Factors Associated With Teenage Pregnancy in South Asia
Factors Associated With Teenage Pregnancy in South Asia
uk
Provided by Bournemouth University Research Online
1. MSc, MA, Project Assistant, Epidemiology Group, School of Medicine and Dentistry, Section of
Population Health, University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.
2. MSc, Institute of Applied Health Sciences, Department of Public Health, School of Medicine
and Dentistry, University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.
3. MBBS, Teaching Fellow, Section of Population Health, School of Medicine and Dentistry,
University of Aberdeen, Scotland, UK.
4. PhD, MEd, MA (Hons) Professor, Maternal & Perinatal Health Research, School of Health &
Social Care, Bournemouth University, England, UK.
5. MGenMed, MPH, Clinical Tutor & Honorary Public Health Lecturer, College of Life Sciences
and Medicine, Suttie Centre for Teaching and Learning, University of Aberdeen, Scotland,
UK.
Abstract
Background: South Asia has a large proportion of young people in the world and teenage
pregnancy has emerged as one of the major public health problem among them. The objective
of this study is to systematically review to identify the risk factors associated with teenage
pregnancy in South Asian countries.
Methods: We systematically searched MEDLINE, EMBASE and CINAHL database (1996 to April
2007) and web-based information. Inclusion criteria were the English-language papers available
in the UK and describing teenage pregnancy in South Asia.
Results: Out of the seven countries in South Asia, most of the studies were related to Nepal,
Bangladesh, India and Sri Lanka. Socio-economic factors, low educational attainment, cultural
and family structure were all consistently identified as risk factors for teenage pregnancy.
Majority of teenage girls are reported with basic knowledge on sexual health however, very few
of them have used the knowledge into practice. Both social and medical consequences of
teenage pregnancies are reported consistently along the most of the studies. Utilization of
health services, which is a protective factor, remains low and consistent. However, teenagers
agreed to delay the indexed pregnancy if they would know its consequences.
Conclusions: In South Asia, many risk factors are a part of socio-economic and cultural
influences. This systematic review is limited by the amount and the quality of papers published
on factors associated with teenage pregnancy. In particular, future research in South Asian
countries is needed with standardised measures and methodologies to gain an insight into
observed variations in pregnancy rates.
Corresponding author:
D. R. Acharya, Epidemiology Group, Section of
Population Health, Institute of Applied Health
Science, Foresterhill, University of Aberdeen,
Aberdeen AB25 2ZD, UK. Tel.: +44 01224 552968;
Fax +44 01224 550925; E-mail:
[email protected], [email protected]
Introduction
T
eenage pregnancy is a public health the attitudes of teenagers could be different
concern both in developed and from other parts of Asia. The objective of
developing world 1 , 2 , 3 . Globally 15 this systematic review is to identify young
million women under the age of 20 give people’s knowledge, attitude and behaviour,
birth, representing up to one-fifth of all risk factors, utilisation of health services and
births 4 and 529,000 women die due to consequences associated with teenage
pregnancy and child birth related pregnancy in South Asia.
complication every year 5 . The risk of death
due to pregnancy-related causes is double Materials and methods
among women aged 15-19 compared to The methodology of this review draws
women in their twenties 6 . Young women are from methods developed by NHS Centre for
also at risk of unwanted pregnancies, Reviews and Dissemination 22 . Three
sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and electronic bibliographic databases, MEDLINE,
unsatisfactory or coerced early sexual EMBASE, and CINAHL were searched
relationships 7 , 8 . systematically for the period 1996 to April,
In the developing world, one-third to 2007. Mesh terms and key words for young
one-half of women become mothers before people, teenage pregnancy and South Asia
the age of 20 and pregnancy related were combined with the Cochrane
complications have become the leading Collaboration strategy for identifying primary
causes of death among them 9 , 10 . South Asian studies. English-language papers available in
countries (India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Nepal, the UK and describing teenage pregnancy in
Maldives, Bhutan and Bangladesh) have high South Asia were retrieved and reviewed. The
proportions of teenage pregnancies, since MEDLINE search strategy was adapted for
early marriage is common and there is a searching other databases. Reference lists of
social expectation to have a child soon after all articles were checked to identify further
marriage 11 , 12 , 13 . A study showed that nearly relevant studies. Due to resource constrains
60% of all girls are married by the age of 18 searching of the grey literature and hand
years and one fourth are married by the age searching was not done.
