of Sri
Lanka Labour Department, this type of accidents account for approximately 13%
of all accidents faced by construction workers in Sri Lanka.
4.2.1.4 Electrocution
[26]
construction employees were stuck between two vehicles or moving machinery
parts. Another type of such accidents is when body parts are pulled into machines
with rotating or rolling parts. According to the Industrial Safety Division of Labour
Department, this type of accidents account for approximately 11% of the
accidents faced by employees of the construction sector in Sri Lanka, while being
on-duty.
Slip/trip and fall accidents are another one of the leading causes of injuries on the
construction sites. Fromrstray toolsrand materialsrto unevenrground or holes,
thererare many hazardsron arconstruction site thatrcould leadrto ardangerous
slip/trip and fall and these could be occurred while working from heights as well
as at the ground level. The lack of friction or traction between the foot and the
ground may cause a person to slip. A trip is when someone’s foot hits something,
causing them to lose balance. Generally, unexpected or unintended changes in
the contact between the feet and the walking surface result in both slips and trips,
and often leads to falls. According to the Department of Labour, about 7% of the
accidents that occur in Sri Lankan construction sites are slips/trips and falls.
Fires and explosions are accidents with devastating consequences, and care
should be exercised at all times as to avoid such risks. Since fires and explosions
could not obviously be contained, these accidents might potentially injure or kill
anyone who is in the proximity of the fire or the explosion as well as employees
and passers-by within long distances of the source could be harmed by flying
debris and objects. The gasses and chemicals that might be emitted in such an
accident, can exacerbate the aftereffects. Flammable liquids and chemicals,
electrical equipment, pressurized containers and the likes stored in construction
sites may present many hazards, if not properly managed and stored. According
to Sri Lanka Labour Department, this type of accidents accounts for
approximately 6% of all occupational accidents suffered by employees of the Sri
Lankan construction sector. However, stringent safety measures and procedures
have proven to be effective in reducing the likelihood of such accidents.
[27]
4.2.1.8 Trench collapses
4.2.1.9 Overexertion
[28]
25% Falling from heights or scaffolding
22%
Falling debris, materials or objects
Other types
0%
Figure 11: Percentages of types of accidents in Sri Lankan construction sites during 2010-2020
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Other industries
Construction industry
[29]
37%
Construction - 311
63%
Other Industries - 538
This pie chart illustrates fatal occupational accidents that occurred in Sri Lanka
during 2010 – 2020, against the industry in which they took place. In the 10 years
under consideration, a total of 849 fatal accidents were reported across all
industries in Sri Lanka. 311 of these fatal accidents happened within the
construction sector. All other industries combined reported 538 fatalities. As the
pie chart indicates at a glance, these numbers amount to 37% of all fatal
occupational accidents in Sri Lanka in the 10-year period of 2010-2020, taking
place in the construction industry. That means more than one in every three fatal
accidents were reported from construction. It is also notable how the fatal
accidents in the construction sector exceeded the number of deaths in all other
industries in 2011.The gravity of the statistics should be understood with
relevance to the number and scale of all other industries in Sri Lanka. As such,
the implications are undeniably concerning.
(Sourced from the Industrial Safety Division of Sri Lanka Labour Department)
[30]
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Other industries
Construction industry
12%
Construction - 1,824
[31]
industry. Other industries in Sri Lanka have reported 13,394 accidents. These
numbers translated into percentages indicate that 12% of the occupational
accidents that took place in Sri Lanka in the given timeframe, could be attributed
to the construction industry. 88% of the non-fatal accidents occurred in other
industries. However, it would inadvertently be noted that the percentage of non-
fatal accidents reported to the Sri Lanka Labour Department, are substantially
lower than the fatal accidents in the same. Construction workers getting individual
treatments after non-fatal accidents without reporting it as an occupational
accident, could be a main reason behind this difference. Consequently, these
numbers should not be looked at in isolation, as it may distort the reality.
