Blockchain - The Accounting Perspective
Blockchain - The Accounting Perspective
Adriana DUȚESCU
Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Bucharest, Romania
[email protected]
Abstract. Blockchain remains still an experimental technology, with current applications addressing only
some elements of small-scale projects. Once the technology matures however, it has the potential to
transform industries and even the economy, as it begins to integrate complementary technologies such as
AI and IoT. It has the potential to bring fundamental changes to financial accounting and auditing, and
even to entire financial markets. This paper explores the potential for blockchain applications in
accounting, identifying major benefits and shortcomings, and analysing opportunities and possible
threats. We investigate mainly the organizational challenges raised by an accounting blockchain systems
and its potential to enhance the accounting activity. We discuss blockchain’s potentially disruptive effect
on the accounting profession, and conversely, the potential role of this professions in further developing
blockchain technology.
Introduction
Blockchain is one of the “buzz” word on everyone lips nowadays and the blockchain’s
technology disruptive effect on potentially each sector of our life is largely recognized, both in
academia and industry.
One of the most challenged area is the financial one, with accounting and audit as
primarily activities to be dramatically changed in the near future. Apart from the transition from
manual to computerized processes, these activities haven’t experienced such technology-driven
disruption in the past. Blockchain’s potential to radically change the accounting, audit and
control activities raises therefore a huge interest for professionals in these fields.
While recognized as being one of the most revolutionary technology available today, the
theoretical framework for blockchain solutions remains raw and empirical evidence almost
insignificant. Blockchain is currently crossing a period of evolving maturity, and most of the
researchers focus on its technical aspects. The vast majority of blockchain applications are
developed as isolated and particular solutions, and there is virtually no blockchain solution at
enterprise level.
The organizational challenges raised by this new technology are somehow left in shadow.
However, to reach its full potential, blockchain needs requires decentralization and, therefore,
major changes in the way that business leaders understand and accept to run their businesses.
Our research aims to address the blockchain topic mainly from this organizational
perspective. This study represents an initial step of a larger research project, with focus on
Blockchain in the financial sector. In this phase we intend to explore the theoretical framework
for blockchain applications in accounting, discuss organizational and technical challenges,
identify benefits and vulnerabilities, and formulate some hypothesis on blockchain solutions and
its implications for accounting. Although accounting and audit systems are generally treated
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
together in this context, we have chosen to address them separately, as, in our opinion, they
require different types of solutions and raise different types of issues from the blockchain
perspective.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. We begin with an overview of blockchain
technology and of the current approaches of accounting blockchain as these have been addressed
in the literature. In the next section we examine the potential implications of blockchain PICBE | 215
technology for accounting and the role of accounting professionals in developing blockchain
solutions at organizational level. We finish with some conclusions, comments on the limitations
of the current study and directions for further investigation.
Methodology
This study represents an initial phase in a broader research project addressing the implications of
blockchain technology for the financial sector. In this initial phase, our objective is to investigate
blockchain technology from an organizational perspective and to identify its main challenges and
opportunities for accounting.
We have chosen as research approach an extensive analysis of both scientific and business
literature concerning organizational issues raised by blockchain technology. Such an approach is
motivated mainly by the current scarcity of organizational solutions or applications based on
blockchain technologies. Without data, any aspect related to blockchain organizational solutions
can’t be empirically investigated. A qualitative research method would be more appropriate at
this stage, and valuable results can be obtained by analyzing opinions of accounting professionals
on this subject. This is the next step in our research. The current study aims to clarify different
aspects related to challenges, opportunities, advantages, limitations, and possible solutions of
blockchain accounting systems, as perceived by both scientific and professional communities.
Literature review
Blockchain – an overview
Undoubtedly, Blockchain represents one of the “hottest” technologies nowadays, with an
important potential disruptive effect on our lives. Therefore, is a subject of great interest, both for
industry and academia. Being a technology that hasn’t reach yet its maturity level, most of the
researchers are focusing on its technical aspects. However, Blockchain raises various
organizational issues, critical to reaching its full potential. This “organizational perspective” is
approached mainly in specific contexts of blockchain applications, while somehow overlooked in
the “big picture” of blockchain research.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
The concept of blockchain itself appeared in 2008, when the mysterious Satoshi Nakamoto used
it to describe the public transaction ledger for the first digital cryptocurrency (Bitcoin). In the
research paper entitled “A Peer-To-Peer Electronic Cash System” he described a peer-to-peer
system in which people could make instant online transactions directly from sender to receiver
without any involvement of any third party like government or financial institutions (Nakamoto,
2008). PICBE | 216
Since then, blockchain technology, also referred as “Distributed Ledger Technology
(DLT) evolved and has been used in different other platforms.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
It is extremely important to note that only together all these components create a
transparent and trusted environment in which to create and share value. However, most of the
developed or currently developing blockchain solutions use only some of these components.
