Sphere Rod Modeling and Analysis of Electric Field Distribution in Air
Sphere Rod Modeling and Analysis of Electric Field Distribution in Air
net/publication/241312392
CITATIONS READS
18 3,350
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Leandros Maglaras on 26 May 2014.
Abstract: - This paper investigates the Modeling and Analysis of the electric field distribution in air gaps,
stressed by the breakdown voltages, under different geometries and arrangements, with Finite Element
Method. The influence on the electric field distribution, caused by the insertion of a dielectric insulated plate,
called Barrier, between the electrodes, is presented. The average, the maximum and the minimum value of the
field strength along the gap axis, when the breakdown voltage stresses the air gap are recorded and analyzed.
The results show that the distribution of the field in the gap axis is strongly affected by the geometry and the
arrangement of the gap. The average and the minimum value of the field strength along the gap axis, decreases
when the gap length increases, while the maximum value of the field strength or the Field Factor in the gap,
functions differently, strongly depending on the gap geometry. In a non-uniform field arrangement, such as
rod - plane, a charged dielectric plate, placed between the electrodes of the air gap, influences the distribution
of the electric field. The simulation results are compared with relative results of referent work.
Key-Words: - Breakdown Voltages, air gaps, numerical analysis, Field stregth, Barrier Effect.
n=(G/(R+1)+sqr((G/R+1)^2+8)/4, (7)
Figure 2. Rod - plate air gap Sphere – sphere, rod – plate and rod - rod
arrangements, with different dimensions of the
sphere, the plate and the rod, different length of the From fig 5 and 6 it results that in the rod-plate
air gap and no barrier between the electrodes, have arrangement the field is much more inhomogeneous
been modeled and analyzed. The field distribution than in the rod-rod and sphere-sphere arrangements.
along axis of the gap is demonstrated in figures With the same value of average field strength, the
below, in relation to the breakdown voltages. Most of maximum value of the field strength is much more
the values of breakdown voltages are measurement higher in the rod-plate air gap, and especially in the
data from experimental referent work [5], [6], [7], [8], arrangement with grounded plate. In the rod-plate
[9], [11], [12] air gap with grounded rod, the field is less
inhomogeneous. The inhomogeneity of the field
ELECTRIC FIELD DISTRIBUTION ALONG THE is one of the basic reasons for the breakdown
AXIS IN AIR GAPS OF DIFFERENT GEOMETRIES. voltage to have different values for different
Eav=1. arrangements and the same gap length. This is shown
in figure 7, for 3 different air gap arrangements.
6
Ffield strength E/Eav
5
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGES OF AIR GAPS
4 Sphere- sphere
70
3 Rod - rod
2 Rod - plate 60
1 plate-
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE KV
50
plate
0
0 12.5 25 37.5 50 40
sphere-
Distance from rod mm sphere
30
20
rod -plate
Figure 5. The field strength distribution along the axis 10
of the gap for three basic small air gap arrangements:
sphere-sphere, rod-rod and rod-plate. Eav=1 for all 0
11
13
15
17
19
7
3.1.1. The sphere - sphere air gaps.
STRENGTH
Emax/Eav
6
5
4
3
The sphere– sphere air gaps are the gaps with the less
2 inhomogeneous electric field distribution along the
1 axis of the gap (figure 8).
0
10 20 30 40 50 60
The models, which have been analyzed, are models
GAP LENGTH mm with sphere diameters of 100 and 250 mm. The
breakdown voltage of the gap increases almost
ROD-ROD. ROD DIAMETER 10 mm
linearly with the gap length, while the field strength
ROD-PLATE GAP. ROD DIAMETER 10 mm. PLATE GROUNDED distribution depends mainly on the gap length.
ROD-PLATE GAP, ROD DIAMETER 10 mm, ROD GROUNDED The maximum value of field strength at breakdown
SPHERE - SPHERE GAP. SPHERE DIAMETER 45 mm
voltage changes slightly with the gap length (figure
9). In the sphere – sphere air gaps the field along the
axis is almost homogeneous. The very small
Figure 6. The maximum value of field strength along inhomogeneity of the field depends mainly on the gap
the axis of the air gap for three basic air gap length, and secondary on the sphere diameter
arrangements: sphere-sphere, rod-rod and rod-plate. The values of breakdown voltage are from referent
Results are from the F.E. Analysis work.
SPHERE SPHERE AIR GAP. SPHERE DIAMETER 100 SPHERE SPHERE AIR GAP. SPHERE
mm. DIAMETER 100 mm.
GAP STRESSED BY BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE
35 140
FIELD STRENGTH ALONG THE AXIS OF
4000 120
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE KV
AXIS OF THE GAP FOR THE
3500 G=5 mm 100
1G=10 m
THE GAP KV/m
3000 27
80
G=20 mm
2500 G=30 mm
60
g=40mm 23
2000
G=50mm 40
1500 G=80 mm 19
20
1000
15 0
15
45
75
9
0
0.
0.
0.
10 20 30 40 50
0.
0.
0.
Figure 8. Sphere-sphere air gap. Field strength Figure 10. Sphere-sphere air gap. The maximum, the
distribution along axis of the gap is shown for minimum, and the average field strength along the
different lengths of the gap, when the gap is stressed axis of the gap are shown in relation to the breakdown
by the breakdown voltage. Sphere diameter is 100 voltage of the gap (Vb). Sphere diameter is 100 mm.
mm. Results from the F.E.Analysis.
300
AXIS AT BREAKDOWN
VOLTAGE KV/cm
250
25
200
20
150
100
15
50
10 0
25 50 75 100 125 150 175
GAP LENGTH mm
Emax Emin
Eav Vb
Πολυωνυµική (Emax)
The maximum value of field strength (between 30 Figure 11. Sphere–sphere air gap model. Field
and 33 KV/cm) appears on both electrodes. It depends strength distribution. The continuous lines are
mainly on the sphere diameter and changes slightly equipotentials, and the arrows lengths are
with the gap length. The average field strength proportional to the field strength values. Colors
decreases almost linearly with the gap length are in connection with the density of the field.
3.1.2 The rod – rod air gap. 3.1.3. The rod-plate air gap.
Although the rod-rod air gap is a symmetric A rod-plate air gap is a non-symmetric
arrangement, the electric field between the rods is arrangement. The electric field between the
much more inhomogenous than in the sphere- electrodes is more inhomogenous than in other
sphere arrangement. The grade of inhomogeniety air gaps. The grade of inhomogeniety depends on
depends mainly on the rod dimensions and the rod and plate dimensions, as well as on the
secondary on the gap length. The experimental gap length. The F.E. Analysis results, in relation with
results for the breakdown DC and AC voltages the experimental results for the values of breakdown
and the F.E. Analysis results for the field strength voltages in the small rod – plate air gaps stressed by
values are shown in the figure 12. AC voltages are shown in the figure 14.
ROD - ROD AIR GAP. ROD DIAMETER 10 mm ROD - PLATE AIR GAP. ROD 6.5 m m , PLATE
50 m m
Eav DC FIELD FACTOR
50 80
Emax DC
5
45
25
35
55
69
89
04
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE KV
FIELD STRENGTH
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
2.
70
40
20000 30000 Vb
35 Emin DC
60 18000
KV/cm
30 25000
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE V
Eav, AC 16000
The average and the maximum value of field strength It is obvious that in the small rod-plate air gaps, the
decrease when the gap length increases up to 8 cm, average and the minimum field strength values
and then tend to achieve steady values, decrease strongly when the air gap length increases,
The model, which has been analyzed with the Finite while the maximum field strength has an almost
Element Analysis, is shown at figure 13. steady value.
Plate
Figure 13. Rod –rod air gap model. Field strength Figure 15. Rod – plate air gap model. Field strength
distribution distribution
3.1.4. The plate-plate air gap. barrier. The distribution of the electric charge on the
A plate-plate air gap is a symmetric arrangement with barrier influences greatly the field distribution in the
an almost homogeneous electric field along the axis gap. The influence depends on the magnitude and the
of the gap. duration of the voltage. In case of an impulse voltage
Plate - plate air gap. Plate diameter 50 mm
of very short duration the accumulated charge
produces a high voltage, about equal to the rod
26 35 voltage at the center of the barrier.. [5], [6], [7], [8],
Eav [14], [17].
BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE KV
FIELD STREGTH KV/cm
24
30 KV/cm
The field strength distribution in the gap changes and
22
25 Emax this influences the value of the breakdown voltage of
20 KV/cm
20
the gap. The influence depends on the gap length and
18 Vb max the position of the barrier in the gap. This is called
KV
16
15
the Barrier Effect. [5], [7], [9], [10], [11], [15].
14 10
8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
VOLTAGE
FLASHOV
FIELD
E/Eav
KV
The surface of the barrier facing the rod electrode, Πολυωνυµι κή (Relative Field stregth on the rod)
which is usually the stressed electrode, is called front Πολυωνυµι κή (Flashover voltage KV)
CHARGE AT BREAKDOWN
160 4.00E-06
ROD - PLATE AIR GAP 100 mm, WITH DIELECTRIC
FIELD STRENGTH AT
VOLTAGE (C)
BARRIER AT DIFFERENT POSITIONS BETWEEN
VOLTAGE (KV)
120 3.00E-06
THE ELECTRODES. THE ELECTRIC CHARGE IS
LINEARLY DISTRIBUTED ON FRONT SURFACE OF
80 2.00E-06
THE BARRIER, TAKING ITS MAXIMUM VALUE AT
THE CENTER OF THE BARRIER.
