Project Management Process Guide
Project Management Process Guide
Methodology
Version 3.0
November24, 2014
Table of Contents
Overview.................................................................................................
Pre-Initiation............................................................................................
Initiating................................................................................................
Planning.................................................................................................
Scope Management Plan......................................................................
Change Management Plan....................................................................
Time Management Plan........................................................................
Cost Management Plan........................................................................
Quality Management Plan.....................................................................
Resource Management Plan..................................................................
Communication Management Plan.........................................................
Risk Management Plan.........................................................................
Procurement Management Plan.............................................................
Requirements Management Plan...........................................................
Issue Management Plan.......................................................................
Document Management Plan................................................................
Executing...............................................................................................
Monitoring & Controlling...........................................................................
Closing..................................................................................................
APPENDIX A Project Management Documentation.....................................
OVERVIEW
Purpose
The purpose of this Enterprise Project Management Methodology guide is to
provide an overview of the life of a project and describe a process to help
project managers guide their projects to a successful conclusion. This guide
represents OA/OITs recommendation for project management, and is intended
to aid agencies in moving towards best practices for this discipline. Each agency
should assess their level of competency in project management and use this
information to their best advantage.
Each project, and possibly phases of very large projects, will consist of six
processes:
1. Pre-Initiation
2. Initiating
3. Planning
4. Executing
5. Monitoring & Controlling
6. Closing
Integrated within these six processes is information that covers the nine
knowledge areas of project management: integration, scope, time, cost, quality,
human resources, communications, risk and procurement.
All project management deliverable forms and templates referenced within this
document are contained within a common collaboration website, which is
described in Appendix A.
Objective
The Enterprise Project Management Methodology guide contains foundational
project management process information and is intended to be used within
agencies that do not currently have a methodology in place. Project
management methodology helps agencies gain greater insight into the
management and control of projects. When the same methodology is used for
all projects within the agency it establishes a common approach across the
entire agency. A common project management approach across the agency
increases the probability of delivering successful projects on a regular basis.
Projects governed by established project management processes are effectively
planned; have appropriate change control processes in place; deliver the right
product or service on time and within budget; and ultimately generate
efficiencies for the agencies. These efficiencies are realized by demonstrating
positive and measurable impacts to the agencys bottom line and by articulating
the success of how the project helps the agency achieve its mission.
Additionally, a consistent project management approach is an effective support
structure when utilized by agencies.
When managing a project, PMI suggests using five processes. OA/OIT has
added a process to this list and suggests the use of the following six processes
for managing a project:
Figure 1 depicts the relationships between the six processes. The figure shows
that project management is not a single-threaded process. Although identified
as distinct processes, in practice, the processes interrelate with portions being
iterative. As an example, as the project is being monitored & controlled, after
the project planning is complete and execution is in progress, the project
manager may have to go back and re-plan based on how the project is
performing. There is a natural loop in the process because most projects dont
execute 100% according to the plan.
In some cases all the processes may be used within individual phases of a
project. For example, in an application development project this could be the
Systems Development Life Cycle (SDLC) phases. This usually occurs with very
large, complex projects that have a lot of risk associated with them. In these
situations the conclusion of each phase is a gate where the steering committee
decides whether to continue with the project or to shut it down. This helps
ensure all the information is present and all the work is completed before a
decision by the steering committee is rendered.
Gates are placed at the conclusion of some processes to allow for a Go/NoGo
decision to take place on behalf of the project. A Go decision means to
continue with the project while a NoGo decision means to discontinue the
project. Depending on the complexity and nature of the project, the group
making the Go/NoGo decision may be a large steering committee, or it could
simply be the projects sponsor. Each gate lists certain information that should
be provided by the project manager to help with the decision making process.
This information is contained within the Project Gate Checklist.
During the Go/NoGo decision process for the Initiation and Planning gates,
special emphasis should be placed on reviewing the projects feasibility study to
make sure it is being satisfied, which was the driving force for creating the
project. Included in the Business Case review is an analysis of cost, schedule
and scope, to make sure they are being effectively managed. If the business
case is being satisfied, this is a reason to deliver a Go decision at that gate.
Conversely, if the business case is not being satisfied, the agency can reevaluate the project to determine if the best option is to discontinue the project
and render a NoGo decision.
A project can receive a Go decision with certain conditions. This means the
project continues, but it must be tightly managed, with reports going to the
projects governing body on a regular and frequent basis, such that a project
termination can be rendered if conditions are not met within a specified time
period. The time period must be short, but reasonable, and it should be
determined at the time when the Go decision with conditions is made.
PRE-INITIATION
The Pre-Initiation process consists of the work performed to define a new
project within an agency. It is where an idea or initiative begins the process to
become a project. A project can be initiated from any number of sources and
often begins with a Stakeholder contacting its IT organization on behalf of an
agency or department. Stakeholders are persons or organizations who are
involved in and influence the project. Their interests may be affected by the
performance or completion of the project.
