Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Physics 8.02 Spring 2014 Practice Problem Set 11 Solutions Problem 1: Electromagnetic Waves and The Poynting Vector
Massachusetts Institute of Technology Department of Physics 8.02 Spring 2014 Practice Problem Set 11 Solutions Problem 1: Electromagnetic Waves and The Poynting Vector
Department of Physics
8.02
Spring 2014
Practice Problem Set 11 Solutions
1
B(x, y, z,t) = Bz (x,t)k = E y,0 sin (x ct) k
c
Suppose the plane wave front (infinite yz -plane) traveling at speed c in the positive x -direction
passes through a rectangular volume of space that has area A perpendicular to the direction of
propagation and length ct , corresponding to the distance the electromagnetic wave travels in
time t .
Inside this volume of space the electric and magnetic fields store energy and that energy changes
in time as the wave passes through the volume.
The energy per time per area transported by this electromagnetic wave is called the Poynting
vector and is defined as
1
S= EB.
0
The power transmitted by the Poynting vector through a surface is the flux given by the
expression
P(t) = S(t) n da .
surface
The flux of the Poynting vector on a surface describes the energy that flows across the surface.
Question 1: What the Poytning vector associated with this wave?
Answer:
1 1
2
1
2
S = EB =
E y,0 sin (x ct) j E y,0 sin (x ct) k
0
0
c
1 2
=
E y,0 sin (x ct) i
0c
So the energy per time per area is transported in the direction of propagation of the wave.
Question 2: What is the time-averaged Poynting vector field on the fixed plane x = 0 over one
period? The definition of a time average of a periodic function f (t) over one period is
f (t) =
1
T
f (t) dt
0
Recall that c = 1 / 0 0 .
Answer: Set x = 0 in your expression for the Poynting vector. Then
1 2
S(0,t) =
E y,0 sin 2 (2ct / )i .
0c
Note
that
Use
the
trigonometric
identity
that
1 1 2
S(0,t) =
E (1/ 2)(1 cos(4ct / ) dti
T 0 0 c y,0
2
E y,0
2 0 cT
2
E y,0
E y,0
E y,0
T
sin(4ct / )
S(0,t) =
t i
i
2 0 cT 0
2 0 cT (4c / ) 0
2
E y,0
2
E y,0
sin(4cT / )
=
i
i
2 0 c 2 0 cT (4c / )
E y,0
i .
S(0,t) =
2 0 c
1
2
S(0,t) = c 0 E y,0
i
2
Because the integral was only over the time, it doesnt matter what plane we choose to time
average the Poynting vector, our result holds for all planes and so
1
2
S(x,t) = c 0 E y,0
i.
2
Question 3: What is the time-average (over one period) of the energy density stored in the
electric and magnetic fields at the point (x, y, z,t) . Recall that uelec = (1/ 2) 0 E 2 and
umag = B 2 / 2 0 . How is that related to the magnitude of the time-averaged Poynting vector?
Answer: We begin by time averaging the electric field energy density
T
uelec
1
1 1
2
= uelec dt = 0 E y,0
sin 2 (2(x ct) / ) dt .
T 0
T 02
1
1
sin 2 (2(x ct) / ) dt = .
T 0
2
To see this explicitly at arbitrary plane with fixed values of x , make the change of variables
u = (2(x ct) / ) . Then du = 2cdt / dt = ( / 2c)du . The limits of the integral go
from u = 2x / to u = (2(x cT ) / ) = (2x / 2) because cT = . Our time-averaged
integral is then
uelec =
2
0 E y,0
2x/2
4T c
2x/
sin (u) du =
2
2 2x/2
0 E y,0
sin 2 (u) du .
