3.assessment Groundwater Occurrences Using VESTEM Techniques at North Galala Plateau, NW Gulf of Suez, Egypt.
3.assessment Groundwater Occurrences Using VESTEM Techniques at North Galala Plateau, NW Gulf of Suez, Egypt.
PII: S1464-343X(19)30268-7
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafrearsci.2019.103613
Article Number: 103613
Reference: AES 103613
Please cite this article as: Abdellatif Younis, Osman M. Osman, Amin E. Khalil, Mohd Nawawi,
Mamdouh Soliman, A.Tarabees Elhamy, Assessment groundwater occurrences using VES/TEM
techniques at North Galala plateau, NW Gulf of Suez, Egypt., Journal of African Earth Sciences
(2019), https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jafrearsci.2019.103613
This is a PDF file of an article that has undergone enhancements after acceptance, such as the
addition of a cover page and metadata, and formatting for readability, but it is not yet the definitive
version of record. This version will undergo additional copyediting, typesetting and review before it
is published in its final form, but we are providing this version to give early visibility of the article.
Please note that, during the production process, errors may be discovered which could affect the
content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
1. Introduction
All over the world especially in arid and semi-arid zones of southern Europe, the Middle
East and North Africa Region characterized by surface water scarcity, groundwater is the main
source of renewable freshwater using for water supply, agricultural and industrial and domestic
activities(Re and Zuppi 2011). Growth of population associated with intensive economic activities
and change in climate are leading to an increase in demand of ground water (Ouhamdoucha et al.
2017; Kammoun et al .2018; Bahir et al.2018, 2019). In Egypt, the water resources exhibit
deficiency because of the increase of urbanization plans outside the Nile valley and insufficcient
water resources from the Nile. The water resources needed is not only for agricultural and drinking
purposes but also for industrial needs as well ( El-Behiry et al. 2006; El Osta et al. 2010; Sultan et
al. 2011; Younis et al. 2016; Arrafa et al., 2017). In this direction, the present study is an effort
exerted to define the spatial extension of groundwater aquifer adopting both DC Resistivity and
Time Domain Electromagnetic techniques. The integration of geophysical data here is conducted
in the light of the available geologic and hydrologic models of the area.
The electric resistivity of rocks is high, however, when the rock is saturated with water, the
resistivity drops significantly. Henceforth, the aquifer that is generally saturated with water will
exhibit an anomalous reduction in its resistivity. Accordingly, the aquifer can be delineated by
identifying the low resistivity zones in the inversion of VES and TEM data. However, this
sometimes is misleading since some rocks exhibit low resistivity (e.g. clays). To solve this
ambiguity extra data are needed such as well-bore or induced polarization (IP). Fortunately, well
data from one borehole in the study is available that is used to resolve ambiguity in the inverted
resistivity values also, available geologic and hydrogeologic studies are also used to control the
distribution of delineated aquifers (Nabighian and Macanae, 1991; Vereecken et al., 2002, 2004;
Rubin and Hubbard, 2005; Younis et al., 2016; Araffa et al. 2019).
2. Study area
The study area located in the southern part of Suez Governorate to the south of the Ain
Sokhna area, about 140 km from Cairo in the Galala Plateau along the Gulf of Suez coast. The
study area covers about 244 km2, bounded by longitudes 32 ° 24' 20'', 32 ° 25' 25'' E, and Latitudes
29° 29' 10'' and 29° 30' 10'' N (Fig. 1). Recently, the study area attracted numerous touristic
activities that increased its rank as a touristic focal area. In addition, there exist a number of
industrial projects in its vicinity. As the area is located far from the Nile river, the main water
resources for the present activities are partly a water pipe from Nile river. As mentioned earlier,
the water shortage may result in cutting the Nile river water supply. Henceforth, the need to explore
more groundwater resources is maximized.
Figure 1 here
According to the morphologic viewpoint, the study area is a hilly area dissected by three
main valleys trending NE-SW direction; namely, wadi Swelem in the north, wadi um Raga in the
middle and wadi Abo Drah in the south (Fig. 2). The three wadis are dipping in the northeast
direction which may result in water discharge towards the Gulf of Suez. The zone of the study is
characterized by elevations ranging from 10m to 200m and has been extraordinarily influenced by
weathering in various periods, which separated the area into numerous wadis, that made
geophysical measurements in such regions difficult (fig. 2).