Future of blockchain
Despite its potential to create new value and unlock existing value flows, blockchain remains still
an experimental technology, with current applications addressing only some elements of small-
scale projects. The attitudes towards blockchain followed the common pattern faced by young
and evolving technologies - they moved from a “hype” characterized by unrealistic expectations
to real disappointments brought by the cryptocurrency crash in 2018. Currently, blockchain
crosses a period of “evolving maturity”, focused on enabling technologies for two of its defining
components: distribution and encryption.
According to Gartner, blockchain will evolve through three phases in the next ten years,
with a first step focused on operational improvement followed by a second one dedicated to the
“real business of blockchain” – reengineer business relationships and redistribute existing data
and value flows in ways that could reinvent how business engage in a digital world (Panetta,
2019).
A first phase began after 2012 and is expected to last through the early 2020’s. This is the
phase of Blockchain-inspired solutions, in which only three of the five elements of blockchain are
used: distribution, encryption and immutability (Zheng et. al, 2017).
In this period of evolving maturity, blockchain is confronted with both technical and
organizational challenges. If the technical challenges are expected to be solved by 2025, the
organizational ones are more resilient. One of the core elements of a fully developed blockchain
solution is decentralization, which means that business leaders must accept full transparency and
be comfortable with automated business decisions outside their full control. This is very difficult.
Moreover, the main intermediaries of the existing centralized infrastructure (market
intermediaries, technology infrastructure providers) are constantly pouring more suspicions in
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
their clients’ ears (Furlonger & Uzureau, 2020). Since all the blockchain-inspired solutions are
designed in a centralized environment, they don’t allow unmediated trade of digital assets.
The second phase is expected to start in early 2020’s and to last until 2030. In this phase,
called Blockchain complete all the 5 elements (distribution, encryption, immutability,
tokenization and decentralization) are used. The major difference from blockchain inspired
solutions is the presence of tokens operating in a decentralized environment using smart PICBE | 218
contracts.
The third phase, expected to start after 2030, is characterized by the integration of
complementary technologies within blockchain networks. Technologies like Internet of Things
(IoT), Artificial Intelligence (AI), Self-Sovereign Identity (SSI) will expand the value that can be
monetized and exchanged in the network, allowing more smaller transactions supported by smart
contracts to take place. This Enhanced Blockchain has the potential to generate new business
models based on decentralized operational structure, with completely autonomous transactions.
Every category of human endeavors, be it in education, economy, politics, healthcare or science
could be reinvented. Blockchain is proving to be the fifth disruptive computing paradigm shift
(Mutambaie, 2018).
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
considers blockchain as fundamental to the economy and promotes cryptocurrency, the
government being very supportive on free public blockchain platforms; additionally, favorable
tax treatment and public funding for blockchain development were enforced. Israel is a leader the
crypto revolution, in digital assets implementation, focused mainly on cryptography’s R&D;
Stock Exchange is developing blockchain applications and governmental agencies start adopting
blockchain, in their communications. The USA Government becomes a blockchain user and PICBE | 219
regulator; regulations on the legal status of cryptocurrencies have evolved, data protection limits
how the personal information may be handled, in some states laws to enforce blockchain
transactions were proclaimed (Deloitte, 2019).
The accounting profession is facing an important challenge today, in leading the
blockchain development and implementation. The profession contribution should be valuable not
only in developing specific, effective regulations and standards but also in advising companies
and other stakeholders when dealing with blockchain and cryptocurrency and optimizing their
processes and systems. New skills will be needed, specifically on technology, consulting and
providing value-added to clients. Additionally, the ability to act as an arbitration party in between
technical people and business stakeholders could be considered an important new skill to be
acquired.
Although measuring rights and obligations from transactions might concern accountants
in connection to blockchain, this technology may help the enhancement of the financial
profession, by uplifting the main efforts from bookkeeping to more value-added subjects, such
as: planning and valuation, integrated analysis and complex interpretation of various outcomes,
data systems assessment. More transparency and timeliness information will become also
attributes that professionals will have to integrate in their wok.
