Modeling and Analysis of Shock Absorber Spring of A Two Wheeler Vehicle
Modeling and Analysis of Shock Absorber Spring of A Two Wheeler Vehicle
This bouncing process is repeated over and over, a little less each time, until the
up-and-down movement finally stops. If bouncing is allowed to go uncontrolled, it will not
only cause an uncomfortable ride but will make handling of the vehicle very difficult. The
design and material selection for spring in suspension system is very important. In this
project a shock absorber is modeled using Creo 6.0.
The materials used for spring are Stainless steel AISI 302, Inconel 718, Spring
steel ASTM A227, Beryllium copper ASTM B197. Comparison is done for four materials
to verify best material for spring of a Shock absorber. Also, the spring diameter has been
varied based on the results to check for scope of improved performance. The Structural
analysis is performed by considering loads, bike weight and single person, bike weight and
two persons.
i
Table of Contents Page No
Abstract Ⅴ
List of Figures Ⅷ
List of Tables Ⅹ
1. INTRODUCTION 1
1.1 Shock Absorber types 3
1.1.1 Elastomeric shock absorbers 3
1.1.2 Hydraulic Dashpot 3
1.1.3 Collapsing safety shock absorbers 4
1.1.4 Self compensating Hydraulic 4
1.1.5 Metal Spring 4
1.1.6 Air (Pneumatic) Spring 5
1.2 Approaches to Shock Absorbers 6
1.3 Applications 6
2. LITERATURE REVIEW 7
2.1 Specification of Problem 9
2.2 Problem Objective 9
3. MATERIALS USED FOR SPRING 10
3.1 Spring 10
3.2 Stainless steel 11
3.3 Inconel 12
3.4 Spring Steel 13
3.5 Beryllium Copper 14
4. MODELING OF SHOCK ABSORBER 16
4.1 Design 16
4.2 Introduction to Creo 16
4.3 Features of Creo 16
4.4 Modelling 17
4.4.1 Spring Calculations 17
4.4.2 Design of Piston Rod 18
ii
4.4.3 Design of Upper Mount 19
4.4.4 Design of Lower Mount 19
4.5 Assembly of Shock Absorber in Creo 20
5. ANSYS WORKBENCH 21
5.1 Overview of Ansys Workbench 21
5.1.1 Importing Files 21
5.1.2 Structural analysis 22
5.1.3 Exporting Materials 23
5.1.4 Geometry 23
5.1.5 Meshing 23
5.2 Structural Boundary Conditions 24
5.3 Loads/Supports/Conditions Enhancements 24
6. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF SHOCK ABSORBER 25
6.1 Load Calculations for analysis 25
6.2 Material used for spring is Stainless steel at a load of 654N 28
6.3 Material used for spring is Inconel at a load of 654N 29
6.4 Material used for spring is Spring steel at a load of 654N 30
6.5 Material used for spring is Beryllium Copper at a load of 654N 32
6.6 Wire diameter of spring 10mm 33
6.7 Material used for spring is Stainless steel at a load of 654N 33
6.8 Material used for spring is Inconel at a load of 654N 35
6.9 Material used for spring is Spring steel at a load of 654N 36
6.10 Material used for spring is Beryllium copper at a load of 654N 37
6.11 Results and discussions 39
CONCLUSIONS 45
REFERENCES 46
iii
List of figures Page. No
Fig 1.1 Shock Absorber 1
iv
Fig 6.14 Equivalent Stresses 31
v
List Of Tables Page. No
Table 3.1 Properties of Stainless Steel 12
vi
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Shock absorbers are a critical part of a suspension system, connecting the vehicle
to its wheels. The need for dampers arises because of the roll and pitches associated with
vehicle maneuvering, and from the roughness of roads. Shock absorbers are devices that
smooth out an impulse experienced by a vehicle, and appropriately dissipate or absorb the
kinetic energy. A safe vehicle must be able to stop and maneuver over a wide range of road
conditions. Good contact between the tires and the road will able to stop and maneuver
quickly. Suspension is the term given to the system of springs, shock absorbers and linkages
that connects a vehicle to its wheels. Shock absorber is an important part of automotive
suspension system which has an effect on ride characteristics. Shock absorbers are also
critical for tire to road contact which to reduce the tendency of a tire to lift off the road. This
affects braking, steering, cornering and overall stability.
1
over and over, a little less each time, until the up and-down movement finally stops. If
bouncing is allowed to go uncontrolled, it will not only cause an uncomfortable ride but will
make handling of the vehicle very difficult. So, the design of spring is important for the
rider’s safety.
Pneumatic and hydraulic shock absorbers commonly take the form of a cylinder with a
sliding piston inside. The cylinder is filled with a fluid (such as hydraulic fluid) or air. This
fluid-filled piston/cylinder combination is a dashpot. The shock absorbers duty is to absorb
or dissipate energy. These are an important part of automobile suspensions, aircraft landing
gear, and the supports for many industrial machines. Large shock absorbers have also been
used in structural engineering to reduce the susceptibility of structures to earthquake damage
and resonance. A transverse mounted shock absorber, called a yaw damper, helps keep
railcars from swaying excessively from side to side and are important in commuter railroads
and rapid transit systems because they prevent railcars from damage station platforms. In a
vehicle, it reduces the effect of traveling over rough ground, leading to improved ride
quality, and increase comfort due to substantially reduced amplitude of disturbances.
Without shock absorbers, the vehicle would have a bouncing ride, as energy is stored in the
spring and then released to the vehicle, possibly exceeding the allowed range of suspension
movement.
2
1.1 Shock Absorber Types
There are a number of different methods of converting an impact /collision into relatively
smooth cushioned contact.
• Rubber Buffer
• Elastomeric shock absorbers
• Hydraulic Dashpot
• Collapsing safety Shock Absorbers
• Self compensating Hydraulic
• Metal Spring
• Pneumatic Springs
1.1.1 Elastomeric shock absorbers
These are low cost options for reducing the collision speed and reducing the shock
loading and providing system damping. They are conveniently moulded to suitable shapes.
These devices have high stopping forces at end of stroke with significant internal damping.
Elastomeric dampers are very widely used because of the associated advantages of low cost
and mouldability together with performance benefits. The inherent damping of elastomers
is useful in preventing excessive vibration amplitude at resonance – much reduced
compared to metal springs. However elastomeric based shock absorbers are limited in being
affected by high and low temperatures. And are subject to chemical attack.
This type of shock absorber is based on a simple hydraulic cylinder. As the piston
rod is moved hydraulic fluid is forced through an orifice which restricts flow and
consequently provides a controlled resistance to movement of the piston rod.
3
Fig1.3 Hydraulic dash pot
With only one metering orifice the moving load is abruptly slowed down at the
start of the stroke. The braking force rises to a very high peak at the start of the stroke and
then falls away rapidly. On completion of the stroke the system is stable - the energy being
dissipated in the hydraulic fluid as heat. This type of shock absorbers are provided with
Springs sufficient to return the actuator to its initial position after the impacting load is
removed.
These are single use units which are generally specially designed for specific duties.
They are designed such that at impact they collapse and the impact energy is absorbed as
the materials distort in their inelastic/yield range. They therefore are more compact
compared to devices based on deflections within their elastic range.
These devices are similar to the hydraulic dashpot type except that a number of
orifices are provided allowing different degrees of restriction throughout the stroke. These
devices are engineered to bring the moving load is smoothly and gently to rest by a constant
resisting force throughout the entire shock absorber stroke. The load is decelerated with the
lowest possible force in the shortest possible time eliminating damaging force peaks and
shock damage to machines and equipment. These type of shock absorbers are provided with
springs sufficient to return the actuator to its initial position after the impacting load is
removed.
4
stopping forces at end of stroke. Metal springs store energy rather than dissipating it. If
metal sprint type shock absorbers are used then measures should be provided to limit
Oscillations. Metal springs are often used with viscous dampers. There are a number of
different types of metal springs including helical springs, bevel washers(cone-springs), leaf
springs, ring springs, mesh springs etc etc. Each spring type has its own operating
characteristics.