Prior to a project becoming active several things must take place.
Agencies should perform strategic planning when appropriate, establishing
a vision and direction for what they want to accomplish in the short term
and in the long term.
The strategic plan is a place to contain the goals, objectives and outcomes
desired by the agency, which then would be supported by a list of
required projects. These projects should align with the strategic plan and
be prioritized for execution.
Agencies might consider developing a Business Case, which is created as
a result of a feasibility study, for each project. The business case identifies
the goals, objectives, risks and desired outcomes the project will satisfy
and include a list of high level deliverables, general timeline and projected
costs for the project. This information is entered into the Project Request
Form and is used to complete the Project Scaling Worksheet, which are
both submitted to OA/OIT for approval.
Project Scaling Worksheet
It is important for the project manager and the project team to review the scale
and complexity of the project, and estimate the level of impact on the
organization. The nature and type of project can have characteristics that define
the complexity of the project. Simple projects can have very little impact on the
organization and more complex projects, as defined by the sponsor or agency
can have large impacts on the organization.
The Project Scaling Worksheet is used to evaluate projects based on a range of
criteria to assign a value to projects: level 1, level 2 or level 3. A level 1 scoring
project is the least complex and a level three project is the most complex.
Factors such as complexity, visibility, and costs are used to determine an overall
score. This score is then used as a guide within the Project Deliverables Matrix
to determine the amount of rigor applied to the project. The Project Scaling
Worksheet must be submitted along with the Project Request Form to OIT for
review and approval.
EPMO Project Request Form
During pre-initiation, for projects greater than $250,000, agencies are required
to complete a Project Request Form and submit it to OA/OIT for review. This
form contains agency and project information. This is approved by the agency
Chief Information Officer (CIO) and the Chief of Policy, Planning, and
Performance Management, and the commonwealths CIO. There is an option for
agencies to request the use of an Enterprise Project Manager from OAs
Enterprise Project Management Office (EPMO) within the Project Request Form.
Upon review of the Project Request Form by the Director of the EPMO, if a
project manager is available and meets the need for the project, an Enterprise
Project Manager is assigned to the project. If the agency chooses to use an
internal resource or an external resource for the role of project manager, the
agency must simply state this in the Alternative Project Manager portion of the
Project Request Form.
360 Degree Impact Assessment
The 360 Degree Project Impact Assessment is a tool designed to assist the
project manager with implementing the correct governance structure and
minimize adverse impacts at the beginning of a project. This assessment is
completed for highly visible projects which meet the following criteria:
1
2
3
Will impact more than 50 percent of your agency employees (or all
enterprise employees) OR
Will be politically or publically sensitive OR
Will cost more than $250,000 to implement
8.
1
.
2
.
Continuous
Improvement
7.
6.
5.
4.
3
.
For further information concerning the 360 Degree Impact Assessment, the
reader is encouraged to download the 360 Degree Impact Assessment
Instructions. This document contains more detailed information about this
assessment.
INITIATING
The Initiating process consists of activities performed to officially kick off a
project. The project manager is assigned during this process. The project
manager reviews the documents that were produced during the Pre-Initiation
process, and then begins to take the project through its life cycle. The following
are the major items associated with the project Initiating process:
Project Charter
Project Governance
Kickoff Meeting
Detailed Requirements
Project Charter
Once the project manager has been assigned and the Pre-Initiation documents
reviewed, best practices dictate that a Project Charter be created. The Project
Charter defines and describes the project at a high level and is a record of the
initial understanding of the project. It involves gathering and documenting
information from people who requested the project.
The Project Charter addresses the business opportunity, project description,
benefits, project organization, constraints that may impact the project, funding,
and high-level project timeline with milestones. It is a high-level management
agreement and authorization to perform work. In its final state, it is a
documented and approved agreement that becomes the basis for planning and
authorizing the project.
Project Scope
Using the information from the Project Charter, the Project Scope document
establishes the parameters for what is to be included in the project. This
document helps further establish the direction of the project and is used to keep
the project moving in the proper direction. The Project Scope document should
include a list of the various deliverables that should be produced throughout the
project, and have a brief description of the acceptance criteria for each
deliverable.
It is also very helpful to document what is NOT included in the scope for a
project. Again, the purpose of the Project Scope is to determine the parameters
for the project, often times folks can misinterpret information and create a scope
for the project that is more broad than desired. Including information that
specifically states things NOT included in the scope of the project helps solidify
the boundaries for the project.
Project Governance
Project Governance establishes the management and authority structure for the
project. A successful project includes establishing a proper understanding of the
10
11
PLANNING
Planning
The Planning process consists of processes performed to plan and manage a
project. It establishes the total scope of the effort, defines and refines the
objectives, and develops the course of action required to attain those objectives.
Time spent in up-front planning for the project requirements and defining the
structure for organizing and managing projects will prevent rework later in the
project.
