fred

TRIZ Contradiction Matrix for finding promising Inventive Principles www.triz.co.uk

✘ Space ✘ Time ✘ Condition ✘ Alternate ✘ Scale ✘ Inverse List Half Selector Source Selector
Top Bottom Matrix All

Improving Parameter Undesirable Result Inventive Identified Inventive Principles

what do we want to make better? what gets worse as a result? principles Hits ID Description
02 Weight of stationary object 14 Strength 28 2 10 27 1. 1. 4 27 Cheap Short-Living Objects

2. 2. 3 1 Segmentation

3. 3. 3 24 Intermediary

4. 4. 3 40 Composite Materials

5. 5. 2 2 Taking Out

6. 6. 2 3 Local Quality

7. 7. 2 6 Universality

8. 8. 2 7 Nested Doll

9. 9. 2 10 Prior Action space

10. 10. 2 13 The Other Way Round selected
11. 11. 2 22 Blessing in Disguise value
12. 12. 2 26 Copying hits
13. 13. 2 28 Replace Mechanical System
Principle 1: Segmentation 14. 14. 2 29 Pneumatics and Hydraulics ###
15. 15. 1 4 Asymmetry ###
a. Divide an object into independent parts.
16. 16. 1 5 Merging ###
17. 17. 1 8 Anti-Weight ###
b. Make an object sectional.
18. 18. 1 9 Prior Counteraction ###
19. 19. 1 11 Cushion in Advance ###
c. Increase the degree of an object's segmentation.
20. 20. 1 12 Equipotentiality ###
21. 21. 1 14 Spheroidality - Curvature ###
22. 22. 1 15 Dynamics ###
23. 23. 1 16 Partial or Excessive Action ###
24. 24. 1 17 Another Dimension ###

###
 1 Weight of moving object 01 Weight of moving object
2 Weight of stationary object 02 Weight of stationary object
3 Length of moving object 03 Length of moving object
4 Length of stationary object 04 Length of stationary object
5 Area of moving object 05 Area of moving object
6 Area of stationary object 06 Area of stationary object
7 Volume of moving object 07 Volume of moving object
8 Volume of stationary object 08 Volume of stationary object
9 Speed 09 Speed
10 Force (Intensity) 10 Force (Intensity)
11 Stress or pressure 11 Stress or pressure
12 Shape 12 Shape
13 Stability of the object's composition 13 Stability of the object's composition
14 Strength 14 Strength
15 Duration of Action of Moving Object 15 Duration of Action of Moving Object
16 Duration of Action of Stationary Object 16 Duration of Action of Stationary Object
17 Temperature 17 Temperature
18 Illumination intensity 18 Illumination intensity
19 Use of Energy by moving object 19 Use of Energy by moving object
20 Use of Energy by stationary object 20 Use of Energy by stationary object
21 Power 21 Power
22 Loss of energy 22 Loss of energy
23 Loss of substance 23 Loss of substance
24 Loss of information 24 Loss of information
25 Loss of time 25 Loss of time
26 Quantity of substance 26 Quantity of substance
27 Reliability 27 Reliability
28 Measurement Accuracy 28 Measurement Accuracy
29 Manufacturing Precision 29 Manufacturing Precision
30 Object Affected Harmful factors 30 Object Affected Harmful factors
31 Object-Generated Harmful Factors 31 Object-Generated Harmful Factors
32 Ease of Manufacture 32 Ease of Manufacture
33 Convenience of Use 33 Convenience of Use
34 Ease of Repair 34 Ease of Repair
35 Adaptability or Versatility 35 Adaptability or Versatility
36 Device Complexity 36 Device Complexity
37 Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring 37 Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring
38 Extent of Automation 38 Extent of Automation
39 Productivity 39 Productivity
 a b
1 Segmentation Divide an object into Make an object sectional.
independent parts.
2 Taking Out Extract (remove or separate) a Extract only the necessary part
"disturbing" part or property or property.
from an object.
3 Local Quality Provide transition from a Have different parts of an
homogenous structure of an object carry out different
object or outside environment functions.
(outside action) to a
heterogeneous structure.

4 Asymmetry Replace a symmetrical form If an object is already

with an asymmetrical form of asymmetrical, increase the
the object. degree of asymmetry.

5 Merging Combine in space Combine in time homogeneous

homogeneous objects or objects or contiguous operations.
destined for contiguous
operations.

6 Universality Have the object perform multiple

functions, thereby eliminating
the need for other objects.

