Handbook of Optical Filters Microscopy: For Fluorescence
Handbook of Optical Filters Microscopy: For Fluorescence
H A N D B O O K of
O P T I C A L F I LT E R S
for F L U O R E S C E N C E
MICROSCOPY
by J A Y R E I C H M A N
HB2.0/June 2017
C H R O M A T E C H N O L O G Y C O R P
AN INTRODUCTION TO
H A N D B O O K of
FLUORESCENCE MICROSCOPY 2
O P T I C A L F I LT E R S Excitation and emission spectra
Brightness of the fluorescence signal
for F L U O R E S C E N C E
The fluorescence microscope
MICROSCOPY Types of filters used in fluorescence microscopy
The evolution of the fluorescence microscope
by J A Y R E I C H M A N
A GENERAL DISCUSSION
OF OPTICAL FILTERS 8
Terminology
Available products
Colored filter glass
Thin-film coatings
Acousto-optical filters
Liquid Crystal Tunable Filters
REFERENCES 30
GLOSSARY 31
Fluorescence microscopy requires optical filters that have demanding spectral
and physical characteristics. These performance requirements can vary greatly
depending on the specific type of microscope and the specific application.
Although they are relatively minor components of a complete microscope
system, optimally designed filters can produce quite dramatic benefits, so it
is useful to have a working knowledge of the principles of optical filtering as
applied to fluorescence microscopy.
This guide is a compilation of the principles and know-how that the engineers
at Chroma Technology Corp use to design filters for a variety of fluorescence
microscopes and applications, including wide-field microscopes, confocal
microscopes, and applications involving simultaneous detection of multiple
fluorescent probes. Also included is information on the terms used to describe
and specify optical filters and practical information on how filters can affect
the optical alignment of a microscope.
Finally, the handbook ends with a glossary of terms that are italicized or in
boldface in the text.
Our coating lab and optics shop are integrated into a single facility operated
by a staff with decades of experience in both coating design and optical
fabrication. We are dedicated to providing the optimum cost-effective
solution to your filtering requirements. In most cases our staff will offer, at no
extra charge, expert technical assistance in the design of your optical system
and selection of suitable filtering components.
Spectra Emission
Spectra dye sample is strongly illuminated by a color of light that is found
to cause some fluorescence. A spectrum of the fluorescent emission
is obtained by scanning with the analyzing spectrometer using this
fixed illumination color. The analyzer is then fixed at the brightest
emission color, and a spectrum of the excitation is obtained by
scanning with the illuminating spectrometer and measuring the
Wavelength
variation in emission intensity at this fixed wavelength. For the
purpose of designing filters, these spectra are normalized to a scale of
FIGURE 1
relative intensity.
Generic excitation and emission spectra
for a fluorescent dye.
These color spectra are described quantitatively by wavelength of light. The
most common wavelength unit for describing fluorescence spectra is the
nanometer (nm). The colors of the visible spectrum can be broken up into the
approximate wavelength values (Figure 2):
2
On the short-wavelength end of the visible spectrum is the
near-ultraviolet (near-UV) band from 320 to 400 nm, and on
the long-wavelength end is the near-infrared (near-IR) band
from 750 to approximately 2500 nm. The broad band of light
from 320 to 2500 nm marks the limits of transparency of
crown glass and window glass, and this is the band most often
used in fluorescence microscopy. Some applications, especially
in organic chemistry, utilize excitation light in the mid-
ultraviolet band (190 to 320 nm), but special UV-transparent
illumination optics must be used.
2 The emission spectrum might change “shape” to some extent, but this is an insignificant effect for most
applications. See Lakowicz (1983) for an in-depth description of the mechanism of fluorescence.
3
The quantum efficiency, which is the ratio of light energy absorbed to
fluorescence emitted, determines how much of this absorbed light energy
will be converted to fluorescence. The most efficient common fluorochromes
have a quantum efficiency of approximately 0.3, but the actual value can be
reduced by processes known as quenching, one of which is photobleaching.
The combination of these factors, in addition to the fact that many specimens
have very small amounts of stained material in the observed field of view,
gives a ratio of emitted fluorescence intensity to excitation light intensity in
a typical application of between 10 -4 (for very highly fluorescent samples) and
10 -6. Current techniques (e.g. fluorescence in situ hybridization), which utilize
minute amounts of fluorescent material, might have ratios as low as 10 -9
or 10 -10.
Thus, in order to see the fluorescent image with adequate contrast, the
fluorescence microscope must be able to attenuate the excitation light
by as much as 10-11 (for very weak fluorescence) without diminishing the
fluorescence signal. How does the fluorescence microscope correct for this
imbalance? Optical filters are indeed essential components,
but the inherent configuration of the fluorescence microscope
also contributes greatly to the filtering process.
Fluorescence
with incident light it need only filter out excitation light
Filter scattering back from the specimen or reflecting from glass
Cube
surfaces. The use of high-quality oil-immersion objectives
(made with materials that have minimal autofluorescence
Filter and using low-fluorescence oil) eliminates surface reflections,
Arc Lamp
Slider Collector
Lenses which can reduce the level of back-scattered light to as
Objective
little as 1/100 of the incident light. In addition, the dichroic
beamsplitter, which reflects the excitation light into the
Specimen Stage
objective, filters out the back-scattered excitation light by
another factor of 10 to 500. (The design of these beamsplitters
is described below.)
