Scribd
Upload
69 views16 pages

Public Policy and Management Cases Design and Preparing A Public Policy and Management Cases

Focusing on the context and approach for developing the skills of case writing for business management and public policy, used as a support resource for a workshop conducted Nov 2022

Uploaded by

Ramana Acharyulu
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
69 views16 pages

Public Policy and Management Cases Design and Preparing A Public Policy and Management Cases

Focusing on the context and approach for developing the skills of case writing for business management and public policy, used as a support resource for a workshop conducted Nov 2022

Uploaded by

Ramana Acharyulu
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 16

How to write

a public
policy case
A grounding on public policy
and business management
case differences
– Business cases aim to teach managerial concepts across sectors
– However, fall short on driving public leadership because
How are – they emphasize
public policy – reasons over emotions,
– economics over politics, and
cases – material benefits over intangibles and meanings
different from – Public policy cases focus on the protagonists (ideally) acting in the public
management interest
– Public leaders tend to face broader, more ambiguous aims than their
cases? business counterparts
– Public policy makers function within more diffuse power structures
– Public policy makers are accountable to a wider array of stakeholders
Three areas to
contrast public – On power and authority of the players in these cases
policy case – On aims and objectives of the case protagonists

with a business – On accountability of the case protagonists

case
– In management cases, normally…
– The case is driven more around the CEO and/or one key
decision maker of the firm
– Power position(s) at the top of the hierarchy,
– Cases showcase the leadership built on a (typical) top-down
strategic decision making organisation
– – except in cases dealing with org design and structure
– In public policy cases,
– The protagonists from a wider variety of roles
– From a very complex power/ hierarchical structures and
– From a range of public service positions ---- resulting in
– Cascade of power structure; decision making and intrinsic
diffusion and profusion of conflict and resolution forms

Authority vs power
portrayal in cases
The aim of government – to further the public interest

Notion of public interest is difficult to define


Aims and • No clear bottomline, no clear way to quantify the benefits, no clear outcome

objectives of • Can cover economics, ideology, public safety, public security and national
security, geo-political relationships etc…

the public • Maximisation objectives may not work


• Public policy makers and implementers face scrutiny of:
policy • Efficiency
• Opportunity fairness
projects • Procedural fairness
• Outcome fairness and
• Balancing the trade-offs of priorities

A public policy case reflects these competing interests, allows the


reader to articulate their own notions as well
– We need to appreciate the policy makers’ implementers for their
accountability>>
– To stakeholders within and outside their immediate organisation
– To recognize the roles of:
Accountability – Voters
of public policy – Service users
– Tax payers
projects – Empoyees
– Elected officials
– Other branches of government
– Non-profit organisations
– Businesses and others
Connect – Cases can be used:
research – To learn about the uncharted phenomena;
– To explicate existing theories; and
to – To examine interesting outliers or to explore unknown archetypes
teaching
– How to go about in each of these scenarios?
– To develop a case that explores a new phenomena…>
– The setting tends to come first and the learning objectives or wider
theory are refined later
– One may begin by an overarching observation or question, and
various scenarios emerge. For example…there could be
– An organisational set up, that works in a way that re-affirms a theory or
conflicts an existing theory
Researching – Or the program goes in a counterintuitive way (just as we learnt from
Aadhaar history)
for a case…1
– Writing a case is an opportunity to learn more – to look for the cause
and effect that can help the phenomenon in a clear way
– One can identify the trends or themes that help make a sense of the
observations
– It ultimately leads to a Descriptive case or a Case Note that’s based on
various insights
– For a case that explicates an existing theory….
– The learning objectives and theory are identified first
– A case setting is selected to illustrate them
– By applying a theory to a specific case situation, the teacher and
students
Researching a – Have an opportunity to test its boundaries and consider how it can
case …2 inform policy making
The approach can lead to developing decision-focused cases where the
application of the theory helps determine how to approach the
dilemma at hand
By reasoning through the decision, students develop a deeper
understsanding of the theory and how it applies in practice
– Examining outliers of a system --- do not merit our attention at
this juncture for the case topics handling, hence we may differ our
Researching a discussions on this…
case…3 – If any of you are interested, we can connect separately on this
dimension
– Case research and writing process have a promise to :::
– Unfold and open up insights and secrets of a program/ scheme/
project/ experiment and help develop a model to get developed

Developing a – Its is therefore, a good thing to start by selecting:


–
public policy –
A setting
A set of learning objectives and a broad storyline to describe and
case>>> discuss

– HOWEVER,
The focus of the narrative and learning objectives may change as the
research process reveals new, perhaps, unexpected facets of the story
Let us look at – Say 5 minutes…

the task on
hand.. After a – The next session will be on architecture for our case writing
short recess… project…
– Use of multimedia in case
– https://ccnmtl.columbia.edu/projects/caseconsortium/casestudies
The Haiti case /124/casestudy/www/layout/case_id_124_id_850.html

– https://www.sipa.columbia.edu/public-policy-case-collection
A podcase and – https://eproduct.hbsp.harvard.edu/eproduct/product/p_human_at
_the_core/instructor/index.html
its use in a
class – Courtesy: HBSP 04 Oct, 2022
Kudremukh – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HWq-JARC7Lw
IOCL Video
Case
Approaches in
– https://www.bu.edu/ctl/teaching-resources/using-case-studies-to-
case writing teach/
and using

You might also like