Colorforelectronic00whit PDF
Colorforelectronic00whit PDF
using color
in charts^
ELECTRONIC
Digitized by the Internet Archive
in 2012
http://archive.org/details/colorforelectronicOOwhit
COLOR FOR THE
ELECTRONIC AGE
Ian V. White
COLOR
FOR
THE
ELECTRONIC
AGE
Z286.D47W49 1990
686.2'254466— dc20 89-77555
CIP
IVIanufactured in Malaysia
23456789 10/95 94
Contents
Introduction
2. The Basics 12
5. Type 106
Appendix 186
Glossary 195
Bibliography 201
Index 205
a
Preface
say such a thing. Yet when Toby Alex, Gregory, and Christopher
agree, there must be something to it, and when Caroline, my
daughter-in-law, gently concurs, my delusions evaporate. Therefore,
to redress the ills I have visited upon her, dedicate this book to my
I
long-suffering Clare.
1 INTRODUCTION
Contrary to what we hear, this is not the Age of Information. It would
be more accurate to call it the Age of Information Chaos. How much
better, were it the Age of Knowledge.
Color can enliven the product. Color applied with taste and care can
beautify. It is more valuable, though, when used to bring out inherent
beauty than when it is a cosmetic added to the surface.
appear pretty, but such beauty is indeed skin-deep and too often
merely phony.
F-i^"^^i^^^
'
^
® M ^^a
/«K 7^ /:=^ , /^x^ /?
.nT/sv.^^ ^
^\^^ r^\ I
i^.f':t^is.^
''^^"^'^^Q^i'fTS^^^
o _
Functional color can link as well as split ^^->^y^^^^ f C^
10 INTRODUCTION
This book is about the functional use of color. It is about color as a
tool:how it can be used to focus attention, explain relationships,
analyze data; how it can help the viewer/reader understand
information faster and more vividly; and how it can make printed
matter easier to absorb, helping turn information into knowledge.
This is value worth adding. Prettiness is a side issue, a by-product, a
lagniappe.
I had to use any time a second color became available? (He also
wore brown shoes with blue suits. This was in the 1950s, when
Doing Your Own Thing had not yet been invented.) Such subjective
attitudes should remain personal and should never be allowed to
impinge on professional decision making. Color in a publication
context is a medium of communication to be chosen and used with
deliberation, not emotion.
fulfill specific tasks. Using color to fulfill a wider purpose brings the
highest return on the investment in color capability.
INTRODUCTION 11
2. THE BASICS
How color is used and
how people see it
You probably learned to think about colors from paints. At school
you found that a dollop of red added to a brushful of blue makes
purple and red mixed with a glob of yellow makes orange. At least
that is what it looked like on the painting you proudly brought home.
Hue: The name of a color, such as brown, blue, green. People can
distinguish thousands of subtle variations. We pick colors on the
basis ofhue because we "like them." Hue, however, is less important
than value and chroma in handling color well.
Hues — even the pure ones — vary widely in value. Yellow is very
(Hue, value, and chroma are terms used in the Munsell system. See
page 189.)
Visibility: The purer the hue, the more visible it is both at a distance and, in
terms of noticeability, close up. The subtler the value in shade or tint,
the more difficult it is to discern.
Contrast: The greater the contrast, the stronger the visibility. Black on yellow
and black on white are the strongest contrasts.
Here is the color wheel, which is in general use. There are all sorts of
variations worked out for measuring scientific balances of color
depending on whether it is studied as light waves, pigments in
suspension, or what have you. The color wheel is the practical
compromise we work with in the less-than-precise world of print and
presentation.
14 THE BASICS
Monochromatic color schemes use one basic hue to give unity to the
product. Variations in lightness or darkness are used, but essentially
these are red or green color schemes.
is usually wise to use the quiet color as the dominant color and the
(I) Analogous color schemes use hues that lie close together on the
color wheel. Since the colors are related, they are harmonious.
Nonetheless, one color should be picked as the dominant color with
the others supporting it.
Contrasting color schemes use hues that have three colors between
them on the color wheel. Though they are called contrasting, they
need not clash or create unpleasant combinations. The brightest
Mm Black-plus color schemes use a palette limited to grays plus one hue.
Grays blend with any color. Bright colors go well with light gray, pale
ones with dark gray, dull colors go well with black. Contrast is the
key to balance.
THE BASICS 15
It is vital that you understand the magic and trickery of color.
Color is always seen in its surroundings. What it is near and
how much of it there is affects how it looks.
16 THE BASICS
Much of the success of
using color depends on
proportion and
relationships. The large
area of darker
background makes the
little yellow square jump
off the page. Reverse the
colors, and the contrast
is much less successful.
Change the proportions,
and there is hardly any
motion.
affected by a color's
strength. In both of
these squares, the red
overpowers the black.
This is why the inner red
square looks larger than
the black one. They are,
of course, both the same
THE BASICS 17
When pure
complementary colors
are placed next to each
other, they have an
upsetting effect on the
color receptors in the
human eye, and visual
vibration ensues. Purple
and green clash. They
can be brought into
harmony by mixing a
little of each with the
other.
'V.c
18 THE BASICS
whatever color you may choose to use, you must apply it
so that it works for you: It should make sense, clarify ideas,
and add value to vwhat you show and tell.
First, analyze the information to find how color can be used to code
it; for instance, if there are tasks the viewer is to perform, make them
vivid with color.
at first. A
is inevitably the first element to attract the eye;
picture
color is be the next. Therefore, it is logical to assign color to
likely to
the most important information, so it is sure to be noticed. It will
probably motivate the reader to penetrate deeper into the text.
Do not confuse the viewer/reader with too many color codes. Under
normal conditions, two colors in addition to black are easily
understood and remembered. As the number of colors increases, the
work's effectiveness decreases, because it requires effort to remember
so many different colors.
Use bright colors in small areas, pale or dull colors in large areas.
20 THE BASICS
Warm colors are brighter, more dynamic, more active, and thus
more "attractive" than cool colors. They are used at their best in
small areas contrasted to cool backgrounds.
Warm colors appear closer to the viewer than cool ones. Therefore,
canny users of color assign red, yellow, or orange to elements that
are supposed to be in the foreground. They assign blue, green, or
violet to objects in the background. If elements in the foreground are
intended to overlap those in the background, the effect of depth and
separation is emphasized by the right use of color, and understanding
is thus enhanced.
Light or pale colors tend tomake an object appear larger than it is.
Dark colors make appear smaller. Therefore, canny users of color
it
THE BASICS 21
Color does not just look nice. It also has cultural connotations.
You must bear them in mind
when picking the colors you intend to use.
22 THE BASICS
Blue was the overwhelming favorite as a color in the same survey.
The tests also proved that its popularity was not based on political
symbolism, where blue is the color of conservatism. Blue connotes
calm, authority, respect; sky, water, cold. Blue means reliability and
corporate strength to financial people, but it means death to doctors
and cooling water to people working around nuclear reactors.
Bright hues, especiallywarm ones like yellow and orange, are active
and seem They are also seen as being
to help mental activity.
cheerful. This is why
they are gaining favor in schools. (Dull, cool
colors have the opposite effect and create quiet and a relaxing
mood.)
Brown is informal and not a power color for men's or women's suits.
THE BASICS 23
Some colors carry symbolism that is generally understood.
Some comes from the way the color is used,
some from the way it is referred to in speech.
24 THE BASICS
Colors played an important part inmedieval heraldry. The palette was
restricted to available materials. Each color (tincture) had its symbolic
meaning. Blazon is the language used to describe the "accidents,"
which were the colors, furs, and metals that composed the heraldic
shield. A complex symbolic, systematized language of shape, color,
and meaning was developed over the years. Like corporate identity
programs, it was strictly codified and enforced. Here are the nine
colors with their heraldic names, meanings, and conventional black-
and-white representations (tricking).
Gules Purpure
(Fortitude and magnanimity) (Sovereignty and )ustice)
Argent Sable
(Cold, peace, and sincerity) (Silver, generosity, and vi/isdom) (Constancy and grief)
THE BASICS 25
The ancient Greek king would not be kingly, were his
robe not purple
26 THE BASICS
Red = embarrassment Yellow = jaundice
Baby boys are blue, and baby girls are pink. Presents
bought before babies are born must be neutral: pale
yellow or white —or there will be trouble.
to catapult an obvious point off the page into the viewer's mind.
When a cliche is used in a fresh way, it rises to being an idiom.