Other important implications will concern the external auditors. Data, information and
procedures confirmation won’t be necessary anymore, the transaction level assertion will change,
specific substantial procedures will evolve towards a more holistic, business integration
approach. Most of the auditors’ specific procedures were repetitive, involving a great amount of
manual work on reframing and checking the information “true and fair “impact on financial
statements, in other words to assess whether the bookkeeping system in free from material errors
and biases. Samples were generated and material levels were assumed within these specific
endeavors. Most of these procedures and techniques will disappear or radically change, replaced
by blockchain and machine learning facilities, leaving more time and space for other value-added
contributions.
On the other hand, transactions within a blockchain system should still be assessed in
terms of their authorization and “according to regulations” features, whether related parties had
been involved, correct classification, measurement and disclosure to financial statements.
Procedures on management’s estimations, possible fraudulent transactions, blockchain protocol
should be performed in the future as well, as the most important part of the auditors’ endeavor.
Automate on-going alerts will help increase the efficiency and the saving time can be devoted to
more high-quality areas of audit.
Blockchain makes useless the service of a central authority. Being a peer-to-peer network,
transactions are recorded securely in blocks and organizations will not have to keep backups in
forms of physical and digital records. This requires a new framework and specific regulations,
and countries and organizations are preparing for these challenges. In 2019 the regulation
framework of blockchain and crypto currencies has been significantly changed all over the world.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
The EU new Directive on money laundry was preceded by UK’s Financial Court of Authority
instructions on cryptocurrency assets related businesses. This edict regulates entities that issue,
store and/or provide marketing of products and services in this domain. Stricter rules are enforced
in connection to identification of the owners of these products and services, specific investments
and trading in the area. In US new regulations concerning the subject were introduced by the
Congress last year, emphasizing how business models can be affected and how authorities may PICBE | 220
use distributed ledgers in their activity. Nevertheless, cryptocurrencies are excluded from the
securities laws. US New blockchain framework was provided in Switzerland by the Swiss
Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) and framework for Initial Coin Offerings
(ICOs) and Digital Assets Service Providers (DASP) was enforced in France, last year
(Deloitte, 2019).
Blockchain accounting
With its main objective of transferring the ownership of assets while assuring a ledger of accurate
financial information in a secure and trusted environment, blockchain is, undoubtedly, an
accounting technology. Therefore, blockchain is expected to change the present accounting
system in different ways. While both researchers and accounting professionals agree on the
disruptive potential of blockchain technology for accounting, it is still unclear how these
transformations will occur, what challenges and risks will bring along the process and how it will
impact the accounting profession.
All these issues are replicated also for the audit system and audit profession. Although in
many studies concerned with blockchain disruptive effect accounting and audit are approached as
one system, this study explores it only for the accounting system. We consider that, although
related, accounting and audit systems present particularities that will differentiate the potential
impact of blockchain upon them.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
-Improved efficiency. Records are kept only once, in blocks accessible anytime by any authorized
user. This will reduce the cost of maintaining physical or digital records. Also, with transactions
recorded in real time and ledgers instantly updated, reconciliations will be removed from the
recording process. The modern technologies, like Artificial Intelligence and Data Analytics will
optimize many accounting processes in an enhanced blockchain system. All these will increase
efficiency and value of the accounting function. PICBE | 221
-Authenticity of information and reduction in fraud. Unlike physical or digital records, blocks in a
blockchain are not susceptible to unauthorized alterations. This will ensure the accuracy of
information stored in the blockchain and will dramatically reduce the chance of fraud. Within a
real time blockchain accounting, the risk of any errors will be completely eliminated.
-Real time reporting. In a real time blockchain accounting, any user registered in the network or
external regulator will be able to access information about an organization in real time.
-Focus on value-added activities. All the organizations’ resources involved in the traditional
record keeping will be available to other value adding activities of the organization in blockchain
accounting.
All these potential benefits of blockchain accounting are promising but in the same time
are raising concerns for the accounting system. Being a solution based on “undoubtable” trust
assured by line codes and machines, it is still difficult to be fully embraced by a system in which
trust is built throughout human validation and enforced by strict regulations. Blockchain is a
technology that redefines trust in the new generation systems (Sachs, 2018).
Moreover, there are technical and organizational challenges attached both to the process
of transformation from traditional accounting systems to blockchain accounting systems and to
the latter one itself.
One of the main challenges is related to the infrastructure for blockchain (Zheng et al,
2018). As blockchain is highly dependent on Internet, the risk of an improper infrastructure must
be seriously considered. In this context, a high level of cybersecurity is required.