Figure 2 here
3. Geological setting
The geology of the area northeast of Suez Gulf have been subject to numerous research
from different perspectives (El-Ramly, 1965; Kuss et al., 2000; El-Behiry et al., 2006; Farhoud,
2009; Boukhary et al., 2009; El Osta et al., 2010; Araffa et al., 2017). From the morphologic point
of view, the area can be to consider as an elevated land that is dissected by many wadis which
most of them are discharging water into the Gulf of Suez. Geologically, the surface rock exposure
ranging from Upper Paleozoic to tertiary (Conoco, 1987; El-Behiry et al., 2006) indicated that the
early contribution to the exposures here belongs to the Permo-Triassic era that is localized at the
extreme southern part of Wadi Ghoweibba (Fig. 3). Kuss et al. (2000) interpreted discrete
sedimentary sequences as a southward progression of the carbonate platform. The evolution of
slope joining the platform part with the basin part documented to be evolved through changing
depositional geometry at a large scale. From the facies architectural point of view, the evolution
began with a rimmed shelf during the Late Cretaceous time and ended with an extremely steepened
ramp that belongs to the newest Cretaceous to Palaeocene times. Bandel and Kuss (1987) pointed
out that the surface sections on the Northern Galala plateaus are mainly clastic sedimentary rocks
that belong to Late Paleozoic toward the Early Cretaceous period. Moreover, Boukhary et al.
(2009) interpreted a formation that consists of grayish and yellowish calcareous marls that are
assigned to Galala Formation (Cenomanian age). The formation then lies beneath a covered
interval and is resting upon a ~70 m thick order of varicolored sandstones interbedded with minor
clay, marl, and limestone belonging to the Permo-Triassic Qiseib Formation. Also, The Jurassic
section comprises also varicolored and cross-bedded sandstones, with mudstone and siltstone
interbed.
Figure 3 here
4. Hydrological Setting
Groundwater assets of Ain Alsokhona region were seriously investigated by numerous
authors (e.g. Elbeheiry et al., 2004; Abdellateif et al., 1997; Abuelata and Hassanan, 1990; Eldiasty
et al., 1981). Groundwater features occur below both artesian and non-artesian conditions. The
accumulation of the groundwater is controlled by topographic elevation, faulting system, lithology
of the stratigraphic layers and the rate of precipitation (ECG, 2008). The study area, which is a
part of the northern Eastern Desert, gets little measures of precipitation (25 mm/year) in autumn
and winter (El-Rakaiby, 1989). This small rainfall rate is considered as the recharge source for
groundwater. The main aquifer in the study area belongs to Quaternary deposits which contain of
the gravel and sand having brackish to freshwater. El Osta et al, (2010) and ECG (2008) stated
that the groundwater table ranges from 9.4 m in the East to 39.9 m in the North West and reach
120 m in the highest elevation area to the West. Also, the Groundwater discharge occurs in the
direction of Suez Gulf or the exploitation through pumping at a rate of about 3000 m3/day (El Osta
et al., 2010). Aquifer recharge depends on the surface runoff water infiltration and the leakages
from both Pliocene Miocene aquifers (El Osta et al., 2010). The groundwater salinity of Quaternary
aquifer is brackish to freshwater with high TDS recorded towards the Suez Gulf (El Osta et al,
2010) because of the saltwater intrusion (ECG, 2008). Also, the groundwater flow is modeled by
ECG (2008) to be from the NW and SW to the coast of Suez Gulf.
