ch09 PDF
ch09 PDF
a. Homogenous products
b. Unrestricted mobility of resources
c. Economies of scale
d. Perfect information
Answer: C
Answer: A
Answer: A
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: The Assumptions of Perfect Competition
Learning Objective: Outline the conditions that characterize perfect competition.
4. Which of the following will reduce the competitive nature of the agricultural industry?
Answer: A
5. Resources are not free to move into and out of an industry when:
Answer: C
a. All the assumptions of a competitive model are satisfied in almost all real-world markets.
b. The efficient outcomes of competitive markets hold only in theory and not empirically.
c. Perfect competition is characterized by its impersonal nature.
d. The outcome of perfect competition is equitable.
Answer: C
Answer: C
Answer: B
Answer: B
10. Assume that coffee shops operate in a perfectly competitive industry. A single coffee shop,
Brick & Mortar, decides to charge an entrance fee in addition to charges for its coffee and pastry.
Which of the following is most likely to happen?
a. Brick & Mortar can continue to charge the entrance fee in the long-run since there is free entry
into the coffee shop industry.
b. As long as the coffee shop industry is perfectly competitive, customers will be willing to pay the
extra charges.
c. Brick & Mortar will not be able to sustain the extra charges as customers will move to coffee
shops that are cheaper.
d. Brick & Mortar can charge their customers extra because there are a large number of buyers and
sellers in the coffee shop industry.
Answer: C
11. According to the _____ principle, firms that do not approximate profit maximization will not
succeed in competitive markets.
a. equity
b. successor
c. survivor
d. winner-takes-all
Answer: C
Answer: D
Answer: D
Answer: D
Answer: C
Answer: A
Answer: B
18. A perfectly competitive firm faces a horizontal demand curve, which implies that:
Answer: B
Answer: B
20. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue for a firm when it prices its products
at $8 and $10.
Refer to Figure 9-1. At a price of $10, the profit maximizing level of output for the firm is _____.
a. OA
b. OC
c. OF
d. OG
Answer: D
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: Short-Run Profit Maximization
Learning Objective: Explain a competitive firm’s optimal output choice in the short run and how
the firm’s shortrun supply curve may be derived through this output selection.
21. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue for a firm when it prices its
products at $8 and $10.
Refer to Figure 9-1. When the firm is producing the profit-maximizing level of output at a price of
$10:
Answer: A
22. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue for a firm when it prices its
products at $8 and $10.
In Figure 9-1, if the market price fell to $8 the firm would:
Answer: B
23. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue curves for a firm.
Refer to Figure 9-2. At which of the following output levels is the firm incurring its highest loss?
a. 1 unit
b. 2 units
c. 3 units
d. 4 units
Answer: A
24. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue curves for a firm.
Refer to Figure 9-2. At which of the following levels of output is the firm maximizing profit?
a. 1 unit
b. 2 units
c. 3 units
d. 4 units
Answer: C
25. The following figure shows the total cost and total revenue curves for a firm.
Refer to Figure 9-2. The firm’s profits are positive:
Answer: C
a. the difference between price and average total cost is the largest.
b. the slope of the total revenue curve equals the slope of the total cost curve.
c. the average total cost equals marginal cost.
d. the marginal revenue exceeds marginal cost by the greatest amount.
Answer: B
27. The competitive firm maximizes its profit by operating at the point where _____ and price is
greater than average variable cost.
Answer: D
28. The perfectly competitive firm maximizes profits by producing at the rate of output where:
Answer: A
29. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
Refer to Figure 9-3. Assuming that price at 0R is $10, the profit maximizing level of output for the
firm is _____.
