This document discusses accounting theory and the underlying principles of accounting standards. It addresses debates around the aims of financial statements and whether accounting should be driven more by economic theory or practical business needs. While economic perspectives can identify logical approaches, some do not translate well to practical accounting. The document also notes ongoing issues with financial instability and "creative accounting" that accounting theory seeks to address through clarifying concepts and improving standards.
This document discusses accounting theory and the underlying principles of accounting standards. It addresses debates around the aims of financial statements and whether accounting should be driven more by economic theory or practical business needs. While economic perspectives can identify logical approaches, some do not translate well to practical accounting. The document also notes ongoing issues with financial instability and "creative accounting" that accounting theory seeks to address through clarifying concepts and improving standards.
Accounting theory is the principles, concepts and definitions
that underpin accounting standards. ACCOUNTING THEORY
Issue with Accounting principles
Wide range of accounting standards-some clear definitions are already in accounting standards. However, what are underlying principles in accounting? Accounting can be used in many different ways: can’t be just one guiding principle involved Debate: what accounts are used for and different principles might have been suggested. ACCOUNTING THEORY
Aims and objectives of accounting?
Eg. What is the balance sheet? What are its aims? Direct interpretation: list of assets and liabilities. However, what does B/S actually do??? How do people use balance sheet? Arguments: B/S reflect the value of a business or tool used by investors to monitor managers-2 different ways of looking at the usefulness of a B/S Can use both ways, but ….what is the core aim of B/S, and again, what is the underlying principle to cater for the different ways it is used. ACCOUNTING THEORY Economic theories as underlying principles in accounting. Develop theories on how people make decisions Economic behaviors that suggest what accounting should be Clash of perspectives: accounting is practical discipline but economics is more towards theoretical Practical business perspectives ≠ theoretical & philosophical Eg. Value an asset at cost is simple & practical, but economist would prefer asset is valued at MP or FV. Is it appropriate for the business? Is it pratical to accountants, managers, etc? Economists’ theory driven logic can be different from accountant’s logic. Accounting Theory Debated question in accounting: what is depreciation? Economists’ perspective: cast doubt in depreciation accounting Accounting practices that have become established over time, through experience eg. Depreciation, may lack logical or rigorous theoretical explanation within existing economic theory Strengths of depreciation (matching) and weaknesses (it is not cash flow) ACCOUNTING THEORY Compatibility of Accounting Practices to Economist perspectives Some accounting practices, eg. discounted cash flows perfectly logical from economists’ perspectives but don’t work quite so well in practice. Definition of DCF: a valuation method used to estimate the value of an investment based on its future cash flows. DCF analysis attempts to figure out the value of acompany today, based on projections of how much money it will generate in the future. ACCOUNTING THEORY Accounting theory must lead to improvements in accounting practice. Economic theory-logical ideas about why people make decisions. Theory’s key attributes: must be based on robust definitions & concepts, clear logical links, explain human DM and be relevant to key problems. (e.g. financial instability, creative accounting) The purpose of IFRS Conceptual Framework (2010): to improve accounting practice by strengthening, consistency, relevance or faithful representation. Strong CF: help to stabilize financial markets and encourage investment. ACCOUNTING THEORY Debate about accounting issues and problems. gain exposure during recession but when economic growth returns, issues are forgotten and reemerge when recession resumes Debate on accounting’s CF-cyclical: recently shaped by growing awareness of financial instability. Starting in 1980’s-groth in capital markets created a need for globally comparable data, annual reports and accounts. Need: agreed framework to achieve comparability and agreed accounting theory. FM have other needs e.g. the problem of managing risks- needs to shift towards CF for financial stability & investment. ACCOUNTING THEORY
FRC is dealing with the problem of financial instability, but
accounting is also not in good shape. Problems are not terminal Creative accounting-1st recognized in the > 30 years, not resolved E.g. Tesco Plc accounting, UK Banking collapses, Enron in USA. Other accounting problems: audit expectations gap, oligopoly by 4 big firms (not enough competition). Emphasize: gap between economic theory based on perfect markets and the economic reality of accounting in which 4 firms dominate. ACCOUNTING THEORY
Author’s view: Modern accounting theory based on
Americanized version, has limitations that have been underestimated. Prefer traditional approach of historical cost and accruals.