Design of A High Efficiency Class F Power Amplifier With Large S - 2020 - Measur
Design of A High Efficiency Class F Power Amplifier With Large S - 2020 - Measur
Measurement
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/measurement
Design of a high efficiency class-F power amplifier with large signal and
small signal measurements
Saeed Roshani ⇑, Sobhan Roshani
Department of Electrical Engineering, Kermanshah Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kermanshah, Iran
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: In this paper, a modified class-F power amplifier is designed and implemented with new method at
Received 13 July 2018 900 MHz frequency. The meandered line compact microstrip resonant cell (MLCMRC), with simple
Received in revised form 20 August 2019 structure is proposed to use as a harmonic control circuit (HCC). The proposed MLCMRC correctly acts
Accepted 23 August 2019
as open-circuit at third and fifth harmonics and acts as short-circuit at second and fourth harmonics.
Available online 26 August 2019
In this design, the proposed PA is integrated with simple MLCMRC, while the large conventional matching
lines are omitted, which leads to harmonics suppression, size reduction, and PAE improvement at same
Keywords:
time. The proposed class-F power amplifier is characterized by small-signal and large-signal measure-
Class-F power amplifier
Harmonic suppression
ments to evaluate its performance. The maximum obtained gain for the proposed PA is 18.5 dB. Also, this
Microstrip meandered line design can obtain 74% PAE under 15 dBm input power, which shows 5% and 10% improvement in the
Efficiency maximum gain and PAE, respectively compared to the conventional class-F PA. Moreover, the applied
MLCMRC resulted in the 36% size reduction, compared to the same PA without MLCMRC.
Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.measurement.2019.106991
0263-2241/Ó 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
2 S. Roshani, S. Roshani / Measurement 149 (2020) 106991
In some recently works, resonators are used as transistor suppressed and the even harmonics will be passed which result
matching network [12–14], which results in size reduction and in in the prefect performance. In many other related works just 3rd
some cases PAE improvement. harmonic is suppressed, which results in the disturbed responses.
Microstrip resonators have several roles in microwave circuits.
Resonators creates transmission zeroes, eliminate harmonics, can 2.1. MLCMRC and harmonic control circuit design procedure
be used as sensors [15,16] and also can be used as harmonic con-
trol circuits at the output block of amplifiers. In this section the design procedure of the proposed meandered
In [7], a compact microstrip resonant cell (CMRC) is used in the line compact microstrip resonant cell (MLCMRC), which is used as
class-F PA as matching network and harmonic control circuit the HCC block, is introduced. These resonators are simulated using
(HCC). This method is interesting but only eliminates 3rd harmonic the advanced design system (ADS) software, based on RT/Duroid
and the obtained linearity is poor. In [17], two cascaded CMRC cells 5880 substrate (er = 2.2, H = 0.508 mm, tana = 0.0009).
are used as multi-harmonic control circuit (M-HCC) in class-F
amplifier structure to create dual-band power amplifier. In [18] 2.1.1. Primitive resonator
another type of CMRC circuit is implemented on the HBT amplifier The proposed power amplifier works at 900 MHz, therefore the
as harmonic control circuit in order to improve the PAE parameter. applied resonator which is used as the harmonic control circuit
But the applied CMRC cell in this work only suppresses one har- (HCC) should suppress third and fifth harmonics with correspond-
monic and efficiency parameter in this work is not good. In [19] ing frequency of 2.7 GHz and 4.5 GHz.
a high-efficiency class-F power amplifier (PA) integrated with The layout of the primitive resonator is depicted in Fig. 2(a).
cavity-microstrip filter is designed. This filter is used to realize out- This symmetric cell has three open stubs. In order to suppress
put impedance matching and suppress the third harmonic. The the nth harmonics, the length of the applied open stub must be
applied filter in this works is also only eliminates 3rd harmonic. equal to p/2n [21–23].