FIGURE 3
Schematic of a wide-field epifluorescence microscope, An epifluorescence microscope using oil immersion, but without any filters
showing the separate optical paths for illuminating
the specimen and imaging the specimen: other than a good dichroic beamsplitter, can reduce the amount of observable
illumination path excitation light relative to observed fluorescence to levels ranging from 1
imaging path
(for very bright fluorescence) to 10 5 or 10 6 (for very weak fluorescence). If
one wants to achieve a background of, say, one-tenth of the fluorescence
image, then additional filters in the system are needed to reduce the observed
excitation light by as much as 10 -6 or 10 -7 (for weakly fluorescing specimens)
and still transmit almost all of the available fluorescence signal. Fortunately,
there are filter technologies available (described in the section beginning on
page 10) that are able to meet these stringent requirements.
4
TYPES OF FILTERS USED IN
FLUORESCENCE MICROSCOPY
The primary filtering element in the epifluorescence microscope is the set
Ocular
of three filters housed in the fluorescence filter cube (also called the filter
block): the excitation filter, the emission filter, and the dichroic beamsplitter. Emission
Filter
A typical filter cube is illustrated schematically in Figure 4.
Beamsplitter
1) The excitation filter (also called the exciter) transmits only those
wavelengths of the illumination light that efficiently excite a specific dye.
Excitation
Common filter blocks are named after the type of excitation filter: Filter
Although shortpass filter designs were used in the past, bandpass filter designs
are now used almost exclusively. Objective
FIGURE 4
2) The emission filter (also called the barrier filter or emitter) attenuates all Schematic of a fluorescence filter cube
of the light transmitted by the excitation filter and very efficiently transmits
any fluorescence emitted by the specimen. This light is always of longer
wavelength (more to the red) than the excitation color. These can be either
bandpass filters or longpass filters. Common barrier filter colors are blue or
pale yellow in the U-block, green or deep yellow in the B-block, and orange
or red in the G-block.
Most microscopes have a slider or turret that can hold from two to four
individual filter cubes. It must be noted that the filters in each cube are a
matched set, and one should avoid mixing filters and beamsplitters unless the
complete spectral characteristics of each filter component are known.
3 The term “dichroic” is also used to describe a type of crystal or other material that selectively absorbs light depending
on the polarization state of the light. (Polaroid ® plastic film polarizer is the most common example.) To avoid confusion,
the term “dichromatic” is sometimes used.
5
Other optical filters can also be found in fluorescence microscopes:
1) A heat filter, also called a hot mirror, is incorporated into the illuminator
collector optics of most, but not all, microscopes. It attenuates infrared light
(typically wavelengths longer than 800 nm) but transmits most of the visible
light.
3) Filters used for techniques other than fluorescence, such as color filters for
transmitted-light microscopy and linear polarizing filters for polarized light
microscopy, are sometimes installed.
THE EVOLUTION OF
THE FLUORESCENCE MICROSCOPE 4
The basic configuration of the modern fluorescence microscope described
above is the result of almost 100 years of development and innovation. By
looking at its development over the years, one can gain a better understanding
of the function of these various components.
4 Most of this information is taken from the following excellent reference: Kasten (1989).
5 The first barrier filter to be used was a pale yellow coverslip, which protected the eye from hazardous radiation, but
some of the early fluorescence microscopes might have lacked even this.
6 6 Several fluorescent dyes were synthesized in the eighteenth century for other purposes, including use as chemo-
therapeutic drugs that stained parasitic organisms and sensitized them to damaging rays.
darkfield condenser, which directed the excitation light into a cone of light
at oblique angles, prevented most of the excitation light from entering the
objective lens, thus reducing the demands on the optical filters. However,
the efficiency of the illumination was greatly reduced, and the objective lens
required a smaller numerical aperture, which resulted in a further reduction
in brightness as well as lower resolution.7
7 Abramowitz (1993).
9 Information and sequence of events confirmed through communication with Dr. Bas Ploem, 2006. 7
10 Inoué (1986) is an excellent text detailing the use of video imaging and microscopes in general.
A GENERAL DISCUSSION OF OPTICAL FILTERS
TERMINOLOGY
Although color designations such as U, B, and G are often adequate for
describing the basic filter sets, it is useful to be familiar with the terms used
for more precise descriptions of filters, especially when dealing with special
sets for unusual dyes and probes. The most common unit for describing
filter performance is the wavelength of light in nanometers, the same as for
fluorochrome spectra described previously. Note that the perceived color
of a filter depends on the bandwidth (described below) as well as specific
wavelength designation. This is especially noticeable when looking through
filters in the range of 550 to 590 nm: a filter with a narrow band will look
pale green while a filter with a wide band, especially a longpass filter, will
look yellowish or even bright orange.
FIGURE 6 1) Bandpass filters are denoted by their center wavelength (CWL) and
A) Nomenclature for transmission bandwidth (FWHM).11 The center wavelength is the arithmetic mean of the
characteristics
wavelengths at 50% of peak transmission. The FWHM is the bandwidth at
B) Nomenclature for blocking
50% of peak transmission.
2) Longpass and shortpass cut-on filters (LP and SP) are denoted by their cut-on
or cut-off wavelengths at 50% of peak transmission. LP or SP filters that have
a very sharp slope (see next page) are often called
edge filters. The average transmission is calculated
over the useful transmission region of the filter,
rather than over the entire spectrum. (Please note
that the use of terms “highpass” and “lowpass” are
discouraged because they more accurately describe
frequency rather than wavelength.)
