Kitplanes0718 CubCraftersFX3 Web
Kitplanes0718 CubCraftersFX3 Web
CubCrafters
EX-3/FX-3
Another
Better Cub!
ROTAX 915 iS
Rotax Raises the Bar
RV-8 ON ICE
How Ice Hurts Performance
CHOOSING AN ELT
JULY 2018
Which One’s Right for You? www.kitplanes.com
CubCrafters
EX-3/FX-3
2 KITPLANES July 2018 www.kitplanes.com & www.facebook.com/kitplanes
Another better Cub! BY PAUL DYE
When CubCrafters started out many years ago, Not only did CubCrafters redesign (and rede-
their intent was to build a better Cub, a daunting fine) the Cub, they took a look at the business of
challenge when you think about the fact that this producing airplanes and turned that on its ear as
ubiquitous airplane is known the world over as well. This single company produces Part 23 cer-
both a workhorse and a fun machine to fly. Cubs tified machines, ASTM-certified Special Light
have explored the far reaches of the globe and Sport aircraft, kits for Experimental Light Sports,
brought their pilots back so they can tell the sto- and kits for the E/A-B market. And now they are
ries—how can they get any better? deeply involved in a factory-assist program that is
The answer is that they can be made lighter similar—but different—to what other companies
to give them better performance, aerodynamic have pioneered. They have their fingers in almost
mods can make them handle better, and modern every niche of the light-plane market, and their
construction techniques can make them easier to sales reflect that, with delivery slots for finished
build and maintain. The end result is a modern- aircraft pre-sold into 2019.
ized version of the venerable machine that the It’s an exciting time to visit CubCrafters’ facility
public associates universally with “light airplanes.” in Yakima, Washington, and we did so early this
Photos: Chris Cram (courtesy of CubCrafters) and Paul Dye KITPLANES July 2018 3
year to sample their latest design, avail-
able as either a complete kit (the EX-3)
delivered to your workshop, or as a
factory-assisted build (the FX-3). Either
way, the customer is part of the build in
varying degrees, and either way, you end
up with one great flying machine.
What’s New
The EX/FX is the next evolution of the
CubCrafters line, borrowing from all of
the previous models, and particularly
from lessons learned with the XCub.
Powered by CubCrafters’ proprietary
CC363i engine and a constant-speed Large cooling gills have been tailored to optimize cooling flow through the cowling.
prop, the airplane has tremendous per-
formance due to power, aerodynamics, Covering up all that power is almost it up with little addition of weight. The
and light weight. a shame, but CubCrafters did it with EX/FX was designed to Part 23 stan-
Let’s start with power. A panel of Cub- a composite cowling that minimizes dards, just like the XCub, so there is
Crafters experts sat down and asked how cooling drag while maximizing cooling. nothing being overly stressed.
they could do better than the traditional And if you are used to the view out the The EX/FX also borrows from the
IO-340 that they have been using on front of a Super Cub, be prepared for a XCub when it comes to flight controls.
previous versions. They added features surprise—the tapering cowling provides Pilots liked the longer stick on the
they wanted such as tapered-barrel Mil- an excellent view over the nose. XCub, but engineering analysis showed
lennium cylinders, a counterweighted Moving back into the airframe, the that in order to use the longer stick, other
crankshaft to better absorb the power EX/FX is now rated for a gross weight elements of the flight control system
pulses from the 9.0:1 compression, and of 2000 pounds. CubCrafters president needed beefing up because more lever-
roller tappets. They decided to use the Randy Lervold explained that they have age means more force can be applied by
Silver Hawk EX fuel injection system, been holding the gross weight at the the pilot. We found the stick geometry
but are sticking with the dual Light old standard of 1850 pounds for years to be very natural—enough stick length
Speed electronic ignitions they have because they have managed to build an to get our hand above the legs, but not
been using for years. Adding a special airplane with an empty weight several so high that you couldn’t rest your arm
cold-air sump fabricated in house and hundred pounds lighter than legacy on your leg to maintain smooth con-
a flow-bench engineered induction sys- Cubs, making the useful load that much trol. The EX/FX uses cables for aileron
tem for better breathing gives them 186 higher. But pilots are pilots (especially control instead of the pushrods of the
hp to deliver to the Hartzell Trailblazer bush pilots), and they always want XCub, but we didn’t find that we could
prop—a constant-speed, blended-airfoil more—so upping the gross weight now actually tell the difference.
