Building Science 2
Building Science 2
SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE BUILDING AND DESIGN
BACHELORS OF SCIENCE IN ARCHITECTURE
BUILDING SCIENCE II
(ARC 3413 / BLD61303)
ASSIGNMENT 1
AUDITORIUM : A CASE STUDY ON ACOUSTIC DESIGN
PERMATA PINTAR, UNIVERSITY KEBANGSAAN MALAYSIA
0320498 Choo Zi Zhao
0319894 Hirendran
1.1 Aim
Taking everything we learnt from the lectures into practicality was very important for each of us. It is one thing
to be introduced to the theory and nomenclature in a lecture hall with slides, no matter how useful - yet quite
another to conduct a field visit. There we were fortunate enough to retrieve architectural and construction
drawings which include plans, sections and schedules from the relevant authorities. These were necessary in
order to make certain calculations as well as determine how sound would react through the geometry of the
space.
We were assigned to take down all relevant observations regarding sound including noise, systems, materials,
and so on.With the use of a sound meter, we also managed to record the sound levels in a more tangible way.
From there we needed to make calculations to find reverberation times.
All of this is eventually going to help us conclude our opinions on the effectiveness of this particular auditorium
as a multipurpose lecture hall.
1.3 Drawings
1.4 Methodology
1.4.1 Equipment
Digital Sound Level Meter
A digital sound level meter, a measuring instrument was used to assess noise or sound levels by measuring sound
pressure at particular points within the auditorium. The sound is then evaluated within the device and acoustic
measurement values are displayed. Most common unit of acoustic measurement for sound is the decibel (dB)
Measuring Devices
Measuring Tape Digital Laser Distance Meter
These devices were used to obtain measurements of the auditorium for drawing and calculation purposes
Digital Camera
A digital camera was used to capture and document visuals of the auditorium which we later used as evidence
for analysis purposes.
3.1 Shape
The shape of the auditorium takes on a fan shape, and gradually grows outwards from the stage
toward the audience. Sound waves from the source travel along the direction of the walls and
reflect uniformly throughout the hall. This configuration allows for sound to be distributed evenly
along the frontal areas of the hall, however causing the back of the hall to experience some
echoing as sound is reflected off the walls. This can be countered by applying materials to
prevent the occurrence of undesirable acoustical defects.
Figure 3.1.2 Elimination of flutter echoes through splayed walls whilst helping to reflect sound
3.2 Arrangement of seats
The seats within the auditorium are arranged in a fan shaped configuration, to ensure a
maximum number of seats are fitted and to obtain an optimum view of the stage area from
every seat.,
It is tested that by including a 140 degree sound proJection angle from the centre of the sound
source on the stage. Should all seat fall within the angle of the sound projection area, the
seating arrangement is well configured and deemed effective
Figure 3.2.1 Arrangement of seating falls within 140 degree angle from centre of sound source
from centre stage, optimal for speech auditoriums.
3.3 Distance of Sound Travel
Short delayed sound reflections from reflective surfaces that arrive at a listener’s position should
have a path difference of not more than about 9 to 10.5m to direct sound. (correspond to time
delay gap of about 30 m/s) Unamplified speech from source to listener has a range of about 9 to
15m beyond which speech intelligibility is poor. Total distance from the stage to the back of the
auditorium is 23.5 metres, requiring for the hall to be equipped with speakers.
Figure 3.3.1 Sound waves (unamplified) have a maximum travel range of 9-15m before
becoming unintelligible
Figure 3.3.2 Addition of balcony allows for reduction of distance between stage and audience,
allowing audience to be closer to sound source
3.3 Sound Shadowing
Portion of the hall beneath the balcony experiences “sound shadowing”, a phenomenon in
which reflected sound from the ceiling is blocked by the balcony due to the depth of the
overhanging balcony.
The raked ceiling maintains a consistent height between the ceiling and the floor, allowing for
sound waves to be reflected more uniformly throughout the auditorium.
Diagrams 3.3.3 Comparison between the flat ceiling and tlited ceiling
3.5 Levelling of stage and seating
In a flat setting where the sound source ( the speaker ) in an auditorium is levelled with the
audience on the ground, issues with hearing and visibility are bound to occur.
