Index General Damage Mechanisms - All Industries 3: Mechanical & Metallurgical Damages
Index General Damage Mechanisms - All Industries 3: Mechanical & Metallurgical Damages
Chloride SCC
Graphitization Galvanic corrosion Oxidation
(Cl SCC)
Softening Atmospheric
Sulfidation Corrosion Fatigue
(Spheroidization) corrosion
Short term
overheating- Stress Caustic corrosion
rupture
Dissimilar metal
Graphitic corrosion
weld cracking
Thermal shock
Erosion / Erosion
corrosion
Cavitation
Mechanical Fatigue
Vibration induced
fatigue
Refractory
degradation
Ammonium bisulfide
Amine stress
corrosion (Alkaline
corrosion cracking Titanium hydriding
sour water)
Naphthanic acid
corrosion (NAC)
Phosphoric acid
corrosion
Change in microstructure
of certain CS & 0.5Mo
steels after long-term oper
in 800F to 1100F range
cause loss in strength, Some grades of
Loss in strength, ductiluty & Steam, FCC, Catalytic Sample pieces, No replica Using Cr containing LAS
Graphitization ductility, & or creep CS & 0.5 Mo 800 F to 1100 F Only by Metallography Spheroidization
creep resistance reforming units suggested above 800 F
resistance, At elevated steels
temp the carbide phases in
these steels are unstable
and may decompose into
graphite nodules
Reduction in toughness in
Primarily 2.25 CR- Hydroprocessing untis &
some alloy steels due to
1Mo @ 900F & optg temp above 650F Install test blocks of same
Temper metallurguical changes Loss in toughness and checking by Impact
3Cr-1Mo & High 650 F to 1100 F (Reactors, hot feed / eff heat no and impact test REFER 4-9 NONE
Embrittlement due to long term exp in increase in brittleness testing
strength LA Cr- exch components & hot regulary by removal
temp range of 650F to
Mo-V rotor steels HP seperators
1100F
Combined effect of
deformation and aging at
Susceptible materials
intermediate temp in Increase in hardness and Only for old materials. If
Vintage CS and Intermediate temp that have not been Brittle cracks by Blue brittleness
Strain aging vintage CS, result in strength with reduction in -- SR not possible buttering
C-0.5 Mo steels along with deformation stress relieved.(Old metallography (Dynamic strain aging)
increase in hardness and ductlity & toughness to be done.
equpt)
decrease in ductility and
toughness
Reduction in toughness in
400 Series + FCC crude and using low ferritic steels
some alloy steels due to Bend or Impact testing Cracks seen during TA &
885 F temper Wrought & Cast Loss in toughness due to fractionation trays and and avoid exposure to
metallurguical changes 600 F to 1000 F & Hardness start-ups, Impact testing, & NONE
embrittlement 300 series + metallurgiacl change weldings & Duplex HE embrittlement temp
due to exp in temp range measurement Hardness measurement
Duplex SS tubes range
of 600F to 1100F
Thourough design to
Mix points of hot and cracks initiate at the minimize thermal
cold streams, de- surface + wide and stresses and thermal
Result of cyclic stresses
No set limit on temp superheaters or often filled with oxides cycling+Controlled rates
caused by variations in
swings, practically Start-up and shutdown attemporators. + coke due to elevated temp + of heating and
temp. relative movement All materials of Corrosion fatigue &
Thermal Fatigue cracks suspected if increase the susceptibility drum shells + coke drum single or multiple _ Visual +MT + PT +SWUT cooling+ravoid igid attch
or diff expansion is construction Dissimilar metal cracking
temp swing exceeds to thermal fatigue. skirts + steam DRAGGER SHAPPED in boilers+drain lines to
constrained under
200F generators + soot + TRANSGRANULAR+ be provided in soot
repeated thermal cycling
blowers + water wall cracks initiate at toe of blowers+provide sleeves
tubes welds. to prevent cold liquid
contacting hot liquid
Localized deformation
or bulging in the order In fire heaters, VI, IR Minimize localized temp
Permanent deformation at
Boilers+coker of 3 to 10% or more montg, TST excursions+proper
relatively low stress levels All fire heater
Short term over untis+hydroprocessing depend on temp, alloy +Thermography to identify burner management and
as result of localized over tubes and Dependent of other Temp, time and stress are
heating - Stress units+refractory lined and stress level + FISH refractory damage + fouling deposit Creep/ Stress rupture
heating, results in bulging common Materials factors critical factors
rupture equpt in FCC, sulfur MOUTH Failures maintian monitor reactor control+bed
and eventaul failure by of construction
plant accompanied by bed thermocouples and thermocouples +Maintian
stress rupture.
thinning at fractured reactor skin thermocouples good refractory lining.
surface.
