Final Assignment Cra
Final Assignment Cra
This is a report about Farmican plc. for the years 2011, 2012 and 2013.
The purpose of this report is to interpret the financial performance,
financial position, cash flows and investor ratios of the company. The
interpretation will present the performance, profitability, efficiency and
the risk as well as the future prospect and growth of Farmican plc. For the
analysis of financial performance ROCE and Net profit ratios were used.
Gearing and interest cover ratios were used for the financial position
while for the investors section, dividend yield, dividend cover and price
earning ratio were analyzed. An overall analysis of cash flow position
was made and an other information section was included as well. Finally,
Shire plc. was used for the comparison of Farmican plc.
FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE
ROCE-Return on capital employed
2011 ROCE
Farmican plc. had a ROCE of 19.13 %, in 2011, which is a quite remarkable and
attractive percentage of return.
2012 ROCE
In 2012, ROCE increased to 27.24%. This indicates that the companys managers
make better use of the available capital, as a result, returning higher profits. This can
be seen by the improvement in operating profit, which occurred due to the significant
increase of unpatented products revenue after the unexpected fire to a competitors
factory. Moreover, the operating improvements resulted in an overall reduction of
operating expense and as further result, an increase of operating profit.
2013 ROCE
The ROCE percentage though, had decreased to 22.66%, in 2013. The main reason
for this effect was the reduction of operating profit. Even though, the sales of patented
products were excellent after the launch of Farmaface in the market, the unpatented
and licensing royalties sales decreased dramatically for Farmican plc. Some of the
unpatented products had to be sacrificed for the production of the new product and an
agreement with an important customer ceased to exist reducing significantly licensing
royalties. In addition, the cancellation of research and development project on the foot
care helped the improvement of operating profit as well.
The companys net profit margin in 2012 increased 7.15% compared to 2012 but
it dropped by 1.86% in2013. The reasons for these changes its the fluctuations
of revenues and expenses in the last two years.
Revenues
Expenses
Market position. Comparing Farmican with Shire for the year 2013, it seems
that Farmicans financial performance is slightly better than Shires, according to
Net profit margins, which are 19.98% and 19.47% respectively.
FINANCIAL POSITION-SOLVENCY
GEARING RATIO
2012
2013
Farmican plc. had to borrow a further 120 million to invest in new facilities,
for the company to cover its production needs, since the company was in
shortage of capacity for unpatented products and for the payment of 150
million of the claim of patented product Farmaface.
On 15th October 2013, Farmican plc. borrowed another 100 million to acquire
its new manufacturing facilities in China to extend even more its production
capacity.
INTEREST COVER
2012
Interest cover has increased significantly by 5.8 times from 2011 to 2012. This
is a result of an increase in revenue of the unpatented products, resulting in an
increase in operating profit. In addition, the increase in interest cover was also
affected by the repayment of 20 million in year 2012. The repayment had a
further result of reducing the finance costs down to 56 million from the 65
million, which were in 2011.
2013
Interest cover in 2013 dropped by 6.76 times from 12.6 to 5.84. Even though
the profits from operations had a small reduction, the main factor for this
decrease is the major increase of finance cost which almost doubled as
compared to the previous year. After the borrowing of 120 million, which was
used in investment in facilities, the total borrowings reached 1000million at
the end of the year. The finance cost though, increased disproportionally to the
new borrowing.
Future
Farmican plc. borrowed a further 100 million on 15th October 2013 to fund
its new facilities in China. Moreover, the companys directors are negotiating
new agreements to replace the borrowings expiring in 2014. If the interest rate
though remains at the same percentage as now, which is 11.15%, then it is
expected that interest cover will be reduced even more. This will also affect the
cash, as a significant amount will be absorbed by finance cost.
Comparison with Shire plc. Farmicans interest cover for the year 2012 is rather low
compared to Shires which covers its interest 24, 86 times. Shire plc. ,has a debt of
676 million and an interest expense of 21.6 million, which is much lower compared
to those of Farmican plc.
Net cash from operating activities for the year 2011 were 620 million whereas in
2012, increased to 878 million. In the last year, operating cash has fallen to 737
million. The main reason, for this, is the fluctuation of operating activities between
each year.
Cash flow from investing activities
In 2012, the company made a sale of products rights, amounting to 62 million. This
action might have been the need of Farmican to inject some immediate cash into the
business to cover some of the current liabilities.
In the last two years, a lot of Farmicans cash were invested for the purchase of
tangible assets, and mostly for the purchase of new facilities, after reaching full
manufacturing capacity. More specific, Farmicans investments in tangible assets
were 270 million in 2012 and 352 million in 2013.