(Sourced from the Industrial Safety Division of Sri Lanka Labour Department)
1600
1400
1200
1000
800
600
400
200
0
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
Other industries
Construction industry
[32]
13%
Construction - 2,135
This pie chart shows the percentages of occupational accidents that were
reported from Sri Lanka in the time period of 2010 to 2020, against the industry
that they were reported from. For the purpose of the study, the sectors have been
recognised as construction and other industries.
When considering the number of accidents reported from the construction sector
per year, the overall trend from 2010-2020 has been on the rise, despite some
minor deviations. After reaching a record high of 250 accidents per year in 2018,
the numbers have considerably declined in 2019 and 2020. The impediments that
followed the coronavirus pandemic and lockdown situations. A total of 16,067
occupational accidents were reported from Sri Lanka in the period 2010-2020.
This is inclusive of fatal and non-fatal accidents. Out of this, 2,135 accidents were
classified under the construction industry. 13,932 accidents were communicated
to the Labour Department from all other industries combined. As percentages,
these numbers indicate that 13% of all reported accidents were from the
construction sector. The remaining 87% could be attributed to other industries in
Sri Lanka.
(Sourced from the Industrial Safety Division of Sri Lanka Labour Department)
[33]
45%
39%
40%
35%
30%
25% 22%
20%
15%
15%
10% 8% 7% 6%
5% 3%
0%
Consequences of accidents
Figure 18: Percentages of consequences of accidents in Sri Lankan construction sites during
2010-2020
(Sourced from the Industrial Safety Division of Sri Lanka Labour Department)
[34]
4.2.3 Causes of identified construction accidents
Following table emphasizes on the specific causes for the 9 prominent types of
accidents that have occurred on Sri Lankan constructionrsites inrtherlast 10-year
period which were collected through documentary review from the Industrial
SafetyrDivision ofrthe SrirLanka LabourrDepartment.
[35]
Types of injuries
Types of injuries
[36]
Machinery accidents Causes
Types of injuries
Electrocution Causes
[37]
Failing to provide ground-fault protection for
workers
Not disconnecting the power supply before
carrying out constructions around live wires
Wires with damaged insulation and covering
Improper use of extension and flexible cords and
touching a damaged extension or flexible cords
Not following manufacturer instructions when
using electronic appliances
Types of injuries
[38]
Types of injuries
Types of injuries
[39]
Not following manufactures’ instructions while
handling or working with the flammable liquids,
chemical and gases
Smoking at work and around flammable liquids,
combustible materials, gases etc.
Insufficient signage warning for passers-by to keep
them out and to take necessary precautions
Workers are not properly trained and/or
supervised
Handling chemicals and flammable liquids etc.
without any necessary Personnel Protective
Equipment (PPE)
Products of liquids, chemicals etc. do not display
proper warnings
Types of injuries
[40]
Improper trench reinforcement (shoring) and
trench boxes to prevent sides of the trench from
caving in
Working close to the trench with heavy machinery
that vibrates around the trench
Types of injuries
Overexertion Causes
Types of injuries
[41]
4.3 Semi-structured Interviews
This section is based primarily on the opinions that were expressed by the
participants. Industrial professionals with at least 5 years of experience and
knowledge in building constructionrsector in Sri Lanka were interviewed in order
to achieve the fourth objective which is: to recommend strategies to minimize the
accidents resulting from the identified causes. Adding further to the fourth
objective, recommendations to improve worksite safety were also collected
through the interviews. The initial intent of the researched was to interview 6
professionals in the industry. However, 4 out of 6 predetermined candidates
agreed to take part in the interviews.
Number of Years of
Respondent Job Role
Experience
01 Project Manager 27
02 Health and Safety Officer 11
03 Engineer 8
04 QA/QC Engineer 13
The opinions of the respondents mentioned above, were of great use for the
researcher throughout the course of the study.
[42]
Type of Accident Preventive Measures
[43]
Ensure toe boards are in place and inspected
frequently.
Use barricades to block off exclusion areas where
workers are not allowed or below the work area
where drop hazards may exist.
Do not exceed the lifting capacity of a crane, lift or
hoist.
Make use of nets, canopies or platforms to catch
debris and objects.
