International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)

Volume 21– No.4, May 2011

Performance Analysis of Content Management

Systems- Joomla, Drupal and WordPress
Savan K.Patel Dr.V.R.Rathod Jigna B. Prajapati
Asst.prof Dean, Computer Applications, Asst.prof
Acharya Motibhai Patel Marwadi Education Acharya Motibhai Patel
Institute of Computer Studies, Foundation’s Group of Institute of Computer Studies,
Ganpat University, Kherva Ganpat University, Kherva
Institutions, Rajkot

ABSTRACT select any CMS because all CMS is worked on specific criteria
At Present there are lots of open source content management and you have to select which is fit as per your need. But still as
systems (CMS) available in the market. As open source CMS per the functionality and general features required by any CMS
has its own advantages but out of so many only few like Joomla, we have finalized below CMSS.
Drupal, WordPress are popular in the market because of good
functionality and support. It is the obvious question for everyone
2. OVERVIEW
that, what are the basic reasons that only these CMS are mostly
acceptable? Lots of surveys have been done to know which is
2.1 JOOMLA
Joomla is one of the most powerful Open Source Content
the best and why? But still it is unanswered. By certain
Management Systems. It is a free open source and content
comparison on data we want to show that why mentioned CMS
publishing system designed for creating highly interactive multi-
are best in their areas? We also want discover ranking for these
language Web sites in short time like online communities,
three CMS that out of these which one is preferable in which
media, portals, blogs and E-commerce applications. Joomla is a
condition. In this paper we are comparing above mentioned
universal free open source content management system.
CMS by Goggle page rank, their documentation support, their
Universality means you can customize it as you wish. In many
popularity, installation survey and many more.
cases Bloggers used WordPress blogging platform. This is a
General Terms natural choice, but you can also blog with Joomla. You can set
Open source Content Management System page by selecting appropriate template. You can choose from
thousands of free templates or select paid one for professional
Keywords design. You can add additional functionality using add-ons.
Open Source, Joomla, Drupal, WordPress, CMS Comparison There are lots of extensions available at Joomla for free and for
some you have to pay. And if for any reason you cannot find
1. INTRODUCTION appropriate you can build it from scratch according to your
Content Management System (WCMS) is a server program that requirements. As Joomla is open source you can also change
stores web page text and publishing details in a database, instead code of the page layout according to your need by hiring web
of as HTML pages.[1] The pages cannot be loaded until it is developer and enjoy the freedom.[4]
requested by client browser and it is built on demand. With the
use of WCMS many types of content can be organized and 2.1.1 Core Features:
published, and the layout, appearance and structure of the site 1. User Management
can be changed easily and quickly, as it is based on templates
and therefore content is separate from presentation - unlike a 2. Media Manager
normal hard-coded site. If you want to change your content, it 3. Banner Management
can be edited online and goes live immediately. Plug-ins can be 4. Contact Management
used to add Functions and features as and when you need.
Different content can be served to different visitors, according to 5. Polls
their language or location. Visitor interaction can be increased 6. Search
compare to static or HTML site.
7. Web Link Management
A CMS can be extended, it means that you can add new features 8. Content Management
and functions as and when your requirement changes unlike
static and HTML site. It means CMS is a dynamic system. 9. Syndication and Newsfeed Management

This dynamic system clearly has numerous advantages over the 10. Template Management
more usual static website. A CMS is now the preferred choice 11. Integrated Help System
for those who want easy content changes, simplified control of 12. System Features
large amounts of content, a choice of plug-ins to accomplish a
wide variety of tasks; and above all, the ability to do a lot more, 13. Web Services
a lot easier, and a lot faster than with any other system. There 14. Powerful Extensibility[5]
are lots of CMS available in the market; out of that we have to
select most 3 or 4 efficient CMS. As there are no fix criteria to