7 Nested Doll Contain an object inside An object passes through a

another, which in turn is placed cavity in another object.
inside another object.
8 Anti-Weight Compensate for the object's Compensate for the object's
weight by joining with another weight by providing
object that has lifting force. aerodynamic or hydrodynamic
forces.

9 Prior Counteraction If it is necessary to carry out If an object must be in tension,

some action, consider a provide anti-tension in
counteraction in advance. advance.

10 Prior Action Carry out the required action in Arrange objects so that they
advance, in full or in part. can go into action, without time
loss while waiting for the action
(and from the most convenient
position)

11 Cushion in Advance Compensate for the relatively

low reliability of an object by
countermeasures taken in
advance.

12 Equipotentiality Change the condition of work so

that an object need not be
raised or lowered.
13 The Other Way Round Instead of an action dictated by Make object a moving part, or
the specifications of the make non-moving part
problem, implement an opposite moveable and outside
action. environment immovable.

14 Spheroidality - Curvature Replace linear parts or flat Use rollers, balls and spirals.
surfaces with curved ones, and
cubical shapes with spherical
shapes.
15 Dynamics Make characteristics of an Divide an object into elements
object or outside environment able to change position relative
automatically adjust for optimal to each other.
performance at each stage of
the operation.

16 Partial or Excessive Action If it is difficult to obtain 100% of

a desired effect, achieve
somewhat more or less to
greatly simplify the problem.

17 Another Dimension Remove problems of moving an Similarly, problems in moving

object in a line by allowing two- an object in a plane are
dimensional movement along a removed if the object can be
plane. changed to allow three-
dimensional movement.

18 Mechanical Vibration Set an object into oscillation. If an oscillation exists, increase

its frequency, even as far as
ultrasonic.
19 Periodic Action Replace a continuous action If an action is already periodic,
with a periodic one (impulse). change its frequency.

20 Continuity of Useful Action Carry out an action without a Remove an idle and
break - all parts of an object intermediate motion.
should be constantly operating
at full capacity.

21 Rushing through Perform harmful or hazardous

operations at very high speed.

22 Blessing in Disguise Utilise a harmful factor or Remove a harmful factor by

harmful effect of an environment combining it with another
to obtain a positive effect. harmful factor.

23 Feedback Introduce feedback. If feedback already exists,

reverse it.
24 Intermediary Use an intermediary object to Temporarily connect an object
transfer or carry out an action. to another one that is easy to
remove.
25 Self-service Make the object service itself Make use of waste material
and carry out supplementary and energy
and repair operations.

26 Copying Use a simple or inexpensive Replace an object or system of

copy instead of an object which objects by an optical copy or
is complex, expensive, fragile or image. A scale can be used to
inconvenient to use. reduce or enlarge the object.

27 Cheap Short-Living Objects Replace an expensive object by

a collection of inexpensive ones,
compromising other properties
(longevity, for example).

28 Replace Mechanical System Replace a mechanical system Use an electrical, magnetic or

by an optical, acoustical or electromagnetic field for
odour system. interaction with the object.
29 Pneumatics and Hydraulics Replace solid parts of an object
with gas or liquid. These parts
can use air or water for inflation
or use air or hydrostatic
cushions.

30 Flexible Membranes / Thin Films Replace customary construction Isolate an object from the
with flexible membrane and thin outside environment with a thin
film. film or fine membrane.
31 Porous Materials Make an object porous or use If an object is already porous,
additional porous elements fill the pores in advance with
(inserts, covers, etc.). some substance.

32 Colour Change Change the colour of an object Change the translucency of an

or its surroundings. object or its surroundings.

33 Homogeneity Make objects interact with a

primary object of the same
material or a material similar in
behaviour.

34 Discarding and Recovering After it has completed its Restore directly any used-up
function or become useless, part of an object.
reject or modify (e.g. discard,
dissolve or evaporate) an
element of an object.

35 Parameter Change Change the aggregate state of

an object, the concentration of
density, the degree of flexibility
or the temperature.

36 Phase Transition Implement an effect developed

during the phase transition of a
substance. For instance, during
liberation of absorption of heat.

37 Thermal Expansion Use expansion or contraction of Use various materials with

a material by heat. different coefficients of heat
expansion.

38 Accelerate Oxidation Replace normal air with Replace enriched air with
enriched air. oxygen.

39 Inert Environment Replace the normal Carry out process in a vacuum.

environment with an inert one.

