What Floats Your Boat
What Floats Your Boat
Grade Level: 8
Integration: Students will solve real-world and mathematical problems involving area,
volume and surface area of 2 – and 3-dimensional objects composed of triangles,
quadrilaterals, polygons, cubes, and right prisms. Students will engineer solutions to the
given problem using gained scientific content knowledge as application of mathematical
skills
Teacher Planning:
MAFS Math Content (The specific content taken from (How will students demonstrate
the standard(s) that students will their understanding of the
be expected to understand by Learning Goal(s))
the end of the lesson)
Know the formulas for the volumes The students will understand: The students will:
of cones, cylinders, and spheres
and use them to solve real-world How to use metric Know and use the formulas to
and mathematical problems. measurement and determine the volume and
appropriate math skills to density of variously shaped
Using a calculator, apply the determine density. objects.
formula to find the volume of three-
dimensional shapes (i.e., cubes,
spheres and cylinders).
Use appropriate tools The students will understand: The students will:
strategically.
How to use appropriate tools Use appropriate tools with
Attend to precision. with accuracy and precision. accuracy and precision to
determine volume and
The equation for the volume of density.
a cylinder is:
V = πr2h
5
Science NGSSS Content (The specific content taken (How will students demonstrate
from the standard(s) that their understanding of the
students will be expected to Learning Goal(s))
understand by the end of the
lesson)
Classify and compare substances The student will understand: The students will:
on the basis of characteristic
physical properties that can be Each material has a unique Characterize items based
demonstrated or measured; for set of physical properties, upon their density compared
example, density.
such as density, and the to water.
properties are the same
The student will know:
regardless of the sample Measure the physical
size. properties of various
All matter has certain physical
materials to determine their
properties that can be used to
That the density of an object density.
classify or distinguish
when compared to the
materials from one another.
density of a liquid, such as Define Density and
water, will determine if the buoyancy.
Density is the amount of
object will float on the liquid.
matter (mass) in a given space
Use the formulas for volume
(volume).
How to calculate density. and density to predict
whether an object will sink or
Buoyancy is the upward force
float.
on an object that has
displaced water.
Engineering Practice(s)
Know Understand Do
Engineering Practice Content Connection Evidence of Learning
The student will know: The students will understand: The students will:
Models represent scientific How to use data to construct Design and construct, a
concepts that we cannot see a model. physical model to
in a classroom setting. demonstrate the concept that
objects with a lesser density
will float on a liquid of a higher
density.
Prior Knowledge – What content knowledge should students have for this
lesson?
Math Solve real-world and mathematical problems involving area, volume and surface
area of two- and three-dimensional objects composed of triangles, quadrilaterals,
polygons, cubes, and right prisms.
Science Differentiate between weight and mass recognizing that weight is the amount of
gravitational pull on an object and is distinct from, though proportional to, mass.
Measure and compare objects and materials based on their physical properties
including: mass, shape, volume, color, hardness, texture, odor, taste, attraction to
magnets.
Feedback to Students – When and how students will receive feedback of their
progress towards the learning goal throughout the duration of the lesson.
Math Referencing formulas on lab sheet and station cards. Assisting with calculator use
as needed.
Science Compiling data from group to analyze results from the various stations, as well as
from using the text to answer the essential question.
7
Science Final paper and completed model show a direct correlation between lower density
and ability to float.
Vocabulary
Mathematics Vocabulary Science Vocabulary Engineering Vocabulary
Volume, cylinder physical property, density, None specific
buoyancy, matter, mass,
volume
Essential Question(s):
How/Why do boats float? How can density be used to determine if an object will float in a given
liquid? How can volume and mass of an object be used to determine the density of the object?
Suggested Technology:
Computer, projector, tablet or smartphone.