Air (Pneumatic) spring These devices use air as the resilient medium. Air has a
high energy storage capacity compared to metal or elastomer materials. For duties with
high loads and deflections the air spring is generally far more compact that the equivalent
metal or elastomer device. Due to the compressibility of air these have a sharply rising
force characteristic towards the end of the stroke. The majority of the energy is absorbed
near the end of the stroke. Air springs require more maintenance than meal or elastomer-
based springs and the temperature range is restricted compared to metal springs.
These devices use air as the resilient medium. Air has a high energy storage
capacity compared to metal or elastomer materials. For duties with high loads and
deflections the air spring is generally far more compact that the equivalent metal or
elastomer device. Due to the compressibility of air these have a sharply rising force
characteristic towards the end of the stroke. The majority of the energy is absorbed near the
end of the stroke. The force on an air cylinder buffer is determined by the relationship
PV^n= constant. Air springs require more maintenance than meal or elastomer-based
springs and the temperature range is restricted compared to metal spring.
5
1.3 Approaches to shock absorption
• Compression of a gas, for example pneumatic shock absorbers, which can act like
springs as the air pressure is building to resist the force on it. Once the air pressure
reaches the necessary maximum, air dashpots will act like hydraulic dashpots. In
aircraft landing gear air dashpots may be combined with hydraulic damping to reduce
bounce. Such struts are called oleo struts (combining oil and air).
• Magnetic effects. Eddy current dampers are dashpots that are constructed out of a large
magnet inside of a non-magnetic, electrically conductive tube.
• Conventional shock absorbers combined with composite pneumatic springs with which
allow ride height adjustment or even ride height control, seen in some large trucks and
luxury sedans such as certain Lincoln and most Land Rover automobiles. Ride height
control is especially desirable in highway vehicles intended for occasional rough road
use, as a means of improving handling and reducing aerodynamic drag by lowering the
vehicle when operating on improved high speed roads.
• The heavier the object or the faster it travels, the more energy it has. Methods of energy
absorption include rubber buffers, metal springs, air springs, and hydraulic shock
absorbers. When the systems have to continuously operate under the influence of shock
loads the shock isolation system generally includes spring-dashpot isolation systems.
For simple shock absorber applications required to mitigate the effect of a single events
then viscous dampers which dissipate the energy, as heat rise of a fluid, are often
preferred. In normal everyday life simple examples of shock absorber systems include
crash helmets, steel toe caps in industrial boots, collapsible bumpers on cars, motor way
barriers.
1.4 Applications:
Shock absorbers are an important part of automobile and motorcycle suspensions,
aircraft landing gear, and the supports for many industrial machines. Large shock absorbers
have also been used in structural engineering to reduce the susceptibility of structures to
earthquake damage and resonance. A transverse mounted shock absorber, called a yaw
damper, helps keep railcars from swaying excessively from side to side and are important
in passenger railroads.
6
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
For providing the best design of spring coil to the suspension system of two-
wheeler vehicles. A lot of technical papers and reduction processes were studied before
deciding upon the most feasible process for project. The following list presents a list of the
main papers referred to, throughout the duration of the project.
N. Lavanya The present work is optimum design and analysis of a suspension spring for
motor vehicle subjected to static analysis of helical spring the work shows the strain and
strain response of spring behaviour will be observed under prescribed or expected loads
and the induced stress and strains values for low carbon structural steel is less compared to
chrome vanadium material also it enhances the cyclic fatigue of helical spring.
Kartik A. S. at el studied the shock absorbers for automobile of capacity 150cc by varying
material for spring using NX UNIGRAPHICS 10. They then compare the models by
analysing structural and modal analysis of the models of Structural Steel, Titanium alloy,
Copper alloy and Aluminium alloy material on ANSYS 14.5. They considered the loads,
bike weight with single person and 2 persons for the analysis.
Rahul Tekade and ChinmayPatil, designed a shock absorber to improve the comfort and
safety of the passengers of the vehicle and also sustain the vibrations. They performed the
structural and modal analysis of the shock absorber of the vehicle. They concluded that for
the spring ASTM A228 (high carbon spring wire) will provide optimum results.
Jerome Christopher J. and Pavendhan R., designed and performed analysis of Shock
Absorber performance by varying diameter of the coil spring. By considering bike mass,
loads, and number of persons seated on a bike, comparison is done to verify best dimension
of spring in the shock absorber. They used ProE and ANSYS for the modelling and analysis
respectively.