These processes define and mature the project scope, project cost, and schedule
the project activities that occur within the project. As new project information is
discovered, additional dependencies, requirements, risks, opportunities,
assumptions, and constraints will be identified or resolved. Due to the many
dimensions of a project, the Planning process may be revisited throughout the
project. As more project information is understood, additional planning may be
necessary.
Rolling Wave Planning acknowledges the fact that we can see more clearly what
is closer to us in proximity, and as we look further ahead, our vision becomes
less clear. Depending upon the projects length and complexity, we may be able
to plan as much as a few weeks or months in advance with a fair amount of
clarity. This requires that we elaborate work packages in greater detail over
time. As we progress through a project, we provide the elaborated detail that
was missing for work packages that appears on the horizon.
The Planning process describes the actions taken to carry out the project and
identifies the level of effort to be administered during the life of the project. The
key deliverable is the Project Management Plan which consists of multiple,
subsidiary plans. The purpose of the Project Management Plan is to guide
project execution and control. It is a compilation of all the planning efforts and
identifies all the work required to complete the project and define how the work
is to be performed. The Project Management Plan provides the following
subsidiary management plans:
Scope Management Plan
Change Management Plan
Time Management Plan
Cost Management Plan
Quality Management Plan
Resource Management Plan
Communications Management Plan
Risk Management Plan
Procurement Management Plan
12
13
Project managers use the Scope Management Plan to outline the results their
project will produce and any influences under which the work will be performed.
The plan should include the major phases for the project, decomposed down to a
list of the deliverables to be produced during each phase. The major phases
should represent the different phases of a SDLC. The list of deliverables will
serve as the lowest level of the projects Work Breakdown Structure (WBS).
Acceptance criteria are also included in the plan for each deliverable.
The Scope Management Plan identifies the internal and external organizations
directly affected by this project. It also identifies affected organizations,
processes, and technologies. Business processes and technologies affected,
enabled and/or replaced by the technology solution produced by this project are
included in the Scope Management Plan.
The Scope Management Plan provides a timeline for significant events for the
project. Major milestones initially documented in the Project Charter are further
detailed in this plan. The plan also includes any legislation either pending or
enacted that may impact the project. It is important for the project team and
business areas to be aware of any legislation that may impact or constrain the
project.
Change Management Plan
The Change Management Plan describes the approach that is followed to
effectively manage changes throughout the life of a project. A change is any
factor that will modify the original project baseline. To address project changes,
the Change Management Plan is divided into the following sections:
Change Management Process
Roles and Responsibilities
Rules/Procedures
Change Impact Analysis Approach
Tools
It is the responsibility of the project manager to establish a change management
process to address any and all changes. Even when organizations have standard
change control processes in place, projects need to specify what process they
will follow. The change control process must be reviewed with the project
stakeholders so they understand how changes are addressed. When a scope
variance or project change goes through the approved change control process, a
decision is made as to whether or not the project should be re-baselined. The
change control process tracks the submission, coordination, review, evaluation,
categorization, and approval for release of all changes to the project baseline.
The Change Management Plan includes the process to track change requests
from submittal to final disposition. The plan is a reference for submitting
change requests, if change request forms are used, and discusses the escalation
process if changes cannot be resolved by the review team. It also describes the
14
15
Project managers are required to document the process they use to manage the
project in the Time Management Plan. It describes the process to develop the
Work Breakdown Structure (WBS), define activities, identify and assign
resources, and capture project updates and status. It provides the frequency at
which the project schedule is updated and also addresses any performance
metrics that may be monitored such as the variance in planned versus actual"
schedule.
The Time Management Plan includes roles and responsibilities as they relate to
the time management process. A tools section identifies any tools that are used
to track work, schedule, and time. Tools such as Microsoft Project, Project
Workbench, and Clarity can be used to track and maintain the work to be
performed and scheduled. Project managers are responsible for tracking and
reporting staffing levels. Time tracking systems, if available, can be used to
track time spent on all project activities.
The Time Management Plan includes a work plan that consists of a list of
detailed activities and the scheduled dates for those activities. The activity list
is a further decomposition of the deliverables identified in WBS within the scope
definition. These activities represent the work necessary to complete each
deliverable. Activity information includes a description, dependencies, estimated
durations, and resources. Tools such as Microsoft Visio and Microsoft Project
allow for the creation of a project network, a graphical representation of all the
activities and their dependencies across the project. Tools like Microsoft Project
and Project Workbench can then calculate the early and late start/finish
schedule dates for each activity within the network, and then display the critical
path(s) for the project.
The critical path is the longest path of activities in the network, such that any
delay in one of these activities means a delay in the completion of the project.
This schedule information is not only used to determine when activities are
planned from start to finish, but it also identifies what resources are needed to
complete the work, and where in time those resources are required.
To build the work plan, the following process is followed:
1. Build Activity List List the detailed activities required to produce each
deliverable. Be sure to use an action verb (build, test, define, analyze, etc.)
as the first word for each activity description.
