Hospital Audit Guide (1972) Industry Audit Guide Audit and Accounting Guide
Hospital Audit Guide (1972) Industry Audit Guide Audit and Accounting Guide
eGrove
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
Industry Developments and Alerts
(AICPA) Historical Collection
1972
Recommended Citation
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Committee on Health Care Institutions, "Hospital audit guide (1972); Industry
audit guide; Audit and accounting guide" (1972). Industry Developments and Alerts. 483.
https://egrove.olemiss.edu/aicpa_indev/483
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) Historical Collection at
eGrove. It has been accepted for inclusion in Industry Developments and Alerts by an authorized administrator of eGrove. For more information,
please contact [email protected].
AN
AICPA
INDUSTRY
AUDIT
GUIDE
HOSPITAL
AUDIT GUIDE
AMERICAN
INSTITUTE
OF CPAs
Copyright 1972 by the
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Inc.
666 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10019
1 Introduction 1
Classification of Hospitals 1
Accounting and Reporting Considerations 1
3 Auditing Procedures—General 13
Scope of Engagement 13
Preparation for the Audit 13
Statistics 14
Other Considerations 15
Management Letters 16
4 Auditing Procedures—Assets 17
Cash 17
Investments 17
Accounts Receivable 18
Inventories 21
Property, Plant, and Equipment 22
7 Financial Statements 38
Exhibit A: Sample Hospital Balance Sheet 40
Exhibit B: Sample Hospital Statement of Revenues and
Expenses 42
Exhibit C: Sample Hospital Statement of Changes in
Fund Balances 43
Exhibit D: Sample Hospital Statement of Revenues and
Expenses and Changes in Unrestricted Fund Balance
(Alternative Presentation) 44
Exhibit E: Sample Hospital Statement of Changes in
Financial Position of Unrestricted Fund 46
Sample Hospital Notes to Financial Statements 48
Schedule 1: Sample Hospital Patient Service Revenues 50
Schedule 2: Sample Hospital Operating Expenses 51
Appendix
Glossary 56
\
Preface
This guide is issued to assist the independent auditor in auditing
hospital financial statements that present financial position, changes in
financial position, and results of operations. Although such statements
are affected by the expanding role of third-party payors, the guide
does not set forth reporting guidelines for third-party reimbursement
purposes. References to third-party payors are made solely in connec-
tion with reporting on financial statements that present financial posi-
tion, changes in financial position, and results of operations.
In writing this guide, it was recognized that information important
to the public for interpretation of financial statements may differ from
that required by management to carry on daily operations. Nothing
herein precludes management from reporting information internally in
any manner they consider necessary to fulfill this function.
Although the guide contains a glossary of terms used in the text, the
reader may find the following publications of the American Hospital
Association helpful in understanding terminology, accounting, and cost
determinations:
Uniform Hospital Definitions (1960)
Chart of Accounts for Hospitals (revised 1966)
Cost Finding and Rate Setting for Hospitals (1968)
Internal Control and Internal Auditing for Hospitals (1969)
The Medicare Audit Guide, published by the American Institute of
Certified Public Accountants in 1969, is also helpful in providing some
background with respect to third-party reimbursement.
Committee on
Health Care Institutions
April 1972
v
Chapter I
Introduction
Health care institutions include hospitals that provide short-
term inpatient and outpatient care, as well as institutions that
provide limited or long-term care, such as those for the mentally
ill and infirm, for the physically handicapped, for child care, and
for home care. Although some recommendations herein may be
found applicable to other types of health care institutions, this
guide applies only to hospitals.
Classification of Hospitals
Hospitals may be classified by type of control, such as:
Voluntary
Community
Religious Affiliated
Educational Institution Affiliated
Government Affiliated
Governmental
Federal
State
County
City
Proprietary (investor owned)
1
Medicaid, Blue Cross, and private insurance carriers. Reporting
requirements of third-party payors usually influence record keep-
ing. With the adoption of cost-based formulas for reimbursement
by many third-party payors, requests for cost data supporting
charges to patients have increased significantly. Data requested
include statistics on occupancy, type of patients, nature of ill-
nesses, average length of confinement by type of ailment, and—
more important from an accounting standpoint—costs of providing
service to particular groups of patients.
Besides third-parties' need for cost data, voluntary and govern-
ment planning agencies will also need financial and statistical
data to help them in improving delivery of health services.
Further, as demand for service increases, financial support will
also increase. This will more than likely require a higher level of
accountability including more financial and statistical informa-
tion. In this connection, the American Hospital Association states
the following on page 24 of its Statement on the Financial Re-
quirements of Health Care Institutions and Services (1969):
2
Chapter 2
Messrs. Stipa and Winick assent to the publication of the guide, but dis-
sent to the requirement that all investments be carried at cost.
Mr. Winick believes that hospitals should be permitted to carry market-
able securities at fair market value as is permitted for other types of entities,
so that the financial statements will better reflect the current financial posi-
tion of the institution and management's performance with regard to such
investments.
