Assessmentof Child Labour and Urbanization
Assessmentof Child Labour and Urbanization
1.0 Introduction
Children are the greatest gift to mankind and childhood is an important stage of human
development because it holds the potential to the future development of any society. However,
children that are denied proper education and a conductive environment are liable to all kinds of
child labour in the society they find themselves. The main cause of child is poverty with is as
result of population growth without proper measures to cater for the people with lead to
Child labour in recent time is becoming a serious issue that developing nation are dealing with as
they focus on developing the economic sector and other sectors. The term “child labor” refers to
situations where “children are compelled to work on a regular basis to earn a living for
themselves and their families and, as a result, are disadvantaged educationally and socially”. It
also applies to situations where “children work in conditions that are exploitative and damaging
to their health and to their physical and mental development; where children are separated from
their families often deprived of educational training opportunities; and where children are forced
‘Child Labour’ implies something different in which young people are being exploited, or over
worked or deprived of their rights to health, education and childhood. It impairs their health,
The difference between child work and child labour may be briefly stated as follows.
1
Child work
(a) It involves light work (children learn to take responsibilities) (b) It accords some respect to
Child labour
(a) It involves hard and hazardous work, often exploitation (b) It entails deprivation of rights to
health and education (c) It is constant, long hours and illegal (d) It involves some payment for
Article 3 of the International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention No. 182 defines the worst
a) all forms of slavery or practices similar to slavery, such as the sale and trafficking of children,
debt bondage and serfdom and forced or compulsory labor, including forced or compulsory
b) the use, procuring or offering of a child for prostitution, for the production of pornography or
c) the use, procuring or offering of a child for illicit activities, in particular for the production
d) work which by its nature or the circumstances in which it is carried out, is likely to harm the
health, safety or morals of children (Thomas, 2018). ( Jack Martin and David Tajgman, 2002).
Child labour is always caused as result of the financial status of the family in which the family
try to balance their income level and their expenses which is rather low and these kids have no
choice but to support their family in any possible means which they can generate income.
2
Therefore, the major cause of child labour is poverty. There are other factors that stem child
labour such as limited access to educational programs, for example, lack of school facilities in
I. lack of legal documentation which keeps them from enrolling in school and receiving
II. poorly funded, trained, and equipped education systems and teaching staff; – cultural
and/or traditional practices in certain geographical locations or among certain peoples, for
example, migrant workers, nomadic and indigenous populations, and lower castes;
III. employment practices whereby businesses and factories employ children because they
can pay them less than adults and because children are young, defenseless, and docile and
may be bullied into doing work they should not be doing or into working long hours;
IV. vulnerable children being coerced into illegal activities, such as drug smuggling; –
V. discriminatory practices in society and in education, for example against girls or certain
VI. lack of acknowledgement of the problem of child labor by some governments, other
socio-economic and political actors, and even the public at large, and a failure to deal
VII. lack of social protection programs through which poor and vulnerable families could
VIII. the death of parents or guardians from HIV/AIDS, creating a new generation of child-
headed households;
3
IX. armed conflict, with children forced to take up arms or provide other forms of military
cities are formed and become larger as more and more people begin living and working in central
areas. Urbanization was also defined as “the demographic process whereby an increasing share
of the national population lives within urban settlements.” Settlements are also defined as urban
only if most of their residents derive the majority of their livelihoods from non-farm occupations.
(Mohamed et.al, 2014). Urbanization refers to the population shift from rural to urban residency,
Globally, more people live in urban areas than in rural areas, with 54 per cent of the world’s
population residing in urban areas in 2014. In 1950, 30 per cent of the world’s population was
urban, and by 2050, 66 per cent of the world’s population is projected to be urban (World
The process of urbanization historically has been associated with other important economic and
social transformations, which have brought greater geographic mobility, lower fertility, longer
life expectancy and population ageing. Cities are important drivers of development and poverty
reduction in both urban and rural areas, as they concentrate much of the national economic
activity, government, commerce and transportation, and provide crucial links with rural areas,
between cities, and across international borders. Urban living is often associated with higher
levels of literacy and education, better health, greater access to social services, and enhanced
opportunities for cultural and political participation. (World Urbanization Prospects, 2014, p. 3).
As a result of the comfort life style such as Standard Education and Health Facilities which are
provided in the Urban area, immigrants leave their various homes in rural area to urban cities to
also enjoy these standards without proper plan on how to care of themselves, some even come to
4
the cites with their families there by adding to the population in the urban areas. This encourage
Child labor even though it may seem temporary and easily accessible solution to gain additional
income for families so they can meet their needs, but it is surely a detriment to families’
wellbeing in the long run considering what those children are missing while working, namely
education, security. It is, therefore, important to investigate how to lower the level of child labor
There is need to solve a given problem or to modify an existing situation is what prompted the
requisite for research project, since the causes of child labour are primarily rooted in poverty
created by social and economic inequality as well as in insufficient educational facilities (Inter-
Parliamentary Union, 96th Conference, September 1996) ( Jack Martin and David Tajgman,
2002, p. 23).
i. The culture of poverty plays a major role in child labour, it has been stated that
globally some group of persons living below the poverty threshold of $2 per day
(Osita-Oleribe, 2007). Most families engage their children in child labour in order
ii. Urbanization keep changing the life style of families in the city, since the
available resources provided are limited to the number of citizens rich and the
employment units available are less compare to the numbers seeking employment.
Having lost interest in doing any meaningful job, they depend on their children to
provide for the whole families. (Adeojo, Urbanization Processes and Child
5
iii. Culture of Laziness: laziness is prevalent in most African states. Since many
adults look up to others to solve their problems, demand others to feed them while
they waste their time on unprofitable activities such as drinking and gossips. A
typical African adult wakes up late, talks or chats most of the day, does minimal
work in the day time, sleeps early when there are no visitors to talk with or no
film to watch, but eats like a horse. In offices, they work at their own pace. The
jobless are less perturbed as long as there is food on the table. Children are
barrow pushers while their lazy parents sit somewhere collecting the monies they
make and feeding fat on them. It is a cultural practice that has been accepted by
iv. Children are faced with Poor condition for survival, living and health; worse
nutrition status and high morbidity rate; high incidence of injuries when left to
care for themselves in an environment that has no program set in place to care for
them in the city and lack of social protection programs through which poor and
socio-economic and political actors, and even the public at large, and a failure to
The purpose of this study is to analyze the effect of urbanization on child labour in Akure (Akure
South). Based on the objectives, the following major questions will be answered in this research;
6
i. What is the relationship between child labour and urbanization?
ii. What are the causes of child labour at the study area?
iii. What are existing nature of the child labour at the study area?
iv. What are the recommended methods or strategies that can help curb such child
1.4.1 Aim
The aim of this research is to study the effects of urbanization on child labour in Akure the
capital of Ondo state with a view to recommending efficient measures to curb such impacts and
1.4.2 Objectives
The problem of child labour in the areas under study has not be measured in terms of the
magnitude and highlighted properly. To achieve the aim, the research will focus on the following
objectives;
d. Determine and recommend proven methods and strategies that can help curb such
7
1.5 Justification of the study
With the impact of urbanization, the roles and structures of the family have experienced a lot
profound changes in the study area. Changes in the definition of marriages, increase in divorces
rate, unemployment, increase in single parenthood coupled with economic downturns have
altered men's role and responsibility of being the sole provider for their families thereby relying
on their children.
Child labour is one of unsolved development issues associated with urbanization. In most of the
areas in Akure we see child labour almost at very corner either hawking sachet water or
Many children, however, carry out work that, far from being beneficial, impedes their growth
and development and, in many cases, can do them harm. Across Akure, children are being
forced, either by circumstance or coercion, to undertake work that damages them psychologically
and physically and deprives them of their childhoods. This kind of work is carried out in
violation of international core standards and national legislation and includes activities that are
mentally, physically, and socially dangerous or morally harmful to children. It deprives them of
schooling or requires them to assume the dual burden of schooling and work. (International,
2008, p. 10)
The increased demand for services and infrastructure in the Akure has depleted natural resources
and caused other environmental problems. Environmental problems include those caused by
8
widespread poverty and those caused by urbanization and a change in consumption patterns. The
cumulative impact of these 2 causes has serious effects on urban dwellers, especially children.
problems. Urban pressures weaken traditional family ties and social control over children. Adult
supervision of children is rare. Schools are not always available. Interaction between children
and parents, recreation, and cultural stimulation are all lacking which all encourages child labor
The project focused on the Analysis of effects of urbanization on child labour in Akure the
capital city of Ondo state. The study focused on the existing forms of child labour in the study
area, the impact of urbanization on the children as well as the communities under study, and how
Urbanization: This means an increasing proportion of national and global populations living in
urban settlements rather than rural areas. The causes of urbanization are population movement,
natural growth (an excess of births over deaths) and policy change – governments’
Coercion: This mean the power to make someone do something by force or threats or get
9
Spontaneity: The quality or state of being “spontaneous” doing things that have not been planned
but that seem enjoyable and worth ding at a particular time. (Merriam Webster Dictionary)
Curb: This means something that controls or limits something else (Merriam Webster
Dictionary)
Ondo State was created in 1976 out of the former Western State. The state lies between latitudes
5 45’ and 7 52’N and longitudes 4 20’ and 6 03’E. It is bounded on the east by Edo and Delta
states, on the west by Ogun and Osun states, on the north by Ekiti and Kogi states. The state has
eighteen (18) Local Government Areas, with Akure as the capital city as well as the largest
settlement. Akure is a city in south-western Nigeria, and is the largest city and capital of Ondo
State. The city had a population of 484,798 as at the 2006 population census.
Akure lies about 7°25’ north of the equator and 5°19’ east of the Meridian. It is about 700 km
Southwest of Abuja and 311 km north of Lagos State. Residential districts are of varying density,
some area such as Arakale, Ayedun Quarters, Ijoka, and Oja-Oba consist of over 200 persons per
hectare, while areas such as Ijapo Estate, Alagbaka Estate, Avenue and Idofin have between 60-
100 people per hectare. The town is situated in the tropic rainforest zone in Nigeria.
10
Figure 1.1: Map of Nigeria showing Ondo state.
AKURE
ONDO
11
Figure 1.2: Map of Ondo state showing Akure.
CHAPTER TWO
The term “child labour” is often defined as work that deprives children of their childhood, their
potential and their dignity, and that is harmful to physical and mental development. It refers to
work that is mentally, physically, socially or morally dangerous and harmful to children; and/or -
interferes with a child’s ability to attend and participate in school fully by obliging them to leave
school prematurely; or requiring them to attempt to combine school attendance with excessively
12
long and heavy work (ILO, Child Labour in india, 2016). “The exploitation of childhood
constitutes the evil the most hideous, the most unbearable to the human heart” (Albert Thomas,
Child labour also refers to the exploitation of the labour of children who are either too young to
work, or are of working age but work under conditions that subject them to risk. It is an
unfortunate reality that children worldwide are often forced to undertake work that is physically,
psychologically and morally damaging to them. Nonetheless, not all work performed by children
There are many inter- linked factors contributing to the frequency of child labour in the world.
Child labour is both a cause and consequence of poverty. Household poverty forces children into
the labour market to earn money. Some perform child labour to supplement family income while
many also are in it for survival. They miss out on an opportunity to gain an education, further
perpetuating household poverty across generations, slowing the economic growth and social
development.
Fact and figures indicates that: The global figure of child labourers stands at 168 million (ILO,
International labour organization, 2012). Globally, it is estimated that: 211 million children
(aged between 5 and 14) are engaged in some type of work and 1 in 12 children (180 million
young people under 18) are involved in the worst forms of child labour (UNICEF 2016).
Asia and the Pacific still has the largest numbers of child labourers (almost 78 million or 9.3% of
child population), but Sub-Saharan Africa continues to be the region with the highest incidence
13
Globally, agriculture remains by far the most prominent sector where child labourers can be
found (98 million), but the problems are not negligible in services (54 million) and industry (12
million). This is found to be the case mostly in the informal economy (ILO, Child Labour in
india, 2016).
Some important progress has been made in tackling child labour but it’s still here and has the
power to haunt. Globally, there are now 30 million fewer working children than 10 years ago.
However, there are still an estimated 215 million girls and boys trapped in child labour (WOW,
2010).
recognized as a serious and enormously complex social problem in India. Working children are
denied their right to survival and development, education, leisure and play, and adequate
standard of living, opportunity for developing personality, talents, mental and physical abilities,
and protection from abuse and neglect. Notwithstanding the increase in the enrolment of children
in elementary schools and increase in literacy rates since 1980s, child labour continues to be a
According to Census of India, 2001, there were 12.26 million working children in the age group
of 5-14 years as compared to 11.3 million in 1991 revealing an increasing trend in absolute
numbers though the work participation rates of children (5-14) has come down from 5.4 percent
during 1991 to 5 percent during 2001. The recent round of the National Sample Survey (NSSO)
estimates suggests that the child labour in the country is around 8.9 million in 2004/2005 with a
NSSO, 2000 “Theories and Concepts” workforce participation rate of 3.4 per cent (NSSO
2004/05).
14
Child labour in Cambodia is emerging as one of the brightest economic growth stories of South-
East Asia, over 313,000 children are trapped in the worst forms of exploitation such as drug
trafficking and prostitution. But the end of all worst forms of child labour in the country could be
within reach, and the Cambodian Government has committed itself to take on the challenge as
have the social partners. But in order to stay the course it will require continued support of those
inside the country as well as a continued financial commitment from donors to ensure that every
child in Cambodia is given the start in life they deserve (WOW, 2010).
Although Access to education has improved in Cambodia but child labour persists. Leap and
Doung are two of the children still left behind. While primary school enrolment has risen from
75 per cent in 1997 to 91 per cent in 2005 most of the children attending school are combining
Child labour in Mali, approximately two out of three children aged 5 to 17 work. This represents
over 3 million children. Few of them go to school and 40 per cent of children aged 5 to 14
perform hazardous tasks. The situation of migrant girls is of particular concern. Working
children are disadvantaged vis-à-vis their non-working counterparts in terms of their ability to
High levels of child labour therefore translate into large numbers of out-of-school children in
many national contexts. The effects of work on school attendance can also take a more indirect
form. Work can lead to late school entry, which, in turn, is often associated with early school
dropout and lack of completion of a course of study. Research in Cambodia illustrates this,
indicating that work tends to delay school entry (or prevent it altogether), reducing the
probability of completing primary school (L. Guarcello; S. Lyon; F.C. Rosati;, 2008 ).
15
In Bangladesh over 16 million children aged 10 to 14, over 6.8 million are children working.
Forty-one percent of this group is girls. Children are engaged in over 300 different types of work
activities of which 49 are considered harmful to their physical and/or mental wellbeing.
Intolerable forms of child labor, as categorized by the International Labor Organization (ILO),
Bangladesh is one of the poorest countries in the world with about 45 million “very poor”
people, (as measured by the Cost of Basic Needs method) Urban working children estimated at
2.5 million are found mostly in the informal working sector where they are often subjected to
exploitative working conditions, as well as physical, social or emotional abuse. For many,
insufficient pay with long hours of work, inadequate or no rest periods and little or no security of
employment are the norm. Many children perform unpaid labor for their families, especially in
the rural areas where families depend on the child's meager income to sustain the family. Many
are abandoned by their families, others run away to the city because of abusive conditions, and
Child labour is a term that needs to be unpacked: it cannot be used in a sweeping manner but
Child Labour: Those children who are doing paid or unpaid work in factories, workshops,
Street Children: Children living on and off the streets, such as shoeshine boys, rag
pickers, newspaper-vendors, beggars, selling water sachets etc. The problem of street
children is somewhat different from that of child labour in factories and workshops. For
one thing, most children have some sort of home to go back to in the evenings or nights,
16
while street children are completely alone and are at the mercy of their employers. They
Bonded Children: Children who have either been pledged by their parents for paltry sums
of money or those working to pay off the inherited debts of their fathers. Bonded child
labour is an acute problem in some states. Bonded children are in many ways the most
difficult to assist because they are inaccessible. If the carpet owner has bought them, they
cannot escape. If the middle-class housewife has paid for them, they cannot run away.
Working Children: Children who are working as part of family labour in agriculture and
in home-based work. If children are working 12-14 hours a day along with their parents
at the cost of their education, their situation is similar to that of children working for
other employers. In fact, children, particularly girls, are expected to take on work burdens
by parents in complete disproportion to their strengths and abilities. This is the largest
category of children who are out-of-school and are working full time. And it is here that
Children used for sexual exploitation: Many thousands of young girls and boys serve the
sexual appetites of men from all social and economic backgrounds. Direct links between
the commercial sexual exploitation of children and other forms of exploitative child
labour are numerous. Factories, workshops, street corners, railway stations, bus stops and
homes where children work are common sites of sexual exploitation. Children are
intermediaries. Village loan sharks often act as procurers for city brothels, lending money
to the family which must be paid back through the daughter’s work. Almost all such
children are betrayed by those they trust and end up with their trust abused. The physical
17
(health, danger of HIV/AIDS, sexually transmitted diseases) and psycho-social damage
inflicted by commercial sexual exploitation makes it one of the most hazardous forms of
Child labour is prevalent in urban centers in Nigeria. This is because a large number of people
move from the rural areas to urban area. Over the years there has been a rapid growth in
Nigeria’s population because of massive rural-urban migration. For instance, Uyo is the capital
of Akwa-Ibom State and also Akure the capital of Ondo state, the city has experienced rapid
urbanization and many poor rural families struggle for a better life in urban areas. This pushes
families to force their children to work in order to supplement family incomes by (Okafor,2010;
The International Labor Organization estimates that about 25 percent of Nigeria’s 80 million
children under the age of fourteen are involved in child labour. Children works in different
sectors such as farms, domestic help, in fishing, mining, armed conflict, street hawking, and
child trafficking. The number of child labour involved in street hawking is a very common form
of child labour in Nigerian cities, these children working from morning to evening and as a result
of this, they do not have the time to enroll in schools or most of them drop out of school. They
work long hours under dangerous and hazardous conditions with little or no pay benefits. (ILO,
Education in Nigeria is compulsory for a child that till nine years old. Nigerian government
makes primary education free and compulsory for all children. However, many children do not
attend school, about six million children in Nigeria, both boys and girl, are estimated to be
18
working. The dropout rates for primary school are high for both boys and girls because of several
factors such as poverty and early marriage teenage pregnancy poor school, or cultural and
religious issues by (Awosusi & Adebo,2012; Elijah & Okoruwa,2006) in (Osment, 2014).
2.3 Urbanization
Urbanization means an increasing proportion of national and global populations living in urban
settlements rather than rural areas. The causes of urbanization are population movement, natural
growth (an excess of births over deaths) and policy change –governments ‘and reclassification of
some places from rural areas to urban settlements. Population movement includes migration for
economic and other reasons, trafficking, and displacement through conflict and disaster. The
pace of natural population growth depends on fertility rates, but in many countries it accounts for
60 per cent or more of urban population growth. Many governments under-report the size of the
urban population, especially the numbers in slums and informal settlements, where many poor
urban dwellers and some migrants live. Population movement includes migration for economic
and other reasons, trafficking, and displacement through conflict and disaster. The pace of
natural population growth depends on fertility rates, but in many countries it accounts for 60 per
Urbanization is primarily the result of migration, and it is reasonable to treat it as such. However,
urbanization is not just the result of rural–urban migration, particularly if rural–urban migration
is taken to mean long-term rural dwellers moving permanently to urban centres. First,
urbanization is the net result of complex migratory movements between rural and urban areas,
including circular migration back and forth. Indeed, net rural–urban migration can be as much
the result of people delaying or not going back to rural areas as it is deciding to move to urban
areas in the first place. Second, urbanization involves both the net movement of people towards
19
and into urban areas and also the progressive extensions of urban boundaries and the creation of
new urban centres. Urbanization can in principle also result from higher natural population
growth in urban areas or from particularly high international out-migration from rural areas,
although neither are considered very significant (Cecilia Tacoli; Gordon McGranahan; David
Satterthwait, 2014).
To urbanize means to remove the rural character of a district or a population urban means of or
living or situated in. a city or a town; Whilst urbanity generally means of the city, but can also
rnean relined or polished in style of manner thus the of becoming urban and hence of ceasing to
be rural. There also a close correlation between urbanization and civilization, for both processes
share a root word meaning town or city this for seen as a fundamental cultural process in
essences is the process of founding and enhancing the growth of cities. urbanization and
civilization are also very definite economic and technological processes. and this suggests that
changing, by and large. from a rural to an urban way of life (Chadwick, 1987).
Urbanization is defined as “the demographic process whereby an increasing share of the national
population lives within urban settlements.” Settlements are also defined as urban only if most of
their residents derive the majority of their livelihoods from non-farm occupations. Throughout
history, urbanization has been a key force in human and economic development (Mohamed
• The rural population of the world has grown slowly since 1950 and is expected to reach
its peak in a few years. The global rural population is now close to 3.4 billion and is
expected to decline to 3.2 billion by 2050. Africa and Asia are home to nearly 90 per cent
20
of the world’s rural population. India has the largest rural population (857 million),
• Close to half of the world’s urban dwellers reside in relatively small settlements of less
than 500,000 inhabitants, while only around one in eight live in the 28 mega-cities with
• Some cities have experienced population decline in recent years. Most of these are
located in the low-fertility countries of Asia and Europe where the overall population is
where the pace of urbanization is fastest. Integrated policies to improve the lives of both
urban and rural dwellers are needed. (United Nations, Department of Economic and
Figure 2.1: Urban and Rural population of the world 1950- 2050
Source: (United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Divison,
2014).
21
2.4 Urbanization in Nigeria
The economy development of Nigeria (Lagos) and several tourist attractions of the city make it a
desired place of residence for people who want to experience the life of a city in Nigeria. In the
past two decades, there has been major significant economic and infrastructural development in
Lagos megacity coupled with the favorable population structure (the majority being in the
working age category). This has made the city more attractive to foreign and local investors,
tourists and business travelers and entrepreneurs. Lagos is increasingly experiencing rapid
urbanization and urban growth. A lot of urban development and renewal plans are presently in
place to achieve further development in the city (Heinrich Boll Stiftung Nigeria, 2016) in
Urbanization processes in a Lagos megacity is chaotic and unfriendly, this has left many
household heads of the megacity in a state of despair, tumult, psychological and mental distress
thereby forcing them to seek all means to adapt to the disturbing changes of the cities, most
especially those who cannot easily cope (the urban poor). Some are the compounding problems
planning and renewal, pollutions (noise, water, and air) and man-made disasters. Lagos is highly
populated; no wonder the numerous slums and the emerging slums in the city. Despite being the
seventh largest economy in Africa, the economic challenges for most of the families are
enormous. Cases of loss of jobs for the family head are abounding coupled with
underemployment. The husband father’s earning is not usually enough to meet the demands of
the city and has made the women active participants in economic activities. The Darwinian view
22
that a process of natural selection “survival of the fittest” occurred in the social world is
applicable to the pressures that urban dwellers face in Lagos mega city. Employment being the
most viable instrument to alleviate poverty and to cope with the pressures of urbanization in
Lagos is a huge challenge for the dwellers. The requirements for major and highly paid
employments in Lagos favors largely the younger youths. The fathers and mothers who are not
socially unconnected struggle with the economic hurdles of the city coupled the high cost of
living (Olaitan, 2007) in (Adeojo, Urbanization Processes and Child Breadwinner in Lagos,
2017).