scimitar measuring 86 inches in diam- gives a significant boost to an already Finally, it might seem to be a trivial
eter. The front end of this airplane looks boosted useful load. The structure was improvement to many, but a lot of
and means business. there, and where it wasn’t, they beefed thought went into the new heater system,
AIRFRAME
Wingspan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34 ft 4 in
Wing loading . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.44 lb/sq. ft
Fuel capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 gal
The cabin heat flows from multiple ducts to provide hot air to both pilot and passenger, Maximum gross weight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2000 lb
as well as the windshield defroster. Typical empty weight . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1060 lb
Typical useful load . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 940 lb
and it does make a difference if you fly be absorbed easily and still leaves 713 Full-fuel payload . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 676 lb
in cold climates. It’s no secret that most pounds for pilot, passenger, and cargo. Seating capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2
light aircraft have poor cabin heat from Unless you’re planning on carrying an Cabin width . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 in
a single hole in the firewall and a heater elk, it’s going to be hard to overload this Forward baggage capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100 lb
muff around the exhaust pipes. It’s even machine. And with a cruise speed of 135 Aft baggage capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60 lb
worse in most tandem aircraft for the mph, you can carry that load a reason-
rear seat occupant—in short, they prob- able distance without having to plan PERFORMANCE
ably need to dress warm. But in the EX/ overnight stops. Cruise speed . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 117 kt
FX, extra attention was paid to maxi- Maximum rate of climb . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2400 fpm
mize airflow and heat transfer into the Flying the FX-3 Stall speed (landing configuration) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 kt
cabin. Heat ducts flow that air to both We showed up at CubCrafters’ door on Stall speed (clean) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 37 kt
the front and rear seats (Yes, this Cub has a clear winter day in February, and the Takeoff distance (to 50 ft agl) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 90 ft
rear-seat heat!), and even to a defroster brand-new factory demonstrator was Landing distance (from 50 ft agl) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 155 ft
when needed. The difference is quite waiting for us, full of fuel and sniffing Specifications and pricing provided by the manufacturer.
noticeable. We flew the airplane on a cold the sky as if to say, “Come on—let’s not
winter day over the Cascade Mountains waste the day!” CubCrafters president, so no boost pump was required; we
and stayed toasty warm the entire time. Randy Lervold, gave us the briefing on just pushed in the mixture, cracked the
CubCrafters has always been good with the upgrades and differences between throttle, and hit the starter. The elec-
cabin amenities, and they kept that repu- the -3 and the earlier models, but it tronic ignitions fired right off, and the
tation going with the EX/FX. was clear he wanted to get in the air as airplane was ready to go.
With the new gross weight of 2000 well. So, in short order, we strapped in The visibility over the nose is about
pounds and an empty weight of 1023, the to the comfortable cockpit and fired up as good as it gets in a Cub. You can eas-
useful load of 977 pounds is astounding the big fuel-injected CC363i. The fuel ily see to taxi, and even when following
for a Cub. Forty-four gallons of fuel can tanks in the high wing are gravity feed, closely behind another Cub for a later
Two knobs direct heated air in abundance to the passenger and/ The new heat duct between the pilot’s legs is very effective—
or the defroster. even in a mountain winter.
These companies want to do as much as is legally allowed to make fabricated by the factory. CubCrafters’ program has turned that
that happen. Enter builder assist. Probably the most famous of around. They place their emphasis on fabrication, rather than
these programs is the Glasair Two Weeks to Taxi method of build- assembly. This means that the builder shows up for a week of
ing a Sportsman: The builder shows up for an intense two-week intense fabrication work under the tutelage of factory techni-
period and “builds” their airplane with the assistance of factory cians. In that week, they fabricate enough of their parts to fulfill
support technicians. the majority of the 51% rule. They then go home and their parts
The FAA provides a checklist that is used to assure that the major are kept in quarantine (so to speak) until the factory has time to
portion of an airplane is built by amateurs (for the purpose of educa- assemble them into an airplane. Finally, the builder comes back
tion and recreation). It is a tally sheet that lists the fabrication and for a couple of days to help with final assembly (to finish the 51%),
assembly tasks involved in building an airplane, and in the simplest and then they can either fly their own test program, or the factory
terms, it must be completed so that amateur builders have per- pilots can do it for them. In these cases, they return again to pick
formed 51% of the tasks. Which specific tasks are not important— up the completed airplane.
what counts is the percentage completed by amateur builders and It’s non-traditional, but within the lines drawn by the FAA. It
the percentage done for them by professionals. allows ownership of an E/A-B aircraft by folks who don’t have time
In traditional builder assist programs, the builder performs to do it the traditional way—but want to stay within the rules.
a large number of assembly tasks using parts that have been —P.D.
