The Boy in Striped Pyjamas - Notes
The Boy in Striped Pyjamas - Notes
OVERVIEW
Teaching suggestion: Published in 2006, John Boynes story of a nine-year old
Students can be asked to German boys friendship with a Jewish prisoner of his
look up background own age in the concentration camp at Auschwitz is
knowledge on Nazi described as a fable, possibly to counter criticisms that
Germany,and the Holocaust it is impossible that the young Bruno should be so
and the part these played in
World War II. A short quiz can
unaware of the persecution of the Jews at this time. A
be conducted to test fable after all is a fictitious tale with moral implications.
knowledge acquired. See In spite of controversial reactions , the work became an
Annex A immediate best-seller. It became no. 1 on the New
York Times best-seller list. More than 5 million copies
have been sold throughout the world and translated into
40 languages. A film version was produced in 2008.
The appeal of the tale lies in the innocence of the
uncorrupted Bruno through whose eyes the reader is
made to view the horrifying realities of the Holocaust. It
reads like an ordinary boys adventure story of
exploration and discovery, the buoyancy and humour
masking the grimness and inhumanity of the persecution
of the Jews in Nazi Germany. Increasingly, the sombre
overtones take over while the reader is led to the
searing climax which is as unexpected as it is tragic.
Author
John Boyne is an Irish novelist (born April 30, 1971) and
educated at Trinity College where he started writing and
getting published. He studied Creative Wriitng at East
Anglia University where he received the Curtis Brown
Award. He is the author of eight novels, most notably
The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, and many short
stories, though this novel was the first he wrote for
younger readers, and one which he wrote within a very
short time. He finished the entire first draft in two and a
half days, writing almost non-stop. He is also the
recipient of the IIrish Times Literary award, British Book
award and he Carnegie Medal.
THEMES
Teaching suggestion: A shared humanity, friendship and universal
Students can be directed to brotherhood, equal treatment in spite of racial or
the important themes
class differences
(i) through defining the overall
meaning The message seems positive, that mans trust and
(ii) recognizing the themes as goodness will prevail over hatred and violence if he
expressed by actions, events, retains the purity of heart that Bruno symbolizes. Bruno
symbols seems to have learned from his mother the kindness and
1 1
See Annex B (i) equality of treatment towards others,irrespective of
their social status. Even his father has demonstrated
kindness towards their maid, Maria, though, somehow
this has not translated into his treatment of the Jews.
The shared humanity and intertwined destinies of all
men is illustrated in Bruno and Shmuel holding hands
even as they go to their deaths. The similarities
between the two boys are constantly emphasized, as are
the loving ties within their respective families.
1 2
from the events as well as the tone of the narrative.
The introduction
The opening chapter aptly deals with the crucial move,
from Berlin to Auschwitz in Poland (though we only find
this out much later, and incidentally through Shmuel) as
it dislocates and disorientates Bruno who has to find new
friends in this new and lonely place. It upsets his
mother and sets her against the husbands priorities,
1 3
bringing about a conflict which is minor compared to the
conflict tearing the country and its peoples apart.
The conclusion
The ending provides a shocking climax, especially as the
narrative seems to move towards the repatriation of
Bruno and his mother and sister to Berlin. Just when the
reader thinks that Bruno will return safely to Berlin
where he can rejoin his friends and embrace his former
life, he goes over to the other side of the fence and joins
Shmuel. The two boys apparently wait for their final
end.
Students should be invited to discuss the emotional
impact of this conclusion. How do they feel as the boys
are marched into the gas chamber, and how far is it a
suitable conclusion?
Teaching suggestion:
Students attention can be
drawn to the point of view STYLE USE OF VIEWPOINT AND LANGUAGE
presented by Brunos Since events are presented through the nine-year old
observation of events and
how it contrasts with the grim
Brunos eyes, there is a childish naivete and lack of
reality of actual events in the specific knowledge in his interpretation of all that is
Holocaust. See Annex E happening around him. He writes with the limited
knowledge of a child protected by his parents from the
ugly truth of war and its inhumane practices. Thus he
may think the camp is a farm, he cant even pronounce
the name, Auschwitz correctly, and calls it, not
inappropriately, Out-With. The Fuhrer, is the Fury,
which again is strangely apt.
There is an element of boyish humour in his
representation of people and places as well as a general
euphemism which make the sinister and threatening
seem harmless. He likens the star of David that Shmulel
has to wear on his sleeve to the swastika his own father
wears, unaware that the latter is the sign of the
aggressive party that subjugates the Jews with wearing
of the degrading mark of their race.