Urban populations access finance and promote easily their ideas and have to some extent a local
market (an urban market with higher consumer density) to do business due to urbanization.
However, this positive effect of urbanization on economic growth is not always observed. Both
economic theory and empirical studies suggest that there is an inverted U-shape relationship
between urbanization and economic development in the first stage of development, urbanization
improves economic growth; in the second stage, there is a negative correlation between
urbanization and economic growth. Rapid urbanization can negatively impact the economy via
its effect on straining infrastructures. Thus it seems that the effect of urbanization
on economic activity is complex and depends on several factors such as level of development,
stage of urbanization, and nature of main economic activities (Mohamed Arouri; Adel Ben
Over half of the world’s population including a billion children now live in urban areas. This
recent change from a predominantly rural to a majority urban population has implications for the
23
protection of children from all forms of violence. Yet to date child protection has been largely
missing from development priorities and from the migration and urbanization agenda (West,
2012).
Many children are susceptible to various forms of abuse, neglect, exploitation and violence, in
their homes and schools, in care and justice systems, in places of work and in their communities.
All forms of violence are often aggravated in armed conflict and natural disasters. A lack of a
protective and caring family environment affects children’s physical and mental health. It can
also prevent children from accessing health, education, nutrition and other basic services. A safe
and protective upbringing is necessary for children to survive and develop to their full potential.
It also makes a positive contribution to society at large. These safety nets are often weakening as
a consequence of urban growth (West, 2012) ( Michael Spence, Patricia Clarke Annez, and
Urbanization is seen as having potential benefits, including economic growth, lower fertility
rates, creativity, high quality of life, and environmental sustainability, depending on governance.
the global population are living in urban slums, and are at risk of climate change problems
resulting from extreme weather and rising sea levels. It is estimated that by 2030, 60 per cent of
urban dwellers will be children. Inequalities will continue to be prevalent in this scenario. While
some urban children are well off, half of the world’s urban poor of all ages are children and
24
Over the years, child labour has directly been linked to economic poverty. Poverty is more
blamed for this worldwide scourge. It is claimed that it is poverty that makes parents/guardians
send their children to the streets to hawk, it is poverty that makes parents send out their children
to prostitute, it is poverty that make the elders sell their children for child trafficking, it is
poverty that makes parents allow their children to be employed into formal and informal sectors
for daily or monthly pay, it is poverty that makes parents deny their children education and allow
them to wallow in dirt and unhygienic conditions in the name of working. In fact, every form of
child exploitation is linked to poverty. (Osita-Oleribe, 2007) However, poverty is not the only
reason since poor countries over the developed innovative and creative programmes and policy
formulation to tackle poverty, But these programmes have failed (and woefully too), especially
in Nigeria and other African states. The other factor encouraging child labour is urbanization
since this deals with population increase without proper measures set in place to control the rapid
rate of the development, which leads to high population density, inadequate infrastructure lacks
of affordable housing population and slum creation congestion and poverty which promotes child
labour.
Even if parents would like to equalize educational expenditures across children, they may not do
so if they lack access to capital markets or if they do not realize the value of borrowing against
future income. In this event, the level of spending on first and last born will be higher than the
family average for two reasons. First, as noted by Cigno and Rosati (2000), families that are
25
liquidity constrained cannot spend the return on their investment in their children until they have
entered the labor force. Once the oldest children in the family begin working, the household
budget constraint is relaxed, permitting more investment in the human capital of younger
siblings.
Second, time spent in a smaller family is longer for first- and last-born than for middle children
Note, however, that when a family is liquidity constrained, the youngest children in the family
receive their bonus in the form of greater educational attainment since their family will be
smallest during their school-age years. By comparison, the oldest children will receive their
bonus in the form of greater maternal attention as infants. In addition, the last children to be
born in the family will enter when the parents are at the peak of their earning power, thus further
biasing human capital formation in the youngest children in the family (Birdsall, 1991), (Parish
and Willis, 1993) in ( Robert M. Stern ,et al, 2002). (Glory E. Edet & Nsikak-Abasi A. Etim,
2013).
Theoretical framework The paper is anchored on Marxian theory. The proponent of this theory is
Karl Marx. According to Marx (1963) in (), the change in the society results from the economic
base and super structural institutions and reflection of the changes in the economic base. The
concrete form of this base is the production of man's subsistence needs, the production process
itself is understandable as a human social activity in terms of social relationship that exists
Karl Marx posits that all through history when we consider those social relationships that make
the production process a social phenomenon, two major classes or group of people are
26
identifiable at all times. They are few individuals who own and control the means of production
and the majority of people who do not own the means of production but who do the actual
Marx opines that a class struggle always emerges between the ruling class and the working class
as a result of the unequal distribution of societal resources. Scholars have criticized Marxian
conflict theory because of his overemphasis on the economy as the major source of conflict in
the society. Marx failed to identify other non-economic variables like bad governance which may
create extremes of wealth and poverty in the same society. In spite of the shortcomings and
deficiencies of Marxian theory, it seems to be the most relevant and suitable theory for this
study. In relating the theory to child labour, it should be observed that unequal allocation of
resources and inequality encourage poverty among members of the society. High level of poverty
influences parents to engage their children into child labour which also is associated with some
social and physical problems. Marxian theory best explains the phenomenon at hand. (Dr.
Nneka, 2014)
As the basic theoretical framework in this paper, I will use what can be called a “dual-dual”
model This corresponds to the characteristics of a developing economy with not only the
traditional and modern sectors but also a kind of dualism within each of these sectors in terms of
moving from the lower income status to a higher level of development may modify the
traditional sector further in the direction of a more market-based modern sector while the
formal/informal dichotomy is accentuated within both the sectors. This is the most important
move theoretically which is consistent with the stylized facts to be explained in this paper.
27
Consequently, this approach reveals that for countries like Nigeria which are at a lower level of
income the theoretical possibility of uneven development of the formal and informal sectors both
in the urban and the rural areas can indeed be empirically confirmed as well. Thus, in this
theoretical framework, the coexistence and distribution of modern and informal type of activities
in both rural and urban areas are to be taken as basic structural features of the economy in
question.
The dual-dual approach integrates poverty analysis with rural-urban movements in an economy
wide setting by endogenizing both migration and intra-group income distributions and the
nominal poverty line. Following this line of work leads to our ultimately being able to assess
overall national poverty. The starting point is the dual economy models of Lewis (1954) in
(Khan, 2008) and Fei and Ranis (1964) in (Khan, 2008). These pioneering efforts, however,
could not or did not take into account the co-presence of dualism within each sector of the two
sector models of the dual economy. Khan (2006) explores both rural-urban and reverse migration
in a dual-dual model for South Asia. In the current formulation, a rural/urban dichotomy is
scheme. (Khan, 2008) A further extension of the early dual-economy models is that the rural
economic sector does not only include agricultural activities, but also non-agricultural activities
technologies, family farms, food production for domestic consumption, and small-scale off-farm
enterprises;
28
2. Rural modern is associated with formal activities, capital-intensive technology, large-scale
farming, cash and export crops, and large-scale off farm enterprises;
3. Urban traditional is associated with informal activities, including petit services such as shoe-
4. Urban modern is associated with formal activities, with formal industrial enterprises, including
textile factories with export-orientation, and modern services, such as banking, insurance,
Poverty analysis in this dual-dual approach can be integrated with migration and various shocks
that are important features of the urbanization process in Africa. (Khan, 2008).