In [20] another type of CMRC circuit is inserted as harmonic control Since middle open stub (los1) is used to suppress the third har-
circuit and output matching network. The presented CMRC circuit monic, therefore the length of los1 is calculated as follows:
in this work suppresses 3rd and 5th harmonics and the obtained
p
power added efficiency (PAE) parameter in this design is 72.5%. los1 ¼ ð1Þ
In the proposed paper, a novel meandered line compact micro- 6
strip resonant cell (MLCMRC) is applied as harmonic control circuit With applied substrate and center frequency of 0.9 GHz, the
(HCC) block, in order to suppress desired harmonics and improve corresponding physical length of los1 is equal to 20.25 mm.
the efficiency of the basic class-F amplifier. The proposed PA cor- Since middle two symmetric open stubs (los2) are used to sup-
rectly works at 0.9 GHz and the proposed MLCMRC eliminates press the fifth harmonic, therefore the length of loss is calculated
3rd and 5th harmonics with high suppression levels. The proposed as follows:
method leads to compact class-F amplifier with high PAE, good lin- p
earity and high gain. los1 ¼ ð2Þ
10
With applied substrate and center frequency of 0.9 GHz, the
2. Circuit design corresponding physical length of los2 is equal to 12.15 mm.
The dimensions of the primitive resonator are listed as follows:
The structure of the simple class-F power amplifier is illustrated l1 = 1.5, los1 = 1.5, los2 = 1.5, W1 = 1.56, W2 = W4 = 0.5, W3 = 1,
in Fig. 1(a). The drain current and voltage waveforms for the ideal LT1 = 34.6 mm and WT1 = 17.5 mm (all in mm).
class-F power amplifier are demonstrated in Fig. 1(b). The drain The frequency response of primitive resonator is shown in the
voltage waveform of applied transistor includes the main fre- Fig. 2(b). As seen in this figure, the primitive resonator correctly
quency and the odd harmonics; therefore, drain waveform should suppresses the third and fifth harmonics, but this cell occupies
be square wave in the ideal Class-F. The drain current waveform large area of 34.6 mm 17.5 mm (0.14 k 0.07 k), which is
includes the fundamental and even harmonics, therefore, drain undesirable.
current in ideal class-F should be half-sinusoid.
In practice, the ideal situation will not exactly occur. But, by 2.1.2. Compact resonator
using the HCC block in the class-F PA, the odd harmonics will be The primitive resonator is designed in the previous section. This
cell works correctly, but occupies large area. Therefore, to reduce
the size of the primitive resonator, meandered lines are used
instead of the long open stubs with corresponding length of los1
and los2. The layout of the compact resonator is shown in the
Fig. 3(a).
The dimensions of the compact resonator are listed as follows:
l1 = 1.5, l2 = 1.5, l3 = 10.5, l4 = 4, l5 = 5.5, l6 = 4, W1 = 1.56, W2 = 0.5,
W3 = 1, W4 = 0.5, LT2 = 10.5 mm and WT2 = 17.5 mm (all in mm).
The frequency response of the compact resonator is shown in
the Fig. 3(b). The compact resonator correctly suppresses the third
and fifth harmonics and has small size, compared to the primitive
resonator. The overall size of the compact resonator is
10.5 mm 17.5 mm (0.0.04 k 0.07 k). This resonator is 70%
smaller than primitive one.
S 11
S_parameters (dB)
-20
S 21
-40
-60
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Freq(GHz)
(a) (b)
Fig. 2. (a) Layout and (b) frequency response of the primitive resonator.
0
S 11
S_parameters (dB)
-20
S 21
-40
-60
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
Freq(GHz)
(a) (b)
Fig. 3. (a) Layout and (b) frequency response of the compact resonator.
