Arbitrage Speculation and Hedging in For
Arbitrage Speculation and Hedging in For
CHAPTER- I
INTRODUCTION
The Foreign exchange market is a place in which participants are able to buy, sell,
exchange and speculate on currencies. Foreign exchange markets are made up of banks,
commercial companies, central banks, investment management firms, hedge funds, and
retail forex brokers and investors. The forex market is considered to be the largest financial
market in the world.
Foreign exchange analysis gives you information on the main currencies. Opening
and closing rates, daily and annual variations, forward contract rates, options, technical and
daily forecasts are presented .This analysis also provides comments on financial relating to
currency issues, and strategic advice that will help you make the most of the current market
situation.
The foreign exchange market (forex or FX for short) is one of the most exciting, fast-
paced markets around. Until recently, forex trading in the currency market had been the
domain of large financial institutions, corporations, central banks, hedge funds and extremely
wealthy individuals. The emergence of the internet has changed all of this, and now it is
possible for average investors to buy and sell currencies easily with the click of a mouse
through online brokerage accounts.
Characteristics of the Foreign Exchange Market
Barter Exchange
Barter exchange (Double coincidence of wants): In the foreign exchange market, for
anybody wanting to sell dollars to get British pound, there must be someone else wanting to
sell the pound for the dollar at the same exchange rate (like in barter exchange).
Role
The history of forex market in India owes its origin to an important decision taken
by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) in the year 1978 which allows banks to undertake intra-
day trading in foreign currency exchange. As a result of this step, the agreement of
maintaining ‘square’ or ‘near square’ position was to be complied with only at the close of
business every day. The history of currency trading in India also clearly shows that during the
initial period when these economic reforms started, the exchange rate of national currency i.e.
Indian rupee used to be determined by the RBI in terms of a weighted basket of currencies of
India’s major trading partners.
The other feature of forex history in India is that a large sum of foreign exchange
in India came through the large Indian population working in foreign countries. However, the
common man was not much interested in forex trading. The things are changing now and
with the growing economy more and more people are showing interest in forex trading and
are looking out for hedging currency risks.
National Stock Exchange of India popularly known as (NSE) was the first
recognized exchange in Indian forex history to launch forex currency futures trading in India.
These currency futures are beneficial over overseas forex trading especially to comparatively
small traders and retail investors. Another important point to know is that before discussing
the history of forex market in India, it is important to know the central government of India
has the powers to control transactions in foreign exchange and hence forex transactions in
India are managed by the government authorities.
Central banks
National central banks play an important role in the foreign exchange markets. They
try to control the money supply, inflation, and/or interest rates and often have official or
unofficial target rates for their currencies. They can use their often substantial foreign
exchange reserves to stabilize the market. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of central bank
"stabilizing speculation" is doubtful because central banks do not go bankrupt if they make
large losses, like other traders would, and there is no convincing evidence that they do make a
profit trading.
The mere expectation or rumor of a central bank foreign exchange intervention might
be enough to stabilize a currency, but aggressive intervention might be used several times
each year in countries with a dirty float currency regime. Central banks do not always achieve
their objectives. The combined resources of the market can easily overwhelm any central
bank.[66] Several scenarios of this nature were seen in the 1992–93 European Exchange Rate
Mechanism collapse, and in more recent times in Asia.
Some investment management firms also have more speculative specialist currency
overlay operations, which manage clients' currency exposures with the aim of generating
profits as well as limiting risk. While the number of this type of specialist firms is quite
small, many have a large value of assets under management and, hence, can generate large
trades.
Those NFA members that would traditionally be subject to minimum net capital
requirements, FCMs and IBs, are subject to greater minimum net capital requirements if they
deal in Forex. A number of the foreign exchange brokers operate from the UK under
Financial Services Authority regulations where foreign exchange trading using margin is part
of the wider over-the-counter derivatives trading industry that includes Contract for
differences and financial spread betting.
There are two main types of retail FX brokers offering the opportunity for speculative
currency trading: brokers and dealers or market makers. Brokers serve as an agent of the
customer in the broader FX market, by seeking the best price in the market for a retail order
and dealing on behalf of the retail customer. They charge a commission or mark-up in
addition to the price obtained in the market. Dealers or market makers, by contrast, typically
act as principal in the transaction versus the retail customer, and quote a price they are willing
to deal at.
It is estimated that in the UK, 14% of currency transfers/payments are made via
Foreign Exchange Companies. These companies' selling point is usually that they will offer
better exchange rates or cheaper payments than the customer's bank. These companies differ
from Money Transfer/Remittance Companies in that they generally offer higher-value
services.
Settlements of Foreign Exchange Transactions are made through the following accounts: -
When our bank deals in an export credit bill on collection basis/on realisation of export
bills negotiated /purchased/discounted, the foreign currency funds is to be credited to our
account. For this purpose, we maintain Foreign Currency accounts with our various
correspondents abroad. The account is called NOSTRO account. Once the proceeds are
credited in our NOSTRO account, we receive the statement, based on which, the concerned
branch, who have handled the transaction, will be informed.
Market participants
Commercial companies
An important part of the foreign exchange market comes from the financial activities
of companies seeking foreign exchange to pay for goods or services. Commercial companies
often trade fairly small amounts compared to those of banks or speculators, and their trades
often have little short-term impact on market rates. Nevertheless, trade flows are an important
factor in the long-term direction of a currency's exchange rate. Some multinational
corporations (MNCs) can have an unpredictable impact when very large positions are
covered due to exposures that are not widely known by other market participants.
Central banks
National central banks play an important role in the foreign exchange markets. They
try to control the money supply, inflation, and/or interest rates and often have official or
unofficial target rates for their currencies. They can use their often substantial foreign
exchange reserves to stabilize the market. Nevertheless, the effectiveness of central bank
"stabilizing speculation" is doubtful because central banks do not go bankrupt if they make
large losses, like other traders would, and there is no convincing evidence that they do make a
profit trading.
Foreign exchange fixing
Foreign exchange fixing is the daily monetary exchange rate fixed by the national
bank of each country. The idea is that central banks use the fixing time and exchange rate to
evaluate behavior of their currency. Fixing exchange rates reflects the real value of
equilibrium in the market. Banks, dealers and traders use fixing rates as a market trend
indicator.
The mere expectation or rumor of a central bank foreign exchange intervention might
be enough to stabilize a currency, but aggressive intervention might be used several times
each year in countries with a dirty float currency regime. Central banks do not always achieve
their objectives. The combined resources of the market can easily overwhelm any central
bank.[66] Several scenarios of this nature were seen in the 1992–93 European Exchange Rate
Mechanism collapse, and in more recent times in Asia.
About 70% to 90% of the foreign exchange transactions conducted are speculative.
This means the person or institution that bought or sold the currency has no plan to actually
take delivery of the currency in the end; rather, they were solely speculating on the movement
of that particular currency. Since 1996, hedge funds have gained a reputation for aggressive
currency speculation. They control billions of dollars of equity and may borrow billions
more, and thus may overwhelm intervention by central banks to support almost any currency,
if the economic fundamentals are in the hedge funds' favour.