of 15 years in South Asia 14 . Primary studies of any study design
Within South Asia, the recorded that looked at knowledge, attitudes,
teenage pregnancy rate is highest in consequences, risk factors and behaviour
Bangladesh 35% followed by Nepal 21% and associated with teenage pregnancy in South
India 21% 15 . Teenage pregnancy can have Asia were included. The term ‘factor’ does
significant effect on the level of education of not imply causality but only associations for
women, their employment opportunities and the purpose of this review. All identified
marital stability and it increases their abstracts were checked against the inclusion
economic and social dependency on family and exclusion criteria agreed a priori,
and neighbours 16 . Although teenagers independently by two reviewers. Any studies
represent a large proportion of population in with pregnancy (conception) as an outcome
the developing countries, still relatively measure were included; studies that only
little is known about their sexual knowledge used proxy outcome measures of pregnancy,
and experience and the risk associated with such as reproductive health or childbearing
the teenage pregnancy 17 , 18 , 19 . In recent (parenthood), were excluded. Any queries
years reviews have been conducted on about inclusion were discussed between
teenage pregnancies in developing countries reviewers or referred to a third reviewer if
or in ethnic minorities 20 , 21 but none of them necessary.
have specifically focused on South Asian Full texts of all the potentially
teenagers. This is a gap as there are cultural eligible reviews were obtained and critically
variations and differences and consequently appraised. A data extraction form was
Factors associated with teenage pregnancy in South Asia: a systematic review 4
pp:3-14
E-ISSN:1791-809X www.hsj.gr
developed and piloted. One reviewer become pregnant (p<0.001) than Buddhist
extracted data from identified studies and teenagers. Structural and social inequalities,
this was checked by the second reviewer. poverty and gender all made young people
Discrepancies were resolved by consensus or extremely vulnerable to teenage
arbitration. The following data were pregnancy28,32.
recorded: author; year of publication; type The likelihood of teenage pregnancy
of study; location; setting(s); age group; and childbearing seemed to be associated
sample size and methodology. All the with the level of education29. However, very
included studies were assessed for few studies have concentrated on education
methodological quality using assessment and teenage pregnancies. Sharma et al.,27 in
checklist 23 , 24 , 25 , however studies were not 2001 showed that among teenage mothers 13
rated or excluded on the basis of the overall (19%) were significantly less likely to have
quality rating. studied beyond primary school education
compared to among the mothers who were in
Results their twenties 4 (6%). This needs to be
Details of the search and study interpreted with caution as the numbers
selection results are shown on the flow chart reported are very low, however such
in Figure 1. A total of ten studies met all differences were also noted by Shrestha31 in
criteria and have been reviewed and a retrospective study (p<0.005) which had a
included in this paper. bigger sample size. Early age at marriage is
culturally acceptable in South Asian culture,
Overview of studies which seems to add the risk of teenage
Of the ten included articles, three pregnancy27. It is also taken as a licence or
studied the sexual health knowledge, social expectation for a woman to enter into
attitude and behaviour, nine studies looked reproductive life and to become pregnant
at risk factors of teenage pregnancy, three immediately after marriage. With mean age
discussed the utilisation of health services of marriage of 15.9 years in rural Nepal,
and nine studies examined the consequences some girls who married before the onset of
of teenage pregnancy. Of those studies, menarche fell pregnant once they were
three were conducted in Nepal, four in India, fertile31.
two in Sri Lanka and one in Bangladesh. Each Low involvement of teenage girls in
study has included more than one outcome decision making also contributed to early
and varied according to the settings such as; pregnancy. Most adolescent marriages (80%)
location, target group, method of data were arranged by parents without the girl’s
collection and analysis. The studies also consent31. A higher proportion of adolescent
varied according to the methodological pregnant women (67%) were found to be part
quality (Table 1). of an extended family, of which just over
half (51%) claimed that the authority over
Risk factors for teenage pregnancies in South conception remains with their husband27 in
Asia spite of the teenagers’ desire to make their
Socio-economic status, educational own decisions. The study also noted that
attainment, cultural factor and family teenage pregnant women seem to be more
structure were all identified as risk factors likely to have had love marriage (against the
for teenage pregnancies in South wishes of parents/family). Consequently, this
Asia 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 . Using a leads to negligence of family members
retrospective questionnaire, Shrestha31 towards care and guidance in teenage
demonstrated that the incidence of teenage pregnancies. In addition, teenage girls are
pregnancies is significantly higher in the also less likely to visit health service clinics
lower social classes (52%) than in the higher without their husband’s permission34. These
social classes (26%). This study also found family structures and social norms have
that Hindu teenagers are more likely to
Factors associated with teenage pregnancy in South Asia: a systematic review 5
pp:3-14
E-ISSN:1791-809X www.hsj.gr
reproductive health services could prevent languages), publication type (studies have
reproductive health problems of young been reported in grey literature) or not being
married couples 48 . Teenage girls need indexed in electronic international
information about local health services, and bibliographic databases.