In 2011 and 2012, Farmican repaid 20 million each year, reducing on the same time
the finance cost payable. In 2013 though, due to the investment, that had to be
undertaken for the new manufacturing facilities, a further borrowing of 120 million
had to be obtained. The additional amount of money acquired, resulted in a significant
amount of cash inflow into the company. However, the increased borrowing, together
with the higher interest rate, has resulted in an increase of finance costs of nearly two
times.
Farmican spends a significant amount of cash each year to pay dividends, keeping its
shareholders satisfied. So far, the company paid dividends of 240 million, 255
million and 260 million for the years 2011, 2012 and 2013 respectively and
proposed further dividends of 260 million for 2014. The dividend payments is one of
the highest cash outflows of the company but it seems that Farmican will be able to
keep paying high dividends in the future.
Farmicans dividend yield had a huge reduction within the last two years from 5.31%
on 2011 down to 2.83% today. A combination of the share market price and dividend
paid out, has affected the drop of the dividend yield. The main reason for this
reduction though is the sharp increase of shares market price.
The other reason which affected the dividend yield drop, but in a lesser extent, is the
constantly increasing dividend paid to shareholders in the last three years.
Comparison with Shire plc. Comparing Farmican plc. with Shire plc., it is clear that
Farmicans return on investment is much higher than that of Shire, which is only
0.16%.
In addition, Farmican plc. pays much higher dividends, which reaching 260 pence
per share, compared to just 11.13 pence for Shire plc.
DIVIDEND COVER
Farmican plc. is covering its dividends from earning 1.82 times in the current year,
while was covering them, 1.17 times and 2.32 times in the years 2011 and 2012,
respectively. Considering that dividends per share are almost the same during the last
years, it is quite obvious that the main reason for the change in the ratio is the
Earnings per Share.
In 2011, Famican plc. had a dividend cover ratio of 1.17 times which is quite
low. It must be taken into consideration though that Farmican plc. paid 85.57%
of its earnings as dividends which is a really high proportion.
In the following year, dividend cover reached 2.32 times due to the fact that
earnings doubled, compared to 2011. In 2013 and according to payout ratio,
Farmican will pay 54.97% of its earnings as dividend. This brings the dividend
cover to 1.82 times.
The price-earning ratio reflects the markets appraisal of the shares future prospects.
The ratio had a constant improvement during the last 3 years and now it is 19.45.
High demand. The high demand for Farmicans plc. shares during the last few
years, has led to the rapid increase of the price earnings ratio as well. This high
demand though was foreseeable since Farmican plc. is operating in the
pharmaceutical industry, which has been one of the best performing and
growing sectors in the year, so far. (ref)
Additionally, the decision of Farmican to invest heavily to acquire new
facilities for its production, led to a further increase of market share price, as
investors are expecting large amounts of profits in the following years.
Comparison with Shire plc. Shire has a price-earnings ratio of 21.14 times, which is
slightly higher than Farmicans 19.45 times. Shire is growing steadily in the industry
and this can be seen by their latest report and the increase of their current market
price, which reached 28.22. However, the high price-earning ratio can also be
explained with the low earnings per share of 1.34. On the other hand, Farmican plc.
has a price earning ratio of 19.45 times which increased significantly during the last
three years and 4.73 as earnings per share.
Other information
Tax investigation
Farmican plc. is under investigation by HMRC for low rate of taxation, after
receiving negative publicity from the Public Accounts Committee. However,
further investigation is needed to find out if HMRC will charge the company with
penalty fees. Farmican plc. might need further borrowings to cover this
payment.
Farmican issued share options to the managers of the company, which can be
exercisable in 2018 if they achieve a certain performance. This will have a
negative impact on Earnings per share since the profit for the year will be
allocated to more shares, therefore less available dividend for each share. This
will be the case if profits remain on the same level as today. However, if profits of
the year increase, then the Earnings per share will increase as well.
Quality improvements
London stock exchange. (2013) Shires income plc. ord 50p. [Online] [Accessed on 30th Nov
2013] http://www.londonstockexchange.com/exchange/prices/stocks/summary/fundamen
UK Deposits.org. (2013) UK Bank Account Rates - Compare UK Bank Interest Rates. [Online]
[Accessed on 1st Dec 2013] http://uk.deposits.org
Hargeaves Lansdown. (2013) Pharmaceutical shares: is now the time to invest?. [Online]
[Accessed on 3rd Dec 2013] http://www.hl.co.uk/news/articles/archive/pharmaceutical-
shares-is-now-the-time-to-invest
Shire plc. (2012) Company profile Shire plc. Shire pharmaceutical group, 1., November,
pp.7-8.