2. Specify Resource Assignments, Effort, and Duration Assign roles or team
members to the activities and determine the amount of effort required to
fulfill the activity. Then determine, based on resource availability, the
duration (total elapsed time) for each activity. An activity requiring 40 hours
of effort may take longer than 5 business days to complete due to resource
availability. Duration always uses business days/weeks (5 days)/months
(average is 21 days) unless there is a special calendar for the project.
16
3. Build Project Schedule Each activity in the work plan should have a
preceding and succeeding activity (except the first and last activity). There
are four types of dependency relationships between activities:
17
Activity
A
Duration
1
Early
Start
(Day #)
1
Early
Finish
(Day #)
1
Late
Start
(Day #)
1
Late
Finish
(Day #)
1
Total
Float
0
11
11
12
16
12
16
17
17
17
17
17
11
12
17
12
17
10
The Critical Path activities are usually highlighted in RED so the user can easily
identify them.
An important element of the project schedule is the Float (or Slack) calculations.
There are two types of float for each activity:
1. Free Float: The amount of time that a schedule activity can be delayed
without delaying the early start date of any immediately following schedule
activities. Activities G and H in the diagram above have Free Float.
18
2. Total Float: The total amount of time that a schedule activity may be
delayed from its early start date without delaying the project finish date. All
activities have Total Float. Critical Path activities have a Total Float equal to
zero (0). Because Total Float influences the Critical Path most frequently,
this form of float is mostly used when analyzing a projects schedule.
To calculate the float value for an activity, subtract the Early Schedule from the
Late Schedule. For example, Activity H has a Late Start day of 12 and an Early
Start day of 2. Therefore, Activity H has 10 days of Total Float without
impacting the Critical Path. Understanding the float for a given activity can help
identify opportunities for the project manager to delay work without impacting
the Critical Path. A delay may be caused by any number of things, most often
they are caused by resource availability.
The project schedule (time) is one of the critically measured success factors for
every project. The project schedule should be detailed enough to show each
activity to be performed, the name of the persons responsible for completing the
task, the start and end date of each task, and the expected duration of the task.
The initially approved version of the schedule is known as the baseline schedule.
A baseline is a snap shot copy of the dates for each activity and summary
element of the WBS.
During the life of the project, actual progress is posted to activities, and this
information can be compared to the baseline schedule to understand if the
project is ahead, behind or on-schedule. If approved changes occur within a
project, the project manager should consider creating a new baseline, or rebaseline the project, to include these changes. Also, during certain phases of a
project, such as completion of gathering requirements, a project manager may
want to re-baseline the project based on this information. A Time Management
Plan template can be found in the Templates section of the EPMO website.
Cost Management Plan
The Cost Management Plan describes the approach used to plan for and control
the costs associated with the project. The plan is divided into the following
sections:
Cost Management Approach
Roles and Responsibilities
Planning and Estimating
Measuring Cost Performance
Reporting
Tools
The Cost Management Plan identifies all planned expenditures for the project
and the approach to be used to manage those costs, if specific processes are to
be utilized and if certain technologies will be in place to capture cost. The
project manager can use the WBS from the project scope to plan and capture
19
cost at any level of the WBS. As an option, the project manager may capture
costs at the deliverable level, the lowest level of the WBS. It is also possible to
create a cost account level within the WBS, which is usually a level above the
deliverable level, and plan and manage costs at the cost account level. The
following is a list of possible costs to a project:
Direct labor internal & external (contractors)
Direct materials and equipment
Other direct costs travel, incidentals
Indirect costs (overhead) incurred during the project
Administrative costs (leases, depreciation)
Cost of quality
Risk mitigation, including contingency funds
The cost estimate, budget information and project work plan are used to create
the project budget (cost baseline). After requirements have been finalized, the
project manager should consider creating a cost baseline for the project. Having
a cost baseline provides the project manager with something to compare against
actual costs as they occur and understand if the project is spending more or less
than planned. This may not apply to deliverables based contracts.
Roles and responsibilities for cost management are important parts of the Cost
Management Plan. Each role concerning the measurement and monitoring of
cost can be identified in the plan. If certain portions of the project are
monitored by specific roles, these roles should also be identified in the plan.
PMI identifies several methods for estimating costs. For high level cost
estimating, analogous estimating is often used. This is the process of
estimating a project based on another project that is similar in size and
complexity. Another option is parametric estimating), which calculates cost by
using the statistical relationship between historical data and variables (e.g.,
square footage in construction) to calculate an estimate. The project manager
simply multiplies the different variables together (square feet multiplied by the
amount of time to cover 1 square foot) to develop an estimated cost. As a final
option, project managers could use a bottom-up estimating approach, which is
completed by assigning a cost to each of the detailed activities within a Work
Plan Schedule, and summarizing the detailed cost to the desired level of the
WBS.
