Editing Worksheet
Editing Worksheet
Colin’s English teacher asked each student to write a biographical report about an interesting person.
Colin wrote this report about a cartoonist. He would like you to read his paper and suggest the
corrections and improvements he should make. When you finish reading, answer the questions that
follow.
Missouri home. (3) Fascinated, the boy would spend endless hours in the woods, quietly and
patiently observing. (4) As he watched he would sketch his observations. (5) By the time
Walter was seven years old, everyone in the neighborhood knew about his drawings.
(6) When he was a teenager, Walter discovered that he enjoyed entertaining people.
(7) He would show them his art and sometimes even sell sketches to friends and neighbors.
(8) During world war I, when Walter was just 16, he joined the Red Cross and reported to
France to drive an ambulance. (9) He didn’t cover his vehicle with the traditional camouflage.
(11) Soon after his return to the United States, this passionate artist developed his own
animation company. (12) Unfortunately, the business failed, but Walter wasn’t ready to give up
on his dream. (13) He decided to partner with his older brother Roy, and start another
company. (14) Walter spent hours at the drawing board and eventually developed a cartoon
character called Oswald the Lucky Rabbit. (15) People liked the character, but it didn’t bring
Walter fame or fortune. (16) Determined to become successful, he created a new character, a
perky little mouse named Mickey. (17) When Mickey was featured in the short film Steamboat
Willie, Walter began to get the recognition he had always wanted. (18) In fact, Mickey Mouse
was such a hit that Walter began producing monthly cartoons starring the animated mouse.
(19) Soon Walter added some sidekicks, including Donald Duck and Goofy.
1
(20) In time, Walter became one of the most beloved and recognized cartoonists in
history. (21) At one point he developed an idea for a feature-length animated movie, but his
colleagues scoffed at them. (22) “Your plan will never work,” they said. (23) “No one will come
to see such a movie.” (24) Walter proved everyone wrong; when Snow White and the Seven
(25) You have probably figured out that the boy named Walter was Walter Elias Disney.
(26) During his lifetime Disney and his staff created 18 animated feature-length films and won
48 Academy Awards. (27) He also produced television shows such as Disney’s Wonderful
World of Color and The Mickey Mouse Club, and founded California’s Disneyland. (28) With a
steadfast determining to reach his goals and a desire to share his appreciation of animals,
Walt Disney enriched the lives of millions of people around the world.
2
5. What change should be made in sentence 13?
A. Change decided to desided
B. Change his to their
C. Delete the comma after Roy
D. Change start to starting
3
Answer Key Editing Practice #1
Genre: Expository
4
English Editing Passage #2
In response to an English assignment, Dustin wrote this paper about an experience he had. He wants
you to read the paper and help him correct and improve it. When you finish reading, answer the
questions that follow.
5
(14) One unexpected checkmate later, I regretted my overconfidence.
(15) A nine-year-old had beaten me in a mere 10 minutes! (16) I concealed my
disappointment and congratulated the apparant prodigy.
(17) “Good game! (18) You’re a terrific player,” I said with a genuine smile.
(19) The next three rounds went by very quickly, with each game proving more difficult
than the one before. (20) By evening I had one win and three losses. (21) After the second
game I was ready to forfeit and go home, but I stayed smiling and sincerely congratulating
each of my opponents.
(22) As the trophies were being awarded, I listened respectful, applauding each winner
as his or her name was called. (23) It was hard to hide my disappointment, but I tried.
(24) Suddenly I heard the announcer say my name and was shocked to see everyone looking
at me.
(25) “For excellent chess etiquette, a friendly attitude, and plain old determination, the
Good Sport Award goes to Dustin Hodges,” the judge declared.
(26) I grinned as I walked up to except the prize. (27) It wasn’t the trophy that I had
hoped for, but the gold plaque looks pretty good on my bookcase. (28) Of course, it won’t stay
there forever. (29) I plan to replace it with the championship trophy next year.
6
3. What is the correct way to rewrite 6. What change, if any, should be made
sentence 7? in sentence 16?
A. I glanced up at the prizes, and A. Change and to I
each trophy. Glistening in the B. Change congratulated to
summer sun. congratulating
B. Glancing up at the prizes. I noticed C. Change apparant to apparent
that each trophy was glistening in D. Make no change
the summer sun.
C. I glanced up at the prizes, that
trophy was glistening in the 7. What change is needed in sentence
summer sun. 21?
D. Glancing up at the prizes, I noticed A. Change second to Second
that each trophy was glistening in B. Delete the comma after home
the summer sun. C. Insert a comma after stayed
D. No change needed
8
Editing Practice #3
Brittney wrote this paper for her English class. She would like you to read her paper and
suggest ways that she might correct and improve it. When you finish reading, answer the
questions that follow.
(1) Visiting my grandmother at her old farmhouse in the country is like going back in
time. (2) During our stay she spends her evenings knitting and told us stories. (3) She wants
us to know what life was like when she was growing up. (4) She hopes we appreciate how
lucky we are to have food, shelter, and work because she recalls a time when those things
(5) Grandma was just 10 years old when the stock market crashed in 1929. (6) All the
money that her family had saved was suddenly gone. (7) The Great Depression, a tragic time
in American history had begun. (8) The once prosperous family farm could not generate the
income it had in the past. (9) As a result, life became very difficult for Grandma’s family.
(10) Money was so scarce that everything, including flour sacks, had to be used in more ways
than one.
(11) Grandma says that she will never forget the flour-sack dresses she and her sisters
had to wear. (12) Even though life was hard and many people felt desperate. (13) Grandma’s
family discovered a secret. (14) They found that they didn’t need money to be happy.
(15) Grandma’s dad loved to think of ways for the family to have fun without spending no
money. (16) He organized rowdy games in the farmhouse kitchen, assisted with the building of
snow forts, and arranged square-dancing parties with neighbors. (17) Instead of buying
Christmas gifts, family members exchanged handmade presents with each other.
(18) Grandma says that her family grew so close during those years that even if she could go
9
(19) Her favorite memorys are of the times when the family would go on secret
missions. (20) They knew that other people were also struggling, and they wanted to help
whenever they could. (21) Sometimes the whole family would sneak over to a neighboring
farm during the night and drop off a loaf of homemade bread or leave a basket of vegetables
(22) Although the neighbors never knew who was behind these little acts of kindness,
grandma says that they brought great joy to her and her family. (23) She believes that this joy
is what sustained them through some of the hardest times in our nations’ history.
10
4. What is the best way to rewrite
sentences 12 and 13? 7. What change, if any, should be made
A. Even though life was hard and in sentence 19?
many people felt desperate, A. Change favorite to favoritest
Grandma’s family discovered a B. Change memorys to memories
secret. C. Change when to which
B. Even though life was hard, many D. Make no change
people felt desperate, Grandma’s
family discovered a secret.
C. Even though life was hard, and
many people felt desperate, and
Grandma’s family discovered a 8. What is the best change to make in
secret. sentence 22?
D. Correct as is A. Change knew to new
B. Change grandma to Grandma
C. Change they to it
5. What change needs be made in D. Insert a comma and quotation
sentence 15? marks before that
A. Change dad to Dad
B. Insert a comma after ways
C. Delete no
D. No change needed 9. What change needs to be made in
sentence 23?
A. Change She to And
6. What change, if any, should be made B. Change sustained to sustaned
in sentence 17? C. Change through to threw
A. Delete the comma after gifts D. Change nations’ to nation’s
B. Change exchanged to
exchanging
C. Change each other to one
another
D. Make no change
11
Answer Key Editing Practice #3End of Editing Practice #3
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
12
Editing Practice #4
In response to an English assignment, Vanessa wrote this story about a memorable day. Read
Vanessa’s story and look for ways she might correct and improve it. When you finish reading, answer
the questions that follow.
Inspection Day
(1) I yawned and gulped a bit more coffee as I stumbled into work at the pizza parlor
that Saturday morning. (2) I was so sleepy that I failed to notice that the parking lot was more
crowded then usual. (3) The sign on the door read “Closed Until 4:00.” (4) That should have
reminded me that this day would be different. (5) However, I didn’t remember until I saw the
mops, buckets, and brooms and hearing the upbeat music booming from the speakers.
(7) My boss Harry is the sort of man who can make even the most borring jobs seem
fun. (8) Today, however, he looked very serious. (9) He insisted that the shop had to be
spotless by the time the inspector arrived. (10) The twinkle in his eye suggested that he
(11) Harry assigned jobs, he checked off each task on his clipboard. (12) When he
called my name, he looked up with a sly, mischievous smile. (13) He said, “I have a very
special job for you, Vanessa. (14) He pointed at the large pizza oven.
