Final Analysis
Final Analysis
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
● Population - 9,57,730 Thiruvananthapuram Thiruvananthapuram MG Road DTPS (Detailed Town Planning
● Population Density - 4,500/km2 District Area - 2,192 km² Corporation Area - 214 km² Scheme) Area - 30 HA (0.3 km²)
● Literacy rate - 93.72%
● Work Force Participation Ratio - 32.40%
District having 4 Taluks spread over 2192 sq.kms.
●
MG Road Location
● Average rainfall - 170 cm/annum
● Average elevation - 16 ft above sea level Context
● Arterial road carrying majority of vehicular and
pedestrian traffic.
● As per Master Plan, it is to be designed as
multi-functional throughfare to cope increasing
commercial activities and traffic.
● As per DTPS average width of 30 m taken on Vanchiyoor (82)
Connectivity:
● Trivandrum International Airport - 4.4 km
● Trivandrum Central Railway Station - 1 km
● Kochuveli Railway Station - 7.6 km Site area is bounded by:
● Palayam to its north
Covering Wards/Locality:
Sreekanteswaram (83)
● Chalai and East Fort to its south
● Thampanoor (ward-81)
● Vanchiyoor to its west
● Chalai (ward-71) Chalai (71)
Spatial Expansion of
Thiruvananthapuram
En partie, l'Inde et Ceylan. Asie (Source: Indian Institute of Architects)
108.1837
2020s MG road (Source: Google earth Pro) 1930s MG road (Source: unknown)
1930s Shot of Padmanabhaswamy temple( Source: Google)
Prominent Landmarks & Thematic Land use( Till 1951) of MG road
Physiographic
1. The contours of the area has widely 1. The revival of natural drainage system
being changed in this period due to lead to minimising urban floods by 2019
rise in new Constructions
2. This was also the rise of flooding
problems of the area due to filling of
the low lying areas
3. Many Ponds were being filled. One
of the major being manjakulam
pond in SVM high School.
Pulimoodu
Vanchiyoor
Thampanoor
Residential Thakaraparambu
Commercial
Open Spaces
Chalai
Water Bodies
Trivandrum
Trivandrum City
City ProposedLand
Proposed LandUse
Use 1986 OnGround
On GroundLand
LandUse
Use(From
(FromPrimary
Primary Survey)
Survey) ProposedLand
Proposed LandUse
UseMaster
Master Plan2031
Plan 2031 Google Satellite Image of MG Road 2022
Inferences
● Increase In commercial land use over
the years
● Drop of Residential land use
percentage in the proposed land use for
2031
● Addition of Land uses like IT Industry
based land use
● Satellite imagery gives a character of
the area
● Government Offices. Social and Cultural Establishments, Community Facilities. ● Movie halls, Hotels, Markets, Godowns Warehouses/storage, Automobile Showrooms,
● Public Utilities buildings, Religious buildings, Residences floor area up to 300 sq.m. Weigh Bridges, Automobile Workshops, Printing presses, hardware/ electronic industries.
● Hostels and Boarding houses, Ashram/Mutts, Gymnasium/ Shops/ Professional ● Marble and Granite Storage/Cutting sites, Taxi Auto Rickshaw stand Parking plaza
offices/Restaurants/Canteen, Wedding halls, Banking and Financial institutions. Cremation grounds, burial grounds and. related constructions.
Any other uses not specified
● Godowns/ Warehouses/ IT software units, Radio and TV Stations, Transmission Towers, ● Sewage Treatment Plants, Solid Waste Management processing units, Slaughterhouses
Auditorium, Convention Center, Art Gallery, Community Halls. Godowns/ Warehouses, non hazardous Fuel Filling Automobile workshops Automobile,
● Library, Museums, Tot Lots, Open theatres, Parks, Play pgrounds, Stadium, Nursery, ● Spray painting workshops. Non nuisance type service industries, Camping sites and
Pump house, Wells and irrigation ponds, etc. Transport terminals.
Additions and alterations to the existing buildings/addition of new block(s) without altering Building essentially incidental to the main use with floor
Fuel filling stations Any other uses not specified
the use, Buildings essentially incidental to the main use with floor area limited to 100 sq. area limited to 300 sq m.