Cost planning should include time oriented project expenses, which shows when
project costs occur over time. This is possible by using the schedule from the
work plan and associating costs to detailed activities in the work plan. The
schedule places the cost of work in time, which helps the project manager
understand when certain costs occur for the project. The project manager
works with the project stakeholders, including the agencys financial
department, to establish the projects estimated budget. This is very important
for projects that span across multiple fiscal years.
20
22
Clearly defined roles allow all project team members to understand what they
are responsible for and to determine any deficits in required skills or knowledge.
Successful projects have people with the right set of skills and experiences. The
Physical Resources section identifies items such as facilities, computers,
materials, and other physical resources that are required to support the project.
The tools section identifies any special tools necessary to complete the project.
Tools may include software such as extraction, transformation, and load
products.
Staffing is dependent upon the skills required to support the project. The roles
and skills necessary to complete assigned deliverables are identified in the
Resource Management Plan. In resource planning, those skills are matched to
the appropriate people. Depending on the staff currently available, the resources
may come from a specific area within the organization. Often there is a mixture
of dedicated and shared staff. For some projects, the cost and expertise might
need to come from contracted resources. A Resource Management Plan assists
the project manager in defining resource types and levels needed and how long
those resources will be involved on the project.
Project managers should know where people are located, what type of role they
play, when their expertise is required, and when they can be released from the
project. The Resource Management Plan helps Project Managers by describing
the required resource roles, role description, location, timeframe and release
criteria.
23
24
25
to log risks, and how the project team determines response strategies.
Response strategies include avoiding, transferring, mitigating, and accepting
risks. Avoidance strategies attempt to overcome the risk by trying to stay away
from or eliminating the risk. This may require a change to the Project
Management Plan so the risk is addressed by reducing scope, adding resources,
or acquiring additional expertise. An example of transferring risk is to outsource
effort that was originally intended for internal resources.
Mitigation reduces the probability or impact of a threat that cannot be avoided.
For example, selecting a tried and proven technology may lessen a risk
compared to using new technology. If new technology cannot be avoided, then
selecting a contractor experienced in the technology can assist with mitigating
the risk. Accepting a risk may be a good choice if the effects on the project are
minimal or if it is difficult, time consuming or expensive to influence the risk.
The Risk Management Plan includes a section to document the risk impact
analysis approach. This is used to assess the impact of each risk. The risks are
often ranked by risk score to highlight the highest priority risks. The plan
includes tools used to track risks which are typically entered into a risk log or
risk register along with the response strategy. The response strategy is a predefined action plan that can be implemented if necessary. The risk log acts as a
central repository for all risks identified in the project. It can be reviewed, and
updated as necessary, every time the project status is recorded. The risk log
includes:
Risk Identity Number
Description of the Risk Event
Type of Risk
Date Opened
Category
Probability of Occurrence
Impact, Should The Event Occur
Risk Score
Risk Response
Detailed Risk Response
Risk Trigger(s)
Timing
Risk Owner
Close Date
The risk description can contain an IF-THEN statement within the description.
See the following example concerning a Common Operational Picture:
Requirement: Use Common Operational Picture (COP) in DII COE Release 1.5
Identified Risk: availability of DII COE version 1.5 when needed
IF - DII COE version 1.5 is more than 1 month late
THEN - Program xyz release 1 will experience a day for day schedule
slip
26
User Involvement This is listed as the number one reason for project
failure! If the users are not intimately involved in planning the project,
they may add requirements or change specifications later in the project,
when it causes time delays and cost increases to your project. Be cautious
of the person that claims to know what the user really wants. Often the
easiest answer is not the right answer.
contingency plans, begin a cross training plan prior to actually losing the
staff member and add it to the risk management plan and state that
significant staff changes will impact both the budget and schedule.
Understand that bringing a resource onto a project midstream will require
ramp-up and training time. This again means delays and increased costs.
Use the project sponsor to help locate replacement staff.
28
and ensures that spend related metrics are tracked, maintained, and
documented.
The Procurement Management Plan lists the roles and responsibilities as they
relate to the procurement management process. At times there is an
opportunity for Project Managers to work with IT Procurement during preprocurement activities. To help in understanding contractor costs, it is important
to assign a project manager to the project as early as possible. If feasible, the
project manager should be present during contract negotiations so they
understand contractor cost drivers.
The Procurement Management Plan describes the project managers
responsibilities for managing and making decisions about contracts for products
or services. It describes the project managers decision authority and
limitations, including budget, signature level, contract changes, negotiation, and
oversight. At a minimum, the project manager is responsible for:
Tracking receipt, review, and coordinating approval of invoices
Associating invoices and scope to approved deliverables
Managing deliverable approvals and escalation
Reporting contracted spend as part of the total project cost
Working with the Agency Purchasing Office to identify and purchase
additional contract services if needed
Coordinating the approval of contractor substitutions
Identifying and tracking Service Level Agreements (SLAs) included in the
project
Project managers are also responsible for working with agencies to monitor
contractor performance throughout the project. If it has been determined that a
contractor has performed unsatisfactorily or deficiently, an agency is required,
as part of the project closeout process, to add entries to the Contractor
Responsibility Program System (CRPS). The CRPS resulted from Executive
Order 1990-3 and implemented by Management Directive 215.9 that seeks to
ensure the commonwealth contracts only with responsible contractors.