2x/
2x/2
2x/
1
sin (u) du =
2
2
2x/2
2x/
u=2x/2
1 u=2x/2 sin(2u)
(1 cos(2u)) du = u u=2x/
2
2 u=2x/
sin(2(2x / 2) sin(2(2x / )
1
= ((2x / 2) 2x / )
2
2
2
sin(2(2x / 2) sin(2(2x / )
=
=
2
2
where we used the fact that sin(2(2x / 2) = sin(2(2x / ) and therefore the second term in
the above expression is zero. So the time-averaged electric field energy density is
uelec =
2
0 E y,0
2x/2
4T c
sin (u) du =
2
2x/
2
0 E y,0
By a similar argument the time-averaged energy density stored in the electric and magnetic fields
2
umag
T
T
T
2
1
1 1 2
1
1
= umag dt =
B dt =
E y,0 2 sin (x ct) dt
2
T 0
T 0 2 0
T 0 2 0 c
1
1
E y,0 2 = 0 E y,0 2
2
4
4 0 c
By a similar argument the time-averaged energy density stored in the electric and magnetic fields
is
1
utotal = uelec + umag = 0 E y,0 2 .
2
Recall that the time-averaged magnitude of the Poynting vector is
1
2
S(x,t) = c 0 E y,0
i.
2
Thus we see that time-averaged energy density is equal to the magnitude of the time-averaged
Poynting vector divided by the speed of light
utotal =
S(x,t)
c
Question 4: What is the time-averaged energy stored in the electric and magnetic fields in a
rectangular volume of cross-sectional area A and length ct , where the length ct is aligned
along the x -axis and ct << . The last assumption allows us to assume that S(x,t) is nearly
uniform across the box.
4
Answer:
1
U total = utotal Vvol = utotal Act = c 0 E y0 2 At
2
Question 5: What is the time-averaged rate of change of the total energy stored in the electric
and magnetic fields in the rectangular volume of cross-sectional area A and length ct ?
Answer:
d
U
dt total
1
c 0 E y0 2 At
1
= lim 2
= c 0 E y0 2 A
t0
t
2
Question 6: What is the time-averaged flow of power through the surface of area A located on
the surface given by x = x p , perpendicular to the direction of propagation? How does the power
that through the rectangular surface (this flux is negative since it flows into the volume) compare
to the time derivative of the energy stored in the fields inside the volume?
Answer: From the introductory remarks, the power through a surface (energy is flowing across
the surface) is given by
P(t) = S(x,t) n da .
surface
Therefore the time-averaged power is on the surface of area A located on surface given by
x = xp ,
P(t) =
surface
1
S(x p ,t) n da = S(x p ,t) A = c 0 E y0 2 A .
2
For simplicity (to avoid complicated integrals), lets assume the wave at time t has just entered
the box and the box is empty. In time t later, the wave has not left the volume, so no power
flows out. Thus we conclude that the power that flows into the rectangular volume (this flux is
negative since it flows into the volume) equals the time derivative of the energy stored in the
fields inside the volume
S(x p ,t) d A =
U
.
dt total
closed
surface
The power that flows into the rectangular volume cross-sectional area A and length ct appears
as rate of change of the energy stored in the fields inside the volume.
d
Ppower = S A =
U
.
dt total
The electromagnetic wave also transports momentum, and hence can exert a radiation pressure
on a surface due to the absorption and reflection of the momentum.
The momentum carried by an electromagnetic wave is related to the energy of the wave
according to
U =cp
If the plane electromagnetic wave is completely absorbed by a surface of cross-sectional area A
U
p =
.
c
The force that the wave exerts on the surface is then the rate of change of the momentum in time
F = lim
t0
p
t
1 U 1 dU
=
.
t0 c t
c dt
= lim
Since the rate of change of energy is related to the power flowing across the surface, the force is
F=
1 dU 1
1
= Ppower =
S A.
c dt
c
c
The radiation pressure Ppressure is then defined to be the force per area that the wave exerts on the
surface
abs
Ppressure
F 1
=
S ,
A c
perfectly absorbing.
When the surface completely reflects the wave, then the change in momentum is twice the
absorbing case since the wave completely reverses direction,
6
p = 2
.
c
Therefore the radiation pressure of a wave on a perfectly reflecting surface is
ref
Ppressure
F
1
=2 S ,
A
c
perfectly reflecting.