Mr. Stipa believes that the use of fair market value may in some cir-
3
cumstances more properly present financial position and operating results
and that its use is more in keeping with the current philosophies of invest-
ment pooling, the recognition of unrealized gains and losses, and the total
return concept now emphasized by institutional boards and their investment
advisors. He therefore believes that the guide should permit the reporting
of investments at either cost or fair market value, at least until the issuance
of an authoritative accounting pronouncement regarding the carrying value of
investments, and the related effect of unrealized gains and losses upon the
financial statements.
4
If third parties reimburse hospitals for depreciation and re-
strict all or part of the reimbursement payment to replacements
of, or additions to, property, plant, and equipment, such payment
should be included in revenue in order to match this revenue
and related depreciation expense. In the statement of changes in
fund balances, the amount of the payment should be shown as
a transfer from unrestricted to restricted funds and returned to
unrestricted funds when expended.
Accumulation of funds for replacement or expansion of hospi-
tal facilities may result from a decision of the governing board
to set aside resources for such purposes. When this is the case,
these accumulations are considered to be designations of unre-
stricted fund balance and should be accounted for as appro-
priations of that balance. Provision for such designations of unre-
stricted fund balance should not be reflected as an expense in the
statement of revenues and expenses.
5
full amount. Such revenues should also be reported on an accrual
basis in the period during which service is provided; other ac-
counting methods, such as the "discharge method,"3 are not
acceptable.
Charity allowances, other arrangements for providing service
at less than established rates, and the provision for uncollectible
accounts should be reported either separately from gross revenues
under "deductions from gross revenues" or by some other dis-
closure. Allowances of this type should also be accounted for on
an accrual basis.
6
ices), the lay-equivalent salaries (or the difference between lay-
equivalent salaries and salaries paid) should be reported as ex-
pense with the credit to nonoperating revenue.
Donated medicines, linen, office supplies, and other materials
which normally would be purchased by a hospital should be
recorded at fair market value and reported as other operating
revenue.
Donations of property and equipment should be recorded at
fair market value at the date of contribution in the unrestricted
fund balance, unless designated for endowment or other restricted
purposes.
7
Grants and subsidies from governmental or community agen-
cies may be given for general support of the hospital. Ordinarily,
these items should be shown as nonoperating revenue. However,
where the grantor specifies that this revenue is to be used for
indigent care, it should be accounted for as a specific purpose
gift (see Restricted Resources, below) and offset against allow-
ances and uncollectible accounts when used.
When restrictions on term endowment funds expire, the re-
leased endowment should be reflected as nonoperating revenue
in the statement of revenues and expenses.
Board-Designated Funds
Unrestricted resources may be appropriated or designated by
the governing board for special uses. These resources may origi-
nate from unrestricted gifts or previously accumulated income.
If the governing board appropriates resources in this manner, it
should be recognized that the board nevertheless has the author-
ity to rescind its action. For this reason such appropriations
should be accounted for as part of unrestricted funds. Disclosure
of board designations should be made in the financial statements.
Board-designated funds should be reported separately from
donor-restricted funds. The term "restricted" should not be used
in connection with board or other internal hospital appropria-
tions or designations of funds.
Unrestricted Funds
All unrestricted resources in the balance sheet should be shown
under the "unrestricted" caption (as illustrated in Exhibit A,
pages 40 to 41) or otherwise disclosed, so the reader will not be
misled as to resources available at the discretion of the governing
board. A total of all unrestricted fund balances should be set
forth.
Restricted Resources
Many hospitals receive, from donors and other third-parties,
gifts, bequests, and grants that are restricted as to use. These
8
generally fall into three categories: (1) funds for specific operat-
ing purposes, (2) funds for additions to property, plant, and
equipment, and (3) endowment funds.
Funds for specific operating purposes consist of donor-restricted
resources and should be accounted for in a restricted fund or as
deferred revenue in the unrestricted fund. These resources should
be reported as "other operating" revenue in the financial state-
ments of the period in which expenditures are made for the pur-
pose intended by the donor.
Resources restricted by donors for additions to property, plant,
and equipment are considered as contributions to the permanent
capital of the hospital. Accordingly, these resources should be
included in the restricted fund balance. A transfer of resources
from restricted fund balance to unrestricted fund balance should
be shown in the financial statements for the period in which
expenditures are made for the purpose intended by the donor.
Endowment resources include both pure endowment funds
(the principal of which may not be expended by the governing
board) and term endowment funds (the principal of which may
be expended upon release of the prohibition on expenditure of
principal). Upon receipt, both types of endowment funds should
be accounted for as restricted funds.
With respect to term endowment funds, footnote disclosure
should be made of pertinent information such as the term of the
endowment and the purposes for which the funds may be used
during the term. When term endowment funds become available
to the governing board for unrestricted purposes, they should
be reported as "nonoperating revenue"; if these funds are re-
stricted, they should be shown as a transfer to specific purpose
or other restricted funds and accounted for as restricted funds.
Each restricted resource should be accounted for in accordance
with instructions of the party placing restrictions on the resources.
Restrictions on many resources are such that the funds can be
grouped for reporting purposes even though they may require
separate accounting in the records. Generally, restricted resources
should be grouped for reporting purposes in the three categories
discussed above.
Other examples of restricted resources include student loan,
annuity, and life income funds.