In the Cockpit
CubCrafters Cubs are different than
regular Cubs. Not only has the com-
pany taken 70 years of experience with
the basic platform and improved the
machine, they have also spent a great deal
of time thinking about the flying experi-
ence for the pilot and passenger. Starting
with the seats, the front is ground adjust-
The large G3X Touchscreen provides everything you need for aviating and navigating.
able to allow you to fit your leg length to
the rudder pedals. The rear seat sling is single GTR 200 com radio is also control- reaching behind the passenger seat.
much more comfortable than anything lable from the screen. However, we did it There is plenty of room back there for
you’d find in an original Cub, and the from the radio head out of habit. Switches camping and exploring gear.
cabin seems spacious. The windows on are arrayed across the top of the EFIS for
both sides swing up and have a nicely the aircraft electrical system and lighting. From the Outside
machined capture latch to hold them The mixture is a push-pull knob on the To many people, a Cub is a Cub. But
there. The door swings down in two left side of the panel and is easy to adjust. look close at the EX/FX-3, and you’ll
pieces on the right side, giving more entry The left side also has throttle and prop find lots of little details you won’t see
room. Both front and rear seats have full control. Push-pull knobs for the new heat anywhere else. Aileron and flap hinges
flight controls, including toe brakes. system are on the top of the panel. And, are billet-machined aluminum, so you’ll
The instrument panel is dominated by of course, seeing as how this is a Cub- never see the telltale rust stains common
a single large Garmin G3X screen, giv- Crafters airplane, there are cup holders on almost every 60-year-old airplane
ing you flight and engine instruments, mounted both fore and aft. you’ll find. The elevators have gap seals
plus moving map capability. The ADS-B/ The large baggage area is reachable on the top surface of the hinge line, add-
transponder system is remote mount, from an outside door on the right side ing to the excellent pitch response you
with pilot control via the EFIS, and the of the aircraft or from the cabin by get at low speeds.
Tundra tires are only natural for an airplane designed for the Go ahead—stand on the brakes—the ventilated disks can take it.
bush—the only choice you have to make is big…or bigger.
at https://tinyurl.com/y7p6aabz and is weighted. While other factory assist cut carbon fabric for layups, assist in
updated as new kits are evaluated. programs focus on assembly, CubCraft- vacuum bagging and infusing a certain
The important score to look for is the ers’ program for the FX leans toward set of parts, and clean flashing and other
first column of any of the checklists, fabrication. This works because of excess material off of parts to finish
which shows the portion that is com- the way the checklist is written. For them. In short, they get a crash course in
pleted by the manufacturer. This needs instance, customers don’t have to make carbon part layup and fabrication while
to be less than 50%, and companies all of the wing ribs—they only have to building parts for their airplane.
that offer quickbuild or factory-assist make “a wing rib.” They do one, and the At the end of the week, the factory
options strive to get it as close to that factory builds the rest. takes all of the parts built by the cus-
number as possible. CubCrafters aircraft consist of a tomer and puts them in a single staging
Note on the NKET list that many huge number of vacuum-bagged, resin- area, ready for assembly into an aircraft.
of the tasks are fabrication, rather than infused parts. Although a builder They add to that pile the parts that the
assembly, and each line item is equally doesn’t have to make them all, they do factory fabricates, and when the time
comes to start the customer’s airplane that the aircraft is amateur built—and in meets the letter of the law. I asked him
down the assembly line, they use that set a condition for safe operation—he issues the obvious question, “Do you feel that
of parts to build it. the airworthiness certificate. a builder who has invested just a couple
When the aircraft reaches a critical The airplane then goes into Phase 1 of weeks in the build is really qualified
final assembly point, the customer comes flight testing, which the customer can to hold the repairman certificate and do
back and helps with that final assem- fly, or it can be completed by the factory the annual condition inspection?”
bly, earning more points on the NKET (for an extra fee). Lervold’s response was interest-
checklist. The finished plane is inspected Many homebuilders have raised an ing and honest: According to him,
by a local DAR, who Lervold says is no eyebrow over this type of homebuild- there has not yet been a builder who
pushover. He quizzes the builder to ing (see sidebar on page 10, “Amateur, has gone through the program and
make sure that they have an understand- Assisted, or Pro?”), but Lervold, a mul- requested a repairman’s certificate. They
ing of the major portions in which they tiple-time homebuilder himself, has all understand the limitations of this
participated. When the DAR is satisfied worked to make sure that the program kind of building.
rudder. Having all of the necessary materials coats. Our rudder might not win a Lindy at Practicing is a great way to build skills, as
included in the kit was very convenient. Oshkosh, but it certainly was airworthy, well as to determine if the whole tube-and-
We didn’t have to worry about not having and I wouldn’t be embarrassed to have it on fabric thing is for you. I predict that the
the appropriate thinner, solvent, or other my aircraft. CubCrafters kit can easily help nudge a lot of
supplies. It took us about 3 hours to get to the One of the nice things about the practice folks who might be on the fence into ordering
point where the fabric was glued in place and kit is that if you feel like you didn’t get enough a full aircraft kit. As one of our group said,
the first coat of Poly-Brush was applied—not practice, you can cut off the fabric, and Cub- “It’s not rocket science—farm boys have
bad for metal airplane builders! Crafters will sell you an inexpensive “refill kit” been covering airplanes since the days of the
Next up was installing rivets in place consisting of the fabric envelope and more Wright brothers.”
of rib stitching, taping, and adding finish chemistry, and you can do it all again. —P.D.