40 Composite Materials Replace a homogeneous

material with a composite one.
c d e space time condition
Increase the degree of an
object's segmentation. 1 1

1 0 0
Place each part of the object
under conditions most
favourable for its operation.

1 0 0

1 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

1 1 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

0 1 0

0 1 0

0 0 0
Turn object upside down.

1 0 0
Replace a linear motion with a
rotating motion, utilise a
centrifugal force.
1 0 0
If an object is immovable,
make it moveable or
interchangeable.

0 1 0

0 1 0
Use multi-layer assembly of Incline the object or turn it "on Project images on to
objects instead of a single its side". neighbouring areas or on to
layer. the reverse side of the
object.

1 0 0
Use the frequency of Instead of mechanical Use ultrasonic vibrations in
resonance. vibrators, use piezovibrators. conjunction with an
electronic field
0 1 0
Use pulses between impulses
to provide additional action.
0 1 0

0 1 0

0 1 0
Increase the amount of a
harmful action until it ceases to
be harmful.

0 0 0

0 0 0

1 1 0

0 0 0
If visible or optical copies are
used, replace them with
infrared or ultraviolet copies.

1 1 0

0 1 0
Replace fields. Use a field in conjunction with
ferromagnetic particles.
0 0 1
 0 1 1

1 0 0

0 0 1
Use colour additives to If such additives are already
observe difficult to see objects used, employ luminescent
or processes. traces or tracer elements.
0 0 1

0 0 0

0 1 0

0 0 1

0 0 1

0 1 0
In oxygen or in air, treat a Use ionised oxygen.
material with ionising radiation.
0 0 1

0 0 1

1 0 0
alternate scale inverse tbd tbd

0 1 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

1 1 0

0 0 0

1 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

0 0 1

0 0 0
0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

1 1 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

1 0 0

0 0 0

1 1 0

0 0 0
0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 1 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

0 0 0

1 1 0
 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Volume of stationary object

Weight of stationary object

Length of stationary object

Undesired

Volume of moving object

Area of stationary object
Weight of moving object

Length of moving object

Result

Area of moving object

(Conflict)