Individual retail speculative traders constitute a growing segment of this market with
the advent of retail foreign exchange trading, both in size and importance. Currently, they
participate indirectly through brokers or banks. Retail brokers, while largely controlled and
regulated in the USA by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and National Futures
Association, have in the past been subjected to periodic foreign exchange fraud. To deal with
the issue, in 2010 the NFA required its members that deal in the Forex markets to register as
such (I.e., Forex CTA instead of a CTA).
Those NFA members that would traditionally be subject to minimum net capital
requirements, FCMs and IBs, are subject to greater minimum net capital requirements if they
deal in Forex. A number of the foreign exchange brokers operate from the UK under
Financial Services Authority regulations where foreign exchange trading using margin is part
of the wider over-the-counter derivatives trading industry that includes Contract for
differences and financial spread betting.
There are two main types of retail FX brokers offering the opportunity for speculative
currency trading: brokers and dealers or market makers. Brokers serve as an agent of the
customer in the broader FX market, by seeking the best price in the market for a retail order
and dealing on behalf of the retail customer. They charge a commission or mark-up in
addition to the price obtained in the market. Dealers or market makers, by contrast, typically
act as principal in the transaction versus the retail customer, and quote a price they are willing
to deal at.
Non-bank foreign exchange companies
It is estimated that in the India, 14% of currency transfers/payments are made via
Foreign Exchange Companies. These companies' selling point is usually that they will offer
better exchange rates or cheaper payments than the customer's bank. These companies differ
from Money Transfer/Remittance Companies in that they generally offer higher-value
services.
HEDGERS:
Governments, Companies & some Investors have Foreign exchange exposure. Adverse
movements between their local or domestic currency and the foreign currency of the group
they are either doing business with (for the exchange of goods and services) or investing in
will affect their bottom line. This is the core of all foreign exchange trading; however it only
makes up approximately 5% of the actual market.
SPECULATORS:
This groups, which includes banks, funds, corporations and individuals creates artificial rate
exposure in order to profit from the variations or movements in the price. They play a vital
role in forex market. Speculators are people who analyze and forecast futures price
movement, trading contracts with the hope of making a profit. Speculators put their money at
risk and must be prepared to accept outright losses in the futures market.
FEMA is a regulatory mechanism that enables the Reserve Bank of India and the
Central Government to pass regulations and rules relating to foreign exchange in tune with
the Foreign Trade policy of India.
Due to continuing integration of the global financial markets and increased pace of
de-regulation, the role of self-regulatory organizations like FEDAI has also transformed.
In such an environment, FEDAI plays a catalytic role for smooth functioning of the
markets through closer co-ordination with the RBI, other organizations like FIMMDA, the
Forex Association of India and various market participants. FEDAI also maximizes the
benefits derived from synergies of member banks through innovation in areas like new
customized products, bench marking against international standards on accounting, market
practices, risk management systems, etc.
Exchange rate:
A foreign exchange rate is the parity between two currencies i.e. the amount of one
currency needed to sell (or buy) in order to buy (or sell) one unit of the other currency. There
are two ways to express such a rate. The most common (or international way) quotes the
amount of any currency that corresponds to one U.S. Dollar.
For example:
One US Dollar (USD) can be exchanged for 68.21 Rupees (INR)
In the foreign extern market it is a mistake to say that the market is going up or down.
In the stock market one can use this expression as stocks either go up or go down. However,
in the FX market a rate as we said defines the parity of two currencies, hence at any time one
goes up, so the other goes down. Therefore we can talk about the dollar going up or down but
not about the market doing so. Another issue that often confuses people (even traders and
bankers) is the difference between a currency moving up and its rate going up. We have to
explain this in more detail as any misunderstanding can lead to painful surprises when trading
in the real market.
A foreign exchange rate usually consists of an integer part and 4 decimal points. Thus
the decimals are expressed either at 10th thousands or hundreds. Each such 0.0001 or 0.01 is
called basis point or pip. E.g. a 50 pips change of 1.5000 is either 1.5050 or 1.4950.
There are actually three ways that institutions, corporations and individuals trade
forex: the spot market, the forwards market and the futures market.
The spot market is where currencies are bought and sold according to the current
price. That price, determined by supply and demand, is a reflection of many things, including
current interest rates, economic performance, sentiment towards ongoing political situations
(both locally and internationally), as well as the perception of the future performance of one
currency against another. When a deal is finalized, this is known as a "spot deal". It is a
bilateral transaction by which one party delivers an agreed-upon currency amount to the
counter party and receives a specified amount of another currency at the agreed-upon
exchange rate value. After a position is closed, the settlement is in cash.
Although the spot market is commonly known as one that deals with transactions in
the present (rather than the future), these trades actually take two days for settlement. Unlike
the spot market, the forwards and futures markets do not trade actual currencies. Instead they
deal in contracts that represent claims to a certain currency type, a specific price per unit and
a future date for settlement. In the forwards market, contracts are bought and sold OTC
between two parties, who determine the terms of the agreement between themselves.
In the futures market, futures contracts are bought and sold based upon a standard
size and settlement date on public commodities markets. Futures contracts have specific
details, including the number of units being traded, delivery and settlement dates, and
minimum price increments that cannot be customized. The exchange acts as a counterpart to
the trader, providing clearance and settlement.
Reading A Quote
USD/INR = 68.22
This is referred to as a currency pair. The currency to the left of the slash is the base
currency, while the currency on the right is called the quote or counter currency. The base
currency (in this case, the U.S. dollar) is always equal to one unit (in this case, US$1), and
the quoted currency (in this case, the Indian Rupee) is what that one base unit is equivalent to
in the other currency. The quote means that US$1 =68.22Indian Rupee. In other words, US$1
can buy 68.22 Indian Rupee . The forex quote includes the currency abbreviations for the
currencies in question.
There are two ways to quote a currency pair, either directly or indirectly. A direct
currency quote is simply a currency pair in which the domestic currency is the quoted
currency; while an indirect quote, is a currency pair where the domestic currency is the base
currency. So if you were looking at the Canadian dollar as the domestic currency and U.S.
dollar as the foreign currency, a direct quote would be USD/INR, while an indirect quote
would be INR/USD. The direct quote varies the domestic currency, and the base, or foreign
currency, remains fixed at one unit. In the indirect quote, on the other hand, the foreign
currency is variable and the domestic currency is fixed at one unit.
For example,
If Indian Rupee is the domestic currency, a direct quote would be USD/INR and
means that USD$1 will purchase 68.22 Rupees.
In the forex spot market, most currencies are traded against the U.S. dollar, and the
U.S. dollar is frequently the base currency in the currency pair. In these cases, it is called a
direct quote. This would apply to the above USD/INR currency pair, which indicates that
US$1 is equal to 68.22 Indian Rupee
However, not all currencies have the U.S. dollar as the base. The Queen's currencies -
those currencies that historically have had a tie with Britain, such as the British pound,
Australian Dollar and New Zealand dollar - are all quoted as the base currency against the
U.S. dollar. The euro, which is relatively new, is quoted the same way as well. In these cases,
the U.S. dollar is the counter currency, and the exchange rate is referred to as an indirect
quote.
Most currency exchange rates are quoted out to four digits after the decimal place,
with the exception of the Japanese yen (JPY), which is quoted out to two decimal places.
