In The Great Gatsby
In The Great Gatsby
Nick, who comes East after being shaped by Midwestern values while growing up,
believes in honesty, friendship. and loyalty. He values decency in human behavior...
The novel develops strong themes concerning morality and personal values. Nick's
character is developed to represent solid personal values and moral conduct, while
the Buchanans come to represent immorality, amorality, and personal values that
have been corrupted by enormous inherited wealth and the social status it has
created for them.
Nick, who comes East after being shaped by Midwestern values while growing up,
believes in honesty, friendship. and loyalty. He values decency in human behavior
and is dumbfounded and appalled by Tom and Daisy's lack of decency in the novel's
conclusion. Gatsby's death is meaningless to them, except as a personal
inconvenience and complication. It is Nick who makes arrangements for Gatsby's
funeral, becoming more and more angry when he realizes he is the only one of
Gatsby's "friends" who cares about him:
Nick is not self-centered and obsessed with his own well being, unlike Tom, Daisy,
and Jordan, as well as Myrtle Wilson, and Meyer Wolfsheim. After his time in the
East, Nick comes home to condemn all the major players, except Gatsby, as being
"foul dust."
On the flip side of the American Dream, then, is a naivete and a susceptibility to evil
and poor-intentioned people.
The affair undertaken by Tom and Myrtle is a nice place to start. This affair relates to
the idea of wealth as a justification for actions (from both sides - Tom and Myrtle).
Tom seems to feel his social position, derived solely from financial wealth, sets him
above or makes him better than George Wilson.
Tom is demeaning to George Wilson, his mistress's husband, who owns a garage in
the wasteland between New York and East Egg.
For her part, Myrtle feels that she is owed the kind of treatment that Tom gives her.
Since her husband cannot offer her the kind of oppulent treatment that Tom can, she
is justified in carrying on an affair with Tom. We see here again in Myrtle the notion
that wealth erases morality.
However, Gatsby and Daisy both have a dream, a romantic notion, which determines
their behavior. More than money, it is a dream of true love that guides Gatsby and
Daisy to do what they do.
Morality for them remains relative. There is no code of right and wrong, in a
conventional sense, that dictates their behavior. Instead, there is a romantic vision of
the "right life" that both of them strive to achieve. Gatsby feels that he can
accomplish this through Daisy. She, for a while, feels reciprocally but later decides
that it is only through Tom that she has a chance to fulfill this vision.
Essay on the immorality of the characters and incidents in The Great GatsbyWhat
do you think of this essay topic and can you please help me expand on it? The Great
Gatsby is ultimately a story...
Essay on the immorality of the characters and incidents in The Great Gatsby
What do you think of this essay topic and can you please help me expand on it?
The Great Gatsby is ultimately a story about morality and the essentially immoral
society at the time.
In a literary essay, discuss to what extent you agree or disagree with the above
statement. Substantiate your views with close reference to incidents and characters
in the novel.
EXPERT ANSWERS
In the character analysis section of enotes, Jordan Baker of The Great Gatsby is
described as having
an amoral aura about her, and the world revolves around herself and false material
values.
This description seems to apply to Daisy and Tom Buchanan as well as they act on
what is expedient to them. Tom exploits the women that he takes; they are no more
to him than sexual objects in his smug and villainous world. Daisy, too, feigns being
"foolish" to exploit others and maintain her illusions. There is a passivity to Daisy
that suggests the effete, amoral personal.
The intense vitality that had been so remarkable in the garage was converted into
impressive hauteur.
In the hotel room, she is affected in her manner with the McKees:
"I told that boy about the ice." Myrtle raised her eyebrows in despair at the
shiflessness of the lower orders. "These people! You have to keep after them all the
time."
Before the others in the hotel room, she pulls her chair close to Nick and boldly tells
him of her first meeting with Tom with some detail. When she boldly calls out "Daisy!
Daisy!," overstepping the bounds of her class in Tom's amoral perception that is
unconcerned with anything else, she has her nose broken.
Of course, like Myrtle, Jay Gatsby is also guilty of moral corruption as he attempts to
move up in social class, using any means necessary. His involvement with the
underworld of Meyer Wolfscheim is, of course, the most salient example.
I agree that the major characters--Jay and Tom and Myrtle--would give you plenty of
material for an essay on immorality in The Great Gatsby. Think of Jay's illegal
business ventures, Tom's consistent affairs with women (even on his honeymoon, for
petes sake) and his views on racial superiority, and Myrtle's affair and lying. Like I
said, plenty to digest with them. Two minor characters with major morality problems,
though, include Jordan Baker and Meyer Wolfscheim. She is a professional golfer
who cheats. That kind of behavior at that level is outrageously immoral. Wolfscheim
was, solely or in part, responsible for "fixing" a World Series. That's immoral on a
national scale, as well.
If you threw this assignment at me right now, I would likely concentrate on Daisy.
You don't have quite as much material as you do if you were to follow Gatsby or
perhaps Nick, but she provides a pretty fantastic portrait of an immoral woman, if
you'd like to take that angle.
She is incredibly manipulative and uses her beauty to get whatever she wants,
whether that is attention, adoring worship from Gatsby, or eventually absolution from
her crime and a clean getaway. She uses Tom, she uses Nick, she uses Gatsby,
everyone and everything she has ever been around she bends to her purposes.
I think you could make an interesting essay out of that, but there are tons of other
ways to take that as well.
