Ventilation On Demand
Ventilation On Demand
Ahead of Hard Rock Mine Ventilation 2014, I caught up with Allison Golsby, CEO of
ConsultMine, to discuss the impact of VOD systems and how they are offering new
opportunities to reduce operational costs, improve efficiency and health & safety.
Some examples are the addition of an adjustable speed drive to reduce fan output based on
shift times, occupancy, the type of mining activity, as well as other factors.
Mines most suited to VOD have operations that are in distinct segments or areas that
traditionally are flood-ventilated, such as block caves, development activities, stoping or for
drill and blast activities. This compartmentalisation does not require the entire mine to be
ventilated at any one time.
Software changes might be needed when implementing components into the ventilation
system that are based on pre-requisites for automation and monitoring.
There's often a need for running communication cables or optical fibre to connect
everything up to the system, which then needs to be read by the software.
There are commercial, off-the-shelf products that enable sites to read PLC outputs in order
to understand through a graphic user interface (GUI). Engineers can analyse fan
components and even have low level semi-controlled systems with alarms set into them.
“Although this is a fair call from a business perspective, they’re only analysing development
costs and management processes. The finalised plans are given to the ventilation engineer
to ventilate.
“However, if teams placed ventilation design early on in the planning process, they could
design the intakes and extraction drives to reduce resistance. South African mine sites are
using this strategy in the form of what they call a blueprint, through which the operational
team manages the technical discipline, incorporating ventilation,” Allison remarked.
Instead of the air flowing through several ventilation areas, resistance is managed and the
operational cost is reduced by at least 15 to 20% without significantly increasing the capital
costs in any way.
Reducing loads on the ventilation system reduces maintenance costs. Having a vent system
constantly at full power invites breakdowns. High pressures in the vent circuit can also be a
safety hazard.
Construction of a surface exhaust fan installation involved use of variable frequency drives
(VFDs), multi-fan PLC and fan operation considerations.
These changes require many levels of monitoring to create a real time response system,
including basic control loop standard, design and simulation, loop tuning of the entire
control system and air monitoring stations (AMS) underground, and interaction testing
between surface fans and AMS across multiple circumstances.
“Mines cannot survive any longer solely by increasing the prices for which they sell the
resource. They have to address costs. If VOD is implemented into the mine as it’s developed,
smaller ventilation shafts, fan installations, supporting infrastructure and capital costs are
lower than a comparable flood ventilation system,” Allison remarked.
At one mine site to which Allison referred, the ventilation system’s fans were significantly
oversized. As a solution, fifteen out of the eighteen system fans were fitted with variable
frequency drives. The damper controls were no longer necessary and the fan control
dampers were opened 100%.
Other benefits from implementing VOD systems relate to more effective management of
dust, fume, DPM, heat, detection of unplanned events and gas, and reduced pressure
differentials. Therefore, lowered leakage and propensity for spontaneous combustion in
coal mines and fans can be on standby and maintained without reducing production.
Ventilation on Demand represents a unique step towards operational cost reduction and
improved efficiency. At Hard Rock Mine Ventilation 2014, Allison will run a workshop on
reducing operational costs via Ventilation on Demand, and conduct an in-depth roundtable
discussion on proactive ventilation design strategies to ensure operational cost savings,
focusing on: