0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 1K views 5 pages U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan's Letter To ICE
U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan, who represents Reading and its surrounding communities, released a statement Thursday announcing they had penned a letter together asking the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement to provide more information about the Berks County Residential Center.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Carousel Previous Carousel Next
Save U.S. Sen. Bob Casey and U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan... For Later Congress of the United States
Washington, BE 20510
October 24, 2019
The Honorable Matthew T. Albence
Acting Director
USS. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
500 12th St, SW
Washington, D.C. 20536
Dear Acting Director Albence:
We write today to obtain more information about the Berks County Residential Center (Berks).
On July 29, 2019, we toured the facility and had the opportunity to speak with both staff and
detainees. We seek clarification on several inconsistencies as well as more information regarding
accounts of deportations that have taken place in recent months.
Families seeking refuge in the United States should not be detained, particularly for prolonged
periods. Many alternatives to detention exist. These alternatives are not only more humane, but
have high efficacy rates and are more cost effective. Families seeking protection should not be
detained as they work through the legal process. However, when families are detained, they
should at a minimum be held in safe conditions with all of their needs met, including access to
medical care, mental health services and sleep.
1. Medical Care
During our visit, we were informed that residents have access to medical services at all hours
provided by the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Health Service Corps.
However, we have heard troubling accounts of medical care not being provided until children are
very ill.! We have also heard that when residents are sent to the hospital or outside medical
services and provided a prescription, those prescriptions will not be filled automatically. Rather,
ICE providers will review and determine whether to provide the treatment. In addition, there
have been reported instances of families being separated when a parent or child is sent to outside
medical services.” Accordingly, we request the following information:
1, Ate pediatricians available on site to care for children?
2. Do health practitioners receive specialized training for the care of children?
3. Are medical staff available on site bilingual? What efforts are made to hire
staff?
4, Is there a procedure for residents to request medical attention?
When are residents referred for outside care?
* Peter Hall, Immigrant family detention center puts Berks County in eye of political storm, The Moming Call,
2018, hutps:/www.mcal.com/news/local'me-nws-berks-immigration-family-detention-center-20180703-story html
2 Franco Ordofez, 3-year-old boy held alone in immigration detention, McClatchyDC, 2016,
hupsi/www anestaichyde.com/news/nation-world/national/article8 5977277 hn
16. Is there a procedure for residents to request medical care outside of the facili
themselves or their children’?
7. What is your policy regarding filling prescriptions from outside medical providers?
© Have there been any incidents in which Berks medical providers have decided not
to fill a prescription or provide a course of treatment recommended by an outside
medical provider? If so, why’?
8. Ifa parent requires medical care at an outside facility, are children kept at Berks or are
they permitted to remain with the parent? Who makes that determination, the parent or
Berks staff? If the determination is made by the staff, what are the guidelines they follow
in making that determination?
9. What guidelines does Berks use when determining whether families or individuals who
are part ofa family unit need to be kept separate from the general population, including
from their own family members due to illness?
What information is provided to families, and in particular children, during
instances where they have been separated from one another for medical care?
for either
I Mental Health Care
Asylum seekers and refugees are more likely to experience poor mental health than the local
population, including higher rates of depression, PTSD and other anxiety disorders.’ Asylum
seekers may have endured significant trauma both in their country of origin and on their journey
to the United States. Furthermore, detention itself can be a point of stress, particularly for
children. Research has shown that children in detention experience high rates of clinical
depression, anxiety disorders and PTSD.‘ Accordingly, we request the following information
about the mental health services available to residents at Berks:
1. Are children and/ or adult family members provided initial, trauma-informed mental
health screenings or must they proactively seek out services?
When are residents informed of the availability of mental health services?
Are mental health practitioners available on site with specialized training for the
treatment of children and adolescents?
4. Cultural competence is central to providing mental health services to culturally diverse
populations. Cultural differences may influence how individuals view mental health; how
and when they will seek treatment; the nature of the client and practitioner relationship;
and even the outcomes of interventions.’ Does Berks work to provide culturally
appropriate and sensitive mental health care?
a. Please describe how culturally competent care is provided, including specific
training for serving populations within the facility
b. How are mental health services provided in the language of the client? Are any
mental health staff bilingual? What efforts are made to hire bilingual staff?