This has an ironical and poignant effect, most noticeably
when Bruno puts on the striped pyjamas, unaware that
this is prison garb, and goes into the gas chamber,
thinking that the doors are closed to prevent the storm
from coming in.
TONE
Thus, there is a deceptively light-hearted tone in the
narration, reinforced by Brunos constant sparring with
his older sister whom he calls A Hopeless Case.
1 4
However, the irony of such name-calling reminds us of
the actual hopelessness of the victims of the Holocaust.
Perhaps the ignorance of Bruno is meant as a rebuke of
the majority of Germans who turned a blind eye to what
was going on in the concentration camps.
Then again, the blithe and oblivious tone of the
narrative also brings out the full horror of the suffering
and oppression of the innocent, that such atrocities are
committed by seemingly rational men as Brunos father
who has shown kindness and responsibility as a father
and as Marias employer.
IMAGERY
Teaching suggestion: The
use of imagery in
Certain stark images stand out. There is the use of signs
emphasizing important and symbols, clothes especially uniforms as part of the
themes should be pointed imagery, as well as the use of houses and dwelling-
out. See Annex F for places, land and territory.
worksheets on the clothing
imagery and the use of Symbolism
symbols Symbols are persons, objects, drawings, logos and even
buildings and places that stand for abstract qualities eg.
the sun is usually used to represent brightness and
Teaching suggestion: The use
of symbols in the text and in
happiness.
literature in general should be In this respect, Auschwitz has come to stand for all the
carefully taught to ensure that horror and inhumanity of the Holocaust, the swastika not
young readers grasp the only as a sign of the Nazi Party but also its oppression
function and effectiveness of this and cruelty, and on the other hand the Star of David as
important technique. The the mark of the Jew, and therefore one of discrimination
worksheet on symbols in Annex and humiliation. The prisoners were also shaven bald, to
F is meant to introduce students further humiliate them and strip them of their human
to the ideas and associations
identity. Later, when Bruno had to have his head shaven
suggested by the symbols in the
text and in ordinary life
because of lice infestation, the two boys draw closer in
common identity. This emphasizes the theme of a
shared human identity.
The fence is probably the most important symbol of
division, between two classes of people, the powerful
and the powerless, the privileged and the dispossessed,
those perceived to be human and those who are
classified as non-human though the obverse could be
truer. Brunos innocence and kindness crosses this
artificial barrier and breaks down the division set up
between human beings.
Clothing imagery
Clothes, especially uniforms, give a common identity but
also discriminate against a certain community. Soldiers
uniforms give the Secret service their pride and power,
as in Brunos fathers smart new uniform while the
striped pyjamas of the Jewish prisoners condemn them
as a lower class, and indeed, not even human. At one
1 5
point, Bruno muses over who decides which group wears
what and why there is this distinction. This is an
important philosophical question on the inequalities that
man creates between human beings, choosing to
intimidate the weak over the strong.
Brunos grandmother, however, ridicules the uniforms
worn by Brunos father, saying that he is dressed like a
puppet on a string. Bruno unwittingly lends to this
shaming by drawing attention to his own costume as a
circus ringmaster which of course, brings in the element
of farce in performing according to orders and
commanding others to obey in a theatre of the absurd.
CHARACTERS
Teaching suggestion: Students Bruno
attention should be drawn to the Bruno is presented as a kind and thoughtful boy who
similarities and the differences treats all around him with respect regardless of their
between Bruno and Shmuel station in life. His only intolerance seems to be of his
and how this is related to the older sister, Gretel, whose sarcasm he resents, but this
themes of discrimination and a appears to be the inevitable sibling rivalry and the usual
common humanity. See Annex lack of understanding of the female by boys his age.
G
Attached to his family, he admires his father and writes
loving letters to his grandmother.
He values friendship, and constantly recalls his three
friends for life back in Berlin. It is no surprise then,
that he turns to Shmuel, and with the best of intentions
tries to give him extra food and help him find his missing
father. It is also his love of play and adventure that
leads him to explore the other side of the fence.
However, it is difficult to believe that a boy with a
private tutor so fervent about his fatherland should be
ignorant about the political situation and not even know
1 6
who the Jews are. This does not prevent him from
having shrewd instincts about who to like and dislike, as
seen in his aversion to Lieutenant Kotler and the Fury.
Shmuel
The Jewish boy also projects the innocence of childhood.
Though he has been subjected to harsh treatment, he
has no real understanding of the political situation, and
does not regard Bruno with hostility or suspicion.
Although he believes that there are no good soldiers and
wonders how such a kind boy as Bruno has a father who
is in charge of such atrocities, he does not express these
sentiments to his friend. The lack of bitterness and the
trust in his friend may seem too idealized to the reader,
but we are made to sympathise with his misery and
hunger as well as the displacement which is an extreme
version of Brunos.
Brunos mother
Brunos praiseworthy values of equality and lack of
discrimination seem to have been inculcated by his
Teaching suggestion: mother who has taught him to treat Maria with respect
Students should be directed to
how each character represents
even though she is a maid in the househiold. She is
certain attitudes to World War II careful not to play favourites with her own children, and
and the treatment of Jews at this obviously disagrees with her husband about his job and
time by Hitlers Nazi Party political affiliations though it appears that she has very
little choice in the matter. Thus she is unhappy in the
new situation but struggles to support her husband
publicly while trying to maintain the childrens respect
for him. Her dalliance with Lieutenant Kotler seems to
be an outlet for her frustrations,
Brunos grandmother
There is some similarity between Brunos mother and her
mother-in-law, a former singer and actress who boldly
criticizes her own son and is ashamed of him and what
he is doing out of ambition. She is obviously in
disagreement with her own husband who is proud of
their sons success. Sadly, she passes away, but
Brunos attachment to her speaks of her courage and
vitality, probably a reflection of the minority of Germans
at the time who opposed Hitlers maniacal policies.
Brunos father
Presented more as a father figure than the abhorrent
Commandant of a concentration camp, we only get
glimpses of the harsh overseer of an inhuman
establishment. He seems to have replaced an inept
former Commandant but apart from the respect and awe
his soldiers seem to have towards him, his treatment of
1 7
his own son, though authoritarian, is patient and
tolerant while we learn from Maria that he has been
generous towards her and her family.
This could be the double standards practised even by the
Mafia who had strong family values and treasured ties
within their own family and expressed gratitude for loyal
service.
However, we do hear him dismiss the people on the
other side of the fence as not being people, the result
of mass brainwashing which could also explain Gretels
holding of that belief which she expresses to Bruno.
He also seems to operate on strict rules and procedures
laid down to his family as well as to his staff eg his office
being out of bounds with no exceptions and how he
expects his children to behave when important visitors
come.
Gretel
Brunos sister seems to have inherited her fathers
characteristics, enjoying control over those who are
weaker like her own brother and Maria, whom she orders
around. Her close friends also enjoyed tormenting
Bruno, making fun of his small size. She herself fancied
the sadistic Lieutenant Kotler and flirted with him
before his transfer elsewhere.
Lieutenant Kotler
A somewhat stereotyped portrait of the SS (Secret
Service) officer with his unnaturally blond hair and
bullying ways, Kotler is the villain of the piece, abusing
the old Jewish servant, Pavel and Shmuel, whom he
suspects of having a friendship with Bruno. He appears
to have a skeleton in the cupboard with his own father a
dissident of sorts. His situation reflects the turmoil of
the times when fathers and sons could be on opposite
sides, as could have been the case with Bruno and his
father, if the boy had not met with such an untimely
end.
Pavel
The old man who has to serve as kitchen help and waiter
is one of the victims of the Holocaust where
trainedJewish professionals were not allowed to practise
in Germany and occupied territory in Europe. He was
one of other servants taken from the camp to serve in
the household, those noticed by Bruno to be whispering
and unhappy.
1 8
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. Why do you think this story is called a fable? What are the features of a fable
, an allegory or a fairytale? Consider which genre or definition best suits The
Boy in the Striped Pyjamas and justify your answer by referring to the themes
and ideas as well as the method of narration.
2. What is the effect of presenting the events through the eyes of a nine-year old
boy?
3. How far can the events in the story be seen as an exploration or adventure?
4. How important is the theme of friendship in this novel? Does it seem to you to
overshadow the importance of family love and ties?
5. Discuss the relevance of Brunos relationship with his sister Gretel. What
does it tell you about the way a child thinks and feels, and how does it reflect on
major themes in the novel?
6. Consider the role played by Lieutenant Kotler in the novel. What qualities are
noteworthy in his character and how are these relevant to the major themes?
7. Discuss the impression Brunos father makes on you and how would you
reconcile his role as father, son, Marias employer and his position as the
commandant of a concentration camp?