The angle of the ceiling panels allows for greater efficiency in the ceilings ability to usefully
reflect sound to the required parts of the hall. As in Permata Pintar’s auditorium, the flat ceiling
panels allow for a 70% efficiency in reflecting sound back to the audience. However, beyond the
efficient ceiling panels, the ceiling should use a concave shape to concentrate sound back to
the audience and preventing undesirable echoing.
Figure 3.6.1 Ceiling panels following angle of tilted ceiling reflect sound waves further than
necessary
Figure 3.6.2 Ceiling panels are oriented at horizontally flat angle to direct reflected sound
waves toward audience
4.3 Acoustic Treatment
4.3.1 Wall Panel
As seen in the diagram, the thickest grade (CMU 4 as highlighted in orange) of masonry block is utilized
throughout the internal wall. This is useful as the slightly rough surface of these blocks is able to absorb larger
frequency noises more effectively. The use of CMU 4 blocks covers both the seating for the audience as well as
the walls surrounding the stage
Diagram 4.3.1.A The types of wall surfaces throughout auditorium
Notation Grade
The higher the annotation-number, the higher the width (thickness) of the masonry blocks. These are also
commonly known as cinder blocks. Throughout the parallel halls of the auditorium, double layering of masonry
units are used. There is an air cavity separating them.
The panels are a block-system of modular hollow concrete masonry units of similar composition. Within many of
these blocks is a visible cavity
Typically, concrete does not make an effective sound absorber. However, porous concrete surfaces with
interconnected pores work well for sound absorption. At the porous surface, the energy of sound is converted
into heat. Porous concrete absorbs sound but has poor sound insulation. According to research, this may cause
sounds to be heard from outside. In our experience, very little was heard.
Therefore, painting or plastering porous concrete reduces sound absorption and increases its sound insulating
characteristics. This is why the concrete is not painted on in the actual hall, making it ideal for a multi-purpose
auditorium. This is the case backstage. The more the concrete weighs, or the denser the concrete, the more
sound insulation (the greater sound transmission loss) rating.
4.3.2 Floor Panel
a) Stage
Figure 4.3.2(a) Ground floor plan
Highlighted area : Flooring of stage and backstage
From the left : Figure 4.3.2(b) Photo of front stage ; Figure 4.3.2(c) photo of back stage
Laminate timber flooring is used for the stage and backstage of the auditorium. It is an unreal timber but
it is more economical than other real timber flooring. Laminate timber flooring is durable as it resists to
scratches, stains and fade. Activities or performances on stage might require music instrument and other heavy
equipments for the shows. Hence, it is suitable to use as a stage flooring in order to keep good appearance and
quality of the floor. However, the acoustic design of the flooring is less satisfying due to the loud and hollow
sound created by laminate timber floors. The level of noises caused is different depending by various shoes
types.
b) Audience’s areas
Figure 4.3.2(d) Ground floor plan
Highlighted area : Flooring of audience’s area
Figure 4.3.2(e) First Floor Plan
Highlighted area : Flooring of audience’s area (Balcony)
From the left : Figure 4.3.2.(f) Flooring in auditorium followed by Right : Figure 4.3.2.(g) steps
Flooring and steps finishes in the audience’s region are saxony carpet tiles. Saxony carpet tiles is good
in sound absorption and has thick padding under it to deflect sound. It is smooth on the surface while its
texture is densely packed with fibre. Thick padding usually installed underneath the carpet to deflect sound.
Nevertheless, there are disadvantages of using carpet flooring. It is less durable and hygienic as allergen and
dusts get trapped in it easily. The appearance of footprints and vacuum cleaner marks are also the weakness of
saxony carpet.
4.3.3 Curtains
These curtains are places strategically above the stage to mask any potentially visible exposed
machinery / systems from the audience sitting below.These weigh heavily to maintain drapery and prevent
movement. The top masking curtains are designed to keep most of the machinery (light and ventilation) out of
view of the audience, as demonstrated in the diagram at the bottom of the page
4.3.4 Seating
In the case of the seating in our assigned auditorium, no special considerations seemed to have taken place
with regards to seat choice and acoustics. The seats are economical, and serve their basic function of seating
more than 600 users comfortably. The fabric seems thin.
