Part One Chapter One: Pre-Conquest Society and Custom Law A. Identification of Custom Law
Part One Chapter One: Pre-Conquest Society and Custom Law A. Identification of Custom Law
countryside, or nearby islands. Result: Population dispersal and village growth ->
cultural inheritance spread (by irradiation until entire island/region is under its
influence) but modified according to needs. Example: Tagalog culture and custom
law dominated central portion of Luzon
C. Regional Political Communities
No political communities more extensive than the various barangays, which
territorially were miniscule units
What is Political community?
Earlier theories: requires compresence of both law and operating government.
Example: Tagalogs and Pampangos (at conquest time) do not constitute a
political community, since there was no single political organization which
administered such system of law on a regional basis (so no regional government)
despite existence fairly coherent custom law system.
Later social theory: any group with common interests constitutes a political
community as long as, within group, there exists regulation of the use of force.
Generally, a political community is a society where there is prevailing
recognition of use of force that is (1) wrongful and (2) privileged or legitimate.
From this viewpoint, it is undeniable that political communities more extensive
than the barangays had existed (like large areas or regions under the sway of
fairly coherent systems of custom law).
Because of its obligatory character, custom law was a highly integrative force
resulting to a substantial degree of political unity within area/region.
And the existence of the political community is not affected by the fact that
there was no political organization that exercised governmental authority on a
regional basis. Instead, this merely indicated a situation where governmental
power within the political community was diffused or decentralized
(manifestation: law enforced by barangays/ interested households within region so
in effect: existing government but difffused).
D. Diversity Within the Regional Community
The political unity achieved was highly fragile. As area become fairly extensive,
counter-pressures for political fragmentation came into operation.
Factors that fostered Diversity in Custom Law
1. Lack of centralized administration - through increasing divergence in the rules
applied. Inherent impetus towards diversity (accelerated by faulty recollection of
ugali, inadequacy of inter-communication among communities within the region,
differences in local conditions and the rise of strong datus in particular barangays)
resulted in the development of sub-systems of custom law. No central authority to
oveerrule the innovations. With the interpretation of ugali in different ways,
separate bodies of custom law developed.
2. Emergence of the barangay as a political entity - with the aid of the physical
barriers (Ex: mountains, sea etc.), each barangay tended to lose its sense of
community and develop into
a separate political entity with distinct community interest just like the time of
conquest. Intergration still happened through the Inter-action between two or
more barangays which resulted to application of same rule while still having
G. Secular Orientation
Orientation of custom law was distinctly secular pre-conquest Philippines never
experienced a political order in the interest of any particular religious creed
instead it was concentrated in the person of datu who has no religious role.
Ratio: Religion is a household affair. No organized religion like churches because
common religious beliefs and practices were never institutionalized. No religious
leadership in rituals, such as catalonan and babaylan.
H. Functions of Custom Law
One must evaluate it in terms of how it meet the social needs
Task: Regulation of force in the resolution of conflicts
1. Prescribed the conditions for legitimate resort to use force
General Rule: Unlawful to use violence on another.
Exceptions: Self-defense or to avenge a grievous wrong (murder of relative)
2. Established alternative remedies: composition and vindication by public
authority
3. Determined the order of power, who had authority to resolve disputes.
4. Determined the order of labor, in accordance with the social and economic
status of persons.
G. Preservation of the Peace
-a central function of custom law. Measures and Limitations just like the general
rule above, were implemented. Peaceful settlement through system of pecuniary
fines were established. Serious offenses against community interest is under
highly rational proceedings by public authority (for highly integrated barangays) .
Little distinction between public offense and privates disputes in terms of
procedures and remedies.
Ratio: violence as threat to community existence. every dispute contained
the seeds of internecine strife, with its threat of disruption to community
Romans:
Self-sufficient with domination
Prior to marriage: women are under a tutelage, can't own a property, can't leave
household and make home elsewhere.
After marriage: virtual emancipation -women can own a property, trade with own
money, maintain independent income from their business, obtain divorce and
remarry and entitled to conjugal share and children.