General speech — both verbal and visual —
is thus enriched.
Every human activity, profession, and interest has its own specialized
jargon.Use them all as potential idea-accelerators, but only when
you can be reasonably certain that your visual shorthand will be
understood by the audience.
THE BASICS 27
—
complement and balance each other. They are printed separately and
on top of each other in varying proportions. The resultant variety of
colors is created by the variety of proportions of the four process
colors combined with the whiteness of the paper.
..W^^^"^
The paper is touched four times, once by each of Individually, the four colors are not very handsome. The magenta
the four process colors. {A press is considerably looks brashly pink when screened down from its solid state. The
more complicated than this diagram.) yellow is invisible on white paper except in large panels, where it
looks crude and vulgar. The cyan is a pale turquoise and the only
color that can be used successfully by itself. Ttiis is done so often that
it looks common and cheap. It is surprising that such unlikely hues
added together can form the visual miracles that they do. The
operative words are "added together." Individually they are unhappy.
In combination they can sing with joy.
four separate plates, one for each of the four process colors. The tiny
dots meld in the eye and produce, as faithfully as possible, an
illusion of the color values of the "continuous tone" originals.
In panels: Color in flat areas can vary from "solid," that, is 100
percent of the ink, to none, zero percent. Mechanical screens
normally vary the density in increments of 10 percent steps, though 5
percent are also available. Even greater flexibility is available in
electronic technology. Superimposing screens of various percentages
in various combinations of the four process colors can simulate any
color you wish — in flat areas. (To avoid muddy colors, it is best not to
let the sum of all the percentages exceed 240.)
28 THE BASICS
If you are unfamiliar with this material, it can sound confusing. Take
heart and look at page 72. It will begin to make sense when you see
some examples.
Second, matched, or mixed colors differ from process colors
in that they are "real" rather than simulated. Think of them as ready-
made tubes of ink of a specific hue: dark red, light pink, olive green.
They are used solid or in screened form in panels or any other way
on the page you wish (except in photographs, unless you are being
very courageous and tricky). The printer can buy them by swatch or
number from ink manufacturers, if they are standard hues. If they are
unusual, the printer can mix them for you the same way that paint
stores produce the color you want for your walls with a splash of —
this and a squeeze of that. The paint store follows formulas produced
by the manufacturer, and their result is visible on the paint chips.
There are many ink manufacturers who produce their own ink-colors
palettes. The Pantone® Matching System,* however, is universally
known and used as a basis for choosing and specifying the colors of
matched inks (see page 191). These are the "pms colors."
If you choose a specific color in the pms system, it can be printed one
of two ways:
1. As a matched ink
(ifyou have a two-color press, one cylinder of the press is used for
black, the other one for the color of your choice).
THE BASICS 29
3. PRESENTATIONS
AND
PUBLICATIONS
Using color for continuity
and identity
Presentations with slides and overheads are identical to printed
publications in one major respect: They are both constructed as
streams of information. The streams flow as sequences of
impressions, slide after slide, overhead after overhead, page after
page. They stop and go very much like filmstrips. The audience,
whether viewers///steners or viewers/readers, needs time to absorb
the information. Presentations are controlled by the speaker, so the
audiences are forced to begin at the beginning. Printed pieces have
the advantage of accessibility anywhere. The rate of speed in which
each impression is revealed is controlled by the speaker in the case
of the presentation and by the individual viewer/reader in the case of
printed matter.
It matters little how many pages there are or how many visuals make
up a presentation. The principle of continuity is as valid for a six
hundred-page manual as it is for a four-page brochure, a newsletter,
or a complex book, a short slide show or an in-depth lecture on an
abstruse subject requiring dozens of overheads. Since they are all
constructed of segments, color can be used to make that construction
clear. If the segments have subsets, color can separate them from the
matrix in which they occur. Color can help to codify the ideas in the
presentations or publications in various ways. It can also unify them
and give them a character of their own. Or it can relate them clearly
within a corporate identity.
2. Make the system as simple as possible. The simpler, the better. Not
only do people understand and remember a technique more easily
if it is simple, but simplicity usually results in elegance. To achieve
Here are ten principles for the use of color in slides or overheads that
respond to the peculiar requirements of verbal-visual presentations
before audiences. Of course, they are not rules. There are no such
things. There is no right way or wrong way that can be proved or
quantified. There is only an effective or ineffective way based on
common sense and experience.
1 . Use color to make the best of the physical situation in which the
presentation will be viewed.
POW!
5.
ninlnln
Use color to prioritize information. Audiences will look at the
brightest area first. Control their response by putting the most
important material in the brightest colors.
m
. Use color to symbolize. The most obvious symbols: red for
danger, green for go, amber for caution.
9. Use color so that its implications help the audience to sort out the
material. By assigning orange to positive attributes, for instance,
every time orange appears on the screen, the audience will
immediately interpret the item as "good news." It takes no more
than two or three repetitions of such color assignment for the
audience to catch on, especially if its first appearance is dramatic
and pointed out by the speaker.
3. Start with a colorful title visual. Use clip art if necessary. Follow
the opener with an agenda visual that shows the key steps in the
presentation. Wind up
with a conclusion visual that lists action
items or recommendations. Assign a color to them that will tie
them together and make them unique by comparison to the rest of
the show.
. Keep the same format throughout so that the audience gets used to
looking at a predictable arrangement. Avoid mixing vertical and
horizontal slides — unless the verticals are strategically inserted as
deliberate breaks. Their change of direction could be emphasized
with a change of color.
1. Limit each visual to the essentials. Simplify and edit out everything
that is not vital. Avoid showing supporting information. Perhaps a
'U
4. People start reading in the top-left corner, then follow diagonally
down to the lower-right corner. Arrange material to follow this
basic pattern. A bright color up there could be a good way to
attract the eye to that starting point.
where people tend to read first (use the brightest color for it, too).
Few scan the bottom of a page or slide first. Place the most
positive copy in the top-left corner. The expected, traditional,
static, dignified way of putting a title in the middle is analogous to
the placement of a newspaper logo on the front page. It sits there
the problem —
we hope.)
It is better to pick a single color and apply it to all the repetitive
signaling devices. Standardize harmonious colors for the nameplate
(logo), indexes, table of contents, column tags, or department
headings, as well as all the other repetitive signage that the piece
may need. The color will not merely unify the publication, but it will
also strengthen its overall image. Besides, you can use different
colors for the illustrations or other events in the sequence of pages,
wherever might be appropriate. They
this will fall into place in the
overall context in which they are viewed.
One more reason not to change colors, where consistency would pay
is that the complexity of too many colors causes confusion.
off better,
Ithas been found that people can distinguish and easily —
—
remember four colors, if those colors are broadly different from
each other. This has been found
be an optimal number. Realism,
to
aesthetics, or function, of course, may demand more. But these
should be the exceptions rather than the rule. Four colors is the
optimal practical maximum.
You have to decide whether you want to use this device in the first
place. If you do, you commit yourself to a discipline that can prove
burdensome. Yet you cannot afford to do things by halves. Sticking to
the rules you make for yourself here and there, wherever it happens
else, lest you dilute the trademark quality of your device, whose
singular visual characteristic is its purpleness.
True, the page will look busier and spottier. This is a characteristic
that some people find offensive, because simplicity, purity, and
plainness have been touted as aesthetically positive values.
Philosophically, this is absolutely so. But we do not face
philosophical dilemmas. We face practical ones. Resolving this
dilemma is not a question of aesthetics but of efficient function. If
Frames and backgrounds for boxes and panels. Assume that you are
preparing a publication illustrated with numerous charts and
diagrams. Expand the idea from just one document and imagine that
What color to use? A strong one. One that will jump off the page,
because this is what you want it to do. Should the color bleed? And
should the number therefore be in a panel? Yes, if at all possible
technically, because the sliver of color visible on the edge of the
color to identify a separate section (and then use that hue within each
section). This variation of the system does not change the basic
principle. It enriches it.
Why not print a strip of color up the edges so that the section you
want to identify is highlighted? The rest of the pages can remain
plain. How wide should the strip be? Wide enough to be able to
accommodate imprecision of trimming (if the publication is bound
and trimmed, like a magazine). The narrower it is, the more critical
does precision become: '/4-inch is too narrow; 'A-inch is more than
ample. However, if you want to print identifying wording in the color
strip (sideways, please, never vertically!) it probably has to be V^-
inch.
Color the section breaks. Breaking out a single section (as in the
yellow pages, above) may be inappropriate, because no one single
unit is more important than the others. Yet the sequence of chapters
or units of which a publication is constructed needs to be explained
as clearly as possible. The most obvious signal is that of identifying
the starts of each section. Careful planning is necessary to make the
most of every opportunity.
first.
Every time a new page is looked at, the first element to be noticed
and studied is the visual, nontextual one —
the diagram. Too often the
information contained in the diagram is repeated in the text, much to
the annoyance of the reader, who is forced to identify and then skip
the duplication.
of view in whose support the facts are being presented, then a new
dimension is added to the problem of preparation. In this case, the
data has to be presented in such a way that the viewer will indeed
reach the intended interpretation.
**See )an V White, Using Chans and Graphs (New York: R. R. Bowker, 1984).
4\
Pa^r
I Weirfr^l - o
NOW :
Most have the x- and y-coordinates. They are needed because most
sets of information show some form of comparison, in terms of size,
rate of changes, development over time, and so forth.
A
->-fWur<r Y
Y
J)ecyeAie
The horizontal x-axis crossing the vertical y-axis creates a field. This
is the area on which the symbols representing the data are plotted
The only format that does not require a coordinate field is the pie
chart, which is a self-contained figure. Pies, however, can be placed
on a tabletop covered with a blue tablecloth, even though blue is not
intrinsic to the pie's message. A common background panel color
can thus tie the pie to the other charts in a group.
Graphics carry a title normally placed above the diagram. Just like a
headline, which refers to the text that follows, the title over a chart or
Arrows are a distinct element in chart making, Not only can they
indicate direction, they can also point out highlighted elements.
Further, they can guide the eye from one element to another
facilitating the reading of charts and graphs. If this were not enough,
they can also illustrate a concept. Color is the material that enables
them to fulfill their potential. (For an analysis of arrows, see page
102.)
As W^
3
^
S^
2
/^.
c^ \ A B C
Q
2
/^
C^ A B
\ C
Description of subject
3
S^
^^
/y^\
2
C^ A B c
Title in color: not very thrilling Indices and scales in color: underwhelming
2
Sw
^v
3
2
^ S^
//^
C^ \ vi^
\^ \
A B c A B C
1
The wrong line in color: color implies emphasis Color emphasizes the correct line and ties it to title
3
Description of subject
\ V.
3
\
Description of subject
U y
/ r^\
2 2
/y^
C^ \
1
/ ^^ f
\
Both lines in
A
3
Description of subject
y ./ \ 3
Description of subject
./ \
/ r\\ /A
2 2 >
\,
/ ^f
\
1 1
A B C A B C
Black lines on red grids: reads well Grid lines in bold color: look like prison bars
Field in solid color; perhaps too strong Field in tint of color: better when many charts are needed
Field stepped in increments. 'See page 8 Field ramped left-to-right. (See page 87)
If you know what this purpose is, you can use graphics and color to
catapult it into the viewer's mind. Deciding what the point is sounds
easier than it is, but making it visible is easier than it sounds. Just
make it bigger and fatter, then color it.
/ ^
1
-
\...---
^"\ c
1 1
1 1
/V B c D E f
People instinctively assume that similar colors relate the elements that
bear them. If there are three balls, two of them are red and one blue,
thetwo red ones "belong" together, and the blue one is the outsider.
Canny communicators can make use of this logic in presenting
diagrammed information so that color is used to group and encode
related elements.
5 y^^ y
4
jj-- .^^\
3
1
/
ABCDEFGH
The red line carries the red label, the blue line
carries the blue label. (The title is in black, This is the title of the figure
ABCDEFGH
CHARTS AND GRAPHS 59
Reversing the colors creates confusion.
This is the title of the figure
5 y'^%^,^/
4
3
/\ .s^K^^^\
2
A B C D E F G H
^
Here the field is in two colors: the red indices
6 15
blue ones to
refer to the red material at left, the
the blue material at right. Such information
would be much harder to understand without
color.
5 /^% 1 4
4
/ ^^ 13
PW^
.
3 12
2 11
1
\
" A B C D E F G H
4 13
3 12
A B C D E F
V
G H
11
10
06-Apr-89
Raw spreadsheet data spewed out by the computer can make the heart sink.
The information is there, but what a job it is to find the conclusions. If
certain information is highlighted by color, the be run in color needs
t>'f>e to
to be bolder, otherwise the emphasized elements disappjear. (Watch out for
red ink: if the numbers represent dollars, use red only for losses.)
06-Apr-89
Here the salient points have been separated from the rest of the spreadsheet
by color. The information is classified, but there is one problem: the color
tint decreases the contrast of black ink on white paper, so the very elements
Since black on white is more highly visible, this version of coloring the
background in panels is much more functional. The salient points are
brighter, the body of information is duller.
What is the viewer conscious of first in this ^irJ!7"F^ fftTfr- .rr. EHH ^EHI^l :'i:"'!±lll
version? Time and Stop. Neither is very
LOS ANGELES 833 Mon. 13:30 Lima Sdo Poulo-RIo
important. From is would probably
so dark that it
845 Wed. 12:30 Lima Rio-Sdo Paulo
be ignored. Destination and Flight seem related
831 Wed. 13:30 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
to each other because the green links them
831 Fri. 13:30 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
visually. But emphasizing such a close 841 Sat. 12:30 Panama Rio-Sdo Paulo
relationship is not helpful.
MIAMI 811 Mon. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Tue. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
801 Wed. 18:45 Manaus Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Wed. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Thurs. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Fri. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Sat. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
807 Sun. 17:00 Belem
Recife
Salvador Rio-Sdo Paulo
811 Sun. 21:00 Nonstop Rio-Sdo Paulo
presentation. Apart from making the object look prettier, color can
expose or it can hide. It can reveal or camouflage. It can also remain
neutral.
Topic title
Topic title
Stub head
HH
•m HilH|
Columrfflea^^
Topic title
The simple color panel that covers the black type is not Additional colorfulness, but little improvement in
very helpful; too dark. communication value. No elements are emphasized.
Stub head Column head Column head Stub head Column head Column head
Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmm Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmm
Stub topic mmmmm mmmm Stub topic mmmmm mmmm
Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmmm Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmmm
Stub topic mmmm mmmmm Stub topic mmmm mmmmm
The color makes totals pop out. They would be more The title and the bottom line it refers to are tied
dramatically visible were they set in bold type as well together and make the rest of the information
as in color. skippable.
Topic title
Topic title
pbpic title
Stub head Column head Column head Bstub head Column head Column head
Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmm Stub topic mmmm mmmmm
Stub topic mmmmm mmmm
Stub topic mmmmmm mmmmmm
Stub topic
mmmmm mmmmm
neighbors, presunr ably signaling its specialness. Screened color areas separate layers from each other.
Stub head Column head Column head Stub head Column head Column head
St r. .^^ - mmmmm Stub top c
rr.rr,mrr^,r^ mmmmm
StoD -ca :
mmmmm mmmm Stub top
mmn-T.m mmmm
StL'C top.c
mmmmmm mmmmmm Stub top c
'--^rvr.n^.ni mmmmmm
St.btODC mmmm mmmmm Stub top c
mn-.n-m mmmmm
mmmmm mmmmm
Stub head Column head Column head Stub head Column head Column head
Rules in color sep arate columns and rows. The rule Type in color separated by vertical rules in black. Since
above the totals is in black. type in color is more unusual, it will gain attention.
...
Bbpic ftfle
Stub head Column head Column head Stub head Column head Column head
Stub topic
Stub topic HHHHBHS^^^91
mmmmmm mmmmmr^l
Stub topic
Stub topic Stub topic
Stub topic mmmm mmmmm" Stub topic
An arrangement that is perhaps a little more complex The bold black rules add horizontal emphasis as well as
than the subject warrants. visibility to heads and totals.
|^.^.,AT.iii.lii'
The greatest contrast in print is that of black ink on white paper. (In
slide presentations, the reverse is true: the strongest effect is that of
white type on black background.)
so in fact, but the viewer will jump to that conclusion simply because
of the physical visual reaction to the printed image.
Black on yellow does stand out more strikingly, but this is a function
of the combination of hue more than of contrast. It is startling, but
not conducive to long-term study. Why is text seldom run on yellow?
Because it hurts to read it.