Footpath access upto 60 m 3.5 m wide The authority in consultation with CTP
5.5 m Width upto length of 200 m HEIGHT of the buildings Shall have power to fix the height of
Cul de sac Owner or person can layout a Subdivided plots exceeds 10 in storeys and ultimate height of buildings
4.5 m Width upto length of 90 m street for building purpose only if number and CTP is consulted. and line of buildings
A A’
Mercantile/Commercial G+2
G+3
2 65 2.50 4 G+4 or More
F Vacant / Parking
3 Educational B 35 2.50 3
4 Medical/Hospital C 40 2.00 3
Distribution
Distribution of shops
of shops in Road
in M.G. M.G.(Source:
Road (Source:
Building Use
Commercial land use in M.G. Road BuildingInventory)
Use Inventory) Franchises emerged
Commercial land use in M.G. Road
Distribution of shops with daily footfall more Distribution of shops with employees coming from
Distribution of shops with daily footfall more than 20
Premise Level Use - Commercial than 20 distance more than 5km
Zone Vendors
1 0
2 3
3 7
4 10
5 11
Distribution oftype(Left)
Distribution of type(Left)&& Count
Count of Vendors
of Vendors Zone Zone wise( Right)
wise( Right)
Distribution
Distribution of Age
of Age Newspaper Clipping, 2022 (The
Hindu)
BOOKS
JEWELLERY
CLOTH
FOOD
Earning per
Type Day
Apparel 400-500
bags 500-1000
books 400-500
Jewellery &
Accessories 400-600
knife 1000
BOOKS
Income & turnover Per day Type of shop acc.Kerala Vending Act, 2019
JEWELLERY
BAGS Category of Street Vendor Area of vending unit FeesVending Per Year
KEYCHAINS <10 sq. feet 750
KNIFE
10-25 sq. feet 1500
CLOTH
Stationary Vendor(fulltime) >25 sq. feet 3000
FOOD
<10 sq. feet 375
Stationary Vendor(Part time or Time 10-25 sq. feet 700
Major Criterias for location Sharing) >25 sq. feet 750
(Clustering) <10 sq. feet 750
● Adjacent land use activity 10-25 sq. feet 1500
○ Location of bookshop
Mobile Vendor( With Motor Vehicle) >25 sq. feet 3000
based on college
proximity <10 sq. feet 375
● Distance to nearby Tourist 10-25 sq. feet 750
Spot, major market or Fees
Mobile Vendor(Vehicle without as per
motor) >25 Street
sq. feet Vendor Act, 2019 1500
railway station. Mobile Vendor(Headload) 250
All the vendors surveyed till the age of 25 and beyond 55 have vendor license
Venders Location and Clustering
● The ROW of city roads are saturated and the abutting dense
development prevents them from widening it.
● Future focus would be on urban mobility -move people not
vehicles
● Concepts like 15 minutes city will be achieved
● For mobility - underground as well as above the ground
options will be explored
● From the lessons from Kochi Metro, the proposal of metro in
trivandrum is being reconsidered
● Alternative mode of transport like LRT and monorail is being
explored
● BRT system was not found to be feasible in Trivandrum
Type of Ownership
● Road Network Inventory
vehicle Percentage
● Traffic Volume Count
● Parking survey car 24.20%
● TMC 2 wheeler 58.20%
bicycle 24.50%
Therefore the design service volume of the road = 5400 PCUs per Hour
Design Speed = 50 Km/Hr
Left Right
Volume Capacity V/C LOS Volume Capacity V/C LOS
Zone 1 1712 2700 0.63 B 1990 2700 0.74 C
Zone 2 1582 2700 0.59 A 1743 2700 0.65 B
Zone 3 1677 2700 0.62 B 2103 2700 0.78 C
Zone 4 1770 2700 0.66 B 1956 2700 0.72 C
Zone 5 2241 2700 0.83 D 1860 2700 0.69 C
Chart 1: Modal Split count of Vehicles Chart 2: Modal Split of Vehicles in ECS
Towards Towards
Palayam Palayam
Towards
East Fort Towards
East Fort
Towards
Towards Palayam
Palayam
Towards
East Fort
Towards
East Fort
Towards
Palayam
Overbridge Junction
B
Towards East B’
Fort
Cross
Section A-A’
A’ A
A A’
Cross
Section B-B’
B’ B
Z1L1
Z1R1
Z2R1
Z2L1
Z2R4
Z2L2 Z2R5
Z2L3
Z3R1
Z3L1
In the delineated area the links were Z3R2
identified and for walkability index is
calculated on the basis of footpath
parameters. The higher the index value
more walkable the area is. Z3R3
Z3L2
● Most links had footpath of width between Z3R4
1m-1.8m
● Some obstructions in the footpath like electric Z4L1
poles, vehicles being parked on the footpaths
and discontinuity makes it difficult to walk
through the area.