Chapter Two: LIABILITY
Obligation to provide inheritance to the adopter. It is debt because of the limitation of the
inheritance to double the amount.
Case: Householder paid another man's fine even without the latter's consent.
Subrogation happens where householder becomes the new creditor.
I. Extent of Liability of Houehold
Unlike the modern law that prevents total destitution of the debtor through exemption
statutes (so debtor is still left with something that enable him to make a fresh start),
custom law maintains total liability where payment may include persons of its members.
Creditors may make them as their alipin where member is reduced to dependent status.
Adoption into creditor household *totally or in part- refers to reduction of debtor
household into dependent house.
Acquisition of alipin does not extinguish the unpaid obligation which only happens when
there's actual payment or principal. Alipin service = interest of the outstanding
obligation.
Chapter Four: MINIMUM GOVERNMENT
A. Baranggay as political community
Baranggay- consisted of autonomous (more or less) households bound by kinship and
lead by the datu.
Territory- all areas under their control including adjacent non-arable lands like the
communal properties: hills and forests
Dispute on the boundaries between barangays settled thru arbitration.
Political Character derived from the authority of the datu (not only acknowledgment of
power but also legitimacy of its exercise.) Burden of government fell on the datu and his
household as well as close associates.
Actual authority dependent on ESSENTIAL QUALITIES OF LEADERSHIP( to have full power
over baranggay affairs.
1. Character, 2. Strength and 3. Sagacity
Nominal Authority (not full power) authority of the weak, irresolute and inept datu.
Effective authority would pass to more capable hands.
As a political political community:
1. Independence from external control caused by a.) resistance to enroachments b.)
tradition and blood ties as constraint to intrude other baranggay (friendship and kinship
are inconsitent to policy of conquest)
c. inherent limitations on expansions: effective consolidation of authority is only possible
with a very limited area, absence of communication facilities, absence of a governmental
machinery to administer the affairs of territorially extensive community) There was not
even mere beginning of bureaucracy.
Membership based on:
1.) Kinship.
2.) Territoriality basis for freeman that transferred his entire household to another
barangay
B. Minimal Government
A virtual one man show
Minimal Government was due to the (1) fact that household organization are virtually sefsufficient and autonomous, (2) partly due to the scarcity of resources, (3) primitive
technology available.
1.) exchange hands and were consumed by the person acquiring them.
2.) Face-to-face Transactions completed on the spot. NO credit transactions
B. Scope of Property
Man acquired things before he acquired property refers to rights over or in respect of
things.
Primitive societies: rules relative to property rights are simple prohibition of theft or
robbery.
Sedentary Societies: More complex because of household occupying a definite territory
for cultivation or mode of production like accumulation of surpluses for exchange.
Barangay Society: same as sedentary societies as it also assumes aspects of
entrepreneurial enterprise. On certain places, some production was specialized and
oriented to trade. Conquest interrupted the commercial evolution, nevertheless,
foundations of legal development has been laid.
Classic Modes of Acquisition
1. Occupation
2. Inheritance
3. Tranfer inter vivos
There exist special contracts like credit transactions, rudimentary and scarce rules: sale,
partnership or inheritance.
C. Lands as Property
Chief Objects: 1. Land (chief source of subsitence), 2. Gold, 3. Slaves, 4. Articles of
Property
1. Occupation basis of title of recognized owner/possessor who cleared and cultivated
the virgin land.
Disputes on land boundaries bet. Barangays through arbitration
New place or territory of the barangay datu allocates arable lands among households.
2. Succession lands are not sold but passed on to descendants.
In case of extreme necessity, lands are diposed or seized by creditors.
D. Commerce in Movables
Factors that encouraged growth of commerce:
1.) Abundance of resources (land is fertile)
2.) Location of barangay favorable to trade on the coast, alongside larger rivers and
streams
3.) Certain articles that locality can't produce by reason of geographical situation (Ex: fish
and salt to inland communities and rice, cloth and forest products for coast-dwellers).
4.) Common tongue and sharing same traditions and customs (No barriers for Trade)most barangays are related by blood since new communities were set up by pioneering
families in older village.