Electric Propulsion Research and Development at Nasa George Schmidt
Electric Propulsion Research and Development at Nasa George Schmidt
R=20180007179 2019-10-15T15:53:26+00:00Z
George Schmidt
NASA Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, Ohio, USA
[email protected]
Electric propulsion (EP) is an important technology for NASA. It has already played a major role on three
missions, namely Deep Space 1, Dawn and Space Technology 7, and it is planned for use on many more. The ion
propulsion system for the ongoing Dawn mission has achieved several notable accomplishments, including providing
a total velocity change (∆V) of over 11 km/s to the spacecraft. As a result of these successes, solar electric
propulsion (SEP) is now broadly recognized as an essential technology for both robotic and human exploration.
NASA is currently conducting many projects focused on research and development of EP for a variety of
applications. All three of NASA’s mission directorates that deal directly with space exploration are actively engaged
in supporting work in this area. This paper describes these projects in more detail, including the specific engineering
activities being conducted at NASA’s main centers for EP technology development, namely Glenn Research Center
(GRC) and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL).
Page 1 of 9
The AEPS system is intended for use as the main Element (PPE) of the Gateway crew-tended cislunar
propulsion system for the Power and Propulsion orbital station [10].
Space Technology Mission Advanced Electric Propulsion System Power and Propulsion Element (PPE)
Directorate (STMD) (AEPS): 13.3-kW Hall thruster/PPU string of the Lunar Orbital Platform—
Gateway (LOP-G)
Page 2 of 9
perform this mission was enabled by its gridded ion The ST-7 system was the culmination of work
propulsion system (IPS). Dawn entered Vesta’s orbit that originally started in 1998 through a NASA Phase
in July 2011, and completed a 14-month survey I SBIR involving Busek and JPL. Following
before leaving for Ceres in late 2012. It entered successful demonstration of colloid thruster
Ceres’ orbit in March 2015, where it remains to this performance in flight on ST-7, the challenge now is
day. Dawn has completed one operational extension to demonstrate that the thrusters have sufficient
to its baseline mission, and is currently executing its lifetime to meet LISA requirements. JPL, Busek and
second extension, which involves approximately UCLA are supported to perform this work from July
three months of operations in a low resonant orbit. 2017 to the end of September 2022.
The Dawn IPS utilizes the NASA-developed In addition to operational missions, NASA is in
NSTAR thruster technology, which first flew on the the formulation phase of several missions which
Deep Space 1 mission from 1998 to 2001 [13]. The would utilize EP. The competitively-selected Psyche
Dawn IPS consists of three thrusters operating one at mission, currently in Phase B, is one of two mission
a time. The system has accumulated record-breaking concepts selected by SMD’s Discovery program. It
statistics for an onboard propulsion system. The is a JPL-managed orbiter mission that seeks to
spacecraft has amassed over 50,000 hours of ion explore the metallic asteroid Psyche [16]. It
engine thrusting and delivered over 11 km/s of V to originally had a planned launch in 2023 as the 14th
the spacecraft, which is greater than the V provided Discovery mission. But in May 2017, the scheduled
by the launch vehicle used to deploy the probe into launch date was moved up to target a more efficient
space. trajectory, launching in 2022 and arriving in 2026
NASA participated in the LISA Pathfinder with a Mars gravity assist in 2023. The baseline
mission, which was led by the European Space Psyche spacecraft uses the SPT-140 Hall thruster
Agency (ESA) [14]. Launched in December 2015, system integrated into a commercially-available
the mission tested technologies needed for the Laser Space Systems Loral (SSL) bus.
Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA), an ESA-led Another future mission concept is the Double
gravitational wave observatory planned for launch in Asteroid Redirection Test (DART) [17], which would
2034 [15]. LISA Pathfinder’s scientific phase started demonstrate the kinetic effects of crashing an
in March 2016 and lasted almost sixteen months. In impactor spacecraft into an asteroid moon, and thus
April 2016, ESA announced that LISA Pathfinder test whether a spacecraft impact could successfully
successfully demonstrated that the LISA mission was deflect an asteroid on a collision course with Earth.
feasible. LISA Pathfinder carried a European DART is directly funded by the Planetary Defense
Technology Package comprising inertial sensors, Coordination Office of SMD . John Hopkins
interferometer and associated instrumentation, as Applied Physics Laboratory (APL) manages the
well as two drag-free control systems: a European mission, which would demonstrate a kinetic impact
unit using cold gas micro-thrusters, and a U.S.-built on the binary asteroid Didymos. The baseline
Space Technology 7 (ST-7) Disturbance Reduction spacecraft concept utilizes a single NEXT-C
System (DRS) using European sensors and a cluster thruster/PPU string. The Preliminary Design Review
of micronewton colloid thrusters (shown in Fig. 2) (PDR) for the mission was held on 10-12 April 2018,
[14]. with a planned launch readiness date in 2022.
Another mission which is still in the early concept
definition phase (Phase A) is the Comet Astrobiology
Exploration Sample Return (CAESAR) mission [18].
This proposed sample-return mission to comet
67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko was one of two
finalists selected by the New Frontiers program in
SMD for further concept development. If selected
after July 2019, it would launch between 2024 and
2025, with a capsule delivering a sample to Earth in
2038. The mission is managed by Goddard Space
Flight Center (GSFC). The spacecraft would employ
three NEXT-C/PPU strings in a 2 + 1 operational
configuration (two thrusters operating with one
employed as a spare).
Figure 2: LISA Pathfinder ST-7 DRS
The highest power mission application of EP
currently planned by NASA would be for the
Gateway crew-tended cislunar orbital station (shown
Page 3 of 9
in Fig. 3). This a concept for an international crew- development test and fabrication/assembly of the
tended cislunar space station involving NASA, ESA, thrusters, along with overall integrated system
Roscosmos, JAXA and CSA. The Gateway would testing. ZIN Technologies is responsible for the
serve as a staging point for missions to the surface of development, fabrication, assembly, and test of the
the Moon and future crewed missions to Mars. It PPUs.
would consist of several elements, all incrementally The NEXT-C propulsion system is designed for
deployed and assembled in cislunar space. These SEP applications that must accommodate variable
include the Power and Propulsion Element (PPE), a input power resulting from changes in solar range
small habitat for crew, a docking module, an airlock over the mission. The NEXT-C thruster (shown in
and logistics module. Fig. 4) has a nominal input power range of 0.5 to 6.9
kW, and utilizes 2-grid dished-out ion optics, capable
of producing thrust levels of 25 to 235 mN and
specific impulses (Isp) of 1,400 to 4,220 seconds (s).
Page 4 of 9
best suited for such missions based on this stepping GRC, in partnership with JPL, is managing a
stone approach to exploration. High-power solar Phase III SBIR contract with Colorado Power
electric propulsion was one of those key Engineering (CPE) to develop, fabricate and test a
technologies. A high-power, 40 kW-class Hall TRL 6 Prototype Development Unit (PDU) PPU.
thruster propulsion system, along with flexible This PPU would be capable of operating at 4.5 kW
blanket solar array technology, represented a readily and be compatible with the NASA-developed
scalable technology with a clear path to much higher HiVHAc+ Hall thruster, SSL’s SPT-140 thruster and
power systems. Aerojet’s XR-5 Hall thruster. GRC will conduct
The 13.3-kW Hall thruster string development, integrated system testing with the HiVHAc+ thruster
led by GRC and JPL, began with maturation of the after PDU PPU delivery. The CDR for the PPU was
high-power Hall thruster (shown in Fig. 5) and PPU. completed in September 2017. The authority to
The technology development work transitioned to proceed with fabrication was given in January 2018.
