Glocalization in Food Business: Strategies of Adaptation To Local Needs and Demands Dr. Ajai Prakash1 Dr. V - B. Singh2
Glocalization in Food Business: Strategies of Adaptation To Local Needs and Demands Dr. Ajai Prakash1 Dr. V - B. Singh2
ABSTRACT
Food industry, the world over, is witnessing unprecedented increase in the number of
multinational enterprises. These multinational enterprises, when deciding to expand their
operations to a new country, have to make a choice between following uniform business
strategies as in their home country or modify their strategies to suit the host country socio-
economic and political environment. Given the economic cost of modification of business
strategies, the choice has widespread implications for the sustainability of multinational
enterprises. The present paper argues that this decision-making is particularly critical in the
case of multinational food enterprises because of large scale variability in food habits across
countries and even within a country. Drawing from case studies of three multinational food
enterprises in India, the paper points out that, in order to operate successfully in their host
countries, the multinational food enterprises must adopt Glocalized strategies in marketing,
product development, advertisement etc.
I.0 INTRODUCTION
Attracted by mere size and growth potential of emerging economies’ food sector, a number
of multinational food enterprises (MNFEs) have entered or are in the process of entering
these markets either through FDI or joint ventures. Strategic alliances between local food
enterprises and multinational food companies have also increased manifold in the recent past.
This increasing globalization process has altered the international competitive dynamics in
the food industry. The dynamism in competitive global markets calls for fundamentally
different vision and strategic thinking in the food companies.
In their host countries, the multinational enterprises have the option of choosing two
fundamental strategies of marketing their products and services: globalized strategies or
localized strategies. Globalized strategies or globalization involves developing marketing
strategies as though the world is a single entity. This means marketing of standardized
products using standardized marketing mix in the same way everywhere. Organizations
employ the standard products, promotional campaigns, prices and distribution channels
across all markets considering the world to be a single market. Localized strategies or
localization, on the other hand, involves marketing strategies for a specific region according
to its cultural, regional and national uniqueness. However, some multinational enterprises
apply hybrid strategies, commonly referred to as Glocalization. This group of strategies
combines the globalization and localization strategies by emphasizing on the fact that
globalization of a product will succeed when the product or service is adapted specifically to
that region.
In this paper, based on learning from three cases of MNFEs in India, we argue that in the
food industry, the multinational enterprises can be successful in their host countries, only if
they adopt glocal strategies of marketing mix. This is because food habits develop very early
in life and these vary significantly across cultures. The MNFEs need to understand the
unique food needs of their consumers and serve the global market accordingly.
We elaborate the concept of glocalization in the next section. In section 3, we present why
Lucknow has taken as peripheral area adopting localization. Section 4 elaborates some food
chains in Lucknow. Section 5 discusses about key learning from these cases followed by
concluding remarks in section 6 along with comparative food chains in section 7.
According to the dictionary meaning, the term “glocal” and the process noun “glocalization”
are “formed by telescoping global and local to make a blend” (The Oxford Dictionary of New
Words, 1991 quoted in Robertson, 1995). The term was modeled on Japanese word
dochakuka, which originally meant adapting farming technique to one’s own local condition.
In the business world the idea was adopted to refer to global localization. The word as well as
the idea came from Japan (Robertson, 1995). According to the sociologist Roland Robertson,
glocalization describes the tampering effects of local conditions on global pressures. At a
1997 conference on "Globalization and Indigenous Culture," Robertson said that the term
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
Glocalization is important in all types of businesses from automobiles to comic books and
from mass merchandisers to fast food restaurants. Comics on Spiderman were launched in
India by modifying the original version to suit the Indian markets. The real life name has
been changed from Peter Parker to Pavitra Prabhakar; he wears a loincloth worn by Hindu
men in India. The other aspects of the comic book have also been modified (The Hindu,
2004). These modifications help consumers in the host country relate with the character in a
much better and effective way. Similarly a recent Indian movie “KRISH” portrayed a
superhero, which can be considered a glocalized version of Batman or Superman. In
Germany, Ayurveda style of medication has been glocalized and has been successfully
implemented by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Group. He has softened the harsh Indian purgation
therapy and concentrated on nutrition advices, on massages and oil applications (Stollberg,
2005). Cultural differences affect efficient working of digital networking environment and
several localized communities are formed. These communities are being managed with the
help of glocalized strategies to facilitate the working of the digital environment (Boyd,
2006).