First-class citizenship l^
held by material in the This type, which is printed on a dark background, is harder to discern than ... 1
layers whose contrast is
greatest. this type wn^cn is priptea on a white background, and stands out more vividly than
this type, which is printed on a white background, and stands out more vividly than . .
this ^yDe A'hch IS pr,nted on a wh te background, and stands out more vividly than
this type, which is printed on a dark background, and is therefore harder to discern. 1
backgrounds equalize
the interpretation of the
data '^'5 ^P®' ^t^'ch is on a colored background whose tone is similar, therefore . .
' t this type, which is printed on a colored background, is no harder to discern than . .
20% This type is surprinted in black ^^^^Hp ^ dropped out in white 20%
This type is surprinted in black ^^^B is dropped out in white
This type is surprinted in black. ^^^Me dropped out in white
is
30% This type is surprinted in black ^^^Re is dropped out in white 30%
This type is surprinted in black. ^^^e is dropped out in white JH
This type is surprinted in black . ^^)e is dropped out in white fl
40% This type is surprinted in black ^^Hbe is dropped out in white 40%
^^Ke
*
This type is surprinted in black. is dropped out in white
This type is surprinted in black. ^^^be
. dropped out in white
is
,^^
50% This type is surprinted in black ^^H|pe is dropped out in white 11
This type is surprinted in black ^^^e is dropped out in white *
This type is surprinted in black.,phis type is dropped out in white
K This type surprinted i^j||jfl this type is dropped out in white 60%
H This type
This type is
is
is surprinted
surprinted
i^^^|
.
.this type
ii^^^ .this type is dropped out in white
Is dropped out in white
70% This type is surprinted in blacM . this type is dropped out in white 70%
This type is surprinted in blacH .this type dropped out in white
is
^
''-.;
. ; .:M,:-r,,-;^', .-.,i ;
r, r>'7)f~k!i this type is dropped out in white
I .
''^H
^ this type
. this type
.this
.
type
this type is
is
is
dropped out in white
dropped out in white
dropped out in white
90%
'l^^l .this . is
50% This type is surprinted in black . .is type is dropped out in white
This type is surprinted in black . Is type is dropped out in white _
"
This type is surprinted in black. . lis type dropped out in "*
is
60% This type is surprinted in black lis type dropped out in white
is
Using color is always a bit risky, and you never know exactly what it
will look like untilit is finally printed, no matter how carefully you
Print out a copy of the black-on-white base drawing (there are few
charts and graphs that lack such a thing), and cover it with a tracing-
paper overlay. Use specially made tissue, which does not allow the
color to bleed through. Sketch in the color with the marker. Then,
having decided which you intend to use, identify each with a swatch
from the color-sample book. If you are using process colors, any
color you choose can be simulated by a combination of the four
process inks.
Then pull your swatches together and compare them for balance (or
contrast) to the gray scale, like the one on the opposite page.
You want them to be in close range, 20% is probably safest, so that
none screams or overwhelms the others. Place the swatch atop the
gray. Half-close the eyes so that you become conscious only of the
tones. When they match, this is the gray value that you are seeking.
rii^v/.*.-i?i»a
"Cv^
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^K '
^ )^^^^^^^^^^^1
darkness you need for dropping out type in white most effectively. So
be aware of the area that such a dark color is being used on.
Colors paler than 15%, however, tend to look a bit washed out,
though they are an ideal background for black text. The actual hue
may affect the effect.
To create color contrast (for instance, to ensure that type stands out
from its colored background) make the difference in gray-scale value
at least 30%.
This is much better: the color of the type is the same green
en J
as in the example above, but the black is paler: 30%
Any screen over 40% tends to be too strong and dark, and therefore
dangerous, if type is to be surprinted. You can surprint black on
yellow even if it is 100% solid. Its brashness and vulgarity, however,
increase in proportion to its intensity.
Process red (magenta) turns into a crude and unattractive pink when
used alone in screen form.
Color progression
Variegation of hue and value effectively splits a is indeed very colorful. Its variety, however, can
series into separate components. Instead of disturb the feeling of flow, making it harder for
Progression can be exhibited most clearly by 15%, 25%, 40%, 60%, 80%, 100%. The darkest
simplicity. Here, a single color is shown in a one (100%) seems to be closest, whereas the
sequence of gradations. The screens used are: lightest one (15%) appears to be farthest away.
For an effect that uses the capacity of the new change the balance. Shown here is 100%
technology to best advantage and produces a magenta, 0% cyan at left; 80% magenta, 20%
colorful result that retains the deliberately cyan; 60% magenta, 40% cyan; 40% magenta,
organized effect, use the illusion of one color 60% cyan; 20% magenta, 80% cyan; 0%
turning into another by stages. This can best be magenta, 100% cyan at right. The result is fairly
accomplished by starting with one pure color at balanced from left to right. If you want to build
left, ending with the other at right, and up to a crescendo, change the proportions of the
superimposing tints in the intervening units that screens. Check in a color book or experiment.
Six units on parade. Even without numbers tar left, as convention dictates. The result is a
showing, we assume numbering to begin at the static presentation without climax.
The six units all overlapping in the same the ones above to be receding into the distance,
direction. Since we read left to right, we interpret whereas the ones below appear to be advancing.
is confusing.
w
The monochromatic
arrangement is shown in
reverse pattern, from
dark to light. Here the
bars atleft are the
If there is something
guiding them along,
they alsostart at the left
and follow toward the
right.
or white glaciers.
The dust particles and water vapor floating in the intervening air are
the physical causes of the illusion. When they are missing, as in the
crystal air of the desert, distances are much harder to determine. The
intervening air is seldom neutral gray, however. Its color is bluish,
purplish. At dawn it is pinkish. At sunset it can be multicolored.
a:i3DDDCCD
Here is the illusion of the Sun traveling from left to right.
'tyM^^^
/ 1 i K
/ \^
/
/ 1
\
9
CHARTS AND GRAPHS 93
The shape of the shadow describes the
position and shape of the object that is
casting it. These examples are "standing
Shadows are thought of as gray. This is why they have been depicted
in black or gray in the preceding examples. This, however, is merely
Gray is the right color when the background has "no" color. Most
commonly this occurs when the background happens to be a piece
of paper. Since gray can easily be produced from black ink or toner
by using a screen, grayness is the commonest, easiest, and cheapest
method of creating the illusion of shadow in printed matter. This,
however, is an oversimplified cliche.
right to change from gray to blue? Or purple? One wishes there were.
Given the variety of contexts, uses, and resultant meanings, no
formulas that make sense can be devised. The only one that makes
sense: open your eyes and observe, then experiment. Play with the
infinite possibilities that the technology now allows. Then have the
courage to try something beyond the safely expected norm.
Boxes and panels are not just boxes and panels. Use your ingenuity
and imagination to make more of them. They are shown here in plain
black on white. Start thinking color: change the lines into color, fill
the spaces with color, surround the spaces with contrasting or
matching color, combine elements. Each is an opportunity to use
color for its own decorative sake. The color can be in the
From Ian V. White, Using Charts and Graphs (New York: R. R. Bowker, 1984).
96 CHARTS AND GRAPHS
rr
V
i
CHARTS AND GRAPHS 97
Twelve panels with headings
Bold rules could be in color or in black. Background needs to be darker to One three-dimensionalized box atop
drops out or surprints in black,
Title create the illusion of a plane floating in another. Shaded edges of the boxes
depending on the background. front of it. Title in white. must be intwo tones.
Title floats near but separate from the Tints separate the functions of the two The shadow creates the illusion of a
field of the illustration. boxes. sheet of paper floating over the surface.
Overlapping units stepped back are shown by means ot Three-dimensionalized boxes with color on the faces, black
shades and shadows (see page 92). edges.
\\ nite panels outlined m bold black, with background a Panels carved out from a solid, with the faces shown at
^ /^ "^r
/' \
^
/ \
^
\l
Panels are carved out from a block, but they are shown Panels are the ends of long, rectangular blocks all vanishing
disappearing in perspective. at acommon point. The rectangular two-by-fours are an
opportunity for color variation.
LOGOTYPE
— —
Then the supervisor, client, spouse whoever objects, "Let's don't
make 'em green, that's boring. Let's make them like the rainbow
hey, that's fun! Red, orange, yellow, green, blue, violet, wow!"
(Fortunately this turns out to be too expensive, so they wind up with
a pea-green instead.)
and pointers
Indicating the way The most obvious use for an arrow is to show
the direction of flow, course, orientation, compass bearing, or even
responsibility. The point is so clear to start with that color can add
little to its interpretation. It can, however, help to make the sign stand
out from its surroundings, to ensure the visibility of the message.
