Federal Reserve Discount Window Process 4000
Federal Reserve Discount Window Process 4000
Section 4000.1
This section contains product profiles of finan- Each product profile contains a general
cial instruments that examiners may encounter description of the product, its basic character-
during the course of their review of capital- istics and features, a depiction of the market-
markets and trading activities. Knowledge of place, market transparency, and the product’s
specific financial instruments is essential for uses. The profiles also discuss pricing conven-
examiners’ successful review of these activities. tions, hedging issues, risks, accounting, risk-
These product profiles are intended as a general based capital treatments, and legal limitations.
reference for examiners; they are not intended to Finally, each profile contains references for
be independently comprehensive but are struc- more information.
tured to give a basic overview of the instruments.
funds, including the term fed funds, are nonne- minimal due to the short maturity. For term fed
gotiable products and, therefore, there is no funds, interest-rate risk may be greater, depend-
secondary market. ing on the length of the term.
Market Participants
Credit Risk
Participants in the federal funds market include
commercial banks, thrift institutions, agencies Fed funds sold expose the lender to credit risk.
and branches of banks in the United States, Upstream correspondent banks may require col-
federal agencies, and government securities deal- lateral to compensate for their risks. All banks
ers. The participants on the buy side and sell should evaluate the credit quality of any bank to
side are the same. whom they sell fed funds and set a maximum
line for each potential counterparty.
Market Transparency
Liquidity Risk
Price transparency is high. Interbank brokers
disseminate quotes on market news services. The overnight market is highly liquid. As there
Prices of fed funds are active and visible. is no secondary market for term fed funds rates,
their liquidity is directly related to their maturity.
Banks may purchase fed funds up to the
PRICING maximum of the line established by selling
financial institutions. Those lines are generally
Fed fund yields are quoted on an add-on basis.
not disclosed to purchasing banks. Active users
All fed funds yields are quoted on an actual/360-
may need to test the availability of funds peri-
day basis. The fed funds rate is a key rate for the
odically to ensure that sufficient lines are avail-
money market because all other short-term rates
able when needed.
relate to it. Bid/offer spreads may vary among
institutions, although the differences are usually
slight. The fed effective rate on overnight fed
funds, the weighted average of all fed funds ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
transactions done in the broker’s market, is
published in The Wall Street Journal. Thompson Fed funds sold should be recorded at cost. Term
Bankwatch rates the general credit quality of fed funds sold should be reported as a loan on
banks, which is used by banks when determin- the call report.
ing credit risk for fed funds sold.
Rates on term fed funds are quoted in the
broker’s market or over the counter. In addition,
money market brokers publish indicative quotes RISK-BASED CAPITAL
on the Telerate screen. WEIGHTING
A 20 percent risk weight is appropriate for fed
HEDGING funds. For specific risk weights for qualified
trading accounts, see section 2110.1, ‘‘Capital
Due to the generally short-term nature of fed Adequacy.’’
funds, hedging does not usually occur, although
fed funds futures contracts may be used as
hedging vehicles.
LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
INVESTMENT
RISKS
A bank may sell overnight fed funds to any
Interest-Rate Risk counterparty without limit. Sales of fed funds
with maturities of one day or less or under
For nonterm fed funds, interest-rate risk is continuing contract have been specifically
excluded from lending limit restrictions by Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond. Instru-
12 CFR 32. Term fed funds are subject to the 15 ments of the Money Market. Richmond,
percent lending limit with any one counterparty Virginia. 1993.
and may be combined with all other credit Stigum, Marcia. The Money Market. 3rd ed.
extensions to that counterparty. Sales of fed Homewood, Illinois: Business One Irwin,
funds to affiliates are subject to 12 USC 371c, 1990.
‘‘Loans to Affiliates.’’ Woelfel, Charles J. Encyclopedia of Banking &
Finance. 10th ed. Chicago: Probus Publishing
Company, 1994.
REFERENCES
Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Fedpoints
#15. New York, June 1991.
maturity structure, low credit risk, and large together with its low credit risk and large
number of issuers make CP an attractive short- number of issuers, makes it an attractive short-
term investment alternative for short-term port- term investment for many investors. Investment
folio managers and for the liquid portion of companies, especially money funds, are the
longer-term portfolios. CP is particularly attrac- largest investors in the CP market. Other signifi-
tive when interest rates are volatile, as many cant investors include the trust departments of
investors are unwilling to buy long-term, fixed- banks, insurance companies, corporate liquidity
rate debt in a volatile interest-rate environment. portfolios, and state and local government bod-
Investors wishing to take a position in short- ies. If CP carries a rating of A-2, P-2, or better,
term rates denominated in a foreign currency thrifts may buy CP and count it as part of their
without taking the risks of investing in an liquidity reserves.
unfamiliar counterparty or facing country risk
often invest in an instrument such as Goldman
Sachs’s Universal Commercial Paper (UCP) or
Merrill Lynch’s Multicurrency Commercial
Issuers
Paper (MCCP). With UCP or MCCP, the dealer
Issuers of CP include industrial companies, such
creates synthetic foreign currency–denominated
as manufacturers, public utilities, and retailers,
paper by having a U.S. issuer issue CP in a
and financial institutions, such as banks and
foreign currency. The dealer then executes a
leasing companies. Financial issuers account for
currency swap with the issuer, which eliminates
approximately 75 percent of CP outstanding,
foreign-exchange risk for the issuer. The inves-
with industrial issuance making up the remain-
tor is therefore left with a short-term piece of
der. Approximately 75 percent of the CP out-
paper denominated in a foreign currency and
standing carries the highest credit rating of
that is issued by a U.S. counterparty, thus
A-1/P-1 or better, while only approximately
eliminating country risk.
5 percent of CP outstanding carries a credit
rating of A-3/P-3 or below. In the U.S. market
Banks and Bank Holding Companies for CP, domestic issuers account for approxi-
mately 80 percent of issuance, with foreign
Bank holding companies (BHCs) are active issuers making up the remainder.
issuers of CP. The money raised is often used to Several large finance companies and bank
fund nonbank activities in areas such as leasing holding companies place their paper directly
and credit cards and to fund offshore branches. with the investor without using a dealer.
BHCs use commercial paper in sweep pro- Approximately 40 percent of all CP outstanding
grams. On a BHC level, the sweep programs are is placed directly with the investor.
maintained with customers at the bank level, and
the funds are upstreamed to the parent as part of
the BHC’s funding strategy. Sweep programs Primary Market
use an agreement with the bank’s deposit cus-
tomers (typically corporate accounts) that per- The primary market consists of CP sold directly
mits them to reinvest amounts in their deposit by issuers (direct paper) or sold through a dealer
accounts above a designated level in overnight acting as principal (dealer paper). Dealer paper
obligations of the parent bank holding company, accounts for most of the market. As principals,
another affiliate of the bank, or a third party. dealers buy and immediately sell the CP (with a
These obligations include instruments such as small markup called the dealer spread). Some-
commercial paper, program notes, and master- times the dealers hold CP as inventory for a
note agreements. short time as a service to issuers in need of
immediate funds. Dealers are mostly large invest-
ment banks and commercial banks with subsid-
DESCRIPTION OF iaries that underwrite and deal in securities.
MARKETPLACE Although dealers do not normally inventory
positions in CP, at times they will agree to
Investors position any paper that the issuer posted but did
not sell on a particular day. The amount unsold
The short-term nature of commercial paper, is usually small, and the positions assumed are
of the reverse repo is that a dealer may borrow money-center or regional banks with a need for
a security it has sold short with either positive or funding.
negative carry. A problem arises, however, when Repos are not traded on organized exchanges.
demand exceeds supply for a specific bond issue There is no secondary market, and quoted mar-
(collateral), and it goes on ‘‘special.’’ This ket values are not available. The Public Securi-
means that those who own the security can earn ties Association has produced a standard master
a premium by lending it to those needing to repo agreement and supplements that are used
deliver on short positions. These ‘‘lenders’’ are throughout the industry. Although the trans-
compensated by paying a below-market borrow- actions themselves are not rated, the entities
ing rate on the cash side of the transaction (the undertaking repos (such as larger banks and
repo rate is lower on ‘‘specials’’ because the dealers) may be rated by Moody’s, Standard &
owner of the special security is the borrower of Poor’s, or other rating agencies.
cash funds and is seeking the lowest lending rate
possible).
PRICING
Bank Nondealer Activity
Repo rates may vary somewhat with the type of
Like dealers, a bank can use repos to fund long collateral and the term of the transaction. Over-
positions and profit from the carry. The market night repos with U.S. government collateral,
also gives a bank the means to use its securities however, generally take place at rates slightly
portfolio to obtain additional liquidity—that is, below the federal funds rate. Interest may be
funding—without liquidating its investments or paid explicitly, so that the ‘‘sale’’ price and
recognizing a gain or loss on the transaction. For ‘‘repurchase’’ price of the security are the same,
money market participants with excess funds to or it may be embedded in a difference between
invest in the short term, reverse repos provide a the sale price and repurchase price.
collateralized lending vehicle offering a better The seller of a security under a repo agree-
yield than comparable time deposit instruments. ment continues to receive all interest and prin-
cipal payments on the security while the pur-
chaser receives a fixed rate of interest on a
Commercial Depositors short-term investment. In this respect, interest
rates on overnight repo agreements usually are
Repos have proved to be popular temporary lower than the federal funds rate by as much as
investment vehicles for individuals, firms, and 25 basis points. The additional security provided
governments with unpredictable cash flows. by the loan collateral employed with repos
Repos (like other money market instruments) lessens their risk relative to federal funds.
can also be used as a destination investment for Interest is calculated on an actual/360 day-
commercial depositors with sweep accounts, count add-on basis. When executed under a
that is, transaction accounts in which excess continuing contract (known as a demand or
balances are ‘‘swept’’ into higher-yielding non- open-basis overnight repo), repo contracts usu-
bank instruments overnight. Again, as collateral ally contain a clause to adjust the interest rate on
for the corporation’s investment, the counter- a day-to-day basis.
party or bank will ‘‘sell’’ Treasury bills to the
customer (that is, collateralize the loan).
HEDGING
DESCRIPTION OF
MARKETPLACE Since repo rates move closely with those of
other short-term instruments, the hedge vehicles
On any given day, the volume of repo transac- available for these other instruments offer an
tions amounts to an estimated $1 trillion. Impor- attractive hedge for positions in repos. If the
tant lenders of funds in the market include large portfolio of repos is not maintained as a matched
corporations (for example, General Motors) and book by the institution, the dealer or bank could
mutual funds. Borrowers generally include large be subject to a level of residual market risk.
If the buyer is to rely on its ability to sell a LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
security in the open market upon the seller’s INVESTMENT
default, it must exercise effective control over
the securities collateralizing the transactions. Repos on securities that are eligible for bank
The Government Securities Act was passed in investment under 12 USC 24 (seventh) and 12
1986 to address abuses that had resulted in CFR 1 and that meet guidelines set forth by the
customer losses when the security was held by Federal Reserve System may be held without
the seller. Its requirements include (1) written limit. Repos that do not meet these guidelines
repurchase agreements must be in place, (2) the should be treated as unsecured loans to the
risks of the transactions must be disclosed to counterparty subject to 12 USC 84 and should
the customer, (3) specific repurchase securities be combined with other credit extensions to that
must be allocated to and segregated for the counterparty. Repos with affiliates are subject to
customer, and (4) confirmations must be made 12 USC 371c.
and provided to the customer by the end of the
day on which a transaction is initiated and on
any day on which a substitution of securities REFERENCES
occurs. Participants in repo transactions now
will often require securities to be delivered or Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve
held by a third-party custodian. (See sec- System. Commercial Bank Examination
tion 2020.1 of the Commercial Bank Examina- Manual. Section 2030.1, ‘‘Bank Dealer
tion Manual.) Activities.’’
Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve ‘‘How Banks Reap the Benefits of Repo.’’
System. Bank Holding Company Supervision International Securities Lending. Second quar-
Manual. Section 2150.0, ‘‘Repurchase ter 1994.
Transactions.’’ Mishkin, Frederic S. The Economics of Money,
Clarke, David. ‘‘U.S. Repo: A Model Market.’’ Banking, and Financial Markets. 4th ed. New
International Securities Lending. September York: Harper Collins College Publishers, 1995.
1993. Stigum, Marcia. The Money Market. 3rd ed.
Cook, Timothy Q., and Robert LaRoche, eds. Burr Ridge, Illinois: Irwin Professional Pub-
Instruments of the Money Market. 7th ed. lishing, 1990.
Richmond, Va.: Federal Reserve Bank of Stigum, Marcia. The Repo and Reverse Markets.
Richmond, 1993. Homewood, Illinois: Dow Jones-Irwin, 1989.
Treasury bills, or T-bills, are negotiable, non- T-bills are issued at regular intervals on a yield-
interest-bearing securities with original maturi- auction basis. The three-month and six-month
ties of three months, six months, and one year. T-bills are auctioned every Monday. The one-
T-bills are offered by the Treasury in minimum year T-bills are auctioned in the third week of
denominations of $10,000, with multiples of every month. The amount of T-bills to be
$5,000 thereafter, and are offered only in book- auctioned is released on the preceding Tuesday,
entry form. T-bills are issued at a discount from with settlement occurring on the Thursday fol-
face value and are redeemed at par value. The lowing the auction. The auction of T-bills is
difference between the discounted purchase price done on a competitive-bid basis (the lowest-
and the face value of the T-bill is the interest yield bids are chosen because they will cost the
income that the purchaser receives. The yield on Treasury less money). Noncompetitive bids may
a T-bill is a function of this interest income and also be placed on purchases of up to $1 million.
the maturity of the T-bill. The returns are treated The price paid by these bids (if allocated a
as ordinary income for federal tax purposes and portion of the issue) is an average of the price
are exempt from state and local taxes. resulting from the competitive bids.
Two-year and 5-year notes are issued once a
month. The notes are generally announced near
Treasury Notes and Bonds the middle of each month and auctioned one
week later. They are usually issued on the last
Treasury notes are currently issued in maturities day of each month. Auctions for 3-year and
of 2, 3, 5, and 10 years on a regular schedule. 10-year notes are usually announced on the first
Treasury notes are not callable. Notes and bonds Wednesday of February, May, August, and
pay interest semiannually, when coupon rates November. The notes are generally auctioned
are set at the time of issuance based on market during the second week of those months and
interest rates and demand for the issue. Notes issued on the 15th day of the month.
and bonds are issued monthly or quarterly,
depending on the maturity of the issue. Notes
and bonds settle regular-way, which is one day Primary Market
after the trade date (T+1). Interest is calculated
using an actual/365-day-count convention. Treasury notes and bonds are issued through
yield auctions of new issues for cash. Bids are
separated into competitive bids and noncompeti-
USES tive bids. Competitive bids are made by primary
government dealers, while noncompetitive bids
Banks use Treasuries for investment, hedging, are made by individual investors and small
and speculative purposes. The lack of credit risk institutions. Competitive bidders bid yields to
• Multiple-price auction. Competitive bids are All U.S. government securities are traded OTC,
ranked by the yield bid, from lowest to high- with the primary government securities dealers
est. The lowest price (highest yield) needed to being the largest and most important market
place the allotted securities auction is deter- participants. A small group of interdealer bro-
mined. Treasuries are then allocated to non- kers disseminates quotes and broker trades on a
competitive bidders at the average yield for blind basis between primary dealers and users of
the accepted competitive bids. After all Trea- the Government Securities Clearing Corpora-
suries are allocated to noncompetitive bidders, tion (GSCC), the private clearinghouse created
the remaining securities are allocated to com- in 1986 to settle trades for the market.
petitive bidders, with the bidder bidding the
highest price (lowest yield) being awarded Buy Side
first. This procedure continues until the entire
allocation of securities remaining to be sold is A wide range of investors use Treasuries for
filled. Regional dealers who are not primary investing, hedging, and speculation. This includes
government dealers often get their allotment commercial and investment banks, insurance
of Treasury notes and bonds through primary companies, pension funds, and mutual fund and
dealers, who may submit bids for the accounts retail investors.
of their customers as well as for their own
accounts. This type of auction is used for
3-year and 10-year notes. Market Transparency
Price transparency is relatively high for Trea-
• Single-price auction. In this type of auction, sury securities since several information ven-
each successful competitive bidder and each dors disseminate prices to the investing public.
noncompetitive bidder is awarded securities at Govpx, an industry-sponsored corporation, dis-
the price equivalent to the highest accepted seminates price and trading information over
rate or yield. This type of auction is used for interdealer broker screens. Prices of Treasuries
2-year and 5-year notes. are active and visible.
During the one- to two-week period between
the time a new Treasury note or bond issue is PRICING
auctioned and the time the securities sold are
actually issued, securities that have been auc- Treasury Bills
tioned but not yet issued trade actively on a
when-issued basis. They also trade when-issued Treasury bills are traded on a discount basis.
during the announcement to the auction period. The yield on a discount basis is computed using
the following formula:
Treasury Notes and Bonds the magnitude of risk to which the dealer is
exposed.
Treasury note and bond prices are quoted on a
percentage basis in 32nds. For instance, a price Liquidity Risk
of 98:16 means that the price of the note or bond
will be 98.5 percent of par (that is, 98 16/32). Because of their lower liquidity, off-the-run
Notes and bonds can be refined to 64ths through securities generally have a higher yield than
the use of a plus tick. A 98:16+ bid means that current securities. Many institutions attempt to
the bid is 98 and 161⁄2 32nds (that is, 98 arbitrage these pricing anomalies between cur-
16.5/32), which is equivalent to 98.515625 per- rent and off-the-run securities.
cent of par. When the note or bond is traded, the
buyer pays the dollar price plus accrued interest
as of the settlement date. Yields are also quoted ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
on an actual/365-day-count convention.
The accounting treatment for investments in
Treasuries is determined by the Financial
HEDGING Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
Treasuries are typically hedged in the futures or 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
options markets or by taking a contra position in Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by
another Treasury security. Also, if a position in Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
notes or bonds is hedged using an OTC option, No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
the relative illiquidity of the option may dimin- and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
ish the effectiveness of the hedge. guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
ment for derivatives used as investments or for
hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
RISKS Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
Market Risk Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
The risks of trading Treasury securities arise (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
primarily from the interest-rate risk associated ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
with holding positions and the type of trading
conducted by the institution. Treasury securities
are subject to price fluctuations because of RISK-BASED CAPITAL
changes in interest rates. Longer-term issues WEIGHTING
have more price volatility than shorter-term
instruments. A large concentration of long-term U.S. Treasury bills, notes, and bonds have a zero
maturities may subject a bank’s investment percent risk weighting. For specific risk weights
portfolio to increased interest-rate risk. For for qualified trading accounts, see section 2110.1,
instance, an institution that does arbitrage trad- ‘‘Capital Adequacy.’’
ing by buying an issue that is relatively cheap
(that is, an off-the-run security) in comparison to
historical relationships and selling one that is LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
relatively expensive (that is, a current security) INVESTMENT
may expose itself to large losses if the spread
between the two securities does not follow its U.S. Treasury bills, notes, and bonds are type I
historical alignments. In addition, dealers may securities with no legal limitations on a bank’s
take positions based on their expectations of investment.
interest-rate changes, which can be risky given
the size of positions and the impact that small
changes in rates have on the value of longer- REFERENCES
duration instruments. If this type of trading is
occurring, the institution’s risk-management sys- Fabozzi, Frank J., and T. Dessa Fabozzi, ed. The
tem should be sufficiently sophisticated to handle Handbook of Fixed Income Securities. 4th ed.
Chicago: Irwin Professional Publishing, 1995. U.S. Department of the Treasury. Buying Trea-
Stigum, Marcia L. The Money Market. 3d ed. sury Securities. Washington, D.C.: The
Homewood, Ill.: Dow Jones-Irwin, 1990. Bureau of the Public Debt, 1995.
CHARACTERISTICS AND
FEATURES USES
TIIs were created to meet the needs of longer- At present, the primary strategy behind the
term investors wanting to insulate their invest- purchase of a TII would be to hedge against
ment principal from erosion due to inflation. erosion in value due to inflation. However,
The initial par amount of each TII issue is banks also use TIIs for investment, hedging, and
indexed to the nonseasonally adjusted Con- speculative purposes. As TIIs are tax disadvan-
sumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers taged, they are most likely to appeal to investors
(CPI-U). The index ratio is determined by who are not subject to tax.
dividing the current CPI-U level by the CPI-U An investor in TIIs is taking a view that real
level that applied at the time the security was interest rates will fall. Real interest rates are
issued or last re-indexed. If there is a period of defined as the nominal rate of interest less the
deflation, the principal value can be reduced rate of inflation. If nominal rates fall, but infla-
below par at any time between the date of tion does not (that is, a decline in real interest
issuance and maturity. However, if at maturity rates), TIIs will appreciate because their fixed
the inflation-adjusted principal amount is below coupon will now represent a more attractive rate
par, the Treasury will redeem the security at par. relative to the market. If inflation rises, but
Every six months, interest is paid based on a nominal rates rise more (that is, an increase in
fixed rate determined at the initial auction; this real interest rates), the security will decrease in
rate will remain fixed throughout the term of the value because it will only partially adjust to the
security. Semiannual interest payments are deter- new rate climate.
mined by multiplying the inflation-adjusted prin-
cipal amount by one-half the stated rate of
interest on each payment date. TIIs are eligible DESCRIPTION OF
for stripping into their principal and interest MARKETPLACE
components under the Treasury STRIPS
program. Issuing Practices
Similar to zero-coupon bonds, TIIs are tax
disadvantaged in that investors must pay tax on The auction process will use a single pricing
the accretion to the principal amount of the method identical to the one used for two-year
security, even though they do not currently and five-year fixed-principal Treasury notes. In
receive the increase in principal in cash. Paying this type of auction, each successful competitive
bidder and each noncompetitive bidder is rates in the market. As the coupon rate on TIIs
awarded securities at the price equivalent to the is well below market for similar maturity instru-
highest accepted rate or yield. ments, the duration of TIIs will be higher,
increasing the price sensitivity of the instrument
for a given change in real interest rates. Also,
the CPI-U index used in calculating the princi-
Market Participants pal accretion on TIIs is lagged three months,
Sell Side which will hurt the investor when inflation is
rising (and help the investor when inflation is
Like all U.S. government securities, TIIs are falling).
traded over the counter, with the primary gov- Longer-term issues will have more price vola-
ernment securities dealers being the largest and tility than shorter-term instruments. A large
most important market participants. A small concentration of long-term maturities may sub-
group of interdealer brokers disseminate quotes ject a bank’s investment portfolio to unwar-
and broker trades on a blind basis between ranted interest-rate risk.
primary dealers and users of the Government
Securities Clearing Corporation (GSCC), the
private clearinghouse created in 1986 to settle Liquidity Risk
trades for the market.
The Treasury securities market is the largest and
most liquid in the world. While an active sec-
Buy Side ondary market for TIIs is expected, that market
initially may not be as active or liquid as the
A wide range of investors are expected to use secondary market for Treasury fixed-principal
TIIs for investing, hedging, and speculation, securities. In addition, as a new product, TIIs
including commercial and investment banks, may not be as widely traded or well understood
insurance companies, pension funds, mutual as Treasury fixed-principal securities. Lesser
funds, and individual investors. As noted above, liquidity and fewer market participants may
TIIs will most likely appeal to investors who are result in larger spreads between bid and asked
not subject to tax. prices for TIIs relative to the bid/ask spreads for
fixed-principal securities of the same maturity.
Larger bid/ask spreads normally result in higher
Market Transparency transaction costs and/or lower overall returns.
The liquidity of the TII market is expected to
Price transparency is relatively high for Trea- improve over time as additional amounts are
sury securities since several information ven- issued and more entities enter the market.
dors disseminate prices to the investing public.
Govpx, an industry-sponsored corporation, dis-
seminates price and trading information via
interdealer broker screens. Prices of TIIs are ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
active and visible.
The accounting treatment for investments in
Treasury inflation-indexed securities is deter-
mined by the Financial Accounting Standards
RISKS Board’s Statement of Financial Accounting Stan-
dards No. 115 (FAS 115), ‘‘Accounting for
Interest-Rate Risk Certain Investments in Debt and Equity Securi-
ties,’’ as amended by Statement of Financial
TIIs are subject to price fluctuations because of Accounting Standards No. 140 (FAS 140),
changes in real interest rates. TIIs will decline in ‘‘Accounting for Transfers and Servicing of
value if real interest rates increase. For instance, Financial Assets and Extinguishments of Liabili-
if nominal interest rates rise by more than the ties.’’ Accounting treatment for derivatives used
increase in inflation, the value of a TII will as investments or for hedging purposes is deter-
decrease because the inflation component will mined by Statement of Financial Accounting
not fully adjust to the higher level of nominal Standards No. 133 (FAS 133), ‘‘Accounting for
debt with end-users, and making markets in dated obligations of the 12 regional Federal
these securities. Home Loan Banks whose mandate is to provide
Prices for the securities traded in the second- funds to savings and other home-financing mem-
ary market can be obtained from the ‘‘Money ber organizations.
and Investing’’ section of The Wall Street Jour- The Federal National Mortgage Association
nal or the financial section of local newspapers. (Fannie Mae) issues short-term discount notes
Other media, such as Internet financial sites and and long-term bonds with maturities of up to
Bloomberg, provide over-the-counter quotes as 30 years. Fannie Mae has also issued indexed
well. sinking-fund debentures which are callable and
contain features of both mortgage-backed secu-
rities and callable corporate bonds. The Federal
Federal Agencies Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie
Mac) issues discount notes and a limited number
Federal agencies do not issue securities directly of bonds. The Student Loan Marketing Associa-
in the marketplace. Since 1973, most have tion (Sallie Mae) issues unsecured debt obliga-
raised funds through the Federal Financing Bank, tions in the form of discount notes to provide
although many of these institutions have out- funds to support higher education.
standing obligations from previous debt issues.
Federal agencies include the following: the
Export-Import Bank of the United States, Com- PRICING
modity Credit Corporation, Farmers Home
Administration, General Services Administra- Agency notes and bonds are quoted in terms of
tion, Government National Mortgage Associa- 32nds (a percentage of par plus 32nds of a
tion, Maritime Administration, Private Export point). Thus, an investor will be willing to pay
Funding Corporation, Rural Electrification 101.5 percent of par for an agency security that
Administration, Rural Telephone Bank, Small is quoted at 101:16. Short-term discount notes
Business Administration, Tennessee Valley are issued on a discount basis similar to the way
Authority, and Washington Metropolitan Area that U.S. Treasury bills are priced.
Transit Authority (neither the Tennessee Valley Agency securities trade at yields offering a
Authority nor the Private Export Funding Cor- positive spread over Treasury security yields
poration is backed by the full faith and credit of because of slightly greater credit risk (due to
the U.S. government). the lack of an explicit government guarantee
for most obligations) and somewhat lower
liquidity.
Federally Sponsored Agencies
Following is a summary of the main federally HEDGING
sponsored agencies and the types of obligations
that they typically issue to the public. The The price risk of most agency securities is
Federal Farm Credit Bank System issues dis- hedged in the cash market for Treasury securi-
count notes; short-term bonds with maturities ties or by using Treasury futures or options. As
of three, six, and nine months; and long-term with all hedges, yield curve and basis risk must
bonds with maturities of between one and be monitored closely. In addition, dealers who
10 years. The Federal Farm Credit Bank also are actively conducting arbitrage trades and
issues medium-term notes which have maturi- other strategies should have the capability to
ties of between one and 30 years. The Federal monitor their positions effectively.
Farm Credit System Financial Assistance Cor-
poration issues 15-year notes, guaranteed by the
federal government, which were issued to sup-
port the Farm Credit System in the mid-1980s. RISKS
The Federal Home Loan Bank System issues
discount notes that mature in one year or less As with any security, much of the risk is a
and noncallable bonds with maturities ranging function of the type of trading strategy con-
from one to 10 years. These debts are consoli- ducted by an institution.
ty’s coupon adjusts by a fraction of the change therefore depend on the frequency of resets, the
in rates, for example, .60 × 10-year CMT + 100 amount of coupon increase at each reset, and
basis points. the final maturity of the note. Longer maturity
De-leveraged floaters are combinations of notes, which have limited reset dates and limited
fixed- and floating-rate instruments. For exam- coupon increases, will be more volatile in
ple, a $10 million de-leveraged floater with a rising- rate environments and will therefore
coupon of 60 percent of the 10-year CMT + 100 have a greater degree of interest-rate and price
basis points is equivalent to the investor holding risk.
a $6 million note with a coupon equal to a
10-year CMT/LIBOR basis swap and a $4 mil-
lion fixed-rate instrument. If rates rise, an inves-
tor in a de-leveraged floater participates in the Dual-Index Notes
rise, but only by a fraction. The leverage factor
(for example, 60 percent) causes the coupons A dual-index note (sometimes called a yield
to lag the actual market. Thus, de-leveraged curve anticipation note (YCAN)) is a security
floaters will outperform straight bond issuances whose coupon is tied to the spread between two
in a declining or stable interest-rate environment. market indexes. An example is a three-year
Conversely, a leveraged floater such as the security which pays a semiannual coupon equal
example above should be purchased by inves- to (prime + 250 basis points − 6-month LIBOR).
tors with an expectation of rising rates in which Typical indexes used to structure payoffs to
they would receive better than one one-to-one these notes are the prime rate, LIBOR, COFI,
participation. The degree of leverage amplifies and CMT yields of different maturities. Yield-
the risks as well as the rewards of this type of curve notes allow the investor to lock in a very
security. The greater the leverage, the greater the specific view about forward rates. Such a play,
interest-rate and price risk of the security. while constructable in the cash market, is often
Other alternatives in this category include difficult and costly to an investor. A purchaser of
floaters which do not permit the coupon to this type of security is typically making an
decrease, so-called one-way de-leveraged float- assumption about the future shape of the yield
ers which can effectively lock in higher coupons curve. These notes can be structured to reward
in an environment where the index rises then the investors in either steepening or flattening
falls. yield-curve environments. However, these notes
can also be tied to indexes other than interest
rates, such as foreign-exchange rates, stock
indexes, or commodity prices.
Ratchet Notes An example of a note which would appeal to
investors with expectations of a flattening yield
Ratchet notes typically pay a floating-rate cou- curve (in a currently steep yield-curve environ-
pon that can never go down. The notes generally ment) would be one with a coupon that floats at
have periodic caps that limit the amount of the
increases (ratchets) or that set a predetermined [the 5-year CMT − the 10-year CMT
increase for each quarter. These periodic caps + a designated spread].
are akin to those found in adjustable-rate mort-
gage products. Based on this formula, the coupon will increase
An investor in a ratchet note has purchased if the yield curve flattens between the 5-year and
from the issuer a series of periodic floors and the 10-year maturities. Alternatively, a yield-
has sold a series of periodic caps. As such, a curve-steepening play would be an issue that
ratchet note will outperform a straight floating- floats at—
rate note in a stable or declining interest-rate
environment, and it will underperform in a [the 10-year CMT − the 5-year CMT
rapidly rising interest-rate environment. In a + a designated spread].
rapidly rising interest-rate environment, a ratchet
note will perform similarly to a fixed-rate instru- In this case, coupons would increase as the
ment with a low coupon which gradually steps spread between the long- and medium-term
up. The price volatility of the instrument will indexes widens.
Rate
2-Year Swap
Rate − 3-Month Redemption
Par LIBOR Rate − 1.40 5*(Rate − 140) Percentage
Under a principal-linked structured note, the the index remains within a designated range, the
maturity and the fixed coupon payments are lower rate is used during periods that the index
unchanged from the terms established at issu- falls outside the range. This lower level may be
ance. The issuer’s redemption obligation at zero. Range notes have been issued which ref-
maturity, however, is not the face value of the erence underlying indexes linked to interest
note. Redemption amounts are established by a rates, currencies, commodities, and equities.
formula whose components reflect historical or Most range notes reference the index daily such
prevailing market levels. Principal-linked notes that interest may accrue at 7 percent on one day
have been issued when the principal redemption and at 2 percent on the following day, if the
is a function of underlying currency, commod- underlying index crosses in and out of the range.
ity, equity, and interest-rate indexes. As the However, they can also reference the index
return of principal at maturity in many types of monthly, quarterly, or only once over the note’s
principal-linked notes is not ensured, these struc- life. If the note only references quarterly, then
tures are subject to a great degree of price risk. the index’s relationship to the range matters
only on the quarterly reset date. With the pur-
chase of one of these notes, the investor has sold
Range Notes a series of digital (or binary) options:1 a call
Range notes (also called accrual notes) accrue 1. A digital option has a fixed, predetermined payoff if the
underlying instrument or index is at or beyond the strike at
interest daily at a set coupon which is tied to an expiration. The value of the payoff is not affected by the
index. Most range notes have two coupon lev- magnitude of the difference between the underlying and the
els; the higher accrual rate is for the period that strike price.
struck at the high end of the range and a put portfolios and/or to express a viewpoint about
struck at the low end of the range. This means the course of interest rates or other financial
that the accrual rate is strictly defined, and the variables. The basic appeal of structured notes
magnitude of movement outside the range is lies in their attendant customized risk param-
inconsequential. The narrower the range, the eters. Attributes that typically are not available
greater the coupon enhancement over a like (or not easily available) to an investor are
instrument. In some cases, the range varies each assembled in a prepackaged format. Addition-
year that the security is outstanding. ally, investors find the notes attractive for other
However, range notes also exist which require distinct reasons. In a sustained period of low
that the investor sell two barrier options:2 a interest rates (such as the United States experi-
down-and-out put struck at the low level of the enced for the five years leading up to February
range and an up-and-out call struck at the high 1994), receiving an ‘‘acceptable’’ return on an
level of the range. For these range notes, the investment became increasingly difficult. Struc-
index must remain within the target band for the tured notes, whose cash flows and market values
entire accrual period, and sometimes for the are linked to one or more benchmarks, offered
entire life of the instrument. If it crosses either the potential for greater returns than prevailing
barrier on even one day, the investor’s coupon market rates. The desire for higher yield led
will drop to zero for the whole period.3 This investors to make a risk-return tradeoff which
type of range note is quite rare, but investors reflected their market view.
should pay careful attention to the payment The fact that most structured notes are issued
provisions attached to movements outside the by government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs)
range. means that credit risk—the risk that the issuer
As the investor has sold leveraged call and will default—is minimal. GSEs are not, how-
put options to the issuer of these securities, a ever, backed by the full faith and credit of the
range note will outperform other floating-rate U.S. government, though most have explicit
instruments in stable environments when the lines of credit from the Treasury. As a result,
index remains within the specified range, and it investors were attracted by the potential returns
will underperform in volatile environments in of structured notes and by their high credit
which the underlying index is outside of the quality (implied government guarantee). As
specified range. Given the degree of leverage noted above, however, the credit risk of these
inherent in these types of structures, the securi- notes may be minimal, but their price risk may
ties can be very volatile and often exhibit a be significant.
significant degree of price risk.