(15) The inside of the oven was caked with the remains of every pizza that had been
made since the last inspection. (16) I wasn’t excited about cleaning it, but I knew I had no
choice. (17) Someone had to crawl inside to clean it, and I was the only person small enough
to fit.
(18) I grabbed the oven cleaner, rubber gloves, paper towels, and scrub brush and
squeezed inside the oven. (19) Quickly I went to work. (20) I was surprised by how efficiently
the oven cleaner ate through all the grime. (21) Fortunately, I was wearing a protective mask
13
and safety goggles, so I didn’t have to worry about the fumes hurting my lungs or burning my
eyes. (22) It was actually kind of fun to watch the remnants of all those pizzas just vanish!
(23) I scrubbed until the job was finally finished. (24) You couldn’t have asked for a
cleaner oven. (25) However, my uniform, which was covered in black soot was another story.
(26) After everybody had a good laugh about how silly I looked, harry rewarded me by letting
me go home early. (27) I cleaned up and then decided to ask some friends to join me for
dinner. (28) This was one night I would definitely not eat pizza, though.
ON
1. What change, if any, should be made
3. What correction needs to be made to
in sentence 2? sentence 7?
A. Change failed to fail A. Change who to he
B. Change notice to notise B. Change borring to boring
C. Change then to than C. Change fun to funner
D. Make no change D. No change is needed
14
5. What is the correct way to rewrite sentence 11?
A. Harry assigned jobs. Checking off each task on his clipboard.
B. As Harry assigned jobs, he checked off each task on his clipboard.
C. Assigning jobs and checking off each task. Harry used his clipboard.
D. No revision is needed.
16
Editing Practice #5
Debra has written about a recent experience. She wants you to review her paper. As you read,
think about the corrections and improvements she should make. When you finish reading,
answer the questions that follow.
A Gift of Life
(1) Last October I gave my big sister a gift that no one else could have gave her.
(2) I gave Shannon my right kidney. (3) Shannon is 10 years older than me, and I’ve always
looked up to her. (4) Now we share a special bond that goes beyond being sisters.
(5) For as long as I can remember, Shannon has been sick. (6) She has type 1 diabetes
and has to give herself shots every day. (7) Her kidneys began to fail last May, Shannon had
to start going to the hospital for dialysis three times a week. (8) In this treatment a machine
does the filtering work that kidneys normally do. (9) Eventually, the doctors told us that
(10) At first, we thought she would have to wait until she reached the top of the Nation’s
transplant list. (11) But then we learned that a family member might be a match. (12) In that
(13) I knew right away that I would like nothing more than to give one of my kidneys to
Shannon. (14) So I was tested—and tested and tested! (15) I was stuck with so many needles
that Shannon laughed and said, Now you understand what it feels like to be me!” (16) As my
sister and I waited to find out whether I could give Shannon the gift that she needed, we grew
closer than ever. (17) After a few weeks the doctors finally confirmed it: we were a perfect
match!
18) The day of the surgery soon arrived. (19) Shannon and I were wheeled into
adjoining operating rooms while our family members huddled tensely in the waiting room.
17
(20) I don’t remember nothing after squeezing Shannon’s arm and before we went into
surgery. (21) The next thing I knew, I was waking up in the recovery room. (22) I was out of the
hospital in three days, and Shannon came home two weeks later. (23) Already her life seems
to have a new sparkle. (24) I know that my kidney is now hard at work in her body makes me
1. What change, if any, should be made 3. What is the correct way to rewrite
in sentence 1? sentence 7?
A. Insert a comma after gift A. When her kidneys began to fail last
B. Change could to couldn’t May, Shannon had to start going to
C. Change have gave to have given the hospital for dialysis three times a
D. Make no change week.
B. Because her kidneys began to fail
last May. Shannon had to start going
to the hospital for dialysis three times
2. What change needs to be made in a week.
sentence 3? C. Beginning to fail last May, Shannon
A. Change me to I am had to start going to the hospital for
B. Delete the comma after me dialysis three times a week for her
C. Change I’ve to i have kidneys.
D. Change her to herself D. No revision is needed.
5. O ON
18
4. How should sentence 10 be changed? 7. What change, if any, should be made in
A. Change thought to thinking sentence 20?
B. Insert quotation marks around wait A. Change nothing to anything
C. Change Nation’s to nation’s B. Change squeezing to squeazing
D. Change transplant to transplent C. Change we to they
D. Make no change
19
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
20
Editing Practice #6
Carmen combined her imagination with what she knew about the past to write this fictional
narrative. As you read Carmen’s paper, look for the corrections and improvements she should
make. When you finish reading, answer the questions that.