Aerojet Rocketdyne via a competitive procurement PDU PPU testing will take place in late-2018, with
selection for the AEPS contract, which included the the plan to enable development of flight hardware in
development, qualification and delivery of multiple a follow-on or separately funded contract.
flight-qualified electric propulsion strings. Each NASA is working with Busek under a Space
string consists of a 12.5-kW Hall thruster, 13.3-kW Technology Announcement of Collaborative
PPU, Xenon Flow Controller (XFC), and associated Opportunity (ACO) to perform life testing of the
intra-string harnesses. NASA supports the AEPS company’s BHT-600 Hall thruster (shown in Fig. 6),
development through in-house EP expertise, plasma including the BHC-2500 cathode. GRC is providing
modeling capabilities, and unique world-class test test facilities and support for a 5,000-hour
facilities. NASA also conducts risk reduction qualification life test that would take place between
activities in support of AEPS development and June 2018 and July 2019. It is envisioned that
mission applications. performing this testing now will reduce the cost for
future customers interested in flying this thruster
system.
Page 5 of 9
2018. The iodine-compatible BIT-3 hardware is focus is to mature critical propulsion components and
scheduled for delivery in the summer of 2018. perform integrated system testing. The tasks in this
effort are aimed at addressing critical technology
IV. RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY gaps and risks, namely scaling up to higher power
and increased propellant throughput, evaluation of
IV.I 500-W HALL THRUSTER TECHNOLOGY engineering/material changes between xenon and
NASA has significant interest in the development iodine, durability testing for more than 1,000 hours
of sub-kilowatt electric propulsion technologies for for both thruster and cathode, iodine flow control and
potential application to small spacecraft, i.e., metering, and material chemical interactions testing.
spacecraft with wet masses in the range 100-500 kg. This effort has resulted in a successful 1,174 hour
As a result, NASA has two parallel technology durability test, which concluded after a second load
development activities: the STMD-funded Sub- of iodine was exhausted.
Kilowatt Electric Propulsion (SKEP) project; and the Tests performed with the Busek BHT-600-I
JPL-funded Magnetically Shielded Miniature thruster performed very similarly with iodine and
(MaSMI) Hall thruster technology (shown in Fig. 7) xenon. Although there were minor material
[19]. Both of these activities seek to develop long- compatibility issues, these were viewed as being
life, high-performance Hall thruster/PPU strings with readily resolvable. A GRC designed and
input powers in the range of 200 to 800 W. manufactured hollow cathode operating on xenon
was used for the test as a result of prior work that
revealed compatibility issues between Barium Oxide
(BaO) emitters and iodine propellant. It was also
shown that the GRC-developed iodine storage and
feed systems were very stable and reliably delivered
gaseous iodine throughout the test, with no clogging
of feed system component degradation. Several
technical challenges still need to be addressed before
iodine-based EP could be fully implemented for
flight. The AISP project also supported work on a
wide range of topics associated with development of
iodine-based EP systems, including thrusters, PPUs,
materials and coatings, cathodes, storage and feed
systems, test facilities, along with test procedures and
concept of operations (CONOPs).
Figure 7: MaSMI Hall thruster
IV.IV 100-KW THRUSTER TECHNOLOGY
IV.II ELECTROSPRAY THRUSTER TECHNOLOGY For the deep-space transportation of very large
NASA has conducted several activities over payloads and potentially even human crews to Mars,
the last few years focused on Microfluidic NASA is developing high power EP technologies
Electrospray Propulsion (MEP). JPL has (>100 kW). The AES program established the Next
developed an MEP thruster based on Space Technologies for Exploration Partnership
microfabrication techniques [20]. The resulting (NextSTEP) Broad Area Announcement (BAA) to
emitter array chip has demonstrated electrospray solicit proposals for high-power propulsion. The
operation with excellent stability and primary goal of this activity was to demonstrate 100
controllability. The thruster has demonstrated a hours of continuous, steady-state operation of an
thrust of 100 µN and an Isp greater than 3,200 s in a advanced plasma-based propulsion system operating
very compact size. Larger arrays of microfabricated at 100 kW. Three contracts were selected: the
emitters have the potential to enable scaling up Variable Specific Impulse Magnetoplasma Rocket
to thrust levels of 1 mN. (VASIMR) led by Ad Astra; the Electrode-less
Lorentz Force (ELF-250) thruster led by MSNW; and
IV.III IODINE THRUSTER TECHNOLOGY the Nested Hall Thruster led by Aerojet-Rocketdyne
NASA is investigating the implications of iodine- (shown in Fig. 8).