8
%T
ways other than absorption. For example, thin-film interference filters
block primarily by reflection, and acousto-optical filters block by
diffraction. Therefore, the term “optical density” is more precise. (Both
of these filter products are described in detail in the section beginning
on page 10.)
transmission scale, the slopes as indicated on the optical density scale are
significantly different. Slope can be specified by stating the wavelength at
which a particular filter must have a specified blocking level.
5) The angle of incidence (AOI) is the angle between the optical axis
of the incident light and the axis normal to the surface of the filter, as
illustrated in Figure 9. Most filters are designed to be used at zero degrees
angle of incidence, called normal incidence, but for beamsplitter coatings
the usual angle is 45 degrees. It should be noted that most types of filters, FIGURE 9
Schematic illustration of terms used to describe polarization.
such as thin-film interference coatings and acousto-optical crystal devices,
The normal axis is the axis perpendicular to the surface of the
are “angle-sensitive,” which means that the characteristic performance coating, and the plane of incidence is defined by the normal
changes with angle. (These products are described in greater detail in the axis and the direction vector of the incident light beam.
FIGURE 11
Polarizing effect of a typical dichroic mirror. This
particular coating is designed for reflecting the 488 nm
linearly polarized argon-ion laser line in the S-plane.
9
AVAILABLE PRODUCTS
The two main types of filter technology used in fluorescence analysis are
colored filter glass and thin-film coatings. In addition, acousto-optical tunable
filters are finding increased use in special applications. These products are
described below. Other products, such as holographic filters and liquid-crystal
tunable filters, are available, but they are used infrequently in fluorescence
microscopy.
1) It is relatively inexpensive;
2) The bandpass types have poor slope and often low peak
transmittance;
12 Some minor exceptions are: 1) sharp-cut longpass filter glasses have a shift in cut-on of approximately 0.1 to
10 0.15 nm/ °C temperature change; and 2) some types of filter glass can be affected by unusual environments such as
intense UV radiation (“solarization”) or high humidity. (Schott Glasswerke catalogue.)
Thin-Film Coatings NOT TO SCALE!!!
Two widely used categories of thin-film coating are 1) metallic coatings Incident Reflected Light,
light modified by interference
for making fully reflective mirrors and neutral-density filters; and 2) thin-
film interference coatings, which are the main component of interference
filters. The main advantage of thin-film interference coatings is the
Thin Film
tremendous flexibility of performance inherent in the way they work. layers
Thickness
As shown in Figure 13, interference coatings are composed of a stack Glass Substrate
of microscopically thin layers of material, each with a thickness on the Transmitted light, modified by
order of a wavelength of light (usually around a quarter of a wavelength interference
and the colors follow contours of constant thickness within the single
layer of soap.13
including bandpass, shortpass, and longpass filters, and dichroic Wavelength (nm)
beamsplitters. By adjusting the number of layers in the stack and the FIGURE 14
thickness of each layer, one can control to high precision the nominal Spectra of a triple-band filter designed for DAPI, FITC, and
Texas Red ® emissions. (Chroma Technology Corp P/N 69002
wavelength, the bandwidth, and the blocking level. One can also emission filter)
create filters with greater complexity than the standard bandpass,
longpass, or shortpass. For example, filters with multiple bands
produced using the modified magnetron sputter deposition process,
illustrated in Figure 14, have several highly transmissive bands and
are valuable tools in fluorescence microscopy.
13 But unlike a soap bubble, the optical thin-films are of solid material (either polycrystalline or
amorphous), and the coating layers are extremely uniform in thickness.
11
Due to advances in coating technology, some of these limitations
have been greatly reduced. All interference coatings, unlike metal
coatings or absorption glass, have a finite blocking range, but high
energy coating technology maintains transmission while extending
the blocking region. Filters produced by modified magnetron sputter
technology, for example, have broader ranges of extinction by using
sophisticated blocking strategies incorporated into the coating
design. The extended blocking region using this coating process
has a negligible effect on the transmission through the bandpass.
The signal-to-noise ratio that this type of filter offers allow for the
FIGURE 16 acquisition of high quality data in many photon-critical applications.
Reflectivity vs. absorptance. This dichroic
beamsplitter sample has high absorption in the UV.
2) In traditional filter technology, the coating materials are limited in
their range of transparency. Outside of this range, coatings become highly
absorbing rather than highly transmissive or reflective. Some of the coating
materials that are ideal for visible filters have excessive absorption in the UV,
so materials with different and less-than-ideal characteristics must be used
for UV filters. As a result, UV filters tend to have more limited performance
and less design flexibility. Another consequence is that one cannot always
calculate the reflectivity from a transmission spectrum by assuming zero
absorption in the wavelength range shown in the spectrum. Figure 16 is an
example of a dichroic beamsplitter designed for high reflectivity in the visible
only. The drop in transmission in the UV is a result of absorption instead
of reflection. In general, one cannot assume that a beamsplitter designed to
reflect the visible will also reflect the UV. Filters produced with newer high
energy coating technology use materials with broader ranges of transparency
in the violet and near UV.
12 14 The effective physical thickness of the thin-film coating does indeed increase with increasing angle of incidence,
but the difference in path length of the interfering reflected light rays decreases.
