Eled 481 Interactive Read Aloud and Close Reading
Eled 481 Interactive Read Aloud and Close Reading
Text Chosen:
Sitti’s Secrets by Naomi Shihab Nye
Nye, N. S. (1997). Sitti’s secrets. New York, NY: .
. Aladdin Paperbacks.
Description of the Text:
Sitti’s Secrets is a book about a young
Arab-American girl named Mona who is visiting
her grandmother (Sitti) and other family in an
unnamed Arabic speaking country. Mona does
not speak Arabic yet finds ways to communicate with Sitti and enjoys exploring the ways that
life is different in her Sitti’s country compared to her own life in America. Towards the end of
the book, Mona writes a letter to the President explaining some of her favorite things about
Sitti and the other people she met in the unnamed country and assures the President he would
like them if he met them, so he should choose to have a peaceful relationship with their
country. I chose this book because it welcomes the reader into this Arabic family’s life and has a
message of striving for understanding and friendship with others who may appear different
than us at first glance. This book offers a lot of rich discussion opportunities and can serve as a
jumping off point for a focus on persuasive writing and figurative language.
Grade: 5
Interactive Read Aloud Plan:
Opening:
“In this book we are introduced to a young girl named Mona who lives in America. Her
grandmother, or Sitti in Arabic, lives very far away on the other side of the world, and even
speaks a different language than Mona. This book is about Mona traveling to visit her Sitti and
learning about what life is like in Sitti’s country. We get to share in Mona’s experiences and
learn alongside her!” I chose to introduce the book this way because it’s giving students a little
background knowledge of the text without giving away any details of the story that will be
uncovered as we read on together.
Stopping Points:
1. (p. 10) Mona and her grandmother, or Sitti in Arabic, don’t speak the same language. Do
you think it was hard for them to communicate? What are some of the ways they are
finding to communicate? (I’m choosing to stop here because one of the big takeaways I
want students to have is that although they may not speak the same language, they still
love each other very much and can come to a mutual understanding on important
things)
2. (p. 18) What was Sitti’s secret that Mona just learned? Do you think she has other
secrets too? What might they be? (This is more of a comprehension check, and should
keep students engaged in the reading by asking them to make predictions)
3. (p. 26) What do you think Mona’s purpose for writing a letter to the President was?
(This is again getting at the book’s big idea of striving to understand and form
relationships with others who may seem different than you. This question is also setting
up a post-reading activity I will have the students do)
Post-Reading Discussion:
How would you describe Sitti and Mona’s relationship? Do you think all the differences
between their countries and their languages make a difference in how much they love each
other? How might this message apply to your own life? What have you learned from reading
this book that you didn’t know before?
Self-Evaluation of Engagement:
As we were reading, was I making connections to the text or comparing my life to the
character’s in the story? (are students making text-to-self connections?)
What questions do I still have that could help me understand this story more? (are
students thinking deeply about the text and striving for understanding?)
Record of Reading:
During our after-reading discussion, the class will name the things that they have
learned from reading this book. We will generalize any specifics into broader categories (e.g. we
learned about another culture) and then choose one category of learning that we think fits best
for this book. We will then add this book to a chart that organizes all our past reading by
categories of what we learned from reading this book.
Written or Artistic Response:
At the end of the story, Mona writes a persuasive letter to the President to try to
convince him that he shouldn’t go to war with Sitti’s country. This is a topic for writing that
Mona cares a lot about, because she really loves Sitti and the other people she met in that
country. Let’s brainstorm as a class some ideas of things that you really care about. Maybe you
really care about pollution, or whales, or immigration, or wheelchair accessible buildings. After
we have spent some time thinking about what you are really passionate about, you will draft a
persuasive letter that is trying to convince someone that they should care about what you care
about too.