9
Investment Income and Gains (Losses)
The statement of revenue and expenses should include income
from investment of board-designated and other unrestricted
funds; unrestricted income from endowment funds; and realized
gains (or losses) on sale of investments of board-designated funds
or other unrestricted funds. Unrealized gains or losses should not
result in adjustment of financial statements, except for declines in
value that result from an other than temporary impairment.
Realized gains (or losses) on sale of investments of endow-
ment funds should be added to (or deducted from) endowment
fund principal unless such items are legally available for other
use or chargeable against other funds. Investment income of
these funds should be accounted for in accordance with donors'
instructions, i.e., as resources for specific operating purposes if
restricted, or nonoperating revenue if not.
Income and net realized gains on investments of restricted
funds, other than endowment funds, should be added to the
respective fund balance unless legally available for unrestricted
purposes. If available for unrestricted purposes, these items should
be included in nonoperating revenue; if legal restrictions exist to
the contrary, investment losses in excess of gains of these other
restricted funds should be charged to restricted fund balance.
Gains or losses on investment trading between unrestricted
and restricted funds should be recognized and separately dis-
closed in the financial statements. Gains or losses resulting from
transactions between designated portions of the unrestricted fund
should not be recognized.
Pledges
All pledges, less a provision for amounts uncollectible, should
be accounted for in financial statements. Pledges should be appro-
priately classified in financial statements as unrestricted or re-
stricted. If unrestricted, revenue from pledges (net of provision
for uncollectibles) should be shown in financial statements of the
period in which the pledge is made as nonoperating revenue. If
part of the pledge is to be applied during some future period,
that part should be reported in financial statements of the period
in which it is received as deferred revenue or as additions to
10
restricted funds. If pledges are restricted in any other way they
should be reported as restricted funds.
11
hospital are handled by such organizations, full disclosure should
be made of the related facts and circumstances. If such organi-
zations are under control of (or common control with) hospitals
and handle hospital resources, their financial statements should
be combined with those of the hospital.
12
Chapter 3
Auditing Procedures-General
The primary purpose of this chapter and subsequent chapters
on auditing is to present auditing procedures specifically appli-
cable to hospitals. Although not contained in this guide, certain
procedures common to audits of other organizations may also
be pertinent.
Scope of Engagement
In each engagement, it should be understood in advance
whether the audit is intended to cover supplementary informa-
tion. In this regard, the independent auditor should consider
issuing or obtaining a letter setting forth the scope and terms of
his engagement.
Many third-party payors require hospitals to submit supple-
mentary cost reports to obtain reimbursement for services pro-
vided to patients covered under such payor's plans. Many such
supplementary reports require an independent auditor's opinion.
Other types of reports examined by independent auditors include
overhead cost reports for research contracts; reports to regional
or national health care organizations; reports for contributors;
and reports for local, state, or federal authorities in connection
with tax exemption matters. The independent auditor should
review all supplementary report requirements and plan his ex-
amination to comply with related filing deadlines.
13
tion charts. The following items are of particular significance in
hospital audits:
Statistics
It is important for the independent auditor to familiarize him-
self with the method (or methods) by which the hospital seeks
reimbursement for services. Current practice emphasizes a reli-
ance on cost-finding as a means of calculating reimbursements
from third parties under various plans and arrangements (most
Blue Cross plans and Medicare use variations of cost-finding in
reimbursement formulas). It is therefore recommended that the
auditor know the details of the type or types of cost-finding re-
quired to be used by his hospital client.5
Hospitals usually compile statistical information on utilization
of services and facilities. Early in his engagement the independ-
ent auditor should ascertain the extent to which his examination
must be expanded to cover statistical data.
auditor may find the following booklets helpful: Cost Finding for
Hospitals (American Hospital Association, 1957) and Cost Finding
and Rate Setting for Hospitals (American Hospital Association, 1968).
14
Other Considerations
To familiarize himself with an engagement and to pinpoint
trends in operations and financial position, the independent
auditor should usually review various data relating to the pre-
ceding period. Such review should ordinarily include documents
of the prior year such as financial statements previously reported
upon; interim financial statements, workpapers (particularly fol-
low-up notes and memoranda for future audits), audit programs,
internal control questionnaires, and management letters and cor-
respondence. In addition to the above review of prior year docu-
ments, the auditor should ordinarily:
15
Management Letters
It is a common but not required practice for the independent
auditor to submit a letter to management commenting on his
findings and recommendations regarding internal control, ac-
counting procedures, and other matters. This letter should be
directed to appropriate officials, generally the chief administrative
officer, the governing board, or the audit committee.
16
Chapter 4
Cash
As in other organizations, a hospital may maintain one or
more bank accounts for operating purposes. Procedures for re-
cording receipts and disbursements will vary with the organiza-
tion. However, if the hospital receives donor-restricted funds, the
auditor should determine if it is required to maintain such funds
separately from the cash of unrestricted funds. The independent
auditor should also determine, by examining underlying docu-
mentation, other legal requirements relating to restricted cash.
In his evaluation of internal control, the auditor should deter-
mine the location of cash collection points in addition to the
cashier's office, such as emergency rooms, outpatient facilities,
and special service departments. He should also review arrange-
ments or agreements whereby the hospital collects cash for
others.