The quote before the slash is the bid price, and the two digits after the slash represent the
ask price (only the last two digits of the full price are typically quoted). Note that the bid price is
always smaller than the ask price. Let's look at an example:
USD/INR=68.210
Bid = 68.180
Ask= 68.240
One of the biggest sources of confusion for those new to the currency market is the
standard for quoting currencies.
Cross Currency
When a currency quote is given without the U.S. dollar as one of its components, this
is called a cross currency. The most common cross currency pairs are the EUR/GBP,
EUR/CHF and EUR/JPY. These currency pairs expand the trading possibilities in the forex
market, but it is important to note that they do not have as much of a following (for example,
not as actively traded) as pairs that include the U.S. dollar, which also are called the majors.
The bid price is used when selling a currency pair (going short) and reflects how
much of the quoted currency will be obtained when selling one unit of the base currency, or
how much the market will pay for the quoted currency in relation to the base currency.
The quote before the slash is the bid price, and the two digits after the slash represent the
ask price (only the last two digits of the full price are typically quoted). Note that the bid price is
always smaller than the ask price. Let's look at an example:
USD/INR = 1$/68.21
Bid = 68.21
Ask = 68.21
If you want to buy this currency pair, this means that you intend to buy the base
currency and are therefore looking at the ask price to see how much (in Canadian dollars) the
market will charge for U.S. dollars. According to the ask price, you can buy one U.S. dollar
with 1.2005 Canadian dollars.
However, in order to sell this currency pair, or sell the base currency in exchange for
the quoted currency, you would look at the bid price. It tells you that the market will buy
US$1 base currency (you will be selling the market the base currency) for a price equivalent
to 68.21 Indian Rupees which is the quoted currency.
Whichever currency is quoted first (the base currency) is always the one in which the
transaction is being conducted. You either buy or sell the base currency. Depending on what
currency you want to use to buy or sell the base with, you refer to the corresponding currency
pair spot exchange rate to determine the price
The difference between the bid price and the ask price is called a spread. Although
these movements may seem insignificant, even the smallest point change can result in
thousands of dollars being made or lost due to leverage. Again, this is one of the reasons
that speculators are so attracted to the forex market; even the tiniest price movement can
result in huge profit. The spread plays an important role in forex market as it only decides the
profit and loss of investors in forex market
The pip is the smallest amount a price can move in any currency quote. In the case of
the U.S. dollar, euro, British pound or Swiss franc, one pip would be 0.0001. With the
Japanese yen, one pip would be 0.01, because this currency is quoted to two decimal places.
So, in a forex quote of USD/CHF, the pip would be 0.0001 Swiss francs. Most currencies
trade within a range of 100 to 150 pips a day.
Fixed exchange rate system refers to a system in which exchange rate for a currency
is fixed by the government.
1. The basic purpose of adopting this system is to ensure stability in foreign trade and capital
movements.
2. To achieve stability, government undertakes to buy foreign currency when the exchange
rate becomes weaker and sell foreign currency when the rate of exchange gets stronger.3. For
this, government has to maintain large reserves of foreign currencies to maintain the
exchange rate at the level fixed by it.
4. Under this system, each country keeps value of its currency fixed in terms of some
‘External Standard’.
5. This external standard can be gold, silver, other precious metal, another country’s currency
or even some internationally agreed unit of account.
6. When value of domestic currency is tied to the value of another currency, it is known as
‘Pegging’.
7. When value of a currency is fixed in terms of some other currency or in terms of gold, it is
known as ‘Parity value’ of currency.
Flexible exchange rate system refers to a system in which exchange rate is determined
by forces of demand and supply of different currencies in the foreign exchange market.
1. The value of currency is allowed to fluctuate freely according to changes in demand and
supply of foreign exchange.
4. The exchange rate is determined by the market, i.e. through interactions of thousands of
banks, firms and other institutions seeking to buy and sell currency for purposes of making
transactions in foreign exchange.
India is having this type of exchange rate system. In this hybrid exchange rate system, the
exchange rate is basically determined in the foreign exchange market through the operation
of market forces. Market forces mean the selling and buying activities by various individuals
and institutions. So far, the managed floating exchange rate system is similar to the flexible
exchange rate system.
But during extreme fluctuations, the central bank under a managed floating exchange
rate system (like the RBI) intervenes in the foreign exchange market. Objective of this
intervention is to minimise the fluctuation in the exchange rate of rupee.
Since, the exchange rate is basically determined by market forces, the upward and
downward movement in the value of rupee are appreciation and depreciation.
What is Depreciation?
Depreciation of the rupee refers to the decrease in the external value of the domestic
currency occurred due to the operation of market forces. Here, the exchange rate is moving
with demand and supply of dollar. Depreciation happens under a flexible exchange rate
system or under a managed floating exchange rate system. (Eg. 1$ = Rs 40 to 1$ = Rs 50)
What is Appreciation?
Appreciation of the rupee refers to the increase in the external value of the domestic
currency occurred due to the operation of market forces. Here, the exchange rate is moving in
accordance with the demand and supply of dollar. Appreciation happens under a flexible
exchange rate system or under a managed floating (Eg. 1$ = Rs 65 to 1$ = Rs 50).
In India, the exchange rate system is managed floating (from 1994 onwards) and hence
the relevant currency movements are appreciation and depreciation. Here, the exchange rate
is determined in the open market through the pressure of buying and selling of foreign
currencies
2. In this system, central bank intervenes in the foreign exchange market to restrict the
fluctuations in the exchange rate within certain limits. The aim is to keep exchange rate close
to desired target values.
3. For this, central bank maintains reserves of foreign exchange to ensure that the exchange
rate stays within the targeted value.
4. It is also known as ‘Dirty Floating.
RESEARCH DESIGN
CHAPTER –II
Arbitrage is the simultaneous purchase and sale of equivalent assets at prices which
guarantee a fixed profit at the time of the transactions, although the life of the assets and,
hence, the consummation of the profit may be delayed until some future date. The key
element in the definition is that the amount of profit be determined with certainty. It
specifically excludes transactions which guarantee a minimum rate of return but which also
offer an option for increased profits.
Hedging is the simultaneous purchase and sale of two assets in the expectation of a
gain from different subsequent movements in the price of those assets. Usually the two assets
are equivalent in all respects except maturity.
Arbitrage .
Arbitrage is the market activity of buying and selling of same security on exchanges
or between spot prices of a security and its future contract.
Definition:
Arbitrage is the profit making market activity of buying and selling of same security
on different exchanges or between spot prices of a security and its future contract. Here
exchange refers to the stock market where shares are traded, like the NSE and BSE.
Description:
A stock is traded in multiple stock exchanges and on each stock exchange the quoting
price may be a bit different. Hence arbitrage as a practice is followed to take advantage of the
price disparity. Originally arbitrage occurred in the currency market, but now it applies
equally in the commodity, futures and the stock market as well.
For example:
Infosys is quoting at Rs 2750 on the BSE and Rs 2760 on the NSE. Hence one can
sell the stock on the NSE and buy from the BSE at the same time. This trade will lead to a
profit without any risk.