Excessive cracking,
Both thermal insu and Proper selection of
spalling or lift-off from
erosion resist refractories refractory, anchors and
Insulating ceramic the substrate, softening
can be Mech damaged. Refractory selection, design fillers and their proper
fibers, castable or general degradation Oxidation, Sulfidation
Refractory (Cracking, spalling & and installation are the keys FCC Reactors, heaters Visual inspection during design & Installation are
refractory brick -- due to erosion and Flue gas dew point
degradation erosion) ,as well as to minimize damage, and boilers shut downs + IR scans the keys to min ref
and plastic refractory may be corrosion.
corrosion due to oxidation, REFER 4-62 damage. Proper curing
refractories. washed thinned and
sulfidation, and other high time as per manuf &
anchors may be
temp mechanisms ASTM stds.
exposed.
HE tubes of different
A form of corrosion that can
For GC, 3 cond shall be materils of TS and / or Good design + Coating
occur at the junction of
met, Presence of baffles particularly if crevice, groove or pitting but more the noble
dissimilar metals when they are All metals with the
Galvanic electrolyte, 2 different salt water cooling is corrosion, at the bolts or Visual inspection & UT materal shall be coated +
joined together in a suitable exception of most N/A Soil corrosion
Corrosion alloys & electrical utilized.+ Buried welds of different materials gauging For piping, electric
electrolyte, such as a moist or noble metals.
connection REFER pg-4- pipelines, electrical REFER PG 4-65 insulating bolt sleeves and
aqueous environment, or soils
65 transmission support gaskets + galvanized steel
containing moisture.
towers and ship hulls.
general or localized,
Critical factors include depending upon whether or
the physical location not the moisture is trapped.
A form of corrosion that occurs
(industrial, marine, rural); + If there is no coating or if
from moisture associated with
Corrosion rates increase moisture (humidity), there is a coating failure,
atmospheric conditions. Marine Surface preparation and
with temperature up to particularly corrosion or loss in
environments and moist Carbon steel, low alloy VT and UT are proper coating application
Atmospheric about 250F. Above 250F designs that trap thickness can be general.+ Corrosion under
polluted industrial environment steels and copper (REFER 4-69) techniques that can be are critical for long-term
corrosion surfaces are usually too dry moisture or when Localized coating failures insulation
with airborne contaminants are alloyed aluminum. used. protection in corrosive
for corrosion to occur present in a cooling will tend to promote
most severe. Dry rural environments.
except under insulation tower mist; temperature; corrosion.+
environments cause very little
presence of salts, sulfur Metal loss may not be
corrosion.
compounds and dirt. visually evident, although
(REFER 4-69) normally a distinctive iron
oxide (red rust) scale forms.
heat exchangers,
In CW systems,
bottom water of storage
effectiveness of treatment
tanks, piping with
is monitored by
stagnant or low
measuring biocide
flow, and piping in
residual, microbe
MIC is usually found in contact with some soils. Microbes require water to
MIC corrosion is usually counts & visual
aqueous environments + equipment where thrive. Systems that
observed as localized pitting appearance.+ Special
A form of corrosion caused by Carbon and low alloy or services where water hydrotest water has not contain water (cooling
under deposits or tubercles probes have been
living organisms such as steels, 300 Series SS is always or sometimes been removed or water, storage tanks, etc.)
Microbiologic that shield the designed to monitor for
bacteria, algae or fungi. It is and 400 Series 0F to 235F (–17 C present,especially where equipment has been should be treated with Cooling water
ally induced organisms + Damage is evidence of fouling which
often associated with the SS, aluminum, copper to 113C). stagnant or low-flow left outside and biocides such as Cl, corrosion
corrosion often characterized by cup- may precede or coincide
presence of tubercles or slimy and some nickel base conditions allow and/or unprotected.+ Product bromine, ozone, ultraviolet
shaped pits within pits in with MIC damage.+ An
organic substances. alloys. promote the growth of storage tanks and light or proprietary
carbon steel or subsurface increase in loss of duty of
microorganisms. + water cooled heat compounds. + REFER 4-
cavities in SS a heat exchanger may be
REFER 4-83 exchangers in any unit 83
indicative of fouling and
where cooling water is
potential MIC
not properly
damage.+ Foul smelling
treated can be affected.
water may be a sign of
+ Fire water systems
trouble.
can be affected.