based EP technology for smaller spacecraft. Through The demonstrations also required development
STMD’s Advanced In-Space Propulsion (AISP) and successful operation of a PPU, feed system and
project, NASA is focusing on developing and other key components. Key performance goals
demonstrating a 600-W iodine Hall thruster- included specific impulses ranging from 2,000 to
based propulsion system, which includes thruster, 5,000 s, total system efficiency greater than 60%,
cathode, PPU, propellant storage and feed system
[21]. The
Page 6 of 9
projected operational life of over 10,000 hours, and a exercised in February 2018. In addition,
total subsystem specific mass less than 5 kg/kW. In thruster/facility risk reduction tests were completed
addition, the technologies had to be scalable to over last year at GRC, where the thruster operated at
megawatt power levels. 100 kW for 10 minutes and 80 kW for 3 hours. In
addition, a 10 kW test of the thruster, PPU and feed
system was completed at the University of Michigan
in February 2018.
The 100-hour, 100-kW steady-state tests for
VASIMR and ELF-250 concepts are expected to be
completed by at their respective company facilities
by November 2018. Demonstration of the Nested
Hall configuration is expected to be completed at
GRC in November 2018.
Page 7 of 9
3.__Hani Kamhawi, David Manzella, Luis Pinero,
Thomas Haag, and Wensheng Huang, “In-Space
Propulsion High Voltage Hall Accelerator
Development Project Overview”, AIAA 2010-
6860, 46th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint
Propulsion Conference & Exhibit.
4.__Jerry Jackson, May Allen, Roger Myers, et al.,
“100 kW Nested Hall Thruster System
Development”, IEPC-2017-219, 35th
International Electric Propulsion Conference,
Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta,
Georgia, USA.
5.__Tim W. Glover, Franklin R. Chang Diaz, et al.,
Figure 9: Interstellar precursor mission enabled by “Principal VASIMR Results and Present
very high Isp EP with beamed energy source Objectives”, Space Technology and Applications
International Forum, February 13-17, 2005,
V. SUMMARY Albuquerque, NM.
6.__John Slough, David Kirtley, and Thomas Weber,
Electric propulsion (EP) is an important “Pulsed Plasmoid Propulsion: The ELF
propulsion technology for NASA. It has played a Thruster”, IEPC-2009-265.
major role on several missions and has the potential 7.__https://www.nasa.gov/feature/goddard/lunar-
to impact a wide range of NASAs interests including icecube-to-take-on-big-mission-from-small-
advanced deep-space science missions; human package.
exploration missions; astrophysics missions (e.g., 8.__http://www.busek.com/index_htm_files/7001081
LISA); and planetary defense. Ultimately, advanced 9%20RevA%20Data%20Sheet%20for%20BIT-
power and electric propulsion technologies could 3%20Ion%20Thruster.pdf.