2.
3,
* Mental health statistics: refugees and asylum seekers, Mental Health Foundation (2019),
‘usps! mentalhealth.org ukistatisties/mental-health-satistics-refugees-and-asylum-scekers (last visited Oct 21
2019),
Sarah A. MacLean et al., Mental health of children held at a United States immigration detention center, 230
Social Science & Medicine 303-308 (2019).
SMP Claire MeCarthy, 6 reasons children need to play outside - Harvard Health Blog Harvard Health Blog (2019),
hsp: health harvard-edablog/6-reasone-childnen-need-to-play-utide-20180522 13880.
25. Play and spending time outdoors has important benefits for children, We were informed
that children are able to go outside whenever they want to, but that they must have
supervision. How often do children play outside? What is the process for requesting to go
outside, and are requests denied?
IIL. Safety and Wellbeing
The importance of sleep, including uninterrupted sleep at night is well documented.® Adequate
sleep aligns with “improved attention, behavior, learning, memory, emotional regulation, quality
of life and mental and physical health.”” Inadequate sleep increases risk of injuries, hypertension,
obesity and depression. Staff at Berks conduct security checks every 15 minutes during the night,
‘opening the door and shining a flashlight in each room. These disruptions occur approximately
40 times’ night, and are likely causing sleep deficiencies for many children. Indeed, just this
month the harm of these checks was documented by the film “Las Madres de Berks” as well as
the statement of a British family held in the facility.* While keeping families secure and safe
from harm is important, it seems that there must far less disruptive means of reaching that goal
Please provide an explanation for the purpose of these security checks and whether alternate
security methods have been considered.
In 2016, a guard plead guilty to sexually assaulting a 19-year old mother detained in Berks.’ The
survivor had fled abuse in Honduras with her three-year-old son. Unfortunately, there have been
other documented instances of sexual harassment and abuse throughout the U.S. immigration
system." The National Prison Rape Elimination Commission has reported ‘on the particular
vulnerability of immigrants in detention to sexual harassment and abuse.!
1, Since the 2016 incident, has Berks implemented new policies or procedures to
safeguard residents from similar instances of abuse? If so, please describe them.
2. Is there a safe, confidential way for residents to report harassment, sexual abuse or
mistreatment by personnel or other residents? Please include information regarding
the process to report such claims and the procedure by which claims are handled and
investigated.
3. Do staff and residents receive any sexual harassment and assault prevention training?
If so, please describe the programs.
6 Shalini Paruth et al., Recommended Amount of Sleep for Pediatrie Populations: A Consensus Statement ofthe
American Academy of Sleep Medicine, 12 Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine 785-786 (2016).
Md
* David Mekecl, British family deported after crossing border into U.S. from Canada and being detained in Berks
facility, Reading Eagle, 2019, htps:/www.teadingeagle.com/news/artclbritish-family-deported-after-rossing-
border-into-us-from-canada-and-being-letained-in-berks-facility
* Renée Feltz, Immigration facility guard given jail ime for sexual assault of detainee, The Guardian, 2016,
Iups://www.theguardian,com/us-news/2016/apr:23/immigration-detention-center-guard-sexual-assault-prison,
‘© Human Rights Watch, Detained and at Risk: Sexual Abuse and Harassment in United States Immigration
Detention (2010), hips/www.hrw.org report’2010/08/25 detained-and-risksexual-abuse-and-harassment-united-
states-immigration-detention.
"'National Rape Prison Elimination Commission, National Rape Prison Elimination Commission Report (2009),
ups: www nejr gov'palles/226680 pakIV. _ Facility Procedures and Length of Detention
Some residents with whom we spoke did not have basic information about their immigration
case and were unaware of their rights or how long they might be detained. The detainee stated
that when she first came to Berks she was told that she was taken there because she was
“illegal,” and that she was aware of her status but not informed of anything else. While providing
an exact timeline to residents may not be possible, it is extremely concerning that a family could
be detained over a week without any information about their situation.