JL
^^iQIEIiIi]
:ri nn
The effect is heightened when pointer and pointee are linked by
color.
Color must be used to split the arrow from its background so that it is
recognized as floating on a plane apart from the elements it overlaps:
Changing the color from one end of the arrow to the other reinforces
the idea of change:
or any other kind of -ish you wish. It also changes color with age.
Let's just call it very light.
People are used to the contrast of very dark ink on very light paper. It
is the traditional way of printing, and it may also be the easiest to
read. The contrast of color against white is inevitably lower than that
of "black." Each hue has a different effect. The darker the color, the
stronger the contrast. The paler the color, the weaker the contrast,
Being aware of this will guide you in compensating by size and
boldness.
To prove the claim that the effects vary markedly, the next eight pages
show the same text, Hamlet's "To be or not to be" soliloquy, set
several different ways for easy comparison. It is set in four
typographic variations: Galliard, Helvetica light, Helvetica medium,
Helvetica bold; in three sizes: 8/8, 10/10, 12/12; using color in four
methods: type in color on white, type in color on black, type in
white on color, type in black on color.
D You can get away with the smaller sizes of the type on white
background if you use the bolder versions.
D All the larger sizes read better.
D Small sizes of type that are run on dark backgrounds (whether
black or color) do not read nearly as well as the larger ones.
D A serif type, with its thick-and-thin lines, is more fragile and
harder to decipher when used with color than any of the sans-serif
versions.
surer you must be that the color handling will not hinder legibility.
When he hi
With a bare bodkin? Who would fardels bear.
To grunt and sweat under a weary life,
But that the dread of something after death.
The undiscover'd country from whose bourn
No traveller returns, puzzles the will.
And makes us rather bear those ills we have
Than fly to others that we know not of?
Thus conscience does make cowards of us all;
And thus the native hue of resolution
Is sicklied o'erwith the pale cast of thought,
And enterprises of great pitch and moment
With this regard their currents turn awry.
And lose the name of action.
ws of outrag«ous fortune
In all sorts of publications, you will find headlines or titles picked out
in color, just because color is available and it makes the page look
more attractive. Is there anything wrong with No. Its wide use
that?
proves that it is a perfectly acceptable technique.
startling and thus stands out against the others is not merely justified
but an advantage. however, the title has been picked out in color
If,
the different typefaces, in all the sizes and styles that are available.
Then multiply the possible combinations by the thousands of colors
we easily distinguish. What richness of expression!
This is an '
though emphasized by color
'
1|l|iftHtfNfl%1lSlil^lPAft%WH^ shaclRM^
'l|l|i^'ir[U'3'Vjli;ilMft% iMf^^imiRIMf
A thin white outline can separate the black type from its background, if the background is too. dark.
Color and the traditional way of setting headlines
Using Up-And-Down style with color reduces the effect of surprise
and emphasis that color can engender. Where the words read
smoothly (that is, when they are set all-lowercase), the interruption
created by color is much more dramatic. Upper and lower case
makes words look like separate units and smoothness is replaced by
visual hiccups.
Squint through half-closed eyes at a printed page that has some type
in color. This is a foolproof way of filtering out the weak from the
strong. You will find that light type recedes or even disappears. The
type in black will remain, because black ink contrasts more vividly
against the white page than color does.
To call attention to specific words or To be, or not to be: that is the question:
phrases, you could set them in italics; Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
boldface; bold italics; larger type size; The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
underscored; a different face; spaced Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
out; and in capitals (though that is very And by opposing, end them'^ To die: to sleep;
unwise). And, of course, in color: but No more; and by a sleep to say we end
look how much paler the words in blue the heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
look. Yet the color used here, cyan, is a That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consummation
strong color. indeed "strong" when
It is Devoutly to be wish'd. To die, to sleep;
seen in bulk, as in the swatch below. rub,
But when seen as the scrawny, thin For in that sleep of death what dreams may come
lines that type is made of, it is sicklied When we have shuffled off this mortal coil.
o'er with a pale cast. Must give us pause: there's the respect
thatmakes calamity of so long life;
For who would bear the whips and scorns of time,
The oppressor's wrong, the proud man's contumely.
The pangs of despised love, the law's delays.
The insolence of office, and the spurns
That patient merit of the unworthy takes.
When he himself might his quietus make
With a bare bodkin? Who would fardels bear,
Tc under a weary life,
:
Larger tvpe uses more ink, just like To be, or not to be: that IS the question:
bolder type does. The emphasized Whether tis nobler in the mind to suffer
words are therefore more noticeable for The Slings and arrows of Outrageous fortune,
two reasons: size and color. Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
And by opposing, end them'i' To die: to sleep:
No more: and by a sleep to say we end
the heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consummation
Devoutly to be wish'd To die, to sleep;
To —
:" -
ay. there's the rub;
For in that sleep of death what dreams may come
When we have shuffled off this mortal coil.
Must give us pause: there's the respect
that makes calamity of so long life;
For who would bear the whips and scorns of time.
The oppressor s wrong, the proud man's contumely,
The pangs of despised love, the law's delays.
The insolence of office, and the spurns
That patient merit of the unworthy takes,
When he himself might his quietus make
With a bare bodkin? ;.:.:. .-.c^,^ 'ardels bear,
To grunt and sweat under a weary life,
But that the dread of something after death,
The undiscover'd country from whose bourn
No traveller returns, puzzles the will.
And makes us rather bear those ills we have
Than fly we know not of?*
to others that
Thus conscience does make cowards of us all;
And thus the native hue of resolution
Is sicklied o'er with the pale cast of thought.
Here the important words are set both To be, or not to be: that is the question:
larger and bolder. It is little wonder that Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
they jump off the page. The color The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
succeeds in attracting the eye because Or to take arnns against a sea of troubles.
there is enough of it there to outscream And by opposing, end thenn'? To die: to sleep:
the black. True, the fact that the lines No nnore; and by a sleep to say we end
also extend out of the column at right the heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
contributes to their noticeability. Cover That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consunnmation
up the excess with a piece of white Devoutly to be wish'd. To die, to sleep;
paper to examine the effect of color and e's the rub;
size alone. Shakespeare's words should For in that sleep of death what dreams may come
not be edited to make them fit into a When we have shuffled off this mortal coil,
column. Must give us pause: there's the respect
that makes calamity of so long life;
Look how wimpy the pale blue looks by To be, or not to be: that is the question:
comparison to the example above. Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune.
Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
And by opposing, end them'? To die: to sleep;
No more; and by a sleep to say we end
the heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consummation
Devoutly to be wish'd. To die, to sleep;
Avoid the black-ink trap: never judge To be, or not to be: that is the question:
relationships that are intended to be Whether 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
seen in color by the way they appear in The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
black on white. Think ahead, and Or to take arms against a sea of troubles,
remember that you are working with And by opposing, end them'?' To die: to sleep;
variety in values, not just colors. When No more; and by a sleep to say we end
they are all shown in black, this variety the heart-ache and the thousand natural shocks
is not only not visible, but the effect is That flesh is heir to, 'tis a consummation
skewed; the heavy black appears Devoutly to be wish'd. To die, to sleep;
overwhelmingly strong. You must To sleep: perchance to dream: ay, there's the rub;
imagine it the way it will be, not the For in that sleep of death what dreams may come
way it looks here. This is why it is most When we have shuffled off this mortal coil.
unwise to show preliminary schemes to Must give us pause: there's the respect
anyone incapable of visualizing the thatmakes calamity of so long life;
final effect you are planning. (This rules For who would bear the whips and scorns of time,
out all bosses.) Play for time. Ask for The oppressor's wrong, the proud man's contumely,
patience. Only show the finished job. If The pangs of despised love, the law's delays.
you must present preliminaries for The insolence of office, and the spurns
approval, be sure they are very good, That patient merit of the unworthy takes.
very precise, and as close to the final as When he himself might his quietus make
fX)ssible. Don't ask them to imagine the With a bare bodkin'?Who would fardels bear.
intended effect. They probably can't. To grunt and sweat under a weary life,
But that the dread of something after death.
The undiscover'd country from whose bourn
No traveller returns, puzzles the will.
And makes us rather bear those ills we have
Than fly to others that we know not of?
Thus conscience does make cowards of us all;
The points where one segment ends and the next begins may not be
important enough to warrant starting a new chapter with its new title.
They may not even be strong enough to warrant the insertion of a
subhead. What is needed is an innocuous signal that says, "Yes,
here's a change in direction, so be aware of it, but don't pay too
much attention to it. Don't stop, continue reading, but realize that
you are now starting on something slightly different."
Arbitrary interruption of Major change in the Regular changes in the Minor changes can be
running text is useless course of thought is flow of thought are represented by initial
and resented signaled by a title shown by subheads letters
occur in pivotal places. (Or, rather, they should occur there, and only
there. They should not be inserted somewhere on the page just
because they make the composition look good. That would be a
misuse of a serious, purposeful signal.)
Nine nonsense verses from "Sylvie and Bruno" by Lewis Carroll are a
delightful opportunity to demonstrate how the same letter H can be
handled in different ways, even though the situations are identical.
*See Ian V. White, Graphic Design for the Electronic Age (New York: Xerox PressAA/atson-Cuptill
Publications, 1988), p. 107 et seq. and Alex White, How to Spec Type (New York: Watson-Cuptill,
1987).
K Le thought he saw an Elephant,
that practiced on a
he looked again, and found
fife:
it was
Heupon
thought he saw
chimney
the
he looked again, and found
a Buffalo
piece:
it was
a letter from his wife. his sister's husband's niece.
'At length I realize/ he said, 'Unless you leave this house,' he said,
'the bitterness of Life!' 'I'll send for the Police!'
Raised, upstanding, or stickup Cut-in two-line drop-cap
He
that
thought he saw a Kangaroo
worked a coffee-mill:
he looked again, and found it was
H le thought he saw a Coach-and-Four
that stood beside his bed:
he looked again, and found it was
a Vegetable-Pill. a Bear without a Head.
'Were I to swallow this.' he said, 'Poor thing,' he said, 'poor silly thing!
'I should be very ill!' It's waiting to be fed!'
He thought
L e he saw an Albatross
oiSM, thought he saw a Garden-Door
that flutteredround the lamp: that opened with a key:
he looked again, and found it was he looked again, and found it was
a Penny-Postage-Stamp. a Double Rule of Three:
'You'd best be getting home,' he said: 'And all its mystery,' he said,
'The nights are very damp!' 'is clear as day to me!'
Plain Fancy
ashamed. You'll look younger, too, because that is the ashamed. You'll too, because that is the
effect that happy exercise has on the human body. How effect happy exercise has on the human body. How does it
Won't be great to fit into all those great clothes again and
it great to fit into all those again and
be comfortable doing it? No more being stuck with the "fat doing it? No more being stuck with the "fat pants"
pants" for you every day. Your self-esteem will soar with the for you every day. Your self-esteem will soar with the results
results of this wonderful new breakthrough in diets. You'll of this wonderful new breakthrough in diets. You'll just love
just love the new yogurt-and-dill-pickle you. the new yogurt-and-dill-pickle you.
Running text with color used only for the title. Color might as Text identically worded, but the key words denoting the
well not be there, for all the good it does. benefits ennphasized with color. Better than the original
monotonous monochromatic version, but still hard to scan.
The visual salesmanship is not as hard-hitting as the verbal
salesmanship of the text.
The yogurt and dill pickle diet The yogurt and dill pickle diet
Picture a slimmer and more glamorous no more
you: Picture a slimmer and more glamorous you: no
embarrassment in public, when people stare (or you think more embarrassment in public, when people
they do). stare (or you think they do).
You'll weigh less because the caloric intake balances
You'll weigh less because the caloric intake balances the
the energy outflow in this scientifically nutritionally con-
energy outflow in this scientifically nutritionally
trolled diet plan.
controlled diet plan.
You'll feel better not only physically, but mentally too.
You'll feel better not only physically, but mentally too.
That's what your new self-esteem and achievement will do
for you.
That's what your new self-esteem and achieve-
You'll have more energy to do the things you've always ment will do for you.
The text has been edited slightly to allow the six key ijenefits Here the benefits have been made maximally visible in the
to be presented in parallel fornn. Each item starts a new margin at left, where the visual pattern supports their verbal
paragraph. Color helps the eye to find the items and ties them repetition. The benefits are tied to the headline by color as
to the headline by implication. well as placement. The benefits gush off the page.
Link words to pictures by a shared color.
When applied strategically^ the two individual elements combine
into a result greater than the sum of its parts.
superficial prettiness.
Mother's depressing
Color can be a series of beacons guiding the reader
into and through text. It can tie related elements together
so that their relationship is noticed at first glance.
It is much more difficult when the words are written first and page
makeup follows as a second step. Often such an analysis shows how
wise it would be to reorganize, simplify, and rewrite the information.
It encourages the development of thought patterns that can be
;um peon legum odioque civiuda. Et tamen in busdam :um peon legum odioque civiuda. Et tamen in busdam
rob pary minuit, potius inflammad ut coercend magist rob pary minuit, potius inflammad ut coercend magist
iste fact cond qui neg facile efficerd possit duo conetud iste fact cond qui neg facile efficerd possit duo conetud
;sim est ad quiet. Endium caritat praesert cum omning ;sim est ad quiet. Endium caritat praesert cum omning
i non est nihil enim desiderabile. Concupis plusque in i non est nihil enim desiderabile. Concupis plusque in
A provocative assertion sure to find favorable response among Running the title in color is the ordinary way of adding color
cat-lovers predisposed toward anything that agrees with their to an page. It only succeeds in making the page more
all-text
passion. In plain black, the burden of attraction, explanation, decorative. The color does not help to motivate the potential
implication, and emphasis rests on what the words say. reader to enter the text. Though the subheads clearly list the
rationale for the assertion in the title, they appear neutral and
inactive.
Cats: best pet bet Cats: better pets than
"um peon legum odioque civiuda. Et tamen in busdam icud quo in perseus, duos labor propter suam susciper
rob pary minuit, potius inflammad ut coercend magist n verbis adem inquite senten confirmavit anim ne aut
iste faa cond qui neg facile efficerd possit duo conetud de enim bon et malut puer utra dicabit, dysa stante an
;sim est ad quiet. Endium caritat praesert cum omning se concede mus si movent. Tamen dicitis nulla turnen
d non est nihil enim desiderabile. Concupis plusque in men argument hoc picurus a parvis petivit aut etiam a
:abil, sed quiran cunditat vel plurify afferat. Nam dilig gna aliquam erat voluptat. Ut enim ad minim veniam,
The title extends its tentacles down the entire page, because The cat words are in red, dog-words in blue.The differences
color ties it to the subheads. The color also arouses greater between them are in black. The way in which the writing is
curiosity than ordinary black would and therefore increases patterned encourages what is, in effect, simple tabulation of
the likelihood of the subheads being scanned. There, information. Such a list is easy to distinguish, fast to scan,
perhaps, a detail may arouse a potential reader's curiosity, and very easy to understand.
where the nnain headline might be passed over as
uninteresting. Thus the chances of pulling in readers are
increased.
Color can be used to advantage wherever highlightings
emphasizing^ or separating elements aid comprehension.
Color pinpoints what you want the viewer to notice.
Write comments in the Use highlighter to mark Circle significant words Lead arrows from one
margin. Print them in important passages. or phrases in the text in item to a related one.
blue, like the one Yellow is the expected "red crayon." Use light blue or pale
above. color, but pink, orange, green so that the text
or light blue are also covered by the color
believable. retains legibility.
Define change-revisions
The vertical bar commonly placed alongside change revisions that
replace obsolete or changed information in technical documents
stands out more effectively in color, because it is unexpected.
6. BLACK-
AND-WHITE
PICTURES
Adding color for meaning
or dramatic effect
Since this chapter is mostly concerned with halftones, a definition is
)n of
tone are
by
I
crossed
lines. The number of determines the fineness of the
lines per inch
dots: coarse reproduction, as in newspapers, requires fewer dots per
inch (sixty-five is usual) than normal magazine quality (133 or 150),
but higher resolution is demanded for fine offset reproduction (200 or
even 300). Clearly the finer the dots, the better the detail and tone
values of the reproduction.
Select the one element that ennbodies the reason for publishing: the
idea readers should care about, the one that they should carry away
and remember. Making such a definition — understanding the
rationale and defending that decision — is probably the hardest part of
BLACK-AND-WHITE PICTIJRFS
Bring out the implied
-
'^^S^
relationship of two
elements (here the little
boy wanting the flower)
by linking them with
color.