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
The concept of glocalization is particularly important to the food industry because of the
seamless challenges this industry faces due to the typical differences that exist in the food
habits of people belonging to various regions/religions/cultures across the globe. There are
numerous examples of companies doing extremely well in their local markets, but when they
go global, these fail completely. One of the reasons that can be cited is not adhering to the
challenges put forward by cultural and regional differences. Like some animals are
considered sacred in one region and are consumed heavily in some others. Availability of
fruits, vegetables, food grains and other resources is also a hindrance in the globalization
process of the food companies.
Glocalization is seen in the communication aspect of marketing strategy as well, like Coca-
Cola airing different advertisements in India with actor Amir Khan in different characters,
i.e. Hyderabadi, Punjabi, Lucknowi, and Bombay-Bhai and as a Gorkha as well.
Glocalization is indeed the most important concept that is being taken up by the MNFEs. In
fact, the success of any food firm, to a large extent, is determined by the trust that it is able to
gain from the residents of a region.
On the basis of the research objectives, the executives, hoteliers, front officer manager, hotel
or restaurant manager, food beverage manager, chefs from hotels, resorts, guest houses and
restaurant services based in Lucknow were surveyed and interviewed.
III.1 Why Lucknow and peripheral area has been taken for the Study?
Few places in the world are endowed with such rich cultural traditions as this normative city
of Nawabs. Whether it is history, architecture, music, dance, handicrafts, etiquette or sports,
Lucknow has its own story to tell.
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
Occupancy level in Lucknow increased marginally by 0.6% in 2004-05 and rate increases by
10% over the previous year. Lucknow has a very stable market and is witnessing a rise in
average occupancy rate for the last two years. Lately, Lucknow has also seen increased retail
activity (Express Hospitality 2006).
IV.1.1OFFERING
A brand is an offering from a known source. McDonald’s carries many associations in the
minds of people. Hamburger, fun, children, fast food, Golden Arches. These associations
make up the brand image.
• Teenagers’ visit McDonald’s as the menu is affordable, and there is internet access in
some restaurants.
• These examples represent just a few of McDonald's possible customer profiles. Each
has different reasons for coming to McDonald's.
Threats
• Nutritional issues. People are becoming more aware of the quality of the food they
eat, and more people are looking for "organic", natural and vegetarian alternatives.
• Obesity Fast food is continually blamed for obesity in children and adults.
• A lengthy recession could hurt fast food chains when pricier chains begin to offer
competitively priced menus with the perception of better quality.
• They also focus on the Quick Service Restaurant Sector. This includes all the obvious
competition and also fish and sandwich shops-any other outlet where food is served quickly.
• The final sector that they focus on is defined as the Burger House Sector. This looks
only at restaurants serving hamburgers including Burger King, Wimpy, Wendy’s and all
independent Burger bars.
They have re-formulated some of their products using spices favored by Lucknowites.
Among these are McVeggie burger, McAloo Tikki Burger, Veg Pizza, McPuff and Chicken
McGrill. Vegetarian products are prepared separately, using dedicated equipment and
utensils. Employees in the vegetarian and non vegetarian sections of the restaurants can be
identified by the different colored aprons that they wear.
IV.2.6.2PRICE:
McDonalds vegetarian burgers are priced from Rs 20 to Rs 48. Wrap paneer salsa is priced at
Rs 45-50.There were many advertisements made by McDonald’s emphasizing on the
schemes, the prices and various other aspects. Some of them were:
The ‘Itch Karo’ Schemes: This advertisement was to promote the scheme of Mc Donald’s
where in you could win prizes right from a small Cadbury to a television or a bike.
Soft Serve Cone: There were many advertisements focusing on the RS.7 soft serve cone.
One of them was of a traffic policeman who gets tired of directing the customers to the Mc
Donald’s outlet.
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
Happy Meal: There are various advertisements relayed during children programmes on the
television and also children channels emphasizing on the happy meals and the toys one get
with them.