Uses by Issuers
USES
Issuers often issue structured notes to achieve
Structured notes are used for a variety of pur- all-in funding rates, which are more advanta-
poses by investors, issuers, and underwriters or geous than what is achievable through a straight
traders. Banks are often involved in all three of debt issue. To induce issuers to issue complex
these capacities. and often very specialized debt instruments,
investors often will sacrifice some return, which
lowers the issuer’s all-in cost of funding. Gen-
Uses by Investors erally, only highly rated (single-A or better)
banks, corporations, agencies, and finance com-
Structured notes are investment vehicles that panies will be able to issue in the structured-note
allow investors to alter the risk profile of their market. A detailed discussion of issuing prac-
tices is included in the ‘‘Description of Market-
2. Path-dependent options with both their payoff pattern
place’’ subsection below.
and their survival to the nominal expiration date are dependent
not only on the final price of the underlying but on whether the
underlying sells at or through a barrier (instrike, outstrike) Uses by Underwriters or Traders
price during the life of the option.
3. McNeil, Rod. ‘‘The Revival of the Structured Note
Market.’’ International Bond Investor. Summer 1994, pp. Investment banks and the section 20 subsidiaries
34–37. of banks often act to underwrite structured-note
Investors in secondary structured notes may (1) on an asset-swap basis or (2) on a straight-
buy the notes at a discount or premium to pricing basis.
issuance and receive the performance character-
istics of the note as shown in the prospectus.
Investors may also purchase structured notes on Asset-Swap Pricing
an asset-swap basis, which strips the optionality
out of a note and leaves the investor with a Structured notes are typically constructed by
synthetically created ‘‘plain vanilla’ return such embedding some form of optionality in the
as LIBOR. Asset-swap pricing is discussed in coupon, principal, or maturity component of a
the ‘‘Pricing’’ subsection below. debt issue. Once these embedded derivatives are
Secondary structured notes are also used to quantified, a swap or series of swaps can be
create special-purpose vehicles such as Merrill undertaken to strip out those options and effec-
Lynch’s STEERS program. In these types of tively create a synthetic instrument with either
programs, secondary structured notes are placed fixed or variable cash-flow streams. This pro-
in a special-purpose vehicle, the receipts of cess is known as asset-swap pricing.5
which are then sold to investors. A series of Asset-swap pricing initially involves decom-
swap transactions is then entered into between a posing and valuing the components of the note,
swap counterparty and the special-purpose vehi- including contingent cash flows. It conveys
cle, which strips the optionality out of the where those components can be cashed out in
structures. The investor therefore receives a trust the market, often referred to as the break-up
receipt which pays a plain vanilla return such as value of the note. After the note is decomposed,
LIBOR. an alternate cash-flow stream is created through
Structured notes often possess greater liquid- the asset-swap market.
ity risk than many other types of securities. The When structured notes are priced on an asset-
most important factor affecting the liquidity of swap basis, the issue is analyzed based on its
the note in the secondary market is the size of salvage value.6 The salvage value on most
the secondary note being traded. Generally, the agency structured issues varies based on the
larger the size of the note, the more liquid the current market and the size, type, and maturity
note will be in the secondary market. Most of the note.
investors will not buy a structured note of Liquidity in the structured-notes market exists
limited size unless they receive a significant because every note has a salvage value. If
premium to cover the administrative costs of demand for the note as a whole is weak, its cash
booking the note. Similarly, most market makers flows can be reconstructed via the asset-swap
will not inventory small pieces of paper unless market to create a synthetic security. In many
they charge a significant liquidity premium. cases, the re-engineered security has broader
Another factor which may affect the liquidity investor appeal, thereby generating needed
of a structured note in the secondary market is liquidity for the holder of the original issue.
the one-way ‘‘bullishness’’ or ‘‘bearishness’’ of
a note. For example, in a rising-rate environ-
ment, leveraged bullish instruments such as
inverse floaters may not be in demand by Straight Pricing
investors and may therefore have less liquidity
Contrasted with an asset-swapped issue, a note
in the secondary market. As many structured
trading on a straight-pricing basis is purchased
notes are sold on an asset-swap basis, the
and sold as is.7 Traders who price structured
characteristics of the structured note can be
notes on this basis compare the note with similar
‘‘engineered’’ out of the note, leaving the inves-
types of instruments trading in the market and
tor with a plain vanilla return. The asset-swap
derive a price accordingly.
market, therefore, helps to increase the liquidity
of these types of notes.
5. See the Federal Reserve product summary Asset Swaps—
Creating Synthetic Instruments by Joseph Cilia for a detailed
PRICING treatment on the topic.
6. Goodman, Laurie. ‘‘Anatomy of the Secondary Struc-
tured Note Market.’’ Derivatives Quarterly, Fall 1995.
The two primary methods by which structured 7. Peng, Scott Y., and Ravi E. Dattatreya. The Structured
notes are priced in the secondary market are Note Market. Chicago: Probus, 1995.
HEDGING RISKS
Structured notes are, from a cash-flow perspec- Market Risk
tive, a combination of traditional debt instru-
ments and derivative contracts. As a result, the The embedded options and other leverage fac-
value (or performance) of a structured note can tors inherent in structured notes result in a great
be replicated by combining components consist- deal of uncertainty about future cash flows.
ing of appropriate zero-coupon debt plus appro- Thus, price volatility is generally high in these
priate futures or options positions that reflect the types of securities. An institution should have—
optionality embedded in the issue. Similar to the or should have ready access to—a model which
decomposition process employed in an asset- is able to quantify the risks. The model should
wap transaction, the fair value of this replicated be able to forecast the change in market price at
portfolio should be equivalent to the fair value various points in time (for example, one year
of the structured note. later or the first call date) for a given shift in
interest rates. For the many variants of these
Theoretically, one should be indifferent about products which are tied to the shape of the yield
investing in a structured note or in its equiva- curve, the ability to model price effects from
lently constructed portfolio as long as the price nonparallel interest-rate shifts is also crucial. In
of the note equals the present value of its most cases (except for some principal-linked
replication components.8 Price discrepancy notes), full principal will be returned at maturity.
should govern the selection process between However, between issuance and redemption,
these alternatives. changes in fundamental factors can give rise to
A hedge of a structured-note position involves significant reductions in the ‘‘market’’ price.
engaging in the opposite of the replication trades As with other types of instruments in which
noted above. To be fully protected in a hedge, an investor has sold an option, structured notes
the sum of the present values of each component will underperform similar straight debt issu-
of the hedge should be less than or equal to the ances in a volatile rate environment. For notes
market value of the note. If, for some reason, the such as callable step-ups and IANs, the investor
note was priced higher than the cost of the may be exposed to reinvestment risk (investing
worst-case replication components, the hedging the proceeds of the note in a low-interest-rate
firm stands to lock in a positive spread if that environment) when rates decrease and to exten-
worst-case scenario fails to materialize.9 sion risk (not being able to invest in a high-
A structured-note position itself can serve to interest-rate environment) when rates increase.
hedge unique risks faced by the investor. For
example, a company which is long (owns)
Japanese yen (¥) is exposed to the risk of yen Liquidity Risk
depreciation. The FHLB issued a one-year struc-
tured range note which accrued interest daily at Due to the complex nature of structured notes,
7 percent if the ¥/U.S.$ is greater than 108.50 or the number of firms that are able and willing to
at 0 percent if the ¥/U.S.$ is less than 108.50. If competitively price and bid for these securities
the yen depreciates, the note accrues interest at is quite small; however, an active secondary
an above-market rate. Meanwhile, the compa- market has developed over the past few years.
ny’s yen holdings will decline in value. This When the structure is complex, however, bid-
note could serve as a perfectly tailored hedge for ders may be few. Consequently, an institution
the company’s business-risk profile. In fact, the hoping to liquidate a structured-note holding
design of many of the most complicated struc- before maturity may find that their only option is
tured notes is driven not by the innovations of to sell at a significant loss. In certain cases, the
note issuers and underwriters, but rather by issue’s original underwriter is the only source
investors seeking to hedge their own unique risk for a bid (and even that is not always guaranteed).
profiles. Some factors influencing the liquidity of the
note include the type, size, and maturity of the
note. In general, the more complex the structure
8. Kawaller, Ira G. ‘‘Understanding Structured Notes.’’
or the more a note exhibits one-way bullishness
Derivatives Quarterly, Spring 1995. or bearishness, the less liquidity a note will
9. Ibid., p. 32. have. Although the asset-swap market allows
the derivative components to be engineered out (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
of these complex structures, liquidity may be ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
impaired because many institutions have invest-
ment guidelines that prohibit the purchase of
certain types of complex notes. Thus, the size of RISK-BASED CAPITAL
the potential market is diminished, and liquidity WEIGHTING
decreases. Also, notes with a smaller size (gen-
erally under $10 million) and a longer maturity Structured notes issued by GSEs should be
(generally greater than five years) will tend to be given a 20 percent risk weighting. Structured
less liquid. notes issued by investment-grade corporations
should be given a 100 percent risk weighting.
For specific risk weights for qualified trading
Volatility Risk accounts, see section 2110.1, ‘‘Capital
Adequacy.’’
For each of these structures with embedded
options, assumptions about the volatility of
interest-rate moves are also inherent. For any of
these options that are purchased by investors LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
(for example, interest-rate floors), the risk that INVESTMENT
expectations for market-rate volatility will
decrease over time exists. If that happens, mar- The limitations of 12 CFR 1 apply to structured
ket valuation of these securities will also notes. Structured notes issued by GSEs are type
decrease, and the investor will have ‘‘pur- I securities, and there is no limitation on the
chased’’ an overvalued option for which he or amount which a bank can purchase or sell.
she will not be compensated if the instrument is Structured notes issued by investment-grade-
sold before maturity. For options that are sold by rated corporations are type III securities. A
investors (for example, interest-rate caps), the bank’s purchases and sales of type III securities
risk that volatility increases after the note is are limited to 10 percent of its capital and
purchased exists. If that occurs, the market surplus.
valuation of the structured note will decrease,
and the investor will have ‘‘sold’’ an underval-
ued option for which he or she will have to pay
a higher price if the instrument is sold before REFERENCES
maturity.
Audley, David, Richard Chin, and Shrikant
Ramamurthy. ‘‘Derivative Medium-Term
Notes’’ and ‘‘Callable Multiple Step-Up
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT Bonds.’’ Prudential Securities Financial Strat-
egies Group, October 1993 and May 1994,
The Financial Accounting Standards Board’s respectively.
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards ‘‘BankAmerica Exec Explains What Happened
No. 115 (FAS 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain with Its $68M Fund Bailout.’’ American
Investments in Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as Banker, October 17, 1994.
amended by Statement of Financial Accounting Cilia, Joseph. Product Summary— Asset Swaps—
Standards No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Creating Synthetic Instruments. Federal
Transfers and Servicing of Financial Assets and Reserve Bank of Chicago, August 1996.
Extinguishments of Liabilities,’’ determines the Cilia, Joseph, and Karen McCann. Product
accounting treatment for investments in struc- Summary—Structured Notes. Federal Reserve
tured notes. Accounting treatment for deriva- Bank of Chicago, November 1994.
tives used as investments or for hedging pur- Crabbe, Leland E., and Joseph D. Argilagos.
poses is determined by Statement of Financial ‘‘Anatomy of the Structured Note Market.’’
Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS 133), Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, Fall
‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging 1994.
Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan- Goodman, Laurie, and Linda Lowell. ‘‘Struc-
cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138 tured Note Alternatives to Fixed Rate and
Floating Rate CMOs.’’ Derivatives Quarterly, Note Market.’’ International Bond Investor.
Spring 1995. Summer 1994, pp. 34–37.
Kawaller, Ira G. ‘‘Understanding Structured Peng, Scott Y., and Ravi E. Dattatreya. The
Notes.’’ Derivatives Quarterly, Spring 1995. Structured Note Market. Chicago: Probus,
McNeil, Rod. ‘‘The Revival of the Structured 1995.
Corporate bonds are debt obligations issued by Collateral trust bonds are secured by pledges of
corporations. Corporate bonds may be either stocks, notes, bonds, or other collateral. Gener-
secured or unsecured. Collateral used for secured ally, the market or appraised value of the collat-
debt includes but is not limited to real property, eral must be maintained at some percentage of
machinery, equipment, accounts receivable, the amount of the bonds outstanding, and a
stocks, bonds, or notes. If the debt is unsecured, provision for withdrawal of some collateral is
the bonds are known as debentures. Bondhold- often included, provided other acceptable collat-
ers, as creditors, have a prior legal claim over eral is provided. Collateral trust bonds may be
common and preferred stockholders as to both issued in series.
income and assets of the corporation for the
principal and interest due them and may have a
prior claim over other creditors if liens or Equipment Trust Certificates
mortgages are involved.
Corporate bonds contain elements of both Equipment trust certificates are usually issued
interest-rate risk and credit risk. Corporate bonds by railroads or airlines. The issuer, such as a
usually yield more than government or agency railroad company or airline, buys a piece of
bonds due to the presence of credit risk. Corpo- equipment from a manufacturer, who transfers
rate bonds are issued as registered bonds and are the title to the equipment to a trustee. The trustee
usually sold in book-entry form. Interest may be then leases the equipment to the issuer and at the
fixed, floating, or the bonds may be zero cou- same time sells equipment trust certificates
pons. Interest on corporate bonds is typically (ETCs) to investors. The manufacturer is paid
paid semiannually and is fully taxable to the off through the sale of the certificates, and
bondholder. interest and principal are paid to the bondhold-
ers through the proceeds of lease payments from
the issuer to the trustee. At the end of some
specified period of time, the certificates are paid
off, the trustee sells the equipment to the issuer
CHARACTERISTICS AND for a nominal price, and the lease is terminated.
FEATURES As the issuer does not own the equipment,
foreclosing a lien in event of default is facili-
tated. These bonds are often issued in serial
Security for Bonds form.
Various types of security may be pledged to
offer security beyond that of the general stand-
ing of the issuer. Secured bonds, such as first- Debenture Bonds
mortgage bonds, collateral trust bonds, and
equipment trust certificates, yield a lower rate of Debenture bonds are not secured by a specific
interest than comparable unsecured bonds pledge of designated property. Debenture bond-
because of the greater security they provide to holders have the claim of general creditors on all
the bondholder. assets of the issuer not pledged specifically to
secure other debt. They also have a claim on
pledged assets to the extent that these assets
have value greater than necessary to satisfy
First-Mortgage Bonds secured creditors. Debentures often contain a
variety of provisions designed to afford some
First-mortgage bonds normally grant the bond- degree of protection to bondholders, including
holder a first-mortgage lien on the property of limitation on the amount of additional debt
the issuer. Often first-mortgage bonds are issued issuance, minimum maintenance requirements
in series with bonds of each series secured on net working capital, and limits on the pay-
equally by the same first mortgage. ment of cash dividends by the issuer. If an issuer
has no secured debt, it is customary to provide a semiannually and at maturity. Interest pay-
negative pledge clause—a provision that deben- ments once a year are the norm for bonds sold
tures will be secured equally with any secured overseas. Interest on corporate bonds is based
bonds that may be issued in the future. on a 360-day year, made up of twelve 30-day
months.