Feature to Change

15 08 29 17 29 02
1 Weight of moving object
29 34 38 34 40 28
10 01 35 30 05 35
2 Weight of stationary object
29 35 13 02 14 02
08 15 15 17 07 17
3 Length of moving object
29 34 04 04 35
35 28 17 07 35 08
4 Length of stationary object
40 29 10 40 02 14
02 17 14 15 07 14
5 Area of moving object
29 4 18 4 17 4
30 02 26 07
6 Area of stationary object
14 18 09 39
02 26 01 07 01 07
7 Volume of moving object
29 40 04 35 04 17
35 10 35 08
8 Volume of stationary object
19 14
19 14
02 14
08 28 13 14 29 30 07 29
9 Speed
13 38 08 34 34
08 01 18 13 17 19 19 10 01 18 15 09 02 36
10 Force (Intensity)
37 18 01 28 09 36
28 10
15 36 37 12 37 18 37
10 36 13 29 35 10 35 01 10 15 10 15 06 35
11 Stress or pressure
37 40 10 18 36 14 16 36 28 36 37 10
35 24
08 10 15 10 29 34 13 14 05 34 14 04 07 02
12 Shape
29 40 26 03 05 04 10 07 04 10 15 22 35
21 35 26 39 13 15 02 11 28 10 34 28
13 Stability of the object's composition
02 39 01 40 01 28
37
13
39
19 39 35 40
01 08 40 26 01 15 15 14 03 34 09 40 10 15 09 14
14 Strength
40 15 27 01 08 35 28 26 40 29 28 14 07 17 15
19 05 02 19 03 17 10 02
15 Duration of Action of Moving Object
34 31 09 19 19 30
06 27 01 40 35 34
16 Duration of Action of Stationary Object
19 16 35 38
36 22 22 35 15 19 15 19 03 35 34 39 35 06
17 Temperature
06 38 32 09 09 39 18
35 38
40 18 04
19 01 02 35 19 32 19 32 02 13
18 Illumination intensity
32 32 16 26 10
12 18 15 19 35 13
19 Use of Energy by moving object
28 31
12 28
25 18
 19 09
20 Use of Energy by stationary object
06 27
08 36 19 26 01 10 17 32 35 06 30 06
21 Power
38 31 17 27 35 37
19 38
13 38 38 25
15 06 19 06 07 02 06 38 15 26 17 07 07 18
22 Loss of energy
19 28 18 09 06 13 07 17 30 30 18 23
07
35 06 35 06 14 29 10 28 35 02 10 18 01 29 03 39
23 Loss of substance
23 40 22 32 10 39 24 10 31 39 31 30 36 18 31
10 24 10 35
24 Loss of information
35 05
01 26 26 30 26 30 16 02 22
10 20 10 20 15 02 30 24 26 04 10 35 02 05 35 16
25 Loss of time
37 35 26 05 29 14 05 05 16 17 04 34 10 32 18
35 06 27 26 29 35 15 14 02 18 15 20
26 Quantity of substance
18 31 18 35 14 18 29 40 04 29
03 08 03 10 15 09 15 29 17 10 32 35 03 10 02 35
27 Reliability
10 40 08 28 14 04 28 11 14 16 40 04 14 24 24
32 35 28 35 28 26 32 28 26 28 26 28 32 13
28 Measurement Accuracy
26 28 25 26 05 16 03 16 32 03 32 03 06
28 32 28 35 10 28 02 32 28 33 02 29 32 23 25 10
29 Manufacturing Precision
13 18 27 09 29 37 10 29 32 18 36 02 35
22 21 02 22 17 01 22 01 27 02 22 23 34 39
30 Object Affected Harmful factors
27 39 13 24 39 04
01 18
33 28 39 35 37 35 19 27
19 22 35 22 17 15 17 02 22 01 17 02 30 18
31 Object-Generated Harmful Factors
15 39 01 39 16 22 18 39 40 40 35 04
28 29 01 27 01 29 15 17 13 01 13 29
32 Ease of Manufacture
15 16 36 13 13 17 27 26 12
16 40
01 40
35
25 02 6 13 01 17 01 17 18 16 01 16 04 18
33 Convenience of Use
13 15 01 25 13 12 13 16 15 39 35 15 39 31
02 27 02 27 01 28 03 18 15 13 25 02
34 Ease of Repair
35 11 35 11 10 25 31 32
16 25
35 11
01
01 06 19 15 35 01 01 35 35 30 15 35
35 Adaptability or Versatility
15 08 29 16 29 02 16 29 07
15 16
29
26 30 02 26 01 19 14 01 34 26
36 Device Complexity
34 36 35 39 26 24
26
13 16
06 36
06
01 16
27 26 06 13 16 17 02 13 02 39 29 01 02 18
37 Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring
28 13 28 01 26 24
26
18 17 30 16 04 16 26 31
28 26 28 26 14 13 17 14 35 13
38 Extent of Automation
18 35 35 10 17 28
23
13 16
35 26 28 27 18 04 30 07 10 26 10 35 02 06 35 37
39 Productivity
24 37 15 03 28 38 14 26 34 31 17 07 34 10 10 02
 Duration of Action of Stationary Object
Duration of Action of Moving Object
Stability of the object's composition

Use of Energy by stationary object

9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

Use of Energy by moving object

Illumination intensity
Stress or pressure

Loss of substance
Force (Intensity)