7
In a project by Mr. A.C. Basha, a Shock Absorber was selected and analyzed by changing
the materials for the springs by Structural analysis alone and the results were presented.
Vijayeshwar BV. et al. In this research paper they evaluated the manufacturing of helical
coil suspension springs as per requirement. The objective of this work is a comparative study
and analysis of suspension helical coil spring with two different materials like Chrome
Silicon and Hard drawn carbon steel. They designed the shock absorber model using solid
works and analysis of stress and deflection they used ANSYS 15.0. After the theoretical and
ANSYS results shows that Chrome silicon spring steel is the optimum suitable material with
low weight and high stiffness for helical spring applications like mono shock suspensions in
bikes and many more.
N. Sai Kumar and Prof. R. Vijay Prakash in this research paper they have design and analyze
the performance of the shock absorber by varying the wire diameter of the coil spring. They
explain all types of shock absorber properties and using metal spring wire. They consider
various types of motorbike spring specification and modeling of suspension springs. They
used alloy steel. Chrome vanadium steel of spring materials. They determine the analysis of
maximum shear stress, maximum principal stress, normal stress, strain, maximum principle
strain, normal strain, total deformation are noted. The results of alloy steel are showing the
best results in three vehicles (Among there for Yamaha alloy steel got the least stress). The
alloy steel is preferable compared to chrome vanadium steel.
Suraj R. Bhosle et al. In this research paper the comparative study of suspension helical coil
spring with different materials using finite element analysis. They create the shock absorber
model in Creo Parametric 2.0 and structural analysis of the same is done using ANSYS 17.0.
The comparative study shows the optimum material to be used for the spring by proper
analysis of the deflection and stresses of the helical spring. They used four different material
of spring are Chrome vanadium, Hard drawn spring wire, steel, Oil tempered carbon steel
and Stainless steel. After the analysis the chrome vanadium stands out to be efficient
material for spring especially at higher loads.
8
2.1 Specification of the Problem
Past research data and studies had shown that there are number of materials that
are used to manufacture springs for two-wheeler shock absorbers or suspension systems by
different manufacturing industries in India and abroad. Different researches that have been
conducted show different materials as the best material for manufacturing springs for two-
wheeler shock absorbers. We have taken four such materials for analysis which were
considered as best materials for manufacturing springs for two-wheeler shock absorbers.
We aim to find the best material among the four by comparing deformations, stresses and
factor of safety produced in each material.
The important problem that is faced by the automotive industry is that the vehicle
handling becomes difficult and leads to uncomfortable ride when spring bouncing is
uncontrolled. This is based on a number of parameters such as load applied and the duration
of it. Therefore, the existing material is stainless steel, the main problem is developed more
stresses, deformations, finally change the material find out the stress, deformation, and
which material is suitable for shock absorber spring selected based on Ansys results.
• Analyze a two-wheeler shock absorber spring to find out the deformations and stresses
produced in the shock absorber.
• CAD model of a two-wheeler suspension system will be created in CREO 6.0 and the
FEA analysis is done to determine the deformations and stresses produced under
different loading conditions using Finite Element Analysis software (ANSYS).
• In this project the existing diameter of spring is 8mm it will be designed and analysis is
performed on this design. Analysis is also performed on the spring by increasing the
diameter by 2mm.
• To find out the best material for a two-wheeler suspension system among the
four materials such that deformation and stress produced in it are minimum under
identical loading conditions.
9
CHAPTER-3
MATERIALS USED FOR SPRING
3.1 Spring
A coil spring is a mechanical device which is typically used to store energy and
subsequently release it, to absorb shock, or to maintain a force between contacting surfaces.
They are made of an elastic material formed into the shape of a helix which returns to its
natural length when unloaded. Under tension or compression, the material (wire) of a coil
spring undergoes torsion.
Coil springs are commonly used in vehicle suspension. These springs are
compression springs and can differ greatly in strength and in size depending on application.