Forex arbitrage is a risk-free trading strategy that allows retail forex traders to make a
profit with no open currency exposure. The strategy involves acting fast on opportunities
presented by pricing inefficiencies, while they exist. This type of arbitrage trading involves
the buying and selling of different currency pairs to exploit any inefficiency of pricing. If we
take a look at the following example, we can better understand how this strategy works.
Definition
An alternative asset pricing model to the Capital Asset Pricing Model. Unlike the
Capital Asset Pricing Model, which specifies returns as a linear function of only systematic
risk, Arbitrage Pricing Theory may specify returns as a linear function of more than a single
factor.
The Arbitrage Pricing Theory (APT) was developed primarily by Ross (1976). It is a
one-period model in which every investor believes that the stochastic properties of returns of
capital assets are consistent with a factor structure. Ross argues that if equilibrium prices
offer no arbitrage opportunities over static portfolios of the assets, then the expected returns
on the assets are approximately linearly related to the factor loadings.
The APT is a substitute for the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM) in that both
assert a linear relation between assets’ expected returns and their covariance with other
random variables. (In the CAPM, the covariance is with the market portfolio’s return.) The
covariance is interpreted as a measure of risk that investors cannot avoid by diversification.
The slope coefficient in the linear relation between the expected returns and the covariance is
interpreted as a risk premium. The APT is used by arbitrage traders for earning profit in forex
market. The Arbitrage is an International tool for earning profits in Foreign exchange market.
ARBITRAGE IN INDIA
Arbitraging in India has been going on for several years. Initially arbitrage activity
was between Stock Exchange Mumbai and all other regional exchanges. Mr. Babulal Bagri
the founder of BLB Securities and Mr. Manubhai Maneklal were legendary arbitragers of that
era. They traded between Mumbai, Delhi and Calcutta markets. Arbitraging in those days was
done manually and not on any online system. The way the fingers of these brokers flew on
telex machines giving trade instructions was an experience by itself. Then it shifted to
cashing on price difference between NSE and BSE limited. Today large amount of arbitrage
happens between cash and derivative markets. Arbitrage is also possible between the current
month and near or far month contracts. In case of Commodity exchanges also there is an
arbitrage opportunity between the local cash markets or mandis and the future markets which
are popularly known as National Commodity Exchanges.
The arbitrager is one who plays the role of balancing the price differences across the
markets. The markets may be two exchanges trading in the same product or two segments
such as cash and derivatives or across international markets and local markets. The arbitrager
continuously tracks prices across the chosen segment. are momentary price differences in two
markets due to difference in level of information as well as demand supply situation in the
market. These price differences are an
The arbitrager has money power at his disposal. He takes deliveries in a particular
market segment and is able to give deliveries in another market segment. There is a time gap
between giving and taking deliveries. He holds the stock for this time and earns an interest on
the funds invested which comes by way of price differential between buy and sell rates. The
arbitrager has a particular interest return as his target. He does not have any open positions
and all his purchases or sells in a particular market segment have a counter position in
another market segment. At the net level his position is always zero. This is how the
arbitrager earns a risk free return.
The arbitrager does not always wait for the expiry of the contract or the settlement of
the transaction. They may reverse the position before the actual settlement date even if they
have to compromise on some percentage of the price difference earned by them. Lesser return
is acceptable if it is earned with smaller or no investment. All decisions are taken with
reference to a benchmark-targeted return.
Arbitrage activity thus adds to liquidity in the markets and also helps in balancing the
prices of same shares across various markets. Prices continuously balance out once the
differences are cash upon. Arbitrage Helps in reducing volatility in markets since continuous
flow of orders reduces impact cost and more depth means less volatility.
A small investor may not always be able to capture small differences in prices. They
are not constantly in front of the trading screen nor do they have sophisticated trading
systems to execute the orders. They are often linked to Internet or a network connection that
is not direct feed into the stock exchange system i.e. BOLT or NEAT. Streaming quotes on
online trading is closest that is available for such trading.
Best strategy is to look for difference in shares prices of stocks that you already have,
hence delivery is not a problem. Otherwise it is a volume game, small returns over thousands
of transactions is the name of the game. It is advisable to study the opportunities. You may
not act on all of them, but it prepares you to invest your money wisely when you are a
Billionaire….
Arbitrage Advantage Fund.
According to the new guidelines by SEBI can hedge the entire position of its equity stock,
opposed to earlier when a mutual fund scheme could buy/sell futures for only up to 50% of the
corpus. Therefore in this new scheme, there is a mandate to deploy up to 80% of the corpus into
equity shares and hedge equivalent futures by allocating the balance 20% towards margins. This will
enhance the returns of an arbitrage scheme phenomenally, just as the Company delivered 7% per
annum returns in the past; and with the new Scheme, the returns to investors would be higher, at
8.5-9% a year.
Arbitrage Strategies
Daily turnover in the derivatives segment is around 3.5 times the cash market
volumes and is to the tune of Rs 30,000 crores. Arbitrage activity is largely concentrated in
single stock futures, while index arbitrage is not very popular, although it contributes about
25-30% of the total stock futures volumes. In India, stock borrowing in the cash market is
cumbersome, making the “Sell Stock buy Futures” strategy Difficult; hence, almost the
entire arbitrage activity is concentrated in “Buy Stock-Sell Futures”. This strategy helps to
develop both stock & forex market in India as large no of investors are attracted by the
returns gained by them in markets than in other normal investments.
derivatives.
It is safe, as it does not carry equity market risk, as all equity positions are completely
hedged.
Potential returns are higher than comparable investment avenues with similar risks.
Since the arbitrage fund is categorized as equity fund, there will be no tax on Long-
Potential returns are higher than those in comparable investment avenues with similar
It does not carry risk equivalent to the equity market risk, as all equity positions are
hedged.
Arbitrage Currency Trading
As with other arbitrage strategies, the act of exploiting the pricing inefficiencies will
correct the problem so traders must be ready to act quickly. For this reason, these
opportunities are often around for a very short-time, before being acted upon. Arbitrage
currency trading requires the availability of real-time pricing quotes, and the ability to act fast
on the opportunities. To aid in the ability to find these opportunities quickly, forex arbitrage
calculators are available.
Doing the calculations to find pricing inefficiencies yourself, can be time consuming
to actually be able to act upon any opportunities found. For this reason, many tools have
appeared across the Internet. One of these tools is the forex arbitrage calculator, which
provides the retail forex trader with real time forex arbitrage opportunities. A Forex arbitrage
calculator are sold for a fee on many Internet sites by both third parties and forex brokers;
and is offered for free or for trial by some upon opening an account. As with all software
programs and platforms used in retail forex trading, it is important to try out a demo account
if possible. The wide variety of products available, it is near impossible to determine which is
best. Trying out multiple products before deciding on one is the only way to determine what
is best for the forex trader.
Cross-broker Arbitrage
Arbitrage between broker-dealers is probably the easiest and most accessible form of
arbitrage to retail FX traders. To use this technique you need at least two separate broker
accounts, and ideally, some software to monitor the quotes and alert you when there is a
discrepancy between your price feeds. You can also use software to back-test your feeds for
arbitrage opportunities.
o) Final settlement price RBI reference rate. (Last working day of the month)
The below table shows the following currencies which are most traded currencies in the
world in a year. These are some of the data which are being used by hedgers, speculators &
arbitragers for the prediction and to make the Investment decision in a particular currency.