Investments
Some noteworthy features of accounting for hospital invest-
ments are: (1) accounting by specific fund, (2) differentiating
between principal and income transactions, and (3) pooling of
investments.
In order to obtain investment flexibility, hospitals frequently
pool resources of various funds for investment purposes. Because
net results of operating the pool do not usually show up as such
in financial statements, it is important that the net profit be allo-
cated equitably to, and reported in, statements of participating
17
funds. In order to accomplish an equitable allocation, investment
pools should be operated on the market-value method. Under the
market-value method, each participating fund is assigned a num-
ber of units based on the percentage it owns of the total pool.
Market value is used to determine the number of units to be
allocated to new funds entering the pool, or to calculate equity
of funds withdrawing from the pool. Net profit of pool operations
should be allocated to participating funds based on the funds'
equity or share of the pool.
Auditing procedures applicable to investments may include
reading custody agreements, reviewing control and safeguarding
procedures, confirming or examining securities, testing author-
ization and documentation supporting transactions, reviewing the
basis of valuation, and reporting income.
Specific inquiries in determining audit scope for investments
should ordinarily include:
Accounts Receivable
In hospitals, accounts receivable have one characteristic not
normally found in other organizations; full rate charges incurred
18
by patients are usually settled for amounts less than full rate. This
difference may be attributable to contractual arrangements with
third-party payors or to courtesy, charity, or other policy dis-
counts; these items are usually not recognized in the hospital rec-
ords until after the patient has been discharged.
Accounts-receivable controls may be maintained under the
following classifications:
19
the Blue Cross account without recognizing the difference be-
tween that amount and the amount Blue Cross may pay in the
future to settle the account. In such a case, the difference will
be recognized in the hospital's records at the time payment is
received from Blue Cross. This situation requires that an allow-
ance be set up in financial statements being reported upon to
reflect amounts that are expected to be collected. Similarly, an
allowance should be set up to recognize other anticipated deduc-
tions such as charity, courtesy allowances, and policy discounts
which will be recognized in the hospital's records subsequent to
the balance sheet date.
Contractual arrangements between hospitals and third-party
payors often provide for tentative billing rates which are subject
to adjustment retroactively as a result of subsequent cost deter-
mination or negotiation. Although the rate finally agreed upon
may not be known by the auditor when he is ready to issue his
report, a reasonable estimate can usually be made of the adjust-
ment and should be reflected in the financial statements. When
settlement is finally made, any difference between the estimate
reported in the financial statements and the finally settled amount
recorded should be accounted for as indicated in Chapter 2
under the section on prior period adjustments.
In evaluating internal control and in determining the resultant
extent of auditing procedures to be applied, the auditor should
review the hospital's procedures for determining amounts that
are collectible for services. In this regard he should evaluate the
hospital's method of determining: (1) the indigency status of
patients on a timely basis, (2) the point at which accounts are
to be turned over to collection agencies or its in-house collection
department, and (3) the estimated provision of uncollectible
accounts.
Auditing procedures applicable to accounts receivable should
ordinarily include confirmation from discharged patients and
from third-party payors who have been billed by the hospital.
Attempting to obtain confirmation of receivables from patients
who are not discharged usually will be impracticable because
such patients usually do not know their indebtedness until they
are discharged. In such cases, alternative procedures as specified
in SAP No. 43, "Confirmation of Receivables and Observation of
20
Inventories," should be followed. The existence of third-party
payor contractual arrangements requires that appropriate audit
procedures be performed, including:
Inventories
Hospital inventories usually are not material in relation to
financial position; inventory usage, however, may significantly
affect hospital operations. The inventory classifications most fre-
quently recorded in the accounts include: medical and surgical
supplies; drugs and medicines; linens, uniforms, and garments;
food; housekeeping supplies; office supplies; maintenance sup-
plies; and stationery and forms. Of these, medical and surgical
supplies and drugs and medicines are often the major items.
Internal control and auditing procedures with respect to hos-
pital inventories differ in some respects from those followed in
21
other organizations. Some differences are as follows:
22
tion purposes. However, the independent auditor should satisfy
himself as to their propriety.
In evaluating depreciation policy, the auditor may refer to the
American Hospital Association's Chart of Accounts for Hospitals
which sets forth plant asset classifications and estimated useful
lives of depreciable assets. He should also be aware that the
accelerated pace of technological improvements in the medical
field makes obsolescence an important factor to be considered in
evaluating depreciation policy. APB Opinion No. 12, "Omnibus
Opinion—1967," should be referred to for information about de-
preciable assets that should be disclosed in the financial state-
ments.
Property, plant, and equipment not used for hospital operations
should be reported separately; examples are real estate received
as a gift and real estate investments of endowment funds.
23
Chapter 5
Auditing Procedures-
Liabilities, Deferred Revenue, and
Fund Balances
24
4. Substantiate deferred fees for educational programs and re-
view existing subsidy or grant agreements for educational
purposes.
5. Consider claims against the hospital for negligence and mal-
practice for possible disclosure of contingent liabilities. Evi-
dence of claims may usually be obtained from claims agents,
insurance companies, and attorneys. Obtaining written repre-
sentation of claims information should be considered by the
auditor.