A coil spring suspension can be stiff to soft depending on the vehicle it is used on. Coil
spring can be either mounted with a shock absorber or mounted separately. Coil springs in
trucks allow them to ride smoothly when unloaded and once loaded the spring compresses
and becomes stiff. This allows the vehicle to bounce less when loaded. Coil spring
suspension is also used high performance cars so that the car can absorb bumps and have
low body roll. In off-road vehicles they are used because of their range of travel they allow
at the wheel. Coil springs used in the engine are compression springs and play an important
role in closing the valves that feed air and let exhaust gasses out of the combustion chamber.
Springs are also mainly used in shock absorbers. The spring is attached to a rocker that is
connected to the valve.
Tension and extension coil springs of a given material, wire diameter and coil
diameter exert the same force when fully loaded; increased number of coils merely (linearly)
increases free length and compressed/extended length.
Metal coil springs are made by winding a wire around a shaped former – a cylinder
is used to form cylindrical coil springs. Coil springs for vehicles are typically made
of hardened steel and stainless steel. A machine called an auto-coiler takes spring wire that
has been heated so it can easily be shaped. It is then fed onto a lathe that has a metal rod
with the desired coil spring size. The machine takes the wire and guides it onto the spinning
rod as well as pushing it across the rod to form multiple coils. The spring is then ejected
10
from the machine and an operator will put it in oil to cool off. The spring is then tempered to
lose the brittleness from being cooled. The coil size and strength can be controlled by the
lathe rod size and material used. Different alloys are used to get certain characteristics out
of the spring, such as stiffness, dampening and strength.
Stainless Steel
Spring steel
Inconel
Beryllium copper
11
Table 3.1 properties of Stainless Steel
Cr = 17-19 %, Ni = 8-10%
Elongation 55%
The material is then fabricated in its most malleable condition. After fabrication, it can be
heat treated as required per the applicable specification.
12
Table 3.2 Properties of Inconel 718
Elongation 12%
Spring steels feature a tensile strength and fatigue strength favorable for the
application, a high elongation at fracture and area reduction at fracture and are particularly
elastic. They can be bent up to the elastic limit and return to their original position after the
load is removed without being permanently deformed. The high elastic limit is achieved by
a special alloy containing silicon, manganese, chrome, vanadium, molybdenum and nickel.
The tensile strength is obtained by the final heat treatment.
2. Work hardening
13
to relieve its stresses and ensure that it does not become brittle. This process is commonly
used to produce items such as flat springs and saw blades.
Work hardening
Work hardening, on the other hand, increases the tensile strength of the material by
rolling it and reducing its thickness. This process is used to create spring steel sheets, strips,
rods, and bars.
Elongation 12%
Beryllium copper is a ductile, weldable, and machinable alloy. Like pure copper,
it is resistant to non-oxidizing acids like hydrochloric acid and carbonic acid, to plastic
decomposition products, to abrasive wear, and to galling. It can be heat treated for increased
strength, durability, and electrical conductivity. Beryllium copper attains the greatest
strength (to 1,400 MPa of any copper-based alloy). It has good thermal conductivity. 3-5
times more than tool steel. It has a solid melting point of 1590 °F (866 °C)and 1800 °F (982
°C) liquid melting point. It has an excellent capacity for being hot formed.
14
Table 3.4 Properties of Beryllium Copper
Cu= 98%, Be= 2%
Elongation 12%
15
CHAPTER 4
MODELING OF SHOCK ABSORBER
4.1 Design
CAD software for mechanical design uses either vector-based graphics to depict the
objects of traditional drafting, or may also produce raster graphics showing the overall
appearance of designed objects. However, it involves more than just shapes. As in the
manual drafting of technical and engineering drawings, the output of CAD must convey
information, such as materials, processes, dimensions, and tolerances, according to
application- specific conventions.
Creo runs on Microsoft Windows and provides apps for 3D CAD parametric
feature solid modeling, 3D direct modeling, 2D orthographic views, Finite Element
Analysis and simulation, schematic design, technical illustrations, and viewing and
visualization. Creo can also be paired with Mastercam (Machining based software) to
machine any designed model in a minimal timeframe, Creo has increased the rate of rapid
prototyping in the industry tremendously.
Creo contains many features that facilitate the engineers to easily create and manage
designs. Some of the important features of Creo are as follows
16
4.3.1 Parametric:
The dimensions and relations used to create a feature are captured and stored in the model.