Advantages of the AOTF include:
2) the ability to rapidly vary the intensity by changing the amplitude of the
acoustic vibrations.
FITC
FITC
DESIGNING FILTERS
FOR FLUORESCENCE MICROSCOPY
Excitation
Emission
%
The primary goal of filter design for fluorescence microscopy is to
create filter sets (typically an excitation filter, emission filter, and
dichroic beamsplitter) that maximize image contrast and maintain
0
300 400 500
Wavelength (nm)
600
image quality.
B)
100
Filter How the filter designer incorporates the available information regarding
a particular application is described in detail below.
0
300 400 500 600
Image quality is maintained by ascertaining the optical quality
D)
Wavelength (nm)
requirements at each point in the microscope where a filter is
100
TRITC inserted, and ensuring that each filter is manufactured to the correct
TRITC Emission
Excitation specifications. In order to ascertain these requirements, one must be
well grounded in the fundamentals of microscope optics and have
%
Bandpass
Emission
Bandpass
Excitation In addition, the filter designer must be aware of all the physical
dimensions required by the various microscope brands and models.
%
IMAGE CONTRAST
0
The general process by which a filter set is optimized for a particular
fluorochrome can be illustrated by taking as an example a specimen
300 400 500 600
Wavelength (nm)
stained with the dye FITC and explaining how filters are designed for
FIGURE 18
this dye.
A) FITC excitation and emission spectra
B) Perfect filter pair for FITC, overlaid on excitation and
emission spectra Fluorescence spectra
C) Filter pair with bandpass excitation filter specific to FITC
D) TRITC excitation and emission spectra, overlaid on The single most important parameter for designing a filter set is the
FITC spectra spectral characteristic of the dye, with excitation and emission spectra
E) Bandpass filter pair for FITC (Chroma Technology Corp P/N
shown in Figure 18A. If this were the only parameter to be considered,
49002), overlaid with excitation/emission spectra for FITC
and TRITC
14
one would illuminate the specimen using a shortpass excitation filter that
transmits all of the excitation spectrum and observe the fluorescence using
a longpass emission filter that transmits the entire emission spectrum. A
pair of filters for FITC having these characteristics is shown in Figure 18B.
These represent “ideal” shortpass and longpass filters: real filters would need
a wider separation between the cut-on and cut-off because of slope limitations
of filters, and the shortpass excitation filter would have a cut-off point
somewhere in the UV.
For cytometric applications where image brightness is not critical, even more
narrow bands are often used in order to maximize the selectivity between
fluorochromes.
Light sources
So far, a hypothetical light source having an equal output in all
colors—a pure white light—has been assumed. Real light sources
can have a wide variety of spectral output, and in many cases it is
important to design filters with the type of light source in mind.
Following is a list of light sources often used for fluorescence
microscopy.
1) Mercury arc lamps are the most common light source for
fluorescence microscopy, chosen for its high brightness (known
technically as luminance or radiance) in the ultraviolet and
visible spectrum. The spectrum of this light source (Figure 19) is FIGURE 19
far from continuous; most of its light output is concentrated in Spectrum of a mercury arc lamp. (Mid-UV output below 300
nm is not shown.)
a few narrow bands, called lines, and each line is approximately
15
10 nm wide. Most general-purpose filter sets should have
100 00 400 500 600
excitation filters that transmit one or more of these lines, but
Mercury
Spectrum there can be noticeable exceptions, one of which is illustrated in
the following example. Figure 20 shows the effect of modifying the
excitation spectrum of FITC by the output of a mercury arc
%
Wavelength (nm) quantitatively, but they are not as bright as a mercury lamp of
equivalent wattage. Even in the region of FITC excitation (between
FIGURE 20 450 and 500 nm) where the mercury lamp is relatively weak,
A) FITC excitation spectrum unmodified, and modified the xenon arc lamp is only marginally brighter. There are two
by the mercury arc lamp spectrum (normalized to 100%
relative peak T). main reasons for this. First, the light-producing arc of the xenon
B) Modified FITC excitation spectrum overlaid with lamp is larger than the arc in the equivalent mercury lamp, which
standard and wide-band excitation filters.
reduces the amount of available light that can be focused onto
the specimen using a typical microscope configuration. Some
relevant data concerning mercury and xenon arc lamps are given in
Table 1. Note the differences in arc size between the lamps. Second,
the xenon arc lamp has proportionally much greater output in the
Near-IR as seen in Figure 21, as well as the IR.
FIGURE 21
3) Metal-halide short-arc lamps are used increasingly for fluorescence
Spectrum of a xenon arc lamp.
microscopy. Spectrally, there is significant variation in output
between models. In general they are similar to mercury arc lamps,
but with greater relative intensity between the main emission lines.