Answer: C
30. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
Refer to Figure 9-3. At the profit-maximizing level of output:
Answer: A
31. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
At the profit-maximizing level of output in Figure 9-3, the profit of the firm is equal to the area
given by _____.
a. RLMG
b. RGZW
c. RGCO
d. RGHS
Answer: B
32. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
At the output level of OC in Figure 9-3, average profit per unit of output is equal to _____.
a. GZ
b. MG
c. ZM
d. GC
Answer: A
33. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
In Figure 9-3, maximum profit per unit is equal to _____.
a. GZ
b. ZM
c. GM
d. FH
Answer: D
34. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
Refer to Figure 9-3. At the output level OB, total profits equal the area given by _____.
a. FTDE
b. GMLR
c. FHSR
d. FBOR
Answer: C
35. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
Refer to Figure 9-3. At the output level OC, average fixed cost is equal to _____.
a. ZM
b. GZ
c. GM
d. MC
Answer: A
36. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, average total cost curve, average variable
cost curve, and marginal revenue curve for a firm for different levels of output.
Refer to Figure 9-3. If the market price is $10, average revenue _____.
Answer: C
Answer: A
38. A profit-maximizing firm expands output until marginal revenue equals the _____ of
producing the last unit.
a. marginal cost
b. average variable cost
c. average total cost
d. average fixed cost
Answer: A
39. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. At a price of $P, the firm will produce the output level _____.
a. OA where marginal cost just covers AVC
b. OB where marginal cost equals the price
c. OC where marginal cost equals ATC
d. OD where the price just covers AVC
Answer: B
40. Figure 9-4 shows the marginal cost curve, average cost curve, average variable cost curve, and
demand curve for a firm over different levels of output and at a market price of $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. The firm’s average fixed cost at the output level OB is _____.
a. KT
b. GT
c. GB
d. GK
Answer: B
41. Figure 9-4 shows the marginal cost curve, average cost curve, average variable cost curve, and
demand curve for a firm over different levels of output and at a market price of $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. At the output level OB the total fixed cost is equal to _____.
a. TBOV
b. KTVP
c. GKPS
d. GTVS
Answer: D
42. Figure 9-4 shows the marginal cost curve, average cost curve, average variable cost curve, and
demand curve for a firm over different levels of output and at a market price of $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. The firm’s average variable cost at the output level OB is _____.
a. BG
b. GT
c. BT
d. BK
Answer: C
43. In the short-run, if a competitive firm finds itself operating at a loss, it will:
Answer: B
44. In the short-run, if the price falls, the firm will respond by:
Answer: C
45. If market price is below a competitive firm’s average total cost, the firm should:
a. shut down only if the price is above its average variable cost.
b. shut down immediately.
c. remain open as long as its average revenue is greater than its average variable cost.
d. expand output in the short-run and expand its production capacity.
Answer: C
46. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. Given that the market price is $P, the firm will be operating at a loss of _____.
a. TBOV
b. RZOA
c. KTVP
d. GKPS
Answer: D
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: Short-Run Profit Maximization
Learning Objective: Explain a competitive firm’s optimal output choice in the short run and how
the firm’s shortrun supply curve may be derived through this output selection.
47. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. If the firm chooses to shut down when the market price is $P, what is the loss it
would incur?
a. KTVP
b. GTVS
c. GKPS
d. TBOV
Answer: B
48. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. The total revenue for the firm at the output level OB is _____.
a. OVTB
b. OSGB
c. OPKB
d. GTVS
Answer: C
49. The short-run supply curve for the firm operating in a perfectly competitive industry is:
Answer: B
50. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. The firm should shut down if the price falls to _____.
a. OP
b. OR
c. OS
d. OV
Answer: B
51. The following figure shows the marginal cost curve, the average cost curve, the average
variable cost curve, and the demand curve for a firm over different levels of output. The market
price is $P.