The layout of the proposed meandered line compact microstrip res- and pass the second harmonic, which occupies large area. In the
onant cell (MLCMRC) is shown in the Fig. 4(a) and its frequency proposed amplifier, the presented MLCMRC circuit is used as the
response is shown in the Fig. 4(b). This suppressing cell is simulated HCC block, to reduce the circuit size and improve the harmonics
using the advanced design system (ADS) software, based on RT/Dur- control blocks, which will be described in the next section.
oid 5880 substrate (er = 2.2, H = 0.508 mm, tana = 0.0009). The
dimensions of the presented MLCMRC are listed as follows:
l1 = 1.5, l2 = 1.5, l3 = 10.5, l4 = 4, l5 = 5.5, l6 = 4, W1 = 1.56, W2 = 0.5, 3. Proposed Class-F PA integrated with MLCMRC
W3 = 1 and W4 = 0.5 (all in mm).
The overall size of the MLCMRC is 8.3 mm 13.5 mm (0.03 The schematic block diagram of the proposed 900 MHz class-F
k 0.05 k). The proposed resonator is 82% smaller than primitive amplifier integrated with MLCMRC is illustrated in Fig. 6. In this
resonator. design, the proposed MLCMRC is used as HCC and output matching
As seen in the Fig. 4(b), frequency response of the proposed network. The applied MLCMRC suppresses the 3rd and 5th har-
MLCMRC shows that the proposed suppressing cell has two trans- monics and passes the 2nd and 4th harmonics, which results in
mission zeros at 2.7 GHz and 4.5 GHz, with high levels of attenua- the good performance. Two tunable stubs with proper lengths
tion. This response is very good for the final class-F PA, which are applied to both sides of the proposed MLCMRC for compensat-
works at 0.9 GHz. The proposed MLCMRC suppresses the 3rd and ing the transistor parasitic capacitances. As a result, the MLCMRC
5th harmonics of PA and passes the second and 4th harmonics cor- and two tunable stubs can effectively operate as a harmonic con-
rectly, which results in the good PA performances. trol circuit.
The layouts of the conventional and proposed class-F power
2.2. Basic class-F power amplifier amplifiers are shown in Fig. 7. The proposed circuit has small size
of 55.6 mm 64.1 mm (0.26 k 0.22 k), which features 36% size
The structure of the basic 900 MHz class-F power amplifier is reduction, compared to the simple structure.
illustrated in Fig. 5. In the power amplifier design, a low-voltage The drain waveforms of the proposed class-F PA are depicted in
pHEMT ATF-34143 transistor is used. The applied DC bias voltages Fig. 8. The proposed amplifier must suppresses 3rd and 5th har-
of the pHEMT ATF-34143 transistor is Vg = -0.75 V and Vd = 5 V. In monics and pass the 2nd and 4th harmonics, so the current and
the basic power amplifier, only open-ended stubs are used in both voltage waveforms are approximately half sine and square, respec-
of the output and input matching networks. Unfortunately, the tively, which shows more similarity to the ideal waveforms, com-
HCC in the basic design can only suppress the third harmonic pared to the other reported works.
4 S. Roshani, S. Roshani / Measurement 149 (2020) 106991
Fig. 6. The schematic diagram of the proposed 900 MHz class-F amplifier integrated with MLCMRC.
Fig. 7. The layouts of the (a) conventional and (b) proposed 900 MHz class-F amplifiers.
10.0 560
520
480
8.0
440
Drain current (mA)
400
Drain Voltage (V)
6.0 360
320
280
4.0
240
200
2.0 160
120
80
0.0 40
0
2 3 4
Time(ns)
Fig. 8. The drain waveforms of the proposed class-F amplifier.
6 S. Roshani, S. Roshani / Measurement 149 (2020) 106991
80
70
60
50
PAE(%)
40
30
20
with MLCMRC (Mea.)
with MLCMRC (Sim.)
10 without MLCMRC (Sim.)
Fig. 12. PAE parameter of the class-F amplifier with (proposed) and without (basic)
20
S 21 resonator.