W^
-^%' 1» ll^^^ ^^^^^^^^^^^^1
^1 ^^^^^B' y^'^-.fs^^^^
^^^^^^i 1
^^^^^pTvA4 \\v\
^1^^
Kjl R
HH^
J^-^
^^^HB^St^F I^B^i'''^
pB 31^
^^i^Hcl^
^^^^s^^^^
1^
v^H
Expose the center of
by leaving color
interest
out.Here the tabletop is
dropped out (or
"knocked out") from the
40% cyan screen that
overprints the halftone
A simple black-and-
white original can be
used as original artwork
and treated as though it
were in color. The
resulting four-color
black-and-white
reproduction is far
richer than the ordinary
halftone
Blatk an.l - .
.
i
-omjii 20% cyan bcreen
The screens are called "line screens" because they are indeed a mesh
of lines through which the continuous-tone original is
rephotographed to be made into a halftone. The spaces between the
lines is what creates the printing dots. We define the fineness of. the
screen in terms of number of lines per inch.
Black mezzotint and Cyan mezzotint and Magenta and cyan mezzotint duotones
cyan mezzotint duotone yellow mezzotint duotone on 30% yellow screen panel
photographed as though it were line art (that is, only 100% black or
100% white, like a line drawing) then all the pale grays that are less
than 50% of black drop out or disappear, and all the grays that are
darker than 50% of black turn into solid black. The result is known as
a line conversion, and it can be extremely striking and decorative.
The black-and-white
original has been
converted into a four-
20%,
step posterization:
40%, 60%, and 80%
steps.
i^.if5^
BLACK-AND-WHITE PICTURES 153
Drawings lend themselves to embellishment with color
more effectively than any other visual elements.
But, as in all color use, there has to be a reason for using color.
In the black-and-white version, the doorway is there, but it is not interpreted as important.
Assuming that the doorway is intended to be the focal point, it needs to be made noticeable.
In the following example, color has been used in three distinct ways.
Each answers a different question:
n How constructed?
is it
defined by color. If the significance lies in its assembly, then clearly indicated in blue. But: The assembly of pipe units is
the presentation communicates well. But: If the significance ignored. The diagram tells a different story.
lies in the way in which the water flows through, then this
Weiss
M2 mw
Which version packs Reproducing full-color pictures is, obviously, more difficult than
more meaning? The reproducing monochromatic ones. The colors must be safeguarded
added cost of the full-
against exaggeration, though some degree of latitude must be
color version is more allowed. The effect of looking at a transparency (or chrome) is very
than recouped by the
different from the effect achieved in printing the same image on
added value of the
paper. One is much brighter than the other. Therefore sensible
information it transmits.
And it does this in
compromises must be made. To ensure credibility however, you must
addition to the visual demand the most faithful reproduction your technology can produce.
delight. You must also control the lighting conditions under which
comparisons are made.
Pure light comes from the sun. Colors look different in direct sunlight
from the way they do in indirect lighting. It is always better to
examine colors under a northern light, away from the direct sun.
Hues appear to change when they are seen under natural light,
fluorescent lights, incandescent light, or varying degrees of light
intensity. Darkness or shade make a difference. So does the
background. This is why it is wise to examine colors in an all-white,
all-black, or all-medium-gray environment.
Blue and green paints are best under daylight fluorescents, pinks and
tans under soft-white fluorescents,and reds and yellows under warm-
tone fluorescents.
Areas of color also affect the way that they look. A small swatch is a
very different entity from a wall's-worth. The value and chroma
appears to change as sizes change.
Time was when pictures in full color were a rarity. Their very
colorfulness was reason to stop, look, examine, and study. Now they
are so commonplace that this is no longer the case. You can no
longer depend on color pictures to give your product anything more
than pictures in color. (Unless you handle them with finesse.)
First, you must see what the pictures actually show. Train yourself to
see what the viewer is going to see. It is often different from what
you — —
knowing the reasons for using an image think you are
showing. Do not kid yourself that you will have a cheerful page just
because you have pictures of outdoor scenes. The sky isn't always
blue. Sometimes it lowers, misty and forbidding. Trees and meadows
aren't always lawn green. They can be parched, frozen, and in
shadow. Roads aren't always gravel driveways. They are usually gray,
patched, and embroidered with potholes.
This is not quite as cynical as it sounds. Though the optimist calls the
and the pessimist half-empty, the realist asks you why
glass half-full
you did not use a smaller glass to start with. A realistic attitude leads
us to examine possibilities in color pictures with a little more
subtlety. Here are a few such considerations.
element, let it speak for itself. Give it the room it deserves, and let it
stand by itself in space, so it can be seen unencumbered. And
whatever you do, do not "help it" with additional color. Leave it
alone. Don't ever dilute its impact by using competing color in the
surroundings. When you have good quality materials to work with,
less is more.
These tour photos share a sunnv, orant^e color This is the only characteristic
that a neatly stackedwoodpile in Switzerland has in comnnon with a detail of
Ayer'sRock in Australia, the entrance to Carmona castle in Spain, or a
gravestone in Salzburg, Austria. But they make a unit, do they not?
3t' „.^^
COLOR PHOTOGRAPHS
The couple under the
umbrella again stand
out from the crowd.
Here, they appear to
have been spotlighted
because the
surroundings have been
made darker.
^ -i.
Let good pictures stand alone. Protect them from corrosion. When
seen in the same context as a full-color picture, flat tints (or spot
color) tend to look somewhat common and cheap. Too often they
infect the picture with their own cheapness, unless the tints
themselves are used with discretion. This is indeed an area where
artistic taste plays an important part.
i)'j^/_'^-
'
^:
—
what you have in mind.) Specifying color choosing what you want
and then communicating it clearly —
is a tricky process. If color were
simple, it would be easy. But color is anything but simple, once you
get deeper than its simplest superficialities. It is not just complex in its
technical aspects or in the effects it creates. It is even more complex
in the way we talk about it and in the way we control it.
Though surrounded with color, we have not had color under control
until the nineteenth century. Before then, dyes and pigments were
limited to organic materials, many which were very rare and
of
therefore expensive. People wore clothes made of fabrics left in their
natural colors. Only the rich could afford dyed ones.
Then aniline dyes were discovered, shortly to be followed by the
coal-tar dyes, which were developed by Adolf von Baeyer in the
1860s. The first color he produced was purple, and the little snail.
Purpura Haemastoma, the marine gastropod of the eastern
Mediterranean who sacrificed its life to help kings look properly
kinglike, could now live a little longer. Then metallic oxides were
Most languages have few names for color.* Most colors other than
the basic color-named ones are named to associate with objects that
have that shade. Or they describe gradations of the original few
—
names light brown, dark purple, pinkish; and so forth.
Roget's International Thesaurus, fourth edition (1977), lists colors in
Whiteness: 30
Blackness: 20
Grayness: 45
Brownness: 104
Redness: 140
Orangeness: 45
Yellowness: 88
Greenness: 100
Blueness: 80
Purpleness: 44
696 words
Only a few of these many words are in general use. The number you
might determine as commonly understood probably depends on the
size of your own vocabulary and experience in the field of color. The
obscure rejects are highly specialized terms. Whatever the total, the
number of names still falls far short of the number of colors people
can distinguish. (Studies have determined that it is within human
capacity to distinguish 7.5 million different colors. Some
computerized crt equipment can produce 16 million.)
Color names other than the obvious basic ones are derivations from
other areas:
and so forth are flowers.
Violet, lilac, rose,
Cherry, orange, lemon, lime, chocolate, olive, and peach are foods.
Sapphire, turquoise, ruby, and emerald are stones.
Rust, terracotta, cobalt, silver, and gold are minerals.
Vermilion, crimson, and carmine are worms or insects.
Canary and cardinal are birds.
Salmon is a fish.
Purple is a shellfish.
Magenta, Delft, and Siena are places.
188 APPENDIX
What is puce, taupe, or beige? We
talk about charcoal, pink, parrot
green, myosotis blue, fuchsia, Caribbean blue. What are they?
Exactly. Nothing but personal interpretations. Toast is a color. Do you
like yours light, medium, or burned? They are inexact, variable, and
confusing. They are also deeply influenced by current fads and
fashions.
Even the basic terms defining groups of colors are imprecise and
vague. They are easier to describe than they are to define. For
instance:
Cool colors: Hues from the blue, green, and violet families; also pale
yellows, whites, and light pinks. They subdue.
Warm colors: Hues from the yellow, orange and red families; also
intense greens and violets. They excite.
Somber colors: Dark blue, dark green, dark purple, dark gray. They
depress. (Sombra means shadow in Spanish.)
T/nt5; Hues that result from adding white to a pure color. Tint
stepping means adding white to paints to produce paler versions.