Another challenge is related to the fact that accounting is largely dependent on
regulations. Although the blockchain technology can assure that these regulations are properly
respected, it should be flexible enough to allow the adoption of any new regulation or the
adjustment of existing ones on real time basis.
The scale to which blockchain is adopted by organizations represents another challenge
for the accounting blockchain. In order to be effective, blockchain accounting needs to be
adopted by a sufficiently large number of organizations (Inghirami, 2018). Currently, enterprise
blockchain solutions are still in their infancy and the number of organizations that attempted
experimenting with blockchain in accounting is rather small.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
Another important aspect is related to the role that accounting is authorized to play in the
development and adoption of blockchain technology itself. Accountants are experts in all the
domains imbedded in blockchain model: standards setting, business logic, record keeping,
application of complex rules (Smith, 2018). Therefore, they should be involved in the “business”
design of different blockchain solutions, together with those who have technical knowledge of
how blockchain works. Accountants have the opportunity to act as consultants to organizations PICBE | 222
considering blockchain solutions. They should play the bridging role between technologists and
business stakeholders in the process of blockchain adoption and also advise on the impact of
blockchain on their businesses and clients.
Conclusion
In this paper, we present a comprehensive overview on blockchain and its potential to enhance
the accounting activity. Our research has shown that this topic is still immature. Blockchain is
one of the most revolutionary technologies available today but unlocking its true potential require
more than technical improvements. While issues like scalability, latency, privacy, security or
authentications are largely recognized as being significant obstacles on blockchain maturing path,
organizational and human issues remain still in a shadow. However, these are critical to
implementing a blockchain solution at organizational level.
As theoretical applications transition to successful proof of concept successes blockchain
technology will become an integral part of the information technology ecosystem. Undoubtedly,
it will have a tremendous impact on financial sector, with one of the most challenged areas being
financial accounting. Blockchain has the potential to largely increase the accounting information
and to reduce the errors in disclosure and earnings management. Moreover, the role of financial
accountants will change. They will be no more expected to record transactions and make
financial statements, but to validate both the source documents and the reasonability of smart
contracts used in accounting blockchain.
This potential impact is generally recognized and intensely studied by accounting and
audit professional bodies. However, it seems that for a largely part of accountants blockchain is
still a rather “exotic” technology related mostly to cryptocurrencies. Therefore, they not only
undermine their chances to take full advantages of blockchain accounting, but also miss the
unique opportunity to participate in the process of designing blockchain solutions for their
clients.
These results outline the framework for a future research, aiming to explore the
accounting professionals’ attitudes and approaches towards blockchain and its impact on
accounting system.
References
Chartered Professional Accountants Canada (CPA& American Institute of CPAs (AICPA)
(2017) Blockchain Technology and Its Potential Impact on the Audit and Assurance
Profession, white paper, Retrieved from:
file:///C:/Users/Adriana/Documents/adriana_2017/Blockchain/blockchain-technology-
and-its-potential-impact-on-the-audit-and-assurance-profession.pdf
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
David Furlonger, Christophe Uzureau (2020) The real business of Blockchain, Gartner, INC.
Harvard Business Review Press, USA
Deloitte’s 2019 Global Blockcahin Survey (2019) retrieved at:
https://www2.deloitte.com/content/dam/Deloitte/se/Documents/risk/DI_2019-global-blockchain-
survey.pdf
PICBE | 223
Erbguth, J. & Morin, JH. (2016). Towards distributed trustworthy traceability and
accountability, Earticle.net.
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020
https://fr.slideshare.net/lablogga/bitcoin-and-blockchain-technology-explained-not-just-
cryptocurrencies-economics-and-markets-applications-in-art-health-and-literacy
Swan, M. (2015). Blockchain: blueprint for a new economy, O’Reilly.
Zheng Z., Xie S., Dai H., Chen X., & Wang H. (2018). Blockchain challenges and opportunities:
a survey, Inderscience Enterprises Ltd. Retrieved from:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/328271018_Blockchain_challenges_and_opport PICBE | 224
unities_a_survey
Zheng Z., Xie S., Dai H., Chen X., & Wang H.(2017). An Overview of Blockchain Technology:
Architecture, Consensus, and Future Trends, 2017 IEEE 6th International Congress on
Big Data. Retrieved from: https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8029379
Zhiwei T.Y., Lin S. & Tang Q. (2018) Blockchain: Introduction and Application in Financial
Accounting, retrieved from https://ssrn.com/abstract=3258504
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2020-0020, pp. 214-224, ISSN 2558-9652| Proceedings of the 14th International Conference on Business
Excellence 2020