Market Participants
PRICING
Buy Side
The major factors influencing the value of a
The largest holder of corporate debt in the corporate bond are—
United States is the insurance industry, account-
ing for more than 33 percent of ownership at the • its coupon rate relative to prevailing market
end of 1993. Private pension funds are the interest rates (typical of all bonds, bond prices
second-largest holders with 13.7 percent of will decline when market interest rates rise
ownership. Commercial banks account for above the coupon rate, and prices will rise
approximately 4.5 percent of ownership of out- when interest rates decline below the coupon
standing corporate bonds. rate) and
• the issuer’s credit standing (a change in an
issuer’s financial condition or ability to finance
Sell Side the debt can cause a change in the risk
premium and price of the security).
Corporate bonds are underwritten in the primary
market by investment banks and section 20 Other factors that influence corporate bond
subsidiaries of banks. In the secondary market, prices are the existence of call options, put
corporate bonds are traded in the listed and features, sinking funds, convertibility features,
unlisted markets. Listed markets include the and guarantees or insurance. These factors can
New York Stock Exchange and the American significantly alter the risk/return profile of a
Stock Exchange. These markets primarily ser- bond issue. (These factors and their effect on
vice retail investors who trade in small lots. The pricing are discussed in the ‘‘Characteristics and
over-the-counter market is the primary market Features’’ subsection above.)
for professional investors. In the secondary The majority of corporate bonds are traded on
market, investment banks and section 20 sub- the over-the-counter market and are priced as a
sidiaries of banks may act as either a broker or spread over U.S. Treasuries. Most often the
dealer. Brokers execute orders for the accounts benchmark U.S. Treasury is the on-the-run (cur-
of customers; they are agents and get a commis- rent coupon) issue. However, pricing ‘‘abnor-
sion for their services. Dealers buy and sell for malities’’ can occur where the benchmark U.S.
their own accounts, thus taking the risk of Treasury is different from the on-the-run security.
reselling at a loss.
HEDGING
Sources of Information
Interest-rate risk for corporate debt can be hedged
For a primary offering, the primary source of either with cash, exchange-traded, or over-the-
information is contained in a prospectus filed by counter instruments. Typically, long corporate
the issuer with the Securities and Exchange bond or note positions are hedged by selling a
Commission. For seasoned issues, major con- U.S. Treasury issue of similar maturity or by
tractual provisions are provided in Moody’s shorting an exchange-traded futures contract.
manuals or Standard & Poor’s corporation The effectiveness of the hedge depends, in part,
records. on basis risk and the degree to which the hedge
has neutralized interest-rate risk. Hedging strat- another corporation. The safety of the bond may
egies may incorporate assumptions about the depend on the financial condition of the guaran-
correlation between the credit spread and gov- tor, since the guarantor will make principal and
ernment rates. The effectiveness of these strat- interest payments if the obligor cannot. Credit
egies may be affected if these assumptions prove enhancements often are used to improve the
inaccurate. Hedges can be constructed with credit rating of a bond issue, thereby reducing
securities from the identical issuer but with the rate of interest that the issuer must pay.
varying maturities. Alternatively, hedges can be Zero-coupon bonds may pose greater credit-
constructed with issuers within an industry risk problems. When a zero-coupon bond has
group. The relative illiquidity of various corpo- been sold at a deep discount, the issuer must
rate instruments may diminish hedging have the funds to make a large payment at
effectiveness. maturity. This potentially large balloon repay-
ment may significantly increase the credit risk of
the issue.
RISKS
Interest-Rate Risk Liquidity Risk
For fixed-income bonds, prices fluctuate with Major issues are actively traded in large amounts,
changes in interest rates. The degree of interest- and liquidity concerns may be small. Trading
rate sensitivity depends on the maturity and for many issues, however, may be inactive and
coupon of the bond. Floating-rate issues lessen significant liquidity problems may affect pric-
the bank’s interest-rate risk to the extent that the ing. The trading volume of a security determines
rate adjustments are responsive to market rate the size of the bid/ask spread of a bond. This
movements. For this reason, these issues gener- provides an indication of the bond’s marketabil-
ally have lower yields to compensate for their ity and, hence, its liquidity. A narrow spread of
benefit to the holder. between one-quarter to one-half of 1 percent
may indicate a liquid market, while a spread of
2 percent or 3 percent may indicate poor liquid-
Prepayment or Reinvestment Risk ity for a bond. Even for major issues, news of
credit problems may cause temporary liquidity
Call provisions will also affect a bank’s interest- problems.
rate exposure. If the issuer has the right to
redeem the bond before maturity, the action has
the potential to adversely alter the investor’s Event Risk
exposure. The issue is most likely to be called
when market rates have moved in the issuer’s Event risk can be large for corporate bonds. This
favor, leaving the investor with funds to invest is the risk of an unpredictable event that imme-
in a lower-interest-rate environment. diately affects the ability of an issuer to service
the obligations of a bond. Examples of event
risk include leveraged buyouts, corporate restruc-
Credit Risk turings, or court rulings that affect the credit
rating of a company. To mitigate event risk,
Credit risk is a function of the financial condi- some indentures include a maintenance of net
tion of the issuer or the degree of support worth clause, which requires the issuer to main-
provided by a credit enhancement. The bond tain its net worth above a stipulated level. If the
rating may be a quick indicator of credit quality. requirement is not met, the issuer must begin to
However, changes in bond ratings may lag retire its debt at par.
behind changes in financial condition. Banks
holding corporate bonds should perform a peri-
odic financial analysis to determine the credit ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
quality of the issuer.
Some bonds will include a credit enhance- The Financial Accounting Standards Board’s
ment in the form of insurance or a guarantee by Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 115 (FAS 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
Investments in Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as INVESTMENT
amended by Statement of Financial Accounting
Standards No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Corporate notes and bonds are type III securi-
Transfers and Servicing of Financial Assets and ties. A bank may purchase or sell for its own
Extinguishments of Liabilities,’’ determines the account corporate debt subject to the limitation
accounting treatment for investments in corpo- that the corporate debt of a single obligor may
rate notes and bonds. Accounting treatment for not exceed 10 percent of the bank’s capital and
derivatives used as investments or for hedging surplus. To be eligible for purchase, a corporate
purposes is determined by Statement of Finan- security must be investment grade (that is, rated
cial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS 133), BBB or higher) and must be marketable. Banks
‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging may not deal in or underwrite corporate bonds.
Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
(FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.) REFERENCES
Fabozzi, Frank, and T. Dessa, eds. The Hand-
RISK-BASED CAPITAL book of Fixed Income Securities. Chicago:
WEIGHTING Irwin Professional Publishing, 1995.
Fabozzi, Frank, and Richard Wilson. Corporate
Corporate notes and bonds should be weighted Bonds. Frank J. Fabozzi Associates, 1996.
at 100 percent. For specific risk weights for ‘‘How Do Corporate Spread Curves Move Over
qualified trading accounts, see section 2110.1, Time?’’ Salomon Brothers, July 1995.
‘‘Capital Adequacy.’’
The state and local income taxation treatment by the SEC. Examination and enforcement of
of municipal securities varies greatly from state MSRB standards is delegated to the NASD for
to state. Many states and local governments securities firms and to the appropriate federal
exempt interest income only on those bonds and banking agency (Federal Reserve, OCC, or
notes issued by government entities located FDIC) for banking organizations.
within their own boundaries.
Secondary Market
USES Municipal securities are not listed on or traded
in exchanges; however, there are strong and
Municipal securities have traditionally been held active secondary markets for municipal securi-
primarily for investment purposes by investors ties that are supported by municipal bond deal-
who would benefit from income that is advan- ers. These traders buy and sell to other dealers
taged under federal income tax statutes and and investors and for their own inventories. The
regulations. This group includes institutional bond broker’s broker also serves a significant
investors such as insurance companies, mutual role in the market for municipal bonds. These
funds, commercial banks, and retail investors. brokers are a small number of interdealer bro-
The value of the tax advantage and, therefore, kers who act as agents for registered dealers and
the attractiveness of the security increase when dealer banks. In addition to using these brokers,
the income earned is also advantaged under state many dealers advertise municipal offerings for
and local tax laws. Wealthy individuals and the retail market through the Blue List. The Blue
corporations face the highest marginal tax rates List is published by Standard & Poor’s Corpo-
and, therefore, stand to receive the highest ration and lists securities and yields or prices of
tax-equivalent yields on these securities. Private bonds and notes being offered by dealers.
individuals are the largest holders of municipal
securities, accounting for three-fourths of these
securities outstanding.
Market Participants
Market participants in the municipal securities
DESCRIPTION OF industry include underwriters, broker-dealers,
MARKETPLACE brokers’ brokers, the rating agencies, bond
insurers, and investors. Financial advisors, who
Issuing Practices advise state and local governments for both
competitive and negotiated offerings, and bond
State and local government entities can market counsel, who provide opinions on the legality of
their new bond issues by offering them publicly specific obligations, are also important partici-
or placing them privately with a small group of pants in the industry. The underwriting business
investors. When a public offering is selected, the primarily consists of a small number of large
issue is usually underwritten by investment broker-dealers, typically with retail branch sys-
bankers and municipal bond departments of tems, and a large number of regional under-
banks. The underwriter may acquire the securi- writers and broker-dealers with ties to local
ties either by negotiation with the issuer or by governments and who specialize in placing debt
award on the basis of competitive bidding. The in their individual regions.
underwriter is responsible for the distribution of
the issue and accepts the risk that investors
might fail to purchase the issues at the expected Market Transparency
prices. For most sizable issues, underwriters join
together in a syndicate to spread the risk of the Price transparency in the municipal securities
sale and gain wider access to potential investors. industry varies depending on the type of security
Standards and practices for the municipal and the issuer. Prices for public issues are more
securities activities of banks and other market readily available than prices for private place-
participants are set by the Municipal Securities ments. Two publications quote prices for
Rulemaking Board (MSRB), a congressionally municipal securities: The Bond Buyer and the
chartered self-regulatory body that is overseen Blue List.
RISK-BASED CAPITAL
Interest-Rate Risk and Market Risk WEIGHTING
Like other fixed-income securities, fixed-income General obligations, BANs, and TANs have a
municipal securities are subject to price fluctua- 20 percent risk weight. Municipal revenue bonds
tions based on changes in interest rates. The and RANs have a 50 percent risk weight.
degree of fluctuation depends on the maturity Industrial development bonds are rated at
and coupon of the security. Variable-rate issues 100 percent. For specific risk weights for quali-
are typically tied to a money market rate, so fied trading accounts, see section 2110.1, ‘‘Capi-
their interest-rate risk will be significantly less. tal Adequacy.’’
Nonetheless, since bond prices and interest rates
are inextricably linked, all municipal securities
involve some degree of interest-rate risk.
Holders of municipal securities are also LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
affected by changes in marginal tax rates. For INVESTMENT
instance, a reduction in marginal tax rates would
lower the tax-equivalent yield on the security, The limitations of 12 USC 24 (section 5136 of
causing the security to depreciate in price. the Revised Statutes) apply to municipal secu-
rities. Municipal securities that are general
obligations are type I securities and may be
purchased by banks in unlimited amounts.
Prepayment or Reinvestment Risk Municipal revenue securities, however, are either
type II or type III securities. The purchase of
Call provisions will affect a bank’s interest-rate type II and type III securities is limited to
exposure. If the issuer has the right to redeem 10 percent of equity capital and reserves for
the bond before maturity, the risk of an adverse each obligor. That limitation is reduced to 5
effect on the bank’s exposure is greater. The percent of equity capital and reserves for all
security is most likely to be called when rates obligors in the aggregate when the judgment of
have moved in the issuer’s favor, leaving the the obligor’s ability to perform is based predomi-
investor with funds to invest in a lower-interest- nantly on reliable estimates versus adequate
rate environment. evidence.
Bankwatch (for domestic banks) or IBCA, Ltd. countries. For specific risk weights for qualified
(for foreign banks). trading accounts, see section 2110.1, ‘‘Capital
The secondary market for Eurodollar CDs is Adequacy.’’
less developed than the domestic CD market.
The current perception of the issuer’s name, as
well as the size and maturity of the issue, may
affect marketability. LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
INVESTMENT
Owning Eurodollar CDs is authorized under the
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT ‘‘incidental powers’’ provisions of 12 USC 24
(seventh). Banks may legally hold these
The Financial Accounting Standards Board’s
instruments without limit.
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 115 (FAS 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain
Investments in Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as
amended by Statment of Financial Accounting REFERENCES
Standards No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for
Transfers and Servicing of Financial Assets and Cook, Timothy Q., and Robert LaRoche, eds.
Extinguishments of Liabilities,’’ determines the Instruments of the Money Market. 7th ed.
accounting treatment for investments in Euro- Richmond, Va.: Federal Reserve Bank of
dollar CDs. Accounting treatment for deriva- Richmond, 1993.
tives used as investments or for hedging pur- Munn, Glenn G. et al. Encyclopedia of Bank-
poses is determined by Statement of Financial ing Finance. 9th ed. Rolling Meadows, Ill.:
Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS 133), Bankers Publishing Company, 1991.
‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging Oppenheim, Peter K. ‘‘The Eurodollar Mar-
Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan- ket.’’ International Banking. 6th ed. Washing-
cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138 ton, D.C.: American Bankers Association,
(FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1, 1991.
‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.) Stigum, Marcia. The Money Market. 3rd ed.
Homewood, Ill.: Business One Irwin, 1990.
RISK-BASED CAPITAL
WEIGHTING
In general, a 20 percent risk weighting is appro-
priate for depository institutions based in OECD
underlying asset pool, up to several multiples of the underlying pool of loans when credit losses
historical losses on the particular asset collater- rise.
alizing the securities. A bank or other issuer may play more than
Overcollateralization is another form of credit one role in the securitization process. An issuer
enhancement that covers a predetermined amount can simultaneously serve as originator of loans,
of potential credit losses. It occurs when the servicer, administrator of the trust, underwriter,
value of the underlying assets exceeds the face provider of liquidity, and credit enhancer. Issu-
value of the securities. A similar form of credit ers typically receive a fee for each element of
enhancement is the cash-collateral account, the transaction.
which is established when a third party deposits Institutions acquiring ABS should recognize
cash into a pledged account. The use of cash- that the multiplicity of roles that may be played
collateral accounts, which are considered by by a single firm—within a single securitization
enhancers to be loans, grew as the number of or across a number of them—means that credit
highly rated banks and other credit enhancers and operational risk can accumulate into signifi-
declined in the early 1990s. Cash-collateral cant concentrations with respect to one or a
accounts provide credit protection to investors small number of firms.
of a securitization by eliminating ‘‘event risk,’’
or the risk that the credit enhancer will have its
credit rating downgraded or that it will not be
able to fulfill its financial obligation to absorb TYPES OF SECURITIZED ASSETS
losses.
An investment banking firm or other organi- There are many different varieties of asset-
zation generally serves as an underwriter for backed securities, often customized to the terms
ABS. In addition, for asset-backed issues that and characteristics of the underlying collateral.
are publicly offered, a credit-rating agency will The most common types are securities collater-
analyze the policies and operations of the origi- alized by revolving credit-card receivables, but
nator and servicer, as well as the structure, instruments backed by home equity loans, other
underlying pool of assets, expected cash flows, second mortgages, and automobile-finance
and other attributes of the securities. Before receivables are also common.
assigning a rating to the issue, the rating agency
will also assess the extent of loss protection
provided to investors by the credit enhance- Installment Loans
ments associated with the issue.
Although the basic elements of all asset- Securities backed by closed-end installment loans
backed securities are similar, individual transac- are typically the least complex form of asset-
tions can differ markedly in both structure and backed instruments. Collateral for these ABS
execution. Important determinants of the risk typically includes leases, automobile loans, and
associated with issuing or holding the securities student loans. The loans that form the pool of
include the process by which principal and collateral for the asset-backed security may have
interest payments are allocated and down- varying contractual maturities and may or may
streamed to investors, how credit losses affect not represent a heterogeneous pool of borrow-
the trust and the return to investors, whether ers. Unlike a mortgage pass-through instrument,
collateral represents a fixed set of specific assets the trustee does not need to take physical pos-
or accounts, whether the underlying loans are session of any account documents to perfect
revolving or closed-end, under what terms security interest in the receivables under the
(including maturity of the asset-backed instru- Uniform Commercial Code. The repayment
ment) any remaining balance in the accounts stream on installment loans is fairly predictable,
may revert to the issuing company, and the since it is primarily determined by a contractual
extent to which the issuing company (the actual amortization schedule. Early repayment on these
source of the collateral assets) is obligated to instruments can occur for a number of reasons,
provide support to the trust/conduit or to the with most tied to the disposition of the under-
investors. Further issues may arise based on lying collateral (for example, in the case of an
discretionary behavior of the issuer within the ABS backed by an automobile loan, the sale of
terms of the securitization agreement, such as the vehicle). Interest is typically passed through
voluntary buybacks from, or contributions to, to bondholders at a fixed rate that is slightly
below the weighted average coupon of the loan transaction. Issuers are further required to revalue
pool, allowing for servicing and other expenses the asset periodically to take account of changes
as well as credit losses. in fair value that may occur due to interest rates,
actual credit losses, and other factors relevant to
the future stream of excess yield. The account-
ing and capital implications of these transactions
Revolving Credit are discussed further below.
Unlike closed-end installment loans, revolving-
credit receivables involve greater uncertainty
about future cash flows. Therefore, ABS struc- Asset-Backed Commercial Paper
tures using this type of collateral must be more
complex to afford investors more comfort in A number of larger banks use ‘‘special-purpose
predicting their repayment. Accounts included entities’’ (SPEs) to acquire trade receivables and
in the securitization pool may have balances that commercial loans from high-quality (often
grow or decline over the life of the ABS. investment-grade) obligors and to fund those
Accordingly, at maturity of the ABS, any remain- loans by issuing (asset-backed) commercial paper
ing balances revert to the originator. During the that is to be repaid from the cash flow of the
term of the ABS, the originator may be required receivables. Capital is contributed to the SPE by
to sell additional accounts to the pool to main- the originating bank; together with the high
tain a minimum dollar amount of collateral if quality of the underlying borrowers, this capital
accountholders pay down their balances in is sufficient to allow the SPE to receive a high
advance of predetermined rates. credit rating. The net result is that the SPE’s cost
Credit card securitizations are the most preva- of funding can be at or below that of the
lent form of revolving-credit ABS, although originating bank itself. The SPE is ‘‘owned’’ by
home equity lines of credit are a growing source individuals who are not formally affiliated with
of ABS collateral. Credit card ABS are typically the bank, although the degree of separation is
structured to incorporate two phases in the life typically minimal.
cycle of the collateral: an initial phase during These types of securitization programs enable
which the principal amount of the securities banks to arrange short-term financing support
remains constant, and an amortization phase for their customers without having to extend
during which investors are paid off. A specific credit directly. This structure provides borrow-
period of time is assigned to each phase. Typi- ers with an alternative source of funding and
cally, a specific pool of accounts is identified in allows banks to earn fee income for managing
the securitization documents, and these specifi- the programs. As the asset-backed commercial
cations may include not only the initial pool of paper structure has developed, it has been used
loans but a portfolio from which new accounts to finance a variety of underlying loans—in
may be contributed. some cases, loans purchased from other firms
rather than originated by the bank itself—and as
The dominant vehicle for issuing securities
a remote-origination vehicle from which loans
backed by credit cards is a master-trust structure
can be made directly. Like other securitization
with a ‘‘spread account,’’ which is funded up to
techniques, this structure allows banks to meet
a predetermined amount through ‘‘excess
their customers’ credit needs while incurring
yield’’—that is, interest and fee income less
lower capital requirements and a smaller bal-
credit losses, servicing, and other fees. With
ance sheet than if it made the loans directly.
credit card receivables, the income from the
pool of loans—even after credit losses—is gen-
erally much higher than the return paid to
investors. After the spread account accumulates USES
to its predetermined level, the excess yield
reverts to the issuer. Under GAAP, issuers are Issuers obtain a number of advantages from
required to recognize on their balance sheet an securitizing assets, including improving their
excess-yield asset that is based on the fair value capital ratios and return on assets, monetizing
of the expected future excess yield; in principle, gains in loan value, generating fee income by
this value would be based on the net present providing services to the securitization conduit,
value of the expected earnings stream from the closing a potential source of interest-rate risk,
and increasing institutional liquidity by provid- that may be difficult to hedge. One source of
ing access to a new source of funds. Investors potential unpredictability, however, is the risk
are attracted by the high credit quality of ABS, that acceleration or wind-down provisions would
as well as their attractive returns. be triggered by poor credit quality in the asset
pool—essentially, a complex credit-quality option
that pays off bondholders early if credit losses
exceed some threshold level.
DESCRIPTION OF For issuers, variability in excess yield (in
MARKETPLACE terms of carrying value) or in the spread account
(in terms of income) can represent a material
The primary buyers for ABS have been insur- interest-rate risk, particularly if the bonds pay
ance companies and pension funds looking for interest on a variable-rate basis while the under-
attractive returns with superior credit quality. lying loans are fixed-rate instruments. While the
New issues often sell out very quickly. Banks risk can be significant, the hedging solutions are
typically are not active buyers of these securi- not complex (that is, dollar-for-dollar in notional
ties. The secondary market is active, but new terms). Potential hedging strategies include the
issues currently trade at a premium to more use of futures or forwards, forward rate agree-
seasoned products. ments (FRAs), swaps, or more complex options
Market transparency can be less than perfect, or swaptions. In the case of home equity loans or
especially when banks and other issuers retain other revolving credits for which the pool earn-
most of the economic risk despite the securiti- ings rate is linked to prime while the ABS
zation transaction. This is particularly true when interest rate is not, prime LIBOR swaps or
excess yield is a significant part of the transac- similar instruments could be used to mitigate
tion and when recourse (explicit or implicit) is a basis risk. The presence of interest-rate risk may
material consideration. The early-amortization have credit-quality ramifications for the securi-
features of some ABS also may not be fully ties, as tighter excess yield and spread accounts
understood by potential buyers. would reduce the ability of the structure to
absorb credit losses.
An asset-backed commercial paper (ABCP)
PRICING program can lead to maturity mismatches for the
issuer, depending on the pricing characteristics
ABS carry coupons that can be fixed (generally of the commercial loan assets. Similarly, the
yielding between 50 and 300 basis points over presence of embedded options—such as prepay-
the Treasury curve) or floating (for example, 15 ment options, caps, or floors—can expose the
basis points over one-month LIBOR). Pricing is ABCP entity to options risk. These risks can be
typically designed to mirror the coupon charac- hedged through the use of options, swaptions, or
teristics of the loans being securitized. The other derivative instruments. As with home
spread will vary depending on the credit quality equity ABS, prime-based commercial loans
of the underlying collateral, the degree and could lead to basis-risk exposure, which can be
nature of credit enhancement, and the degree of hedged using basis swaps.
variability in the cash flows emanating from the
securitized loans.
RISKS
HEDGING
Credit Risk
Given the high degree of predictability in their
cash flows, the hedging of installment loans and Credit risk arises from (1) losses caused by
revolving-credit ABS holdings is relatively defaults of borrowers in the underlying collat-
straightforward and can be accomplished either eral and (2) the issuer’s or servicer’s failure to
through cash-flow matching or duration hedg- perform. These two elements can blur together,
ing. Most market risk arises from the perceived as in the case of a servicer who does not provide
credit quality of the collateral and from the adequate credit-review scrutiny to the serviced
nature and degree of credit enhancement, a risk portfolio, leading to a higher incidence
ment to the assets sold, those assets are deemed 25 percent of a bank’s capital and surplus for
to have been sold with recourse. In the case of any one issuer. In addition to being able to
asset-backed commercial paper, capital gener- purchase and sell type IV securities, subject to
ally must be held against the entire risk- the above limitations, a bank may deal in those
weighted amount of any guarantee, other credit type IV securities that are fully secured by type
enhancement, or liquidity facility provided by I securities.
the bank to the SPE. Type V securities consist of all ABS that are
not type IV securities. Specifically, they are
defined as marketable, investment grade–rated
LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK securities that are not type IV and are ‘‘fully
INVESTMENT secured by interests in a pool of loans to
numerous obligors and in which a national bank
Asset-backed securities can be either type IV could invest directly.’’ They include securities
or type V securities. Type IV securities were backed by auto loans, credit card loans, home
added as bank-eligible securities in 1996 prima- equity loans, and other assets. Also included are
rily in response to provisions of the Riegle residential and commercial mortgage securities
Community Development and Regulatory as described in section 3(a)(41) of the Securities
Improvement Act of 1994 (RCDRIA), which Exchange Act of 1934 (15 USC 78c(a)(41)) that
removed quantitative limits on a bank’s ability are not rated in one of the two highest
to buy commercial mortgage and small-business investment-grade rating categories, but are still
loan securities. In summary, type IV securities investment grade. A bank may purchase or sell
include the following asset-backed securities type V securities for its own account provided
that are fully secured by interests in a pool (or the aggregate par value of type V securities
pools) of loans made to numerous obligors: issued by any one issuer held by the bank does
not exceed 25 percent of the bank’s capital and
• investment-grade residential mortgage–related surplus.
securities offered or sold pursuant to section
4(5) of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 USC
77d(5)) REFERENCES
• residential mortgage–related securities, as
described in section 3(a)(41) of the Securities SR-97-21, ‘‘Risk Management and Capital
Exchange Act of 1934 (15 USC 78c(a)(41)), Adequacy of Exposures Arising from
that are rated in one of the two highest Secondary-Market Credit Activities.’’ July
investment-grade rating categories 1997.
• investment-grade commercial mortgage secu- SR-96-30, ‘‘Risk-Based Capital Treatment of
rities offered or sold pursuant to section 4(5) Asset Sales with Recourse.’’ November 1996.
of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 USC 77d(5)) SR-92-11, ‘‘Asset-Backed Commercial Paper
• commercial mortgage securities, as described Programs.’’ April 1992.
in section 3(a)(41) of the Securities Exchange Dierdorff, Mary D., and Annika Sandback.
Act of 1934 (15 USC 78c(a)(41)), that are ‘‘ABCP Market Overview: 1996 Was Another
rated in one of the two highest investment- Record-Breaking Year.’’ Moody’s Structured
grade rating categories Finance Special Report. 1st Quarter 1997.
• investment-grade, small-business loan securi- Kavanaugh, Barbara, Thomas R. Boemio, and
ties as described in section 3(a)(53)(A) of the Gerald A. Edwards, Jr. ‘‘Asset-Backed Com-
Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 USC mercial Paper Programs.’’ Federal Reserve
78c(a)(53)(A)) Bulletin. February 1992, pp. 107–116.
Moody’s Structured Finance Special Report.
For all type IV commercial and residential ‘‘More of the Same. . .or Worse? The
mortgage securities and for type IV small- Dilemma of Prefunding Accounts in Automo-
business loan securities rated in the top two bile Loan Securitizations." August 4, 1995.
rating categories, there is no limitation on the Rosenberg, Kenneth J., J. Douglas Murray, and
amount a bank can purchase or sell for its own Kathleen Culley. ‘‘Asset-Backed CP’s New
account. Type IV investment-grade small- Look.’’ Fitch Research Structured Finance
business loan securities that are not rated in the Special Report. August 15, 1994.
top two rating categories are subject to a limit of Silver, Andrew A., and Jay H. Eisbruck. ‘‘Credit
Card Master Trusts: The Risks of Account Card Securitizations: Catching Up with Wind-
Additions.’’ Moody’s Structured Finance Spe- Downs.’’ Moody’s Structured Finance Spe-
cial Report. December 1994. cial Report. November 1994.
Silver, Andrew A., and Jay H. Eisbruck. ‘‘Credit van Eck, Tracy Hudson. ‘‘Asset-Backed Securi-
Card Master Trusts: Assessing the Risks of ties.’’ In The Handbook of Fixed Income
Cash Flow Allocations.’’ Moody’s Structured Securities. Fabozzi, F., and T.D. Fabozzi.
Finance Special Report. May 26, 1995. Chicago: Irwin Professional Publishers, 1995.
Stancher, Mark, and Brian Clarkson. ‘‘Credit
2
0 1. Today almost all CMOs are structured as real estate
0 30 60 90 120 150 180 210 240 270 300 330 360 mortgage investment conduits (REMICs) to qualify for desir-
Mortgage Age (Months) able tax treatment.
The Tax Reform Act of 1986 allowed for a divided into four tranches, labeled A, B, C, and
five-year transition during which mortgage- Z. Tranche A might receive the first 25 percent
backed securities could be issued pursuant of principal payments and have an average
to existing Treasury regulations. However, as of maturity, or average life, of one to three years.2
January 1, 1992, REMICs became the sole Tranche B, with an average life of between three
means of issuing multiple-class mortgage- and seven years, would receive the next 25 per-
backed securities exempt from double taxation. cent of principal. Tranche C, receiving the
As a practical matter, the vast majority of CMOs following 25 percent of principal, would have an
carry the REMIC designation. Indeed, many average life of 5 to 10 years. The Z tranche,
market participants use the terms ‘‘CMO’’ and receiving the final 25 percent, would be an
‘‘REMIC’’ interchangeably. ‘‘accrual’’ bond with an average life of 15 to
CMOs do not trade on a TBA basis. New- 20 years.3
issue CMOs settle on the date provided in the The sequential pay structure was the first step
prospectus and trade on a corporate basis (three in creating a mortgage yield curve, allowing
business days after the trade) in the secondary mortgage investors to target short, intermediate,
market. Common CMO structures include or long maturities. Nevertheless, sequential pay
sequential pay, PACs, TACs, and floaters and structure maturities remained highly sensitive to
inverse floaters as described below. prepayment risks, as prepayments of the under-
lying collateral change the cash flows for each
Sequential pay structure. The initial form of tranche, affecting the longer-dated tranches most,
CMO structure was designed to provide more especially the Z tranche. If interest rates declined
precisely targeted maturities than the pass- and prepayment speeds doubled (from 100 per-
through securities. Now considered a relatively cent PSA to 200 percent PSA as shown on chart
simple design for CMOs, the sequential pay 2), the average life of the A tranche would
structure dominated CMO issuance from 1983 change from 35 months to 25 months, but the
(when the first CMO was created) until the late average life of the Z bond would shift from
1980s. In the typical sequential pay deal of the 280 months to 180 months. Hence, the change in
1980s (see chart 2), mortgage cash flows were the value of the Z bond would be similarly
greater than the price change of the A tranche.
Chart 2—Four-Tranche Sequential Planned amortization class (PAC) structure.
Pay CMO The PAC structure, which now dominates CMO
issuance, creates tranches, called planned amor-
Monthly Payment, Thousands of Dollars
1.5
tization classes, with cash flows that are pro-
200 Percent PSA tected from prepayment changes within certain
Tranche A limits. However, creating this ‘‘safer’’ set of
Tranche B 1.0 tranches necessarily means that there must be
Tranche C
other tranches, called ‘‘support’’ bonds, that are
by definition more volatile than the underlying
Tranche Z
.5 pass-throughs. While the PAC tranches are rela-
tively easy to sell, finding investors for higher-
yielding, less predictable support bonds has
0 been crucial for the success of the expanding
CMO market.
1.5 Chart 3 illustrates how PACs are created. In
100 Percent PSA the example, the estimated prepayment rate
for the mortgages is 145 percent of the PSA
1.0
standard, and the desired PAC is structured to
.5
2. Average life, or weighted average life (WAL), is defined
as the weighted average number of years that each principal
dollar of the mortgage security remains outstanding.
0 3. Unlike the Z tranche, the A, B, and C tranches receive
0 60 120 180 240 300 360 regular interest payments in the early years before the princi-
Month pal is paid off.
be protected if prepayments slow to 80 percent protection can break down from extremely high,
PSA or rise to 250 percent PSA. The PACs extremely low, or extremely volatile prepay-
therefore have some protection against both ment rates.
‘‘extension risk’’ (slower than expected prepay- A PAC bond classified as PAC 1 in a CMO
ments) and ‘‘call risk’’ (faster than expected structure has the highest cash-flow priority and
prepayments). In order to create this 80 to 250 the best protection from both extension and
percent ‘‘PAC range,’’ principal payments are prepayment risk. In the past, deals have also
calculated for 80 percent PSA and 250 percent included super PACs, another high-protection,
PSA. lower-risk-type tranche distinguished by
The area underneath both curves indicates extremely wide bands. The mechanisms that
that amount of estimated principal that can be protect a PAC tranche within a deal may dimin-
used to create the desired PAC tranche or ish, and its status may shift more toward the
tranches. That is, as long as the prepayment support end of the spectrum. The extent of a
rates are greater than 80 percent PSA or less support-type role that a PAC might play depends
than 250 percent PSA, the four PACs will in part on its original cash-flow priority status
receive their scheduled cash flows (represented and the principal balances of the other support
by the shaded areas). tranches embedded within the deal. Indeed, as
This PAC analysis assumes a constant prepay- prepayments accelerated in 1993, support
ment rate of between 80 and 250 percent of the tranches were asked to bear the brunt, and many
PSA standard over the life of the underlying disappeared. A PAC III, for example, became a
mortgages. Since PSA speeds can change every pure support tranche, foregoing any PAC-like
month, this assumption of a constant PSA speed characteristics in that case.
for months 1 to 360 is never realized. If prepay- A variation on the PAC theme has emerged in
ment speeds are volatile, even within the PAC the scheduled tranche (SCH). Like a PAC, an
range, the PAC range itself may narrow over SCH has a predetermined cash-flow collar, but it
time. This phenomenon, termed ‘‘effective PAC is too narrow even to be called a PAC III. An
band,’’ affects longer-dated PACs more than SCH tranche is also prioritized within a deal
short-maturity PACs. Thus, PAC prepayment using the above format, but understand that its
initial priority status is usually below even that
of a PAC III. These narrower band PAC-type
bonds were designed to perform well in low-
Chart 3—Principal Payments volatility environments and were popular in late
Monthly Payment, in Thousands of Dollars 1992 and early 1993. At that time, many inves-
2.0 tors failed to realize what would happen to the
145 Percent PSA tranche when prepayments violated the band.
Tranche A
1.5 In chart 3, the four grey shaded areas repre-
Support Tranche
sent the PAC structure, which has been divided
Tranche B into four tranches to provide investors with an
1.0
Tranche C instrument more akin to the bullet maturity of
Tranche D Treasury and corporate bonds.4 The two support
.5
tranches are structured to absorb the full amount
of prepayment risk to the extent the prepayment
0
rate for the PAC tranches is within the specified
range of 80 to 250 percent PSA. The second
2.0 panel of chart 3 shows principal cash flows at
Multi-PAC Redemption Schedule
with a Range of 80%–250% PSA the original estimated speed of 145 percent PSA,
1.5 which are divided between the PAC and support
bonds throughout the life of the underlying
1.0 mortgages.