● A few roads were not wide enough to provide
footpaths.
● A few roads in the site had drain covers Z4L2 Z4R1
extended throughout the link acting as space for
pedestrians to go walk over. Z5L1 Z5R1
● Although there were no sidewalks in the bus
stops present on footpaths but it didn't seem to
cause much hindrance. Z5L2
Z5R2
● With less kerb heights other motor vehicles get
easy access to the footpaths and sometimes
they park on footpath only also promoted by Z5R3
shopkeepers and vendors Z5R4
Z5L3
The area is moderately walkable to highly walkable, the walkability index is 6.83
3 wheeler 54 344 93 35 0 0 14 invalid 73 326 71 invalid 48 0 105 invalid 1163 22.96603 2326
4 wheeler 21 303 56 28 0 0 9 invalid 117 315 38 invalid 39 16 69 invalid 1011 19.96445 1011
Total 130 1357 554 105 0 0 56 0 427 1364 226 0 254 99 492 0 5064 100 5803.35
Count the number of vehicles passing throught the Junction Name Traffic (In PCU)
intersection in the various turning directions Pazhavangadi 8189.2
Calculate the equivalent PCU of the vehicles by Overbridge 6421.5
using the specified factors
Flyover 6340.2
Finding the modal split of the vehicles
passing through the junction Ayurveda 5361.75
Pullimodu 5803.35
Adding up the PCU calculated in the last step . Statue 4125.6
Cantonment Police 3951.45
Spencer 5542.4
Inference
● The traffic movement varies through the zones
based on the activity and land uses.The
institutional zone has comparatively lesser traffic
movement than compared to zones having the
commercial use.
● The modal split of the vehicular movement is
dominated by the two wheelers followed by auto
rickshaws.
● The highest volume of traffic has been seen in
the zone five because of the presence of the
railway station,the padmanabaswamy temple
and the way through to NH66.
● The intersection has the highest PCU ranging to
Modal split of traffic 8189 thus it can be inferred that the traffic signal
can sufficiently handle the present traffic
volume.
3 wheeler 54 344 93 35 0 0 14 invalid 73 326 71 invalid 48 0 105 invalid 1163 22.96603 2326 Overbridge 6421.5
4 wheeler 21 303 56 28 0 0 9 invalid 117 315 38 invalid 39 16 69 invalid 1011 19.96445 1011
Flyover 6340.2
bus 0 57 0 0 0 0 0 invalid 52 88 0 invalid 0 0 0 invalid 197 3.890205 433.4
Ayurveda 5361.75
LCV 4 11 15 3 0 0 2 invalid 38 13 0 invalid 0 0 0 invalid 86 1.698262 120.4
11:00-12:0
Cycle 0 19 12 12 6 0 0 13 invalid 7 33 15 invalid 0 0 5 invalid 122 2.409163 48.8 Pullimodu 5803.35
Total 130 1357 554 105 0 0 56 0 427 1364 226 0 254 99 492 0 5064 100 5803.35
Statue 4125.6
Cantonment Police 3951.45
Zone 3 Spencer 5542.4
Street Name Street Name Street Name
modal Equivalen
split t PCU
VEHICLE SB SB SB SB WB WB WB WB NB NB NB NB (In
TYPE Right Thru Left U-turn Right Thru Left U-turn Right Thru Left U-turn Number) %
2 wheeler 234 323 invalid 181 invalid 401 345 158 244 invalid 280 119 2285 49.68471 1713.75
3 wheeler 77 178 invalid 58 invalid 261 141 82 123 invalid 156 139 1215 26.41879 2430
4 wheeler 61 128 invalid 41 invalid 233 100 40 110 invalid 138 78 929 20.20004 929
TOTAL 397 653 0 281 invalid 928 612 282 511 0 593 342 4599 100 5361.75
Methodology
Count the number of vehicles passing throught the
intersection in the various turning directions
Survey Results
Accommodation(till 2019)
Travel
Thiruvananthapuram City Other Distribution
Type
in 2018
Ayurvedic Centers 1 24
Homestays 8 51
Grihas-thali 0 0
RestHouse 1 7
GuestHouse 4 14
Travel
Yatri Nivas 2 1
Distribution
Resorts 3 185 in 2019
Serviced Villa 9 1
Hotels/Others 369 213
SOCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
● Health facilities and Education
● Parking facility : Parking space is a huge constraint
facilities: Residents prefer accessing
in the area. People park their vehicles in vacant land
private schools and hospitals situated at
available nearby or on roads.
