Carib Studies Module 1 Notes
Carib Studies Module 1 Notes
Hierarchy of Values
Another variation apparent in society and culture is the different ways in which individuals
rank values. Patriotism, for example, may be very highly valued, but for some individuals or
groups other values may be ranked higher. For example:
- Uppermost in other people's hierarchy of values will be the development of an overall
national consciousness where patriotism becomes more important than small group
affiliation.
- Others value the personal highly.
- Directly opposite to such a value position, will be a Gandhi, a Mandela, or a Martin
Luther King, where what is good for mankind takes precedence
Latent and Manifest Acts
According to the sociologist there is a myriad of possible effects to each action in the society
and culture.
Latent functions refer to the unintended, hidden, or unexpected consequences of an act.
Manifest functions, on the other hand, refer to the anticipated, open, or stated goals of an act.
Status and Roles
All members of society occupy a number of social positions known as statuses. In society an
individual may have several statuses - occupational, family, gender. Statuses are culturally
defined despite the fact that they may be based on biological factors such as sex.
Each status in society is accompanied by a number of norms that defines how an individual
occupying a particular status is expected to act. This group of norms is known as role. Social
roles regulate and organize behaviour. In particular they provide means for accomplishing
certain tasks.
Cultural Renewal, Retention and Erasure as a part of values
Cultural Erasure
The erasure of cultural practices is often a gradual process and usually stems from an on-
going conflict between traditional ways of accomplishing tasks in the society and newer
methods. The latter may be more efficient and cost-effective and may save time and energy.
The adoption of appliances such as refrigerators, washing machines, dishwashers, and
microwaves, has contributed to the loss of cultural practices.
Cultural retention results from a deliberate desire to keep traditions alive so that some groups
would be able to preserve their sense of identity. Small groups especially, within larger
communities, tend to feel alienated. You may be able to think of distinct social groups in your
country where retention of cultural practices is emphasized because it is thought that the very
existence of the group depends on these practices.
Cultural renewal refers to efforts to salvage parts of our past by fashioning new practices
based on the old. Such efforts stem from a feeling that there is much value in what we have
neglected. Also, in incorporating new values and norms into our society and culture we find
that traditional practices are re-cast and appear in different forms. In many Caribbean
countries traditional food preparations which are time consuming and labour intensive are
now speeded up and made easier to produce for the tourist market and working persons using
modern techniques such as refrigeration and food processing.
Hybridization
This refers to the processes of cultural and ethnic mixing to produce new or ‘creole’ forms.
For example, prior to Columbus’ arrival the Kalinagos and Tainos adopted each other’s’
languages and customs.
Racial and Ethnic Hybridization
Amerindian, African and to a lesser extent Indian women, were forced to cohabit and have
children for European oppressors
This went on for centuries resulting in a mixed or coloured race of people. Sexual relations
resulting in children of mixed race is called miscegenation.
Children of such unions with predominantly white features according to the prevalent racial
ideologies asserted that these lighter skinned children were somehow better than their
maternal ancestors and were treated more leniently.
A pigmentocracy evolved where people of fairer complexions wielded more prestige and
power in the society than others.
Thus, skin colour, facial features and even hair texture are important in the discourse of
culture and identity in the Caribbean, a social construct based on biological characteristics
From the very beginning indigenous populations and later on the enslaved and indentured
have been considered subhuman.
Racial and ethnic hybridization then underscored and emphasized the prevailing ideologies in
the society, equating skin colour with social constructions of inferiority and superiority
A continuum of colour and shade therefore came to characterize Caribbean people with each
colour and shade with a different connotation. Those almost white ones had higher prospects.
This respect for colour has extended into all walks of life even to the acquirement of
European physical features or even alliances with white or lighter skinned persons as means
of social betterment.
Persons of mixed race have such a diversity of features it is often difficult for them to identify
a sense of cultural belonging. Some countries may have a larger ‘coloured’ population i.e.
Trinidad or St. Lucia or with two larger populations which make the coloured populace i.e.
Jamaica or Antigua.
The combos are innumerable and are found at all socio-economic aspects of the society
however there is an alignment of these people more with affluent groups in society.
Various terms have been coined to define these groups:
- Europeans encountered the Amerindians in the 15th century and during the violent
impact, the race of mestizos were born. Hispanic scholars used this term to label all
mixed-race Caribbean people i.e., Afro-mestizo, European-Indian mestizo.
- In the British Caribbean, scholars the race produced through the interactions between
the enslaved Africans and the Europeans were termed as mulattoes. Due to use of
lightness as a marker on the social hierarchy finer distinctions emerged such as the
sambo (mulatto x African), quadroon (mulatto x European).
Other unions took place between maroon Africans and Amerindians, forming the Afro-
Amerindian mestizo type for example the Misquito Indians of Belize and Nicaragua. The
Belize Garifuna which relocated to St Vincent were descendants of Black Carib rebels and
local Africans and Amerindians.
Their Arawakian language persists as well as the religious and kinship networks. This
hybridized culture is a remarkable example of cultural retention.
The Caribbean is a rich showcase of racial and ethnic diversity from hybridization and as
such can be defined as a polyglot society.
Cultural Hybridization
Cultural hybridization is defined as the development of new cultural forms out of existing
ones through a period of contact and interaction.
Creolization is used instead if this process took place within the context if European
colonization. Thus, in the Caribbean the two are interchangeable
The greatest effect of this is cultural diversity, manifest through the hybrid forms created
when two or more ethnic groups meet and interact. These hybrids can be any mixture of the
original forms.
The Processes of Cultural Hybridization
To understand this process, we must have a fundamental understanding of the terms: cultural
erasure, cultural retention, and cultural renewal.
Cultural Erasure
This refers to practices which have died out or are currently dying.
There is a debate as to whether culture can truly die.
Due to the definitions of culture as material and non-material previously a culture can survive
through the artefacts it has left behind.
Non-material culture is harder to define as the language of the Taino can still survive through
place names or local dialects to a small extent.
The hybridity also due to the intermingling between Europeans and the Amerindian
populations during conquest could mean that Taino practices may exist today through some
Caribbean practices.
Cultural Retention
This refers to practices which have survived even when most other forms and symbols of a
culture are no longer existent.
Traditional Carib basketry designs and technology still continue in Dominica and elsewhere
though these populations continuously change and adapt to modernity.
A cultural retention usually refers to a specific aspect of culture for example religion or
language.
Cultural Renewal
This occurs when a group goes through a conscious rejuvenation process and returns to some
elements of its culture which it believes have been ignored or suppressed.
It normally via a change in consciousness brought on by radical historical change.
For example, the advent of Garveyism & the Harlem Renaissance in the early 20th century
catalysed a development of black consciousness in the Caribbean and the US.
Examples of Cultural Hybridization
Religion
World Religions which met in the Caribbean underwent a large amount of hybridization or
syncretism into creolized formats. These could be small differences or radical ones from the
original.
Christian and African religions have undergone a larger process of syncretism than other ones
since Conquest and later Missionary activity
Africans tried to fill in the vacuum left in their cultural life due to removal from their
homelands and as such created a large amount of syncretic religions which often incorporated
elements of the dominant religion inclusive of the belief in the creator and cosmology.
Myal is an early creolized religion developed in Jamaica where Christian elements were
blended with African World views.
US Baptists fleeing the American revolution settled in Jamaica bringing their views to Myal
believers who often incorporated actively Christian doctrine into the Myal world view.
Revivalism, Pukumania and Kumina were all derived from Myal.