39
 International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 21– No.4, May 2011

Apart from above Joomla has nice Community. The most active independent developers. In fact, every aspect of web site
members provide you faster response to your queries. You can regarding the creation, organization and search engine
ask anything about your problem and be sure that you will get an optimization can be now handled with the use of WordPress
answer in short time. The community is strong and helpful. plug-ins. Actually these plug-ins are add-ons and improve the
Joomla also have strong Developers that worked to make functionality of the user interface. With lots of WordPress plug-
Joomla better and better every time. Always ready to find out ins available it becomes popular in the public. Lots of people
the problem and its solutions. Add-ons make Joomla more confused in selecting plug-ins to simplify a particular task. For
efficient, you can find lots of free add-ons, components, them, there is a large WordPress community ready to advice
modules, templates on the new developers’ site on Joomla.org. how to use them with WordPress content management system.[9]
You can also find commercial or ask for custom add-ons,
modules, components or templates. Joomla is very easy to use 2.3.1 Core Features:
and update. Even a novice can work with Joomla. It's simple to 1. Full standards compliance
use, but has a lots of features if you need. Installing Joomla is on
2. No rebuilding
single click. You can configure in a few minutes.
3. WordPress Pages
There are lots of extensions available in Joomla like Shopping
Carts, Forums, Calendars & Events, Ad serving tools, Search, 4. WordPress Themes
Google Maps, Business & People, Directories, Classified Ads,
Community Portal Tools, Reservations, Automated Backup, 5. Cross-blog communication tools
Newsletters, Polls Quizzes, Blogs & News, Image Galleries & 6. Spam protection
Portfolio Tools, and Project Management & Groupware & Many
More.[6] 7. Full user registration
8. Password Protected Posts
2.2 DRUPAL
Drupal is an open source platform for building robust, flexible 9. Easy Importing
websites. It is used by all over the world here are some of the
reasons why it is best: Drupal is a CMS which allows user to 10. XML-RPC interface
update their web pages without technical knowledge and ensure 11. Workflow
that it fits your organization's workflow. Unlike printed
materials, web site should be dynamic. Drupal is a dynamic 12. Intelligent text formatting
platform that will grow as your need expands. By adding
features like advanced search, auto-tagging, and 13. Multiple authors[10]
internationalization, you'll allow users to explore your web
content in different ways. Drupal can be installed in multiple
3. ANALYSIS
languages, allowing both administrators and users to view a site There are lots of CMS available; first we have to do analysis
in their own language. You can customize Drupal according to regarding which are the most popular CMS? Below graph shows
your content, user and features of organization that make shine some comparison of CMS.
in front of others. You do not have to relying on vendors, Drupal
have large developer community which provides support,
security, testing, documentation for your web site. Whenever
you hear about next big enhancement in web design, Drupal is
always there. Drupal community member makes Drupal better
and better. [7]

2.2.1 Core Features:

1. Administer
2. Build
3. Collaborate
4. Connect
5. Create
6. Design & Display
Fig 1: Installation survey [3]
7. Extend
In one survey 4000 peple responed rgarding which CMS they
8. Organize & Find[8] are using and above graph shows that more than 70% of user
uses Joomla, Drupal and WordPress. This show that these are
2.3 WORDPRESS top 3 cms in market.but by just considering installtion point we
WordPress is initially designed as a blogging platform, in the
can not say these are the best one.below graph shows which
last several years WordPress has changed itself as a useful
CMS provide better documentation?
content management system. One of the main advantages of
WordPress is the large number of plug-ins released by

40
 International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 21– No.4, May 2011

4. COMPARISION
Now, as it is clear that Joomla, Drupal and WordPres are most
Popular CMS for users, we have to now judge among this three,
which is the best one?

4.1 Popularity Comparison

In this we will see which CMS are most popular among users as
well as provide more documentation for their user quries. It
means that those CMS provide better documentation have more
users and have good communities.

Fig 2: Documentation survey[3]

Above graph show that WordPress is on top with more than 160
books in print, more than 70 they have realeased in 2010 and
also announced 8 books. Joomla and Drupal got 2nd and 3rd
position with also good documentatoin support as well.
Fig 4: Number of Search in Google [3]

Above fig shows Google search data of particular CMS. Fig

shows that Joomla gets full popularity in Google search gets
above 90 lacks search while Drupal having above 20 lacks.
There is no drought that popularity wise Joomla gets first rank.
But that is not enough to tell it best for all. There are several
things to consider when you are comparing CMS to select the
best one.

4.2 Average Budget Comparison

One survey has been conducted by webology for CMS
professionals to compare their opinion regarding Joomla and
Drupal. Out of 196 respondents 84 said that they are fine with
Joomla, 70 with Drupal and 42 with other CMS. Another survey
has taken regarding average budget of website built on each
platform. Below table shows some of the survey data.
Table1. Budget Comparison [11]
Fig 3: page rank [3] CMS Respondents Average Budget
Page rank is uses to determine the importance of a web page. It's Drupal 61 $45,184
one of many factors used to determine which pages appear in
search results.[2] From above figs we can see that those site uses Joomla 81 $19,847
WordPress, Joomla, Drupal get the highest page rank in search Other 40 $31,063
engine. As this is the much unanswered question that which
CMS is best? Because, it is highly based on user requirements
and its future need. It’s also based on users’ technical support to As Drupal is offering more functionality of large site handling
handle and manage web site operation. Now, its clearly for multi user, also provide in multi language and many more,
mentioned from the above figures that WordPress, Joomla and it’s also provide complex site management comparing to
Drupal are most prominent CMS in their services but lets see Joomla. That is why its average cost is almost 250% higher than
some mre comparison to determine out of these three which one Joomla.
is best in which condition.
Joomla is for simple site which didn’t require much complex
facility. If you have small business, didn’t require more complex
facility and if there is less chance to extend your site in future
then Joomla is best choice for you as far as budget is concern.