a further distance rather than
government institutions available
nearby.
● Recreational facilities: there is lack of
recreational places like parks in the
area.
The nearest park and stadium are Graph : Satisfaction level with water facility
around 250 m from the site.
Picture 1 : zone 1
Residential converted to
homestays
Evolution:
● The area was a mixture of residential, commercial and
government offices.
● But now, number of commercial establishments are
increasing and number of Residences are decreasing. THAMPANOOR
● Big shops introduced 7 years ago. Till then small retailers along the
stretch. Kerala Vyapari Vyavasayi Ekopana Samithi
Issues: (KVVES)is claimed to be the single largest
trade organization in the world. It was formed in
● Profitability of retail business is in a decline over years, 12-13 Years 1980 to safeguard the interests of traders,
ago retail was profitable, now itʼs not. Small shops are getting closed businessmen and industrialists.
rapidly due to lack of business. Increasing number of abandoned
buildings both under construction and previously occupied.
● Large,franchisee retail shops affects the business of small shops.
Family customers go to big shops only, for example: Pothy's.
● Lack of proper infrastructure and utilities, Water supply isn't
continuous and is only available 6-7 hours a day. Pipelines are badly
maintained. Water supply isnʼt available at least 6 days in a month.
● Small lodges and hotels are in decline Small scale hospitality is in
● Lack of support to the small retailers from Government. Government decline
regulations make it difficult for them.
Future Perspective:
● The current commercial growth will continue but more and more
small retail shop will get closed and get replaced by big retailers
Addressing different stories on past development proposal:
● No issues were raised when widening happened the process was
handled well.
● Even bunk shops near padmanabhaswamy temple were given new Small retail is on the verge of collapse
shops.
● The claims that compensation wasnʼt provided are false.
Compensation was given to everyone
History:
● Earlier there was Travancore fort and its residents .
● Water logging were happening in the Eastfort area
during every monsoon because Manjalikum pond was
cleared for british army school.
Infrastructure:
● 90 % of residents uses pipe line and some uses bore
well
● Planned to have underground service line and got
cancelled because water logging issue THAMPANOOR
● Local people are depending Chala and Palayam ● Narcotics supplies near school
market and which reduces sales of small commercial surroundings
owners. ● No support from current ruling
● Restaurant and homestays are increasing because government
neighbouring railway station and Temple ● Less availability of parking
● Road redevelopment largely influencing property spaces
prices ● Some drains are not maintained WASTE MANAGEMENT POLLUTED DRAINAGE
Socio-economic characteristics:
● Most of the people are employed in government sector and
some are commercial shop owners
● Middle to higher income people are found in ward
Redevelopment:
● Mg road redevelopment not affected the school because its kept
enough distance from Road
WATER LOGGED AREA Spatial context
● Some land behind the school are encroached by people
Issues(School);;
● Cycle riders in the school are demanding cycle lines because of
heavy traffic
● Strength of school is getting lower because of its location
between big commercial,presence of surrounding school and
SMVHSS ,SCHOOL
poor infrastructure( especially for HS )prices