In this respect they are similar to standard xenon arc lamps. Metal
halide sources have significant advantages over traditional mercury
and xenon arc lamps: a) they have a useful life up to 2000 hours,
compared to 200 hour of the typical mercury illuminators and 400
15 This shift can occur, for example, under conditions of low pH values (pH less than 6) (Haugland, 1992).
16
LAMP TYPE RATED POWER LUMINOUS FLUX AVERAGE BRIGHTNESS ARC SIZE RATED LIFE
(watts) (lumens) (candela/mm2) w x h (mm) (hours)
Mercury
HBO 50W/3 50 1300 900 0.20 x 0.35 200
HBO 100W/2 100 2200 1700 0.35 x 0.25 200
HBO 200W/2 200 10000 400 0.60 x 2.20 400
Xenon
XBO 75W/2 75 1000 400 0.25 x 0.50 400
XBO 150W/1 150 3000 150 0.50 x 2.20 1200
TABLE 1
Data for xenon and mercury arc lamps. Boldface entries indicate most common sizes for fluorescence microscopes. (From Abramowitz, 1993)
The main disadvantage is that due to larger arc size (the smallest size
being approximately 1.2 mm) and limitations of optics of the elliptical
reflector, the average brightness is similar to the xenon arc lamps. And
like xenon arc lamps, they generally have higher output in the IR than
the mercury arc lamp.
rated for at least 10,000 hours, with many lasting upwards of 300 400 500 600
Wavelength (nm)
700 800 900
17
The main disadvantage now is, ironically, the narrow spectral emission
band. This is for two reasons: a) for multi-channel applications, the output
of several diffferent colors of LED must be combined, necessitating relatively
complex optical schemes that can limit overall brightness; and b) there are
only a limited number of spectral bands available, especially one in the green
spectral region that can match the very useful 546 nm mercury line.16 One
must also be aware that for any single LED color, there can be significant
variability in peak wavelength from batch to batch (up to 20 nm,) as well
as a wavelength dependence on the temperature and magnitude of the drive
current used to power the LED (up to 5 nm.)
Detectors
The excitation filter must be designed to block any out-of-band light
FIGURE 23
that can be picked up by the detector. Arc lamps and filament lamps
Typical spectrum of an argon-ion laser. (Data from Spectra-physics
Lasers, Inc.) have output throughout the near-UV, visible, and IR, so the filter
must have adequate attenuation over the whole range of sensitivity of
the detector. But for laser illumination, the blocking range of excitation
filters need only cover the range of output of the laser. For example, IR
1 00
50 blocking is not required for the argon-ion laser (Figure 23).
10
5 Figure 24 shows some sensitivity spectra of important detectors.
%
FIGURE 24
Sensitivity of various detectors. Each spectrum is In general it is preferable to block out-of-band light with the excitation
normalized to peak sensitivity. (Video and PMT filter instead of the emission filter for three reasons: 1) the specimen will be
data from Hamamatsu Corp.)
exposed to less radiation; 2) fewer components in the emission filters generally
improve its optical imaging quality; and 3) many microscopes have shallow
cavities for holding emission filters, so it is beneficial to eliminate components
that add to the finished thickness. There are certain cases, for example UV
excitation, where the process of extending the blocking of the excitation filter
greatly reduces the peak transmission of the filter. In these cases it would be
appropriate to provide extended IR blocking in the emission filter instead.
16 The recent use of conversion phosphors has helped to overcome this limitation. Conversion phosphors are coat-
18 ings that are added to LED systems that absorb the LED light and emit light at a longer wavelengths. Phosphors
having output spectra that better match the excitation spectra fluorochromes can be selected.
When doing visible photographic work, it is important to have IR blocking
because some built-in light meters have IR sensitivity that could affect
exposure times.
Beamsplitters
The final stage in the design of a filter set is to select a dichroic beamsplitter
that matches the spectra of the excitation and emission filters. Beamsplitters
having both high reflectance of the excitation band and high transmittance
of the emission band not only maximize the signal but also improve contrast
by further reducing background noise. Reflectance of greater than 95% of
the excitation band, with average transmission greater than 95% in the
emission band, can now be achieved with advanced coating technology such
as modified magnetron sputtering.
FIGURE 25
Completed filter set design for FITC (Chroma Technology Corp P/N 49002)
19
OPTICAL QUALITY
The optical quality requirements for an optical filter depend very much
on such factors as the type of filter (especially whether it is a component
of the illumination optics or the imaging/detection optics), the type of
microscope, and the intended application. For example, the optical quality
specifications for an emission filter used for quantitative image analysis with
a laser scanning confocal microscope are much different from those for an
excitation filter used for qualitative visual observation with a standard wide-
field microscope. Although specific requirements for every type of filter and
every application cannot be described here, by introducing the key optical
quality parameters and analyzing a few basic microscope configurations, one
can develop a set of general guidelines that can be applied to most situations.
reflected
optical element from a perfect plane, usually measured in fractions or
wavefront
multiples of a wavelength of visible light (usually 550 or 630 nm, but
TRANSMITTED WAVEFRONT DISTORTION
sometimes using the CWL for a bandpass filter). The actual reflected
wavefront distortion (RWD) that a plane wave of light undergoes when
incident transmitted
reflected from the surface is twice the value of the surface flatness.17
wavefront wavefront
It should be noted, however, that specifications using the term "RWD"
are usually interpreted as the surface flatness of the substrate at normal
incidence, because this is the standard configuration when measuring
WEDGE (PARALLELISM)
with a commercial interferometer. If the specification must truly be for
RWD and not flatness, then this should be clearly noted.
incident
wavefront deviated
wavefront
The RWD of light reflected off a beamsplitter or mirror is solely
wedge angle determined by the surface flatness of the reflecting surfaces, usually just
the front surface.
3) Wedge (also called parallelism) is a measure of how parallel are the outer
surfaces of an optical element. Wedge is usually measured in arc-minutes
or arc-seconds of angle. The main effect of wedge is to induce an angular
17 This is strictly true only for light reflected at normal incidence. The value for light reflected at non-normal incidence
is modified by a cosine factor. For example, the reflected wavefront distortion at 45 degrees angle of incidence is
approximately 1.4 times the surface flatness.