Refer to Figure 9-4. The total variable cost for the firm at output level OB is _____.
a. BT
b. BKPO
c. BK
d. BTVO
Answer: D
Difficulty Level: Hard
52. The perfectly competitive firm minimizes losses by shutting down whenever:
Answer: D
Answer: B
54. Abe’s Taxi Company operates in a perfectly competitive market. Gasoline is a variable input in
the taxi services industry. As the price of gasoline decreases, the short-run marginal cost curve for
Abe’s Taxi Company:
Answer: B
55. During the 1970s, oil prices reached historical highs, causing many competitive industries to
reduce the supply of goods and services. Which of the following is the most likely explanation for
this reduction in supply?
a. The total fixed cost of the firms would have increased due to the higher price of oil.
b. The marginal cost curves of the firms most likely shifted upward.
c. The supply curves of firms may have shifted downward.
d. The average total cost of these firms mostly likely shifted downward due to the high inflation.
Answer: B
Answer: C
57. Assume that labor is the variable input for a firm. Which of the following will occur if the
wage rate increases?
a. Its average variable cost, average fixed cost, average total cost, and marginal costs will increase.
b. Its average variable cost and average total costs will increase and profits will decrease.
c. Its marginal cost, average total costs, and output will increase.
d. Its marginal cost and average variable costs will increase.
Answer: D
Answer: D
Answer: C
60. The short-run supply curve for a perfectly competitive industry is:
Answer: B
61. The short-run supply curve for a competitive industry is derived by summing the _____ for
each firm in the industry.
Answer: A
Answer: D
Answer: A
64. The short-run supply curve for a competitive industry is upward-sloping because:
a. firms must pay more for inputs as more are hired. /firms must incur higher costs the more inputs
they hire.
b. the efficiency of the variable inputs decreases as more such inputs are employed in production.
c. new firms enter the industry as product prices increase.
d. of the law of diminishing marginal utility.
Answer: B
66. Which of the following is a condition for long-run equilibrium in a competitive industry?
a. Each firm in the industry is earning zero economic profit.
b. The inputs employed in the industry earn less than they would had they been used elsewhere.
c. Each firm in the industry will produce that level of output at which marginal cost is the lowest.
d. The number of new entrants into the industry is positive.
Answer: A
67. At the profit maximizing level of output in a competitive industry, the firm is:
Answer: A
68. In the long-run, firms in a competitive industry earn only a normal rate of return because:
Answer: C
Answer: B
70. If price remains above the average total cost for firms in a competitive industry:
Answer: B
a. firms in that market can sustain prices above average total cost.
b. firms in that market can maintain market power.
c. economic profits are not sustainable.
d. accounting profits will be zero.
Answer: C
Answer: C
a. Along the industry’s long-run supply curve, firms in the industry earn a positive economic profit.
b. The long-run supply curve for a constant cost industry is horizontal.
c. The industry’s long-run supply curve is derived by horizontally summing the long-run supply
curves of the individual firms.
d. In the long run, the industry experiences an increase in the price of inputs.
Answer: B
74. In an increasing-cost industry, the slope of the long-run supply curve is _____.
a. zero
b. negative
c. positive
d. infinity
Answer: C
75. In a constant-cost industry, the slope of the long-run supply curve is _____.
a. zero
b. negative
c. positive
d. infinity
Answer: A
76. Suppose a constant-cost competitive industry produces widgets using labor and capital in fixed
proportions. A firm in the industry faces:
Answer: C
77. If a competitive industry is characterized by increasing cost, which of the following will occur
in response to an unexpected increase in demand?
78. In the long run, if the input procurement prices increase as the output supplied by firms in an
industry rises:
Answer: A
Answer: B
80. The slope of the long-run supply curve in a decreasing-cost industry is _____.
a. zero
b. negative
c. positive
d. infinite
Answer: B
81. Which of the following is constant along the industry long-run supply curve?
a. Technology
b. Number of firms
c. Input prices
d. Price of output
Answer: A
82. The demand for corn has increased over the past few decades to satisfy the increasing demand
from the food and ethanol industries. The primary beneficiaries of an expansion in the output of
corn are owners of farmland suitable for corn production. What can you conclude about the nature
of the corn industry?