Post warning signs at hazardous work zones.
Wear protective safety gears such as helmet,
hard-toe boots etc. at all times while on the job.
Educate workers to stay away from barricaded
hazard areas, areas with posted signs warning
about the potential for falling objects.
[44]
Make sure that appropriate machinery and
equipment are available to perform tasks safely.
[45]
Turn off all machines and vehiclesrwhen theyrare
not in use, whenrchanging accessories, andrprior
torservice or cleaning.
Strictly follow the maximum weight limits
prescribed when lifting, moving and storing loads.
Wear seat belts when driving or operating
machines or vehicles to avoid being thrown out
and crushed in the event of an accident.
Wear protective safety gears at all times while on
the job.
Barriersrto keeprpeople awayrfrom dangerous
machinery/equipmentrof vehicles.
Slips/trips and falls Make wearing work boots with slip and puncture
resistance mandatory for workers.
Make sure all areas have adequate lighting to
illuminate any potential hazards.
Clean up spills, drips and leaks immediately.
encourage workers to keep the working space
clean whenever possible.
remove garbage and debris etc. at regular
intervals.
Keep walkways free from obstacles and keep
walkways free of clutter.
Post adequate warning signs at hazardous areas
Controlling individual’s behaviour through regular
monitoring.
Regularly inspect worksites to identify any hazards
that could potentially cause slips, trips or falls.
Extensiversafety trainingron therprevention of slip,
tripsrfalls shouldrbe providedrfor employees.
[46]
and using electrical equipment, chemicals, gases
flammable liquids etc.
Separate ignition hazards and combustibles when
storing.
Ensuring that only authorized and qualified
personnel handle explosives.
Banning the consumption of alcohol, drugs and
smoking by employees at the construction site.
Wearing adequate PPEs while handling
chemicals, flammable liquids etc.
Reducing fire risk by preventing overheating and
regular maintenance.
Make sure that hot works are carried out in a
separate area situated well away from explosive
substances and the main structure.
Waste should be minimized whenever possible
and disposed of as soon as possible.
Make sure the fire exits and escape routes are
clearly marked, and kept unobstructed.
Ensurerworkers receiverappropriate trainingron
procedurerthey needrto follow, includingrfire drills.
[47]
A competent person must inspect the trenching
and excavation operations.
Use proper arrangement to barricade the area
being excavated.
Eliminate the cave-in hazards due to weather and
climate by rescheduling the task or changing the
task.
Employees should not be assigned to work
underground if water is leaking or accumulating,
unless precautions are taken well in advance.
A qualified person should carefully examine and
evaluate soil conditions.
Before working in and around trenches,
employees should receive training on trenching
safe practice and on recognizing hazards.
[48]
4.3.2 Recommendations to improve construction site safety
Respondent R3 stated that Sri Lanka lacks rules and regulations regarding health
and safety measures. He was concerned that the law enforcement agencies were
rather lax on the subject of onsite safety. Therefore, he recommended that new
rules and regulations be implemented by the regulatory bodies regarding the
health and safety of construction sites. Respondent R3 further opined that the
establishment of an organisational framework must be considered immediately,
to aid in policy implementation. It should have closely defined roles and
responsibilities at various level for all personnel, and should ensure that safety is
[49]
integrated into the operational activities. Finally, he emphasized the requirement
of adequate insurance policies on construction risks.
Planrout short and long term safety budgets to ensure the adequacy of safety
implementationronrsite
[50]
Conductrweekly formalrsafety meetingsrat therproject level
[51]
Job Role Number of Participants
Project Manager 3
Deputy Project Manager 1
Senior Quantity Surveyor 2
Draughtsman 8
QA/QC Engineer 2
Engineer 12
Assistant Engineer 4
Health and Safety Officer 3
Site Supervisor 6
Quantity Surveyor 8
Assistant Quantity Surveyor 18
27%
Consultant
73% Contractor
[52]
31% Less than 5 years
27%
5-10 years
10-20 years
24% 73%
More than 20 years
4%
10% 13%
Diploma
Degree
Masters
71% Chartered
In the section B of the questionnaire survey, the participants were asked to rate
the level of effectiveness of the recommendations that were initially given by the
industry professionals during the interviews. The ranking ranged from degrees 1
to 5; which are norimpact, lowrimpact, moderaterimpact, highrimpact andrvery
high impact respectively. To determine the relative ranking of the
recommendations the scores were then transformed into importance indices
using “Relative Importance Index” (RII) formula. The following table shows the
[53]
Relative Importance Index of each recommendation based on the effectiveness
to improve the construction site safety in Sri Lanka.