Loss of energy
Temperature
Strength
Speed

Shape

Power
02 08 08 10 10 36 10 14 01 35 28 27 05 34 06 29 19 01 35 12 12 36 06 02 05 35
15 38 18 37 37 40 35 40 19 39 18 40 31 35 04 38 32 34 31 18 31 34 19 03 31
08 10 13 29 13 10 26 39 28 02 02 27 28 19 19 32 18 19 15 19 18 19 05 08
19 35 10 18 29 14 01 40 10 27 19 06 32 22 35 28 01 18 28 15 13 30
13 04 17 10 01 08 01 08 01 08 08 35 10 15 08 35 07 02 04 29
19 32 01 35
08 04 35 10 29 15 34 29 34 19 24 35 39 23 10
01 14 13 14 39 37 15 14 01 40 03 35 10 28
28 10 03 25 12 08 06 28
35 15 07 35 28 26 35 39 18 24 35
29 30 19 30 10 15 05 34 11 02 03 15 02 15 15 32 19 10 15 17 10 35
06 03 19 32
04 34 35 02 36 28 29 04 13 39 40 14 16 19 13 32 18 30 26 02 39
01 18 10 15 02 10 35 39 17 07 10 14
02 38 40 17 32
35 36 36 37 19 30 38 30 18 39
29 04 15 35 06 35 01 15 28 10 09 14 06 35 34 39 02 13 35 06 07 15 36 39
35
38 34 36 37 36 37 29 04 01 39 15 07 04 10 18 10 13 18 13 16 34 10
02 18 07 02 34 28 09 14 35 34 35 06 10 39
24 35 30 06
37 35 35 40 17 15 38 04 35 34
13 28 06 18 35 15 28 33 08 03 03 19 28 30 10 13 08 15 19 35 14 20 10 13
15 19 38 40 18 34 01 18 26 14 35 05 36 02 19 35 38 38 02 19 35 28 38
13 28 18 21 10 35 35 10 35 10 35 10 19 17 01 16 19 35 08 35
19 02 14 15
15 12 11 40 34 21 14 27 21 10 36 37 18 37 40 05
06 35 36 35 35 04 35 33 09 18 19 03 35 39 14 24 10 35 02 36 10 35
36 21 15 10 02 40 03 40 27 19 02 10 37 14 25 03 37
35 15 35 10 34 15 33 01 30 14 14 26 22 14 13 15 02 06 04 06 35 29
14
34 18 37 40 10 14 18 04 10 40 09 25 19 32 32 34 14 02 03 05
33 15 10 35 22 01 02 35 17 09 13 27 39 03 35 01 32 03 27 04 32 35 14 02 02 14
13 19
28 18 21 16 18 04 40 15 10 35 35 23 32 27 15 29 18 27 31 39 06 30 40
08 13 10 18 10 03
10 30 13 17 27 03 30 10 19 35 10 26 35 28
35 19 35 35
26 14 03 14 35 40 3518 40 26 40 10 35 28 31 40
03 35 19 02 19 03
14 26 13 03 27 03 19 35 02 19 28 06 19 10 28 27
05 16 28 25 35 27 10 39 04 35 35 18 35 38 03 18
39 35 19 18 27 16
16
03 23 36 40 18 38
02 28 35 10 35 39 14 22 01 35 10 30 19 13 19 18 32 30 19 15 02 14 21 17 21 36
36 30 03 21 19 02 19 32 32 22 40 39 36 40 21 16 03 17 17 25 35 38 39 31
13 19 26 19 32 03 02 19 32 35 32 01 32 35 13 16
32 30 35 19 32 13 01
10 06 27 06 19 19 01 15 01 06
08 15 16 26 23 14 12 02 19 13 05 19 28 35 19 24 02 15 06 19 12 22 35 24
35 21 02 25 29 17 24 09 35 06 18 03 14 19 37 18 15 24 18 05
 27 04 19 02 28 27
36 37 35
29 18 35 32 18 31
15 35 26 02 22 10 29 14 35 32 26 10 19 35 02 14 16 06 16 06 10 35 28 27
16
02 36 35 35 02 40 15 31 28 10 38 17 25 19 19 37 38 18 38
16 35 14 02 19 38 01 13 35 27
36 38 26 03 38
38 39 06 07 32 15 02 37
10 13 14 15 03 36 29 35 02 14 35 28 28 27 27 16 21 36 01 06 35 18 28 27 28 27 35 27
28 38 18 40 37 10 03 05 30 40 31 40 03 18 18 38 39 31 13 24 05 12 31 18 38 02 31
26 32 10 10 19 10 19 19 10
10 37 37 36 04 10 35 03 29 03 20 10 28 20 35 29 01 19 35 38 35 20 10 05 35 18
01
36 05 04 34 17 22 05 28 18 28 18 10 16 21 18 26 17 19 18 10 06 18 32 10 39
35 29 35 14 10 36 15 02 14 35 03 35 03 35 03 17 34 29 03 35 07 18 06 03
35 14 35
34 28 03 14 03 17 40 34 10 10 40 31 39 16 18 31 25 10 24
21 35 08 28 10 24 35 01 02 35 34 27 03 35 11 32 21 11 21 11 10 11 10 35
11 28 36 23
11 28 10 03 35 19 16 11 03 25 06 40 10 13 27 19 26 31 35 29 39
28 13 06 28 06 28 32 35 28 06 28 06 10 26 06 19 06 01 03 06 03 06 26 32 10 16
32 02
32 24 32 32 13 32 32 24 28 24 32 32 32 27 31 28
10 28 28 19 32 30 03 27 13 32 35 31
03 35 30 18 03 27 19 26 03 32 32 02 32 02
32 34 36 40 40 02 10 24
21 22 13 35 22 02 22 01 35 24 18 35 22 15 17 01 22 33 01 19 01 24 10 02 19 22 21 22 33 22
35 28 39 18 37 03 35 30 18 37 01 33 28 40 33 35 02 32 13 06 27 22 37 31 02 35 02 19 40
35 28 35 28 02 33 35 40 15 35 15 22 21 39 22 35 19 24 02 35 19 18 02 35 21 35 10 01
35 01
03 23 01 40 27 18 27 39 22 02 33 31 16 22 02 24 39 32 06 22 18 02 22 34
35 13 35 19 01 28 01 13 01 03 27 01 27 26 28 24 28 26 27 01 15 34
35 12 35 16 01 04 19 35
08 01 01 37 13 27 11 10 32 04 18 27 01 27 01 12 24 33
18 13 28 13 02 32 15 34 32 35 32 40 29 03 01 16 26 27 13 17 01 13 35 34 02 19 28 32
34 35 12 29 28 30 03 28 08 25 25 13 01 24 24 02 10 13 02 24
01 11 01 13 11 01 11 29 15 01 15 01 15 10 15 01 02 35
34 09 13 02 35 01 04 10
10 02 04 02 09 28 27 13 28 16 32 02 32 19 34 27
35 10 15 17 15 37 35 30 35 03 13 01 27 02 06 22 19 35 19 01 18 15 15 10
35 16 02 16
14 20 01 08 14 32 06 35 03 35 26 01 29 13 29 01 02 13
34 10 19 01 29 13 02 22 02 13 10 04 02 17 24 17 27 02 20 19 10 35 35 10
26 16
28 35 28 15 17 19 28 28 15 13 13 28 29 30 34 13 02 28 29
03 04 36 28 35 36 27 13 11 22 27 03 19 29 25 34 03 27 02 24 19 35 19 01 35 03 01 18
35 38
16 35 40 19 37 32 01 39 39 30 15 28 39 25 06 35 35 16 26 16 16 10 15 19 10 24
15 32 26 02 08 32 02 32 28 02 35 10
28 10 02 35 13 35 18 01 25 13 06 09 23 28
01 13 19 19 13 27 18 05
28 15 10 37 14 10 35 03 29 28 35 10 20 10 35 21 26 17 35 10 35 20 28 10 28 10
01
10 36 14 34 40 22 39 10 18 02 18 16 38 28 10 19 01 38 19 10 29 35 35 23
 Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring
Object-Generated Harmful Factors
24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38