The below data is also depend upon the country’s development in all sectors & economic
policy, Inflation & Interest rates etc.
Spreads
When arbitraging, it is critical to account for the spread or other trading costs. That is,
you need to be able to buy high and sell low. In the example above, if Broker A had quoted
1.3038/1.3048, widening the spread to 10 pips, this would have made the arbitrage
unprofitable.
In fact, this is what many brokers do. In fast moving markets, when quotes are not in
perfect sync, spreads will blow wide open. Some brokers will even freeze trading, or trades
will have to go through multiple re quotes before execution takes place. By which time the
market has moved the other way. Sometimes these are deliberate procedures to thwart
arbitrage when quotes are off. The reason is simple. Brokers can run up massive losses if they
are arbitraged in volume.
In case you have placed orders in a near month contract and the middle month
contract of the same underlying, for calculating the margin at order level,value of all buy
orders and sell orders (in the same underlying-group) are added.
Margin is levied on the higher of two i.e. if sum of buy orders is higher than the sum
of the sell order value, then all buy orders will be margined and vice versa.
In other words, margin is levied at the maximum marginable order value in the same
underlying. For example, you have placed the following buy and sell orders.
As explained above, margin is levied on the higher of Buy and Sell Order value. In the above
given example, Sell Order Value is greater than Buy Order Value. Hence margin would be
levied at specified margin % on Rs. 144000.
As a hedge, the value trader could have bought one contract in the spot market. But
this would be risky too because he would then be exposed to changes in interest rates because
spot contracts are rolled-over nightly at the prevailing interest rates. So the likelihood of the
non-arb trader being able to profit from this discrepancy would have been down to luck rather
than anything else, whereas the arbitrageur was able to lock-in a guaranteed profit on opening
the deal.
Cross-currency arbitrage
Trading text books always talk about cross-currency arbitrage, also called triangular
arbitrage. Yet the chances of this type of opportunity coming up, much less being able to
profit from it are remote.With triangular arbitrage, the aim is to exploit discrepancies in the
cross rates of different currency pairs.
CURRENCY TABLE
Currency Last Day High Day Low % Change Bid Ask
EUR/INR 75.658 -- -- +0.03% 75.658 75.721
GBP/INR 98.310 -- -- -0.21% 98.310 98.373
INR/JPY 1.7235 -- -- -0.28% 1.7235 1.7243
INR/CHF 0.014605 -- -- -- 0.014605 0.014624
INR/CAD 0.020518 -- -- +0.01% 0.020518 0.020531
AUD/INR 47.880 -- -- -1.50% 47.880 48.023
Over the years, financial markets have becoming increasingly efficient because of
computerization and connectivity. As a result, arbitrage opportunities have become fewer and
harder to exploit.
At many banks, arbitrage trading is now entirely computer run. The software scours
the markets continuously looking for pricing inefficiencies on which to trade. For the
“ordinary trader”, this makes finding exploitable arbitrage even harder.
Nowadays, when they arise, arbitrage profit margins tend to be wafer thin. You need
to use high volumes or lots of leverage, both of which increase the risk of something getting
out of control.
Without the threat of arbitraging, broker-dealers have no reason to keep quotes fair.
Arbitrageurs are the players who push markets to be more efficient. Without them, clients can
become captive within a market rigged against them.
Disadvantages of Arbitrage
Liquidity discount/premiums
When checking an arbitrage trade, make sure the price anomaly is not down to vastly
different liquidity levels. Prices may discount in less liquid markets, but this is for a
reason. You may not be able to unwind your trade at your desired exit point. In this case,
the price difference is a liquidity discount, not an anomaly.
Execution speed challenge –
Arbitrage opportunities often require rapid execution. If your platform is slow or if you
are slow entering the trades, it may hamper your strategy. Successful arb traders use software
because there are a lot of repetitive checks and calculations.
Lending/borrowing costs –
Advanced arbitrage strategies often require lending or borrowing at near risk free rates.
But once fees are added, traders outside of banks cannot lend or borrow at anywhere near
risk free rates. This invalidates many arbitrage opportunities.
Spreads and trade costs
Always factor in all trading costs from the start.
SPECULATION
Currency speculation exists whenever someone buys a foreign currency, not because
she needs to pay for an import or is investing in a foreign business, but because she hopes to
sell the currency at a higher rate in the future (in technical language the currency
"appreciates"). This is nothing more than the old rule of buying low and selling high—only
with foreign money.
Examples of FDI in the India include Ford cars plant in Kanchipuram, Hyundai cars
plant in Sriperumbuthur. If a foreign company wants to build a plant here they need to
exchange their foreign currency for U.S.$. Again, they need to find currency speculators who
will buy Yen, DM or French Francs because they expect these currencies to gain in value.
The sum of currency transactions that are directly related to trade and investment is
considered the "primary exchange market," because it is linked to the exchange of real goods
and services. Most currency transactions do not occur in the primary market, though, but in
the secondary, or speculative, market—through which five times as much money changes
hands as in the primary market.
The more currency speculators are involved in the secondary market, the easier it is
for traders and investors to buy and sell foreign exchange when they need to. Hence,
"increased liquidity" means easier access to foreign currencies because there is a larger
market for such currencies.
The Laissez-Faire Bias of "Information"
Since currency speculation is a high-risk undertaking, any information that could
potentially be important will be collected. Hence, currency traders spend a fair amount of
time devouring up-to-date information on their computer screens. Traders look out for basic
economic variables such as unemployment, inflation, and productivity growth.
They are also interested in the economic institutions of a particular economy, such as
labor-management relationships and financial market stability. When these indicators seem to
portend higher profits, that suggests to speculators that the currency will rise in value in the
future. But if the indicators predict lower profits (such as, in some cases, from falling
unemployment), speculators will unload the currency and its value will drop.
Much of what currency speculators go by are their subjective perceptions (often based
on the actions of other large speculators), rather than objective standards for evaluating the
performance of an economy. For example, during the recent crisis, currency traders argued
that the Southeast Asian nations brought about their own downfall because they never got rid
of corruption. Yet the business world seems generally to agree that Italy is as corrupt as
Thailand, and more corrupt than Malaysia or South Korea, yet nobody has proposed selling-
off Italian Lira.
Herd Behavior
While the processing and interpretation of information is an integral part of currency
markets, "herd behavior" among currency traders is equally important, especially since it
makes many interpretations self-fulfilling. If large numbers of traders behave in the same
way, a currency will automatically gain or lose in value—just like the speculators had
guessed in the first place.
A consensus is formed for a while where everybody believes that the particular
currency will only gain in value, and for a while this is true as everybody continues to buy.
Thus, the profits which the original buyers had expected are generated by more speculators
buying this particular currency.
Speculation Tricks
The trick in making money with currency speculation is to know when to get in or
out. At some point the first speculators decide to get out because they have made enough
money, or they think that the currency is likely to fall in value. Information that signals
speculators to sell are usually indications that local profit opportunities are decreasing.