5. Material and methods
As pointed out earlier, the surface features are rugged with the presence of many
inaccessible areas that limits the application of geophysical surveys there (fig. 2). As a result, the
measurements were conducted in accessible places only. VES data were carried out at 4 sites
distributed within the three wadis in available places (Figs. 1 and 2). Resistivity data have been
carried out by using ABEM™ SAS 1000 resistivity meter. The measurements took place by
Schlumberger array with AB/2 spacing starting from 1 m to 1000 m. Moreover, the TEM survey
was conducted using the TEM-FAST 48 conductivity meter. Like the resistivity case, the
measurements were conducted in wadis where surface conditions at the sites are suitable for
surveying. Nine sites were surveyed along the three wadis where the survey is distributed evenly
among them. The loop size used is limited by the width of the wadis surveyed. TEM data survey
in the study adopted a single loop configuration in which signals are transmitted and received
utilizing the same loop (Fitterman and Stewart, 1986). Henceforth, the loop-size is chosen as 50
m that can roughly set the target depth to 150 m. For controlling the inversion of TEM data, the
survey site number one is chosen close to a producing well in the area. The well data comprises
the lithology, depth to the water aquifer, screen depth, and water quality that are used for the final
interpretation of the data. At each site, the survey was repeated several times to enhance the signal
to noise ratio. Consequently, measurement with the highest signal to noise ratio was selected for
the modeling and interpretation.
5.1. Vertical Electrical Sounding (VES)
The analysis of the obtained data was accomplished in both qualitative and quantitative
approaches. Qualitative analysis is to investigate the measured raw data to delineate the parallel
and vertical variations in the sounding of resistivity data. In other words, the resistivity sounding
data schemed in the form of resistivity curves at different electrode half spacing (AB/2). The curves
are then qualitatively interpreted to reflecting the possible sum of layers and relative apparent
resistivity. By correlating laterally, layer extension maybe delineated accordingly (Younis et al.,
2016; Araffa et al. 2019).
In quantitative interpretation, there are two different techniques adopted. The first is Zohdy
(1989), which is an automatic inversion interpretation technique applied to the digitized apparent
resistivity curves. It doesn't require a primary guess for the number of layers, their thicknesses, or
their resistivities, and it doesn't require extrapolation of the first and last branches of a sounding
curve to their respective asymptotes. The number of layers is identical to the number of digitized
points, and layer boundaries are dispersed consistently on a logarithmic depth scale. The second
technique is utilizing the obtained inversion from Zohdy’s code that is used as the 1-D a priori
model for the IPI 2win program (Bobachev et al. 2000). This program depends on direct separation
as a 1-D forward modeling and Newton algorithm of the minimal number of strata to solve the
inverse problem. A preliminary 1-D model (thicknesses and resistivities) can be used for
regularizing the procedure of the fitting error minimization. A critical preferred standpoint in this
program is that the idea of deciphering a profile is that, it is treated as a union representing the
geological structure of the surveyed area instead of a group of independent objects dealt with
separately. In the inversion process, some model parameters were fixed according to the available
geological data and borehole data.
Figure 4 here
Figure 5 here
TEM-48PPC and ZOND version 5.2 2016 programs were used in the processing and
interpretation of the data. To obtain a more accurate results, VES’s data that were interpreted
individually were used as a primary model for the 1-D inversion of the TEM data. borehole data
is then utilized to link the lithological information to the TEM and VES models (Fig. 7).
Figure 6 here
resistivities of some sites along the study area which have similar behaviors, but the thickness of
layers changes from site to another. These resulted models from VES data indicate that the study
area characterized by similar lithological and /or hydrological conditions. The similarity between
the peaks and troughs on each of the sounding curves reflects the predominance of a subsurface
stratigraphic sequence having similar electrical properties prevailing the whole study area.
Based on the available subsurface information, the borehole data and hydrogeological
information, the obtained resistivity inversion models show the layer sequence of alternating
resistivity values. These correlations are observed despite that the measurements were carried out
at separate wadis.
Figure 7 here
Figure 8 here
Figure 9 here
Figure 10 here
The generated VES and TEM cross sections give a tentative description of the subsurface
at the study area. From these sections, six geoelectric layers could be distinguished (figs 8 to 10).