[54]
The table above shows the RII rates and their ranks calculated according to the
feedback given by the questionnaire survey participants regarding the
effectiveness of improving construction site safety. The highest ranking (1st)
recommendation is to “provide proper safety training for all employees”, with a
0.866 RII rate. The 2nd highest ranking recommendation is to “make regular site
safety inspections” with 0. 842 RII rate. “formulate safety regulations and policies”
is the 3rd highest ranking with the 0.821 RII rate. According to the results of the
questionnaire survey, rankings 4th, 5th and 6th are “identify, asses, evaluate risks
and decide precautions” (RII = 0.809), “proper project planning” (RII = 0.797) and
“conduct daily safety meetings each morning for employees” (RII = 0.785)
respectively. “Ensure that all new employees are givenran appropriaterorientation
regarding safety and safety inspection” with 0.773 RII and “Use coercive
enforcementrmechanisms suchras fines” with 0.746 RII arerranked in 7thrandr8th
positions in the table. The 9th, 10th and 11th ranking recommendations are
“develop incentive programs” (RII = 0.737) “conduct weekly formal safety
meetings at the project level” (RII = 0.701) and “introduce new technologies to
workers” (RII = 0.719). “Record findingsrand updatingrin relationrto therwork
condition”, “plan out short term and long term safety budgets to ensure the
adequacy of safety implementation on site” and “implement total safety
management at an organizational level” are ranked in 12th, 13th and 14th positions
in the table. The questionnaire survey participants were of the opinion that
“discuss onsite safety in management meetings” and “adequate insurance
policies on construction risks” are the least effective out of the given 16
recommendations to improve construction site safety. Those recommendations
are ranked in the 15th and 16th positions in the table with the 0.654 RII and 0.42
RII respectively.
4.5 Summary
This chapter analysed and presented findings of this research. Data obtained
through the documentary review, semi-structured interviews and the
questionnaire survey, were instrumental in achieving the research objectives.
The following are some of the key findings gathered from the data collection
process, listed out to provide a brief overview.
[55]
The 9 most prominent types of accidents that occurred in Sri Lankan
construction sites in last 10-year period were identified.
Statistical data of fatal, non-fatal, and total construction accidents in Sri Lanka
during last 10-year period were compared to that of all other industries.
[56]
Chapter 5 - Conclusion and recommendations
5.1 Conclusion
To identify the various types of accidents recorded in the construction sites in Sri
Lanka during last 10-year period
The documentary review utilised statistical data sourced from the Industrial
Safety Division of Sri Lanka Labour Department in order to achieve the first
objective. Accordingly, the 9 most prominent types of accidents that have
occurred in Sri Lankan construction sites in the last 10-year period were
identified. Those accidents are as follows;
3) Machinery accidents
4) Electrocution
8) Trench collapses
9) overexertion
“Falling from heights or scaffolding” accidents were the most common type of
accidents that occurred in Sri Lankan construction sites. Those accidents account
[57]
for approximately 22% of all on-the-job accidents of construction workers. The
2nd most common type of accidents that were recorded was “falling debris,
materials or objects”, accounting for 17% of on-the-job accidents of construction
workers. According to the statistics, 13% of accidents were from the “machinery
accidents” and “electrocution” categories. Additionally, “being caught between
objects”, “slips/trips and falls” and “fires and explosions” accounted for 11%, 7%
and 6% of total number of accidents that occurred on Sri Lankan construction
sites in last 10-year period, respectively. There were also 5% and 3% of accidents
caused by “trench collapses” and “overexertion” in construction sites according
to the statistical records of the Industrial Safety Division Sri Lanka Labour
Department.