So far we have been focusing on exchanges in the present, or what currency traders
call the "spot market," where U.S.$ are exchanged for French Franc or Dutch Guilder right
now. Speculative purchases in the spot market are done with the intent to sell the currency
relatively quickly. Many speculators will hold foreign currency that they buy in the spot
market for a mere 15 to 20 minutes. After this time a speculator simply decides to take her
gain or loss, and to start all over again.
Profit in Speculation
Surprisingly enough, a speculator can make a handsome profit in that short amount of
time. Let's say that a U.S. speculator thinks that Indian Rupee (INR) are going to rise in
value, so she takes $10 million and buys INR. If the original price is 66.50 per U.S.$ , she
will get 669889500 Rs .
After twenty minutes, the value of the INRhas increased to 66.8 cents. Her 669889500
Rs can now be converted back into U.S.$, yielding $10.020 million (0.668 times of
669889500 Rs), leaving the trader with a profit of $20,000 for less than half an hour of work.
Even though the margins between the selling and buying prices of a currency are usually less
than 1%, the large volume of each transaction, generally $10 million or more, make
handsome profits possible.
Consequently, she will enter an agreement to sell a fixed amount of this currency at a
specified time in the future, at something close to the current rate. If her guess is correct, at
the specified future date she will be able to buy the currency cheaply in the market and sell it
at the higher contracted exchange rate.
But by offering a forward sales contract to other market participants, the speculator
signals that she thinks the currency is going to depreciate in the future. Since foreign
exchange markets rely on a lot of intangible information, and since the number of large
currency speculators is relatively small, such a signal can have a relatively large impact. If
George Soros, for example, decides to offer a forward sale on Thai bhat, other speculators are
likely to take notice, and adjust their predictions about the future value of the Thai currency
downwards. If a growing number of speculators think that the Thai currency will fall, they
will start selling their holdings, thus driving down the value of the currency, and hence
making George Soros' prediction come true.
Contrary to intuition, currency speculation can also occur in fixed exchange rate
regimes. In fact, almost all cases of fixed exchange rates have eventually been abandoned
because of currency speculation. Under such a regime, a government makes a commitment to
buy or sell its own currency to keep it at a fixed exchange rate.
If a currency's exchange rate is set too high (overvalued), the nation's central bank has
to constantly prop it up. The bank does this by buying its own currency (thereby raising
demand relative to supply), or by selling its reserves of other currencies.
But since a central bank holds only limited amounts of foreign currency, it will
eventually be unable to buy more of its own currency. At that point, a government has three
options. The first is to impose austerity on its own people through higher interest rates and
reduced government spending—which will reduce imports, raise exports, and so increase
foreign currency reserves.
If the government is unwilling to force a recession, it will have to let its currency
depreciate, either by setting a new, lower exchange rate, or by allowing its currency to be
flexible ("float"). Either way, if speculators regard an exchange rate as too high and likely to
fall soon, they will sell the currency in the forward market. If they guess right, they will be
able to buy it in the future at a low market price, and sell it high at the already-contracted for
rate. If many speculators sell the currency in the forward market, this will signal that the
currency is overvalued, and people will begin selling the currency in the spot market.
Eventually, the central bank will be unable to support the fixed exchange rate and the
currency's value will fall. This is another self-fulfilling prophecy, as the speculators who
originally began the downward trend pull others along with them, thus actually devaluing the
currency.
• These risks and constraints are a problem for more than the developing economies in
Southeast Asia and elsewhere. Nowadays, no single country is large enough to
stabilize its own currency if speculators, who have billions of dollars at their beck and
call, decide to speculate against it. We all, it seems, have to be vigilant against the
risks and ravages of currency speculation. Reducing currency speculation is not an
easy task, and cannot be accomplished by a single country.
• Floating Regimes (n = 35):
USD, JPY, EUR, GBP, CAD, AUD, NZD, CHF, ZAR, MXN, KRW, SEK, ILS
HKD (7.81:1USD),
Disadvantages of speculation
Winner’s Curse:
Auctions are a method of squeezing out speculators from a transaction, but they may
have their own perverse effects. The winner’s curse says that in an auction, the winner will
tend to overpay in one of two ways:
The winning bid exceeds the value of the auctioned asset such that the winner is
worse off in absolute terms; or
The value of the asset is less than the bidder anticipated, so the bidder may still
have a net gain but will be worse off than anticipated.
The winner’s curse is not very significant to markets with high liquidity for both
buyers and sellers, as the auction for selling the product and the auction for buying the
product occur simultaneously, and the two prices are separated only by a relatively small
spread. This mechanism prevents the winner’s curse phenomenon from causing mispricing to
any degree greater than the spread.
Economic Bubbles:
Speculation is often associated with economic bubbles. A bubble occurs when the
price for an asset exceeds its intrinsic value by a significant margin. Speculative bubbles are
characterized by rapid market expansion driven by word-of-mouth as initial rises in
commodity price attract new buyers and generate further inflation. Speculative bubbles are
essentially social epidemics whose contagion is mediated by the structure of the market.
Volatility
For a speculator, a good performance would occur when there is a very high level of
volatility. It is a controversial point whether the presence of speculators increases or
decreases the short-term volatility in a market. Their provision of capital and information
may help stabilize prices closer to their true values. On the other hand, crowd behaviour and
positive feedback loops in market participants may also increase volatility at times.
HEDGING
When a currency trader enters into a trade with the intent of protecting an existing or
anticipated position from an unwanted move in the foreign currency exchange rates, they can
be said to have entered into a forex hedge. By utilizing a forex hedge properly, a trader that
is long a foreign currency pair, can protect themselves from downside risk; while the trader
that is short a foreign currency pair, can protect against upside risk.
The primary methods of hedging currency trades for the retail forex trader is through:
Spot contracts are essentially the regular type of trade that is made by a retail forex trader.
Because spot contracts have a very short-term delivery date (two days), they are not the most
effective currency hedging vehicle. Regular spot contracts are usually the reason that a hedge
is needed, rather than used as the hedge itself.
Foreign currency options, however are one of the most popular methods of currency
hedging. As with options on other types of securities, the foreign currency option gives the
purchaser the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell the currency pair at a particular
exchange rate at some time in the future. Regular options strategies can be employed, such as
long straddles, long strangles and bull or bear spreads, to limit the loss potential of a given
trade.
A forex hedging strategy is developed in four parts, including an analysis of the forex
trader's risk exposure, risk tolerance and preference of strategy. These components make up
the forex hedge:
Analyze risk:
The trader must identify what types of risk (s)he is taking in the current or proposed
position. From there, the trader must identify what the implications could be of taking on
this risk un-hedged, and determine whether the risk is high or low in the current forex
currency market.
In this step, the trader uses their own risk tolerance levels, to determine how much of
the position's risk needs to be hedged. No trade will ever have zero risk; it is up to the
trader to determine the level of risk they are willing to take, and how much they are
willing to pay to remove the excess risks.
If using foreign currency options to hedge the risk of the currency trade, the trader
must determine which strategy is the most cost effective.
By making sure that the strategy works the way it should, risk will stay minimized.
The forex currency trading market is a risky one, and hedging is just one way that a trader
can help to minimize the amount of risk they take on. So much of being a trader is money
and risk management, that having another tool like hedging in the arsenal is incredibly
useful.