Suppose a space station is placed in orbit the same distance away from the sun as the earth but on
the opposite side of the sun from the earth in a circumpolar orbit (the orbit plane is perpendicular
to the plane of the earths orbit around the sun). The average earth-sun distance is
re,s = 1.50 1011 m . An astronaut of mass m = 100 kg on a space walk loses contact with the
space station. The spacesuit has a cross sectional area of approximately A = 2 m 2 . The mass of
the sun is ms = 1.99 1030 kg . The gravitational constant is G = 6.67 1011 N m 2 kg 2 .
a) What is the radiation pressure of the sun on the astronaut spacesuit. Assume it is perfectly
reflecting?
Answer: We need to know the magnitude of the Poynting vector. We can use the fact that the
time averaged power output of the sun is Psun = 4 1026 W and hence
Psun
3.9 1026 W
S =
=
= 1.4 103 W m -2 .
2
11
2
4res
(4)(1.50 10 m)
Therefore
ref
pressure
1
1
2(1.4 103 W m 2 )
=2 S =2 S =
= 9.2 106 Pa
8
1
c
c
(3.0 10 m s )
ref
pressure
1
2(1.4 103 W m 2 )(2.0 m 2 )
A= 2 S A=
= 1.8 105 N
8
1
c
(3.0 10 m s )
Fgrav = G
mms
2
re,s
Problem 3: Intensity of the Sun At the upper surface of the earths atmosphere, the timeaveraged magnitude of the Poynting vector, referred to as the solar constant, is given by
S = 1.35 103 W m 2 .
a) If you assume that the suns electromagnetic radiation is a plane sinusoidal wave, what are the
magnitudes of the electric and magnetic fields?
Answer: The magnitude of the time-averaged Poynting vector is related to the amplitude of the
electric field by
1
2
S = c 0 E y,0
.
2
So
E y,0 =
2 S
c 0
2(1.35 103 W m 2 )
= 1.01 103 V m 1 .
8
1
12
2
1
2
(3.0 10 m s )(8.85 10 C N m )
The associated magnetic field is less than one tenth the earths magnetic field.
b) What is the time-averaged power radiated by the sun? The mean sun-earth distance is
res = 1.50 1011 m .
Answer: The time-averaged power radiated by the sun at the distance re, s that the earth lies from
the sun is given by
Psun =
S(t) n da = S
surface
2
r = res
4res 2
11
26
Suppose the slits are located at the plane x = D . The light that emerges from slit 1 and slit 2 at
time t are in phase. Suppose a screen is placed at the plane x = 0 . Suppose the transverse
component of the electric field of the wave from slit 1 at the point P is given by
E1 = E0 sin (t ) .
Lets assume that the plane wave from slit 2 has the same amplitude E0 as the wave from slit 1.
Since the plane wave from slit 2 has to travel an extra distance to the point P equal to the path
length, this wave will have a phase shift relative to the wave from slit 1,
E2 = E0 sin (t + ) .
Question 1: Show that the phase shift , the wavelength , the distance between the slits, and
the angle related by
=
2
d sin .
As a hint determine a relationship between, the ratio of the phase shift to 2 and the ratio of
the path length r = d sin to wavelength ; i.e. how are / 2 and r / related?
Answer: The ratio of the phase shift to 2 is the same as the ratio of the path length
r = d sin to wavelength ,
9
r
=
.
2
2
d sin .
Question 2: The total electric field at the point P is the superposition of the these two fields
Etotal = E1 + E2 = E0 (sin (t ) + sin (t + )).
A+ B
A B
sin A + sin (B ) = 2sin
cos
.
