Experiences in Nature - Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder
Experiences in Nature - Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder
No matter what we touch, an atom or and decay. But more than just experience, they want
a cell, we cannot explain it without to really feel part of nature’s great circling. Maria
knowledge of the wide universe. (Maria Montessori’s vision was that the children should
Montessori, To Educate the Human “live in Nature.” 1 She saw that children naturally
Potential 6) revel in forest and field and stream, and want to be
intimate with their kin, the Earth’s creatures. And
And for this knowledge of the wide universe she came to believe more and more strongly, espe-
to take root, the child needs, in addition to hearing cially after the experiences she and her son Mario
the inspiring great story of our cosmos and expo- had with children living in nature in India, that a
sure to all the scientific disciplines, the experience deep intimacy with the natural world was not only
of simple natural and timeless acts such as sow- very healing for the child but prepared him well for
ing seed, gathering the crops, and celebrating the the next plane of development, for his relationship
bounty with friends. to society, to the human family.
1
In The Discovery of the Child, a brilliant chapter titled “Nature in Education,” Maria Montessori elaborates on this idea beautifully
and with a practicality clearly based on lived experience with children.
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 153
The monarch sits quietly, perched upon a nearby
flower. He is probably the last of his kind before
the incoming frost. The wind blows cool in my
face. I know it’s coming … fall.
“The Crows!”
The crows, here they come, darting to the
ground.
The crows, the crows, they’re every-
where,
The crows, on the ground, walking all
around,
The crows, the crows, they’re every-
where.
Here more come, in the air,
The crows, the crows, they’re every-
where. (Zeke, age eight)
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 155
So first of all it is essential that our children get are a real inspiration and source of much interest
their hands in the soil, in the “good clean dirt,” as for them as they pursue this work.
grandmother used to say. Our children have to learn
gardening, the whole of gardening, from preparing There is so much to see in a well cultivated gar-
the ground for the seed, to harvest and the further den. J. Henri Fabre, the great French entomologist so
preparations for the next cycle. This is so vitally admired by Maria Montessori, did most of his classic
important because this experience is the most direct observations of spiders, caterpillars, bees, and other
way for a child to access the laws of nature, to par- insects in field and garden. Unbroken time, patience,
ticipate in nature’s mysteries, and to make both a a writing journal, a sketchpad, and a hand lens are
heart connection and a nascent scientific observer ’s the indispensable tools. Daily access is also vitally
awakening to plants, insects, animals, fungi, water, important. For in Fabre’s own words regarding his
sunlight, and so on. We have watched children keep- observations of garden spiders, “What I did not see
ing a daily nature journal of their observations of very plainly yesterday I can see the next day, under
different seeds as they sprout and grow. A deep kin- better conditions, and so on any of the following
ship with the plants being studied and cared for is days, until the phenomenon under observation is
developed, not to mention the incredible refinement revealed in all its clearness” (231).
of the powers of observation and the patient waiting
that is fostered. Children are born naturalists, and And “the child, who more than anyone else is
not surprisingly the lives, diaries, and drawings of a spontaneous observer of nature, certainly needs
the great historical and contemporary naturalists to have at his disposal material upon which he can
Courtesy of Mr. Katsuhiko Yorita, Information Center, Okinawa, Japan, submitted by Takako Fukatsu
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 157
critical first- and second-plane years? If the answer notating the songs. These are fascinating pieces to
is yes, one can then begin to imagine how this child, play on the tone bars. 2
grounded in his natural world, is prepared to be
the “Erdkind” of the third plane of development, Elementary children need to hear the stories
eager to work out the societal adaptations needed of the natural scientists throughout history, both
for his time, place, and circumstances. the well-known and lesser known. Figures such as
Charles Darwin, Jane Goodall, Carolus Linnaeus,
In order to more fully embody nature and the Rachel Carson, George Washington Carver, Gregor
biological sciences, children also need to see and Mendel, and Anton van Leeuwenhoek are definitely
hear of examples of people throughout history who on the list. There are many others, especially those that
were inspired by nature. They need to know of the inspired Dr. Montessori, such as J. Henri Fabre and
writers, artists, and composers who drew upon Ernst Haeckel, or those of the American nature-study
the natural world for their work. It is important to and conservation movements of the late nineteenth
read to them examples from writers such as Wen- and early twentieth centuries, such as John Muir,
dell Berry, Annie Dillard, Mary Oliver, and Edwin Liberty Hyde Bailey, and Anna Botsford Comstock.
Way Teale. During this time period there was written a wealth of
literature for children and teachers. Notable examples
include Life and Her Children by Arabella Buckley
To glimpse the intensity of this relationship
(1840-1929), published in 1880. Buckley was the
to nature and to inspire creativity in composing
secretary of Sir Charles Lyell, geologist, and a friend
nature poetry, read this poem by Mary Oliver to
of Charles Darwin. Her many books for children are
your children:
deeply grounded in evolutionary theory and portray
“Of What Surrounds Me” the classification of animals as understood at the time.