Advantages of currency Hedging
The main advantage of this investment approach is to help reduce the risks and losses
of the investor. Hedging is a good strategy when dealing with foreign investment
opportunities. The price of currencies are volatile, however, hedging currencies can provide
investors with more leverage when they put money in the very risky Forex market.
Moreover, investors who do not have the time to monitor and check their investments
can also benefit from hedging. There are many hedging tools that can effectively lock profits
for investors. The gains from hedging are often realized in long term gains.
Also, since the objective of hedging currencies is to minimize losses, it can also allow traders
to survive economic downturns, or bearish market periods. If you are a successful hedger,
you will be protected against inflation, interest rate changes, commodity price volatility and
currency exchange rate fluctuations.
Current Spot Rate (15th July '08) Buy 100 USD - INR Oct '08 Contracts on 15th July
08 : 44.5000 (1000 * 44.5500) * 100 (Assuming the Oct '08 contract is trading at 44.5500 on
15th July, '08),Sell 100 USD - INR Oct '08 Contracts in Oct '08 Profit/Loss (futures market) :
44.7500 1000 * (44.75 -44.55) * 100 = 20,000 Purchases in spot market @ 44.75
Total cost of hedged transaction : 44.75 * 100,000 100,000 * 44.75 20,000 = INR
4,455,000
A jeweller who is exporting gold jewellery worth USD 50,000, wants protection
against possible Indian Rupee appreciation in Dec 08, i.e. when he receives his payment. He
wants to lock-in the exchange rate for the above transaction.
One USD - INR contract size : USD 1,000 Sell 50 USD - INR Dec '08 Contracts (on
15th Jul '08) : 44.6500 Buy 50 USD - INR Dec '08 Contracts in Dec '08 : 44.3500 Sell USD
50,000 in spot market @ 44.35 in Dec '08 (Assume that initially Indian rupee depreciated ,
but later appreciated to 44.35 per USD as foreseen by the exporter by end of Dec '08)
Profit/Loss from futures (Dec '08 contract) : 50 * 1000 *(44.65 44.35) = 0.30 *50 * 1000 =
INR 15,000
The net receipt in INR for the hedged transaction would be: 50,000 *44.35 + 15,000 =
2,217,500 + 15,000 = 2,232,500. Had he not participated in futures market, he would have
got only INR 2,217,500. Thus, he kept his sales unexposed to foreign exchange rate risk.
Consider a small Indian company that has exported goods to a U.S. customer and
expects to receive US$50,000 in one year. The Indian CEO views the current exchange rate
of US$1 = 68.22 as favorable, and would like to lock it in, since he thinks that the Indian
Rupees may appreciate over the year ahead (which would result in fewer Indian Rupee for
the U.S. dollar export proceeds when received in a year’s time). The Indian company can
borrow US$ at 1.75% for one year and can receive 2.5% per annum for Indian Rupees
deposits.
From the perspective of the Indian Company, the domestic currency is the Indian Rupee and
the foreign currency is the US dollar. Here’s how the money market hedge is set up.
1. The Indian Rupee borrows the present value of the U.S. dollar receivable (i.e.
US$50,000 discounted at the US$ borrowing rate of 1.75%) = US$50,000 / (1.0175) =
US$49,140.05. Thus, after one year, the loan amount including interest at 1.75%
would be exactly Rs 3350772
2. The amount of US$49,104.15 is converted into Indian Rupee at the spot rate of 1.10,
to get 3290726 Rs.
3. The Indian Rupee amount is placed on deposit at 2.5%, so that the maturity amount
(after one year) is = Rs 3350772 x (1.025) = Rs 3434541.
4. When the export payment is received, the Indian company uses it to repay the US
dollar loan of US$50,000. Since it received Rs 3434541 for this US dollar amount, it
effectively locked in a one-year forward rate = Rs 3350772 / US$50,000.
Potential reasons could be that the company is too small to obtain a forward currency facility
from its banker; or perhaps it did not get a competitive forward rate and decided
To hedge money market hedge instead.
If an importer who is expected to pay $ 300000 in March 2011 wants to hedge his exchange
risk, he has to buy 300 lots (300000/1000) of USDINR call option by paying a total amount
of 300 multiplied by the premium quoted for that particular contract. There is no need for the
buyer of an option to worry about the margin money as he pays the premium upfront and
fixes the price at which he has to buy. Meanwhile a seller of options should park in margin
money similar to the Rupee futures contract whenever he receives a margin call from the
brokerage.
To hedge, exporters and those who receive payment from abroad should sell a contract of a
particular currency pair in which they have exposures.
To hedge, importers and those who want to remit money abroad should buy a contract of a
particular currency pair in which they have exposures.
A company Gk exports will receive $1 million payment in May 2011 from an importer. The
company expects the dollar to lose value versus the rupee in the month of May. To hedge its
exchange risk, GK exports should sell 1000 lots of USDINR May futures contract to hedge
its exchange risk.(1000000/1000) If the company wants to hedge only for 50% then it has to
sell 500 lots of USD/INR May contract. However, hedging doesn’t negate the exchange risk
when the company’s assumption on the USD/INR exchange rate goes awry.
Margin for one lot USDINR pair is Rs. 1250(approx). So the initial margin money parked
should be equivalent to Rs. 12, 50,000. Apart from this the Company has to park in the
margin money on receiving the margin call from the brokerage/bank based on the market
vagaries.
Though Rupee Futures platform provides hedging avenue for exporters & importers to hedge
their risk, the hedging volumes has not increased compared to the speculative volume due to
the following reasons.
Lack of Awareness
Only near month contracts are liquid and pricing is reasonable, whereas far- month
contracts are illiquid and prices remain distorted.
Fears about receiving margin calls and procedure hassle for corporate in dealing with
futures is keeping away many participants. Also the margin money which remains
idle for few months is viewed as a flaw in managing the cash in many companies, as
the same benefits they can get in the forward market without parking margin money.
There lies the key differentiator for this market.
Few companies have a policy of not hedging their exchange risk fearing the market
volatility and in some other companies they prefer to hedge only in OTC
markets(Forward contracts)
Hedging through long term capital flows
The various possibilities are explored under the assumption that short-term capital
flows only serve as a means of hedging.
In this case capital imports and capital exports are both hedged in equal
proportions. Consequently net short-term capital flows are a constant fraction of net. Long-
term capital flows (always going in the opposite direction) .
In this case, the hedge ratio for long-term capital exports and imports is still equal.
However. It varies over time. Therefore. Even when net long-term capital flows are constant,
net short-term capital flows vary. However, net short-term capital still flows in the opposite
direction.
Hedging in the forward market has a lot in common with a money market hedge. In
both cases of hedging there is a short-term capital movement. In the case of a forward hedge
the short-term capital movement of the hedger is replaced by a capital movement of a bank.
Therefore, such forward transactions can be interpreted as a credit from the bank to the
counterparty in the forward deal . Since forward transactions with customers also involve
counterparty risk for the bank, just like credit risk in case of a loan, they require a certain
amount of collateral.
The connection between derivative and the underlying cash market is not as close for
options as for forwards. Open options positions are also routinely covered, but not 100
percent , since it is not known whether the option will be exercised or not. Therefore, only a
proportion which is given by the 'delta' of an option will be hedged. For an option "close at
the money' this is about 50 percent.