Sequencing Calendar:
Day 1 Day 2
Science Engage: Continue Explain:
Photos of boats; introduction of Review text as it applies to essential
essential question. question
Explore: Engineering Challenge
Stations; determining density
Begin Explain:
Distribution of Taxt
8
Engineering Design:
Problem/Challenge:
Design a boat, made from a specified size of aluminum foil, that will float in a
tub/bucket of water when a cargo of 5 or more pennies are added. Design must be
backed by mathematical data, in the form of density calculations, that clearly
demonstrate that lower density objects will float on a liquid of higher density.
Background
The U.S. Navy is seeking designs for a new generation of cargo ships. You are to
create a design out of a piece of aluminum foil that measures 12 x 24 inches and can
remain afloat carrying a minimum of 5 pennies. The more pennies your craft can carry
and still float will enhance your bid (score).
Objectives
Clearly show, using the appropriate math, how your design has a smaller density
than the water it is floating on (1 g/cm3).
Clearly show your design floating with at least 5 pennies inside the hull
Problem/Challenge:
attached form) that includes a picture of the model floating with at least 5 pennies
contained in the hull and completed math to show density of the boat compared to
water.
10
Accommodations:
o Place a strong student in math in each group.
o Place a strong reader in each group.
o Provide the necessary equations and model the math.
o Allow additional time as needed.
Engage:
- Ask leading questions as students are looking at the pictures of boats
- Have students utilize compare and contrast.
Explore:
- Place each station under an Elmo (or similar projector) or videotape the
stations for ease of visualizing the analysis discussion.
Explain:
- Only provide the necessary part of the text. Ideally use the first 12 paragraphs,
but this can be edited down if needed.
- Read the text to the students. Discuss what they underline and circle with
them. Explain difficult vocabulary and concepts.
Evaluate:
- Scaffold the final design paper. Provide some examples that you have made.
References
Day 1: Objective and Students will collect data from observations, activities,
Cognitive Complexity and texts to draw conclusions to formulate a reason why
boats float, despite being constructed of materials that
would appear to have too much mass to do so.
Students will develop a working definition of density and
calculate and compare the densities of various materials
in the shape of quadrilaterals, cubes, and cylinders.
Complexity: high
Essential Question(s) Why do boats float? How does a physical property, such
as density, factor into the ability to float?
Materials Pictures of boats (you may obtain by performing an
internet search for “boats” then click images on the top
header or display pictures of your own choosing.)
(Stations) Distilled or tap water (approx. 6 gallons), 6
small tubs (Halloween candy or Easter basket size),
station instruction cards, 1 can regular Coke, 1 can Diet
Coke, 1 roll plastic wrap, “Fun Size” (large) candy bars
and “Bite Size” (small) candy bars (same candy, such as
Milky Way or 3 Musketeers), 2 identical sets of Density
cubes, 1 roll of aluminum foil, 1 box of raisins,
carbonated beverage, 1000 ml graduated cylinder (or
smaller if preferred), ping pong ball, rubbing alcohol,
vegetable oil, dish soap, beads, soda cap, cherry
tomato, 100% maple syrup popcorn kernels, honey, corn
syrup, bolt, die.
For each station (optional):
one scale or balance
one graduated cylinder
one ruler (metric)
calculator
Pacing Engage: 5 minutes,
Explore (Stations) 45 minutes,
Explain (Introduce text and homework) 5 minutes.
Student Grouping Groups of 4 students (ideally).
Optional: You may begin with the Pick up an index card as they enter the
question, “What does the term - density room.
mean when I apply it to the
characteristics of an object?” A quick Students will answer the question and
glance at the responses will inform you if pass the cards back to the teachers.
a bit of instruction of the concept is
necessary prior to starting.
Students will observe, take notes, and
If one is needed, obtaining a set of pass the density cubes while examining
density cubes from your Subject Area the differences between them.
Leader will provide hands-on materials for
use in a mini-lesson on density. Explain: Students will enter room, picking up a
a. What density represents copy of the lab sheet, and be allowed to
b. Have them pass around and comment among themselves on the
compare the cubes. projected pictures of boats.
c. Introduce the formula.