1, Please provide a description of the intake process at Berks, including a description of
the information provided to residents and the timeline for when this information is
provided,
a. In your response, please provide official guidelines or training manuals for
intake staff. as well as any written documents provided to residents.
b. Please also indicate whether and what information about the facility, outside
resources, health and mental health services, legal proceedings and length of
stay are provided.
¢. Please indicate the language(s) in which the information is communicated,
Do residents have access to telephone services? Are these services free for all
residents; are there any restrictions on when or to whom calls can be made?
‘© During the tour, we noticed calling card machines on the premises. Are
residents required to purchase calling cards or do they have the option to use
other payment methods for calls? Please provide the cost and rates for calling
cards purchased from the machines on premises.
‘What procedures does the facility have in place pertaining to infant care and hygiene?
a, Are there policies in place to ensure that infants are able to remain with
parents at all times? If'so, please provide a copy of any procedures related
specifically to the care of infants under 12 months of age.
b. On October 15, 2019, it was reported that an ICE officer told a detained
mother she could allow her infant to be separated from the family and sent to
another facility. Please provide the context for this comment, a description of
the protocols under which a child would be separated from their parent while
in family detention, and the number of instances since January 20, 2019 that a
child has been voluntarily or involuntarily separated from their parent at
Berks.'*
Among the most concerning stories we heard from residents, were about attempted and
successful deportations in the middle of the night. Residents reported being taken from bed
without warning, denied access to telephones to call counsel and transported for removal. In
many of the reported instances, legal proceedings had not yet concluded as some residents had
pending appeals. All those seeking asylum should have a fair opportunity to present their claims
in accordance with U.S. and international law. Deportations in the middle of the night not only
make it more difficult for residents to reach counsel and therefore exercise their legal rights, but
2 4 British couple claim they swerved from Canada imo the US. to avoid an animal on the road. Now they and
their baby are in custody in Berks County, Reading Eagle, 2019, bttps:/ww readingeagle com news/articl!an-
english-couple-swerved-fom-canada-into-the-us-1o-avoid-an-animal-on-the-toad-now-they-and-theit-baby-are-in-
todypin-berka-oountyalso are potentially traumatizing to the families at Berks. For children being deported, the
disruption without explanation can be frightening and traumatizing. One resident described the
experience as worse than detention. For the children that remain, waking up to find other
residents have simply disappeared is also frightening and likely contributes to their considerable
anxiety. We strongly urge you to develop removal protocols that not only ensure individuals can
fully exercise their legal rights, but are more humane and consider the emotional impact of such
actions on children.
Finally, it is well established that detention, even brief detention, is harmful to children. While
the Flores settlement indicates that children should not be detained for more than twenty days,
there have been many reported instances of families at Berks held well beyond that period. In
2017, there were reports of families, including young children, detained for over 600 days."* As
such, please provide:
1. The number of families, including a breakdown of adults and children, that have been at
Berks since January 20, 2017:
a. the average length of stay for these families: and
b, the number of families that have been held for over 20 days and the total length
of time for each of these instance
The length of time each family currently in custody has been at the facility.
Since January 20, 2017, the number of attempted deportations for individuals or families
with pending legal cases or appeals: and deportations for individuals or families with
pending legal cases or appeals.
4. Since January 20, 2017, the number of families that were deported from the facili
the number of families released to a sponsor.
y and
We are a Nation of immigrants and we are a Nation of laws. It is possible for the United States to
foster an immigration system that respects both of these values by treating all individuals with
compassion and dignity, while also securing our border and protecting our national security, The
Berks facility is not furthering either of these goals. We appreciate your prompt attention in this
matter and look forward to a prompt response.
Sincerely
Bvt. Corey iS.
Robert P. Casey, Jr. Chrsy Houlahan
United States Senator Member of Congress
® Amnesty International, USA: Children Held at Berks Immigration Center Granted Release (2017)
usps www amnesty. usa-children-held-berks-immigration-center-granted-release
5