The Shouter Baptists also developed similarly to Myal where US Baptists who settled in
Trinidad & Tobago and St Vincent in the 19th Century had their beliefs syncretized into the
existing African beliefs of Rada, Shango and Obeah; migration between the countries also
served to strengthen the faith though persecuted by Britain.
African Elements such as drumming and dancing to music is important to worship with an
emotional ceremony.
Rastafari believe that all members of the black race belong to one of the twelve tribes of
Israel and that one incarnation of Jah is Christ.
Santeria in Cuba survives with a host of Roman Catholic saints renamed in Yoruba. In these
afro-centric religions a greater emphasis is placed on spiritual possession and occult
practices.
Syncretism is a complex process whether African or Christian beliefs are dominant. The
beliefs are better described as integrated as practitioners have melded both European and
African elements which are very hard to deconstruct and explain.
The beliefs aren’t merely just retentions but are hybrids formed under subjugation and
resilience to for an identity.
Not surprisingly major Christian denominations such as Catholicism and Anglicanism are
currently being creolized. Clapping, dancing, and drumming are a mainstay in worship today
Language
Caribbean languages are extremely hybridized mainly of the dominant European language as
well as words sprinkled from other languages and expressed through oral culture
African languages from the enslaved were not usually written languages and were mixed to
form creole languages which differed immensely from the European master tongue.
These are referred to as creole or patois. Each country has their own type which has emerged
due to immense hybridization.
Each language has a specific structure and lexicon which tremendously differs from the
standard, either created or adopted from other languages.
Each type whether English, French or Dutch creole is considered a fully developed language
as it meets the needs of those in the society. It is usually the mother tongue of all residents in
a specific Caribbean country.
Creole, especially in the Anglophone Caribbean is expressed as a continuum, where one end
is the extreme of creole (basilect) and the other Standard English. In between includes
language used for all different situations. Mesolect tends to be used by most creole speakers
and it is easier to shift between creole and the standard language.
Since the words used in English creole for example in Jamaican creole or Trinidadian creole
are similar to the standard the social construction that these languages are corrupt has
developed.
This has arisen due to ideologies of European culture as superior and Hybridized cultural
forms as inferior.
French creoles are found in the patois of Dominica, St Lucia and all the French Territories
and Haiti.
It Haiti creole is called kweyol. The French lexicon creoles in the Anglo-Caribbean are not
widely spoken but are extremely similar to the Franco-Caribbean.
Haitian creole is different due to the Haitian revolution’s removal of French influence in 1804
the language structure differs immensely from others and is often debated as Ewe language
with French vocab.
Cultural Change
The terms enculturation, acculturation, assimilation, transculturation and inter-culturation are
accurately used to describe cultural change.
Enculturation
This is a process of socialization where a person becomes part of another’s culture.
This can occur through assimilation or acculturation.
This has been tried by European Colonists. One has to note however of the view that one’s
culture can be erased while being enculturated.
Once the practice still lives in one’s memory and can be practiced by others it isn't erased.
Enculturation alerts us to the possibility of cultural erasure.
Acculturation
Acculturation was used as the means for the colonies to develop an appreciation of British
culture during colonization.
For example the adoption of English as an official language, English curriculum even
institutions of laws and governance.
The belief was that subjects would be socialized into a deep appreciation of British culture,
following its customs and practices; without the expectation of becoming British but
encultured to produce a hybrid culture with English values
Acculturation meant the erasure of some aspects of African and Amerindian culture however
a unique culture was formed where there was reverence to British values and an embrace of
Afro-centric and other cultural forms (religion/language)
Retentions also existed through African herbal medicine and cooking i.e. Garifuna and the
Maroons.
Assimilation
This occurs when a dominant group makes a bid to enculturate another by attempting to
supplant all aspects of its culture and make it over into the image of the dominant group.
For example, the French assimilation policy where the French intended to convert her
colonized people into French people, culturally speaking ignoring indigenous customs and
values.
The colonies of Martinique and Guadeloupe are acknowledged as part of France however
both ambivalently identify with their Caribbean Identity and their French citizenship showing
that despite pressures Caribbean people have only been enculturated to a certain extent as
hybridized Franco-Caribbean culture exists.
Transculturation
This describes the process whereby a culture changes drastically, actually overcoming itself
and translating into something new.
For instance, Cuba before and after the revolution where cultures of pre-revolutionary Cuba
has been transformed into a more rigid socialist perspective after 1962. However, despite
social change and collectivist economy many cultural beliefs remained
Another is the experience of ‘seasoning’ to slavery of newly arrived Africans by creole
Africans. Despite many attempts at cultural erasure some elements of identity remained.
Inter-culturation
This refers to the mixing of cultures that goes on between groups who share a space. The
groups do not necessarily give up their own culture but participates in various ways in each
others’ lives.
For example, the meeting of Africans and other groups in a Culturally plural society such as
Trinidad & Tobago at schools or at the workplace.
Social Stratification
This is another characteristic through which Caribbean society can be identified.
It refers to the ranking of social groups according to one or more criteria deemed important in
society.
The ranking usually indicates the money, power or prestige of a specified group.
Different positions on the hierarchy are called social strata and status is a rank or position in
the hierarchy.
This system indicates that groups in society are unequal, and this condition persist across
generations.
Ranking society may differ for example in closed systems of social stratification like the
Caribbean society during slavery the criteria determining one’s status was race and colour.
Therefore, the system was closed to mobility as race was the determining factor.
Similarly for caste systems which are also closed one can only interact within one’s caste.
Closed systems like these are based on ascribed or hereditary status.
Social Inequality
Stratified ranking systems of social groups are forms of institutional inequality meaning
people have proportional access to privileges based on their position in the hierarchy.
Thus, even a poor person with qualifications may lose a job to a wealthy not as qualified
applicant.
In the Caribbean where colour is held in high regard it often happens that lighter coloured
individuals obtain better jobs and better marriage prospects and opportunities than those
ranked lower on these traits
This is an example of social stratification maintains inequality where groups with more
money obstruct other groups from moving upwards in society and are called gatekeepers.
Social Stratification Under Slavery
Plantation society in the Caribbean in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries was a closed system
of stratification based on ascribed criteria of race and colour.
Race and colour were tied to ones occupation in the society. Black people to a could only be
slaves or free people of colour. White people were never of low social status though white
indentured labours strained on the borders.
One could not escape this system unless one had bargaining power. Persons of mixed descent
were fortunate in this regard and got lighter work as a result (that was a pun LOL). Many
were also freed by their white fathers and even educated, so had better prospects. Coloureds
were an efficient buffer group in the society.
However, under closer inspection the three levels were also rigidly subdivided.
Among whites those born in Europe were usually of higher standing but were often absentee,
so the creole whites were at the top of the hierarchy. Poorer whites (overseers etc.) were
somewhat removed but still ranked above the free coloureds via race.
Among free coloureds there were divisions based further on hue, degree of education, a
protection from a white person while among the enslaved distinction only existed based on
labour type i.e., house & field.
Social Class and Social Stratification
In the Caribbean today social class is mainly used to distinguish among the different social
strata based on social and economic resources.
The Caribbean is defined using the ‘class structure’, stratification under upper, middle and
lower social classes.
Social class in modern society is perceived as based on achieved criteria referring to one’s
performance in being able to earn what the society values (wealth, power, prestige). There is
however unequal opportunity in getting rewards.
It is important to note though the Caribbean is stratified according to social class, that
situation has evolved gradually from plantation society.
Social Mobility
This is the movement of individuals from one social class to another, either up or down the
hierarchy.