at the same time they also want to be Thirdly, the included studies used a
assured that the confidentiality is variety of study designs, content and size
maintained at each step. and were of varying quality. This diverse
Although they have reasonable nature of studies made it difficult to explore
knowledge of contraceptive method, it is not variations between countries or between age
translated to behaviour. Our review shows groups, and to interpret and summarise key
that teenagers are not very familiar with findings. Some studies examined factors
consequences of teenage pregnancies. For associated with teenage pregnancy in
example, teenagers would have delayed the deprived inner-city areas, while some others
index pregnancy if they had known about its were conducted in hospital setting making
consequences. These factors should be taken the exploration of potential socio-economic
into consideration by teenage sexual health differences not possible.
policy makers and programme directors. In particular, future research in South
Thus, more practical, innovative, interesting Asian countries is needed with standardised
and effective human right-based measures and methodologies. It will help to
interventions should be designed, so that gain insight into observed variations in
teenagers could get direct benefit by pregnancy rates and ensure that new public
acquiring knowledge. health and sexual health interventions are
There are relatively fewer studies better designed and implemented. Funders
conducted in relation to teenage pregnancy of future research should also consider
in South Asia, although they comprise a supporting longitudinal studies to be able to
significant proportion of the total explore changes over time.
population. Firstly, this systematic review is
limited by the amount and the quality of
papers published focusing on factors
associated with teenage pregnancy carried
out in South Asia. One study has reported
that Hindu religion is associated with high
teenage pregnancy; however it did not
describe what major factors contributed to
create such scenario. More research is
needed to explore the impact of religion on
the risk of teenage pregnancy.
Secondly, most studies reporting
factors associated with teenage pregnancy
are related to Nepal, Bangladesh, India and
Sri Lanka. None of those studies were
conducted in Pakistan, the Maldives or
Bhutan, reducing the generalisability of
findings to the whole of South Asia. One
possible explanation for the lack of studies
from the latter countries is that teenage
pregnancy is not perceived as a public health
problem; hence not the focus of research.
Another reason could be bias in our search
strategy and databases, e.g. due to language
(perhaps studies have been reported in local
Factors associated with teenage pregnancy in South Asia: a systematic review 8
pp:3-14
E-ISSN:1791-809X www.hsj.gr
Possible references
identified from databases
N=111
Papers not relevant/duplicates and
not meeting inclusion criteria N=72
Brennan et al. Survey N= 19,300 Sampling method is Quantitative Survey with structure Urban and Risk factors &
2005 not clearly mentioned questionnaire Rural consequence of
community, teenage pregnancy
India
Goonewarden Prospective N =620 Quantitative Interview with pre-tested Hospital Attitude/behaviour,
e & cohort study 13-16 years = 95 questionnaire to the setting, Sri risk factors,
Deeyagaha 17-19 years = 250 participants Lanka consequences,
Waduge 2005 20-24 years = 275. utilisation of health
All the nulliparous mothers services mode of
aged less than 24 years in delivery
study period were included
Pathak et al. Survey N=151 Study area (village) Quantitative Pre-tested semi-structured Rural Prevalence of Iron,
2003 were randomly selected, and and questionnaire, clinical Community, Vit. A, & Iodine
all APM* were included in the experimental examination, and instrument India deficiencies among
study from selected village study assessment teenage pregnant
mothers and its
consequences
Sharma et al. Case-control N=140 Quantitative One to one interview with pre- Urban and Risk factors,
2002 study 13-19 years=70 tested questionnaire rural/Hospital knowledge &
20-29 years=70 setting, Nepal behaviours of
purposive & random teenage pregnant
woman
Shrestha 2002 Retrospective N =1,150 Quantitative Interview with pre-tested Rural Risk factors,
exploratory Below 19 yr=575, & qualitative structured questionnaires to community, knowledge, attitude,
study and 20 and above=575 the participants, key Nepal behaviour &
survey Two-stage cluster sampling informants consequence of
technique used teenage pregnancy
Ganatra & Survey N= 226 Married adolescents ≤ Quantitative Interview with structured Rural Risk factors, attitude,
Hirve 2002 20 years, 43 never married & qualitative questionnaire, group community, behaviour &
and separated ≤ 20 and 1491 discussion, key informants, India consequence of
married women >20 years, and in-depth interviews and teenage pregnancy
Clustered sampling use of hospital record
Sharma et al. Case-control N=140 Quantitative Interview with pre-tested Hospital Risk factors,
2001 study Adolescent =70 structured questionnaire and setting, Nepal consequences,
20-29 years=70 hospital delivery record utilisation of health
All primigravida adolescent services & mode of
were included in index group delivery
and control group were chosen
randomly
Khandait et Hospital N=46,443 Quantitative Observed the hospital records Hospital Risk factors &
al. 2000 record survey Sampling method is not clearly record consequence of
(retrospective mentioned setting, India teenage pregnancy
analysis)
Weerasekera Hospital Adolescent N=1600 Quantitative Information were recorded on Hospital Risk factors,
1997 record survey Over 20 yr N=14699 pre-designed data collection record utilisation of health
Sampling method was not forms setting, Sri services &
clearly mentioned Lanka consequences
teenage pregnancy
* APM= Adolescent Pregnant Mothers
Bibliography
11) Stone N., Ingham R., Simkhada P.