The Procurement Management Plan summarizes key contract options such as
the commonwealth turnaround time to review and approve deliverables and
acceptance criteria for each deliverable. It provides a management strategy
which includes available options should there be a need to change or add to
what is already contracted. Contract options may include SLAs to maintain a
high quality of service from its suppliers. SLAs are contractual levels of service
the supplier has agreed to provide during the life of the contract. If a vendors
performance is identified to be lower than the agreed upon levels, there is an
agreed upon penalty, usually of a financial nature.
The Procurement Management Plan lists of applicable contract documents. The
project manager should have access to copies of all contractual documents. The
29
30
practice because Excel cells can be formatted to easily capture different types of
information. Some information may be number oriented and require
calculations as requirements, while other requirements require free form textual
information. Excel accommodates both styles of information. Also, Excel allows
for the use of multiple spreadsheets within a single file. This allows project
managers to maintain requirements for different aspects of the project without
having to go to multiple files to see the information.
Storage of requirements information is an important part of the Requirements
Management Plan. The use of a document management system is highly
desirable for storing requirement information. Document management systems
provide several benefits to the project manager.
Aid in locating information Documents are cataloged and help users find
information quickly
Control of information Versions of documents are captured allowing for
strong control of information
Security of information Document management systems allow librarians
to control who has rights to read and/or modify documents
Issue Management Plan
The Issue Management Plan describes the approach the project manager uses to
manage issues during the life of the project. The Issues Management Plan is
divided into the following sections:
Issues Management Approach
Roles and Responsibilities
Supporting Documentation
An issue is a point or matter in question or in dispute, or a point or matter that
is not settled and is under discussion or over which there are opposing views or
disagreements. The practice of issue identification and resolution helps keep the
project moving forward and avoids unnecessary delays during the life of the
project. Issues are captured and tracked within the issue log within the Project
Log spreadsheet. The issue log captures the following information about each
issue:
Description
Assigned
Date Opened
Due Date
Date Closed
Status
Severity
Impact
Notes
32
The project manager is responsible for capturing all issues associated with the
project and making sure each issue is being addressed by a member of the
project team until the issue is closed. The project manager should report on the
status of issues on a regular basis, providing the status on project issues as a
part of regular communication. This includes weekly and monthly status
reporting.
Document Management Plan
Document Management is an important part of managing and monitoring
performance and results. The Document Management Plan controls how project
documentation is stored, retrieved and archived. Project Collaboration is often
used for larger projects and shared drives are often used for smaller projects.
The Document Management Plan includes the following:
Document Management Process
Document Librarian
Roles and Responsibilities
The document librarian is an important role for the project. This person is
responsible for making sure the documents follow the document management
process, and ensures all documents are properly cared for. This is critically
important for projects where deliverables are documents. The librarian must
make sure the signed-off documents are protected and not modified without
prior approval, as described in the Document Management Plan. Also, it is
important that the librarian organizes documents so they can be easily retrieved
for reporting purposes. On small projects the project manager may fill this role,
while for large projects this role may require a full time person to handle
documents for the project.
The project team may elect to use a Collaboration site to contain all of the
projects documentation. Collaboration sites are organized using different
folders to represent a variety of project elements where documents are stored.
The Document Management Plan lists the structure of Collaboration site as well
as:
Folders and sub-folder structure,
File naming convention,
Document templates,
Version control
Backup and retention policy.
Document management standards are used to provide a manner for naming and
filing project documents. Documents should be stored where they are accessible
to all team members and must be handled and named in a consistent manner. It
is expected that the majority of project documents exist in an electronic format
and are stored in a Collaboration site or document repository of some sort.
33
EXECUTING
The Executing process consists of activities performed to execute the Project
Management Plan.
managers are also responsible for tracking and reporting staffing levels through
the life of the project. Time keeping systems, if available, can aid in tracking
time spent on all project activities.
Managing Communications
Project managers are responsible for estimating and tracking time to manage
communications using the Communications Management Plan. This plan
describes who, how, what, and when information will be distributed. Project
information is disseminated using project management deliverables such as
meetings and status reports. Meetings are structured around project related
topics and can involve the project manager, project team members, project
stakeholders, and agency management. The frequency and topics covered at
these meetings is outlined in the Communications Management Plan. Meetings
are a good way to bring visibility to all areas of the project. They provide an
opportunity to discuss important issues and make management decisions on the
project with input from several sources.