In closed systems like in Plantation society social mobility was impossible or very limited.
Now in the Caribbean it is possible now due to what one has achieved. A society where one
can advance socially based on achievements is called a meritocracy.
The main ways of advancement are:
- Marrying up
- Acquiring the necessary educational credentials.
- Owning a successful business and investing wisely
In many cases mobility is intergenerational meaning that a family can move up the socio-
economic bracket due to the foresight of one of the elders in the family
Indentureship
Indentureship has been described as a ‘new slavery although the Indian and Chinese
immigrants weren't defined as chattel and could practice their own customs and religions.
They were paid extremely low wages and were always in debt to the company store where
they were coerced to buy goods with substandard living and sanitation facilities.
They were not allowed to move around freely and if caught some distance from the plantation
they could be flogged, charged with vagrancy and jailed. If they attempted to run away they
were hunted down charged with breach of contract and returned to work. They were charged
with exorbitant fines & many died from malnutrition and suffered from malaria, yaws and
dysentery.
As a system of production, indentureship was very much related to African plantation
society.
The socio-economic influences of the plantation pervaded the society though some Africans
moved away.
They now occupied the lowest social stratum and were also discouraged from interacting
with the Africans to continue disunity among labourers.
However, times had changed. Towards the end of the 19th century Caribbean plantations
were no longer as important to Europe had global empires and the sugar was under
competition from other larger sugar producers such as Brazil and Cuba. Eventually the
nationalist Indian movement brought pressure on the British to discontinue immigration due
to dissatisfaction of the treatment of Indians so the British ended Indian indentureship in 1917
(a similar situation happened in China were it ended in 1885).
Resistance
Caribbean people have always sought ways and means of resisting the harsh conditions under
which they existed.
They resisted in two ways
1) active resistance 2) passive resistance
Active resistance included riots, rebellions, revolutions, development of peasant groups.
Passive resistance involved pretence (deaf, lack of understanding of oppressors’ language,
fake illnesses, malingering, satirize /mimic European lifestyle, suicide, infanticide).
Amerindian Resistance
The threat of the Spanish to the to Tainos aroused in them a spirit of warfare. Although the
Spanish had superior weapons of warfare, they still put-up resistance.
The Tainos resisted oppression by running away and by committing individual and group
suicide and infanticide,
They refused to work and starved out the Spanish by burning their food stores.
The effort of the Spaniards to Christianize the Amerindians was met with much resistance.
The Spaniards sought to save the souls of the abused Indians but were forced to unite even
from the first year of invasion and present some form of military opposition to European
Invasion.
The African Resistance
African were kept in subjugation for nearly three centuries. This was mainly done through the
threat of physical violence and brainwashing.
African resistance was persistent, powerful and successful. It was either active or passive.
Africans resisted passively through suicide, sabotage (damaging tools and property) vendetta,
malingering, apathy, escape, maroonage, revolt, rebellion, and revolution.
Resistance occurred despite the efforts of the planters to ‘break the spirit’ of the strong and
intimidate the weak. Planters applied the system of divide and rule as well as confusion
where they mixed the slaves of different languages to avoid communication.
Maroonage was one of the most successful forms of slave resistance. It was a system which
started with the freed blacks who fled the plantations to the mountains during Spanish
colonization.
It was prominent in mountainous larger territories such as Jamaica (Blue Mountains &
Cockpit Country) and Cuba (Hammerhead Mountains)
It proved successful because the Europeans found it difficult to deal with the guerilla warfare
use by the Maroons to protect their freedom.
Maroons would also raid plantations and encourage other slaves to runaway
Slaves not only resisted slavery, sometimes their response to oppression took on organized
forms such as rebellions, which were more organized and larger. E.g., the Tacky Rebellion in
1760, and the Sam Sharpe Rebellion in 1831.
Revolution and Rebellion
The largest and most successful slave revolution was the Haitian Revolution of the 1790s.
The Haitian revolution is argued to have, ignited the flame of liberation for all slaves
throughout the Caribbean and the New World.
The success of the Haitian revolution inspired other slaves to fight for their freedom.
It inspired other revolts of the 1830s e.g., Barbados 1816, British Guiana 1823, Jamaica 1831.
These slave revolts contributed to the abolition movement in England and finally the
abolition of slavery in 1838.
Peasantry
After Emancipation many ex-slaves left their plantation to escape forced and unpaid labour.
Once they were freed, many moved away for the plantations into deep rural areas.
Ex-slaves developed new forms of labour. The skilled slaves moved into towns.
The acquisition of land was a means of independence for the slaves. Many sought to buy land
which was blocked by the planters and the government.
The planters used different tactics to block the peasants form owing land. They would charge
high rents for land and evict them. They also refused to sell them land and block their means
of acquiring credit to do so.
However, the peasants found means of acquiring land. They pooled their resources together
and bought land, the received help from the missionaries and many resorted to squatting.
Effects of Peasantry
The peasants helped to diversify the economy in the post-emancipation period and the decline
of sugar.
The peasants turned to developing cash crops for export. They grew crops such as Cocoa,
bananas, coffee, ginger cotton, arrowroot, and coconuts on their smallholdings. They also
grew food crops and reared animals
This new found independence made the peasants self-sufficient and resilient in the face of
economic hardships.
The peasants received little support from the colonial government.
The peasantry could have been more successful had they received more help form the
government.
The planters were determined to do everything keep the slaves dependent on the plantations.
Ex-slaves found refuge in the ‘free villages’ which were set up by the missionaries.
The free villages helped the development of the peasantry. This peasantry transformed the
Caribbean from a predominantly mono-cropping of sugar cane to small farming of mixed
crops which created economic independence for the ex-slaves.
Significance of Resistance
This desire of the slaves to be independent from the hegemony of the Plantocracy developed
a spirit of cooperation and caring among rural communities. This close bond has evolved as
part of the rural culture of the Caribbean.
The experience of slavery has been profound in shaping the modern Caribbean. It has
changed the systems of land tenure, agricultural practices, and population: size, race,
ethnicity and structure.
The descendants of slaves continue to experience erasure of their traditional culture, language
dress and religion etc. They have remained largely poor.
The history of the Caribbean is filled with struggle against colonialism, oppression and social
injustice. E.g., in the politics of Jamaica, Haiti, Trinidad and Guyana may have its roots in the
experience of slavery and a the practice of planters to prevent unity and prevent another
Haitian Revolution. It also manifested again with the practice of creating disunity amongst
the blacks and the Indians.
Movements Towards Independence
By the dawn of the 20th Century Caribbean people were beginning to understand what
freedom meant were beginning to challenge the very basis of colonialism, particularly in the
aftermath of two World Wars.
This happened in two major ways, through Economic Enfranchisement & Political
Enfranchisement.
Economic Enfranchisement
The Condition whereby a country or nation achieves the right to determine how it will
develop its systems of production.
Despite the European control of the Caribbean economy here was resistance from people who
wanted to develop their own means of making a living.
Plantation economies were typically based on large quantities of cheap unskilled labour based
on monoculture. Almost all of the harvest was to be manufactured in Europe.
Food produce was haphazard, and it was normally left to the ex-slaves to grow their own
vegetables and fruits for domestic sale.
The downturn of sugar revenue in the 19th century indicated that plantation economies would
decline.
Small and peasant farmers as result began to produce new crops as a result to diversify the
markets for export.
Cocoa, bananas, coffee, ginger, cotton, coconuts and arrowroot were grown by peasant
farmers on smallholdings. Animals were also reared.