6. Consider the effect on financial statements caused by timing
differences between the period in which items enter into the
determination of reimbursement under third-party reimburse-
ment arrangements and the period in which such items enter
into the financial statements.
7. Review policies requiring deposits from certain classes of pa-
tients, such as maternity patients. From admitting and medi-
cal records, test application of these deposits; confirmation
on a test basis should be considered.
8. Ascertain that pension liabilities and income tax are ac-
counted for in accordance with APB Opinion No. 8, "Account-
ing for the Cost of Pension Plans," and APB Opinion No. 11,
"Accounting for Income Taxes," respectively.
Fund Balances
Fund balances represent the net equity of funds. Unrestricted
fund balance includes working capital, net resources invested in
plant assets, board-designated funds, and other unrestricted re-
sources. Restricted funds consist of:
25
and must be distinguished from board-designated unrestricted
funds.
3. Endowment fund resources held for the production of income.
Endowment funds terminating after a period of time or upon
the happening of a certain event should ordinarily be disclosed
separately from other permanent endowment funds.
26
2. Transfers have been made from restricted to unrestricted
funds for additions to property, plant, and equipment financed
by restricted resources.
3. Receipt and acknowledgment procedures for all gifts exist
and that restrictive covenants are being complied with. (In-
come and expenditures included in restricted funds should be
reviewed to determine that such items are accounted for in
accordance with the governing instrument.)
4. Earnings (losses) on investments of each restricted fund are
properly accounted for. (If investments are pooled, the auditor
should test to satisfy himself that earnings (losses) are ac-
counted for in appropriate funds.)
5. Changes in restricted fund balance involving research grants
are in accordance with grant agreements. (The auditor should
review the budget, expenditures, term, billing procedures, al-
lowable cost provisions, and any renegotiation requirements.
He should also review the adequacy of reserves for disallow-
ances of cost items and other adjustments.)
27
6. The use of an independent party for some of the critical
functions such as:
a. A bank or other fiscal agent as receiving agent for the
campaign.
b. An independent organization for circularizations with
pledgors.
28
Chapter 6
Auditing Procedures-
Revenues and Expenses
29
Delivery and labor room
Central services and supply
Intravenous therapy
Emergency service
Other
3. Revenue from other professional services (ancillary services).
These may be classified as follows:
Laboratories
Blood bank
Electrocardiology
Radiology
Pharmacy
Anesthesiology
Physical therapy
Other
30
lowing deserve special note: internal control over routine charges
should be maintained through the daily census while internal
control over other charges may be effected by use of prenum-
bered departmental tickets for each revenue source or a log
numbering system (initiated at the time of the request for service
or the time service is provided) or such other system which
assures that services provided are charged to the patient. Regard-
less of whether the service will be paid for, control over charges
for the service provided should be exercised.
The independent auditor should make sufficient tests of both
gross revenue and deductions therefrom to satisfy himself that
the hospital's system of internal control and accounting proce-
dures are comprehensive enough to cover any unusual circum-
stances with patients' accounts. To provide this assurance, the
auditor ordinarily should:
31
for services performed and ( 2 ) a provision for uncollectible ac-
counts. Types of allowances are:
32
reimbursement computation on an estimated basis; ( 2 ) com-
pare per diem interim rates established by third-party payors with
estimated average allowable per diem cost experienced, and
multiply the difference by the patient days served under the
contract; or (3) use other techniques which may be appropriate
in the circumstances.
33
Nonoperating Revenue
Nonoperating revenue includes revenue not directly related to
patient care, related patient services, or the sales of related goods.
It usually includes the following:
34
2. Specific research projects should be properly authorized and
a determination made as to the specific purpose funds avail-
able to cover related costs. Amounts of specific purpose funds
transferred to cover authorized research expenditures are in-
cludable under nonpatient revenue. Research expenditures
should be properly controlled and related to budgets and
authorizations.
3. Internal control over unrestricted gifts may be exercised
through written gift receipt and acknowledgment procedures.
Expenses
The American Hospital Association's Chart of Accounts for
Hospitals may be used as a guide for establishing expense classi-
fications in hospitals. Suggested major classifications of expenses
are:
Nursing services
Other professional services
35
General services
Fiscal services
Administrative services
These classifications are subdivided by organizational unit
(responsibility center).
An object or natural classification is also provided indicating
the nature of the expense, such as:
Salaries and wages
Employee benefits
Fees to individuals and organizations
Supplies
Purchased services
Other expense
The extent of classifications and subclassifications depends
upon many factors such as size of the hospital, degree of manage-
ment and accounting sophistication, and external requirements
for cost reports or comparability with other hospitals.
Expenses incurred in soliciting funds for a fund-raising cam-
paign should be disclosed separately in the financial statements.
Showing these expenses as a deduction from related revenue is
usually an acceptable manner of reporting.
Internal control over hospital expenses requires the same gen-
eral procedures as are required in any other organization: separa-
tion of duties, competent personnel, adequate payroll procedures,
control over procurement and stores, and so forth.
Payrolls generally represent a major portion of a hospital's
operating costs; therefore, tests of payrolls would represent an
important procedure in the audit.
In addition to performing the regular tests of transactions, the
auditor should:
36
c. Review the basis upon which the hospital has segregated
charges if it bills for hospital-based physicians.