It is the project managers responsibility during project execution to keep the
stakeholders informed of project status. Information should be timely, and
delivered with a level of detail that reflects the audience receiving the
communication. For example, technical team members may need detailed
information and action items where the customer and project sponsor may need
a high level summary of the status of the project and its deliverables. A
standard format for meetings should be followed for exchanging information
concerning the progress of the project. Meetings are structured using an
agenda, and minutes are produced as a result of the meeting. Meetings provide
the means by which the project team and the stakeholders stay informed about
the progress and key activities required to successfully complete the project.
The project team is expected to report project status to the project manager
who then reports status to internal and external stakeholders. The Project
Status Report, like status meetings, follow a standard format for the formal
exchange of information on the progress of the project. Status reports are
prepared by the project team detailing items captured while monitoring and
controlling the project. S Status reports include:
Activities completed during the current report period
Activities scheduled for the next reporting period
Review of key milestones
Update on risks, action items, issues, and decisions found in the Project
Log
Update on project performance metrics (schedule, scope, cost, and
quality)
Managing Procurements
Project managers are responsible for estimating and tracking time to manage
procurements using the Procurement Management Plan. They must be familiar
with all the contract terms and conditions associated with the project. Project
35
36
37
All of this information is captured in a single Project Log spreadsheet with tabs
for risks, action items, issues and decisions which enables the project manager
to manage these items. . . .
Monitoring and Controlling Project Risks, Action Items, Issues and
Decisions (RAID)
Project Managers are responsible for monitoring and controlling risks, managing
action items, tracking issues, and documenting major decisions through the life
of the project.
Risks
Risks are identified, analyzed and prioritized and responses are developed
during the planning process using the Risk Management Plan. Risks can also be
identified as acceptable or unacceptable. Often an acceptable risk can be
seen as an opportunity. Risks that are identified as high probability and/or a
high impact have a risk response plan. If an identified risk does occur, the
response in the Risk Management Plan is implemented. The project manager
communicates to the stakeholders that a risk has arisen and then describes the
planned approach to address the risk. As the response is applied, the
stakeholders are kept informed of the impact to the project and any changes
that may arise due to the risk.
Project managers continually look for risks that have potential to impact the
project. A risk response can be prepared so the project manager can react
appropriately and efficiently to a risk once it occurs. There is always a
possibility of risks occurring that were not documented during planning. If this
happens, project managers identify, quantify, and respond to the risk. The risk
tab in the Project Log can be used as a risk register to track and monitor project
risks, update risk information, and recommend corrective action, as needed.
Project managers should periodically conducting risk reviews with the project
team to review all of the documented project risks. During the review, they
determine if all of the identified risks are still present or if new ones have
occurred.
Action Items
Action items are unplanned work or tasks to be completed by a certain date,
often discovered during meetings. They are prioritized, assigned, and managed
for completion. Action items are documented activities, events, or tasks that
are typically addressed by a single person. Project managers know action items
are an important method to get work accomplished. Successful projects have
practices and controls around managing and completing work associated with
action items. The best way to manage action items is to record them in an
action item log in the Project Log. Project angers manage the action item log so
actions can be maintained by those responsible for resolution.
38
Issues
Project managers document issues as they arise throughout the life of a project.
Issues can be anything that may negatively affect the project in meeting its
goals. They are usually something that cannot easily be resolved and typically
arise unexpectedly. An issues log in the Project Log offers a mechanism to
record and address unanticipated issues.
The concept of an issue having one owner is important to effectively manage
issues. The owner is someone within the project team who is responsible for
ensuring the issue is resolved. All members of the team should be encouraged to
log issues as soon as they arise. Generally, ownership should be at the proper
level at which the issue could possibly be resolved. The project manager can
assign the issue to someone as a work package with its own time and cost
tolerances. The sooner an issue is logged and addressed, the more likely it will
be resolved without having a major impact on the project. An escalation
procedure can be determined in the event that a solution cannot be resolved
within the time and cost tolerances by the initial owner.
Decisions
Throughout a project, many decisions, large and small, are made. Project
managers are responsible for capturing and sharing decisions that impact the
project. The Project Log is used to manage important decisions which should
always be documented. Who, what, where, when, and why major decisions are
made are recorded and are reviewed at a later date. These records become
paramount during post project reviews. Examples of decisions include:
Executive decisions on project direction
Changes to stakeholder expectations
Goal / strategy decisions
Priority changes
Go / No-Go decisions
Monitoring and Controlling Changes
Project managers use the change section in the Project Log to monitor and
control changes in the project in accordance with the Change Management Plan.
They monitor the implementation of approved changes and control changes by
executing the process to document, analyze for impact, and approve or deny
changes. A straightforward change process will encourage team members,
customers and stakeholders to follow the process instead of circumventing it.
Changes can come from many sources, and are a normal and necessary part of
project management. These changes can impact project scope, time
management, cost management, quality management, human resource
management, communications management, risk management, and
procurement management. They are both inevitable and valid during the life of
a project. Often details are not known when planning a project. As unknowns
become clear, changes to the project follow. Successfully managing changes is
not avoiding or preventing them, but to actively monitor and document change.