This strategy of economic diversification attempted to make small farmers more independent
of the planter and the small wages offered on the plantation and introduced them to self-
organization for the export market and develop new trade sophistication for the wider world.
They received little economic support from colonial who would prefer a subservient
peasantry.
They were often the source of discriminatory practices from the planters often refusing to sell
them land and often sabotaged them in the process. However, they also banded together to
buy out plantations for impoverished planters. Baptist missionaries sometimes helped in these
purchases forming in cases free villages. Others with little alternatives just squatted on crown
lands for example Trinidad and Guyana
It must be remembered that effort to establish an economic basis for independence was done
in colonial rule; it would have been more successful if the planters weren’t so obstructionist.
This refers to the right of a people or nation to determine their own affairs. The Caribbean
colonies were under the control of European powers.
However, after emancipation it was only inevitable that Caribbean people would develop the
ability to challenge this rule.
Political Enfranchisement
The many migrations of Caribbean people inclusive the Panama Canal, South America and
the Dutch Antilles the modern sugar plantations of Cuba, Puerto Rico and Santo Domingo
and other migrations into Europe due to the World Wars helped to develop a consciousness
of political and economic conditions in these countries and exposed workers and soldiers to
new and different ideas.
These individuals were unwilling to resume to lowly status in the social hierarchy due to
exposure to different political ideologies.
Moreover, due to Marcus Garvey black nationalist sentiment began to spread enabling
resistance.
In the 1930’s economic conditions had deteriorated to such levels that the region was
wracked by labour riots, strikes and social unrest.
This period saw the rise of labour leaders who eventually rose as political leaders, including
Uriah ‘Buzz’ Butler, Adrian Cola Rienzi & Captain A. A. Cipriani of T&T, Alexander
Bustamante and Norman Manley of Jamaica, Grantley Adams of Barbados and Nathaniel
Crichlow of Guyana all of whom developed Trade Union movements in the Caribbean.
While creole whites were involved initially it quickly developed into a working-class struggle
dedicated to improving the social conditions of the poor.
The trade labour unions naturally became the birthplaces of Caribbean party politics
To Union leaders it was clear the interests of labour had to be represented in the government
so that laws can be passed to protect their activities as well as worker’s rights.
Eventually Trade leaders began to comprise the legislature instead of the planter classes
forming a lobby for self-government and eventually independence.
Once Indian and African Caribbean individuals got elected to office the writing was on the
wall for Colonialism in the region.
Developing Geographic Awareness
Geographical Perspectives on Environment, Society and Culture
Traditional physical geography has for a long time asserted the dominant role the landscape
plays in influencing society and culture. While human and social geography stresses the
importance humans have to shape the landscape through breakthroughs.
Recently however the new postmodern perspective asserts that ‘people’ is not a simple term
to just define
Aboriginal people often have a perspective of geography which is different from let’s say a
urban one.
The postmodern outlook also emphasises that the environment is not a fixed entity meaning
that it changes overtime through its relationship between humans and the space around it.
Caribbean Perspectives on Environment
The colonial experience has left us with the perspective that humans should control and
dominate the environment.
Pre-Columbian perspectives differed immensely as it was the belief that the environment was
sacred, devoted to worship and should be left virtually untouched.
With the Europeans came a new perspective – as conquerors with new technological
advances they became better at controlling nature to produce tools, medicine and food hence
the idea of the environment as something to control became entrenched through colonization.
Through capitalism plantations, mines and ranches became an organized backdrop for the
activities of the wealthy and a source of raw materials.
Therefore, environmental perspectives solely depend on how directly related people are to the
importance of the Earth to their existence whether economically or spiritually.
Environmental Hazards
Natural events are termed Environmental Hazards when they have the potential to destroy
human life and property.
Natural Events are when such environmental occurrences occur away from human habitation.
Only when people and their property is harmed do we label them as environmental disasters.
Environmental Degradation
This is defined as the general way of describing loss of some degree of quality in the land, air
or waters around us. For instance, infertile soil or polluted rivers.
Pollution is a more specific term referring to the ways in which human beings have caused
the contamination of the environment through adding pollutants that harm human, plant and
animal life.
Natural processes of Environmental Change
The environment constantly changes especially through natural events.
These changes are cyclical for example the theory of plate tectonics states that continents
have been moving for millions of years causing volcanic activity and earthquakes.
Hurricanes also continue to wreak havoc on the landscape.
Environmental Disasters: Soil Erosion
Soil is formed by the breakdown of rocks over hundreds of years.
The rocks decompose into their inorganic materials which combine with vegetation, water,
air and humus to form soil.
Soil Erosion is defined as the removal of soil by wind, water or moving ice.
It is a natural process but human activity has served to accelerate this process.
It is a creeping hazard meaning that its occurrence is often not dramatic and may go
undetected as soil is hardly likely to be reused or recovered.
Social and Cultural Practices which Accelerate soil erosion: Deforestation
Since plant roots and vegetation hold soil together and leaves and branches often slow rainfall
when plants are removed soil is often left bare and is easily washed or blown away.
This can happen through:
Slash and Burn: practice to remove undergrowth which increases fertility because of the ash
but leaves the land bare leading to erosion
Overgrazing: occurs when animal numbers exceed the land’s ‘carrying capacity’; increasing
the likelihood that they will remove vegetation leaving soil bare.
Bulldozing: clearing lands like hillsides for development projects leaves land unprotected
with construction is in progress
The making of charcoal: common practice in places where fuel is expensive wee large
expanses of wooded landed is burnt to convert to charcoal.
Social and Cultural Practices which Accelerate soil erosion: Farming
Shifting cultivation: where plots are cleared and cultivated for a few years and left fallow
while another one is cleared for use. Since this is continuous land loses it fertility and its
ability to withstand erosion
Ploughing up and down hillsides as well as in neat rows helps to create channels which flow
from the top of a hill downwards or provides a path for the wind to blow away soil.
Effects of Soil Erosion
Removal of topsoil leaves immature subsoils which cannot sustain previous crop
production so land productivity decreases
Land may become useless; overgrown will secondary vegetation i.e. bush or carved
into gullies or ravines
Soil erosion near rivers from hillsides may increase sediment build-up on riverbeds
reducing river capacity.
When coupled with hurricanes, earthquakes or any other natural disaster eroded
hillsides are more prone to create landslides or mudslides.
Soil Conservation
This is meant to prevent erosion and restore eroded land to pre-erosion conditions
1. Afforestation: Vegetation or topsoil is brought to an eroded area to produce a dense
network of roots to bind the soil together, prevent water and wind erosion and create
new organic matter to make new soils.
2. Landscaping: An entire area may have to be re-sculpted into an undulated land before
afforestation
3. Agricultural Practices:
- Contour Ploughing: Tilling land across hillsides rather than down breaks potential
natural channels of water downslope
- Planting shelter belts: Lines of trees are planted at intervals along flat land
expanses to break the force of wind
- Intercropping/strip cropping: Neat rows between crops are avoided when different
crops are planted together at different angles
- Agroforestry: Crops such as Coffee, Cocoa, fruit trees and bananas are growing in
the forest co-existing with existing vegetation.
- Crop rotation: Each crop depletes different nutrients in the soil so different crops
are planted in succession rather than continuously so nutrients will regenerate
naturally
- Terraces: Building small walls or ridges around sloping land to prevent rainfall
from freely running downwards reducing the probability of soil erosion.
- Stubble mulching: Leaving stubble residues after harvesting on the field as long as
possible helps to reduce evaporation while covering the soil
Soil Erosion and Poverty
While soil erosion is natural accelerated soil erosion in Caribbean countries today is a
tremendous social and cultural phenomenon
In countries that are very poor i.e., Haiti people are mostly driven by their need to survive and
fulfil basic needs and have no realization of the long term effects associated with that.