Therefore it can be concluded that the sound inside the auditorium will be depend on the occupancy at the time.
The seats also made considerably noise upon unfolding the attached table. These creaking noises of the seat
frame may be mildly distracting. Also, when sat on, a considerable thud is heard.
4.3.5 Ceiling
Plaster ceiling has been used throughout the hall. Especially in the region above the ground-floor-seating, the
plaster panelling is used to shield audience from the view of various service-components like air-conditioning
and electrical conduits.
Notation
4.3 Materials
4.3.1 Material Coefficient
The majority range of hearing frequency for human speech is 300Hz to 3000Hz, thus the sound frequencies
chosen for each absorption coefficient of materials are 125Hz, 500Hz and 2000Hz.
Components Materials Descriptions Absorption Coefficient (Hz)
Wall Rockface Concrete 140mm thick wall with 0.02 0.03 0.04
Masonry Unit Block block-system of
modular hollow.
Flooring Saxony Carpet Tiles 16 oz carpet tiles with 0.02 0.08 0.35
300mm length and 300
width.
Doors Hollow Metal Doors Double entry door in 0.35 0.44 0.54
ironmongery schedule.
Seatings Fabric Chairs Thin fabric covering of 0.13 0.59 0.61
chairs attached with
foldable table.
Steps Saxony Carpet Tiles 16 oz carpet tiles with 0.02 0.08 0.35
300mm length and 300
width on steps of
300mm tread and
150mm riser.
Railing Glass Railings Steel handrail are 0.10 0.04 0.02
attached beside the
glass railings.
Control Room Glass Windows Glass with 4mm thick 0.15 0.03 0.02
panels.
Curtains Cotton Curtains 200kg of front masking 0.03 0.13 0.49
curtain ; front centre
masking curtain and
mechanism for 400kg.
Figure 4.3.1 Tables of materials and sound absorption coefficient
4.3.2 Sound Absorption Calculations
Sound absorption coefficient of each material is based on the 500 Hz of sound coefficient from figure 4.3.1
table for following calculations:
Walls
Surface area
= (374.16m2 x 2) + (37.74m x 12.92m) + (125.86m2 x 2) + 411.86m2 + 128.94m2 x2)
= 748.32m2 + 487.6m2 + 251.7m2 + 411.86m2 + 257.88m2
= 2157.36m2
Absorption of surface
= S x 𝛼𝑠
= 2157.36m2 x 0.03
= 64.72 m2 sabins
Ceiling
Surface area
= (132.42m2 +164.38m2 +159.98m2 +157.35m2 +154.74m2 +148.39m2 +144.55m2 +140.64m2 +158.85m2
+195.43m2 )
= 1556.73m2
Absorption of surface
= 1556.73m2 x 0.01
= 155.67m2 sabin
Flooring
Surface area
= (Ground Floor 1059.7m2 ) + (Balcony 192.03m2 )
= 1251.73m2
Absorption of surface
= 1251.73m2 x 0.08
= 100.14m2 sabins
Doors
Surface area
= (77.4m2 x 2) + (38.74m2 x 2)
= 154.94m2 + 77.47m2
= 232.41m2
Absorption of surface
= 232.41m2 x 0.44
= 102.26m2 sabins
Railings
Surface area
= (23.12m2 x 2) + (1.55m x 19.6m)
= 46.24m2 + 30.38m2
= 76.62m2
Absorption of surface
= 76.62 x 0.04
= 3.07m2 sabins
Seatings
Surface area
= (0.66m x 0.66m) + (0.75m x 0.66m)
= 0.44m2 + 0.50m2
= 0.94m2
Absorption of surface
= 0.9306m2 x 0.59
= 0.549m2 sabins
* Total no. of seatings in auditorium = 627 seats
Total seating absorption coefficient
= 627 x 0.549m2 sabins
= 344.22 m2 sabins
Stage Flooring
Surface area
= 28.09m2
Absorption of surface
= 28.09m2 x 0.05
= 1.41m2 sabin
Control Room - Exterior Walls
Surface area
= 86.09m2 + 46.84m2
= 132.93m2
Absorption of surface
= 132.93m2 x 0.03
= 3.99m2 sabins
Control Room - Windows
Surface area
= 3.60m2 x 5
= 18m2
Absorption of surface
= 18m2 x 0.03
= 0.54m2 sabins
Total sound absorption coefficient
= 64.72 m2 sabins + 155.67m2 sabin + 100.14m2 sabins + 102.26m2 sabins + 3.07m2 sabins + 344.22 m2
sabins + 3.99m2 sabins + 0.54m2 sabins + 1.41 m2 sabin
= 776.02m2 sabins
4.4 External and Internal Noises
Diagram shows the three major poor planning sectors