.5
Chart 4 shows how both PACs and the sup- than PAC bonds.5 Conversely, PAC bond inves-
port tranches react to different prepayment tors are willing to give up yield in order to
speeds. The average lives of the support bonds reduce their exposure to prepayment risk or
in this example could fluctuate from 11⁄2 to negative convexity. Nevertheless, PAC bond
25 years depending on prepayment speeds. Sim- holders are exposed to prepayment risk outside
ply put, support-bond returns are diminished the protected range and correspondingly receive
whether prepayment rates increase or decrease yields above those available on comparable
(a lose-lose proposition). To compensate holders Treasury securities. In extreme cases, even PAC
of support bonds for this characteristic (some- tranches are subject to prepayment risk. For
times referred to as ‘‘negative convexity’’), example, at 500 percent PSA (see the third panel
support bonds carry substantially higher yields of chart 4), the PAC range is broken. The
support bonds fail to fully protect even the first
PAC tranche; principal repayment accelerates
sharply at the end of the scheduled maturity of
PAC A.
Chart 4—Principal Payments
Targeted amortization tranche structure. A tar-
Monthly Payment, Thousands of Dollars geted amortization tranche (TAC) typically offers
2.0
80 Percent PSA protection from prepayment risk but not exten-
sion risk. Similar to the cash-flow schedule of
PAC A
1.5 a PAC that is built around a collar, a TAC’s
PAC B
schedule is built around a single pricing speed,
PAC C and the average life of the tranche is ‘‘targeted’’
PAC D 1.0 to that speed. Any excess principal paid typi-
Support cally has little effect on the TAC; its targeted
Tranche speed acts as a line of defense. Investors in
.5
TACs, however, pay the price for this defense
with their lack of protection when rates increase,
0 subjecting the tranche to potential extension
risk.
2.0
250 Percent PSA Floaters and inverse floaters. CMOs and REMICs
can include several floating-rate classes. Floating-
1.5
rate tranches have coupon rates that float with
movements in an underlying index. The most
1.0 widely used indexes for floating-rate tranches
are the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR)
and the Eleventh District Cost of Funds Index
.5 (COFI). While LIBOR correlates closely with
interest-rate movements in the domestic federal
0 funds market, COFI has a built-in lag feature
and is slower to respond to changes in interest
2.0 rates. Thus, the holders of COFI-indexed float-
500 Percent PSA ers generally experience a delay in the effects of
changing interest-rate movements.
1.5
1.0
5. Price/yield curves for most fixed-income securities have
a slightly convex shape, hence the securities are said to
possess convexity. An important and desirable attribute of the
.5 convex shape of the price/yield curve for Treasury securities
is that prices rise at a faster rate than they decline. Mortgage
price/yield curves tend to be concave, especially in the range
0 of premium prices, and are said to possess negative convexity.
0 60 120 180 240 300 360 Securities with negative convexity rise in price at a slower rate
Month than they fall in price.
Since most floating-rate tranches are backed sensitive to prepayment rates than the under-
by fixed-rate mortgages or pass-through securi- lying pass-throughs.6 Despite the increased
ties, floating-rate tranches must be issued in exposure to prepayment risk, these instruments
combination with some kind of ‘‘support.’’ The have proved popular with several groups of
designed support mechanism on floaters is an investors. For example, mortgage servicers may
interest-rate cap, generally coupled with a sup- purchase POs to offset the loss of servicing
port bond or inverse floater. If interest rates rise, income from rising prepayments. IOs are often
where does the extra money come from to pay used as a hedging vehicle by fixed-income
higher rates on the floating CMO tranches? The portfolio managers because the value of IOs
solution is in the form of an inverse floating-rate rises when prepayments slow—usually in rising
tranche. The coupon rate on the inverse tranche interest-rate environments when most fixed-
moves opposite of the accompanying floater income security prices decline.
tranche, thus allowing the floater to pay high Two techniques have been used to create IOs
interest rates. The floater and the inverse tranches and POs. The first, which dominates outstand-
‘‘share’’ interest payments from a pool of fixed- ings in IOs and POs, strips pass-throughs into
rate mortgage securities. If rates rise, the coupon their interest and principal components, which
on the floater moves up; the floater takes more are then sold as separate securities. As of
of the shared interest, leaving less for the October 1993, approximately $65 billion of the
inverse, whose coupon rate must fall. If rates supply of outstanding pass-throughs had been
fall, the rate on the floater falls, and more money stripped into IOs and POs.7 The second tech-
is available to pay the inverse floater investor nique, which has become increasingly popular
and the corresponding rate on the inverse rises. over the past few years, simply slices off an
Effectively, the interest-payment characteris- interest or principal portion of any CMO tranche
tics of the underlying home mortgages have not to be sold independently. In practice, IO slices,
changed; another tranche is created where risk is called ‘‘IOettes,’’ 8 far outnumber PO slices.
shifted. This shifting of risk from the floater Since IOs and IOettes produce cash flows in
doubles up the interest-rate risk in the inverse proportion to the mortgage principal outstand-
floater, with enhanced yield and price ramifica- ing, IO investors are hurt by fast prepayments
tions as rates fluctuate. If rates fall, the inverse and aided by slower prepayments. The value of
floater receives the benefit of a higher-rate- POs rises when prepayments quicken and falls
bearing security in a low-rate environment. when prepayments slow because of the increases
Conversely, if rates rise, that same investor pays in principal cash flows coupled with the deep
the price of holding a lower-rate security in a discount price of the PO.
high-rate environment. As with other tranche IOs and IOettes are relatively high-yielding
types, prepayments determine the floating cash tranches that are generally subject to consider-
flows and the weighted average life of the able prepayment volatility. For example, falling
instrument (WAL). interest rates and rising prepayment speeds in
With respect to floaters, the two most impor- late 1991 caused some IOs (such as those
tant risks are the risk that the coupon rate will backed by FNMA 10 percent collateral) to fall
adjust to its maximum level (cap risk) and the up to 40 percent in value between July and
risk that the index will not correlate tightly with December. IOs also declined sharply on several
the underlying mortgage product. Additionally, occasions in 1992 and 1993 as mortgage rates
floaters that have ‘‘capped out’’ and that have moved to 20- and 25-year lows, resulting in very
WALs that extend as prepayments slow may high levels of prepayment. CMO dealers use
experience considerable price depreciation. IOettes to reduce coupons on numerous tranches,
allowing these tranches to be sold at a discount
(as preferred by investors). In effect, much of To the extent that banks do operate as market
the call risk is transferred from these tranches to makers, the risks are more diverse and challeng-
the IOette. ing. The key areas of focus for market makers
The fact that IO prices generally move are risk-management practices associated with
inversely to most fixed-income securities makes trading, hedging, and funding their inventories.
them theoretically attractive hedging vehicles in The operations and analytic support staff required
a portfolio context. Nevertheless, IOs represent for a bank’s underwriting operation are much
one of the riskiest fixed-income assets available greater than those needed for its more traditional
and may be used in a highly leveraged way to role of investor.
speculate about either future interest rates or Regulatory restrictions limit banks’ owner-
prepayment rates. Given that their value rises ship of high-risk tranches. These tranches are so
(falls) when interest rates increase (decrease), complex that the most common approaches and
many financial institutions, including banks, techniques for hedging interest-rate risks could
thrifts, and insurance companies, have pur- be ineffective. High-risk tranches are so elabo-
chased IOs and IOettes as hedges for their rately structured and highly volatile that it is
fixed-income portfolios, but such hedges might unlikely that a reliable hedge offset exists.
prove problematic as they expose the hedger to Hedging these instruments is largely subjective,
considerable basis risk. and assessing hedge effectiveness becomes
extremely difficult. Examiners must carefully
assess whether owning such high-risk tranches
reduces a bank’s overall interest-rate risk.
USES
Both pass-through securities and CMOs are
purchased by a broad array of institutional DESCRIPTION OF
customers, including banks, thrifts, insurance MARKETPLACE
companies, pension funds, mortgage ‘‘bou-
tiques,’’9 and retail investors. CMO underwriters Primary Market
customize the majority of CMO tranches for
specific end-users, and customization is espe- The original lender is called the mortgage orig-
cially common for low-risk tranches. Since this inator. Mortgage originators include commercial
customization results from investors’ desire to banks, thrifts, and mortgage bankers. Origina-
either hedge an existing exposure or to assume a tors generate income in several ways. First, they
specific risk, many end-users perceive less need typically charge an origination fee, which is
for hedging. For the most part, end-users gen- expressed in terms of basis points of the loan
erally adopt a buy-and-hold strategy, perhaps in amount. The second source of revenue is the
part because the customization makes resale profit that might be generated from selling a
more difficult. mortgage in the secondary market, and the profit
is called secondary-marketing profit. The mort-
gage originator may also hold the mortgage in
its investment portfolio.
Uses by Banks
Within the mortgage securities market, banks Secondary Market
are predominately investors or end-users rather
than underwriters or market makers. Further- The process of creating mortgage securities
more, banks tend to invest in short to inter- starts with mortgage originators which offer
mediate maturities. Indeed, banks aggressively consumers many different types of mortgage
purchase short-dated CMO tranches, such as loans. Mortgages that meet certain well-defined
planned amortization classes, floating-rate criteria are sold by mortgage originators to
tranches, and adjustable-rate mortgage securities. conduits, which link originators and investors.
These conduits will pool like groups of mort-
9. Mortgage boutiques are highly specialized investment
gages and either securitize the mortgages and
firms which typically invest in residuals and other high-risk sell them to an investor or retain the mortgages
tranches. as investments in their own portfolios. Both
government-related and private institutions act prepayment rates. Despite the application of
in this capacity. Ginnie Mae; Freddie Mac, and highly sophisticated interest-rate simulation
Fannie Mae are the three main government- techniques, results from diverse proprietary
related conduit institutions; all of them purchase prepayment models and assumptions about future
conforming mortgages which meet the under- interest-rate volatility still drive valuations. The
writing standards established by the agencies for subjective nature of mortgage valuations makes
being in a pool of mortgages underlying a marking to market difficult due to the dynamic
security that they guarantee. nature of prepayment rates, especially as one
Ginne Mae is a government agency, and the moves farther out along the price-risk con-
securities it guarantees carry the full faith and tinuum toward high-risk tranches. Historical
credit of the U.S. government. Fannie Mae and price information for various CMO tranche
Freddie Mac are government-sponsored agen- types is not widely available and, moreover,
cies; securities issued by these institutions are might have limited value given the generally
guaranteed by the agencies themselves and are different methodologies used in deriving mort-
generally assigned an AAA credit rating partly gage valuation.
due to the implicit government guarantee.
Mortgage-backed securities have also been
issued by private entities such as commercial
banks, thrifts, homebuilders, and private con- Decomposition of MBS
duits. These issues are often referred to as
private label securities. These securities are not A popular approach to analyzing and valuing a
guaranteed by a government agency or GSE. callable bond involves breaking it down into its
Instead, their credit is usually enhanced by pool component parts—a long position in a noncall-
insurance, letters of credit, guarantees, or over- able bond and a short position in a call option
collateralization. These securities usually receive written to the issuer by the investor. An MBS
a rating of AA or better. investor owns a callable bond, but decomposing
Private issuers of pass-throughs and CMOs it is not as easy as breaking down more tradi-
provide a secondary market for conventional tional callables. The MBS investor has written a
loans which do not qualify for Freddie Mac and series of put and call options to each homeowner
Fannie Mae programs. There are several reasons or mortgagor. The analytical challenge facing an
why conventional loans may not qualify, but the examiner is to determine the value and risk
major reason is that the principal balance exceeds profile of these options and their contribution to
the maximum allowed by the government (these the overall risk profile of the portfolio. Com-
are called ‘‘jumbo’’ loans in the market). pounding the problem is the fact that mortgagors
Servicers of mortgages include banks, thrifts, do not exercise these prepayment options at the
and mortgage bankers. If a mortgage is sold to a same time when presented with identical situa-
conduit, it can be sold in total, or servicing tions. Most prepayment options are exercised at
rights may be maintained. The major source of the least opportune time from the standpoint of
income related to servicing is derived from the the MBS investor. In a falling-rate environment,
servicing fee. This fee is a fixed percentage of a homeowner will have a greater propensity to
the outstanding mortgage balance. Consequently, refinance (or exercise the option) as prevailing
if the mortgage is prepaid, the servicing fee will mortgage rates fall below the homeowner’s
no longer accrue to the servicer. Other sources original note (as the option moves deeper into
of revenue include interest on escrow, float the money). Under this scenario, the MBS
earned on the monthly payment, and late fees. investor receives a cash windfall (principal pay-
Also, servicers who are lenders often use their ment) which must be reinvested in a lower-rate
portfolios of borrowers as potential sources to environment. Conversely, in a high- or rising-
cross-sell other bank products. rate environment, when the prevailing mortgage
rate is higher than the mortgagor’s original term
rate, the homeowner is less apt to exercise the
option to refinance. Of course, the MBS investor
PRICING would like nothing more than to receive his or
her principal and be able to reinvest that princi-
Mortgage valuations are highly subjective pal at the prevailing higher rates. Under this
because of the unpredictable nature of mortgage scenario, the MBS investor holds an instrument
with a stated coupon that is below prevailing negative one.11 If that were the case, the value of
market rates and relatively unattractive to poten- a pass-through security would always be hedged
tial buyers. with respect to interest rates. However, IOs and
Market prices of mortgages reflect an expected POs do represent extremities in MBS theory
rate of prepayments. If prepayments are faster and, properly applied, can be used as effective
than the expected rate, the mortgage security is risk-reduction tools. Because the value of the
exposed to call risk. If prepayments are slower prepayment option and the duration of an IO and
than expected, the mortgage securities are PO are not constant, hedges must be continually
exposed to extension risk (similar to having managed and adjusted.
written a put option). Thus, in practice, mort- In general, a decline in prepayment speeds
gage security ownership is comparable to own- arises largely from rising mortgage rates, with
ing a portfolio of cash bonds and writing a fixed-rate mortgage securities losing value. At
combination of put and call options on that the same time, IO securities are rising in yield
portfolio of bonds. Call risk is manifested in a and price. Thus, within the context of an overall
shortening of the bond’s effective maturity or portfolio, the inclusion of IOs serves to increase
duration, and extension risk manifests itself in yields and reduce losses in a rising-rate environ-
the lengthening of the bond’s effective maturity ment. More specifically, IOs can be used to
or duration. hedge the interest-rate risk of Treasury strip
securities. As rates increase, an IO’s value
increases. The duration of zero-coupon strips
Option-Adjusted Spread Analysis equals their maturity, while IOs have a negative
duration.12 Combining IOs with strips creates a
For a further discussion of option-adjusted spread portfolio with a lower duration than a position in
(OAS) analysis or optionality in general, see strips alone.13
section 4330.1, ‘‘Options.’’ POs are a means to synthetically add discount
(and positive convexity) to a portfolio, allowing
it to more fully participate in bull markets. For
example, a bank funding MBS with certificates
HEDGING of deposit (CDs) is exposed to prepayment risk.
If rates fall faster than expected, mortgage
Hedging mortgage-backed securities ultimately holders (in general) will exercise their prepay-
comes down to an assessment of one’s expecta- ment option while depositors will hold their
tion of forward rates (an implied forward curve). higher-than-market CDs as long as possible.