Deforestation from making charcoal and cutting forests to make farmland reduces soil
fertility over time.
Reduction of yields, resultant flooding etc. are seen as the plight of the poor so soil erosion
becomes a problem made worse by poverty because since the poor don’t have enough power
soil conservation doesn’t get profiled.
Some solutions may include:
- Population Control
- Productive employment
- Meeting basic social welfare needs,
- Better income distribution
Drought
Drought is a temporary feature of climate where an unusually long period of rainfall is below
‘normal’ levels in that region causing severe depletion of the water available to all living
beings
Drought is a natural phenomenon and may occur due to changes in relief, size and location as
well as global changes in whether patterns.
Size, Relief and Location
Small territories such as Antigua don’t generate much convection rainfall; accompanied by a
flat landscape reduces the likelihood of relief rainfall so are at immense risks of drought
Large countries such as Guyana very near the equator have frequent rainfall throughout the
year, but due to the largeness there may be regional variations
In the Greater and Lesser Antilles rainfall is influenced by the north-east trades. Where winds
rise over mountains there is much relief rainfall.
The physical environment conserves and stores water that can be available in dry seasons i.e.
Groundwater store. This seeps to maintain rivers at a base level and when this is affected
drought is extremely pronounced. Like erosion drought is a creeping hazard as the store may
prevent detection for a while.
Historical Context
Analysing the dominant and subordinate ideas about the family in the Caribbean
- Amerindian traditions of raising the family have disappeared for example, initiation
rites of young Kalinago boys as warriors
- African extended networks during slavery ensured familial support through matrifocal
relationships and extended kin
- The European dominant idea of the nuclear family was brought to the Caribbean
entrenched in the society yet most of the population has matrifocal families
- Indians brought the extended family through the joint household with a strong
patriarchal family structure with emphasis on early marriage
The Myth of the Nuclear Family
The ethnocentric notion of the co-residential nuclear family has been indoctrinated into the
Caribbean psyche
European scholars interpreted the diversity of Caribbean family systems as inferior and
unstable later labelling our females as promiscuous and our males as irresponsible
Missionaries and authorities seemed to believe marriage as the salvation for the region
Despite our many single parent, unwed couples, visiting arrangements, several partners and
matrifocal households the bias towards the nuclear family is at the heart of these other
systems as negative
This ethnocentric stereotype that males are to be the authority figures and women are to be
the homemakers has also added a portrayal that any other arrangement is unstable and
irregular
Caribbean Family Forms
The diversity of Caribbean family forms has been theorized in to originate in three different
ways:
1. African Retentions: Matrifocal families are typical of West Africa where polygamy is
practiced and wives are accommodated in separate households. This view
acknowledges slavery as a factor which altered the family structure somewhat
2. Slavery: Others believe that cultural retentions such as family life couldn’t have
survived through slavery. The unions that the enslaved were forced to undergo
influenced the family forms we see today. Marriage was rare, cohabitation was
irregular & children remained with their mothers.
3. Economic Thesis: Which states that since slavery ended more than 150 years ago
other factors such as poor women wanting to enter sexual relations for money. Since
men were not usually very wealthy women had to seek successive relationships to
make money. Children were not seen as liabilities but means for the household to
survive. Critics of this thesis easily state that affairs happen at all social strata.
Despite the diversity of our Caribbean family forms they are normal for the people using
them and fulfil the same function any family anywhere should provide to its members.
The main focus of Caribbean family forms isn’t the composition of the household like in the
nuclear family, but the extended network of kin which arises.
Practices such as godparenthood and fictive kinship (ex. ‘Aunty Karen’ when she’s actually
your mother’s friend), are chosen to provide support to the child and become as close as kin
in some cases.
The practice of child shifting i.e., leaving a child with a relative while a parent migrates, etc.
reflects the idea that the extended family is meant to shoulder responsibilities.
An analogy is for example family ownership of land. No one member can claim land
ownership so cooperation and shared responsibility for it is essential. This concept is alien in
most European societies.
Functionalist Perspective on Family
Functionalists say that the family should carry out several functions for order, stability and
harmony in society, including:
- Reproduction
- Socialization
- Economic function
- Provision of love and a sense of belongingness
These functionalist ideas and values provide a basis for the common interpretation of the
institution of the family across the region. The family is seen as the basic unit of society. If
these functions are carried out in an optimal manner and if everyone plays a role, then
families would be happy, and society would not be threatened by a breakdown of social
order.
Marxist/Conflict Perspective on the Family
For the conflict theorist, families are associated with exploitation, oppression and domination.
Nuclear families in particular are seen as products of capitalism where labour has to move
where employment is located leaving behind the extended family. Conflict theorists also
argue that the values attributed to nuclear family units are a result of the values imposed by
the rich and powerful in the society.
The nuclear family form also fits into the capitalist plans in that there is a sexual division of
labour where the man works outside, and the woman stays at home and carries out the roles
of wife, mother and homemaker.
Conflict theorists believe that the “assigning of roles” in a family has contributed to family
oppression, abuse and violence. This is because what results is an unequal distribution of
power that jeopardizes gender relations and even produces generational conflict.
Even children are affected by this assignment of roles as they are expected to be obedient and
subservient and many of them are powerless because their voices are silenced.
Impact of the Family
This can be assessed through the effect on the individual, the group and through other
institutions and is based on the norms and values the family type has.
Individual
Individuals in each family will have different perceptions of the norms and values instilled on
them by it. For example, the patriarchal structure of the Indian extended family instils that
males must be obeyed so a girl in the family has a much different experience than the eldest
son.
Groups
The idea of kin impacts different groups as follows:
- African families: Kin in these families include anyone related by blood and by fictive
kinship ties. Kin can be perceived as beneficial as they usually help members of the
family for example through remittances but can be seen as burdensome if you are
expected to help an endless succession of family members
- Muslim families: Kinship here also includes the idea of polygamy. In the Caribbean
this practice isn’t intense but when it occurs such families are scrutinized and often
restricts social interaction with outsiders.
- Women: Caribbean women often see themselves as locked into certain predetermined
roles such as the caregiver/nurturer. Some come home and basically have a second
shift of doing domestic chores. These roles are often disadvantage in comparison to
men & is an example of gender socialization
Institutions
Ideas about the social institution of the family can affect other institutions and even the
family itself as dominant and alternative values and norms often compete for legitimacy.
The family: The nuclear family has been at odds for a long time with the ideas of Caribbean
family forms. Functionalist perspective, where the family is seen as an agent which ensures
stability has been misinterpreted as scholars often see the diversity of Caribbean families
while not accepting the fact that they have the same functions as other types. However as of
recent new more expanded views of the family have been accepted as legitimate.
Education
The family impacts education in many ways. For example, parental support is proven in most
cases to improve academic performance. Also, research evidence has proven that lower
socio-economic families are more reluctant to interact with the school environment.
Education
This institution is primarily concerned with socializing members of the society into the
norms, knowledge and skills to which it deems important (just like religion and the family)
Education can be through primary socialization (informal i.e. living in society) or through
secondary socialization (teaching through formal means like in school)
Historical Context of Education
Formal education during slavery was only formal and meant for Europeans.
The Spanish however gave religious instruction to their slaves while the British felt that any
type of education would increase salve capacity to think increasing the probability of
rebellion.