This enables not only to capture your design intent, but also to quickly and make changes
to the model in the revolved body. Whole size is reduced parametrically since all the circles
are driven by relation and dimension. A change in one hole reflects the others.
A solid model is the most complete type of geometry model used in CAD systems.
It contains all the wire frame and surface geometry necessary. To fully describe the edges
and the faces of the model.
4.3.3 Constraints
4.4 Modeling
The below diagram represents the designing procedure of spring using Creo
design tool. Select the helical sweep command and select a front plane and draw a line in
17
downward direction of 230mm and the distance from the center line is 25mm. select sketch
draw a circle with diameter of 8mm. click on ok. Then the required spring will be obtained.
The above piston rod is modeled by selecting a front plane and sketch. Draw
a circle of 10mm and extrude by a length of 90mm.
18
4.4.3 Modeling of Upper Mount
19
Select a front plane and draw a circle of 50mm diameter and extrude it to a depth of
3.50mm. On the plane of circle select the circle command and 28mm of outer diameter,
26mm as inner diameter and extrude to a length of 128mm. Now, on the other side of the
construct a circle of 28mm. Select the right plane and take the reference line where a circle
is constructed of 28mm diameter and the inner diameter is 12mm.Extrude it to a depth of
20mm.
20
CHAPTER 5
ANSYS WORKBENCH
When working in ANSYS Workbench, there is a need to import files, such as input
files, existing mesh files, geometries, etc. When you edit an imported file, ANSYS
Workbench saves a copy of the file to the project directory, rather than overwriting the
original file. This process ensures that your original files are never compromised. Most files
from previous releases can be imported using File> Import. The import operation will create
systems, cells, and links to represent the previous release project. For more information on
importing legacy databases, see Importing Legacy Databases.
21
5.1.2 Structural Analysis
The Structural template defines a basic structural simulation process that can be
used to simulate and evaluate the displacements, stresses, strains, and forces in structures or
components caused by loads that do not induce significant inertia and damping effects.
Before you create the simulation process, the options in this template are:
Physics:
• Select Structural and thermal when you want to model situations where the
temperature field introduces thermal strains in the structural field, which, in turn result in
thermal expansion and stresses.
• Select Structural and electric conduction when your simulation requires structural
and electric conduction loads on a system or component.
• Select Structural, thermal, and electric conduction when you need to model
situations where electric effects create thermal effects, and where thermal effects cause
structural strains and deformation.
Material Assignment You can export a material for use in another project. Exporting
materials is only supported for files. Follow the procedure below:
2. Click the library icon to show the source information of the material which includes the
library name, material name, and library location.
22
5.1.4 Geometry
5.1.5 Meshing
ANSYS provides meshing capabilities for various geometric models. When the
imported geometry represents a structural region (or solid part), or when the imported
geometry represents a fluid region (or fluid flow volume), use part-based meshing to create
a mesh. Part-based meshing can be used to create separate meshes for fluid regions and
structural regions when you import multiple geometry files. When the imported geometry
represents solid parts and a flow volume needs to be extracted, use a volume creation task,
along with flow volume meshing, to create a mesh. In this case, meshing the flow volume
involves identifying the location of the flow volume, generating a surface wrap mesh for
the extracted volume, and then meshing the volume itself. When the imported geometry
represents multiple solid parts that you want to unite to create a single flow region, or to
simplify a body with many surface patches, use a volume creation task to simplify the
geometry and generate the surface mesh, and then use flow volume meshing to create the
volume mesh.
23
5.2 Structural Boundary Conditions
• Rotating Force.
The new Rotating Force boundary condition is available for Harmonic Response
analyses using the Full Solution Method option. This boundary condition enables you to
create forces that rotate synchronously or asynchronously.
• Nodal Force.
Harmonic Response and Transient Structural analyses that use a linked Modal
Analysis System now support the Nodal Force boundary condition.
24
CHAPTER 6
The Static Structural analysis is performed on the shock absorber by applying two
different types of loads weight of bike and one person, weight of bike and two weight
persons. To find the stresses and deformation formed on the shock absorber. The spring
material is varied by using four different kinds of materials stainless steel, Inconel, Spring
Steel, beryllium Copper. The loads are applied on the top mount of shock absorber and the
fixed support is placed at the bottom mount. Load is applied the z-direction.