S 11 80 80
S_parameters (dB)
0.0
-10 S 22 70 70
Efficency
60 60
-30 GSM-900
Freq. Band 50 50
GSM-900
0.9 GHz
G 40 40
-50 Simulated Freq. Band
Pout
8.8 GHz 9.15 GHz Measured 30 30
-70 20 20
8.8 GHz 9.15 GHz
0 1 2 3 4 5
10 10
Freq(GHz) 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1
Freq(GHz)
Fig. 10. Simulated and measured S-parameters of the proposed PA.
Fig. 13. Drain efficiency and output power of the proposed class-F amplifier.
40
2
Pout
K = 1.63
30
1.5
Pout(dBm) & Gain (dB)
Gain
K-Δ
20
1
0.0 0
0.5 0.9 1.0 1.5 2.0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Pin (dBm)
Freq(GHz)
Fig. 14. Gain and output power parameters of the class-F PA with (proposed) and
Fig. 11. Stability k -4 test for the proposed class-F amplifier. without resonator (basic).
S. Roshani, S. Roshani / Measurement 149 (2020) 106991 7
Table 1
The performances improvement in the proposed class-F PA.
Table 2
The performance comparison of the proposed class-F PA with similar works.
Ref. Class Freq. PAE (%) Gain (dB) P-1 dB Size reduction
[7] F 2.4 GHz 74% 11 dB 19 dBm 32%
[18] F 1.95 GHz 48% 13 dB 27 dBm N.A.
[19] F 2.4 GHz 70.9% 17 dB 35 dBm N.A.
[20] F 1.8 GHz 72.5% 18.2 dB 37 dBm N.A.
[11] F 1 GHz 64% 12 dB 21 dBm –
[26] F 2.4 GHz 59% N.A. 23 dBm –
[27] F 2 GHz 70.5% N.A. 19 dBm –
[28] F 5.5 GHz 70% 13.7 dB 27 dBm –
[29] F1 9.6 GHz 54% 10 dB N.A. –
This work F 0.9 GHz 74% 18.5 dB 29 dBm 36%
In the linear applications of the proposed PA, the PAE value is the conventional output matching lines with large size are omitted,
about 66% under 10 dBm input power. which leads to the size reduction, harmonics suppression and PAE
Fig. 13, shows the output power and drain efficiency of the pro- improvement at same time. The proposed MLCMRC is applied as
posed power amplifier versus frequency under a constant input harmonic control circuit block which suppresses the 3rd and 5th
power of 15 dBm. As shown in Fig. 13, the output power is higher harmonics with high attenuation level. The proposed PA has high
than 29 dBm at the frequency of the 0.9 GHz. The drain efficiency is linearity (P1dB = 29 dBm), high maximum gain of 18.5 dB and high
75% at the operating frequency. The GSM frequency band is shaded PAE of 74% PAE under 15 dBm input power. Moreover, the applied
in Fig. 13. As seen in Fig. 13, the results show that, the proposed MLCMRC resulted in the 36% size reduction, compared to the same
amplifier correctly works in GSM standard at the whole frequency PA without MLCMRC. The small-signal and large-signal measure-
range of 880–915 MHz with more than 70% drain efficiency and ment results of class-F PA are in good agreement with the simula-
more than 27 dBm output power. tion results, which confirms the validity of the proposed design.
The measured and simulated results of the output power and
gain parameters of the fabricated class-F amplifier are depicted Declaration of Competing Interest
in Fig. 14. The output power for the basic class-F power amplifier
without resonator is 28.9 dBm at 15 dBm input power, and the The authors declare that they have no known competing finan-
measured gain for this basic PA is 13.9 dB. For the proposed cial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared
class-F PA with MLCMRC the measured output power is to influence the work reported in this paper.