Object Affected Harmful factors

Adaptability or Versatility
Manufacturing Precision
Measurement Accuracy
Quantity of substance

Extent of Automation
Ease of Manufacture

Convenience of Use
Loss of information

Device Complexity
Ease of Repair
Loss of time

Reliability

10 24 10 35 03 26 03 11 28 27 28 35 22 21 22 35 27 28 35 03 02 27 29 05 26 30 28 29 26 35
35 20 28 18 31 01 27 35 26 26 18 18 27 31 39 01 36 02 24 28 11 15 08 36 34 26 32 18 19
10 15 10 20 19 06 10 28 18 26 10 01 02 19 35 22 28 01 06 13 02 27 19 15 01 10 25 28 02 26
35 35 26 18 26 08 03 28 35 27 22 37 01 39 09 01 32 28 11 29 26 39 17 15 35
15 02 10 14 28 32 10 28 01 15 01 29 15 29 01 28 14 15 01 19 35 01 17 24
01 24 29 35 17 15
29 29 40 04 29 37 17 24 17 35 04 10 01 16 26 24 26 24 26 16
30 29 15 29 32 28 02 32 15 17
24 26 01 18 02 25 03 01 35 01 26 26
14 28 03 10 27
29 30 26 28 22 33 17 02 13 01 15 17 15 13 14 01 02 36 14 30
30 26 26 04 29 09 02 32 15 30
06 13 32 03 28 01 18 39 26 24 13 16 10 01 13 26 18 28 23
10 35 02 18 32 35 26 28 02 29 27 02 22 01 01 18 02 35
30 16 40 16 16 04 16 15 16 23
04 18 40 04 40 04 32 03 18 36 39 35 40 36 30 18
02 06 29 30 14 01 25 28 22 21 17 02 29 01 15 13 29 26 35 34
02 22 26 28 10 15 29 26 01
34 10 07 40 11 02 16 27 35 40 01 40 30 12 04 16 24
35 16 02 35 35 10 34 39 30 18 02 17
35 03 35 01 01 31
32 18 16 25 19 27 35 04 26
10 19 11 35 28 32 10 28 01 28 02 24 35 13 32 28 34 02 15 10 10 28 03 34
13 26 10 18
29 38 27 28 01 24 32 25 35 23 35 21 08 01 13 12 28 27 26 04 34 27 16
10 37 14 29 03 35 35 10 28 29 01 35 13 03 15 37 01 28 15 01 15 17 26 35 36 37
02 35
36 18 36 13 21 23 24 37 36 40 18 36 24 18 01 03 25 11 18 20 10 18 10 19
37 36 10 14 10 13 06 28 22 02 02 33 01 35 19 01 02 36
03 35 11 02 35 35 24
04 36 19 35 25 37 27 18 16 35 37
14 10 10 40 28 32 32 30 22 01 17 32 32 15 02 13 01 15 16 29 15 13 15 01
36 22 35 01
34 17 16 01 40 02 35 01 28 26 01 29 01 28 39 32
15 32 35 24 35 40 32 35 02 35 35 30 02 35 35 22 01 08
35 27 13 18 35 19
35 30 18 27 39 30 10 16 34 02 22 26 39 23 35
29 03 29 10 03 27 18 35 15 35 11 03 32 40 27 11 15 03 02 13 27 03
11 03 03 27 15
28 10 27 16 37 01 22 02 10 32 28 02 03 32 28 15 40
20 10 03 35 11 02 03 27 22 15 21 39 27 01 29 10 01 35 10 04 19 29
10 03 12 27 06 10
28 18 10 40 13 16 40 33 28 16 22 04 27 13 28 15 39 35
28 20 03 35 34 27 10 26 17 01 25 34
10 22 35 10 01 01 02 01
10 16 31 06 40 24 40 33 06 35
35 28 03 17 19 35 32 19 22 33 22 35 04 10 02 18 02 17 03 27 26 02
24 26 27 26 27
21 18 30 39 03 10 24 35 02 02 24 16 27 16 35 31 19 16
19 01 11 15 35 19 19 35 28 26 15 17 15 01 06 32 02 26
01 06 01 19 03 32 15 19 32 15
26 17 32 32 39 28 26 19 13 16 19 13 10
35 38 34 23 19 21 03 01 01 35 02 35 28 26 01 15 15 17 02 29
19 35 35 38 32 02
19 18 16 18 11 27 32 06 27 06 30 17 28 13 16 27 28
 03 35 10 36 10 02 19 22 19 35
01 04
31 23 22 37 18 16 25
35 20 04 34 19 24 32 15 19 22 18 02 26 10 26 35 35 02 19 17 20 19 19 35 28 02
10 19 32 02
10 06 19 26 31 02 31 02 35 34 10 10 34 34 30 34 16 17
10 18 07 18 11 10 21 22 21 35 35 32 35 03
19 10 32 02 19 07 23 02
32 07 25 35 35 02 02 22 01 15 23
15 18 06 03 10 29 16 34 35 10 33 22 10 01 15 34 32 28 02 35 15 10 35 10 35 18 35 10
35 10 10 24 39 35 31 28 24 31 30 40 34 29 33 02 24 34 27 02 28 24 10 13 18
24 26 24 28 10 28 22 10 10 21
32 27 22 35 33 35
28 32 35 23 01 22
24 26 35 38 10 30 24 34 24 26 35 18 35 22 35 28 04 28 32 10 18 28 24 28
35 28 06 29
28 32 18 16 04 28 32 28 18 34 18 39 34 04 10 34 01 32 10 35 30
24 28 35 38 18 03 03 02 35 33 03 35 29 01 35 29 02 32 15 03 03 13 03 27
33 30 08 35
35 18 16 28 40 28 29 31 40 39 35 27 25 10 10 25 29 27 10 29 18
10 30 21 28 32 03 11 32 27 35 35 02 27 17 13 35 13 35 27 40 11 13
10 28 01 11
04 40 03 11 23 01 02 40 40 26 40 08 24 01 28 27
24 34 02 06 05 11 28 24 03 33 06 35 01 13 01 32 13 35 27 35 26 24 28 02
28 32 32 01 23 22 26 39 10 25 18 17 34 13 11 02 10 34 32 28 10 34
32 26 11 32 26 28 04 17 01 32 26 02 26 28
32 30 25 10
28 18 01 10 36 34 26 35 23 18 18 23
22 10 35 18 35 33 27 24 28 33 26 28 24 35 02 25 35 10 35 11 22 19 22 19 33 03
02 34 29 31 02 40 23 26 10 18 02 28 39 02 22 31 29 40 29 40 34
10 21 03 24 24 02 03 33 04 17 19 01 02 21
01 22 02
29 39 01 40 39 26 34 26 31 27 01
32 24 35 28 35 23 01 35 02 05 35 01 02 13 27 26 06 28 08 28
24 02
18 16 34 4 01 24 12 18 13 16 11 09 15 01 11 01 01
04 10 04 28 17 27 25 13 01 32 02 25 02 05 12 26 15 34 32 26 01 34
12 35
27 22 10 34 08 40 02 34 35 23 28 39 12 01 32 01 16 12 17 12 03
32 01 02 28 11 10 10 02 35 10 01 35 01 12 07 01 35 01 34 35
25 10
10 25 10 25 01 16 13 02 16 11 10 26 15 04 16 13 11 07 13
03 35 35 13 35 05 35 11 01 13 15 34 01 16 15 29 27 34
35 28 01
15 08 24 01 10 32 31 31 01 16 07 04 37 28 35
13 03 13 35 02 26 26 24 22 19 27 26 27 09 29 15 15 10 15 01
06 29 19 01 01 13
27 10 01 10 34 32 29 40 01 13 26 24 28 37 37 28 24
35 33 18 28 03 27 27 40 26 24 22 19 05 28 15 10
02 21 02 05 12 26 01 15 34 21
27 22 32 09 29 18 28 08 32 28 29 28 11 29 37 28
24 28 11 27 28 26 28 26 01 26 01 12 01 35 27 04 15 24 34 27
35 33 35 13 02 33 02
35 30 32 10 34 18 23 13 34 03 13 01 35 10 25
13 15 01 35 01 10 18 10 22 35 35 22 35 28 01 28 01 32 01 35 12 17 35 18 05 12
35 38
23 10 38 34 28 32 01 13 24 18 39 02 24 07 19 10 25 28 37 28 24 27 02 35 26
 39
Productivity