29
Figure 2.2 Conceptual framework
The demands of life in the city make an average young and adult woman either directly
employed or self-employed in different businesses like trading and servicing to compliment the
family well-being. In most houses majorly in the suburbs and slums area in Akure, there are
shops where majorly women engage in different economic activities like food selling, trading
and others.
30
Urbanization processes in a Akure is chaotic and unfriendly, this has left many household heads
of the city in a state of despair, psychological and mental distress. Child labour in Nigeria is still
a major concern despite the passage of the child right act into law. The number of children in
Akure engaging in child labour activities such as street trading, apprenticeships, prostitution,
hostel attendants, car washing, hawking, domestic service and weaving are still on the increase.
(Bassey et al 2012) in (Adeojo, Urbanization Processes and Child Breadwinner in Lagos, 2017).
The basic of child labour as confirm by few literatures on child labour shows that the main cause
of child labour is poverty which is as a result of unemployment which one of the effects of
urbanization in Akure (Adeojo, Urbanization Processes and Child Breadwinner in Lagos, 2017).
The issue of child labour is evident from the reviewed literature, but the big problem with Akure,
is the lack of reliable data capturing the magnitude of the problem. Several factors influencing
child labour are: poverty; single parenting; ignorance of the parents; and strong socio-cultural
beliefs. A common socio-cultural belief common among rural dwellers is that child labour is part
incomes.
(TIFOW, 2014).
A household decision to either send or not to send a child to work is usually a function of a
number of factors. As child labour has enormously adverse effects on human capital
development. The frequently used variables in previous literature review about child labour can
characteristics include gender, age, wage, relationship with the household, and birth order, Early
31
characteristics are household income, parental education, occupation, household head, gender of
household head and the number of children and/or household size. Single parents, Insecurity,
Low satisfaction of basic needs, Low parental love Family break up Finally, ‘Urbanization
factors’ characteristics are the location, infrastructure, neighborhood, High population density,
In conclusion, the successful answers of these factors eliminate/reduce the child labour while the
existence of those factors contributes the child labour phenomenon as in Figure 2.2.
32
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 Introduction
the specific procedures or techniques used to identify, select, process, and analyze information
about a topic. The methodology section allows the reader to critically evaluate a study's overall
validity and reliability. Research methodology is simply the processes, procedures, method and
instrumentalities, by which data are sourced, specified, defined, collected, processed and
This Chapter describes the methodological framework used in achieving the stated aim and
objectives of the study. This Chapter showed how the research hypotheses postulated were
empirically determined and examined relevant methodological approaches adopted in the study.
A well-articulated research must be able to provide information on fundamental issues that can
aid the execution of a research. The study focus on measures to mitigate the effects of
The research design refers to overall strategy that you choose to integrate the different
components of the study in a coherent and logical way, thereby, ensuring you will effectively
address the research problem. it the blueprint for the collection, measurement and analysis of
data.
33
The function of a research is to ensure evidence obtained enables you to effectively address the
to the research problem generally entails specifying the type of evidence needed to test a theory,
A research design is the set of methods and procedures used in collecting and analyzing
measures of the variables specified in the research problem research. The design of a study
defines the study type (descriptive, correlation, semi-experimental, experimental, review, meta-
analytic) and sub-type (e.g., descriptive-longitudinal case study), research problem, hypotheses,
independent and dependent variables, experimental design, and, if applicable, data collection
2. In order to equip the reader with sufficient information to appreciate how qualitative the
research is undertaken
4. To provide practitioners contemplating or undertaking qualitative research for the first time
with guidance on the collection, analysis and presentation of data. (Leedy, Paul D. and Jeanne
34
Figure 3.1: Data Collection and Analysis process
main focus of a scientific query. A research population is also known as a well-defined collection
of individuals or objects known to have similar characteristics. All individuals or objects within a
certain population usually have a common, binding characteristic or trait. (Blakstad, 2018).
35
The target population for this study is the total population of the study area. The 2006
census put population of Akure as 491,033. It has 245,198 males and 245,835 females. With
Akure south having a population of 360,268 with 178,672 males and 181,596 females. It was
further projected to 2018 with the aid of projection formula. The study area has recently been
classified as a commercial area being the most populated local government area in Ondo state
Pt = Po (1+r) n
Po= 360,268
P2018=?
n = (2018-2006) = 12
P2018=563,459 people.
The projected population of Akure south at 2018 is 563,459 people as a result of its commercial
growth also with migration as one factors of that increase the effects of urbanization.
36
3.4 Sample frame
Sampling frame is the source material or device from which a sample is drawn. It is a list of all
those within a population who can be sampled, and may include individuals, households or
institutions. Sampling frame is a list of sampling units from which selection of sample is made
In many practical situations the frame is a matter of choice to the survey planner, and sometimes
a critical one. Some very worthwhile investigations are not undertaken at all because of the lack
of an apparent frame; others, because of faulty frames, have ended in a disaster or in cloud of
The sampling frame for this study is Oja oba in Akure south local government in Akure in Ondo
state as the district has the populated due to its commercial function. The raster imageries for the
study area was gotten from Google earth and was digitized by the researcher in order to easily
ascertain the total number of building in the study area. The data for the study was collected from
selected residents in Isolo, Araromi, Odo ikoyi, Ijomu, Igbataye, Oke idanre, Oweakala and Deji
palace communities in Akure. The sampling frame of the houses in the communities is 435 for
Araromi/ Odo ikoyi/ Isolo for Ijomu/ Igbataye / Oke idanre 420 and Oweakala and Deji’s palace
380.
This refers to the number of items to be selected from the population to constitute a sample. The
number of students, families or electors from whom you obtain the required information is called
the sample size (Kumar, 2011). Sample size measures the number of individual samples
37
measured used in a survey. It is the part of population that helps to draw interferences about the
population.
The sample size used for the study is 10% of the total population in the study area. Hence, 10%
of
the total population (1,235) is 123. Therefore 123 questionnaires will be administered using
The procedure for choosing the sampling unit from a population is known as sampling. It
characteristics of a whole population. The systematic random sampling techniques were adopted
selecting every kth element in the sampling frame”. It is assumed that the item to be selected or
sample are randomly distributed or listed in the sample size, and then 1/kth item is selected,
where K is constant. The value of K is usually determined by the researcher, and it is usually
38
dependent upon the size of the sample frame that is to be selected from the sample frame. For the
purpose of this study K is given as seven (7). the first respondent will be selected randomly while
every next seventh building will be selected to make up one hundred and twenty-three (123)
respondents to be selected.
This simply implies the instrument (tools) used in collecting data from the target
population. Data collection instruments such as questionnaires and oral interview will be
employed for the purpose of this research. The adoption of questionnaire as instrument and
techniques will be used for collection of data on the field for this research; also little interactive
discussion will be put into place to get in-depth information for the purpose of adequate and
factual information on this research. Questionnaire is a data collection tool consist of a series of
questions for the purpose of gathering information from respondents. The question posed to
respondents are structurally and uniformly phrased, open ended questions were avoided to guide
against ambiguity and to permit objective comparison of results, and also to enhance easier
analysis. The questionnaire is well-designed meet the research goal and objectives.
Primary data is otherwise called raw information; they are information gathered from the
first source in a controlled or an uncontrolled situation. These data will be collected from field
survey through a well design questionnaire, personal interview, personal observation the use of
photographic equipment.
39
They are also external data, these data are already collected, processed and analyzed by
the researcher within the study area. These includes publication, journals magazines internet
The Questionnaires will be administered directly to the respondents and will be collected
immediately by the researcher. Also, two field assistants will be employed so as assist in the
The data obtained for this research will be analyzed with the use of Statistical Package
for Social Science (SPSS) software. A variety of analytical tools appropriate will be adopted to
analyze the data collected in this study in order to achieve the goal of this research. Descriptive
statistics such as mean, frequency and percentages will be used for the analysis. Also, the study
will adopt the use of photographs to show a vivid description of the situation on ground.