8. What do you think of Brunos mother and her conflicting attitudes and
behaviour in the course of the story? How far is she a sympathetic figure or one
to be criticized?
10. Discuss the use of events and observations that foreshadow the grim
ending. How effective are these methods of preparing us for what happens
eventually?
11. Discuss the importance of setting, especially the use of rooms ,windows,
houses and open spaces, to create mood and emotions in the main characters.
12. How has reading this story affected the way you look at the world, history
and the treatment of people? Has it made you more optimistic or more
pessimistic?
1 9
SUGGESTIONS FOR CREATIVE WRITING AND DRAMATIZATION
The class may be divided into groups with four in each group and assigned these
creative writing tasks. The group decides who is to write the speech in question,
and who is to speak and act it out, probably with a back-up chorus, sounds or
music:
1. Imagine that you are Brunos father and that you have now left your job at
Auschwitz after Brunos disappearance. Write a short speech to be delivered as
a dramatic monologue, reflecting on your discovery of his clothes and boots at
the fence, and how you feel about your sons disappearance.
2. Write a short dialogue between Brunos father and mother shortly after they
discover Brunos disappearance. The exchange can take place anywhere, at the
fence, in the house, or when they are back in Berlin.
3. Write and act out a speech made by Maria, the overpaid maid, after Brunos
disappearance. She may be speaking to herself or addressing Brunos mother or
Gretel.
4. Imagine that you are Lieutenant Kotler after you have been transferred from
your position at Auschwitz and deliver a short speech on how you feel about
having to leave.
5. Imagine that you are Gretel and that you are speaking to one of your friends
about Brunos disappearance, and how you feel now that he is gone.
6. Imagine that you are a survivor of Auschwitz Concentration Camp and learn
about the possible death of the Camp Commandants young son in the gas
chamber. Express your feelings on the matter in a short speech to other
survivors of the Holocaust.
7. Assume the identity of Herr Liszt, Brunos tutor and deliver a lesson to your
student on how you think injustice has been done to the German people.
8. Imagine that you are Pavel, still working at Auschwitz, and having heard of the
disappearance of Bruno, make a short speech regarding your recollections of the
boy and how you feel about what could have happened to him.
1 10
USEFUL WEBLINKS
http://www.history1900s.about.com/od/holocaust/tp/holocaust.htm
A simpler, clearer presentation of essential facts about the Holocaust, ghettos
and concentration camps, the various signs and symbols (swastika, yellow star)
used and their origins and meaning. Students can access the website
themselves and learn about the basic facts on the Holocaust.
Videos from the Miramax film(2008) directed by Mark Herman, The Boy in the
Striped Pyjamas:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5-bR1WBOttU
The horrific closing scene from the film, juxtaposing the frantic search conducted
by Brunos parents with the marching of the two boys into the gas chamber
where they undress thinking it is just a shower, before the screen goes black.
http://www.filmeducation.org
An illuminating 17- minute interview with the author, John Boyne, on his
gratification at the public reception to his book, how he feels about the number of
translations made, the fable aspect, the importance of Brunos character on the
effectiveness of the book, the presentation of family life, what each character
represents, and what Bruno might grow up to be.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BysBHJCirfI
Excerpt from the documentary Memory of the Camps, which includes horrific
scenes of terror from Dachau, Buchenwald, Belsen and other Nazi concentration
camps.
Other Websites
http://bookbrowse.com/reviews
A summary is given that highlights the book as a fable, there are brief reviews
from media like The Guardian and The Observer.
http://www.aish.com/j/as/48965671.html
Very useful as the comments here reflect the critical voices of the Jewish
community, especially Rabbi Benjamin Bleck who condemns the book as a
profanity, not just a lie and fairytale, because it alters the truths of the Holocaust
and considers the subject matter of the Holocaust too grim for Grimms
Fairytales.
This bitter denunciation is rebutted by another reader, also a Jewish rabbi, who
says that the book does not purport to be a historical account.
1 11
http://www.exclusivebooks.blogspot.sg/2009/06/discussion-questions-for-boy-in-
striped.html
Contains discussion questions on the novel which are quite similar to those on
other websites but there are more questions on Brunos father and his
relationship to Bruno. There is also a question on Lieutenant Kotler which
probes what drove him to be so cruel. A question on Brunos mother seems to
view her as morally responsible in not doing enough to stop the atrocities at
Aushwitz.
1 12
Poetic and graphic, these are the memoirs of a 13 year old Jewish girl who
endured the round-ups, transports, torture and forced labour of the Nazis when
they invaded Hungary in 1944.