living room to visit with relatives. (3) I went to the den, where I found a 1958 high school
(4) I had heard that the 1950s was a decade of cool cars, cool hamburger joints, and
cool rock-and-roll music. (5) Aunt Sharon, by her own report, had been cool then, too.
(6) I starred at the yearbook picture of my great-aunt. (7) The girl with the ponytail looked back
at me. (8) Surprisingly, she waved to me, inviting me into her world.
(9) Nobody in the school cafeteria seemed to notice me, but I definitely noticed
everyone else, especially Aunt Sharon and her girlfriends. (10) They all looked strangely alike
in their plaid skirts, cuffed socks, and saddle shoes. (11) Their ponytails swung from side to
side. (12) Talking about sock hops and drive-ins. (13) Guys with short hair and identical school
sweaters winked at these girls. (14) In another part of the cafeteria, I noticed some boys who,
on the contrary had long hair and wore leather jackets. (15) I suddenly realized that cliques
hadn’t started with my generation they had been around in the 1950s, too!
(16) After school a boy named Steve drove Sharon home. (17) Steve’s convertible was
really cool! (18) I rode in the backseat with one of Sharon’s friends, but no one paid no
attention to me. (19) I must have been invisible to the other teenagers in the car.
(20) After Steve pulled the car into the driveway, I followed Sharon into her house.
(21) In the middle of the living room sat a huge piece of furniture that Sharon referred to as
21
the new television. (22) The profile of a native American in a full headdress filled the tiny
screen set in a big wooden cabinet. (23) A soft hum accompanyed the black-and-white image.
(24) “Why is there always a test pattern in the afternoon?” Sharon complained loudly.
(25) “I sure wish the three networks would start their broadcasts before seven o’clock.”
(26) Could it be true that there were only three stations? (27) Were there really no TV
programs in the daytime? (28) Were all the shows really in black and white? (29) This was
(30) Sharon picked up the handset of the big black telephone, but she quickly hung up.
(31) Sharon’s family shared a party line with another household, and someone else was
already talking on the phone. (32) Sharon would have to wait until the line was free to make
her call. (33) She turned on the radio next. (34) I expected to hear Elvis Presley or the Everly
Brothers. (35) Instead, I heard a man telling a mystery story in a low voice. (36) As spooky
music played in the background, my head begins to swirl with visions of ponytails, convertibles,
and TV screens. (37) I happily rode the wave of images back to the twenty-first century.
(38) The world of the 1950s had been a cool place to visit, but I definitely didn’t want to stay
there!
22
D. Their ponytails swung from side to side as they talked about sock hops and drive-ins.
3. What change can be made to sentence D. Insert quotation marks around new
14? 7. What change, if any, should be made in
A. Change cafeteria to cafuteria sentence 22?
B. Delete comma after cafeteria A. Change profile to profille
C. Insert a comma after contrary B. Change native american to Native
D. No change is needed American
C. Change filled to filling
D. Make no change
24
Editing Passage # 7
In this paper, Luke writes about a personal experience. He would like you to read his paper.
As you read, look for the corrections and improvements that he should make. When you finish
reading, answer the questions that follow.
Fantasyland
(1) “Follow your dreams! (2) Reach for the stars! (3) Wishes can come true!”
(4) By the time I was 16 I had grown tired of hearing those old clichés. (5) There were
(6) Then I saw an advertisement in the newspaper. (7) A world-famous theme park was
seeking summer guides for an adventure atraction. (8) Those interested in applying had to be
reliable, outgoing, and show responsibility. (9) The ad stressed that the park was looking for
(10) Oh, how I wanted that job! (11) Another summer of babysitting and lawn mower
sounded less than exciting. (12) However, as far as I could see, I didn’t have a trait or talent
that qualified as “something special.” (13) I was unsure about whether or not to apply.
(14) When I told my family about the ad, I didn’t get any encouragement.