40
CHAPTER FOUR
This chapter covered detailed analyses/presentation of data obtained from the field
survey. Data were presented using frequency counts, percentages and charts. Also, it presents
Data used for the study was collected in August,2018. The total number of questionnaires
administered were (123 copies). The questionnaire was administered to the residents in Akure
4.2.1 Sex
Information in Table 4.1 revealed that the preponderance of male (52.7 %) than female in
the area. This may be connected with the fact that 2006 census for Akure records more males
Male 68 52.5
Female 55 47.5
41
Total 123 100
4.2.2 Age
It was gathered that 18.7% of the respondents are under 18years and 49.6% are between
49.6
the
50age range of 18-30 and 31.7% are between the age range of 31-50 and above. This shows that
45
most
40 inhabitants in the study area belong to the have more working class.
31.7
35
30
18.7
25
20
15
10
5
0
under 18 years 18-30 years 31-50 years
An estimate of the respondents marital status indicates that 53.7% are single and 43.1%
are married and 3.3% are widow/widower, (Figure 4.2). This is as a result that raising a family in
that environment one has to be fully ready for responsibility that comes with family such as
42
3.3
43.1 53.7
4.2.4 Occupation
As shown in the Table 4.2, 19.5% of the respondents were students, 30.1% were traders,
23.6% are self-employed, 18.7% are unemployed and 8.1% of the respondents earns their daily
needs from other sources. This result indicates that they are more traders in the study area, this
may be due to the facts that the core of the study area is a commercial center this attracts more
population from other parts of the states. Also from the researcher observation and oral
investigation most of the respondents were traders due to the fact that study area is actually a
43
50 44.7 Table 4.2:
40 37.4
30 Occupation of
20
8.1 9.8
10 Respondents
0
n n n n
t io tio tio tio
ca u ca c a
u c a
e du ed ed
u
ed
al ar
y
ar
y
io
n Student
r m d ut
fo im on ts it
o Pr c
N Se r in Trader
he
ig
H Self-employed
Unemployed
Others
Total
education, 37.4% had primary education, 44.7% had secondary education and only 9.8% higher
institution education. The result of the findings in this area shows that the residents are literate as
majority had at least secondary education. This could be based on the fact that Yoruba cherished
education. The Yoruba’s. The tribe (Yoruba), is one of the biggest in the country, many of its
representatives are educated, get high job positions, become professors, and reach other
44
Figure 4.3: Educational Qualification of Respondents
From the respondent’s responses and as shown in Figure 4.4 19.5% earns below #10,000,
16.3% earns between #10,000-#20,000, 28.5% earns between #20,000-#50,000, 24.4% rans
between #50,000- #100,000 and 11.4% earns above #100,000. From the result, majority of the
respondents earns at least 20,000 monthly. This may be due to the fact that the most of them are
trader and some are self-employed. Also, judging from the cost of living in Akure, it is not too
expensive except when there is high price of petrol in which all services prices will increase,
45
11%
19%
24%
16%
28%
From the research findings and as shown in the Figure 4.5 2.4% has a household size of
2, 26% has household size of 3, 16.3% has household size of 4, 36.6% has a household size of 5
and 18.7% has a household size above 5 excluding the parents. This result indicates that
majority of the residents have a family size of 5 which have great impact on child labour joined
with the level income above it clear that the size of the family will have impact on how the
46
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
0
less than 2 3 4 5 more than 5
Figure 4.5: Number of children (household size)
From the field survey 43.1% of the respondents are indigenes, 33.3% has only spent less
than 5 years, 13.8 % spent between 6-10 years, 4.9% fall in the range of 11-15 years and only
4.9% has spent above 15 years the community. This fact confirms that the responds are very
Indigene 53 43.1
47
4.3 Child Labour” causes, effect and solution”
From the research findings and as shown in the figure (4.6) revealed that 54.5 % of the
respondents believed that the cause of child labour is poverty while 25.2% agreed to cheap
labour as the cause of child labour in factory and 11.4 % of the respondents said it illiteracy and
2.4% said it the culture of laziness and 6.5% of the respondents went with others. From the
above the largest percent confirmed that the cause of child labour is poverty. (Adeleye, 2014)
2% 7%
11%
poverty
cheap labour
55%
25% illiteracy
culture of
laziness
others
Attempt were made to know the age range of children working, 11.4% were between the
age of 3-5 years, 52.8% were between the range of 6-8 years and 10.6% were between the age
range of 9-11 years and 12.2% were between 12-14 years of age and 13% were between 15-18
48
years of age. From the result in figure 4.7 the highest number of children fall under the range of
52.8
60
50
40
30
11.4 12.2 13
20 10.6
10
0
3-5 years 6-8 years 9-11 years 12-14 years 15-18 years
49
4.3.3 Poverty the main cause of child labour
From the survey as showed in the figure 4.8 below, 79.7% of the respondents agreed that
the main cause of child labour is poverty and 20.3% of the respondents said no that to poverty
been the main cause of poverty. In developing countries child labour major issue is poverty being
the key factor that forces children to work (khan et al, 2018).
no 20.3
yes 79.7
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
From the research findings and as shown in the table below (Table 4.4), 8.9% of the
respondents said physical health, 44.7% agreed with Social and psychological consequences,
13.8% agreed that lowering of self-esteem of children and 32.5 % pointed out that it will affect
their education (not attending schools). From the survey its noted that majority of the
respondents agreed that child labour affect the children more Socially and psychologically
(West, 2012).
50
Frequency Percent (%)
Efforts made to know the type of job they are mostly involved in, from the survey as
showed in the figure 4.9 below, 50.4% of the children are in hawking of different types of
products, 19.5% of the children do load carrying in the market, 8.1% do bus conductor for
drivers, 12.2% fetch water for money and 9.8% do Mechanics and vulcanisers. This result
indicates that the most common job done by the children in child labour is hawking, some even
sell sachet water to drivers on the main road just to for a living put their lives in harm’s way.
51
50.4
19.5
12.2 9.8
8.1
h aw k in g lo ad car r y in g b u s c o n d u ct o r w at er f et ch in g M e ch an ic s a n d
v u l can i s er s
Plate II: Showing the picture of a 5-year-old boy carrying load for money in the study area.
52
Plate III& IV: Pictures showing children hawking in Oja oba
Information in table 4.5 revealed that 14.6% of the respondent agreed that child labour
affects the parent, 48.8% of the respondents agreed that the children are more affected, 20.3%
support that the economy is affected more and 16.3% of the respondents believed that urban
growth is more affected. This result shows that children are the most affected in child labour,
they are affected physically, socially and educational wise too more than any other components
of the society.
53
Impacted targets Frequency Percent (%)
Parents 18 14.6
Child 60 48.8
Economic 25 20.3
Parents 18 14.6
Efforts made by the researcher to know the type of child labour in the study area, the
information is shown in figure 4.10 below, 9.8% for young bus conductor, 22.8% for child
begging and 67.5% for child hawking. This result shows child hawking is most common type of
9.8
22.8
67.5 young Bus Conductors
Child Begging
child hawking
54
Plate V: Showing the picture of an 8-year-old girl hawing in the study area.
Information in figure 4.11 below revealed that 61% of the respondents agreed with
migration, and 9.8% of the respondents support natural growth, 26.8% of the respondents said
policy change “government’s reclassification” and 2.4%agreed with other causes of urbanization.
From the above results, migration is regarded as the main cause of urbanization since it deals with
movement of population into a particular region. Migration contributes more to the problems of
urbanization since it always leads to over population without proper measure to contain the
increasing population.