The Poly-Fiber process is used to close the Even a metal airplane builder can learn Ready for rivets and tape!
envelope around the frame. how to iron the fabric taut.
KP: Can the airplane be put on larger or smaller main gear if a person parts, including wing ribs, extensions, and instrument panel. They
wants to go even rougher or wants to fly mostly off of pavement? What form and rivet (880 rivets!) their ailerons and flaps.
options are available for tires? KP: Does the builder of the FX version help in final assembly of the
JW: Being Experimental, the builder/buyer can do whatever they aircraft, or is it ready to go when they come back to fly?
like. However, with the 80-inch Trailblazer, clearance is an issue with JW: Most, but not all, of the assembly is complete when the builder
anything shorter than the included 3x3 landing gear and 26-inch returns for their second two-day session. This is when they install the
tires. With the 83-inch prop choice, 29-inch tires are required for seats and harnesses, landing gear and tires, LED lighting, cowl, spin-
adequate prop clearance. Thirty-one-inch Bushwheels are the largest ner, and a smattering of parts that finish the assembly.
we recommend. KP: If a person orders an EX model, how complete is the kit? What might
KP: What are the reasons that a person might want an EX/FX versus a they still need to buy? Does it come with a razor blade taped to the outside of
Part 23 aircraft from you? the box, like the old Christen Eagles, just to emphasize that it is “complete”?
JW: Because of the increased latitude provided by Experimental JW: Builders have to supply their own box knife, as well as all of the
certification. Owners/builders can modify their airplane if they choose. tools required to complete the build. They will also need to buy two
That is especially important considering today’s accelerated evolution batteries, paint, and an ELT if they choose to use one. Everything else
in avionics. For adventure airplanes, advancements over current land- is included in the kit.
ing gear are an incentive. Owners/builders can service their airplane KP: What is the price for the FX versus the EX (similarly equipped).
too (though we don’t necessarily encourage FX buyers to do that). We’re In other words, what is the cost of the builder assist program?
big proponents of owning Experimental. Though pilots can use Part 23 JW: Apples to apples, the premium for the FX airplane will be about
certified aircraft commercially, the lingering stigma attached to the $70,000 over an EX with the same equipment.
term “Experimental” is not valid for our FX program. KP: Does the builder of an FX do any fabric work?
KP: Tell us about the FX build program. How long does it take? JW: Yes, he/she cuts several of the envelopes, but does not actu-
JW: Seven working days (a five-day session and a two-day session). ally install them on the fuselage or wings. Since fabric installation
From the builder’s initial arrival here to the delivery of his finished is smack in the middle of the aircraft assembly, more fabric work
airplane, ready for Phase 1 test flight, is about 60 days. doesn’t fit well into the program.
KP: You turned builder assist on its head—What prompted the KP: How does the FAA look at the FX program—are they satisfied that
unique take on builder assist with the FX program? the builder is doing the major portion per the National Kit Evaluation
JW: Jim Richmond, CubCrafters’ founder, prompted it. He asked the Team (NKET) checklist to qualify the airplane as amateur-built?
question, “How can more airplane buyers enjoy the benefits of own- JW: Several FAA offices, including our Manufacturing Inspection
ing Experimental?” FX offers Experimental ownership and greater District Office (MIDO) in Spokane and Flight Standards District Office
involvement in the construction process (and thus greater familiarity (FSDO) in Seattle, as well as MIDOs in our customers’ home districts
with the airplane) with less commitment (time, effort) than a kit. have reviewed and approved the Amateur-Built Fabrication and
KP: If a person builds the FX version, what components do they actu- Assembly Checklist for FX airplanes produced so far, and thus the
ally fabricate at the factory? Give a few examples. aircraft were approved for Experimental certification. However, the
JW: The list is long. Builders cut all of the tubing for the fuselage. National Kit Evaluation Team has not reviewed the FX program, and
They cut and lay up all but the largest of the composite parts. They we haven’t asked since the FX is not a kit.
cut and, where appropriate, hydroform all of the sheet-aluminum —P.D.