(15) “You really need a summer income, Luke,” advised my dad. (16) “You had better
(17) “Thousands of kids will apply for that job,” my older brother said. (18) “You don’t
(20) Still, I tacked the ad on my bulletin board, where they kept catching my eye. (21) A
brainstorm came to me one evening as I was finishing and completing my Spanish homework.
(22) I knew what my “something special” could be! (23) I was doing pretty well in Spanish
class. (24) I would hone my skills and market myself as a bilingual guide since many of the
25
(25) I began working in the school’s language lab every afternoon. (26) I checked out
Spanish tapes from the library and watched a Spanish channel on TV. (27) As I immersed
myself in the language, I started making straight A’s in Spanish class and I was feeling very
confident.
(28) After a few weeks of waiting, I wrote a letter of application to the park’s director and
described my special ability. (29) In May, I was invited to the park for an interview. (30) By
June, I was standing on the bow of the adventure boat ride pointing out man-made volcanoes.
(32) Now my advice to others is simple. (33) Follow your dreams and reach for the
stars! (34) I’m proof that wishes really can come true.
26
3. What change, if any, should be made
6. What change is needed in
in sentence 8? sentence 27?
A. Change interested to A. Change As to Although
interesting B. Change myself to me
B. Delete the comma after reliable C. Delete the comma after
C. Change show responsibility to language
responsible D. Insert a comma after class
D. Make no change
28
Editing Practice #8
Sandi’s teacher asked her to write a paper related to setting a goal. Sandi decided to write a
personal narrative about a goal she had achieved. She wants you to review her paper and
think about the corrections and improvements she should make. When you finish reading,
answer the questions that follow.
Car Shopping
(1) I had always dreamed of having my own car by the time I was 18, so I launched a
vigorous campaign as soon as I turned 17. (2) I began presenting evidence to prove that
(3) “Wouldn’t it be great, Mom,” I suggested, “if I could run errands for you while you’re
at work? (4) Even better, you’d never have to drive me to my after-school job again!”
(5) Another day I added “Have you noticed that I’m always home on time when I borrow
your car? (6) Have you noticed that I keep the gas tank filled?”
(7) Then there was my favorite argument. (8) “Don’t you like for me to set goals and
and earning money to make my dream a reality. (10) Shortly before my 18th birthday, setting
out to buy my first car. (11) I asked Uncle Ray and Aunt Ellen to accompany me because they
are my families shrewdest consumers. (12) Since I had a limited budget, everyone agreed that
I should shop for a used car. (13) “It should be something inexpensive with low mileage,” Uncle
Ray insisted.
(14) We went straight to a used-car lot near my dad’s office, where we were greeted by
a cheerful salesman. (15) My aunt and uncle headed for a small blue sedan with 50,000 miles
on the odometer. (16) I went toward a sporty red convertible with 120,000 miles.
(17) “It gets great gas mileage!” Uncle Ray said as he pointed to the sedan.
29
(18) “It’s RED!” I exclaimed as I danced around the sports car.
(24) “From my personnel experience,” Mom wisely said, “I can tell you that the red car
will look great in the repair shop. (25) And considering how many miles are on the engine, it
will probably be there most of the time. (26) With that in mind, I think you’d better go with the
(27) Little Blue, I must admit, has been an exceptionally good car. (28) With regular oil
changes, it keeps humming along. (29) Whenever I pass a sporty red convertible being pulled
30
4. What is the best way to rewrite 7. What change, if any, should be made
sentence 10? in sentence 24?
A. It was shortly before my 18th A. Change personnel to personal
birthday, I set out to buy my first B. Change the second comma to a
car. period
B. Shortly before my 18th birthday. C. Change that to it
I set out to buy my first car. D. Make no change
C. Shortly before my 18th birthday,
I set out to buy my first car.
D. No correction is needed. 8. What change is needed in sentence
26?
A. Delete comma after mind
B. Insert a comma after sedan
5. What change, if any, should be made C. Change smarter to smartest
in sentence 11? D. Delete the quotation marks at the
A. Change accompany to acompany end of the sentence
B. Change families to family’s
C. Change shrewdest to most
shrewdest 9. What correction needs to be made to
D. Make no change sentence 29?
A. Change convertible to corvertable
B. Change smile to smiled
6. What change, if any, should be made C. Change the exclamation mark to a
in sentence 19? question mark
A. Insert quotation marks after the first D. No correction is needed
comma
B. Change noted to notes
C. Change reasonably to reasonable
D. Make no change
End of Editing
Practice #8
31
Answer Key Editing Practice #8
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
32
Editing Passage #9
Nicole wrote this story in response to a class assignment. Read Nicole’s paper and think about
the corrections and improvements she should make. When you finish reading, answer the
questions that follow.