2
2
To show that the total transverse component of the electric field is
2
Answer: We first use the superposition principle to add the component sof the two electric fields
yielding
t + t +
t (t + )
Etotal = E0 sin t + sin t + = 2E0 sin
cos
2
2
( ( )
))
Thus the total transverse component of the electric field is (noting that cos( / 2) = cos( / 2)
2
Question 3: The intensity of the light is equal to the time-averaged Poynting vector
1
I= S =
EB .
0
Because the amplitude of the magnetic field is related to the amplitude of the electric field by
B0 = E0 c . The intensity of the light is proportional to the time-averaged square of the electric
field,
I Etotal 2 ,
10
sin 2 t + = .
2
2
(E + E )
1
Answer: The intensity of the electric field time-averaged square of the electric field is
(E + E )
1
Let I max be the amplitude of the intensity. Then the intensity of the light at the point P is
I = I max cos 2
2
Question 4: Show that the intensity is maximal when
d sin = m, m = 0, 1, 2, 3, ... .
Answer: The intensity has a maximum when the argument of the cosine is an integer number of
2
d sin , we have that
multiples of , 2 = m . Since the phase shift is given by =
d sin = m, m = 0, 1, 2, 3, ...
Question 5: Graph the intensity pattern on the screen as a function of distance y from the point
O for the case that D >> d and d >> .
11
Question 6: Determine the average over all phases of the time averaged total electric field,
(E + E )
1
phase
average
2
1 2m
E1 + E2 ) d .
(
2m 0
Answer: The intensity of the electric field time-averaged square of the electric field is
(E + E )
1
= 2E0 2 cos 2 .
2
2 E0 2
E0 2 2 m
E0 2
1 2 m 2
2
cos
d
=
(1
+
cos
)
d
=
(2m + sin 0 ) = E0 2 .
0
0
2m
m
2m
2
(E + E )
1
= E12 + E2 2 ?
(E + E )
1
phase
average
= E12 + E2 2 ?
E12 = E0 2 sin 2 (t ) = E0 2 2 ,
E2 2 = E0 2 sin 2 (t + ) = E0 2 2 .
If you only time average the total electric fields then
(E + E )
1
E12 + E2 2 .
(E + E )
1
2
phase
average
= E12 + E2 2 .
12
where we used that fact that that the amplitude of the magnetic field is related to the amplitude of
the electric field by B0 = E0 / c , and the direction of the field satisfy
Answer: We first use the identities cos(kz t) = cos(kz)cos( t) sin(kz)sin( t) , to rewrite the
electric field as
1
2E
1
S=
E B = 2E0 cos(kz)cos( t) i 0 sin(kz)sin( t) j
o
o
c
4E 2
S= 0 cos(kz)cos( t)sin(kz)sin( t)k
c 0
13
1
Now use the identity cos(a)sin(a) = sin(2a) to rewrite the Poynting vector as
2
E2
S = 0 sin(2kz)sin(2 t)k .
c 0
c) What is the time-average of the Poynting vector? Briefly explain your answer.
Answer: Note the time average of the Poynting vector is given by
T
1
S Sdt .
T 0
Therefore
T
1 E2
S = 0 sin(2kz)sin(2 t) dtk
T 0 0 c
T
E0 2 1
=
sin(2kz) sin(2 t) dtk
0 c T
0
T
1
1
sin(2 t)dt =
cos(2 t) 0 = 0 ,
20
2
S = 0.
This result may seem surprising at first. If we rewrite the z -component of the Poynting vector as
S z (t) = A(t)sin(2kz) ,
where
A(t) =
E0 2
sin(2 t)
0 c
is the time dependent amplitude. Then the spatial dependence sin(2kz) remains fixed with
respect to time i.e. there is no propagation. Only the amplitude A(t) varies sinusoidally with
time.
E2
In the graph below, we plot S z (t) = 0 sin(2 t)sin(2kz) vs. z for various values of
0 c
2 t = 0, / 12, / 6, / 4, / 3, / 2 .
14
We see that the nodal structure does not change. If we time average S z (t) we see that the
sinusoidal amplitude averages to zero over one cycle.