35 03
24 37
01 28
15 35
14 04
28 29
30 14
07 26
10 26
34 02
10 15
17 07
10 06
02 34
35 37
10 02

03 28
35 37
10 14
35 37
17 26
34 10
23 35
40 03
29 35
10 14
35 17
14 19
20 10
16 38
15 28
35
02 25
16
12 28
35
01 06
28 35
34
28 10
29 35
28 35
10 23
13 23
15

13 29
03 27
01 35
29 38
10 34
28 32
10 18
32 39
22 35
13 24
22 35
18 39
35 10
28 01
15 01
28
01 32
10
35 28
06 37
12 17
28
35 18
05 12
35 26
 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

Volume of stationary object

Weight of stationary object

Length of stationary object

Undesired

Volume of moving object

Area of stationary object
Weight of moving object

Length of moving object

Result

Area of moving object

(Conflict)

Feature to Change

1 Weight of moving object X

2 Weight of stationary object

3 Length of moving object

4 Length of stationary object

5 Area of moving object

6 Area of stationary object

7 Volume of moving object

8 Volume of stationary object

9 Speed

10 Force (Intensity)

11 Stress or pressure

12 Shape

13 Stability of the object's composition

14 Strength

15 Duration of Action of Moving Object

16 Duration of Action of Stationary Object

17 Temperature

18 Illumination intensity

19 Use of Energy by moving object

20 Use of Energy by stationary object

21 Power

22 Loss of energy

23 Loss of substance

24 Loss of information

25 Loss of time

26 Quantity of substance

27 Reliability

28 Measurement Accuracy

29 Manufacturing Precision

30 Object Affected Harmful factors

31 Object-Generated Harmful Factors

32 Ease of Manufacture

33 Convenience of Use

34 Ease of Repair

35 Adaptability or Versatility

36 Device Complexity

37 Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring

38 Extent of Automation

39 Productivity
 9
Speed

Force (Intensity) 10
11

Stress or pressure
12

Shape
13

Stability of the object's composition

X
14

Strength
15

Duration of Action of Moving Object

16

Duration of Action of Stationary Object

X
17

Temperature
18

Illumination intensity
19

Use of Energy by moving object

20

Use of Energy by stationary object

21

Power
22

Loss of energy

X
X
23

Loss of substance
 24
Loss of information

Loss of time 25

X
26

Quantity of substance
27

Reliability
28

Measurement Accuracy
29

Manufacturing Precision
30

Object Affected Harmful factors

31

Object-Generated Harmful Factors

32

Ease of Manufacture
33

Convenience of Use
34

Ease of Repair
35

Adaptability or Versatility
36

Device Complexity
37

Difficulty of Detecting and Measuring

38

Extent of Automation
X
 39
Productivity