4.4.1 External Noises
Outside the hall, there are a number of noises that can disrupt the hall. Due to the louvred windows situated at
the ceiling of the hall, sounds from the external surroundings can be heard at higher dBs than needed, especially
the drizzling of raindrops. As the bottom of the doors are not sealed with blockers, conversations and footsteps
from outside the hall can infiltrate the space.
4.4.1.1 Doors
There are no transition corridors between the auditorium and the foyer, so should there be activity happening
around the foyer, the disturbance can clearly be heard inside. This is because the doors were installed with no
seals.
4.4.1.2 Louvered windows
Louvered windows are situated on the ceiling of the auditorium, directly above the stage. Because of this, any
noise can be heard throughout the auditorium, whether it be rain, airplanes’ engines, or even birds chirping.
4.4.2 Internal Noises
There are more undesired internal noises that disturb the efficiency of the hall. The lights and the air conditioner
produces a faint humming sound when turned on, and the speakers make unneeded echoes whenever sound is
played through them. 'Clacking' sounds can be heard from the chairs whenever they are used.The cheap fabric
used on the chairs is a bad sound absorber. It does not act as a real human if there is no one sitting on it.
● Air conditioner
Produces decent amount of noise that will bother the acoustic feel of the auditorium.
● Lights
Produces some slight noise deflection.
● 3 angled sound speakers
Projecting at every angle in the auditorium, the speakers direct sound without a proper direction,two speakers
are attached to the wall, two at the edge of the stage, as well as a hollow space under the stage for the
subwoofers.This indicates of poor planning and lack of consideration of the speakers placement that causes
noise deflection.
Control room glass panels
Glass panels can be seen at the top seating level of the auditorium which act as the railing of the top level and
the control room’s barrier from the auditorium, the window can't be opened whatsoever,(it merely acts as a
viewpoint from the control room)due to that action, the sound reduction index rises. As mentioned that the
glass can’t be opened, the sound will reduce and flutter as it hits the glass
4.5 Sound Propagation
4.5.1 Sound Concentration
SIL measurement of the auditorium when the lights was switched on.
SIL measurement of the auditorium when the lights and Air-Conditioner was switched on.
SIL measurement of the auditorium when the lights, Air-Conditioner and Speakers was
switched on.
In conclusion, throughout the three conditions of the auditorium, the point in which sound is the most
concentrated is at the seatings beneath the cantilevered platform. This could possibly be due to the short
distance between floor and ceiling in said area providing a higher amount of reflection, resulting in an increase
of decibels.
4.5.2 Sound Reflections
It is essential for the sound to be reflected back towards the audience to ensure the sound are more effective.
At the same time, the amount of sound reflected should also be considered with the added design of these
reflections in order to reduce the presence of echoes. To reduce the resultant reflected sound, the surface of
the auditorium must be concealed with an absorbent materials even so the ceiling reflectors function to reflect
sound effectively back to the audience and the choice of materials and combination use of excessive reflection
surface of the auditorium have shown the possibilities to make a fluent and lively soundscape.
Diagram shows the sound propagation towards row 5, 11, and 18.