IV.2.6.3PROMOTION
At Mc Donald’s the prime focus is on targeting children. In happy meals too which are
targeted at children small toys are given along with the meal. Apart from this, various
schemes for winning prices like the lucky draws and also scratch cards are given when an
order is placed on the various meal combos.
IV.2.6.4PLACE
Mc Donald’s outlets are very evenly spread throughout the Lucknow region. Mc Donald’s
does not offer home delivery but its outlets are very readily accessible. Mc Donald’s also
offers take away drive through facilities.
IV.2.6.5PEOPLE
The employees in McDonalds have a standard uniform and McDonalds specially focuses on
friendly and prompt service to its customers from their employees.
IV.2.6.6PROCESS
The food manufacturing process at Mc Donalds is completely transparent i.e. the whole
process is visible to the customers. In fact, the fast food joint allows its customers to view
and judge the hygienic standards at Mc Donalds by allowing them to enter the area where the
process takes place.
IV.2.6.7PHYSICAL EVIDENCE
McDonalds focuses on clean and hygienic interiors of is outlets and at the same time the
interiors are attractive and the fast food joint maintains a proper decorum at its joints.
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
McDonald’s world class training inputs have been implanted in India. Training is a
continuous process at McDonalds. The training squad maintains logs of the employees,
which clearly states that which employees are to be trained, and on what station.
The 3/30 Plan: According to this plan, the training squad has to train 3 people on three
different stations in a month. One employee is trained on one station.
IV.6 PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL:
After a period of 3 months, the employees are checked for the health safety, cleanliness and
sanitation after which he is given the yellow Badge. After receiving the Yellow Badge, there
are 5 stations that the employees have to be proficient in: Backroom Cleaning, Fried
Products, Buns, Dress and Grill (BDG), Counter, and Personality.
• The profile of the employees mainly consists of college students who want to use
their spare time and get some fast money.
• The employees feel that there is very slow growth in the company. It takes one 3
months just to get the yellow badge, and even after that, the promotions come very slow.
• The salary packages are not very attractive.
Host and hostesses, Mystery Diner, Meter Rule, and Served in 60 Seconds
standarsition:
They follow a 6 step rule. As soon as the customer comes to the counter they have to:
measures to achieve this include – Bulk buying, long-term vendor contracts, and
manufacturing efficiencies.
V.0 DOMINOS
Domino's Pizza India Ltd. was incorporated in March 1995 as the master franchisee for India
and Nepal, of Domino's Pizza International Inc., USA. Moreover, the company holds the
master franchisee rights for Sri Lanka and Bangladesh through its wholly owned subsidiary.
Mr. Shyam S. Bhartia and Mr. Hari S. Bhartia of the Jubilant Organosys Group were the
promoters of the company.Like most corporate success stories, Domino's started out small -
with just one store in 1960. Now, Domino's Pizza is celebrating over forty years of
delivering food, fun and innovation.
First Dominos outlet was opened at Faizabad road in 2004
• Second at Saharaganj in 2005
• Third at Ashiyana in 2008
• Fourth at Engineering College chauraha, Aliganj in 2010
• Fifth at Phoenix Mall on 24th December,2010
V.4 ACCESSIBILITY
This website has been created to conform to the Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). The
WAI initiative allows web site makers to build websites that are easily accessible by people
with disabilities.
The reason is family ties. Another important step in their growth came in 1977 when Pizza
Hut was acquired by one of the true giants of international business: PepsiCo, Inc. as part of
the PepsiCo corporate family. The food service industry today is one of the fastest growing
industries in the carryout procedures to provide faster, more efficient service and rapidly
expanded their delivery operations throughout the country.
• USP: Lamb chops, Big Boys Burger, 21 ice-cream flavors Nirula's 1st Outlet was
launched on Shahnajaf Road on 25th May, 2005,
• Nirula's 2nd Outlet, Express at Spencers, launched on 29th June, 2007,
• Nirula's 3rd Outlet launched at Patrakarpuram on 15th July 2007
• Now all old outlets have been closed and recently NIRULA’S opened a new
Restaurant in Sahara Ganj Mall, Lucknow. The Outlet Format is Nirula’s Potpourri.