enable rapid transportation throughout the solar 9.__Daniel A. Herman, Todd Tofil, et al., “Overview
system. NASA currently has many projects focused of the Development and Mission Application of
on research and development of EP for a variety of the Advanced Electric Propulsion System
applications. All three of NASA’s mission (AEPS)”, IEPC-2017-284, 35th International
directorates that deal directly with space exploration Electric Propulsion Conference, Georgia Institute
are actively engaged in supporting work in this area. of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
Almost all of the EP research and development work 10._https://www.nasa.gov/sites/default/files/atoms/fil
within NASA is being performed by Glenn Research es/20180327-crusan-nac-heoc-v8.pdf
Center (GRC) and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory 11._https://gameon.nasa.gov/gcd/files/2017/07/AISP
(JPL). _Hall-Thruster.pdf
12._Charles E. Garner, and Marc D. Rayman, “In-
VI. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Flight Operation of the Dawn Ion Propulsion
System Through Completion of Dawn’s Primary
Work done at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Mission”, AIAA Propulsion and Energy Forum,
California Institute of Technology was done under a 52nd AIAA/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion
contract with the National Aeronautics and Space Conference
Administration (NASA). The respective authors 13. Garner, C.E., Rayman, M.D., and Brophy, J.R.,
would like to thank the Jet Propulsion Laboratory for “In-Flight Operation of the Dawn Ion Propulsion
funding this study through the various program System Through Year One of Cruise to Ceres,”
offices. The information presented about future Presented at Joint Conference of 30th
mission concepts is pre-decisional and is provided for International Symposium on Space Technology
planning and discussion purposes only. and Science, 34th International Electric
Propulsion Conference and 6th Nano-satellite
VII. REFERENCES Symposium, Hyogo-Kobe, Japan, July 4 – 10,
2015.
1.__Jack Fisher, Brian Ferriauolo, et al. , “NEXT-C 14._John Ziemer, Colleen Marrese-Reading, et al.,
Flight Ion Propulsion System Development “Colloid Microthruster Flight Performance
Status”, IEPC-2017-218. Results from Space Technology 7 Disturbance
2.__https://www.nasa.gov/planetarydefense/aida. Reduction System”, The 35th International
Page 8 of 9
Electric Propulsion Conference, Georgia Institute
of Technology, USA
15._https://www.elisascience.org/files/publications/L
ISA_L3_20170120.pdf
16._David Y. Oh, Steve Collins, et al., “Development
of the Psyche Mission for NASA’s Discovery
Program”, IEPC-2017-153, 35th International
Electric Propulsion Conference Georgia Institute
of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
17._https://www.nasa.gov/planetarydefense/aida
18._https://solarsystem.nasa.gov/missions/caesar/in-
depth/
19._Ryan W. Conversano, Robert B. Lobbia, et al.,
“Development and Initial Performance Testing
of a Low-Power Magnetically Shielded Hall
Thruster with an Internally-Mounted Hollow
Cathode”, IEPC-2017-64, 35th International
Electric Propulsion Conference, Georgia Institute
of Technology, Atlanta, Georgia, USA
20._Colleen M. Marrese-Reading, John Anderson, et
al., “Silicon Emitter Needle and Array Design
for Indium Electrospray Arrays for Spacecraft
Propulsion”, 52nd AIAA/SAE/ASEE Joint
Propulsion Conference, AIAA Propulsion and
Energy Forum, (AIAA 2016-4547)
21._https://gameon.nasa.gov/gcd/files/2017/07/AISP
_Hall-Thruster.pdf
22._John Brophy, Nathan Strange, Dan Goebel,
Shawn Johnson, Dan Mazanek and David
Reeves, “Characteristics of a High-Power Ion
Beam Deflection System Necessary to Deflect
the Hypothetical Asteroid 2017 PD”, IAA-PDC-
17-04-03, IAA Planetary Defense Conference –
PDC 2017, 15-19 May 2017, Tokyo, Japan
23._John R. Brophy , James E. Polk , and Dan M.
Goebel, “Development of a 50,000-s, Lithium-
fueled, Gridded Ion Thruster”, IEPC-2017-042,
35th International Electric Propulsion
Conference, Georgia Institute of Technology,
Atlanta, Georgia, USA
24._http://kiss.caltech.edu/papers/solar/papers/CityTe
ch2017_sglf_paper.pdf
Page 9 of 9