A forward-rate expectation can be thought of as The bank could purchase POs as a hedge against
a no-arbitrage perspective on the market, serv- its exposure to prepayment and interest-rate
ing as a pricing mechanism for fixed-income risk. As a hedging vehicle, POs offer preferable
securities and derivatives, including MBS. alternatives to traditional futures or options; the
Investors who wish to hedge their forward-rate performance of a PO is directly tied to actual
expectations can employ strategies which involve prepayments, thus the hedge should experience
purchasing the underlying security and the use potentially less basis risk than other cross-
of swaps, options, futures, caps, or combinations market hedging instruments.
thereof to hedge duration and convexity risk.10
With respect to intra-portfolio techniques,
one can employ IOs and POs as hedge vehicles.
Although exercise of the prepayment option RISKS
generally takes value away from the IO class Prepayment Risk
and adds value to the PO class, IOs and POs
derived from the same pool of underlying mort- All investors in the mortgage sector share a
gages do not have a correlation coefficient of common concern: the mortgage prepayment
option. This option is the homeowner’s right to pass-throughs have little credit risk.14 Approxi-
prepay a mortgage any time, at par. The prepay- mately 90 percent of all outstanding pass-
ment option makes mortgage securities different through securities have been guaranteed by
from other fixed-income securities, as the timing Ginnie Mae, Fannie Mae, and Freddie Mac.15
of mortgage principal repayments is uncertain. This credit guarantee gives ‘‘agency’’ pass-
The cash-flow uncertainty that derives from through securities and CMOs a decisive advan-
prepayment risk means that the maturity and tage over nonagency pass-throughs and CMOs,
duration of a mortgage security are uncertain. which comprise less than 10 percent of the
For investors, the prepayment option creates an market.
exposure similar to that of having written a call In general, nonagency pass-through securities
option. That is, if mortgage rates move lower, and CMOs use mortgages that are ineligible for
causing mortgage bond prices to move higher, agency guarantees. Issuers can also obtain credit
the mortgagor has the right to call the mortgage enhancements, such as senior subordinated struc-
away from the investor at par. tures, insurance, corporate guarantees, or letters
While lower mortgage interest rates are the of credit from insurance companies or banks.
dominant economic incentive for prepayment, The rating of the nonagency issue then partially
idiosyncratic, noneconomic factors to prepay a depends upon the rating of the insurer and its
mortgage further complicate the forecasting of credit enhancement.
prepayment rates. These factors are sometimes
summarized as the ‘‘five D’s’’: death, divorce,
destruction, default, and departure (relocation). Settlement and Operational Risk
Prepayments arising from these causes may lead
to a mortgage’s being called away from the The most noteworthy risk issues associated with
investor at par when it is worth more or less than the trading of pass-through securities is the
par (that is, trading at a premium or discount). forward settlement and operational risk associ-
ated with the allocation of pass-through trades.
Most pass-through trading occurs on a forward
basis of two to three months, often referred to as
Funding and Reinvestment Risk ‘‘TBA’’ or ‘‘to be announced’’ trading.16 During
this interval, participants are exposed to coun-
The uncertainty of the maturities of underlying terparty credit risk.
mortgages also presents both funding and rein- Operating risk grows out of the pass-through
vestment risks for investors. The uncertainty of seller’s allocation option that occurs at settle-
a mortgage security’s duration makes it difficult ment. Sellers in the TBA market are allowed a
to obtain liabilities for matched funding of these 2.0 percent delivery option variance when meet-
assets. This asset/liability gap presents itself ing their forward commitments. That is, between
whether the mortgage asset’s life shortens or 98 and 102 percent of the committed par amount
lengthens, and it may vary dramatically. may be delivered. This variance is provided to
Reinvestment risk is normally associated with ease the operational burden of recombining
duration shortening or call risk. Investors receive various pool sizes into round trading lots.17 This
principal earlier than anticipated, usually as a delivery convention requires significant opera-
result of declines in mortgage interest rates; the tional expertise and, if mismanaged, can be a
funds can then be reinvested only at the new
lower rates. Reinvestment risk is also the oppor-
tunity cost associated with lengthening dura-
tions. Mortgage asset durations typically extend 14. Credit risk in a pass-through stems from the possibility
as rates rise. This results in lower investor that the homeowner will default on the mortgage and that the
foreclosure proceeds from the resale of the property will fall
returns as they are unable to reinvest at the now short of the balance of the mortgage.
higher rates. 15. For a full explanation of the minor differences between
these agencies, see chapter 5 in Fabozzi, The Handbook of
Mortgage-Backed Securities, 1995.
16. In the forward mortgage pass-through trading, or TBA
Credit Risk trading, the seller announces the exact pool mix to be
delivered the second business day before settlement day.
17. ‘‘Good delivery’’ guidelines are promulgated by the
While prepayments expose pass-throughs and Public Securities Association in its Uniform Practices
CMOs to considerable price risk, most MBS publication.
source of significant risk in the form of failed are exceeded. Even floating-rate tranches face
settlements and unforeseen carrying costs. risks, especially when short-term rates rise sig-
nificantly and floaters reach their interest-rate
caps. At the same time, long rates may rise and
Price Volatility in High-Risk CMOs prepayments slow, causing the floaters’ maturi-
ties to extend significantly since the floater is
When the cash flow from pass-through securi- usually based on a support bond. Under such
ties is allocated among CMO tranches, prepay- circumstances, floater investors could face sig-
ment risk is concentrated within a few volatile nificant losses.
classes, most notably residuals, inverse floaters, In addition to possible loss of market value,
IOs and POs, Z bonds, and long-term support these safe tranches may lose significant liquidity
bonds. These tranches are subject to sharp price under extreme interest-rate movements. These
fluctuations in response to changes in short- and tranches are currently among the most liquid
long-term interest rates, interest-rate volatility, CMOs. Investors who rely on this liquidity
prepayment rates, and other macroeconomic when interest-rate volatility is low may find it
conditions. Some of these tranches—especially difficult to sell these instruments to raise cash in
residuals and inverse floaters—are frequently times of financial stress. Nevertheless, investors
placed with a targeted set of investors willing to in these tranches face lower prepayment risk
accept the extra risk. These classes are also than investors in either mortgage pass-throughs
among the most illiquid bonds traded in the or the underlying mortgages themselves.
CMO market.
These high-risk tranches, whether held by
dealers or investors, have the potential to incur Cap Risk
sizable losses (and sometimes gains) within a
short period of time.18 Compounding this price The caps in many floating-rate CMOs and ARMs
risk is the difficulty of finding effective hedging are an embedded option. The value of floating-
strategies for these instruments. Using different rate CMOs or ARMs is equal to the value of an
CMOs to hedge each other can present prob- uncapped floating-rate security less the value of
lems. Although pass-through securities from the cap. As the coupon rate of the security
different pools tend to move in the same direc- approaches the cap rate, the value of the option
tion based on the same event, the magnitude of increases and the value of the security falls. The
these moves can vary considerably, especially if rate of change is non-linear and increases as the
the underlying mortgage pools have different coupon approaches the cap. As the coupon rate
average coupons.19 equals or exceeds the cap rate, the security will
exhibit characteristics similar to those of a
fixed-rate security, and price volatility will
increase. All else being equal, securities with
Risks in ‘‘Safe’’ Tranches coupon rates close to their cap rates will tend to
exhibit greater price volatility than securities
Investors may also be underestimating risks in with coupon rates farther away from their cap
some ‘‘safe’’ tranches, such as long-maturity rates. Also, the tighter the ‘‘band’’ of caps and
PACs, PAC 2s, and 3s, and floaters, because floors on the periodic caps embedded in ARMs,
these tranches can experience abrupt changes in the greater the price sensitivity of the security
their average lives once their prepayment ranges will be. The value of embedded caps also
increases with an increase in volatility. Thus, all
else being equal, higher levels of interest-rate
volatility will reduce the value of the floating-
rate CMO or ARM.
18. Examples of single-firm losses include a $300 million
to $400 million loss by one firm on POs in the spring of 1987;
more recently, several firms have lost between $50 million and
$200 million on IO positions in 1992 and 1993. FFIEC Regulations Concerning
19. For a discussion of the idiosyncratic prepayment Unsuitable Investments
behavior of pass-throughs, see Sean Becketti and Charles S.
Morris, The Prepayment Experience of FNMA Mortgage-
Backed Securities. New York University Salomon Center, The Federal Financial Institutions Examination
1990, pp. 24–41. Council (FFIEC) issued a revised policy state-
business–related securities and certain residential- Backed Securities. New York: New York
and commercial-related securities rated Aaa and University Salomon Center, 1990.
Aa are type IV securities. As such, a bank may Cilia, Joseph. Advanced CMO Analytics for
purchase and sell these securities for its own Bank Examiners—Practical Applications
account without limitation. CMOs and stripped Using Bloomberg. Product Summary. Chicago:
MBS securitized by small business–related Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, May 1995.
securities rated A or Baa are also type IV Davidson, Andrew S., and Michael D.
securities and are subject to an investment Herskovitz. Mortgage-Backed Securities—
limitation of 25 percent of a bank’s capital and Investment Analysis and Advanced Valuation
surplus. Banks may deal in type IV securities Techniques. Chicago: Probus Publishing,
that are fully secured by type I transactions 1994.
without limitations. Fabozzi, Frank J., ed. The Handbook of Mortgage-
CMOs and stripped MBS securitized by cer- Backed Securities. Chicago: Probus Publish-
tain residential- and commercial-mortgage- ing, 1995.
related securities rated A or Baa are type V Fabozzi, Frank J. Valuation of Fixed-Income
securities. For type V securities, the aggregate Securities. Summit, N.J.: Frank J. Fabozzi
par value of a bank’s purchase and sales of the Associates, 1994.
securities of any one obligor may not exceed Klinkhammer, Gunner, Ph.D. ‘‘Monte Carlo
25 percent of its capital and surplus. Analytics Provides Dynamic Risk Assess-
ment for CMOs.’’ Capital Management
Sciences, Inc. October 1995.
REFERENCES Kopprasch, Robert W. ‘‘Option Adjusted Spread
Analysis: Going Down the Wrong Path?’’
Bartlett, William W. Mortgage-Backed Securi- Financial Analysts Journal. May/June 1994.
ties. Burr Ridge, Ill.: Irwin Publishing, 1994. Zissu, Anne, and Charles Austin Stone. ‘‘The
Becketti, Sean, and Charles S. Morris. The Risks of MBS and Their Derivatives.’’ Jour-
Prepayment Experience of FNMA Mortgage- nal of Applied Corporate Finance. Fall 1994.
CHARACTERISTICS AND
FEATURES
CGBs, with maturities ranging from one to DESCRIPTION OF
20 years, are issued every six to eight weeks in MARKETPLACE
an average tender size totaling A$800 million.
Most CGBs are noncallable, fixed-coupon secu- Issuing Practices
rities with bullet maturities. The Australian
Treasury has issued some indexed-linked bonds
with either interest payments or capital linked to CGBs are issued periodically on an as-needed
the Australian consumer price index. However, basis, typically every six to eight weeks. Gen-
there are few of these issues and they tend to be erally, issuance is through a competitive tender
very illiquid. CGBs can be issued with current whereby subscribers are invited to submit bids
market coupons, but in many cases the Austra- as they would in an auction. Issue size is
lian Treasury will reopen existing issues. announced one day before the tender day. Bids,
Interest for government bonds is paid semi- which are sent to the Reserve Bank of Australia
annually on the 15th day of the month, and it is through the Reserve Bank Information Transfer
calculated on an actual/365 day-count basis. System (RBITS), are submitted to the Reserve
Coupon payments that fall on weekends or Bank of Australia on a semiannual, yield-to-
public holidays are paid on the next business maturity basis. Specific information on the issue
day. Semiannual coupon payments are precisely is announced later on the tender day, such as the
half the coupon rate. Bonds that have more than amounts tendered and issued, the average and
six months left to maturity settle three business range of accepted bids, and the percentage of
days after the trade date (T+3). Bonds with less bids allotted at the highest yield.
than six months left to maturity may settle on
the same day, provided they are dealt before
noon; otherwise, they settle the next day.
Secondary Market
CGBs are quoted in terms of yield and rounded A change in the political environment, withhold-
to three decimal places to determine gross price ing tax laws, or market regulation can have an
for settlement purposes. While tick size is adverse impact on the value and liquidity of an
equivalent to one basis point, yields are often investment in foreign bonds. Investors should be
quoted to the half basis point. familiar with the local laws and regulations
governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
actions, and authorized counterparties.
HEDGING
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
Interest-rate risk may be hedged by taking an
offsetting position in other government bonds or The accounting treatment for investments in
by using interest-rate forward, futures, options, foreign debt is determined by the Financial
or swap contracts. Foreign-exchange risk may Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
be hedged by using foreign-currency derivatives Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
and swaps. 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
(CDS). Therefore, Canadas may trade when- using interest-rate swaps, forwards, futures (such
issued without an exchange of cash. as futures on 10-year and 5-year Canadas, which
are traded on the Montreal Stock Exchange
(MSE)), and options (such as options on all
Market Participants Canadas issues, which are traded on the MSE).
Sell Side Hedging may also be effected by taking a contra
position in another Canadian government bond.
Primary distributors include investment dealers Foreign-exchange risk may be hedged through
and Canadian chartered banks. the use of currency forwards, futures, swaps,
and options. The effectiveness of a particular
hedge depends on the yield curve and basis risk.
Buy Side For example, hedging a position in a 10-year
Canadas future with an overhedged position in a
A wide range of investors use Canadas for 5-year bond may expose the dealer to yield-
investing, hedging, and speculation, including curve risk. Hedging a 30-year bond with a
domestic banks, trust and insurance companies, Canadas future exposes the dealer to basis risk if
and pension funds. The largest Canadian holders the historical price relationships between futures
of Canadas are trust pension funds, insurance and cash markets are not stable. Also, if a
companies, chartered banks, and the Bank of position in notes or bonds is hedged using an
Canada. OTC option, the relative illiquidity of the option
Foreign investors are also active participants may diminish the effectiveness of the hedge.
in the Canadian government bond market. In
general, foreign market participants are institu-
tional investors such as banks, securities firms,
life insurance companies, and fund managers. RISKS
Liquidity Risk
Market Transparency
The Canadian bond market is considered to be
Price transparency is relatively high for Cana- one of the most liquid bond markets in the
das; several information vendors disseminate world, and Canadas are traded actively in both
prices to the investing public. Trading of Cana- domestic and international capital markets. Most
das, both domestically and internationally, is investment dealers in Canadas will make mar-
active and prices are visible. kets on all outstanding issues. The most liquid
issues are the short-term issues of less than
10 years, but several 15-year and 30-year Cana-
PRICING das are actively traded and very liquid. All
government bond issues are reasonably liquid
Bonds trade on a clean-price basis (net of
when their outstanding size, net of stripping, is
accrued interest) and are quoted in terms of a
over C$1 billion. ‘‘Orphaned’’ issues, small
percentage of par value, with the fraction of a
issues that are not reopened, are the only Cana-
percent expressed in decimals. Canadas typi-
das that are very illiquid because they are not
cally trade with a 1⁄8- to 1⁄4-point spread between
actively traded.
bid and offer prices. Canadas do not trade
ex-dividend. If a settlement date occurs in the
two weeks preceding a coupon payment date,
the seller retains the upcoming coupon but must Interest-Rate Risk
compensate the buyer by postdating a check
payable to the buyer for the amount of the Canadas are subject to price fluctuations caused
coupon payment. by changes in interest rates. Longer-term issues
tend to have more price volatility than shorter-
term issues; therefore, a large concentration of
HEDGING longer-term maturities in a bank’s portfolio may
subject the bank to a high degree of interest-rate
Interest-rate risk on Canadas may be hedged risk.
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
REFERENCES
The accounting treatment for investments in
foreign debt is determined by the Financial Crossan, Ruth, and Mark Johnson, ed. ‘‘Cana-
Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of dian Dollar.’’ The Guide to International Capi-
Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS tal Markets 1991. London: Euromoney Pub-
115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in lications PLC, 1991, pp. 37–49.
Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by Fabozzi, Frank J. Bond Markets, Analysis, and
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards Strategies. 3d ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J.:
No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers Prentice-Hall, 1996.
and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin- Fabozzi, Frank J., and T. Dessa Fabozzi, ed. The
guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat- Handbook of Fixed Income Securities. 4th ed.
ment for derivatives used as investments or for New York: Irwin, 1995.
hedging purposes is determined by Statement of J.P. Morgan Securities. Government Bond Out-
Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS lines. 9th ed., April 1996.