Surviving Hitler: A Boy in the Nazi Death Camps (2002) by Andrea Warren
This is the story of a 12 year old Jewish boy in a concentration camp in Poland
whose friends tell him to treat it as a game, work hard and not take anything
personally in order to survive.
1 13
Annex A
Teaching Suggestion:
Building Prior Knowledge - What is the Holocaust and its place in World War
II?
Suggested Quiz
Activity
1. Class is divided into 2 groups and answer a series of
questions based on the above material.
1 14
ANNEX B (i)
Students Worksheet
THEMES
Readers may react to the book differently. Here are some interpretations of the
meaning of the book. Show how far you agree with each response by filling in
your own response in each box:
1 15
ANNEX B (ii)
Students worksheet
THEMES
Friendship
Symbolic action
Quotation:
1 16
Shmuels pride in his mother is shown when ...
Discrimination
Abusive treatment of another race, class or group
Incident 1
Incident 2
Incident 3
Quotations to illustrate...
1.
2.
3.
1 17
ANNEX B (iii)
Teaching Suggestion
CLASS DEBATE
Two teams of four members each can be chosen with one proposing that the
view of human nature presented in the text is optimistic (Team A) and the other
(Team B) opposing this view.
These are the areas each team can consider in coming up with their argument:
Team A Team B
Tone of narrative -
any evidence of
humour, light-
heatedness, love
and happiness or
anger, frustration,
violence?
Symbols,
metaphors, imagery
Attitude of
characters
1 18
ANNEX C
How effective is the opening chapter in conveying the mood and themes of
the novel?
1. Students watch the trailer from the Miramax film of The Boy in the Striped
Pyjamas (available on Youtube.com) which shows the opening scene of the film.
2. Teacher points out how the film version may differ from the actual opening
chapter of the book OR elicits these responses from the students themselves.
Main Activity
1. Class is divided into groups and asked to discuss how far the opening chapter
of the novel introduces the mood and themes effectively.
1. Students watch the concluding scene from the Miramx film (also available on
youtube.com).
2. Teacher points how the differences and similarities between the film version
and the book OR elicits responses from the students themselves.
Main Activity
1. Class is divided into groups and asked to discuss how far the concluding
chapter is a satisfactory ending to the novel.
1 19
Annex D
Students worksheet
USE OF CONTRAST
Differences in places
Show the differences between Brunos old home in Berlin and the new house at
Out-With and how he feels about the change by filling in the boxes with the
relevant details:
Bruno loved his old home because
Show the differences between Bruno and Gretel in the way they regard people:
Bruno
Gretel
1 20
ANNEX E
POINT OF VIEW
The novel is written from the innocent nine-year-old Brunos point of view and his
lack of knowledge of the Holocaust causes him to represent events without their
grim implications. For each observation, provide the actual fact or conclusion
that Bruno is unaware of:
From the window, Bruno and Gretel see that the fathers and grandfathers and
other people were all in striped caps and striped pyjamas
Herr Liszt tells Bruno that he will inform him of the wrongs done him
The Fury asks Gretel why she would want to speak French
1 21
Bruno observes that the servants in the new house whisper to each other and
Pavel looks very unhappy and angry
Pavel tells Bruno that he was a doctor before, and Mother takes the credit of
attending to Brunos injuries
Lieutenant Kotler calls Pavel names and shows his anger when Pavel spills the
wine at dinner
After crossing over the fence, Bruno is surprised when the room they are
marched into seems warm and airtight without the rain coming in
1 22
ANNEX F
Students Worksheet
Yellow star
Swastika
1 23
Students worksheet
IMAGERY OF CLOTHES
Costumes and uniforms are mentioned frequently in the book, starting from the
reference in the title to striped pyjamas which are actually the prison garb of the
Jewish prisoners in the concentration camps.
Father .. looked very smart in his freshly pressed uniform. His thick dark hair had
obviously recently been lacquered and combed, and as Bruno watched from above he
felt both scared and in awe of him.
I wonder if all the performances I made you give as a boy led you to this. Dressing up
like a puppet on a string (Brunos Grandmother to her son)
Do I look handsome in my ringmasters costume? asked Bruno, for that was what he
had been wearing for the party that night the red and black outfit of a circus ringmaster
and he had been very proud of himself in it.
1 24
Well, if thats the case, said Bruno, and if I had a pair of striped pyjamas too, then I
could come over on a visit and on one would be any the wiser.
1 25