Answer: B
Answer: C
Answer: A
85. Eggs, which are standardized products, are sold within a city at higher prices than in the
suburbs. Given that firms in the city are able to sustain the higher prices but do not make higher
profits than firms in the suburbs, this means that:
Answer: D
Answer: B
87. Assume a competitive industry produces widgets using labor and capital in fixed proportions.
Both input supply curves slope upward. The government considers the equilibrium price of widgets
to be too high and imposes a price ceiling that is below the equilibrium price. Which of the
following is most likely to occur?
a. The sales of widgets will increase and the prices and employment of both inputs will rise.
b. The sales of widgets will decline and the prices and employment of both inputs will remain
unchanged.
c. The sales of widgets will decline and the prices and employment of both inputs will fall.
d. The sales of widgets will increase and the prices and employment of both inputs will fall.
Answer: C
88.Consider a perfectly competitive firm facing the following conditions: TR = 150Q and
TC = 500 + 3Q + Q2. What is the firm’s profit maximizing output?
a. 50
b. 73.5
c. 87.5
d. 102
Answer: B
a. 50
b. 78
c. 103
d. 150
Answer: C
90. Consider a perfectly competitive firm facing the following conditions: TR = 150Q and
TC = 500 + 3Q + Q2. What is the firm’s marginal revenue when Q = 50?
a. 50
b. 78
c. 103
d. 150
Answer: D
91. Examine the following markets with respect to the assumptions of perfect competition. Explain
your answer.
Answer:
a) For a market to be considered perfectly competitive it needs to have large number of buyers and
sellers, free entry and exit, product homogeneity, and perfect information. Further, any individual
firm in the market should be a price taker.
1. Number of buyers and sellers: There are a large number of buyers and sellers in the dollar market
such as companies, institutional investors, brokers, hedge funds, traders, central banks, etc.
2. Entry and exit: There are hardly any barriers to entry in the dollar market.
3. Nature of the product: A dollar is standardized and does not vary across countries.
4. Information: Information on factors that drive the value of the dollar is easily available.
All the buyers and sellers in the dollar market are not always price takers; a very large buyer or
seller can influence the price of the dollar, although it would not be possible for a single seller or
buyer to sustain the price change for a long period of time.
b) Public utilities usually refer to water, electricity, public transport, and postal services.
1. Number of buyers and sellers: In most countries, public utilities are provided by a single seller,
usually the government. There are a large number of buyers of public utilities.
2. Entry and exit: There are significant barriers to entry in the public utilities market. High fixed
costs are a deterrent to new entrants. Also, some governments prohibit entry by law.
3. Nature of the product: The nature of public utilities like water and electricity provided to
different homes is the same.
4. Information: Information on the product is easily available to consumers.
Since there is usually only one seller, only buyers are price takers, not sellers.
c)1. Number of buyers and sellers: There are a small number of sellers in the newspaper market
with a large number of buyers.
2. Entry and exit: High fixed costs of printing presses and economies of scale present barriers to
entry in the print newspaper market. In the online newspaper market however, barriers to entry are
almost completely eliminated.
3. Nature of the product: Newspapers are not perfectly substitutable; they can be broadly divided
into tabloids, business newspapers, local dailies, etc.
4. Information: Buyers usually have perfect information about the prices of the various newspapers.
d) 1. Number of buyers and sellers: The healthcare market has a large number of buyers and sellers.
2. Entry and exit: Entry is restricted by high fixed costs like the investment required to set up a
hospital, the advanced educational qualifications required to work in the healthcare industry, etc.
3. Nature of the product: The product is not perfectly homogenous but is differentiated.
4. Information: Information about the product is asymmetric with healthcare providers possessing
more information than patients about the products and services that need to be provided.
e) 1. Number of buyers and sellers: The number of sellers is large. Although the brands of cereal
available are large, the number of sellers who own these brands are not many.
2. Entry and exit: Huge advertising budgets as well as the need for strong distribution networks
form barriers to entry in this industry.
3. Nature of the product: The product is highly differentiated.
4. Information: Consumers have perfect information about the product.
92. Suppose the total revenue (TR) and total cost (Tc. curves of a perfectly competitive firm are
given by the following set of equations: TR = 100Q and TC = Q2 + 4Q + 5, where Q is the output.
Derive the firm’s profit maximizing output and calculate the total and average profit earned by the
firm at this level of output.
Answer: Since TR = 100Q, marginal revenue [MR] and average revenue [AR] will both be equal to
100 at the profit maximizing level of output. Also, given that TC = Q2 + 4Q + 5, marginal cost
[MC] will be equal to (2Q + 4). We know that in a perfectly competitive market, profit is
maximized at the output where MR = MC. This implies, the profit maximizing output of the firm
will be derived as follows:
100 = 2Q + 4
or Q = (100 – 4)/2 = 48.
Substituting the value of Q in the TR and TC equations we get:
TR = 100 × 48 = 4,800.
TC = (48)2 + 4 × 48 + 5 = 2,501
Now total profit = TR – TC = 4,800 – 2,501 = 2,299 and average profit per unit = 2,299 ÷ 48 = 47.9
(approx.).
93. On the graphs below, demonstrate the circumstances that would prevail in a perfectly
competitive market where the representative firm is experiencing economic losses. Draw the
relevant cost curves (marginal, average total, and average variable costs; use U-shaped curves), the
marginal revenue curve, and the market supply and demand curves. Shade in the area of total
revenue and the area of economic loss. As you’ve drawn it, will the firm shut down in the short-run
or choose to continue production? Explain your answer.
Answer:
The loss and revenue are identified in the graph for the representative firm. The loss is the rectangle
ABP0F [ = (AR-ATc.q]. This is an economic loss because the AR (equal to P for a competitive
firm) is less than ATC. This price P0 is taken from the market. Note that MC intersects ATC and
AVC at the minimum of both the ATC and AVC curves. Recall the relationship between
“marginal” and “average”.
Total revenue = AR*q and this is shown by the rectangle P0Bq*O. Note that total cost (TC =
ATC*q) would be rectangle ABP0F plus rectangle P0Bq*O, hence this firm is experiencing
economic losses (which doesn’t mean they are making negative accounting profits; it means they
could be doing better in some other business).
This firm will continue production because P0 > AVC at the profit-maximizing level of output, q*.
They would be worse off by shutting down since they would lose their TFC which are greater than
the current economic losses (rectangle ABP0F). In P0 was AVC, then the firm would be better off
by shutting down (TFC would be less than economic losses).
b) Will Jack exit the industry in the long-run? Why or why not?
Answer:
a) Jack will exit the industry in the short-run if the price (P) is not above his average variable cost
(AVc.. TC = TVC + TFC $280 = TVC + $30 TVC = $250. Thus, AVC = TVC/Q = $250/10
lawns = $25 per lawn. So, P = $27 per lawn > AVC = $25 per lawn and Jack will not shut down in
the short-run.
b) In the long-run, assuming that market conditions remain the same (and there is not an increase in
the demand for mowed lawns for some reason), Jack will exit the industry if P < ATC, that is, if he
is earning negative economic profit.
ATC = TC/Q = $280/10 lawns = $28 per lawn > P = $27 per lawn, therefore Jack is earning
negative economic profit and will exit the lawnmowing business in the long-run, seeking to do
something else with his time and assets like opening a lemonade stand.
92. The long-run cost function faced by each producer in a perfectly competitive industry is given
by: MC(Q) = 20 - 6Q + Q2. The corresponding long-run average cost function is AC(Q) = 20 – 3Q
+ Q2/3. The market demand curve for the product is D(P) = 1100 – 50P.
a) What is the long-run equilibrium price in this industry? At this price, how much would an
individual firm produce?