Students will comment on the posed
Teacher will have picture of various boats question, beginning with student in left
projected on front board as students enter front corner of each group and rotating
room. Allow students to view the pictures clockwise. When commenting, only one
and comment naturally. student speaks at a time with no other
student commenting or challenging.
Seat students in groups of 3 or 4 for best
effectiveness. Instruct students to not
touch the lab materials on their tables Students will write the best explanation in
until told to do so. the top box of the lab sheet.
1. When starting a station, students Students will read the text for homework
should observe what is happening
in the tub/bucket and record their Article found at EXPLAINTHATSTUFF!
observations on the lab sheet.
(You might wish to focus their
attention on what is floating, how
high in the water it is floating, and
what the objects appear to be
constructed of.)
2. Students should then calculate
the density of each object in the
tub/bucket. (The formula is on the
lab sheet.)
Day 2:
Objective and Cognitive Students will review complex text and determine
Complexity information in support of an answer to their essential
question. Students will apply that understanding of
buoyancy to the design and construction of a boat that
will carry a designated cargo (mass). Students will
compute the overall density of their boat design.
Essential Question(s) Why do boats float? How does a physical property, such
as density, factor into the ability to float?
Materials Text – Ships and Boats, Aluminum foil sheet, Proposal
sheet, Rubric, Density Rules, Project Assignment
Paper, scissors, ruler, balance/scale, pennies,
calculators.
Pacing Explain (Introduce text 10 minutes, Explore
(engineering) 40 minutes.
Student Grouping Groups of 4 students (ideally).
Assessment options:
While the final question on the student
worksheet, “Why will your design work?”
should include the concept of density as it
applies to their design and the water used
to float their vessel, you may need to
emphasize that point during instructions.
Directions:
1) Write what you observe.
2) Measure the density of each object in the water. (Note: at some stations, a dry
sample of the item may be available so you will not need to remove the item in
the water. Also, for ‘packaged’ items, measure the package and round to the
nearest .1g and nearest .1cm.
SODA
CANDY BARS
You can’t measure precise density here
but what inferences can you make?
RAISINS/SODA
You can’t measure precise density here
but what inferences can you make?
LIQUIDS
22
METAL/WOOD
CUBES
METAL/PLASTIC
CUBES
23
Paragraph Notes
Number
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
# Notes:
25
Summary:
Background
The U.S. Navy is seeking designs for a new generation of cargo ships. You are to
create a design out of a piece of aluminum foil that measures 12 x 24 inches and can
remain afloat carrying a minimum of 5 pennies. The more pennies your craft can carry
and still float will enhance your bid (score).
Objectives
Clearly show, using the appropriate math, how your design has a smaller density
than the water it is floating on (1 g/cm3).
Clearly show your design floating with at least 5 pennies inside the hull
Clearly show all design changes over the time of your project.
Timeframe
Description of Work Due Date
Project Submission of aluminum foil model with
Submission appropriate paperwork.
Approval Signature
________________________________________
Density Calculations
What determines whether an object floats or sinks? It is the density (mass per unit of
volume) of the object compared to the density of the liquid. If the object is denser than
the fluid, it will sink. If the object is less dense than the fluid, it will float. So, how do you
determine, using math, if your “boat” will float?
Equation 1:
The ship floats because its density is less than the density of water. But when cargo or
other weight is added to the ship, its density is now defined by Equation 2 below.
Equation 2:
If too much cargo or weight is added to the ship, the density of the ship becomes
greater than the density of water, and the ship sinks. Extra cargo would need to be
thrown overboard in a hurry or it is time to abandon ship!
Find the volume of the boat by filling the boat with either water (or if you prefer not to
worry about getting all the water out when you go to add pennies to the “cargo”,
because any added water will add mass, use sand), then measure the volume of the
added water (sand) in a graduated cylinder.
Finding the mass is easy – put the aluminum foil (the hull) or the pennies on the
balance/scale and mass them. To find the mass of the air, take the volume of the boat
and multiply it by .001225 g.
27