3. Test the hospital's method of recording services (and sup-
plies ) furnished to employees, such as value of meals, housing,
and laundry; test distribution of these items to various depart-
ments and the treatment thereof for Social Security, with-
holding tax, and insurance purposes.
4. Test procedures for recording charges for special nurses and
the rebilling of such charges to hospital patients.
5. For hospitals which record values for contributed services,
the following should ordinarily be considered:
a. Test the compensation value assigned to services contrib-
uted by non-paid individuals based on time spent and job
description by comparison with compensation paid to
workers in similar positions.
b. Determine that maintenance costs incurred on behalf of
contributing personnel have been considered in arriving
at salary equivalents.
c. Examine time records supporting the salary-equivalents for
voluntary services and test computations.
6. Review fund-raising costs of endowment or building fund
campaigns to determine whether such expenses are properly
chargeable thereto.
7. Review and analyze, where necessary, the following:
Maintenance and repairs
Operations of plant
Professional fees (other than medical)
Administration and general expense
Laboratory supplies and expense
X-ray supplies and expense
Pharmacy supplies and expense
Dietary supplies and expense
Operating room supplies and expense
Medical and surgical expense
New or unusual expense accounts
Miscellaneous expense
37
Chapter 7
Financial Statements
Basic financial statements of a voluntary hospital consist of
the following:
Balance sheet
Statement of revenues and expenses
Statement of changes in fund balances
Statement of changes in financial position
Notes to financial statements
Statements of revenues and expenses and of changes in fund
balances may be set forth separately as shown in the accompany-
ing Exhibits B and C, pages 42 and 43. Alternatively, a combined
statement of revenues and expenses and changes in unrestricted
fund balance—which also should reflect the details of changes in
the composition of unrestricted funds—may be presented as shown
in the accompanying Exhibit D, pages 44 and 45. If the alter-
native combined statement is provided, a separate statement of
changes in the restricted fund balances should also be included.
Basic statements may be accompanied by schedules which set
forth supplementary information such as the following:
Patient service revenue
Operating expenses
38
Illustrations of these statements and schedules follow. Illustrative
statements for investor-owned (proprietary) hospitals are not in-
cluded since they should follow reporting requirements of other
investor-owned businesses.
It should be noted that information about the accounting
policies adopted and followed by the hospital should be disclosed
in the financial statements. This disclosure is recommended by
APB Opinion No. 22, "Disclosure of Accounting Policies." The
text of the Opinion should be referred to for the content and
format of disclosure.
39
Sample Hospital EXHIBIT A
40
Balance Sheet
December 31, 19
With Comparative Figures for 19—
Current Trior Liabilities and Fund Current Prior
Assets Year Year Balances Year Year
Unrestricted Funds
Current: Current:
Cash $ 133,000 $ 33,000 Notes payable to banks $ 227,000 $ 300,000
Receivables (Note 3) 1,382,000 1,269,000 Current installments of long-
term debt (Note 5) 90,000 90,000
Less estimated uncollec- Accounts payable 450,000 463,000
tibles and allowances (160,000) (105,000) Accrued expenses 150,000 147,000
1,222,000 1,164,000 Advances from third-party
Due from restricted funds 215,000 payors 300,000 200,000
Inventories (if material, state Deferred revenue 10,000 10,000
basis) 176,000 183,000 Total current liabilities 1,227,000 1,210,000
Prepaid expenses 68,000 73,000
Deferred revenue—third-party
Total current assets 1,814,000 1,453,000 90,000
reimbursement (Note 4) 200,000
Other: Long-term debt (Note 5):
Cash (Note 2) 143,000 40,000 Housing bonds 500,000 520,000
Investments (Notes 1 and 2) 1,427,000 1,740,000 Mortgage note 1,200,000 1,270,000
Property, plant, and equip- Total long-term debt 1,700,000 1,790,000
ment (Notes 4 and 5) 11,028,000 10,375,000 6,918,000
Fund balance* 7,400,000
Less accumulated deprecia-
tion (3,885,000) (3,600,000)
Net property, plant, and
equipment 7,143,000 6,775,000
Total (Note 2) $10,527,000 $10,008,000 Total $10,527,000 $10,008,000
Restricted Funds
• Composition of the fund balance may be shown here, on the Statement of Changes in Fund Balance (such as illustrated in Ex-
hibit D), or in a footnote.