Damage Affecting
Description Temperature range Affects Affectfing equpt
Mechanism Materials
Control of gas
by metallography, phase and alloy
damage on gas selection + AS with
exposued surfaces Field metallography Cr & Mo form stable
High temperature
and primarly + Hardness testing carbide & more
hydrogen attack
thruwall + free of (Softening) resistant to
carbide phases & carburization. (refer
CS is pure iron API RP 941 for H2
serv)
Rot: Coatings/Inhibitors +
Rotating equpt where Fatugue fracture is minimize galvanic +
cracks developed under the Cracking
galvanic couples brittle+most often corrosion resist,
combined affects of cyclic initiates
between the impeller TRANSGRANULAR as in Rot: UT + MT, Dearators: Proper FW and
loading and corrosion, often concentrations
Corrosion and the pump shaft SCC but NOT branched + Deaerators: WFMT condensate chemical Mechanical fatigue and
initiates at a stress All metals and alloys. --- such as pits,
fatigue where pitting or often propagation of Cycling boilers : control + PWHT + Smooth Corrosion fatigue
concentration such as a pit notches,
corrosion + Deaerators multiple cracks + little buckstays grinding of weld re-
in the surface. Can iniate at surface defects
in later 80's+ Cycling plastic deformation (Refer informcement., Cycling
multiple sites. under cororsion
boilers page 4-135) boilers: Slow satrt-up and
water chemistry
HE tubes + furnace
tubes and piping.
A form of SCCC normally
+ Fired heaters burning
occurring during S/D, S/U or Typically occurs next to
A combination of oil, gas, coke depend
during operation when air and welds, but can also occur in Polythionic Acid
Sensitization: formation of environment, material, on sulfur levels in the
moisture are present. Cracking the base metal (it is usually Stress Corrosion
chromium carbide in the and stress are required. fuel.+ FCC units +
Polythionic is due to sulfur acids forming quite localized and may not Cracking (PTA
grain boundaries of the + Sensization + 300 H hydroprocessing units
Acid Stress from sulfide scale, air and 300 Series SS, Alloy be evident until a leak PT after thorough VERY INTERESTING & SCC),
metal. Sensitization are more susc for (heater tubes, hot
corrosion moisture acting on sensitized 600/600H and Alloy appears during start-up or, cleaning during IMPORTANT , REFER Intergranular
occurs in the 750F sensitization in HAZ , 'L' feed/effluent exchanger
cracking Aust SS + Usually adjacent to 800/800H. in some cases, operation.+ shutdowns PAGE 5-32 Corrosion (IGC)
to1500F range. (<0.03% C) will not tubes, bellows).+ Crude
(PASCC) welds or high stress areas. Cracking propagates and
(time/temp/composition sensitize while weldign and coker units
+ Cracking may propagate intergranularly + Corrosion Intergranular
dependent), unless temp are less (piping).+ Boilers and
rapidly through the wall thk of or loss in thk is usually Attack (IGA).
than 750F high temperature
piping and components in a negligible.
equipment exposed to
matter of minutes or hours.
sulfur-containing
combustion products.
Post-fabrication SR heat
Surface breaking or cracks that treatment of about 1150°F
Carbonate occur adjacent to CS welds Typically parelell to weld Montg of pH and for both repair and
In gas scrubbing units, Cracking susceptibility
Stress under the combined action of FCC & Main and can also be in weld and carbonate concentration attachement welds also +
cracking may occur when increases with Amine cracking
Corrosion tensile stress and Carbon steels & Low fractionator OH HAZ + Spider web of small + WFMT, ACFM, NO PT, coatings + clad with
the CO2 content is above increaasing pH and and caustic stress
Cracking corrosion in carbonate- alloy steels condensing & reflux cracks + + SWUT+ Grinding crack 300SS / Alloy 400 + water
2% and temperatures corbonate concentration corrosion cracking
(Carbonate containing systems. It is a form system + CO2 removal INTERGRANULAR + very for detection + AET for wash non PWHT prior to
exceed 200F (93C). REFER PG 5-52
cracking) of Alkaline Stress Corrosion fine Oxide filled cracks crack monitoring steam out or HT +
Cracking (ASCC) METAVANADATE
inhibitor
deg C deg F
260 500
enter here
4.2 Mechanical & Metallurgical damages
4.3 Uniform & Localized loss of thickness
4.4 High temperature corrosion
4.5 Environment assisted cracking
5.1.1 Uniform OR Localized loss of thickness
5.1.2 Environment assisted corrosion cracking
5.1.3 Other mechanisms
Q What is the difference between temper embrittlement & 885 F embritlement
A Phenomenon is mostly similar, both occurs at long term esposure to 600F to 1100 F(Temp emb) & 650-1100F (885
emp emb) & 650-1100F (885 F) but occurs in 2.25Cr-1Mo steels & 885F occurs in 400,300SS & duplex HE tubes