These units look like to be extending in an NE-SW direction. Also, the VES outcome data show a
great coherency with the resulted TEM sections. The recognized geoelectric units can be depicted
considering the borehole data as follows:
Figure 11 here
Figure 12 here
and deep) disconnected by a conductive thick clay layer. This study aimed to assessment the
present situation of groundwater in the Quaternary and Pliocene aquifers at Galala plateau
Northwest Gulf of Suez. Review of the got geophysical outcomes and relationship with the
accessible geologic, and hydrogeologic data uncovered that the shallow aquifer is consists of
Coarse Sand with silt immersed with water and the deep aquifer is consists of the sand with
brackish to fresh water. The two zones were influenced by high contrasts in the topographic rise.
Resistivity maps show that groundwater in the shallow aquifer might be of good quality than the
water in deep Aquifer. The most appropriate areas for burrowing new water wells possess the
southwestern zone of the area of study for both zones. Also, from the maps, we indicate that the
groundwater fellow from the south and southwest to north and northeast in the direction of the
Suez Gulf. Also, the resistivity distribution of the study area indicates that there is affecting from
seawater intrusion which reduces the values of resistivity in the northeast direction of the study
area.
8. Acknowledgment
We gratefully acknowledge Dr. Mohammed Abdel Zaher and Dr. Khamis from NRIAG
for field observations made along the geophysical lines.
9. References
Abdallah, A.M. and Abd El-Hady F.M., 1966. U.A.R. J. Geol. 10 (1) (1966) 1–24
Abdellatif, T.A., Galal, G.H. and Yousef, A.M.A., 1997. Structural and lithological impact on the
groundwater occurrences along Wadi El Naqra-Wadi Bedaa area. Proc 15th An. Meet., Egypt,
Geoph. Soc (EGS), pp.107- 124.
Abuelata, A.S. and Hassanein, A.G., 1990. Comparative study of the geoelectric characteristics and water
qualities in the Cairo- Suez and Cairo-Sokhna roads, Eastern Desert, Egypt. Mansoura Sci. Bull.,
Fac. Sci., Mansoura University, Egypt V.17 No1, Supplement, pp.511-532.
Araffa S. A., Adel M.E. Mohamed, Fernando M. Santos.,2017. Geophysical investigation in the
Northwestern part of the Gulf of Suez, Egypt. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum (2017) 26, 457–475
Araffa, S. A., Essa, K. S. A. T., Khalil, M. H., El-Nahry, A. E. H., & Galal, A. N. H., 2017. Evaluation of
groundwater potentiality survey in south Ataqa-northwestern part of Gulf of Suez by using
resistivity data and site-selection modeling. NRIAG Journal of Astronomy and Geophysics, 6(1),
230–243. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nrjag.2017.02.002
Araffa, S. A., Soliman S. A., El Khafif, A., Younis, A. and Shazley T. F., 2019. Environmental
investigation using geophysical data at East Sadat City, Egypt. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum,
28, 117–125.
Bahir, M., Ouazar, D., and Ouhamdouch, S.,2019. Hydrogeochemical investigation and groundwater
quality in Essaouira region, Morocco. Marine and Freshwater Research
https://doi.org/10.1071/MF18319
Bahir, M., Ouhamdouch, S., and Carreira, P. M., 2018. Isotopic and geochemical methods for
studying water–rock interaction and recharge mode: application to the Cenomanian–
Turonian and Plio-Quaternary aquifers of Essaouira Basin, Morocco. Marine and
Freshwater Research 69, 1290–1300. doi:10.1071/MF17370.
Bandel, K., and Kuss, J., 1987. Depositional environment of the pre-rift sediments: Galala Heights (Gulf
of Suez, Egypt). Berliner Geowiss Abh A, 78, 1-48.
Bobachev, A., Modin, I, Prevago, E. and shevnin, V.,2000. IPI2win program set for 1D data interpretation,
Russia, Moscow 2000, Moscow State University, Geological Faculty, Dept. of Geophysics. 29p.
Boukhary, M., Morsi, A.-M. M., Eissa, R., & Kerdany, M., 2009. Late Cenomanian ostracode faunas from
the area south of Ain Sukhna, western side of the Gulf of Suez, Egypt. Geologia Croatica, 62(1),
19–30. https://doi.org/10.4154/GC.2009.02
Conoco., 1987. Geological map of Egypt, Scale 1:500,000, NH36 SW-BENI SUEF sheet.