41
 International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 21– No.4, May 2011

Joomla is also very user friendly. Joomla also provide such 4.5 Popularity Comparison
environment that novice can also handle its work.

4.3 Features Comparison

Fig 7: CMS preference [3]

Fig 5: Features comparison [12] According one survey from 1200 hundred responded regarding
which CMs they preferred first. Joomla is on the 1st position
From the above fig we can say that Joomla and Drupal are on with more than 1100 response. Drupal and WordPress are on 3rd
the same rating for content management features while and 4th position respectively with very big difference compare
WordPress and Plone get little higher rating for the same. If you to Joomla.
see the flexibility then Joomla and WordPress are less flexible
then Plone and Drupal. If you consider the layout of the CMS
then as per the above figure WordPress, Plone and Drupal are
almost on the same rating while Joomla get little low rating
compare to others.

4.4 Social Bookmarking

Fig 8: CMS usage ratio of popular site [3]

According to Alexa’s rankings for the top one million websites

run on which CMS in terms of the technologies used on those
sites WordPress get over 12.5% of site under it. Joomla is on
2nd place with almost 2.5% share, and Drupal goes down to
Fig 6: Social Bookmarking [3] 3rd with 1.4%.

5. CONCLUSION
If you see the result of social bookmarking out of 100%, Drupal From the above analysis and with the reference of fig1 and fig2
and WordPress covers almost 38%. Joomla is on 3rd position it’s proved that Joomla, Drupal, and WordPress are most
with 15%. Graph is not showing the result of CMS below 3%. efficient CMS compare to others as it shows highest
There is a big gap between 3rd and 4th one for the same installations, better documentation support and highest page
comparison. rank as per the graph of fig 3.
Many of the site owners doesn’t require complex facility they
just want good layout, user friendly environment, and better
page rank in search criteria to work with. With the reference of
fig 3, fig 4 and fig 7, Joomla has shown everything in its favor.
If you are novice in content management then Joomla is best for

42
 International Journal of Computer Applications (0975 – 8887)
Volume 21– No.4, May 2011

you. Drupal is best for web developers to perform critical task [2] Marziah Karch, “What Is PageRank and How Do I Use It?”
and provide most facilities and flexibility in rich web site and available: http://google.about.com/od/searchengine
also provide good documentation support as well. Now a day’s optimization/a/pagerankexplain.htm
WordPress is providing more add-ons for better site handling.
Fig 8 shows that most popular sites are using it. Before 2009 [3] Water & Stone, “2010 Open Source CMS Market Share
WordPress is good for blogging platform but from last 2 years it Report”
has changed much and also providing good content [4] Jan Pascal, “Advantages of Joomla Content Management
management. With the reference of fig 2 we can see that it System”. Available:http://ezinearticles.com/?Advantages-
provides highest documentation support. of-Joomla-Content-Management-System&id=3854563
If you are running on a small business and doesn’t have more [5] ©2005-2010 Open Source Matters, Inc “Features Overview”
complex requirement then we suggest you to use Joomla as it is Available: http://www.Joomla.org/core-features.html
the most cheaper than others. If you need multi- language,
shopping cart kind of facility; use Drupal. As worpress has [6] Joomlatribune first Joomla online news paper “Reasons to
changed much it comes in between Joomla and Drupal. There choose Joomla” Available: http://www.Joomlatribune.com/
are many things to consider while selecting a CMS. Some of Joomla-articles/reasons-to-choose-Joomla.html
them are listed here. [7] “Why Drupal”, Available: http://evolvingweb.ca/why-Drupal
1. Requirement of your website [8] Drupal.org, “Drupal CMS Features”Available:
2. Future need http://Drupal.org/features
3. User’s technical knowledge
[9] “Drupal vs WordPress - Comparing CMS Software”
6. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Available: http://webhostingtop.org/blog/338-Drupal-and-
It is my privilege to express my sincerest regards to my guide Wordpress
Dr. V. R. Rathod for their valuable inputs, able guidance, [10] WordPress.org, “Features” Available: http://WordPress.org/
encouragement, and whole-hearted cooperation. about/features
[11] levelten Interactive,” 2010 CMS Intelligence Report”,
Available: http://www.leveltendesign.com/files/CMSIR.pdf
7. REFERENCES
[1] SiteLeads.net,“The advantages of a (Web) Content [12] cmsmatch.com, “Comparision chart” Available:
Management System (WCMS)” available: http://www.cmsmatch.com
http://www.siteleads.net/bm/blog/the-advantages-of-a-web-
content-management-system-.shtml

43