Whatever it is I am saying, I always It is important to have had exposure to these heroes
need a leaf or a flower, if not an of biology and nature study, to have heard of their
entire field. As for the sky, I am so wildly
particular life-changing experiences, and to experience
in love with each day’s inventions, cool blue
or cat gray or full their original words and feel how the soul is stirred,
of the ships of clouds, I simply can’t nourished, and inspired by such writing.
say whatever it is I am saying without
at least one skyful. That leaves water, a Drawing is an essential experience that supports
creek or a well, river or ocean, it has to be children in their developing powers of observation.
there. For the heart to be there. For the pen
to be poised. For the idea to come. (32)
Children must record what they see in the natural
world by illustration (and composition). Dr. Montes-
These words are simple and deep, but clear sori identified this need for children to experience
enough for an older elementary child to grasp. themselves as observer/illustrators. After the begin-
ning work with geometry, she experimented with
Other areas of creative endeavor in which one having the children draw geometric designs, using
can explore nature themes include art, music, dance, rulers, compasses, protractors, squares, and pen and
and drama. Study the nature-based art of Jean- ink. All the geometric figures were reproduced as
François Millet, John Constable, Claude Monet, and designs and gathered into a portfolio. Thus, not only
Georgia OKeeffe. Listen to nature-related music by did the children acquire a deep understanding of the
composers such as Antonio Vivaldi in the visually geometric forms, they developed coordination and
descriptive piece The Goldfinch; and Georg Frideric hand-eye skills that laid the foundation for further
Handel’s The Cuckoo and the Nightingale. An interest- work in drawing. “To confer the gift of drawing
ing footnote to this would be the work of Dr. Tony we must create an eye that sees, a hand that obeys,
Phillips at State University of New York at Stony a soul that feels; and on this task the whole life
Brook. Dr. Phillips, a professor of mathematics, has must cooperate. In this sense life itself is the only
been analyzing native bird songs, slowing down preparation for drawing. Once we have lived, the
the sound, playing these pieces on the piano, and inner spark of vision does the rest” (Montessori,
2
See http://www.math.sunysb.edu/~tony/birds/music/index.html. Children can listen to bird songs and begin to train their ears
in this way, as well as with the Montessori bells.
The Advanced Montessori Method—The Montessori secting and identifying the parts of a violet, “with
Elementary Material 309). great joy they began to draw them; and they were
accurate, skilled, tireless, and patient, as they are
When the children had practiced these geometric in everything else” (313-314).
exercises for a while, she then introduced opportu-
nities for observation in nature: This type of work is the same done by great re-
searchers and naturalists in the field. Jane Goodall
The observation of nature (flowers and their dif- has kept meticulous notes and sketches as she studied
ferent parts—pollen, leaves, a section of some part the chimpanzees in Gombe Stream National Park in
observed under the microscope, plant seeds, shells, Tanzania over a period of forty-five years. 3
etc.) serves to nourish the child’s aesthetic imagi-
nation. The children also have access to artistic
designs, collections of photographs reproducing
Children are innately drawn to illustrate what
the great masterpieces, and Haeckel’s famous work they see in nature. They employ pen and ink and
Nature’s Artistic Forms, all of which equipment is watercolors with ease, if the environment is prepared
so interesting and delightful to a child. (303) for this. These exercises have to be offered as a regular
work in the class, just like grammar and multiplica-
The work with natural objects was a perfect next tion, not as a specialty that occurs periodically.
step for the drawing experience, and the children
began to enjoy simple botanical dissections and There must be time, especially quiet, reflec-
working with microscopes: After carefully dis- tive time, in nature, in the garden, or studying the
3
See an image of Dr. Goodall and a sample page from her notebooks at this site: http://bio1151.nicerweb.com/Locked/media/
ch01/inductive.html.
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 159
He calls these “rendezvous points,” where we meet
a “concestor,” our most recent common ancestor. He
tells the tale in the spirit of Chaucer ’s Canterbury
Tales. Many of these stories are perfect little fables
to inspire thought and further research among
elementary students. For example, “The Hippo’s
Tale,” which is also “The Whale’s Tale,” tells how
we now know that both hippopotami and cetaceans,
closely related, are descendants of land mammals.
In classification, the super-order Cetartiodactyla
includes cetaceans (whales, dolphins, etc.) and the
artiodactyls (even-toed ungulates: hippos, deer,
etc.). Every tale in this book can become a point of
Courtesy of Brad Bachulis
interest for the Timeline of Life.