Continental Oil Company (CONOCO)., 1987. Stratigraphic Lexicon and Explanatory Notes to the Geologic
map of Egypt 1 :500000. Edited by Maurice Hermina, Eberhard and franz K.
ECG (Engineering Consultants Group), 2008. El- Ain Al-Sokhna 2x650 MWe GAS/OIL THERMAL
POWER PROJECT, final report volume-1, ECG File No. 1312
El Ostal , m., El sheikh, A. and Barseeem, M., 2010. comparative hydrological and geoelectrical study on
the Quaternary Aquifer in the deltas of wadi Badaa and Ghweiba, El Ain El Sukhna area, Northwest
Suez Gulf, Egypt. International Journal of Geophysics (Volume 2010, Article ID 585243, 15 pages
doi:10.1155/2010/585243.
El-Behiry, M. G., Shedid, A., Abu-Khadra, A., & El-Huseiny, M., 2006. Integrated GIS and Remote
Sensing for Runoff Hazard Analysis in Ain Sukhna Industrial Area, Egypt. JKAU: Earth Science,
17, 19–42.
El-Behiry, M.G., Shideed, A.G. and Elhusseiny, M.S., 2004. Geographic Information System and remote
sensing application for water resources: Wadi Ghoweibba Basin, West Gulf of Suez, Egypt.7th
International. Conf. on Geol. Arab World, Cairo Univ, Egypt, p.22.
Eldiasty, M.I., Elhakeim, B.E.A. and Saber, H.S.M., 1981. carried out some recent geophysical well logging
investigations in mining and ground water prospect in Ain El-Sokhna, Abu Tartur, and Maghara.
which, different bore hole are drilled in the area to study the geological section and geophysical
parameters. electromagnetic data. Geophys. Prospect. 58, 267–277.
El-Rakaiby, M. L., 1989. Drainage basins and flash flood hazard in selected parts of Egypt. Egypt J
Geol, 33(1-2), 309-323.
El-Ramly, I. M., 1965. Contribution To the Hydrogeological Study of Limestone Terrains in U.A.R. In
Proceedings of the Symposium on fractured rocks, Dubrovnik, (pp. 348–377).
Farhoud, K., 2009. Accommodation zones and tectono-stratigraphy of the Gulf of Suez, Egypt: A
contribution from aeromagnetic analysis. Geo Arabia, 14(4), 139–162.
Fitterman, D.V. and Stewart, M.T., 1986. Transient electromagnetic sounding for groundwater,
Geophysics, Vol. 51, pp 995-1005.
IPI2WIN., 2011. Programs for resistivity and induced polarization sounding interpretation version 3.1.2c
Bobachev A. A., programs set for VES data interpretation. Dep. of Geophysics, Geological Faculty,
Moscow State University, Russia.
Kammoun. S., Trabelsi. R., Re. V., Zouari. K., and Henchiri. K., 2018. Groundwater quality assessment in
semi-arid regions using integrated approaches: the case of Grombalia aquifer (NE Tunisia) Environ
Monit Assess (2018) 190:87 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10661-018-6469-x .
Kuss, J., Scheibner, C., & Gietl, R., 2000. Carbonate platform to basin transition along an Upper Cretaceous
to Lower Tertiary Syrian Arc uplift, Galala Plateaus, Eastern Desert of Egypt. GeoArabia, 5(3),
405–424. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1378/chest.126.3.838
Nabighian, M. N. and Macnae, J. C., 1991. Time domain electromagnetic prospecting methods, in
Nabighian, M. N. Ed,. Electromagnetic Methods in Applied Geophysics, Vol. 2. Society of
Exploration Geophysicists, pp. 427-520.
Ouhamdouch, S., Bahir, M., and Carreira, P. M., 2017. Geochemical and isotopic tools to
deciphering the origin of mineralization of the coastal aquifer of Essaouira basin, Morocco.
Procedia and Earth Planetary Science 17, 73–76. doi: 10.1016/J.PROEPS.2016.12.038.