29.2 dBm at 15 dBm input power, and the corresponding measured
gain is 14.2 dB. Moreover, the maximum obtained gain for the con- Acknowledgments
ventional class-F amplifier without resonator is 17.5 dB and for the
proposed class-F PA with MLCMRC is 18.5 dB, which shows 5% The authors would like to thank the Kermanshah Branch, Isla-
improvement, compared to the conventional PA. The 1 dB com- mic Azad University for the financial support of this research
pression point (P1dB) for the simple class-F PA without MLCMRC project.
is about 28 dBm and for the proposed class-F PA with MLCMRC is
29 dBm, which 1 dB improvement is achieved. References
The performance improvement in the presented class-F PA is
listed in Table 1. As seen in this table, the proposed PA has 10% [1] P. Colantonio, F. Giannini, E. Limiti, High Efficiency RF and Microwave Solid
PAE improvement and also 5% improvement in the maximum gain, State Power Amplifiers, John Wiley & Sons, 2009 Jul 8.
[2] F.H. Raab, An introduction to class-F power amplifiers, RF Des. 19 (5) (1996)
compared to the simple class-F PA. Also, 36% size reduction is 79–84.
obtained by using MLCMRC. [3] T. Suetsugu, M.K. Kazimierczuk, Maximum operating frequency of class-E
A performance comparison between proposed amplifier and amplifier at any duty ratio, IEEE Trans. Circuits Syst. II Express Briefs 55 (8)
(2008 Aug) 768–770.
some other similar works in class-F and inverse F are summarized [4] N.O. Sokal, Class-E RF power amplifiers, QEX 2 (204) (2001 Jan) 9–20.
in Table 2. As seen, based on the given parameters in Table 2, the [5] M. Hayati, S. Roshani, M.K. Kazimierczuk, H. Sekiya, A class-E power amplifier
proposed PA has very good performance, compared to the related design considering MOSFET nonlinear drain-to-source and nonlinear gate-to-
drain capacitances at any grading coefficient, IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 31
works. The proposed PA not only has the smallest size among the (11) (2016 Nov) 7770–7779.
reported works, but also has the best PAE and gain compared to [6] M. Hayati, S. Roshani, S. Roshani, M.K. Kazimierczuk, H. Sekiya, Design of class
them. According to P-1 dB parameter of the proposed PA, which E power amplifier with new structure and flat top switch voltage waveform,
IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 33 (3) (2018 Mar) 2571–2579.
is about 29 dBm, it can be seen that the proposed PA has a better [7] S. Chen, Q. Xue, A class-F power amplifier with CMRC, IEEE Microwave
linearity, compared to the reported works in the Table 2. Wireless Comp. Lett. 21 (1) (2011 Jan) 31–33.
[8] P. Colantonio, F. Giannini, G. Leuzzi, E. Limiti, On the class-F power amplifier
design, Int. J. RF Microwave Comput. Aided Eng.. 9 (2) (1999 Mar 1) 129–149.
5. Conclusion [9] F.H. Raab, Class-F power amplifiers with maximally flat waveforms, IEEE Trans.
Microwave Theory Tech. 45 (11) (1997 Nov) 2007–2012.
In this work, an optimized class-F PA structure with efficiency [10] R. Negra, F.M. Ghannouchi, W. Bachtold, Study and design optimization of
multi harmonic transmission-line load networks for class-E and class-F K-
improvement at 0.9 GHz is designed and implemented. In this band MMIC power amplifiers, IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech. 55 (6) (2007
design, the modified PA is integrated with simple MLCMRC while Jun) 1390–1397.
8 S. Roshani, S. Roshani / Measurement 149 (2020) 106991
[11] Y.Y. Woo, Y. Yang, B. Kim, Analysis and experiments for high-efficiency class-F [21] K.K. Cheng, C. Law, A novel approach to the design and implementation of
and inverse class-F power amplifiers, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theor. Tech. 54 dual-band power divider, IEEE Trans. Microwave Theor. Tech. 56 (2) (2008
(5) (2006 May) 1969–1974. Feb) 487–492.