Our approach to the discipline of biology is • Ability to identify the common native
based on the child’s psychology, on his growing plants and animals of their region
interests throughout the first and second planes of
development. There is a building up of substantive • Familiarity with domesticated plants
knowledge of the discipline in a systematic way. and animals
Knowledge of the anatomy and physiology of the
• Ecology and relationships among the
major phyla is gradually acquired together with a
organic and inorganic
comprehensive taxonomic scheme. The scientific
nomenclature is introduced over a nine-year period. • Taxonomy and its current nomenclature
The understanding of biology is, in the Montessori (e.g. Cnidaria in place of the old term
elementary classroom, always related to the timeline Coelenterata)
of life and the emerging story of the evolution of
life on Earth. The maintenance and history of the • All current organizing principles, such
Earth’s atmosphere, hydrosphere, and lithosphere as Domains and Kingdoms, not a simple
through the work of Earth’s living creatures is a plant/animal dichotomy
unique aspect of our elementary science. In addi-
tion, the elementary child is offered a fundamental • The anatomy, physiology, and main
understanding of the nature and role of the key characteristics of the Domains and
elements of carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, Kingdoms
and a vision of the great global cycling of water,
carbon, and nitrogen. • Deep understanding of the Timeline
of Life, including the life forms of the
As Montessori educators, we must stay current Pre-Cambrian
in our knowledge of the sciences. We must read,
discuss with colleagues, and support our classroom • A clear introduction to the Bacteria
environments as lively, stimulating laboratories. For and Protists in the later years of the
example, Richard Dawkins’ The Ancestor’s Tale takes elementary—we must move from the
a different look at the evolution of life. Dawkins seen to the unseen (microscope work
moves from the present back into the past, noting is essential here, as is a real laboratory
each important event of evolution along the way. experience)
• Plant Form and Function The following words of Professor Bailey echo Dr.
Montessori’s faith in nature as central in education:
• Animal Form and Function “The light, the dark, the moon, the cloud, the rain, the
wind, the falling leaf, the fly, the bouquet, the bird, the
• Ecology
cockroach—they are all ours. If one is to be happy, he
These are the worlds to open to the elementary must be in sympathy with common things. He must
student, not a detailed study, but an introduction to live in harmony with his environment” (31).
these concepts, planting the seed. All of these topics
should be introduced during the elementary years Anna Botsford Comstock, the author of the Cornell
and most are already represented in our classroom Nature Study Leaflets, was a scientist-illustrator of
materials. One large area of biology study that may renown. Her famous book Handbook of Nature Study
not be as developed is the study of the cell. Just as (1911) is still in print today and is a great resource
we present the golden bead unit as the basic build- for teachers. 4 Both Professor Bailey’s and Professor
ing block of mathematics and the letters as the basic Comstock’s desire was to cultivate in the child a
unit of language, so we must present the cell as life’s love of the outdoor environment, a love of beauty
fundamental unit of structure and function. in nature, and an ability to observe simple, com-
mon natural things. Such experiences would, they
Now let us return to experiences in nature, for believed, truly develop the child. Their approach
these are the bedrock upon which the aesthetic was to follow the child’s interests, not the subject
and intellectual work is founded. Dr. Montessori matter. Dr. Montessori combined this approach with
writes of five gradations of ascent in the study of a parallel intellectual study and presented them as
nature. It starts out with the child’s being initiated complementary and as both necessary for a deep
into the world of just observing the phenomena of understanding of our natural world.
4
Anna Botsford Comstock was the first college professor to actually take her students outside to study nature. Her scientific illus-
trations, particularly wood-engravings of insects, were exhibited nationally. In 1894 she established the nature study curriculum
in New York public schools. She was also elected to the National Wildlife Federation’s Conservation Hall of Fame in 1988. Both her
life story and her beautiful drawings are worth sharing with children.
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 161
What we elementary Montessori teachers have
to remember is that the real experiences in nature
come first, and not only that, but they must con-
tinue to be the centerpiece of what we call Cosmic
Education as we gradually grow the intellectual
disciplines and introduce the scientific materials
for exploration and development.
Montessori, Maria. From Childhood to Adolescence. Montessori, Renilde. Educateurs san Frontières. Paris:
1948. New York: Schocken, 1973. Desclee de Brouwer, 2000.
Montessori, Maria. The Advanced Montessori Oliver, Mary. New and Selected Poems: Volume Two.
Method—The Montessori Elementary Material. New Boston: Beacon Press, 2005.
York: Stokes, 1917.
Wikramaratne, Lena. “The Child in the World of
Montessori, Maria. The Montessori Method. New Nature.” The NAMTA Quarterly 2.2 (1976, Win-
York: Stokes, 1912. ter): 26-31.
Gerard Leonard is AMI trained in Dublin at the primary and elementary levels. He has taught for over
thirty years in primary, elementary, and adolescent classrooms. He is the program coordinator at The Cobb
School Montessori in Simsbury, Connecticut and is in the AMI Elementary Training-of-Trainers Program.
He is a member of the NAMTA board and serves on the advisory board of the Montessori Training Center
of New England.
Kathleen Allen is AMI trained and has been teaching for more than forty years. Additionally, she conducts
research and design in the field of classroom materials, including scientific illustrations, and is a key imple-
menter of The Keepers of Alexandria. She currently teaches an upper elementary class at Hudson Country
Montessori School (Danbury, CT) and is working towards a doctorate in history.
Reprinted from The NAMTA Journal 33,3 (2008, Summer): 81-97. This talk was presented at The Fourth
Adolescent Colloquium, Chicago, IL, April 24-27, 2008.
Leonard and Allen • Experiences in Nature: Resolute Second-Plane Directions Toward Erdkinder 163