Re, V., and Zuppi, G.M., 2011. Influence of precipitation and deep saline groundwater on the
hydrological systems of Mediterranean coastal plains: a general overview. Hydrological
Sciences Journal, 56(6), 966–980. https://doi.org/10.1080/02626667.2011.597355.
Rubin, Y., Hubbard, S.S., 2005. Hydro geophysics. Springer, The Netherlands, p. 583.
Soliman, M.M., 2005. Environmental and geophysical assessment of the ground and subsurface water
resources of Ras El-Hekma area, northwestern coast of Egypt. Ph.D. Thesis, Faculty of Science,
Ain Shams University, Cairo, Egypt, 148p.
Sultan, M., Metwally, S., Milewski, A., Becker, D., Ahmed, M., Sauck, W., … Welton, B., 2011. Modern
recharge to fossil aquifers: Geochemical, geophysical, and modeling constraints. Journal of
Hydrology, 403(1–2), 14–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhydrol.2011.03.036
Vereecken, H., Hubbard, S., Binley, A., Ferre, T., 2004. Hydrogeophysics. Introd. Guest Ed. Vadose Zone
J. 3, 1060–1062.
Vereecken, H., Yaramanci, U., Kemna, A., 2002. Non-invasive methods in hydrology Special issue. J.
Hydrol. 267, 125–299.
Younis, A., Soliman, M., Moussa, S., Massoud, M., Abd El Nabi, S., Attia, M., 2016. Integrated
geophysical application to investigate groundwater potentiality of the shallow Nubian aquifer at
northern Kharga, Western Desert, Egypt NRIAG Journal of Astronomy and Geophysics (2016) 5,
186–197.
Zohdy., A.R. 1989. A New Method for the Automatic Interpretation of Schulmberger and Wenner Sounding
Curves. Geophysics, Vol. 54, pp.245-253.
Zond., 2016. Program for one-dimensional data interpretation of transient electromagnetic method using
arbitrary source-receiver configuration (loop/line/dipole) version 5.2.
FIGURE CAPTIONS
Figure 1. Physical image map of the studied site.
Figure 2. Digital Elevation Map (DEM) of the site showing the elevation differences and flow
direction routes (blue).
Figure 3. (a) Geological map northwestern Gulf of Suez (after CONOCO,1987). (b) The
composite lithologic section in the vicinity of the area of study without scale (modified after
Abdallah and Abd El-Hady, 1966).
Figure 4. 1-D VES Data Inversion for the four sites considered using the IPI2win program.
Figure 5. Decay curves of TEM resulted according to time and induced voltage (a) TEM station
01, (b) TEM station 02, (c) TEM station 03 and (d) TEM station 06.
Figure 6. TEM inversion model at site #1 correlated with the borehole data at the close site used
to control the inversion.
Figure 7. 1-D model inversion examples of the TEM stations of the present study. At sites #2,
site #3, site #6 and site #8.
Figure 8. A tentative geologic Profile P1 compiled using the resistivity model inversion of VES
and TEM data along the profile. Surface elevation obtained from the DEM model.
Figure 9. A tentative geologic Profile P2 compiled using the resistivity model inversion of VES
and TEM data along the profile. Surface elevation obtained from the DEM model.
Figure 10. A tentative geologic Profile P3 compiled using the resistivity model inversion of VES
and TEM data along the profile. Surface elevation obtained from the DEM model.
Figure 11. Contour maps for the shallow aquifer showing (A) spatial average resistivity, (B)
isopach, (C) depth from the surface to the water table, (D) genuine elevation of the water surface
referenced to the sea level.
Figure 12. Contour maps for the deep aquifer showing (A) spatial average resistivity, (B) isopach,
(C) depth from the surface to the water table, (D) genuine elevation of the water surface referenced
to the sea level.
First Aquifer composed of coarse sand with silt, shows low to moderate resistivity
Second aquifer shows low resistivity values that may show fresh to brackish water
groundwater flow from southwest to north and northeast towards the Gulf of Suez
Seawater intrusion in deep aquifer in the northeast directions towards the Gulf