250 2.00E-06 40 1.00E-06
AT BREAKDOWN
VOLTAGE KV
BREAKDOWN
10 30 50 70 90
CHARGE AT
VOLTAGE C
VOLTAGE
150 1.20E-06
KV/cm
The analysis also showed that the field strength on rod Unhomogenen elektrischen Felde bei
increases very much, when the barrier is moved from verschiedenen, Spannungsarten . ETZ, vol. 33,
rod to the middle of the gap. When the barrier comes pp. 1161-1165.
near the plate the value of field strength on rod [6] Marx E (1930), Der elektrische Durchshlag
decreases again. von Luft im unhomogenen Feid . Arch. f. El.,
vol. 24, pp. 61f.
4. Conclusions [7] Roser, H. (1932), Schirme zur Erhohung der
From the analysis of the different arrangements of the Durchschlagapannung in Luft . ETZ, vol. 17,
air gap models in connection to the values of the pp. 411-412.
breakdown voltages the following conclusions arise. [8] Hidaka K., and Kouno, T., A (1982), Method
1) The distribution of the electric field in a rod – for measuring field in space charge by means
plate or rod – rod air gap is strongly affected by of Pockel’s device. J. Electrostatics vol. 11 pp.
the geometry (shape and dimensions) of the 195-211
electrodes and the arrangement of the air gap. It [9] Hidaka, K., Chiba, M., and Kouno, T. (1988),
is worth observing that there is a significant Barrier effect on electrical breakdown in air.
difference in the graphs of voltage drop between IX International Conference on Gas Discharges
the two different arrangements, the one with and their Applications, Venice, pp. 479-482
plate grounded and the other with rod grounded. [10] Topalis, F. V., and Stathopulos, I. A. (1991),
2) The breakdown voltage of the plane gap Barrier effect in small and medium air gaps.
arrangements increases with the gap length, VII International Symposium on High Voltage
especially in the arrangements of rod-rod and engineering, Dresden, pp. 157-160
rod-plate air gaps, in a not linear way. The [11] Topalis, F. V., and Stathopulos, I. A . (1992),
Values of breakdown voltage of air gap Barrier effect on electrical breakdown in non-
arrangements with a barrier depends on the uniform small and medium air gaps. VI
position of the barrier in the gap. The average International Conference on Dielectric
value of field strength along the axis of the gap, Measurements and Applications Manchester
at breakdown voltage, decreases with the gap [12] Li Ming, Mats Leijon and Tord Bengtsson.
length. (1994) Barrier effects in air gaps under DC
3) The maximum value of the field strength along voltage. 7th International Symposium on Gaseous
the axis of the gap at breakdown voltage tends dielectrics Knoxville, USA
to get a steady value, more or less independent [13] F.V Topalis , and I. F. Gonos and I. A
of the gap length, in the symmetric arrangements Stathopoulos (1999), Insulation properties of
of sphere-sphere, rod-rod and plate-plate composite dielectric arrangements. Proceedings
arrangements. In the rod-plate arrangements it of the LASTED International Conference Power
seems that the maximum value of the gap and Energy Systems. Las Vegas Nevada-USA
increases with the gap length. [14] Li Ming, Mats Leijon and Tord Bengtsson.
4) In a rod plate air gap with a barrier the most (1995) Factors influencing barrier effects in air
determinant factor for the breakdown voltage is gaps. Ninth International Symposium On High
the value of the field strength on the rod and on Voltage Engineering. Graz, Austria.
the barrier. [15] S M Lebedev, D P Agoris, I Vitellas and Yu P
Pokholkov (2000). The role of polarization in the
breakdown of an air gap with barrier. J. of Phys.
References: D: Appl. Phys. 34 (2001)
[1] Sylvester P. P., Ferrari R. L. (1996), Finite [16] F.V Topalis , and I. F. Gonos and I. A
elements for electrical engineers, Cambridge Stathopoulos (2002) Insulation properties of
University Press composite dielectric arrangements. International
[2] M. S. Naidu, V. Kamaraju (1996), High Voltage Journal of :Power and Energy Systems, Vol 22,
Engineering, McGraw Hill No. 3.
[3] Ε. Kuffel, W.S. Zaengl, J. Kuffel. (2000) High [17] A. Maglaras. Numerical analysis of electric
Voltage Engineering. Fundamentals. Newnes field in air gaps, related to the Barrier Effect. 1st
Oxford. IC-SCCE Athens, 2004.
[4] Khalifa, M. (1990) High-Voltage Engineering,
Theory and Practice. Marcel Dekker inc., New
York
[5] Marx E ., Der Durchschlag der Luft im