Answer: In the long-run all firms earn zero economic profit. This implies price [P] = average cost
[AC], and each firm produces where P = MC. Thus,
20 – 6Q + Q2 = 20 – 3Q + Q2/3, solving which we get Q = 4.5. Substituting the value of Q in the
MC equation we get P = 20 – 6 × 4.5 + (4.5)2 = 13.25. This implies, at a price of 13.25, each firm
will produce 4.5 units.
95. Explain the difference between diminishing marginal returns to factor and a decreasing-cost
industry.
Answer: The upward slope of the short-run industry supply curve (the portion of the marginal cost
curve above the average variable cost curve) is due to diminishing marginal returns. Diminishing
marginal returns operates in the short-run when one input is fixed. It implies that as the
employment of an input is increased, the additional output that is produced with the help of the
additional input decreases.
A decreasing-cost industry is one where the long-run supply curve is downward sloping. This
means that output expands at a lower cost. Lower cost is due to the fall in input prices as more is
demanded.
96. Fair trade coffee is a movement designed to increase the price coffee growers in developing
countries receive for their output. Retailers such as supermarkets and coffee shops charge their
customers extra for either brewed coffee or coffee beans, promising to remit the additional charge
to coffee growers in developing countries.
a) Assuming entry costs for growing coffee are sufficiently low, which presumably they are,
explain why the fair trade coffee program is not likely to benefit the growers, notwithstanding
coffee retailers’ promises to do so.
b) Who would you predict benefits most from the fair trade subsidy that seeks to improve the living
standards of coffee growers?
Answer:
a) The fair trade coffee program acts as a subsidy to coffee growers, which creates economic profit
that would then be competed away. If barriers to entry are sufficiently low and firms in the
wholesale coffee market are price takers, both of which are true, then any residual paid to existing
coffee growers creates economic profit, which attracts new entrants into the market. The new
entrants then, drive down the existing price of coffee so that the new price plus the residual paid to
coffee growers by the retailers, either brewed or in bean form, equals the original price before the
fair trade program began paying the subsidy.
Suppose coffee beans are selling in the wholesale market without the subsidy for $3 per pound and
that a coffee retailer (i.e., a supermarket) sells the roasted and flavored beans for $10 per pound. In
order to boost the price received by coffee growers, retailers begin charging, say, and extra $2 per
pound under the fair trade program, promising their customers that they will remit the additional $2
per pound to the coffee growers in order to raise their standard of living. Coffee growers now
receive $5 per pound for their coffee beans on the wholesale market, $3 per pound for the coffee
and the $2 per pound fair trade subsidy.
This $2 per pound increase in the earnings of coffee growers around the world means that they now
earn economic profits – a residual payment greater than their opportunity costs of producing coffee.
This attracts new entrants (i.e., marginal growers and those in other markets earning less than the
coffee growers benefiting from the subsidy) seeking some of the economic windfall accruing to
coffee growers, whose additional output in the market drives down the wholesale price to $1 per
pound. That $1 per pound, plus the $2 fair trade subsidy, leaves coffee growers earning no more
than the original $3 per pound they were earning without the fair trade subsidy. And now that there
are more people producing more coffee, it’s likely that the wholesale price actually falls below $1
per pound, leaving the original coffee growers worse off with the fair trade subsidy than without.
b) The demand curve faced by wholesale coffee growers may indeed be highly, if not perfectly,
elastic, but that of the coffee retailers is probably not. This means that the wholesale price falls to
$1 per pound, as noted above, but the retail price of $12 per pound ($10 plus the $2 fair trade
subsidy) does not. In fact, it may serve to better price discriminate (to be discussed in Chapter 12),
thus being at least mostly internalized by the coffee retailers.
a) Assume that the gold-mining industry is perfectly competitive. On the diagrams below, illustrate
the long-run equilibrium in the overall gold market and for a representative gold mine. Draw the
industry supply and demand curves as well as the firm’s marginal cost curve. Indicate the
equilibrium prices and quantities in both markets (at the industry-level and at the firm-level).
b) Assume an increase in the demand for jewelry causes a surge in the demand for gold. Using
your diagrams, show what happens in the short-run to the gold market and to each existing gold
mine. Specifically, are individual firms earning positive, negative, or zero economic profits?