Market Transparency
RISKS
The market for French government bonds is
active, and market transparency is relatively Liquidity Risk
high for most issues. The French Treasury
regularly publishes the debt-issuance schedule French bonds are among the most liquid in
and other information on the management of its Europe. Because the French Treasury issues
debt. Auction results, trading information, and OATs and BTANs as tranches of existing bonds,
prices for most issues are available on inter- most bond issues have sizable reserves and
dealer broker screens such as Reuters, Telerate, liquidity. SVTs make a market in French gov-
and Bloomberg. ernment bonds, a practice that enhances liquid-
ity of the market. The most recently issued
ten-year OAT generally serves as the benchmark
PRICING and is thus the most liquid of these issues. For
the medium-term market, the most recent issues
OATs are quoted as a percentage of par to two of two- and five-year BTANs serve as the
benchmark. Next to the U.S. Treasury strip governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
market, French strips are the most liquid in the actions, and authorized counterparties.
world. As stated above, the face value of all
stripped OATs is uniform, ensuring the fungibil-
ity of coupons of different maturities. Because
primary dealers may reconstitute strips at any ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
time, their liquidity is comparable to the refer-
ence OAT. The accounting treatment for investments in
foreign debt is determined by the Financial
Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
Interest-Rate Risk Financial Acounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
From the perspective of an international inves- Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by
tor, the market risk of French government bonds Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
consists primarily of interest-rate risk and No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
foreign-exchange risk. The interest-rate risk of a and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
French government bond depends on its dura- guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
tion and the volatility of French interest rates. ment for derivatives used as investments or for
Bonds with longer durations are more price hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
sensitive to changes in interest rates than bonds Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
with shorter durations. Because they are zero- 133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
coupon instruments, French strips have longer Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
durations than OATs of comparable maturity, cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
and they are more volatile. (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
Foreign-Exchange Risk
RISK-BASED CAPITAL
From the perspective of an international inves-
tor, the total return from investing in French
WEIGHTING
government securities is partly dependent on the
French government bonds and notes are assigned
exchange rate between the U.S. dollar and the
to the zero percent risk-weight category.
euro.
are accepted to the point that covers the amount dealers, provided they are residents of the Euro-
to be offered up to the stop-out price. Noncom- pean Union and subject to comparable financial
petitive bids may also be accepted and awarded regulations.
at the average of accepted competitive bids plus
a Treasury spread.
The Treasury makes an announcement of Buy Side
auction dates annually and also makes a quar-
terly announcement of the types of bonds and A wide range of investors use Italian govern-
minimum issue sizes to be offered in the fol- ment bonds for investing, hedging, and specu-
lowing three months. The auctions are held at lation. These investors include domestic banks,
the beginning and middle of the month. Gener- nonfinancial corporate and quasi-corporate pub-
ally, three- and five-year bills are sold on the lic and private enterprises, insurance companies,
same day, ten- and thirty-year bonds are sold and private investors. Foreign investors, includ-
together, and CCTs are sold on the third day of ing U.S. commercial banks, securities firms,
the auctions. insurance companies, and money managers, are
The Bank of Italy may reopen issues, that is, also active in the Italian government bond
sell new tranches of existing bonds, until the market.
level outstanding reaches a certain volume.
After that threshold volume is reached, a new
bond must be issued. If an issue is reopened, the Market Transparency
Bank of Italy issues new tranches of securities
with the same maturities, coupons, and repay- The Italian government bond market is an active
ment characteristics as existing debt. The ability one. Price transparency is relatively high for
to reopen issues improves liquidity and avoids Italian government securities because several
the potential poor pricing of securities that often information vendors, including Reuters, dissemi-
occurs when a market is flooded with one very nate prices to the investing public.
large issue.
PRICING
Secondary Market
Prices and yields of Italian government securi-
Italian government bonds can be traded on any ties are stated as a percentage of par to two
of the following: the Milan Stock Exchange, the decimal places. For instance, a price of 97.50
telematic government bond spot market (Mer- means that the price of the bond is 97.50 percent
cato Telematico dei Titoli di Stato or MTS), and of par. The price spread is generally narrow due
the over-the-counter (OTC) market. Bonds may to the efficiency of the market.
be traded on the Milan Stock Exchange if they Bonds trade on a clean-price basis, quoted net
are transformed into bearer bonds (at least six of accrued interest. Italian government bonds do
months after being issued). The stock exchange not trade ex dividend. Interest on Italian bonds is
is the reference market for the small saver; only accrued from the previous coupon date to the
small dealings are transacted there. At the end of settlement date (inclusive). In this regard, Italian
the day, the exchange publishes an official list of bonds pay an extra day of interest compared
the prices and volumes of trading. The MTS is with other bond markets.
the reference market for professional dealers.
HEDGING
MARKET PARTICIPANTS
Italian government bonds can be hedged for
Sell Side interest-rate risk in the Italian futures market
(Mercato Italiano Futures or MIF) as well as the
Only banks authorized by the government of London International Financial Futures Exchange
Italy may act as primary dealers of Italian (LIFFE). The MIF and LIFFE offer futures on
government bonds. Branches of foreign banks ten-year Italian government securities, and the
and nonfinancial institutions can also act as MIF offers futures on five-year Italian govern-
ment securities. The LIFFE also offers OTC investment portfolio may increase interest-rate
options on individual bonds as well as options risk.
on futures contracts. OTC forwards and swaps
can also be used to hedge interest-rate risk.
The effectiveness of a hedge depends on the Political Risk
yield-curve and basis risk. For example, hedging
a position in a five-year note with an overhedged A change in the political environment, withhold-
position in a two-year note may expose the ing tax laws, or market regulation can have an
dealer to yield-curve risk. Hedging a thirty-year adverse impact on the value and liquidity of an
bond with an Italian bond future exposes the investment in foreign bonds. Investors should be
dealer to basis risk if the historical price rela- familiar with the local laws and regulations
tionships between futures and cash markets are governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
not stable. Additionally, if a position in notes or actions, and authorized counterparties.
bonds is hedged using an OTC option, the
relative illiquidity of the option may diminish
the effectiveness of the hedge.
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
The accounting treatment for investments in
RISKS foreign debt is determined by the Financial
Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
Liquidity Risk Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
The Italian bond market is one of the most liquid 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
markets in the world. Liquidity is maintained by Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by
40 market makers, which include 16 specialists, Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
top-tier market makers (Morgan Guaranty, No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
Milan), and 24 other market makers who are and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
obligated to quote two-way prices. Ten market guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
makers have privileged access to the Bank of ment for derivatives used as investments or for
Italy on the afternoon of an auction to buy extra hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
bonds at the auction price. The purchases are Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
subject to a limit set by the Bank. For instance, 133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
if a particular issue were oversubscribed and Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
prices were likely to shoot up, the selected cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
market makers would be able to buy more of the (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
same bond and maintain or increase market ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
liquidity.
Before selling a new bond, the Bank of Italy
may reopen issues until they reach a certain RISK-BASED CAPITAL
volume. Liquidity is also maintained by limiting WEIGHTING
the number of government entities that issue
debt. In the case of Italy, only the central Italian government bonds and notes are assigned
government may issue debt securities. to the zero percent risk-weight category.
futures, options, or swaps. Similarly, foreign- the U.S. dollar, the investor will benefit by
exchange risk can be reduced by using currency receiving more dollars than otherwise. Over the
forwards, futures, options, or swaps. last few years, volatility in the U.S.-Japanese
exchange rate has been particularly high, pri-
marily because of the Japanese banking crisis.
RISKS
Liquidity Risk Political Risk
The market for longer-term JGBs tends to be A change in the political environment, withhold-
more liquid than that for the shorter-term issues, ing tax laws, or market regulation can have an
although liquidity has improved for the shorter- adverse impact on the value and liquidity of an
term issues in the past few years. The bench- investment in foreign bonds. Investors should be
mark ten-year JGB still accounts for the major- familiar with the local laws and regulations
ity of trading volume in the secondary market governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
and therefore enjoys the best liquidity. JGBs actions, and authorized counterparties.
issued more recently also tend to be more liquid
than older issues. The market for medium-term
bonds is less liquid because such bonds are ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
typically purchased by individuals and invest-
ment trust funds, which tend to be buy-and-hold The accounting treatment for investments in
investors. The existence of a large and active foreign debt is determined by the Financial
JGB futures market enhances the liquidity of Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
these issues. Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by
Interest-Rate Risk Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
Like all bonds, the price of JGBs will change in and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
the opposite direction from a change in interest guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
rates. If an investor has to sell a bond before the ment for derivatives used as investments or for
maturity date, an increase in interest rates will hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
mean the realization of a capital loss (selling the Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
bond below the purchase price). This risk is by 133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
far the major risk faced by an investor in the Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
bond market. Interest-rate risk tends to be greater cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
for longer-term issues than for shorter-term (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
issues. Therefore, a large concentration of long- ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
term maturities may subject a bank’s investment
portfolio to unwarranted interest-rate risk.
RISK-BASED CAPITAL
WEIGHTING
Foreign-Exchange Risk
Japanese government bonds and yields are
A non-dollar-denominated bond (a bond whose assigned to the zero percent risk-weight cate-
payments are made in a foreign currency) has gory.
unknown U.S. dollar cash flows. The dollar-
equivalent cash flows depend on the exchange
rate at the time the payments are received. For LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
example, a U.S. bank that purchases a ten-year INVESTMENT
JGB receives interest payments in Japanese yen.
If the yen depreciates relative to the U.S. dollar, Japanese government bonds and notes are type
fewer dollars will be received than would have III securities. As such, a bank’s investment in
been received if there had been no depreciation. them is limited to 10 percent of its equity capital
Alternatively, if the yen appreciates relative to and reserves.
bonds tend to be more liquid than bonds that Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
have been traded in the market for a longer 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
period of time. Debt and Equity Securities," as amended by
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
Interest-Rate Risk and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
Interest-rate risk is derived from price fluctua- ment for derivatives used as investments or for
tions caused by changes in interest rates. Longer- hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
term issues have more price volatility than Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
shorter-term issues. A large concentration of 133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
long-term maturities may subject a bank’s invest- Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
ment portfolio to greater interest-rate risk. cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
(FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
Political Risk
A change in the political environment, withhold- RISK-BASED CAPITAL
ing tax laws, or market regulation can have an WEIGHTING
adverse impact on the value and liquidity of an
investment in foreign bonds. Investors should be Spanish government bonds are assigned to the
familiar with the local laws and regulations zero percent risk-weight category.
governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
actions, and authorized counterparties.
LEGAL LIMITATIONS FOR BANK
INVESTMENT
ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
Spanish government bonds are type III securi-
The accounting treatment for investments in ties. As such, a bank’s investment in them is
foreign debt is determined by the Financial limited to 10 percent of its equity capital and
Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of reserves.
government bond market. Investors include have more price volatility than short-term instru-
banks, securities firms, insurance companies, ments. However, the Swiss capital market is
and money managers. characterized by relatively low and stable inter-
est rates.
Market Transparency
Foreign-Exchange Risk
The market of SGBs and SGNs is fairly active.
Price transparency is relatively high for Swiss Currency fluctuations may affect the bond’s
government securities since several information yield as well as the value of coupons and
vendors, including Reuters and Telerate, dissemi- principal paid in U.S. dollars. The Swiss franc is
nate prices to the investing public. one of the strongest currencies in the world as a
result of the strength of the Swiss economy and
the excess liquidity in the banking system.
PRICING Volatility of Swiss foreign-exchange rates has
historically been low.
Notes and bonds are quoted as a percentage of
par to two decimals. For example, a quote of Political Risk
98.16 would mean a price that is 98.16 percent
of par value. The price quoted does not include A change in the political environment, withhold-
accrued interest. Notes and bonds do not trade ing tax laws, or market regulations can have an
ex dividend. adverse impact on the value and liquidity of an
investment in foreign bonds. Investors should
be familiar with the local laws and regulations
HEDGING governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
actions, and authorized counterparties.
Interest-rate risk may be hedged by taking
contra positions in other government securities
or by using interest-rate swaps, forwards, ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
options, or futures. Foreign-exchange risk can
be hedged by using currency swaps, forwards, The accounting treatment for investments in
futures, or options. foreign debt is determined by the Financial
Accounting Standards Board’s Statement of
Financial Accounting Standards No. 115 (FAS
RISKS 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain Investments in
Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as amended by
Liquidity Risk Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for Transfers
The market for SGBs is more liquid than the and Servicing of Financial Assets and Extin-
market for SGNs due to a lower number of SGN guishments of Liabilities.’’ Accounting treat-
issues. Bonds typically trade in a liquid market ment for derivatives used as investments or for
for the first few months after they are issued. hedging purposes is determined by Statement of
However, after a few months on the secondary Financial Accounting Standards No. 133 (FAS
market, liquidity tends to decrease as a result of 133), ‘‘Accounting for Derivatives and Hedging
the fact that issue size is relatively small. In Activities,’’ as amended by Statement of Finan-
addition, liquidity is hampered by buy-and-hold cial Accounting Standards Nos. 137 and 138
investment practices and by federal and cantonal (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See section 2120.1,
taxes levied on secondary transactions. ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further discussion.)
HEDGING
Secondary Market U.K. gilts may be hedged for foreign-exchange
risk using foreign-exchange options, forwards,
U.K. gilts are traded on the London Stock and futures. Gilts can be hedged for interest-rate
Exchange, International Stock Exchange, and risk by taking a contra position in another gilt or
London International Financial Futures Exchange by using derivative instruments such as for-
(LIFFE). Gilts can be traded 24 hours a day. wards, swaps, futures, or options. Currently, the
Generally, gilts are traded on the International LIFFE gilt futures contract is the most heavily
Stock Exchange between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. and traded hedging instrument. The effectiveness of
on the LIFFE between 8:30 a.m. and 4:15 p.m. a particular hedge depends on the yield curve
and between 4:30 p.m. and 6:00 p.m. The and basis risk. For example, hedging a position
typical transaction size in the secondary market in a six-year note with an overhedged position in
varies between £5 to £100 million. a two-year bill may expose the dealer to yield-
curve risk. Hedging a thirty-year bond with a
bond future exposes the dealer to basis risk if the
historical price relationships between futures
Market Participants and cash markets are not stable.
Sell Side
The primary dealers of U.K. government bonds RISKS
are the GEMMs. GEMMs quote the exact size,
amount, and terms of the issuance beginning Liquidity Risk
eight days before an auction, thereby creating a
‘‘shadow market.’’ At this time, they quote Gilts trade in an active and liquid market.
prices on a when-issued basis. Liquidity in the market is ensured by the BOE,
which is responsible for maintaining the liquid-
ity and efficiency of the market and, in turn,
Buy Side supervises the primary dealers of gilts. GEMMs,
who act as primary dealers, are required to quote
A wide range of investors use U.K. government two-way prices at all times. An increase in
bonds for investing, hedging, and speculation. foreign investment activity in the gilt market has
These investors include banks, nonfinancial cor- led to a substantial increase in competition and
porate and quasi-corporate public and private enhanced liquidity.
enterprises, pension funds, charities, the pension Liquidity is also enhanced through the BOE’s
divisions of life insurance companies, and pri- ability to reopen auctions and tap issues. The
vate investors. The largest holders of gilts are ability to reopen issues improves liquidity and
domestic entities, but foreign investors, includ- avoids the unfavorable pricing that may occur
ing U.S. banks, are also active participants in the when the market is flooded with one very large
market. issue. A tap issue allows the BOE to relieve a
market shortage for a particular bond. An active governing foreign bond issuance, trading, trans-
repo market allows market makers (GEMMs) to actions, and authorized counterparties.
fund their short positions, and it improves turn-
over in the cash market and attracts international
players who are familiar with the instrument, ACCOUNTING TREATMENT
which further improves liquidity.
The Financial Accounting Standards Board’s
Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 115 (FAS 115), ‘‘Accounting for Certain
Foreign-Exchange Risk Investments in Debt and Equity Securities,’’ as
amended by Statement of Financial Accounting
Currency movements have the potential to affect Standards No. 140 (FAS 140), ‘‘Accounting for
the returns of fixed-income investments whose Transfers and Servicing of Financial Assets and
interest and principal are paid in foreign curren- Extinguishments of Liabilities,’’ determines the
cies. The devaluation of a foreign currency accounting treatment for investments in foreign
relative to the U.S. dollar would not only affect debt. Accounting treatment for derivatives used
a bond’s yield, but would also affect bond as investments or for hedging purposes is deter-
payoffs in U.S. dollar terms. Some factors that mined by Statement of Financial Accounting
may affect the U.K. foreign-exchange rate Standards No. 133 (FAS 133), ‘‘Accounting for
include— Derivatives and Hedging Activities,’’ as amended
by Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
• wider exchange-rate mechanism bands, which Nos. 137 and 138 (FAS 137 and FAS 138). (See
increase the risk of holding high-yielding section 2120.1, ‘‘Accounting,’’ for further
currencies; discussion.)
• central bank intervention in the currency
markets;
• speculation about the European economic and
monetary union and its potential membership, RISK-BASED CAPITAL
which puts European currencies under pres- WEIGHTING
sure vis-à-vis the deutsche mark; and
• endemic inflation in the United Kingdom. United Kingdom government bonds are assigned
to the zero percent risk-weight category.