41
EXHIBIT B
Sample Hospital
Statement of Revenues and Expenses
Year Ended December 31, 19
With Comparative Figures for 19
Current Prior
Year Year
Patient service revenue $8,500,000 $8,000,000
Allowances and uncollectible accounts (after
deduction of related gifts, grants, subsidies,
and other income-$55,000 and $40,000)
(Notes 3 and 4) (1,777,000) (1,700,000)
Net patient service revenue 6,723,000 6,300,000
Operating expenses:
Nursing services 2,200,000 2,000,000
Other professional services 1,900,000 1,700,000
General services 2,100,000 2,000,000
Fiscal services 375,000 360,000
Administrative services (including interest
expense of $50,000 and $40,000) 400,000 375,000
Provision for depreciation 300,000 250,000
Total operating expenses 7,275,000 6,685,000
Loss from operations (368,000) (212,000)
Nonoperating revenue:
Unrestricted gifts and bequests 228,000 205,000
Unrestricted income from endowment
funds 170,000 80,000
Income and gains from board-designated
funds 54,000 41,000
Total nonoperating revenue 452,000 326,000
Excess of revenues over expenses $ 84,000 $ 114,000
42
Sample Hospital EXHIBIT C
Statement of Changes in Fund Balances
Year Ended December 31, 19
With Comparative Figures for 19
Current Prior
Year Year
Unrestricted Funds
Balance at beginning of year $6,918,000 $6,242,000
Excess of revenues over expenses 84,000 114,000
Transferred from plant replacement and ex-
pansion funds to finance property, plant,
and equipment expenditures 628,000 762,000
Transferred to plant replacement and expan-
sion funds to reflect third-party payor rev-
enue restricted to property, plant, and
equipment replacement (230,000) (200,000)
Balance at end of year $7,400,000* $6,918,000
Restricted Funds
Specific purpose funds:
Balance at beginning of year $ 71,000 $ 50,000
Restricted gifts and bequests 35,000 20,000
Research grants 35,000 45,000
Income from investments 35,260 39,000
Gain on sale of investments 8,000 —
Transferred to:
Other operating revenue (100,000) (80,000)
Allowances and uncollectible accounts (8,000) (3,000)
Balance at end of year $ 76,260 $ 71,000
Plant replacement and expansion funds:
Balance at beginning of year $1,100,000 $1,494,000
Restricted gifts and bequests 113,000 150,000
Income from investments 15,000 18,000
Transferred to unrestricted funds (de-
scribed above) (628,000) (762,000)
Transferred from unrestricted funds (de-
scribed above) 230,000 200,000
Balance at end of year $ 830,000 $1,100,000
Endowment funds:
Balance at beginning of year $3,975,000 $2,875,000
Restricted gifts and bequests 2,000,000 1,000,000
Net gain on sale of investments 175,000 100,000
Balance at end of year $6,150,000 $3,975,000
43
Sample Hospital EXHIBIT D
44
Statement of Revenues and Expenses and
Changes in Unrestricted Fund Balance
(Alternative Presentation)
Year Ended December 31, 19
With Comparative Figures for 19
Operating expenses:
Nursing services 2,200,000 2,200,000
Other professional services 1,900,000 1,900,000
General services 2,100,000 2,100,000
Fiscal services 375,000 375,000
Administrative services (including in-
terest expense of $50,000 and $40,-
000) 400,000 400,000
Provision for depreciation 300,000 300,000
Total operating expenses 7,275,000 7,275,000
Loss from operations (368,000) - - (368,000) (212,000)
Nonoperating revenue:
Unrestricted gifts and bequests $ 228,000 - 228,000 205,000
Unrestricted income from endowment
funds 170,000 - 170,000 80,000
Income and gains from board-desig-
nated funds 24,000 $ 30,000 54,000 41,000
NOTE: If the alternative format above is presented, the total column must be included to present fairly the information contained
therein.
45
Sample Hospital EXHIBIT E
46
Statement of Changes in Financial Position of
Unrestricted Fund
Current Prior
Year Year
Funds provided:
47
Sample Hospital
Notes to Financial Statements
December 31, 19
Quoted
Cost Market
Board-designated funds $1,427,000 $1,430,000
Specific-purpose funds 200,000 210,000
Plant replacement and expansion
funds 800,000 838,000
Endowment funds 6,100,000 8,200,000
Accumulated
Cost Depreciation
Land 300,000 $ - 0 -
Land improvements 140,000 100,000
Buildings 7,088,000 2,885,000
Fixed equipment 2,000,000 800,000
Movable equipment 1,500,000 100,000
$11,028,000 $3,885,000
48
Cost reimbursement revenue in the amount of $110,000 resulting
from the difference in depreciation methods is deferred in the current
year and will be taken into income in future years.
49
Schedule I
Sample Hospital
Patient Service Revenues
Year Ended December 31, 1 9 —
With Comparative Figures for 19
50
Sample Hospital Schedule 2
Operating Expenses
Year Ended December 31, 19—
With Comparative Figures for 19
Current Year Prior Year
Supplies Supplies
Personal and Other Personal and Other
Services Expense Services Expense
Nursing services: $
Administrative office
Medical and surgical
Pediatrics
Intensive care
Psychiatric
Obstetric
Newborn nurseries
Premature nurseries
Other units
Operating rooms
Recovery rooms
Delivery and labor rooms
Central services and supply
Intravenous therapy
Emergency service
Education
Other _
i
Other professional services: $
Administrative office
Laboratories
Blood bank
Electrocardiology
Electroencephalography
Radiology
Clinics
Inhalation therapy
Medical records
Pharmacy
Anesthesiology
Physical therapy
Social service
Education
Research
Other _
$
51
Sample Hospital Schedule 2
Operating Expenses (cont'd) (cont'd)
Current Year Prior Year
Supplies Supplies
Personal and Other Personal and Other
Services Expense Services Expense
General services: $
Administrative office
Dietary
Plant engineering
Power plant
Electricity and refrigeration
Maintenance shops
Automotive service
Elevator operators
Security
Housekeeping
Laundry and linen
Personnel quarters
Printing and duplicating
Physicians' offices
Auxiliary units
Fiscal services: $
Administrative office
Accounting
Admitting
Credits and collections
Data processing
Receiving
Cashier
Communications
Storerooms
Other
$
Administrative services: $
Executive office
Personnel
Purchasing
Public relations
Governing board
Medical staff
Employee benefits
Insurance
Auxiliaries
Interest
Other
$
52
Chapter 8
53
In our opinion, except for the effect of reflecting investments
of endowment funds at market value as stated in the preceding
paragraph . . . .