20
deviation in the direction of a light beam, causing, for example, image shifting.
The amount of angular deviation is about one-half the wedge angle for a typical
filter.18 The wedge of internal coating surfaces, while not contributing greatly
to beam deviation, can cause noticeable ghost images as a result of off-axis
internal reflections.
4) The clear aperture of optical filters should not restrict the overall aperture
of the microscope. It is also of critical importance that there is no leakage of
unfiltered light around the edge of the clear aperture. Filter manufacturers
usually sell filters in rings to ensure there is no leakage. If a filter is purchased
without a ring, it is usually the responsibility of the customer to install the
filter in a way that eliminates leakage.
5) Scratches and digs are measured in terms of mil-spec standards; e.g., “80/ 50
scratch/dig.” The term digs includes such things as particles and small bubbles
embedded inside a filter and macroscopic inclusions in exposed coatings.
With this in mind, some observations can be made regarding optical quality
requirements for this type of microscope.
18 For small angles of incidence, the angular deviation = ( N - 1) α, where N is the refractive index of the glass in the
filter, and α is the wedge angle. Most filters use optical glass with a refractive index of approximately 1.5.
19 For an in-depth description of Köhler illumination optics, please refer to Inoué (1986) or literature from the micro-
scope manufacturers. 21
1) The illumination optics of the microscope are designed for uniform
illumination of the specimen with minimal flare, and not necessarily for
faithful imaging of the light source or apertures. Therefore, excitation filters
do not require transmitted wavefront distortion of imaging quality,20 but
only what is generally considered the industry standard of optical quality.
Likewise, the surface flatness of the dichroic mirror does not require imaging
quality.
20 The term "imaging quality" denotes a level of optical quality that will not degrade the overall performance of a spe-
cific optical system. For a typical microscope, a TWD of 1 wave per inch is generally considered adequate for optical
filters and beamsplitters.
22 21 Most
modern microscopes of this type have relay lenses in the filter-block housing that improve the collimation
inside the cube. The sensitivity is reduced but not eliminated entirely.
The wedge and, to a lesser extent, the thickness of the dichroic beamsplitters
and the emission filters must be tightly controlled for filter sets that require
sub-pixel registration (SPR). The optical-quality requirements for SPR filter
sets is discussed in more detail on page 24.
6) Since the excitation filter is usually positioned near the field diaphragm (a
point conjugate to the image plane in Köhler illumination), pinholes in the
excitation filter are very noticeable and must be eliminated.
FILTER TYPE
OPTICAL QUALITY
PARAMETER EXCITATION EMISSION BEAMSPLITTER
23
FILTER SETS FOR SUB-PIXEL REGISTRATION
A common method for imaging specimens with multiple fluorochromes
is to record images of each fluorochrome separately, using a high-
resolution monochrome CCD camera. The separate images are then
pseudo-colored and overlaid into a single image. Images are obtained
using a different filter "cube" for each fluorochrome. The matched set
of filter cubes are installed in a multi-position slider or turret.
Another secondary cause of image shift can be the flatness of the dichroic
beamsplitter. Thin-film interference coatings in have intrinic mechanical
stress that will cause a substrate to warp. The amount of stress is heavily
dependant on the coating process. Some processes such as magnetron and
ion-beam sputter deposition, make coatings with very high stress, enough
to noticeably warp a thin substrate. If the light beam in the imaging path is
not collimated, this warpage can induce a significant image shift. This effect
may be noticeable if all dichroic beamsplitters in the sets that are installed in
multi-position slider or turret are not made by the same deposition process.
24 22 This assumes that the refractive indices of the glass substrates used in the filters are similar.
FILTERS FOR CONFOCAL MICROSCOPY
Relay
Objective
FIGURE 27
Nipkow-Disk Scanning CFMs Schematic of a confocal fluorescence microscope
with Nipkow-disk scanning.
Figure 27 is a schematic illustration of a CFM with broad-band arc
lamp illumination, a Nipkow-disk scanning mechanism, and an
image detector, either a camera or direct visual observation.
25
Laser Scanning CFMs
Figure 28 is a schematic illustration of a CFM with laser illumination, a
Illumination Path
Imaging Path moving-mirror scanning mechanism, and photometric detection such as a
Detectors
With Apertures Emission Filters
photomultiplier tube (PMT). The optical paths in this microscope design
Dichroic Mirror Spatial Filters are significantly different from those in wide-field microscopes. The two
For Emission (Pinholes, Slits)
major differences are:
Laser
1) the pinhole (or slit) in the illuminator is imaged onto the specimen
Excitation/Emission
Laser
Beamsplitter plane via critical illumination, with the laser spot being directly focused
onto the sample; and
Scanner
Excitation Filters
Objective
Dichroic Mirror 2) the image is formed by synchronously matching the train of electrical
For Excitation
signals generated by the detector to the position of the laser beam on the
Specimen specimen, similar to the image-forming mechanism of a television set.
FIGURE 28 The electrical signals from the detector correspond to the variations in
Schematic of a laser scanning confocal fluorescence microscope. the intensity of the fluorescence signal that passes through the conjugate
pinhole (or slit) aperture.