City Pig
(1) In the dictionary the word mooch means “to beg.” (2) That’s how Moochie the
potbellied pig got his name. (3) He is a moocher, and people love that about him. (4) From
(6) Moochie’s owners, the O’Callahans, have had to put there rotund pet on a diet. (7) Now the
(8) The O’Callahan house sits on the corner of 14th and Thompson avenue.
(9) Surrounded by a big yard with rows of corn and tomato plants, the home is on a lovely
patch of country right in the middle of the city. (10) Each morning Moochie emerges from his
shed to greet the day. (11) Like all potbellied pigs, Moochie doesn’t oink, he makes a hoarse
snorting noise. (12) For seven years he snorted his way to the fence each day. (13) His tiny
eyes constantly searched for passersby who might offer him a snack.
33
(14) Then one spring day everything changed: a man named Mike Gorman moved in
next door. (15) Gorman, an urban type loved the boulevards and shops that were a few blocks
away. (16) He did not, however, love living beside what he called a farm!
(17) “There are zoning laws,” he informed Mr. O’Callahan. (18) “Residents cannot raise
livestock! (19) I’ve notified the authorities, so I suggest you relocate your hog.
(20) The neighbors rallied around Moochie. (21) They signed petitions and wrote letters.
(22) But laws are laws. (23) Pigs are considered livestock—even pigs that love humans and
are loved in return. (24) The O’Callahans had 30 days to find a new home for Moochie.
(25) Time ticked away. (26) Neighbors came to feed Moochie one last time. (27) Some little
boys sneaked cookies through the fence. (28) Moochie munched away, unaware of his
impending fate.
(29) Then neighbor Tommy Jones had an idea. (30) He had learned that service
animals were allowed almost everywhere. (31) He had read about service animals—dogs and
monkeys that help the disabled. (32) Why couldn’t Moochie be a “service pig”? (33)
Grandmother O’Callahan was forgetful, and whenever her family went out, she often got
(35) Moochie could become a companion pig a helping hand for Grandmother
O’Callahan. (36) The O’Callahans loved the idea and wrote a proposal to the city. (37) They
began training Moochie and bought him a vest (size extra-large) that read “Service Animal.”
(38) City officials seemed glad to have found a loophole that would let Moochie stay
with the O’Callahans. (39) The neighborhood celebrated its victory. (40) Mike Gorman was a
good sport about it; he just avoided the O’Callahan yard. (41) He was the only neighbor who
34
1. What is the best way to rewrite sentences 4 and 5?
A. From Grandpa Forester to two-year-old Olivia Sánchez, everyone in the neighborhood.
Enjoys feeding Moochie a carrot or potato.
B. Everyone in the neighborhood, from Grandpa Forester to two-year-old Olivia Sánchez,
enjoys feeding Moochie a carrot or potato.
C. Everyone in the neighborhood who enjoys feeding Moochie a carrot or potato is from
Grandpa Forester to two-year-old Olivia Sánchez.
D. No correction is needed.
35
5. What change needs to be made to sentence 15?
A. Insert a comma after type
B. Change boulevards to Boulevards
C. Insert a comma after boulevards
D. Change away to a way
36
Answer Key Editing Practice #9
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
37
Editing Passage #10
After a firsthand experience with an unusual species of fish, Christopher wrote this paper. He
would like you to review his paper and think about the corrections and improvements he
should make. When you finish reading, answer the questions that follow.
(1) With a fishing pole in my hand, I prowled the banks of Goose Creek one August
morning. (2) I was after catfish, the major residents of the neighborhood stream. (3) Suddenly I
spied a shadow in the water. (4) I was sure it was the world’s biggest catfish!