Though Daisy, Tom, Jordan and Nick escape punishment for their involvement in
Myrtle's death, no characters are finally innocent in the novel. A quick review of the
characters shows us how moral (or immoral their world is:
Tom, Daisy, Myrtle, and Gatsby are involved in affairs, cheating in one way or
another. George Wilson commits murder. Jordan Baker cheats in her sport. Tom is a
racist. Gatsby is a bootlegger and a fraud.
Nick is the only character that grows through the novel. He is not perfect, in any
sense, but he matures.
His first moral shock comes when he goes to dinner with Tom, Daisy and Jordan and
discovers that Tom's affair is a scandal but not a matter of morality. Tom is cheating
on Daisy, yet no one suggests that this act is immoral. It is, rather, dramatic and
rude, but the affair itself is not as much of an issue as the fact that everyone knows
about it.
The concern for perception here is directly related to the shallow values of the rich
set; "values" which lead to dishonesty and immoral behavior.
The materialism of the East creates the tragedy of destruction, dishonesty, and fear.
No values exist in such an environment.
The example of Jay Gatsby is central to a discussion on the special morality of this
group of people. Gatsby puts an great emphasis on achieving a certain dream of
love. This dream is, in itself, pure. Yet, to achieve his goal of marrying Daisy, Gatsby
must break up a marriage (between Tom and Daisy), effectively undoing two lives in
order to realize his own dream.
Gatsby never doubts the validity of his position, morally or otherwise, and maintains
confidence even in the end after Myrtle has been run over. He waits for Daisy to call.
George Wilson comes instead as an arbiter of misplaced moral justice and Gatsby's
dream comes to an end.
Jay Gatsby, the dreamer and romantic, is a liar and a criminal (as a bootlegger) and
Nick sees him as being a low sort of person at first. Later, Nick learns to empathize
with Gatsby, recognizing Gatsby's rare penchant for maintaining innocence in the
face of circumstances that would have erased any innocence in others.
Nick's ability to empathize with Gatsby can be seen as evidence of his own moral
growth. In the end, he does not judge Gatsby, but relates to him with sympathy -
something he could or would not do at the novel's outset.
Nick is the only character willing to sympathize with Gatsby in the end. He goes so
far as to tell Gatsby how he feels, before Gatsby is shot.
[Nick] tells him he is better than the “whole rotten bunch put together.”
This statement represents the sole important moral achievement in the novel. Nick
learns that people can be good and bad at the same time and he chooses to see the
good in Gatsby.
For, after observing and listening to the guests, Tom realizes that they are
not the types who come to East Egg. In the 1920s, men who quickly and
mysteriously acquired fortunes were frequently suspected of illegal activity.
"I found out what your 'drug-stores' were....You're one of that bunch that
hangs around with Meyer Wolfsheim...." (7)
"He and this Wolfsheim bought up a lot of side-street drug-stores here and
in Chicago and sold grain alcohol over the counter....I picked him for a
bootlegger the first time I saw him, and I wasn't far wrong."(7)
"What about it?" Gatsby politely responds as he does not try to display any
emotion. Instead, he turns on Tom,
"I guess your friend Walter Chase wasn't too proud to come in on it." (7)
Tom responds that Gatsby betrayed Walter, but Gatsby counters by saying
that Walter was glad to "Pick up some money."
People suspect that Gatsby makes most of his money as a bootlegger, but
he isn’t positively identified as such until the big scene in New York when
he and Tom quarrel over Daisy. Tom has been investigating Gatsby and
has learned some facts about him which he uses to try to destroy Daisy’s
illusions. The most significant accusations are on page 133 in my edition of
the novel.
Gatsby doesn’t deny Tom’s accusation. Obviously Tom has gathered too
much damaging information about him, and the more Tom talks the worse
it seems to everyone present . Tom has found out that Gatsby, with
Wolfsheim and others, is involved in other illegal activities.
The fact that Gatsby had bootlegging operations in the gangster-ridden city
of Chicago makes him seem especially corrupt, because that city was
known for mobster rule, criminals like Al Capone, and frequent murders.
First of all, Tom was sleeping with George's wife, Myrtle. This was as much
Myrtle's fault as it was Tom's but we can say that by sleeping with his wife,
Tom was hurting George and Myrtle's marriage. Faced with a failing
business and a cheating wife, who no longer had any respect for him,
George's misery partly had to do with the affair between Myrtle and Tom.
First of all, Tom was sleeping with George's wife, Myrtle. This was as much
Myrtle's fault as it was Tom's but we can say that by sleeping with his wife,
Tom was hurting George and Myrtle's marriage. Faced with a failing
business and a cheating wife, who no longer had any respect for him,
George's misery partly had to do with the affair between Myrtle and Tom.
Perhaps the most dramatic instance when Tom victimizes George is when
Tom tells George that Gatsby is the one who killed Myrtle with the car.
(This is untrue; Daisy was driving.) In the final chapter, Nick confronts Tom,
asking him if he blamed the accident on Gatsby. Tom replies:
"What if I did tell him? That fellow had it coming to him. He threw dust into
your eyes just like he did in Daisy’s, but he was a tough one. He ran over
Myrtle like you’d run over a dog and never even stopped his car.”
Tom told George that Gatsby was responsible for Myrtle's death. (George
had already suspected Myrtle was having an affair and may have also
concluded that Gatsby was the man she was having the affair with.) When
Tom blamed Gatsby, this leads George to confront Gatsby and kill him,
then to turn the gun on himself. Again, Tom plays a direct role in George's
misfortune.