15
Problem 6: Diffraction
A monochromatic light with a wavelength of = 600 nm passes through a single slit which has a
width of 0.800 mm.
Question1: What is the distance between the slit and the screen if the first minimum in the
diffraction pattern is at a distance 1.00 mm from the center of the screen?
Answer: The general condition for destructive interference is
sin = m
m = 1, 2, 3, ...
m
L
a
16
sin = m
y
.
a L
where small-angle approximation has been made. Thus, the position of the m-th order dark fringe
measured from the central axis is
L
ym = m
.
a
Let the second bright fringe be located halfway between the second and the third dark fringes.
That is,
1
1 L
L 5 L
.
y2b = ( y1 + y2 ) = 2
+3 =
2
2 a
a 2 a
The approximate wavelength of the incident light is then
17
d sin
= 2 = 2
2 d sin d y
= 2(3.14)
(1.00 10 4 m)(4.00 10 3 m)
= 3.49 rad .
(6.00 10 7 m)(1.20 m)
(c) If the phase difference between the two waves arriving at point P is =1/3 rad, what is the
value of ?
Answer:
1
d sin
rad = 2
3
= sin 1
= 3.18 104 rad = 0.0182 .
2 d
d
4d
(e) In the double-slit interference experiment, suppose the slits are separated by d = 1.00 cm
and the viewing screen is located at a distance L = 1.20 m from the slits. Let the incident
18
L
L L
m
=
d
d
d
(5.00 10 7 m)(1.20 m)
= 6.00 10 5 m = 60.0 m.
(1.00 10 2 m)
(f) What is the distance between the third-order fringe and the center-line on the viewing screen?
Answer:
L
L
0= 3
d
d
7
(5.00 10 m)(1.20 m)
=3
= 1.80 10 4 m = 180 m.
2
(1.00 10 m)
19
Try pulling the sheet and observe the fields that are generated. In the problem below we will
calculate the electric and magnetic fields associated with an oscillating infinite charged sheet.
Consider an infinite charged sheet that has a uniform charge density and is being pulled in the
positive y -direction at a velocity v (see two views of the moving sheet below).
20
Solution:
a) What is a vector description of the surface current density?
So we need to do Amperes law around the loop. The current enclosed is the product of the
surface current density K with the length of the Amperian loop l . Therefore Amperes Law
becomes
B
d s = 0 Ienc 2Bl = 0 Kl = 0 v y l
B = 0 v y / 2
o v y
2 k; x > 0
B=
o v y
2 k; x < 0
c) If the sheet position oscillates as y(t) = y0 sin( t) , what are is the direction and
magnitude of the magnetic field as a function of (x,t) ?
Suppose the sheet is now oscillating according to y(t) = y0 sin( t) . Then the y-component of the
velocity of the sheet is given by the expression v y (t) = y0 cos( t) . Then the magnetic field
propagates according to
21
0 y0 cos( t kx)
x>0
k;
2
B(x,t) =
0 y0 cos( t + kx) k;
x<0
2
d) What is the direction and magnitude of the electric field as a function of (x,t) , for both
regions x > 0 and x < 0 ?
The associated electric field is then
c0 y0 cos( t kx)
j; x > 0
2
E(x,t) =
.
c
y
cos(
t + kx)
0
0
j; x < 0
2
e) What is the Poynting vector associated with this infinite plane wave in the regions
regions x > 0 and x < 0 ?
c0 2 2 y0 2 cos 2 ( t kx)
i; x > 0
E(x,t) B(x,t)
4
S(x,t) =
=
2 2
2
2
0
c0 y0 cos ( t + kx) i; x < 0
2
22
2 2
2
c 2 2 y0 2
1 c0 y0
= 2 S =2
= 0
Area
2
4
4
Ptotal
two sides
Fv
A
q Ev
A
= Ev =
c0 2 y0 2 cos 2 ( t kx)
2
c0 2 2 y0 2
=
4
This is the same as the time-averaged power radiated, so this is 100% efficient process!
23