4.5.3 Echoes and Sound Delay
Sound delay refers to the difference in travel time between the direct sound and reflected sound to a specific
point. If the time delay between both paths of sound is relatively brief, the reflected sound will reinforce that
which travels directly from the source. However, should the time delay be too long, the reflected sound will not
merge with the direct sound, thus affecting the overall sound quality. This acoustical defect is called an echo,
and the minimum time delay to consider a sound as such varies – 40ms for speech, and 100ms for music
.
Time Delay = ( R1 + R2 ) - d
0.34
= ( 4.6 + 2.8 ) - 5
0.34
= 7.06 ms .
7.06ms sound delay is acceptable for a speech-oriented auditorium
Time Delay = ( R1 + R2 ) - d
0.34
= ( 4.2+ 5.5) - 8.3
0.34
= 4.2ms .
4.02ms sound delay is acceptable for a speech-oriented auditorium
Time Delay = ( R1 + R2 ) - d
0.34
= ( 6.5 + 4.1) - 10.2
0.34
=1.18 ms .
1.18ms sound delay is incredibly short, even for a speech oriented-auditorium
4.5.4 Reverberation
Reverberation is defined as the persistence of sound after a sound is produced. It is primarily caused by the
successions of reflections off the surfaces in the room, which will result in the prolonged period of audibility
after the source of sound has ceased. Reverberation time plays a major part in affecting the quality of speech
and music within a given space - it can either create a live space, in which sound continues to reflect for a long
period of time, or a dead space, in which sound cannot be sustained. Reverberation time differs for different
types of sound - what is optimal for speech-oriented activity produces disastrous results for music.
Rt = 0.16V/A , whereby
V= volume of the room (m3),
A= total absorption of room surfaces
Since,
V = 5753.6m3
A= 776.02m2 sabins
then,
0.16( 5753.6)/ 776.02
=1.18s
Since the recommended reverberation time for large rooms (>7500m3) is 1.00, the reverberation time for this
hall is too long. Thus, it is not conducive for good speech intelligibility. However, it is suitable for
music-orientated activities,
Rt = 0.16V/A , whereby
V= volume of the room (m3),
A= total absorption of room surfaces
Since,
V = 5753.6m3
Rt = 1s
Then
0.16( 5753.6)/1
= 920.58m2 sabins
920.58m2 sabins - 776.02 sabins (current auditorium absorption) = 144.56m2 sabins
In order to have a good speech intelligibility auditorium, Permata Pintar Auditorium has to increase their
absorption of room surfaces to another 144.56m2 sabins.
4.5.5 Acoustical Defects and Design Issues
Besides the extremely low reverberation time, this auditorium also suffers from flutter echoes due to
substandard design. Despite the low sound delay due to the speakers directing sound in every angle, flutter
echoes tend to appear around the stage. This is because of the different ceiling surfaces between the two
spaces.
External noise could be heard from inside the auditorium due to a lack of measures in terms of design. For
instance, the doors that leads to the foyer were found to have a lack of seals, leaving voids beneath the doors
unobstructed. Louvred windows can be found on the roof of the auditorium, allowing foreign sounds to disrupt
the interior space, especially during rain.
Furthermore, the usage of cheap seats are one of the main reasons for the occurrence of acoustical
defects. The thin fabric does not act as a great sound absorbent materials. This is an inefficient use of the
available sound energy, and a better acoustical feel would be produced if the seats were made with better
material.
References
Flooring :
http://www.colincheneyflooring.com.au/main/page_timber_species.html
http://www.floorfacts.com/compare/laminate-floors.html
https://crystalcarpet.net/hollow-sounding-laminate-floors-what-will-help/
https://www.lowes.com/projects/build-and-remodel/carpet-buying-guide/project
http://www.diynetwork.com/how-to/rooms-and-spaces/floors/your-guide-to-the-different-types-of-carpet
https://www.builddirect.com/learning-center/home-improvement-info/sound-transmission/
Sound Frequency :
http://www.seaindia.in/blog/human-voice-frequency-range/
Materials Coefficient:
https://cds.cern.ch/record/1251519/files/978-3-540-48830-9_BookBackMatter.pdf
Reverberation:
http://www.acoustics.com/101.asp