To identify the resultant deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri Lanka
during last 10-year period from objective 01 above.
A total of 16,067 occupational accidents were reported from Sri Lanka in the
period 2010-2020. Out of this, 2,135 accidents were classified under the
construction industry. As percentages, these numbers indicate that 13% of all
reported accidents were from the construction sector. In the 10 years under
consideration, a total of 849 fatal accidents were reported across all industries in
Sri Lanka. 311 of these accidents took place in the construction sector. These
numbers amount to 37% of all fatal occupational accidents in construction
industry in Sri Lanka in the 10-year period of 2010-2020. That means more than
one in every three fatal accidents, were reported from the construction sector.
When considering the number of non-fatal accidents during the last 10-year
period, 15,218 accidents were reported to the Industrial Safety Division, among
which 1,824 occurred in the construction sites. These numbers, when translated
into percentages, result in 12% from the total occupational non-fatal accidents
are happening in the construction industry. Furthermore, this research analysed
[58]
the varying consequences of occupational accidents that occurred in construction
sites of Sri Lanka. Almost two-fifths of the accidents that inflicted considerable
damage, 39% to be precise, resulted in physical injuries. Approximately 22% of
such accidents effected bodily fractures. 15% of such reported worksite accidents
in Sri Lanka resulted in death of one or more persons.
To establish the specific causes for deaths and injuries in construction sites in Sri
Lanka during last 10-year period from objective 01 and 02 above.
Based on the research evidence, several major causes have been discovered for
the 9 most prominent types of accidents that have occurred in Sri Lankan
construction sites in the last 10-year period which were collected through
documentary review.
[59]
range of factors, some of which were singled out to be improper trench
reinforcement and trench boxes, placing spoil pile too close to trenches, and
failure to provide daily inspection of excavations. The major factors that led to
“Overexertion” of workers, were found out to be long working hours in high
temperatures, workers not being in acceptable physical conditions and workers
not being provided with necessary training and supervision.
The research study has highlighted a number of essential suggestions that were
given by the construction industry professionals in the semi-structured interviews,
to minimise the 9 most prominent types of accidents that were identified to have
occurred in Sri Lankan construction sites over the last 10-year period.
[60]
caused by persons “being caught between two objects”. “Slips/trips and falls” can
be prevented by providing slip resistant boots and puncture resistant soles.
Similarly, by requesting and encouraging workers to keep the workspace clean
and by placing warning signs appropriately, slips and falls can further be
prevented. “Fires and explosions” in construction sites can be prevented by
allowing qualified personnel to handle explosives, banning consumption of
alcohol, drugs and smoking by employees around the construction site, and by
ensuring chemicals, flammable liquids etc. are stored and used in accordance
with the manufacturer’s instructions. Byrensuring properruse ofrshoring, sloping,
benching, trench boxes or trench shield and by keeping excavated soil (spoils),
equipment or other materials at least 2 feet from the edge of excavations many
“trench collapses” can be avoided. Moreover, a competent and experienced
person must regularly inspect the trenching and excavation operations. To
prevent “overexertion”, supervisors should check whether the workers are in
optimal physical condition before a job is assigned to them. The tasks provided
should be switched regularly to increase variety of physical movements, and
workers must be provided with appropriate training in relevant tasks to increase
skills and efficiency in executing them.
[61]
recognise the root causes for the identified accidents to establish effective safety
measures to mitigate accidents in Sri Lankan construction sites. Therefore,
further research is required to find out root causes of identified 9 accidents that
will be essentially beneficial in preventing accidents in the construction sites in
Sri Lanka more effectively.
5.3 Recommendations
[62]
developed to reward those who adhere construction site safety protocols and
health checks of employees should be conducted.
Daily safety briefings should be conducted before the duties commence, and
formal safety meetings should be conducted weekly at project level in order
to take necessary decisions about site safety.
[63]
References
Ahamed, M., Nafeel, A., Rishath, A., and Dissanayake, P. (2011) Site safety of
Sri Lankan building construction industry [online]
Available at: http://www.civil.mrt.ac.lk/conference/ICSECM_2011/SEC-11-76.pdf
[Accessed 20th of January 2021]
Ayob, A., Shaari, A., Zaki, M. and Mumaaim, M. (2018) Fatal occupational injuries
in the Malaysian construction sector – causes and accidental agents. Earth and
Environmental Science, 140 012095
Available at: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1755-1315/140/1/012095
[Accessed 20th of March 2020]
Chim, B., Chun, C. and Wah, F. (2018) Accidents in construction sites: A study
on the causes and preventive approaches to mitigate accident rate. International
Journal, Vol. 1 (3)
[64]
De Silva, N. and Nawarathna, A. (2014) Reporting procedure of construction
accidents in Sri Lanka [online]
Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316911490
[Accessed 29th of December 2020]
Fung, I., Tam, C., Tung, K., and Man, F. (2005) Safety cultural divergences
among management, supervisory and worker groups in Hong Kong construction
industry. International Journal of Project Management, 23(7), pp.504-512
Hamid, A., Majid, A., and Singh, B. (2008) Causes of accidents at construction
sites. Malaysian Journal of Civil Engineering, 20(2), pp.242-259
Health and Safety Executive (2020) Construction statistics in Great Britain, 2020
[online]
Availablerat:ihttp://www.hse.gov.uk/STATISTICS/industry/construction/index.ht
m
[Accessed 29th of March 2021]
[65]
Availablerat:ihttps://www.ilo.org/legacy/english/protection/safework/worldday/pr
oducts05/report05_en.pdf
[Accessed 29th of December 2020]
Kadiri, Z., Nden, T., Avre, G., Oladipo, T., Edom, A., Samuel, P. and Ananso, G.
(2014) Causes and Effects of Accidents on Construction Sites (A case study of
some selected construction firms in Abuja, FCT Nigeria). IOSR Jouenal of
Mechanical and Civil Engineering, 11 (5), 66 - 72
Li, R. and Poon, S. (2009) Workers’ compensation for non-fatal accidents: review
of Hong Kong court cases. Journal of Asian Social Science, 8 (4)
Mthalane, D., Othman, A. and Pearl, R. (2008) The economic and social impact
of site accidents on the South African society. Paper presented at the proceeding
of the 5th post graduate conference on construction industry development,
Bloemfontein, South Africa
[66]
Ogwueleka, A. (2013) A review of safety and quality issues in the construction
industry. KICEM Journal of Construction Engineering and Project Management,
3 (3), 42 – 48
Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.6106/JCEPM.2013.3.3.042
[Accessed 9th of April]
Pakistan Bureau of Statistics (2014) Labour Force Survey 2013 – 2014 (Annual
Report) [online]
Available at: https://www.pbs.gov.pk/content/labour-force-survey-2013-14-
annual-report
[Accessed 01st of April 2021]
[67]
The Guardian (2021) Revealed: 6,500 migrant workers have died in Qatar since
World Cup Awarded [online]
Available at: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/global-
development/2021/feb/23/revealed-migrant-worker-deaths-qatar-fifa-world-cup-
2022
[Accessed 25th of March]
Tsang, Y., Fung, I., Tam, V., Sing, C. and Lu, C. (2017) Development of an
accidents modelling in the Hong Kong construction industry. International Journal
of Construction Management, 17 (2), 124 - 131
Udo, U., Usip, E. and Asuquo, C. (2016) Effect of lack of adequate attention of
safety measures on construction site in Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria. Journal of
Earth Sciences and Geotechnical Engineering, 6 (1), 113 - 121
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2019) Number and rate of fatal work injuries, by
industry sector [online]
Available at: https://www.bls.gov/charts/census-of-fatal-occupational-
injuries/number-and-rate-of-fatal-work-injuries-by-industry.htm
[Accessed 8th of April]
[68]
Appendices
[69]
[70]
[71]
[72]