55
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Migration Natural growth Policy change others
“governments’
reclassification”
Efforts made to know the main negative impact of migration in urbanization, is shown in
table 4.6 below, 18.7% of the respondents said low level quality of life, 35% or the respondents
said overpopulation, 22% support social problems, 8.1% said slump area creation, and 16.3%
said unemployment. From the result above, overpopulation is noted to be the main negative
effects of migration which leads to unemployment and later low level quality of life (poverty)
56
Table 4.6: Negative impact of Migration
Overpopulation 43 35
Social problems 27 22
Unemployment 20 16.3
Findings on the cause of unemployment in the study area is represented in figure 4.12
shown below, 54.5% of the respondents said over population, 11.5% of the respondents said
increasing industrialization and 34.1% said its political and socio cultural disadvantages. From
the result above, the main cause of unemployment is overpopulation when people seeking for
57
political and socio cultural disadvantage
increasing industrialization
11.5 34.1
overpopulation
0
10
20
30 54.5
40
50
60
4.4.4 low level quality of life is a negative impact of migration; what effect does give the
most;
From the survey as showed in the figure 4.13 below 22% of the respondents said low in
level of health, 30.9% of the respondents said shortage of facilities, 16.3% of the respondents
agreed with increasing in crimes waves, 15.4% said population problems and 15.4% pollution
problems. From the result it can be denoted that low level quality of life leads to shortage of
facilities.
58
35
30.9
30
25
22
20
16.3 15.4 15.4
15
10
0
low in level of S hortage of Increas ing in P opulation P ollutions
health facilities crimes problems problems
Findings revealed that 20.3% of the respondents said the policies are uncoordinated,
39.8% said the policies are not well implemented, 32.5 of the respondents
Said the policies are largely unenforced and 7.3% said there is no direct child labour policy.
This result proves that there are policies but they not effective on reducing child labour in the
study area. Some of the policies set are already forgetting and some polices on only lasted for
some period of time before going into extinction. This survey shows that there is need for the
59
45
39.8
40
35 32.5
30
25
20.3
20
15
10 7.3
5
Figure 4.14: Rate the Impact of Government on Policies Formation and Enforcement
Research to ascertain the effects of urbanization on child labour is shown in the figure
4.15 below, 54.5% of the respondents agreed that urbanization lead to abuse and violence on the
child is such environment hawking, 27.6% said poverty and 17.9% support developmental
damage.
A respondent, for example cited of what boys pass through “It is easy to get beaten if you are a
street boy. Men can beat a boy and rape him. There is nothing you can do but run away if you are
lucky.” Also a seven-year-old boy at Isolo market said “I was put to work in a small factory. It
was a small room and there were six other boys like me, working for 14 hours a day and paid
little or no money at all”. “My initiation was four gang members beating me for 18 seconds.”
from a Girl in Araromi This are various issues that conform children in child labour.
60
60
50
40
30
20
10
Plate VI: Showing the picture a child sleeping on a major at the study area.
61
4.4.7 Laws against on street trading
Research to ascertain if government should set laws against street trading is shown in
figure 4.16 below, 100% of the respondents said government should set laws against on street
trading especially on highway road, while 0% of the respondents said no. From the result above
government should set enforceable laws to curb on street trading this will help control child
labour.
120
100
100
80
60
40
20
0
0
yes no
62
Plate VII: Street trading in Akure.
63
4.3.8 Saving children from all forms of child labour
Estimate to know the best way to control all forms of child labour the study area, this is
shown in figure 4.16 below, 23.6% of the respondents agreed to child protection, 31.7% of the
respondents said family support, 23.6% of the respondents suggested urbanization programming
(economic revitalization) and 21.1% of the respondents said child at the center of urban
planning. From the survey the main reason child labour is encouraged in the study area is
poverty and child labour will only be reduced if the main factor that contribute to it handled
effectively.
21% 24%
24%
32%
Figure 4.16: How to save children from all forms of child labour
64
CHAPTER FIVE
Child labour is a major problem in developing countries like Nigeria and it is influenced
more by factors of urbanization such as migration and unemployment, from the study carried out
on the assessment of child labour and urbanization in Akure the capital of Ondo state.
From the survey it was discovered that the main factor that contributes to child labour is poverty
which is one of the effects of urbanization caused by unemployment. Also the household size
contributes to child labour since the income available is not sufficient for the number of children
The only option left is to send these children into child labour so as to offset the financial
constraint.
On the age range of children working in the study area it was discovered that the highest number
of kids found in child labour are between the age of 6-8 years. This stage is one of the most
amazing stage any child hopes to enjoy once this stage is lost there no means to get those feeling
back, but at this level they are ready exposed to life which they are to be prepared for until they
are 18 years, but now they are looking for means to survival at a very young and tender age
facing a lot of challenges along the way putting their life and future in harm’s way.
On the effects It was discovered that Child labour is a cause and consequence of poverty and
family support programs as well as education and training is crucial to breaking this cycle. At the
same time, interventions of government on integrating child at the center of urban planning must
be integrated with other interventions to effectively remove children from hazardous work.
65
These includes measure that will address poverty and underdevelopment, inadequate health and
social policies, weak labour market institutions, inadequate legislation and an inadequate
enforcement of laws. Both supply side factors such as the role of poverty in compelling parents
to send their children to work, and demand side factors such as the way a society organizes its
production processes help determine the extent to which children engage in child labour. Social
exclusion mechanisms are another strong factor that keep children out of school leading them to
work. In many cases, children in the worst forms of child labour belong to the most
5.2 Recommendations
Education is often cited as the key to eliminating child labour. But by itself, education
isn’t enough. The main cause of child labour is urban poverty, to control child labour measures
to tackle urban poverty should be established, such as family support, integration of child at the
One of the ILO’s responses to pioneer a livelihood scheme to help decrease, and
eventually eliminate, a family’s reliance on its children for income. This IPEC programme
encourages parents and other adults from the country’s poorest families to work together to
create savings groups (WOW, 2010). CEPROMIN runs a project on improving the living
conditions of children and mining families living in the mining camps of Potosí. The project
makes sure they are properly fed and looked after and, most importantly, that they receive a
quality education. In addition, the project addresses the needs of adults, improving the socio-
66
economic environment. This combined approach can make a big difference. (ILO, International
Child protection responses in emergency situations need to: include work with families
to prevent and stop abuse and family separation; to address the potential for trafficking and
institutionalization; and to provide psychosocial support and reunify children with parents or
ensure that other forms of appropriate care are provided. Child protection responses also require
working with children on the potential for and effects of violence following emergencies,
particularly with girls on sexual violence, and with boys on compulsion to join violent groups
and gangs. Child protection needs to be a key part of disaster prevention, risk reduction and
emergency planning, and should involve boys and girls in their own protection (West, 2012).
5.2.3 The Centre for Child Rights and Corporate Social Responsibility (CCR CSR)
They have developed a training that enables migrant parents to communicate with their
children effectively when they are working far from home. A book for parents, Distant but Close,
covers various aspects of parent–child communication. It includes exercises that help parents
find an effective way to connect with their children while away and practical ways to re-bond
with their children on their return. International and Chinese companies are investing in the
Improving access and quality of education will not be sufficient if parents do not see a
value in children attending school. The parents of children in the study area are often poorly
educated themselves. A startling 11.6 percent of adults, when asked why a child was not in
67
school, indicated that school was not considered valuable—three-quarters of these children
worked. While this minority is an extreme example, it is likely that this sentiment lingers in other
households and may sway a family’s choice between sending a child to school or to work. It is
vocational alternatives.
Increased awareness among traditional ILO partners and new social partners on
5.3 Conclusion
cumulative efforts by all countries. It is heart breaking when children who are supposed to be
nurtured and trained in becoming leaders of tomorrow are being exploited and grown up too
quickly as adults through child labour. Many child labourers are intelligent with a bright future;
however, poverty have deprived them of the opportunity to be educated. Urban poverty affects
children’s lives in many ways, particularly within the family, cash is essential in an urban area,
where families do not have any produce from land or animals to exchange for goods however,
unemployment is a major concern materially and emotionally and it affects the division of roles
68
and the power relations in the family setting in which children may have to take up harmful work
Abuse and violence in the home is not a characteristic of poverty, but poverty exacerbates
problems, especially in urban areas where traditional safety mechanisms are no longer available.