After 1834 the Negro Education Act that elementary schools would be built in the British
Caribbean. The rationale behind this was these schools would help ex-slaves make the
transition towards a free society.
Elements such as reading, writing and arithmetic were encouraged. The Bible was the main
text and English values were heavily steeped through songs, poems, etc. (remember Colonial
Girls School).
Elementary education meant that the education wasn’t meant to go any further to primary or
secondary because the planter class felt that it may upset the social order (which it kinda did)
They were a few secondary schools with charged fees based on the English classical
curriculum.
Many Caribbean scholars can through the system to attend prestigious universities such as
Oxford and Cambridge and returned as lawyers, writers and scholars who challenged the
colonial system (told you).
Ideas of education from the Caribbean perspectives in these times included:
1. Education was the primary means to upwards social mobility
2. Elites sought to block primary and secondary education as it was believed that the
status quo would be damaged. The general populace were upset at these tactics to
prevent their success.
3. Secondary curricula was steeped in Euro-centric values and culture as the belief was
that only education in British ideals would develop us.
4. Only the ‘bright’ students should be taught at the secondary level and beyond as
shown through streaming and the Common Entrance Examinations.
5. More emphasis was placed at going to ‘good’ schools as it was believed that only at
such schools could children receive high achievement
Less dominant ideas include:
1. Educating students with disabilities is to house such students separately where they
can get individualized attention. The idea of mainstreaming students is less popular
hence in our system mechanisms to care for students with disabilities are in large part
absent
2. Home schooling is undertaken by families who believe that teaching students in
public schools exposes them to wide variety of unsavoury occurrences (violence,
etc.).
Purposes of Education
In purpose of education right after slavery was to inculcate English customs and values so
that governing ex-slaves would be easier.
To the enslaved though education was seen as a primary means of upward social mobility – a
belief which is still here with us today.
The 20th Century belief is more complex as now it is mandatory for children to be educated
the idea is that not all children will contribute equally to the society after they have been
educated so differentiation practices such as streaming to ensure ‘bright’ children would get
qualifications.
Tertiary education was seen the same way as only the academic elite were expected to go to
university ensuring them status as a part of the intelligentsia (professional and intellectual
class)
It can be observed therefore that education organizes the opportunities and life chances of
children.
Another view is that education contributes to social cohesion, enabling people to come
together. This view was seen through the ideas of 19th century colonial authorities who
believed that if people were exposed to a similar curriculum and values, they probability of
socialization and integration into the society would increase
Education was also seen as a means economic development as it grants skills which ensures a
productive workforce seeing people as human capital
Recently postmodern thinkers have associated human development to education increasing
peoples’ chances to develop themselves etc. (see Mod 2)
Education in modern times is seen as a human right for all no matter the disabilities and
disadvantages.
Impact of Education
Individuals
It is expected to confer social mobility on individuals. However, the tremendous weight of
credentials to achieving mobility can confer low self-esteem and feelings of inadequacy
which can lead to under-achievement.
Groups
There are different impacts on different socio-economic groups. Theorists say schools have a
middle-class bias and are intrinsically set up to reward children who already have the cultural
capital to succeed in the academic world. This can be seen through how middle-class children
can code-switch while speaking which offers them more opportunities for interaction and
varied experience as contrasted with working class children who cannot code switch from
creole which reduces the likelihood of academic success.
Institution
Religion and education in the Caribbean perspective are intrinsically linked as many
denominational churches made serious attempts to educate children in the colonial era. The
Jesuits, Baptists etc. have produced very high demand schools which place a major focus on
religion therefore religious instruction is emphasised in the socialization of the students.
Religion
"Men in every society throughout the ages have pondered over questions dealing with such
matters as existence, purpose and divinity. To help explain the unexplainable, provide a sense
of purpose in life and make the unknown future less threatening, every society' has developed
the institution of religion"(Campbell, 2002).
Historical Context of Religion
Ideas of the dominant class usually are perpetuated in religious beliefs. The system of
religion in the Caribbean has been a struggle between the ideas of the dominant Europeans
and colonized peoples.
Syncretism and Hybridization have re-created the institutions of religion primarily through
the Africans and Amerindians adopting many European forms and practices into their own
traditions from slavery until now.
Our peoples did accept the religious beliefs of the smaller denominations who came as
missionaries so Caribbean countries have wide varieties of Christianity.
Religion is influenced by the stratification of society where Europeans and Coloureds
normally attended mainstream religions and more syncretic religious forms were associated
with the poorer groups. Dual membership often existed where people would have formal
alliances with a mainstream religion but still would practice traditional forms such as in Cuba
with Santeria.
After emancipation syncretic religious forms flourished such as Myal as well as African ones
such as Vodun. Laws were often passed to restrict these practices such as the Obeah Act in
Jamaica which outlawed its practice.
Resistance also created other distinctive worldviews such as through Rastafari formed in the
1930’s in Jamaica based on Marcus Garvey’s philosophies.
In the 19th Century in Trinidad, Guyana and Suriname there were Hindus belonging to
various sects who have schools today. Many Hindus were also converted to Presbyterianism
due to the Canadian missions there who marketed it as a means towards upward mobililty
US missionaries especially in the last half of the 20th century have brought their unique
brand of Pentecostalism and Fundamentalism to the region.
Impact of Religion
Individuals
Religion can be a source of oppression. For example the oppression of women in almost all
mainstream and alternative religions
Groups
Religion can help groups maintain solidarity and keep their traditions alive in the face of
globalizing western culture. For example the Garifuna still practice many of their African
customs today.
Institutions
Religion is seen as a major factor in the establishment of the Justice system as countries with
different religious systems have usually varying Justice systems. For example Sharia Law vs
Western legal system based on Christianity
Some religious laws have various tenets which bind their believers which can affect
interaction with other institutions for example Jehovah’s Witnesses do not believe in blood
transfusion altering relationships with heath care professionals
Religion also has an immense ability to generate conflict in a society especially among Plural
societies.
The Justice System
This refers to the ideas and beliefs a society have about protecting and preserving the rights
and obligations of citizens through the political and Judicial framework in a country.
Political Framework: idea that citizens entrust power to representatives to make decisions,
defend and uphold their interests
Legal Framework: the system of laws which are fair to all persons and enshrined within a
constitution.
Historical Context
The Justice system in the Caribbean evolved out of our history of colonialism, resistance and
independence.
As Captives the native people were treated so badly that in 1512 with the help of Montesinos
and Las Casas, The Laws of Burgos were created to help protect them from the harsh
treatment, convert them to Christianity but strangely still allowed Ecomienda. These ‘rights’
were in large part ignored.
Under slavery, African people had no rights and were classified as chattel (property) while
Europeans through being white possessed power over them. In Spanish Colonies La Siete
Partidas and in the French Colonies the Code Noir each laid down laws including provisions
for slave property. In the British Colonies Assemblies were established made of the planter
class who enacted laws to control, subdue and coerce slaves
This is why Caribbean law has such heavy sanctions for property offences in its legal
systems.
There was no true fairness as laws inclusive of penalties and rewards were based on the rigid
system of racial stratification in the society.
There were however alternative ideas and resistance movements threatened the stability of
the colony such as missionaries who often attempted to educate Africans to some extent and
tried to instil some semblance of Human rights to the African population – not necessarily
which would result in freedom.
The military nature of the Haitian Revolution in 1804 which resulted in the freedom of
Haitian Africans ensured that the justice system there became dominated by fear and
intimidation despite Her people having their rights enshrined with a constitution.