Knowledge of sexual health issues among
1) Lawlor DA., Shaw M. Teenage pregnancy unmarried young people in Nepal. Asia-
rates: high compared with where and Pacific Population Journal. 2003; 18: 33-
when? Journal of the Royal Society of 54.
Medicine.2004;97:121–123. 12) Mathur S., Mehta M., Malhotra A. Youth
2) Johnson M., Myors K., Langdon R. Coping reproductive health in Nepal: is
styles of pregnant adolescents. Public participation the answer? Engender
Health Nursing.2001;18: 24-32. Health, New York. 2004; Available from:
3) Chedraui P., Hidalgo L., Chavez M., http://catalog.icrw.org/docs/nepal_0104.pd
Glenda SM. Determinant factors in f, Accessed 12/02/08.
Ecuador related to pregnancy among 13) Adhikari R. Early marriage and
adolescents aged 15 or less. Journal of childbearing: risks and consequences.
Perinatal Medicine. 2004; 32: 337–341. World Health Organization, Geneva 2003;
4) WHO. Maternal mortality ratios and rates: Available from:
a tabulation of available information. http://apps.who.int/reproductive-
World Health Organisation (3rd edition), health/publications/towards_adulthood/7.p
Geneva. 1991; Unpublished report. df , Accessed 10/11/08.
5) WHO. Facts and figures form the World 14) Mehra S., Agrawal D. Adolescent health
Health Report 2005. World Health determinants for pregnancy and child
Organisation,Geneva. 2005; Available fro health outcomes among the urban poor.
m: http://www.who.int/whr/2005/media_ce Indian Pediatrics. 2004;41:137-45.
ntre/facts_en.pdf, Accessed 18/12/08. 15) The World Bank. Children and Youth. The
6) Population Reference Bureau. The World Bank, Washington DC. 2004;
World’s youth 2000. Population Reference Available from:
Bureau, Washington DC. 2000; Available f http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTCY/
rom:http://www.prb.org/pdf/WorldsYouth_ Data/20333440/YIN-SA.pdf, Accessed
Eng.pdf, Accessed 03/06/08. 22/08/08.
7) Singh S., Darroch JE. Adolescent 16) Kirby D., Coyle K. School-based programs
pregnancy and childbearing: levels and to reduce sexual risk-taking behaviour.
trends in developed countries. Family Children and Youth Services Review.
Planning Perspectives.2000;32:14-23. 1998;19 (5-6): 415-436.
8) Wight D., Henderson M., Raab G., 17) Hughes J., McCauley AP. Improving the
Abraham C., Buston K., Scott S., Hart G. fit: adolescents’ needs and future
Extent of regretted sexual intercourse programs for sexual reproductive health in
among young teenagers in Scotland: a developing countries. Studies in Family
cross sectional survey. British Medical Planning. 1998; 29:233-45.
Journal. 2000; 320:1243-44. 18) Oakley A., Fullerton D., Holland J.
9) UN. The right to reproductive and sexual Behavioural interventions for HIV/AIDS
health. United Nations Department of prevention. AIDS. 1995; 9: 479-86.
Public Information (DPI/1877). 1997; 19) NIMH. Methodological overview of a multi-
Available from: http://www.un.org/ site HIV prevention trial for populations at
ecosocdev/geninfo/women/womrepro.htm, risk for HIV. AIDS, National Institutes of
Accessed 06/04/06. Mental Health 11. 1997; (suppl.1):S1–
10) Viegas OA., Wiknsosastro G., Sahagun S11.
GH., Chaturachinda K., Ratnam SS. Safe 20) Christoffersen MN., Hussain MA. Teenage
childbirth needs more than medical pregnancies: consequences of poverty,
services. World Health Forum. 1992; 13: ethnic background and social conditions.
59-65. Social Forksnings Instituttet Denmark.
2008;Availablefrom:http://www.sfi.dk/grap
Factors associated with teenage pregnancy in South Asia: a systematic review 11
pp:3-14
E-ISSN:1791-809X www.hsj.gr