[12] Y.C. Li, K.C. Wu, Q. Xue, Power amplifier integrated with bandpass filter for [22] S. Roshani, A Wilkinson power divider with harmonics suppression and size
long term evolution application, IEEE Microwave Wireless Comp. Lett. 23 (8) reduction using meandered compact microstrip resonating cells, Frequency 71
(2013 Aug) 424–426. (11–12) (2017 Oct 26) 517–522.
[13] S. Roshani, M. Hayati, S. Setayeshi, S. Roshani, G. Mohamadpour, A [23] M. Hayati, S. Roshani, S. Roshani, F. Shama, A novel miniaturized Wilkinson
miniaturized harmonic suppressed power amplifier integrated with lowpass power divider with n th harmonic suppression, J. Electromag. Waves Appl. 27
filter for long term evolution application, Analog Integr. Circ. Sig. Process 89 (6) (2013 Apr 1) 726–735.
(1) (2016 Oct 1) 197–204. [24] K. Fu, C.L. Law, T.T. Thein, Test bed for power amplifier behavioral
[14] M. Hayati, S. Roshani, A novel miniaturized power amplifier with nth characterization and modeling, Measurement 46 (8) (2013 Oct 1) 2735–2745.
harmonic suppression, AEU-Int. J. Elect. Commun. 68 (10) (2014 Oct 1) [25] M. Alizadeh, D. Rönnow, A two-tone test for characterizing nonlinear dynamic
1016–1021. effects of radio frequency amplifiers in different amplitude regions,
[15] Y.L. Then, K.Y. You, M.N. Dimon, C.Y. Lee, A modified microstrip ring resonator Measurement 1 (89) (2016 Jul) 273–279.
sensor with lumped element modeling for soil moisture and dielectric [26] A. Dupuy, K.M. Leong, T. Itoh, Class-F power amplifier using a multi-frequency
predictions measurement, Measurement 1 (94) (2016 Dec) 119–125. composite right/left-handed transmission line harmonic tuner, in: Microwave
[16] S. Majidifar, G. Karimi, New approach for dielectric constant detection using a Symposium Digest, 2005 IEEE MTT-S International 2005 Jun 12, IEEE, p. 4.
microstrip sensor, Measurement 1 (93) (2016 Nov) 310–314. [27] M. Wren, T.J. Brazil, Experimental class-F power amplifier design using
[17] S. Chen, Q. Xue, Highly efficient dual-band power amplifier based on cascaded computationally efficient and accurate large-signal pHEMT model, IEEE Trans.
CMRCs, in: 2012 Asia Pacific Microwave Conference Proceedings 2012 Dec 4, Microwave Theor. Tech. 53 (5) (2005 May) 1723–1731.
IEEE, pp. 367–369. [28] G. Nikandish, E. Babakrpur, A. Medi, A harmonic termination technique for
[18] C.K. Poek, B.P. Yan, E.S. Yang, InGaP/GaAs HBT power amplifier with CMRC single-and multi-band high-efficiency class-F MMIC power amplifiers, IEEE
structure, Microwave Opt. Technol. Lett. 46 (1) (2005 Jul 5) 84–88. Trans. Microwave Theor. Tech. 62 (5) (2014 May) 1212–1220.
[19] Q.Y. Guo, X.Y. Zhang, J.X. Xu, Y.C. Li, Q. Xue, Bandpass class-F power amplifier [29] E. Cipriani, P. Colantonio, F. Giannini, R. Giofrè, Effects of gate bias voltage and
based on multifunction hybrid cavity–microstrip filter, IEEE Trans. Circuits compression level on a X-band MMIC class F1 PA, in: Microwave Integrated
Syst. II Express Briefs 64 (7) (2016 Aug 16) 742–746. Circuits Conference (EuMIC), 2011 European 2011, IEEE, Oct 10, pp. 546–549.
[20] A. Pirasteh, S. Roshani, S. Roshani, A modified class-F power amplifier with
miniaturized harmonic control circuit, AEU-Int. J. Elect. Commun. 1 (97) (2018
Dec) 202–209.