Emancipation occurred for the rest of the Caribbean after 1834 and eventually blacks and
coloureds won representation in colonial assemblies. Independence resulted in most
Caribbean countries having some form of the Westminster Model of government.
To achieve political enfranchisement, we were forced to adopt European judicial and
legislative systems.
The evolution of our justice system originated from the strong insistence of ensuring basic
human rights for the mass of our citizens inclusive of freedom of expression, of assembly,
respect of private property, fair trial, vote and run for public office.
However due to stratification of our society there are entrenched inequalities of the lower
income brackets in terms of acquiring the full representation of the Justice system.
Functionalist Perspective of the Justice System
Functionalists believe that values about justice, equality and fairness are universally
acclaimed as good and form the basic framework for society. Society has to have ways of
dealing with those who break the laws of society because they contribute to disorder and
disharmony leading to chaos and confusion.
Functionalist created the institutions of the justice system to take care of such deviants- by
one or more of the following, punishment, deterrence or rehabilitation. The police force and
the court system have a role to perform. Deviant behaviour is explained is explained largely
in terms of breakdown in the family socialization process or how individuals react to changes
in society. For example, the anomie theory says that there are socially accepted means of
obtaining the rewards of society but those who cannot access the rewards through these
means will try other socially.
Conflict/Marxist Perspective on Justice System
According to Marxist thought the justice system is another institution that forms part of the
state apparatus. It functions to maintain the wealthy in power and by extension seeks to
oppress others and discriminate against them.
The view is that the inequalities of society are brought on by capitalism which helps to isolate
poorer class who cannot access better jobs. So the acts of crime that these individuals may
commit could be regarded as a rebellion against their situation.
Marxists believe that there is a superstructure that includes the police service and the law
courts which functions to control the activities of the poor. Criminal statistics are used as a
device to blame social problems on the working class. This is evidence of unequal law
enforcement, says Marxist, because the many crimes of the wealthy go either unreported or
unpunished. In sum, social order is imposed by the powerful on the powerless and is not
based on shared values. The justice system serves the interest of the elites and is not about
social integration.
Impact of the Justice System on Society
Individuals
Laws may or may not respect an individual’s rights to cultural differences. Ex. A man’s
cultural right to have several wives may not be respected legally
Laws be respected legally but not at another organization such as a school. Ex. A girl’s legal
right to wear a skirt 5 inches above her knees may not respected.
Groups
Constitutions may restrict the rights of certain groups as they see fit. Ex. Persons under 18 are
not allowed to vote.
Laws may also discriminate between certain groups ex. People over 65 are allowed to retire
while in certain jobs people are not allowed to retire early with benefits (i.e., ageism).
Institutions
Claims of justice may be represented to protect members of institutions such as the Family
through Family Court, etc.
Interacting with the Wider World
Imperialism and Colonization
The Age of Imperialism began with the coming of the Europeans who conquered lands and
established colonies in carved up regions in the world. These powers ruled their subjects
through fear and psychological conditioning to promote European culture as superior
During colonialism territories became settled in European attitudes, culture and political
systems which became hegemonic in the Caribbean. The metropole (mother country) exerted
all influence in the colony while the colony wasn’t allowed to have its own identity.
The colonizer instilled economic patterns which only allowed it to become profitable while
instilling a belief that colonized would never achieve equality.
The culture of the colonizer was also regarded with praise and reverence while the culture of
the colonized was met with disdain.
Neocolonial and Postcolonial Societies
The dominant attitudes and cultural norms today still reflect the metropole rather than the
periphery. There is therefore a belief that the legacy of the colonizer is still hegemonic
despite our independence.
Indigenous efforts to regain legitimacy of our syncretic cultures have been largely ignored
Also, Multinational companies also threaten to hinder whatever independence we do have. As
they normally export their profits outside the region after ‘investing’ here. There is a general
imbalance in trading relationships. These relationships between the ex-colonizer and the
excolonized today are labelled as neocolonial.
Postcolonial society is a term to describe how these neocolonial relationships of continued
dominance and subjugation affect people in the ex-colonies.
Influence of Extra-regional countries on the Caribbean
Postcolonial theory shows how the dominance of the West is perpetuated, resisted and
integrated into Caribbean society and culture through the interactions between the metropole
a periphery through socialization and can be broken down into:
1. Consumption Patterns
2. Creative Expression
3. Political Influences
4. Migration
5. Sport
6. Tourism
Consumption Patterns
Western countries have profoundly influenced consumption patterns in the Caribbean.
Colonial policies for many years have skewered our economic relationships with them by
prohibiting us from Manufacturing and encouraging dependency.
Despite attempts to combat this people still view European products as superior so we can
conclude that this reflects a mindset privileging western values.
This can be analysed through:
- The value of assessing what is foreign whether through clothes, ideas or music – is
somehow better than the local alternatives is viewed as a sort of self hate imposed by
the colonized on the colonizer
- The extreme importance placed on being modern. Having the most up to date western
products is a matter of course because since the West is the pacesetter we just have to
follow the trend
- Building social capital through brand names etc. has been seen as a way to confer
approval from peers. Those without brands are seen with disdain as losers.
- The ‘Universal’ Caribbean feeling that the US is a must go place where it is even said
that having a holiday visa is a status symbol because ‘foreign’ is the centre of the
world
Creative Expression
Our expressions are unique among themselves and show strong influences especially among
extra-regional territories through:
- Festivals
- Music
- Theatre
- Cuisine
Which both effect and have been affected by Extra-regional territories.
Festivals
Effects on the Caribbean by extra-regional territories:
Western territories and more specifically former colonizers directly influence our
society and culture through observances of certain religious days such as Easter and
Christmas. We also celebrate them in a similar way in the Caribbean including the
immense role mass media and commercialization have on certain religious days.
Secular festivals such as New Years’ Eve, Fathers’ Day and Valentines day have
penetrated our culture due specifically to the US. Halloween hasn’t yet penetrated but
is on the rise. All these celebrations have also been immensely commercialized as
well due to mass media.
Impacts on Extra Regional Countries
In the Caribbean Diaspora, festivals have come to play a big role in the lives of the
migrants. In North America (Canada and USA), England and elsewhere, large
Caribbean festivals are staged featuring our music, food, craft, fashion and general
culture.
NOTTING HILL CARNIVAL (England)
This carnival is staged in Notting Hill, London on the last weekend in August (since 1956). It
began with the black immigrants from W.I especially from Trinidad. It served as a form of
uniting the immigrants who were facing racism, unemployment, poor housing and general
oppression which led to the suppression of their self esteem.
Hill festival reflected a blend of old and new - the Caribbean carnival with the English
summer. It became the vehicle for protest and demonstration on part of immigrant but later
became the model for other different and smaller festivals. It helped to focus on and
encourage respect for Caribbean traditions through the melding of Calypso and reggae.
CARIBANA (Canada)
Every summer, Toronto (Canada) blazes with calypso, steel pan and masquerade costumes
during the annual Caribbean Festival. Caribana is the largest Caribbean festival in North
America. The two-week Festival attracts over a million participants annually, including
hundreds of thousands of American tourists. Among the highlights is the Caribbean Parade,
one of the largest in North America. Thousands of costumed masqueraders and dozens of
trucks carrying live soca , calypso, steel pan, reggae and salsa artists jam the 1.5 km parade
route all day
Outdoor concerts and glamorous dances round out the entertainment. Caribana was created in
1967. Based on Trinidad Carnival, the Festival exhibits costumes of Jamaica, Guyana, the
Bahamas. Toronto's Caribana Festival is a complex hybrid inheriting aspects from most of
the region. Coincidentally, Toronto's Caribana Festival falls on the anniversary of the
emancipation from slavery in Trinidad (August 1, 1834).