(5) Shortly after I cast my line, the fish took the bait with a hard strike. (6) I gasped as I
reeled it in. (7) It was obvious that I had not caught an ordinary creek fish! (8) I filed my plastic
gear box with creek water and toted the red-bellied fish home alive. (9) While my new friend
(10) First I checked my reference books and the Internet. (11) Then I called Reuben’s
Reef, a pet store that specializes in exotic fish. (12) I soon realized I had a red piranha, a fish
normally found in South America. (13) I learned that many states have outlawed the sale of
piranhas because experts worry that people will tire of it and release the fish into local
waterways. (14) This is a problem because piranhas in the wild will eat many other kinds of
38
(15) I checked my piranha’s razor-sharp teeth and read about its meat-eating habits, I
named it Jaws. (16) My mother hesitantly agreed to let me keep my unusual pet, at least until I
could find a suitable home for it. (17) I assured her that the piranha’s reputation for being
(18) Jaws would not leap from the bathtub and attack us. (19) In fact, piranhas are
usually quite shy. (20) Those kept as pets spend most of their time hiding behind aquarium
plants. (21) All the same, I treated Jaws with cautious and respect. (22) I knew that an
(23) When Jaws refused the worms I offered; I decided that I needed to find him a new
home fast! (24) Luckily, Reuben’s Reef offered me 40 dollars in exchange for my exotic pal.
(25) “You saved that animal’s life,” Reuben told me. (26) “He wouldn’t have survived
long in that cold creek.” (27) Then Reuben showed me the 25-gallon aquarium where Jaws
would be on display. (28) “Piranhas are high-maintenance fish,” Reuben said, “but this ones
worth it because he’s a beauty.” (29) Together, we admirred the piranha’s flat glossy-black
(30) Jaws seemed happy in his new home. (31) My mom was ecstatic to have her
bathtub back. (32) And when my story was featured in the newspaper, I became an instant
celebrity. (33) A day of fishing had turned into a pretty exciting adventure.
39
2. What change, if any, should be made in sentence 13?
A. Change have outlawed to has outlawed
B. Change worry to worrying
C. Change it to them
D. Make no change
40
6. What change, if any, should be made in sentence 23?
A. Change the semicolon to a comma
B. Change decided to decide
C. Change him to them
D. Make no change
41
Answer Key Editing Practice #10
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
42
Editing Passage #11
Brian’s English teacher asked him to write a narrative about a person who overcomes a fear.
Brian decided to write a story about his brother Dean. Brian wants you to read his paper and
think about the corrections and improvements he should make. When you finish reading,
answer the questions that follow.
(2) “Don’t give up, Dean!” Uncle Jim shouted encouragingly. (3) “You can do it!”
(4) “Your almost there,” Kurt called as he tugged on the rope that ensured his cousin’s
safety. (5) Kurt and Dean had just finished helping Uncle Jim install a climbing wall at a
community gym in Canterville, Texas. (6) The wall which was made of concrete and crushed
granite. (7) It looked just like a sandstone cliff. (8) Despite his fear of heights, Dean had
(9) Dean heard his cousin and uncle urging him on from below, but he didn’t reply.
(10) He was studying the last section of the thing to determine a strategy for scaling the
artificial rock wall. (11) He knew he was only a few feet from the top but if he neglected to
(12) Dean trusted Kurt to serve as his belayer, which is the person who controls a
climber’s safety rope. (13) While Dean climbed, Kurt took the slack out of the safety rope that
was attatched at the top of the wall. (14) That way, if Dean starts to slip, he would fall only a
(15) However, Dean didn’t want to fall even a few feet, he was too close to his goal.
(16) As Dean clung to the rock face calculating each move with precision, Uncle Jim and Kurt
watched intently. (17) Finally, with a burst of energy, Dean climbed over the last outcropping
43
(18) Uncle Jim and Kurt cheered wildly. (19) Dean smiled broadly and then grew quiet
again. (20) To rappel to the ground was the scariest part for him, and his uncle and cousin
knew it. (21) The last time Dean had scaled a climbing wall, it had taken 15 minutes for him to
muster the courage to rappel down. (22) As the others watched in anticipation, Dean
consciously relaxed his tense muscles, took a deep breath, and backed over the edge. (23) In
seconds he had descended more than 40 feet to the gym floor. (24) His feet had barely hit the
floor when Dean surprised Uncle Jim and Kurt by exclaiming, “I’m ready to go up again!”
44
4. What change needs to be made in sentence 13?
A. Change Kurt to he
B. Insert a comma after rope
C. Change attatched to attached
D. No change is needed
45
Answer Key Editing Practice #11
Genre: Literary Nonfiction
46