In the emission optics, any components that are located between the objective
and the detection aperture must be of imaging quality. In the example
illustrated, this includes all of the emission filters and beamsplitters shown.
Some systems might use a single aperture that would be located between the
main excitation/emission beamsplitter and the detection unit. In this case,
the optical requirements for the filters within the detection unit might be less
critical.
26
EFMs, the spectral requirements are basically the same, with one exception:
because of reduced signal intensity and the addition of extra optical elements,
each of which produces undesirable reflections and scattering, excitation and
emission filter pairs must have very low cross-talk.23 In addition, extra care is
required in the quality control of pinholes in the filters.
1) Excitation filters must have a blocking range that covers the entire output
spectrum of the laser. While filters that block to 800 nm are suitable for
traditionalthe laser sources , the DPSS lasers often have residual output at the
NIR wavelengths used in the laser, particularly 1064 nm, that may fall within
the response range of the detector. One special consideration regarding the
filtering of laser excitation is that excitation filters for lasers should attenuate
as much as possible by reflection in order to reduce the thermal load on the
filter. For example, UV excitation filters for argon-ion lasers should have high
reflectivity in the blue-green region of the visible spectrum where most of the
laser power is concentrated.
2) The lasers used in most CFMs are polarized, so knowledge of the polarization
conditions is very useful when designing beamsplitters for optimum
performance. The dichroic beamsplitter illustrated in Figure 9, for example,
was optimized for use in S-plane orientation with the 488 nm argon-ion laser
line, enabling the beamsplitter to have greater throughput in, for example, a
band of fluorescent emission that cuts on at 500 nm. Note that fluorescent
emissions are largely unpolarized even when the excitation light is polarized,
so the beamsplitter must efficiently transmit the fluorescence in both planes
of polarization. Knowledge of the polarization conditions is especially useful
when designing multiple-band polychroic beamsplitters, which must have very
narrow reflection bands in order to maximize the transmission of the emission
signals.
3) Emission filters must have a blocking range on the short wavelength side
of the band that includes all laser lines that might be used with the particular
filter. Blocking on the long wavelength side is recommended for applications
that use multiple probes, to improve selectivity between the probe signals.
Here the range of blocking only needs to cover the range of the detector, which
can be as short as 700 nm for some PMTs (Figure 23).
23 Some systems utilize polarized optics to reduce the effect of these reflections.
27
TABLE 3
Methods for applications using multiple probes.
1. Separate single-band filter sets. Standard microscope. No extra equipment is necessary. Simultaneous imaging is
not possible.
Brightest images.
Imprecise imaging of combined
images.
2. Multi-band filter sets. Standard microscope. Simultaneous visual observation Reduced brightness.
with no registration errors.
Not recommended with xenon arc
No extra equipment is required illumination.
(other than special filter set).
Color balance is fixed.
3. Multi-band beamsplitter and Microscope with filter wheel or Sequential visual observation with Extra equipment (a filter wheel or
emitter, single-band exciter. slider in the illumination path. no registration errors. slider) is necessary.
4. Multi-band beamsplitter, Microscope with filter wheels or Exciters and emitters can be Extra equipment (two filter wheels
single-band emitters and sliders in both the illumination designed to have brightness or sliders) is necessary.
exciters, single camera. path and imaging path. similar to method 1.
Registration errors between
Photo camera, or electronic Reduction in registration error emitters might still be present.
camera with image processing. (by eliminating movement of the
beamsplitter).
5. Multi-band beamsplitter, Microscope with filter wheel or In addition to advantages in More complicated apparatus
single-band emitters and slider in the illumination path. method 4: requiring additional beamsplitters
exciters, multiple cameras. and cameras.
Beamsplitter assembly for sepa- Registration errors from emitters
rating channels, each channel can be eliminated;
having a separate emission filter.
Additional applications are sup-
ported (e.g., ratio imaging).
6. Neutral beamsplitter, replacing Any valid combination of exciter Brightness can be reduced by
multi-band beamsplitter in and emitter can be used. as much as 80%, so special light
methods 4 and 5. sources are recommended (e.g.,
laser illumination).
28
FILTERS FOR MULTIPLE PROBE APPLICATIONS
When making a multiple-exposure photograph or multiple electronic
images of specimens stained with several fluorochromes, using separate
filter cubes in a standard microscope, there will be unavoidable
registration shifts between exposures. Varying amounts of wedge in the
emission filter and beamsplitter, variations in thickness and alignment
of the beamsplitter, and mechanical vibration that occurs when the
cubes are switched all contribute to this shift. Although for some
applications these effects can be reduced to acceptable levels, many
others require more sophisticated filter designs and optical apparatus.
Listed in Table 3 are some available methods for applications involving multiple
probes. These include the multi-band filter sets introduced earlier, illustrated
in Figure 29, and various configurations that utilize both multi-band and single-
band filter components. All of these methods are designed to eliminate the
aforementioned registration errors. Method 2 offers the ability to visually observe
up to three colors simultaneously. (Methods 3 through 6 can also do this if multi-
band filters are added to the filter sets.) It should be noted that this list is only a
guide, not an exhaustive list of all possible methods and configurations.
Emission Filter
Excitation Filter
Dichroic Beamsplitter
100
%T
0
400 500 600 700
Wavelength (nm)
FIGURE 29
®
Spectra of a triple-band filter set designed for the dyes DAPI, FITC, and Texas Red .