The covering of an open option position can be brought about by spot purchases and
sales, the net amount at the end of the day being swapped (thus creating a forward position)
or by forward/futures transactions. In both cases, there will be repercussions in the credit
markets in both countries, just as described above for forward and swap transactions.
Therefore, the use of options for hedging purposes will also become visible in the short-term
capital account, but not to the same extent as hedging operations via the forward market.
Next, hedging usually involves huge costs and expenses that can eat up a big chunk of
your profits. In order to be successful with this investment approach, you need to have
enough money to fund your investments and you should also be willing to wait for a long
time before you can enjoy the profits. The major disadvantage is that there will a loss of
money for small investors with limited capital.
In the end, currency hedging can be an investment trap if you think that it is without
risks. As with any type of investment approach, hedging also has risks that can result in huge
losses. Before you embark on any type of hedging strategy, you need to understand its
underlying concepts clearly.
CHAPTER –IV
DATA ANALYSIS
• World’s largest financial market trades at $4.0 trillion values of currency per day in
trades ($3.3 in 2007).
• NSE stock exchange of India currently trades about 40 Million Rupee per day.
• Market is a 24/5(7) over-the-counter market.
• Major markets open Monday through Friday; Middle East markets also open on
weekends
• There is no central trading location (i.e., no central trading floor).
• Trades take place through a network of computer (Reuters screens) and telephone
connections all over the world.
• 37% of all trades take place through banks located in the U.K. (London);
• 29% the U.S. (New York);
• 27% in Indian Markets (NSE)
• 6% Japan (Tokyo).
• Saudi Arabia and Bahrain each 0.1%.
Most popular traded currency is the
• USD (86%);
• EUR (52%);
• GBP (39%);
• JPY (27%);
• INR (11%)
• AUD (8%);
• CHF (6%);
Most popular traded currency pair is the
USD/EUR (28%);
USD/JPY (14%);
USD/GBP (9%);
USD/AUD (6%)
USD/INR (5%)
EUR/INR (3.5%)
GBP/INR (1%)
The below table shows us the banks which deal with Forex transactions In a year and
the market share of those banks in dealing in forex & mainly in settlement, handling of INR
transactions in a year
The brokerage fee per unit of a base currency becomes negligible since the electronic
dealing/matching system of Reuters places restrictions on the minimum size of a currency
trade. Moreover, it is only possible to trade multiples of the minimum quantity of a currency.
The matching system does not accept trading orders that violate these restrictions. Deposits,
however, do not face such restrictions on quantity traded as they are traded at other
venues.The below table shows the minimum trading volume of Indian Rupee(INR) in an year
EUR/INR 75 Billion
GBP/INR 67 Billion
JPY/INR 10 Billion
The settlement costs are associated with messages/notices that are sent to counterparts
of a trade. In our case, a trade is settled and implemented through the SWIFT (Society for
Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication) network. There are three notices
associated with each transaction: notice of confirmation, payment instructions and notice
of incoming payments.
Confirmation of a deal is sent to both sides of the deal on the trading date. This is
followed by payment instructions to the banks where both parties have accounts that will be
debited.
Finally, a notice of incoming payments may be sent to the banks where both parties
want the incoming payments to be credited.The cost of a notice is 14–28 cents and is the
same for transactions in the FX and security markets.
The cost does not depend on the venue of trading, i.e. it is the same for trading
directly or via a broker (voice or electronic). Thus each party incurs a total cost of 0.42–0.84
cents for the three messages per transaction.
These costs are charged at the end of each month. SWIFT invoices its customers
either in dollars or euros, depending on the country in which the customer is located
irrespective of the invoicing address. The following table illustrates the volume of arbitrage
done in Indian Rupees
2008 12992
2009 16758
2010 21663
2011 23112
2012 28004
2013 31850
2014 36487
2015 39009
124.70(USD
Currency swaps -INR) Interest rate and forex risk.
Mahindra and Mahindra
Trade payables in Yen and Euro
Forward Contracts 350 (INR-JPY) and
2(INR-EUR) export receivables in dollars.
27.3($-INR)
5390 (JPY- Interest rate and foreign
Currency Swaps INR) exchange risk.
Arvind Mills
Most of the revenue is either in
Forward Contracts 152.98 ($-INR) 703.67 dollars
2.25 (GBP-
INR) or linked to dollars due to export.
5 (INR-$) 21.88
Option Contracts 122.5 ($-INR) 547.16
Infosys
Note:
1. $-INR Forward contracts denote selling of USD forwards to convert revenues to
INR. INR-$ Forward contracts denote buying of USD forwards to meet USD
payment obligations.
2. $-INR Option contracts are Put options to sell USD. INR-$ are Call options to buy
USD
From the above table it can be seen that earnings of all the firms are linked to either US
dollar, Euro or Pound as firms transact primarily in these foreign currencies globally.
Forward contracts are commonly used and among these firms, Ranbaxy and RIL depend
heavily on these contracts for their hedging requirements. As discussed earlier, forwards
contracts can be tailored to the exact needs of the firm and this could be the reason for their
popularity. The tailorability is a consideration as it enables the firms to match their exposures
in an exact manner compared to exchange traded derivatives like futures that are standardised
where exact matching is difficult.
RIL, Maruti Udyog and Mahindra and Mahindra are the only firms using currency
swaps. Swap usage is a long term strategy for hedging and suggests that the planning
horizons for these companies are longer than those of other firms. These businesses, by
nature involve longer gestation periods and higher initial capital outlays and this could
explain their long planning horizons.
Another observation is that TCS prefers to hedge its exposure to the US Dollar through
options rather than forwards. This strategy has been observed among many firms recently in
India11. This has been adopted due to the marked high volatility of the US Dollar against the
Rupee.
Options are more profitable instruments in volatile conditions as they offer unlimited
upside profitability while hedging the downside risk whereas there is a risk with forwards if
the expectation of the exchange rate (the guess) is wrong as firms lose out on some profit.
The use of Range barrier options by Infosys also suggests a strategy to tackle the high
volatility of the dollar exchange rates. Software firms have a limited domestic market and
rely on exports for the major part of their revenues and hence require additional flexibility in
hedging when the volatility is high. Another implication of this is that their planning horizons
are shorter compared to capital intensive firms.
It is evident that most Indian firms use forwards and options to hedge their foreign
currency exposure. This implies that these firms chose short-term measures to hedge as
opposed to foreign debt. This preference is possibly a consequence of their costs being in
Rupees, the absence of a Rupee futures exchange in India and curbs on foreign debt. It also
follows that most of these firms behave like Net Exporters and are adversely affected by
appreciation of the local currency.
There are a few firms which have import liabilities which would be adversely affected
by Rupee depreciation. However it must be pointed out that the data set considered for this
study does not indicate how the use of foreign debt by these firms hedges their exposures to
foreign exchange risk and whether such a strategy is used as a substitute or complement to
hedging with derivatives
.
Analysis for Cash Flow Hedging
Interest -5 -5
INR Depreciate by 5
% 26.25 10 7 43 .25
INR Appreciate by 5
% 23.75 10 7 40 .75
Fluctuation +/-2. 98 %