Indicate their profit on your graph.
c) If the demand for gold remains high, what would happen to the price over time? Specifically,
would the new long-run equilibrium price be above, below, or equal to the short-run equilibrium
price in part (b)? What causes this change in price, if any?
d) Would the new long-run equilibrium price be above, below, or equal to the original long-run
equilibrium price? That is, as you’ve drawn it, is the long-run supply curve in the gold industry
upward-sloping, horizontal, or downward-sloping? Explain why it would have this shape.
Answer:
a) The demand curve, D1, intersects the supply curve at industry quantity Q1 and market price is P1.
Since the industry is in long-run equilibrium, the price equals the minimum point on the
representative firm’s average total cost (ATc. curve, so the firm produces output q1 and makes zero
economic profit.
b) The increase in jewelry demand leads to an increase in the demand for gold, shifting the demand
curve to D2. In the short-run, the prices rises to P2, industry output rises to Q2, and the
representative firm’s output rises to q2. Since price now exceeds ATC, the representative firm now
earns positive economic profits equal to area P2abc.
c) Since gold mines are earning positive economic profits, over time other firms will enter the
industry. This will shift the supply curve to the right, reducing the price below P2. But it’s unlikely
that the price will fall all the way back to P1, since gold is in short supply.
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: Long-Run Competitive Equilibrium
Learning Objective: Define the conditions characterizing long-run competitive equilibrium.
Answer: Costs for new firms are likely to be higher than for older firms, since they’ll have to
discover new gold sources. Thus, the MC and ATC curves of the representative firm shift upward.
So it’s likely that the long-run supply curve in the gold industry is upward-sloping indicating that
this is an increasing-cost industry. That means the long-run equilibrium price, PLR, will be higher
than it was initially but less than the short-run equilibrium price (higher than P1 but less than P2).
98. Given below are the input supply curves for the housing and pencil industries, respectively.
Graphically illustrate the long-run supply curve for the two industries and comment on the nature
of the housing and pencil industries.
Answer: (1) The housing industry: In an increasing-cost competitive industry, increases in output
(in response to increased demand) bid up input prices. Therefore input supply curves are upward
sloping; as more houses are built the inputs that are used in housing are acquired at a higher cost.
The cost curves of the firms in the industry shift upward with increases in output.
(2) The pencil industry: In a constant-cost competitive industry, increases in output (in response to
increased demand) do not affect input prices. Therefore input supply curves are horizontal straight
lines; as more pencils are produced the wood, eraser, and graphite used to produce a pencil are
acquired at the same cost. This is because the demand for wood from the pencil industry is too
small to affect the price of wood. The cost curves of the firms in the industry do not shift with an
increase in output.
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: The Long-Run Industry Supply Curve
Learning Objective: Understand how the long-run industry supply curve describes the relationship
between price and industry output over the long run, taking into account how input prices may be
affected by an industry’s expansion/contraction.
99. Derive the first-order and second-order conditions for perfect competition.
Answer: The first-order condition for perfect competition is that price should equal marginal cost.
The total profit of the firm is the difference between total revenue and total cost.
Π=R–C
Total revenue is price times quantity; R = PQ. Substituting,
Π = PQ – C
The first-order condition for finding the profit-maximizing output requires that the first derivative
of the total profit function be equal to zero.
Q C
P – 0
Q Q Q
C
Given that equal marginal cost, P – MC 0
Q
R
Since price remains constant for a competitive firm, marginal revenue given by equals P.
Q
Therefore MR = MC.
The second-order condition for profit maximization requires that the second derivative of the total
profit function be negative:
2 2C
0 – 0
Q 2 Q 2
Difficulty Level: Medium
Section Reference: The Mathematics behind Perfect Competition
Learning Objective: Delineate the mathematics behind perfect competition.