LABOUR DAY IN BROOKLYN (USA)
The West Indian American Day Carnival is the biggest parade in New York with 3 million
participants each year. The parade depicts costumes, illustrating beauty and pageantry with
many masqueraders and live performers. The parade begins at 1 am and ends at 6 There are
live performers in front of the viewing stage at the Brooklyn Library.
The people of the Caribbean have exported their carnival traditions to Canada, England,
several US cities. However the New York version of this celebration far exceeds any like
celebration in the US.
Music
Caribbean music has developed from African, European and Asian mix with African music
having the dominant role.
The African characteristics in Caribbean music are:
- close relationship between rhythm and speech tone (as in calypso)
- spontaneity in rhythm and melody
- willingness of performers to extemporize
- polyphony: emphasis on many voices and parts in music and the bringing these voices
in harmony as well as keeping them separate
- arrangement of complicated rhythms
Impact of Extra-Regional Countries on music
Most of our successful musical forms have been developed through themes of resistance from
our history of oppression through colonization and stratification explain the fact they
(calypso, ska, reggae) originated among the poor whether Trinidad or Jamaica.
Reggae has always been associated with resistance and Rastafari as its message of defiance
against British authority has linked together all who have been oppressed likewise Calypso
sought to expose inequalities like racism and political/religious oppression from the Roman
Catholic Church in Trinidad with wit and satire.
Impact on Extra-regional territories
Steelband men or pannists have gone abroad and settled and have taught citizens and tune the
pans. Today steel band music is on the curriculum of some schools in America and the
fashioning of the pans is a growing skill, which has potential to contribute to the economies
of these countries in North America and Europe. Oc saw over 600 pannists from Europe,
North America and Caribbean taking part in International Steel band Festival. There is the
Pan European Association promoter development of the pan in Europe.
In Zambia, Sunsplash is staged in Lusaka each year. Reggae music is being used to market
products like Levi jeans, it is being used in movies-arid has been incorporated into other
musical forms like Jan rock. The University of Vermont even has a course in the Rhetoric of
Reggae.
The staging of Reggae Sunsplash festival has caught on in all parts of the world Japan and
North America attesting to the roots that reggae has spread to all parts of the world. Reggae is
now incorporated into music of other countries e.g. Sayoko ha Sukiyaki to reggae, in
Nicaragua protest songs against the government.
Cuisine
Extra-regional influence on the Caribbean
- Cuisine in the Caribbean has a high degree of creative adaptations of the food
traditions of Europe, India, China and Pre-Columbian peoples including their
creolization
- For example the use of saltfish or salted cod in Jamaica has its origin from the
importation of slat or smoked fish from the British colony of Canada to feed the
slaves. Also other culinary traditions like the consumption of intestines (tripe) and
other animal parts not prime from eating originated via slavery
- Rise of Western style ‘fast foods’
Our influence on Extra-regional territories
- There has been limited acceptance of Caribbean culinary practices, foods, seasonings
and beverages in mainstream America and Europe. The little acceptance there is tends
to focus in the large cities where there are concentrations of Caribbean people-
Miami, London, Toronto, New York. These food and products are largely purchased
by the immigrants.
- Evidence that Caribbean foods are not widely accepted can be seen in the lack of
representative in menus across UK, USA and Canada
- In Britain places like Brixton market however imported Caribbean produce has
become a familiar sight and an important part of the economy.
Political Influence
Extra-regional influence on us
- In the 60’s and 70’s while the region was gaining independence the model of
government that was instilled was the Westminster system. This happened throughout
the British Empire and today these independent former British Governments make up
the Commonwealth
- This system is a parliamentary government where the head of government is the
Prime Minister and depends on the parliamentary body for his/her position meaning
that there is no clear separation of powers between the executive (cabinet, PM) and
the legislature (MP’s, senate, etc). In Constructional monarchies there is usually a
head of state (Governor General) with mostly ceremonial powers.
- During the era of decolonization, this system was imposed on us without our input.
Two Houses were installed – the lower house (House of Representatives) and the
upper House (Senate).
- The electoral system imposed was First Past the Post where candidates run for a seat
in parliament based on constituency. The candidate who polls most vote in a
constituency wins. Therefore, for party to win the election they must get majority
seats
Our influence on them
- Political influence of Caribbean on outside world is based mainly on the issue of
migration that Caribbean nationals have been associated with from the beginning of
the century.
- Faced with this large immigrant population, the population is in a position to form
groups to influence policy making on issues such as education, unionization,
discrimination.
- Immigrants are usually supporters of the status quo and so they generally accept the
norms and values of these societies. They form a pool of voters or whom politicians
rely on to vote in a conservative manner ex Cubans and Dominicans in Miami.
- The Caribbean impact in politics is quite evident in the US, in the number of state and
city legislators of Caribbean heritage during national elections. The first African
American woman to sit in congress and to run for the presidency was a Caribbean
national - Shirley Chisholm. The first non-white chairman of Joint Chief of Staffs and
Secretary of State was a Caribbean - Colin Powell.
Migration
Extra-regional influence on us
The Culture of migration that characterizes Caribbean societies sees migration as means
better life. This has resulted in major cities in the North Atlantic (USA, Canada, England) are
heavily populated with Caribbean nationals
Positive effects include
- Training of skilled individuals who migrate and contribute to the Caribbean
- Remittances from foreign workers
Negative effects include
- Brain Drain
- Racism and unfair treatment in these countries
- Injustices felt by seasonal workers who are segregated by the general populace on
orchards or handed down menial jobs
- The mindset that better opportunities lie by going Abroad
Our influence on extra-regional territories
In US the Caribbean nationals are more socio-economically mobile than African- Americans
and Hispanic (New York's Newsday Newspaper Survey). Thus they represent not only very
significant power (over 1 billion per annum) but they generate jobs and contribute to the
development of the areas they choose to reside in.
- Caribbean nationals helped to rebuild the war tom economies of Europe (i.e France)
- Brain gain: nationals educated at expense of Caribbean states migrate to developed
countries where they establish themselves thus contributing to their economy
- Carnival celebrations help to generate millions of dollars to the economy of Canada
and England when Caribbean festivals are held; boosts tourism; promotion of sales for
businesses
- Migrant farm workers have worked in USA and Canada help to harvest crops before
winter
- Offshore banking in the region which provide tax haven for clients in metropolitan
countries- Cayman Islands, Bahamas, Turks and Caicos, Virgin Islands
Sport
Sports and recreation: cricket, soccer, tennis, netball as well as maypole dances (European
influence); basketball, hip hop, rap, American football. Halloween (North American
influence)
We are pace setters in sports particularly in cricket and track and field
- In cricket we invented ‘cutting’ batting as well as rejuvenated the sport in the 1930’s
- In Track and field Jamaica has a long-standing tradition of doing extremely well…
Usain Bolt/Asafa Powell etc.
Tourism
Tourism Extra-regional impacts on us
Positive impact: Foreign exchange earnings retention (cultural/heritage tourism),
infrastructural development understanding and appreciation of ones culture
Negative impact: Prostitution, drug trafficking, environmental pollution (beaches, damage to
coral reefs, erosion through hotel construction, destruction of natural vegetation, prejudice,
landownership
Rastafarianism
Impacts
- it was one of the first full-fledged movements to confront issues of racial identity and
prejudice all over the world with reggae music
- Incited Jamaica's middle-class blacks and then people all over the world to reflect on
the importance of their African heritage