54
have upon accounts receivable, patient revenue, loss for the year,
and unrestricted fund balance.
In our opinion, except for the effect, if any, of the final deter-
mination of the Medicare reimbursement referred to in the pre-
ceding paragraph . . . .
55
APPENDIX
Glossary
Knowledge of special terminology used in hospital accounting
is necessary for an understanding of a hospital's financial state-
ments. Terms most frequently used are defined in this section.
No attempt has been made to define all accounting, technical,
medical, and semi-medical terms used.
Definitions used in this section have been adapted from a vari-
ety of sources, including:
Terminology bulletins of the AICPA
Kohler's A Dictionary for Accountants (Prentice-Hall, Inc.,
1970)
Chart of Accounts for Hospitals (American Hospital Asso-
ciation, 1966)
Uniform Hospital Definitions (American Hospital Associa-
tion, 1960)
College and University Business Administration (American
Council on Education, 1968)
56
Contractual replacement funds. Funds set aside by agreement with
third-party payors for renewal and replacement of property, plant,
and equipment.
Contributed services. See Donated services.
Cost finding. The segregation of direct costs by cost centers, the
allocation of overhead costs to revenue-producing and other centers
between inpatients, outpatients, and other classifications.
Donated services. The estimated monetary value of service of per-
sonnel who receive no monetary compensation or partial compen-
sation for their services. The term is usually applied to services
rendered by members of religious orders, societies, or similar groups
to institutions operated by or affiliated with such institutions.
Endowment funds. Funds in which a donor has stipulated, as a con-
dition of his gift, that the principal of the fund is to be maintained
inviolate and in perpetuity and that only income from investments of
the fund may be expended. (See also Term-endowment funds.)
Functional classification. The grouping of expenses according to the
operating purposes (e.g., patient care, education, research) for
which costs are incurred.
Fund. A self-contained accounting entity set up to account for spe-
cific activity or project.
Fund balance. The excess of assets over liabilities (net equity). An
excess of liabilities over assets is known as a deficit in fund balance.
Funds functioning as endowment. See Board-designated investment
fund, which is the preferred term.
Funds held in trust by others. Funds held and administered, at the
direction of the donor, by an outside trustee for the benefit of an
institution or institutions.
Governing board. The policy-making body of the institution. Some
of the responsibilities usually attributed to the governing board may
be assumed by appropriate committees.
Living trust funds. Funds acquired by an institution subject to agree-
ment whereby resources are made available to the institution on
condition that the institution pay periodically to a designated person,
or persons, the income earned on the resources acquired for the
lifetime of the designated person, or persons, or for a specified
period.
Non-expendable funds. See Endowment funds, which is the preferred
term.
Object classification. A method of classifying expenditures according
to their natural classification such as salaries and wages, employee
benefits, supplies, purchased services, etc.
57
Permanent funds. See Endowment funds, which is the preferred
term.
Plant. Physical properties used for institutional purposes; i.e., land,
building, improvements, equipment, and so forth. The term does not
include real estate or properties of restricted or unrestricted funds
not used for hospital operations.
Plant replacement and expansion funds. Funds donated for renewal
or replacement of plant.
Pooled investments. Assets of two or more funds consolidated for
investment purposes.
Restricted funds. Funds restricted by donors for specific purposes.
The term refers to specific purpose and endowment funds.
Retirement of indebtedness funds. Funds required by external
sources to be used to meet debt service charges and the retirement
of indebtedness on plant assets. The term "sinking funds" is some-
times used to describe these funds.
Share of pooled investments. The proportion of pooled investments,
including accumulated gains or losses, owned by a particular fund,
usually expressed by a number (units) indicating the fractional
ownership of total shares in the pool or by a percentage expressing
the portion of the total pool owned by the particular fund.
Sinking fund. See Retirement of indebtedness funds.
Special purpose fund. See Specific purpose funds.
Specific purpose funds. Funds restricted for a specific purpose or
project. Board-designated funds do not constitute specific purpose
funds.
Temporary funds. See Specific purpose funds.
Term endowment funds. Donated funds which by the terms of the
agreement become available either for any legitimate purpose desig-
nated by the board or for a specific purpose designated by the donor
upon the happening of an event or upon the passage of a stated
period of time.
Unexpended plant funds. See Plant replacement and expansion funds.
Unrestricted funds. Funds which bear no external restrictions as to
use or purpose; i.e., funds which can be used for any legitimate
purpose designated by the governing board as distinguished from
funds restricted externally for specific operating purposes, for plant
replacement and expansion, and for endowment.
58