(Chroma Technology Corp P/N 69002)
29
REFERENCES
Abramowitz, M. (1993) Fluorescence Microscopy: The Essentials. Olympus
America, Inc.
Brimrose Corp., Baltimore, MD. AOTF Spectroscopy (March 1993 catalogue).
Ealing Electro-optics (1992) Product Guide, Holliston, MA.
Haugland, R.P. (1992) Handbook of Fluorescent Probes and Research
Chemicals, 5th ed. Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR.
Inoué, S. (1986) Video Microscopy. Plenum Press, New York.
Kasten, F. H. (1989) The origins of modern fluorescence microscopy and
fluorescent probes. Cell Structure and Function by Microspectrophotometry
(E. Kohen and J. G. Hirschberg, eds.). Academic Press, San Diego, CA.
Lakowicz, J. (1983) Principles of Fluorescence Spectroscopy. Plenum Press,
NewYork.
Schott Glasswerke. Mainz, Germany. Optical Glass Filters (catalogue).
30
GLOSSARY
with page references
Autofluorescence (p. 2)
In fluorescence microscopy, any fluorescence from substances other
than fluorochromes, including primary fluorescence from the specimen,
fluorescence
from immersion oils and other media, and fluorescence from glass optical
components within the microscope.
Background (p. 4)
Any detectable light that is not a desired primary or indirect fluorescent
emission. Sources of background include cross-talk between excitation and
emission filters, light leaking through pinholes in filters, and electronic noise
in cameras, as well as autofluorescence.
31
Bandpass (p. 8, fig. 6)
An optical filter that has a well-defined short wavelength cut-on and long
wavelength cut-off. Bandpass filters are denoted by their center wavelength
and bandwidth.
Barrier filter
See Emission filter.
Blocking level
See Attenuation level.
Brightfield (p. 6)
A kind of diascopic illumination in which the field of view is illuminated
directly. Also, the type of condenser used for this kind of illumination.
32
Cross-talk (p. 9, fig. 7)
The minimum attenuation level (over a specified wavelength range) of two
filters placed together in series. The transmission spectrum of the beamsplitter
is sometimes included in this evaluation.
Darkfield (p. 6)
A kind of diascopic illumination in which the specimen is illuminated
obliquely, i.e., at angles that will not enter the objective directly. Also, the
type of condenser used for this kind of illumination.
Edge filter (p 8)
Another term for either a shortpass or longpass optical filter. The term
usually denotes a filter with a very sharp cut-on or cut-off.
Emitter
See Emission filter.
33
Excitation filter (p. 5, fig. 4)
Also Exciter. A color filter that transmits only those wavelengths of the
illumination light that efficiently excites a specific dye. See Emission filter.
Exciter
See Excitation filter.
Fading
See Photobleaching.
Filter block
See Filter cube.
Fluorescence (p. 2)
A molecular phenomenon in which a substance absorbs light, then radiates
part of this absorbed energy as light of another color, one of lower energy and
thus longer wavelength. This process is known as excitation and emission.
Fluorescence is distinguishable from other types of luminescence in that the
process of excitation and emission occurs nearly instantaneously (i.e., on the
order of nanoseconds).
34
Fluorochrome (p. 2)
A fluorescent dye used either directly as a specimen stain or conjugated to an
active substance to make a fluorescent probe.
Fluorophore
See Fluorescent probe.
FWHM
See Bandwidth.
Hot mirror
See Heat filter.
35
Interference filter
See Thin-film interference coating.
Luminance
See Radiance.
Parallelism
See Wedge.
36
Photobleaching (p. 3)
Also Fading. A photochemical reaction that causes the intensity of fluorescence
to decrease with time.
Polarization (p. 9)
Restriction of the orientation and phase of the electromagnetic field vibrations
caused by propagating light. These vibrations are transverse to the direction
of propagation of the light, and can be oriented at some angle around the axis
of propagation. When the orientation and the phase of the vibrations change
rapidly and randomly in time, the light is said to be unpolarized. When the
vibrations are restricted to one particular orientation angle over an extended
length of time, the light is said to be plane-polarized. Light can be partially as
well as totally plane-polarized. When the relative phase of the vibrations varies
with angle in a regular periodic fashion over an extended length of time, the
light is said to be elliptically polarized. Circular polarization is a special case
in which the amplitude of the vibrations are equal for all angles. When light
is elliptically polarized, the orientation of the vibrations rotates around the
propagation axis at the frequency of the light.
P-plane
See Polarization.
37
Quenching (p. 4)
Any chemical process which reduces the quantum efficiency of a fluorochrome
in situ.
Slope (p. 9)
A measure of the sharpness of the transition from the transmitting region to
the blocking region of a color filter.
38
S-plane
See Polarization.
Substrate (p. 5)
The ground and polished piece of optical glass that is used as a base for the
beamsplitter coating.
TE-mode
Another term for S-plane polarization. (Short for “transverse-electric” mode.)
See Polarization.
TM-mode
Another term for P-plane polarization. (Short for
“transverse-magnetic” mode.) See Polarization.
39
Transmitted wavefront distortion (TWD) (p. 20)
A measure of the distortion a plane wave of light undergoes when transmitted
through an optical element, measured in fractions or multiples of a wave-
length of visible light (usually 550 or 630 nm).
40
CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
AND MANUFACTURING
Chroma Technology Corp and the Chroma logo are registered trademarks of Chroma Technology Corp