Nirula’s failed in Lucknow due to the problem of not being able to adapt to the local
conditions because of following reasons:
Shortcomings in the marketing strategy
Pricing Issues
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
Despite outlets being located at prominent places, the focus of the strategy could not
assimilate culture
Not able to cater the local taste.
Aryan is a Multi Cuisine Fine Dining Restaurant in Lucknow. It was established in Lucknow
in 2001. It is owned by Mr Rahul khanna. Aryan having a chain of six branches (excluding
Lucknow zoo branch) at Lucknow.
History Chart
2001 ARYAN MG Marg, Lucknow (Head Office)
2004 ARYAN Aliganj, Lucknow
2006 ARYANShahnazafRoad,Lucknow
Royal café of Lucknow is the oldest and famous food outlet in Lucknow. It is owned by Mr.
Murli Das Ahuja who is the Managing Director. There are other five brothers of M.D. Ahuja,
who are equal partners. The main active member who manages all the catering and staff is
Mr. K.L. Ahuja .Royal café is having two branches at Lucknow, one is at Saharaganj and the
other is at Hazaratganj opposite to Sahu cinema.
HISTORY CHART
Seventies Small Restaurant owner (Tea & Samosa) (Father Mr. P. Ahuja)
Marksmen (Halwasia)
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
Figure 3.5-2
IX.3 OVERVIEW
Chhappan Bhog is a reputed name in premium quality sweets and Namkeen & other
delectable delicacies perhaps the best that has won the heart of millions around the globe.
Since its inception in 1992, they worked hard to offer their clientele best quality products
wrapped in traditional cordiality. Thus today they possess the reputation of being one of the
leading firms in this trade.
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)
The year was 1991. A workaholic young man of 24 years came forward. Confident at heart &
dreams in his eyes to change the manufacturing and marketing scenario in this trade. With
the assistance of a few 'think-a-like' people, he started the ground work and gradually gave it
a shape and thus emerged- chhappan bhog, the name that changed the concept of
conventional selling in this trade.
The name 'Chhappan Bhog' is an old mythological Hindu name derived from age old
'Mahabharat times, when a royal get together would take place with various delicacies,
probably 56 in numbers, keeping the old term alive, it proceeded further.
A tempting range of exotic North, Indian & Bengali sweets, premium quality namkeens and
Indian beverages are displayed in a very practical as well as elegant manner.Apart from
sweets & namkeens, they offer mouthwatering chaat to their those customers who have an
inclination towards (Chatpata) tingling taste.
A well equipped kitchen is the integral part of their shop. Their strictly follow the modern
methods of preparation. A team of experienced karigars have been deputed to keep an eye on
the process of manufacturing, so that no stone is left unturned. Hygiene is the 'mantra' among
their kitchen staff.
XII.0 CONCLUSION
Glocalization should form a very important aspect in the expansion plans of the Global Food
firms. Glocalization attributes the success of a global product completely to localization of
the product according to the specific needs of that region. Many companies collapse, when a
decision to launch in different locations simultaneously is taken without any prior estimation
of the degree of adaptation needed. For example, Nirula’s failed in Lucknow due to the
problem of not being able to adapt to the local conditions. The food multinational
enterprises have to be particularly sensitive to these issues because challenges faced in this
industry due to the cultural differences are more critical and complex as compared to the
other industries.
REFERENCES
1. Ahmed, A., & Manohar, G. “Glocalization”: IIPM knowledge center. Available at:
http://www.iipm.edu/iipm-old/iipm-glocalization.html
2. Boyd, D. (2006). "Glocalization: When Global Information and Local Interaction Collide."
O'Reilly Emerging Technology Conference, San Diego, CA. March 6.
3. Campbell, M. (2002). “Asterix Promoting McBurgers in France: McDonald in the
'glocalization' of fast food marketing”, Toronto Globe & Mail, January 24.
4. Hye-won, J. (2006). “Is globalization succumbing to glocalization?” The Korean Times, July
18.
5. Kappan, R. (2004). ‘Web’ man in a new weave, The Hindu. Available at:
http://www.gothamcomics.com/html/spiy_desi_2.htm. Accessed on: September 26, 2006
Asian Journal of Technology & Management Research Vol. 01 – Issue: 01 (Jan - Jun 2011)