Hues dulled by the addition of black, gray, white, or the
Tones.-
complementary color. Also known as neutralized hues. They are
quiet.
Pastels: Hues that result from adding white to a tone. They are pale,
cheerful, but a bit washed-out.
•Pantone, Inc.'s check standard trademark for color reproduction and color reproduction materials.
APPENDIX 18'
all,because you can go to any supply-shop and buy sheets of
colored paper (called Color-Aid) coordinated with its system. You can
use them as a frame of reference.
The Munsell system is based on five colors: red, yellow, green, blue,
purple.
shown with white at the head and black at the foot of the scale
forming the vertical axis of the Munsell Globe. Value is
determined by a photometer, which measures darkness in degrees.
-'J
The Munsell Globe, sometimes called the Munsell Tree, is shown here in
diagrammatic form. The value (from 1, black, to 9, white) forms the vertical
axis or trunk. Hues are arrayed as around the center. They go from yellow to
red, purple, blue, and green back to yellow. Their purest form is at level 5.
Above they become paler, below they become darker Chroma or saturation
is shown by steps leading out from the axis, with the minimum or gray at the
center and the brightest possible at the perimeter. Saturation varies not only
with each hue but also with each value step.
190 APPENDIX
The Pantone system
Pantone is a registered trademark for color reproduction materials.
The Pantone Matching System is a system of color standardization
developed originally for printers and designers, but now accepted
throughout industry and in computerized technology. It consists of
more than 533 colors, each numbered or named.
It is a precise and reliable method of selecting a color and
Note that the various Pantone products and systems are not generic,
and that they are protected by copyrights and registered trademarks.
They can be used to communicate color selection. Any reproduction
of a color accompanied by its identification intended for use in
corporate manuals or graphic color standards, however, should first
be checked out with their Trademark Control Department, 55
APPENDIX 191
Knickerbocker Road, Moonachie, N.]., 07074; telephone (201)
935-5500.
stand alone: yellow, red, blue, green, white, and black. All other
colors can be described by their degree of resemblance to two or
more of them. The theory, proposed by Ewald Hering of Germany in
the late nineteenth century has been developed by Anders Hard of
Sweden.
The Colour Atlas, index fans in chromatic order, paper samples, and
other materials are available from Edgebrite Ltd., 60 High Street,
Bridgnorth, Shropshire WV
164DX, Great Britain.
192 APPENDIX
The colorimeter measures the light energy and wavelengths reflected
by a sample. It defines the intensity of the light (luminance), its hue,
and its saturation. Combined, they produce a value of chromaticity.
The value of the ciE system lies in its permanence. Color samples, no
matter how produced and preserved, tend to fade over time.
carefully
The precise numbers, however, can be used as controls in the
cie
preparation of replacement swatches.
APPENDIX 193
create a shiny car may look very different from the dye a
steel to
clothwas dipped in or the ink used in printing on newsprint.
Matching them in four-color process inks is yet another compromise.
194 APPENDIX
GLOSSARY
Bit image Eight-bit: electronic image format representing each pixel as a
number from one to 256, each of which describes a value of gray or
a fixed value from a color palette.
Color Light waves reach the viewer's eye by transmission (through an object
between the source of light and the viewer) or by reflection (when
waves bounce off an object). All substances, whether transparent or
solid, absorb some wavelengths while letting others pass through or
bounce off. Green glass looks green because it absorbs all colors in
white light except green, which it allows to pass through. A purple
grape looks purple because it absorbs all colors in white light except
purple, which it reflects. White objects reflect all and black ones
absorb all light waves (at least in theory). There is no such thing as
perfect white or perfect black.
Color, additive When color is produced by colored lights, then mixing color affects
the total value (lightness or darkness). Combining colored lights
produces a lighter result, light is composed of all the
because white
colors of the spectrum. (See Primaries, additive and subtractive.)
Color, subtractive When color is produced by pigments, mixing colors produces darker
values.
Color bars Rectangles of color printed on color proofs to check the ink densities,
trapping,and other technical factors required to conform to quality
standards.
Color filter Dyed gelatin or plastic under glass, used to absorb certain colors and
improve others. Blue, green, and red filters are used in making color
separations.
The positive process: releases magenta, cyan, and yellow dyes in the
When developed, the light shining through the
film's three layers.
transparency recreates the original image.
Color proof Hard copy in color to check before the piece is printed.
Color separations A colored original transformed into four printable segments: the three
subtractive primaries (yellow, magenta, and cyan) and black. It is
done by photographing the original through filters or by means of an
electronic scanner. The four negatives are turned into positive
printing plates, which are superimposed on each other in the printing
process. The four colors combine and accumulate to create the
illusion of full color, similar to the original.
Color wheel Diagram of colors, originally created by bending Sir Isaac Newton's
spectrum into a circle. In desktop publishing, the color wheel
displays all available colors.
Colored paper Best color reproduction is provided by white paper of the right
surface smoothness. The white paper is the light source off which
waves are They pass through the inks, which are generally
reflected.
transparent. Colored paper affects the appearance of the color
printed on it, because it does not reflect the full spectrum of white
light but only parts of it (since other parts are absorbed by the paper
itself).
Expresslonistic colors Colors picked for emotional impact or meaning rather than for literal
description.
198 GLOSSARY
Hue/Luminance/Saturation. Also called hsb (Hue/Saturation/
Brightness). A means of characterizing a color in desktop publishing.
The equivalent of the traditional hue/value/chroma relationships.
The characteristic of a color that is distinguished by a name such as
red, blue, and so forth. The actual hue is created by a wavelength of
light.
Moire pattern Undesirable star or other patterns resulting from the superimposition
of dot-screens at wrong screen angles.
Neutralized colors Also called tones, these colors are hues dulled by the addition of
white, black, gray, or some of the complementary color pigment.
Pastel colors Colors resulting from white pigment being added to neutralized hues.
Primary colors The hues from which other colors can be mixed.
Primaries, additive Red, green, and blue are the three primary hues that form white light
when they are added together. Video display terminals represent
colors this way.
Primaries, subtractive The three ink colors (yellow, magenta, and cyan) used in process
color printing. Each primary is created by absorbing, that is
"subtracting," one of the additive primaries from white light.
Ramping, or gradation The illusion of a gradual change of one color to another, like the
effect of an airbrush, created in the software by a series of discrete
steps.
GLOSSARY 199
RGB Red/Green/Blue: the additive colors used by computers to display
colors.One hundred percent of all colors equals white light.
Saturation The purity of a color. Its brightness. Same as chroma.
Screens The eye thinks that a pattern of dots looks like a shade of gray. The
smaller the dots, the lighter the shade; the larger the dots, the darker
the shade perceived. They are produced by photographing the
original artwork (photograph or any continuous tone illustration)
through an actual screen of fine lines. The fineness of the screens can
vary from sixty-five lines to 1 50 lines or more per inch. Sixty-five- or
eighty-five-line screens are used for printing on newsprint. Better
paper can accommodate more detailed printing produced by finer
screens, which yield higher resolution.
Shade Color resulting from black pigment being added to a pure hue.
Spot color Also flat or matched color. Areas of solid color used on the printed
Style sheet Formatting table that assigns attributes to a graphic element, such as
stroke weight, color, and fill pattern in a drawing program.
Tint Color resulting from white pigment being added to a pure hue.
Undercolor removal (ucr) Increasing the quality of color reproduction by changing the balance
of inking. The amount of ink used to print yellow, magenta, and cyan
is decreased, while black is increased to produce a stronger image.
200 GLOSSARY
BIBLIOGRAPHY
For further reading you may find these works useful.
Alton Cook and Robert Fleury, Type and Color (Rockport, Mass.;
Rockport Publishers, 1989).
Jan V. White, Graphic Design for the Electronic Age (New York:
Xerox PressA^'atson-Guptill Publications, 1988).
Paul Zelanski and Mary Pat Fisher, Colour for Designers and Artists
(London: The Herbert Press, 1989).
INDEX
3
Whether you work in electronic or traditional media, this is your best source for the
creative, controlled use of color, benefiting the communications novice and the
seasoned professional alike.
I
GRAPHIC DESIGN ^^""^'^^l Graphic Design for the Electronic Age
FOR THE
ELECTRONIC 224 pages. 300 two-color illustrations.
AGE The
ISBN 0-8230-21 22-X. $24.95 (paper).
ISBN D-flS30-D73S-4
llllllllllli
90000