25
• Click on ANSYS workbench tool.
26
APPLY MESH
27
6.2 Material used for spring is stainless steel AISI 302 at a load of
654N (weight of bike and one person)(8mm)
6.2.1 Material Used for spring is Stainless Steel AISI 302 at a load of
893N (weight of bike and two persons)
28
Fig 6.7 Total Deformation
6.3 Material Used for spring is Inconel 718 at a load of 654N (weight of
bike and one person)
29
6.3.1 Material Used for spring is Inconel 718 at a load of 893N (weight of
bike and two persons)
6.4 Material Used for spring is Spring Steel ASTM A227 at a load of 654N
(weight of bike and one person)
30
Fig 6.13 Total deformation
6.4.1 Material Used for spring is Spring Steel ASTM A227 at a load of
893N (weight of bike and two persons)
31
6.5 Material Used for spring is Beryllium Copper ASTM B197 at a load
of 654N (weight of bike and one person)
32
Fig 6.19 Total deformation
6.7 Material Used for spring is Stainless Steel AISI 302 at a load of 654N
(weight of bike and one person)
33
Fig 6.21 Total deformation
6.7.1 Material Used for spring is Stainless Steel AISI 302 at a load of
893N (weight of bike and two persons)
34
6.8 Material Used for spring is Inconel 718 at a load of 654N (weight of
bike and one person)
6.8.1 Material Used for spring is Inconel 718 at a load of 893N (weight of
bike and two persons)
35
Fig 6.27 Total deformation
6.9 Material Used for spring is Spring steel ASTM A227 at a load of
654N (weight of bike and one person)
36
6.9.1 Material Used for spring is Spring steel ASTM A227at a load of
893N (weight of bike and two persons)
6.10 Material Used for spring is Beryllium Copper ASTM B197 at a load
of 654N (weight of bike and one person)
37
Fig 6.33 Total deformation
6.10.1 Material Used for spring is Beryllium Copper ASTM B197 at a load
of 893N (weight of bike and two persons)
38
6.11 RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
The Equivalent stresses and total deformation of four materials are tabulated in the
below table 6.1
Existing Diameter of spring 8mm
Table 6.1 Analysis Results of 8mm spring diameter
Materials Load Applied(N) Maximum Maximum Total
(Weight of bike and Equivalent Stress Deformation(mm)
one person (von misses)
& (Mpa)
Weight of bike and
two person)
350
345
340
335
330
325
320
Stainless steel AISI 302 inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM Beryllium copper ASTM
A227 B197
Materials
39
Total deformation at 654N load
30
Total deformation(mm)
25
20
15
10
5
0
Stainless steel AISI 302 Inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM beryllium copper
A227 ASTM B197
Materials
470
465
460
455
450
445
440
Stainless steel AISI 302 Inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM A227 beryllium Copper ASTM
B197
Materials
40
Total Deformation at 893N load
40
35
Total Deformation(mm) 30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Stainless Steel AISI 302 Inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM A227 Beryllium Copper ASTM
B197
Materials
On comparing the stress and total deformation for a applied load of 893N.The
minimum stress and deformation values are observed in spring steel ASTM A227.
41
Diameter of spring: 10mm
The Equivalent stresses and total deformation of four materials are tabulated in
the below table 6.2
220
Stresses(Mpa)
210
200
190
180
stainless steel AISI inconel 718 spring steel ASTM breyllium copper
302 A227 ASTM B197
Materials
42
Total Deformation at a load of 654N
12
Total Deformation(mm)
10
8
6
4
2
0
stainless steel AISI inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM Beryllium Copper
302 A227 ASTM B197
Materials
The figures 7.5 and 7.6 shows the stresses produced and total deformation
for the applied load of weight of bike and one person of 654N and 10mm spring
diameter. The stresses and deformations are maximum in Inconel 718 and Beryllium
Copper ASTM B197. Maximum stress and deformation in beryllium copper ASTM
B197 is 214.86 and 11.19, Spring steel ASTM A227 has lower stresses and
deformation i.e., 330.03 and 17.653 when compared to other materials.