However, children in urban poverty experience levels of depression and distress that are higher
The results of household and working children surveys, as well as of field observations, suggest
that streets in Akure are central to child labor. The livelihoods of about half of working children
are based on activities carried out on the streets. Because the streets expose children to a number
of health hazards and accidents, interventions designed to improve the conditions of children in
Akure would have a considerable impact if their priorities were on this group of children. The
study provides useful information on the nature and extent of child work in Akure and on
urbanization has increased the extent of child labour in Akure It also provides information that
would raise awareness on the welfare implications of child work in Akure as well as it
Ensures adequate provisions are made for child in preparation of master plan
Reveals the ways to curb some socio economic problems associated with
planning;
69
5.5 Contribution to Knowledge
urbanization, Thus, the study in its little way has helped to expand the knowledge base of urban
and regional planning in the area of child labour and urbanization. This study has also revealed
the relationship between urbanization factors such as migration- over population- unemployment
Based on the gaps that are observed in literature and in the course of this research, the following
70
REFERENCES
FORMS . CAPE TOWN : University of Cape Town (UCT) in terms of the non-exclusive
https://explorable.com/research-population
Blier, s. p. (2015). Art and risk in Ancient yoruba: ife history, power and identity. Cambridge
Carl-Erik Särndal; Bengt Swensson; Jan Wretman. (2003). Model assisted survey sampling.
London.
Chadwick, G. (1987). Model of Urban and Regional Systems in Developing Countries. New
York: Pergamon Press, Maxwell House, Fairview Park Elmsford, New York 1 0523,
U.S.A. .
71
Dash, B. M. (2013). FACTORS CONTRIBUTING THE INCIDENCE OF CHILD LABOUR IN
Dr. Nneka, P. O. (2014). IMPACT OF STREET HAWKING ON THE SOCIAL AND. Awka:
Department Or Sociology/Anthropology.
ILO. (2012). International labour organization. Delhi: ILO Decent Work Team for South Asia
and Country Office for India, Core 4B, Third Floor, India Habitat Centre, New Delhi
110003, India .
ILO. (2016). Child Labour in india. India: ILO Decent Work Team for South Asia and Country
Office for IndiaCore 4B, Third Floor, India Habitat Centre, New Delhi 110003, India.
ILO-IPEC. (2006). The International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC).
International, W. (2008). Best Practices in Preventing and Eliminating Child Labor through
Education Drawn from the Global CIRCLE Project. United States of America:
IPEC, I. P. (2010). National modular child labour survey country report. Nigeria: ILO; Federal
72
Jack Martin and David Tajgman. (2002). Eliminating the worst forms of child labour.
Joseph j. Amon, Jane Cohen, and juliana kippenberg. (2012). Child labour and Evironmental
khan et al. (2018). determinants and Working Conditions of Child Labour: A Case Study of
Children Working at Automobiles Workshop. Arts and Social Sciences Journal, volume
9, 1-7.
Khan, H. (2008). Challenges for Sustainable Development:. USA: Josef Korbel School of
KOTHARI, C. (2004). Reserach Methodology . New Delhi: NEW AGE INTERNATIONAL (P)
Kumar, R. (2011). Research Methodology "a step- by -step for beginners (3rd Edition ed.).
London: SAGE Publications Ltd 1 Oliver’s Yard 55 City Road London EC1Y 1SP.
L. Guarcello; S. Lyon; F.C. Rosati;. ( 2008 ). Child labour and Education For All: an issue
“Tor Vergata” .
73
Leedy, Paul D. and Jeanne Ellis Ormrod. (2013). Practical Research: Planning. . Tenth edition.
Boston: SAGE.
Mehta p. (1992, jul 10). Urbanization and its consequences on children. Retrieved june 19, 2018,
Michael Spence, et.al. (2009). Urbanization and Growth. Washington, DC: The World Bank,
Mohamed Arouri; Adel Ben Youssef,Cuong Nguyen-Viet and Agnès Soucat . (2014). Effects of
http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/pgda/working.htm .
Mohamed et.al. (2014). Effects of urbanization on economic growth and human capital
Osita-Oleribe, O. E. (2007). Exploring the causes of child labour series. International NGO
Journal, 006-009.
Osment, L. (2014). Child labour; the effect on child, causes and remedies to the revolving
Prognosys. (2012). A Study on Child Labour with Special reference to Child Labour Project
Ltd. 2012.
74
Robert M. Stern ,et al. (2002). The Determinants of Child Labor: Theory and Evidence .
Michigan : School of Public Policy The University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan
48109-1220 .
Thomas, A. (2018, june 21). child labour. Retrieved from International Labor Organization
(ILO): www.ilo.org
University of Nairobi, in Partial Fulfillment for the requirements of the Award of the
United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Divison. (2014). World
World Urbanization Prospects. (2014). The 2014 Revision. United Nations: United Nations.
WOW. (2010, august). The face of Child labour from Africa to Asia and the Americas. The face
of child labour, 7.
75
ABBREVIATIONS
76
APPENDIX
77
7. Length of stay in the area A. Indigene ( ) B. less than 5 years ( ) C. 6-10 years ( ) D. 11-
15years ( ) E. Above 15 years
8. Ward representation __________________________
9. Number of children? A. less than 2 ( ) B. 3 ( ) C. 4( ) D. 5 ( ) E. more than 5
10. Religion A. Christianity ( ) B. Muslim ( ) C. Traditional ( ) D. Others, please specify
_______________
SECTION B: CHILD LABOUR: This section contains questions that seek to gather
information from respondents the reasons that lead to child labour and there impacts on the
children in the study area (Akure).
11. Why do children work? A. poverty ( ) B. cheap labour ( ) C. illiteracy ( ) D. culture of
laziness ( ) E. others specify _________________
12. Age of range of children working in the study area a. 3-5 years ( ) B. 6-8 years ( ) C. 9- 11
years ( ) D. 12-14 years ( ) E. 15-18 years ( )
13. Is the main cause of child labour poverty A. yes ( ) B. no ( )
14. Effect of child labour on the children a Physical health ( ) B .Social and psychological
consequences ( ) C. lowering of self-esteem of children ( ) D. not attending schools ( ) E.
others specify ___________________
15. Type of job are they mostly involved A. hawking ( ) B. load carrying ( ) C. bus conductor (
) D. water fetching ( ) E. Mechanics and vulcanisers ( )
16. Who does child labour really affect A. parents ( ) B. Child ( )C. Economic( ) D. urban
growth( )
17. Types of child labour in the environment A. young Bus Conductors ( ) B. Child Begging ( )
C. child hawking
SECTION C: URBANIZATION AND CHILD LABOUR
18. Causes of urbanization? A. migration B. natural growth C. policy change “governments’
reclassification”
19. What is the main negative impact of migration A. Low level quality of life ( ) B.
Overpopulation ( ) C. Social problems ( ) D. Slump area( ) E. Unemployment ( )
20. Major causes of unemployment in the area A. overpopulation ( ) B. increasing
industrialization ( ) C. political and socio cultural disadvantage ( )
78
21. Let say low level quality of life is the main negative impact of migration, what effect dost
this give the most? A. Low in level of health ( ) B. Shortage of facilities ( ) C. Increasing in
crimes ( ) D. Population problems ( ) E. Pollutions problems ( )
22. Rate the impact of government on policies formation and enforcement A. uncoordinated ( )
B. not well implemented ( ) C. largely un enforced ( ) D. No direct child labour policy ( )
23. Effect of urbanization on child labour A. Abuse and violence B. Poverty C. developmental
damage d. others specify_____________
24. Government should set laws street trading? A. yes B. no
25. How to save children from all forms of child labour A. child protection B. family support c.
urbanization programming D. child at the centre of urban planning
79