280
275
270
265
260
255
250
stainless steel AISI inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM Beryllium copper
302 A227 ASTM B197
Materials
43
Total Deformation at 893N load
18
Total Deformation(mm)
16
14
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
stainless steel AISI 302 Inconel 718 Spring steel ASTM Beryllium Copper
A227 ASTM B197
Materials
The Fig 6.7 and Fig 6.8 are the graphs plotted for the wire diameter of 10mm
spring. In which the values of stress and total deformation are 271.08Mpa and 9.9113mm
for spring steel ASTM A227 are lower when compared to materials of stainless steel
AISI 302, Inconel 718, Beryllium Copper ASTM B197.
44
CONCLUSIONS
• The Spring material is varied by four types of materials by applying two different loads
of 654N and 893N. By comparing the stresses and total deformation in the spring. The
spring material is proposed.
• For spring diameter of 8mm, Spring steel ASTM A227 has lower stress and total
deformation of 450.63Mpa and 24.104mm at a load of 893N. When compared to the
materials of stainless steel AISI 302, Inconel 718, Beryllium Copper ASTM B197. So,
the spring steel ASTM A227 is proposed as the best material for spring.
• From the analysis results, it is observed that the spring with 10mm wire diameter made
with Spring steel ASTM A227 at a load of 893N results in less stress value 271.08Mpa
and less total deformation 9.9113mm. when compared to spring with 8mm wire
diameter made of stainless steel AISI 302, Inconel 718, Beryllium Copper ASTM
B197.
• As per the above values observed, wire diameter of spring with 10mm and material for
spring as spring steel ASTM A227 is found to be a better choice for the spring of the
shock absorber as when compared to the existing model.
45
REFERENCES
1. Mr. A. Chinnamahammad Basha, Mr. Vijay Rami Reddy, “DESIGN AND ANALYSIS
OF SHOCK ABSORBER” IRJET - International Research Journal of Engineering and
Technology, Jan-2017, Volume: 4, Issue: 1, pp 201 – 207.
2. Akshat Jain,SheelamMisra, Arun Jindal, Prateek Lakhian (2017) “Structural Analysis
of Compression Helical Spring Used in Suspension System, AIP,Vol.3”.
3. Gajendra Singh Rathore and Upendra Kumar Joshi, “Fatigue Stress analysis of helical
Compression Spring: A Review”, International Journal of Emerging Trends in
Engineering and Development, ISSN: 2249-6149, Volume: 2, Issue: 3, pp. 512-520,
May 2013.
4. Singh Pankaj, Amilkanthwar Rushikesh, Walli Sanket, Jasoliya Viraj, Patel Kaushal
(2017) “Design and analysis of helical compression spring used in suspension system
by finite element analysis method” IRJET, Vol.6.
5. Mr. SudarshanMartande, Mr. Y. N. Jangale, Mr. N. S. Motagi, March 2013, “Design
and Analysis of Shock Absorber”, International Journal of Application or Innovation in
Engineering and Management (IJAIEM), Volume 2, Issue 3, pp. 197-199.
6. Design and analysis of two wheeler vehicles rear shock absorber by using composite E
glass Epoxy material” by Mr. Marnish Modi, Mr.Saleha Shaikh and Mr.A.N.Shayani
IJEISR,Vol.1 (1)-P.P-01-06 ISSN: 2395-6372, 2015.
7. Brita Pyttel, K K Ray, Isabell Brunner, Abhishek Tiwari, S. A. Kaoua. “Investigation of
probable failure position in helical compression springs used in fuel injection system of
diesel engines”, IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil Engineering (IOSRJMCE)
ISSN: 2278-1684 Volume 2, Issue 3 (Sep-Oct. 2012), PP 24-29.
8. Atul.M, Pungal, Prof.Bhosale.K.C(2018) “Comparative analysis of two wheeler
suspension helical compression spring for steel and composite material at different
loading conditions, IRJET,Vol.5”.
9. Adhith Kumaar SB, Displacement and Stress Analysis of Suspension Systems using
ANSYS, International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT), ISSN:
2278-0181, Vol. 7 Issue 03, March-2018.
46