39
project, and what is being done to address the root causes. Project managers
report to stakeholders schedule performance metrics in terms of variances in
planned versus revised schedule as they occur. Schedule status can be
summarized using the following indicators:
Green - Key milestones are on schedule
Yellow - Key milestone has been missed but schedule contingency exists
Red - Key milestone has been missed and no schedule contingency exists
Scope
Controlling scope is the process of monitoring changes to project requirements
that may increase or decrease the project's scope beyond what was originally
planned. When monitoring the project scope, it is important to determine the
current status of the projects tasks to ensure the planned work accurately
reflects the current condition of the project. Any factors that may influence or
impact the scope for these tasks must be understood. Project managers
manage the scope baseline and take action with scope changes.
A scope baseline is represented by a fixed set of requirements that are used to
define what will be delivered. Any change in requirements may change the
current scope baseline and may necessitate a new one. Increased scope is
sometimes known as scope creep. It may affect the number of resources
needed for the project, schedule, and cost. Scope change requests can be
introduced by any stakeholder involved with the project and generally
represents a perceived need for a change to a product feature, a project
deliverable, or some other requirement. The change process should be
managed as change requests occur. Scope, and the changes made to the scope,
is regularly revisited and verified by the project manager, project team, and
stakeholders to ensure the product and deliverables satisfy the goals of the
project. The Change Management Plan should include a formal process for the
key stakeholders to formally review and accept or reject project scope changes.
Project scope is controlled by the Project Manager and it is their responsibility to
report scope changes to all project stakeholders. Stakeholders must be aware
of scope changes, their impact on the project, and what is being done to address
them. Project managers report the scope performance metrics in terms of
variances in planned versus revised scope to stakeholders as they occur. Scope
status can be summarized using the following indicators:
Green - Project Scope is being delivered, features and functionality is built
as designed
Yellow - Project Scope is being delivered and scope changes have been
introduced. Impact of scope changes are unknown
Red - Project Scope is being delivered and scope changes have been
introduced. Scope changes will negatively impact project budget and/or
schedule - scope changes are not approved
Cost
42
43
44
CLOSING
The Closing process consists of processes and activities performed to close a
project. Project managers are responsible to close the project by verifying the
project has met the needs of the sponsoring business and all deliverables have
been accepted and approved. Also included in this process is the transition of
resources off the project, the finalization and sharing of project information, and
the close out of any procurement efforts. Project managers use a Project
Closeout Checklist to assist them in closing a project. Activities in the closing
process can be categorized as organizational, contractual, and administrative.
Organizational
Organizational project closing activities include the project manager soliciting
customer feedback on the success or failure of the project. This can be
accomplished using a customer satisfaction survey or other similar methods.
Gauging customer satisfaction is one way to measure the success of a project.
If customer satisfaction ratings on projects are high, or are improving, it is a
good indication that the project is successful. In contrast, if customer
satisfaction ratings are low, or dropping, it is an indication that the project is not
successful. This could indicate a need to review the processes followed in the
project and look for areas to improve.
The transfer of project knowledge is an important organizational project closing
activity. Project managers should conduct a lessons learned session to
transfer project knowledge. . The use of lessons learned helps prevent future
project teams from making the same mistakes as preceding project teams and
also establishes a framework for success in future projects. Problems
encountered throughout the project can be documented and prioritized, allowing
for a focus on the top problems and issues. Sessions can address the following
questions:
Did the delivered products meet the requirements and goals of the
project?
Are the sponsor and business areas satisfied with the end products?
Were schedule and cost budgets met?
Were risks identified and mitigated?
What were the successes?
What improvements could have helped the project?
Another organizational project closing activity is the release of resources that
supported the project. This includes any staff, facilities, equipment, and
systems used during the project. If personnel have been assigned to the project
and the project is nearing its end, it is important to return the resources back
into the available resource pool. This can help ensure that other projects do not
fall short of resources. If the project team has occupied temporary project
facilities for a period of time, it is important to notify the controlling facilities
45
administration that the space may be no longer needed. The same applies to
equipment and systems.
Contractual
As part of the closing process, contracts applicable to the project need to be
discontinued or closed. The Procurement Management Plan may include a
description for the activities to close out any contracted effort. Project
managers work with Procurement to satisfy those activities. Contract closure is
the process of concluding contracts with participating vendors. These contracts
may be vehicles for providing technical support, consulting, or any number of
services supplied during the project. Contracts can be brought to closure for
variety of reasons, including contract completion, early termination, or failure to
perform.
Other closing contract activities can include the verification that all deliverables
were acceptable, the resolution of open items, the reconciliation of any changes
to the contract, and the collection of any supporting documentation. The
contract terms and conditions may also provide direction for contract closure
that must be a part of this closeout procedure. Project managers must
understand any processes that may be unique to administering and closing
contracts such as retaining payments.
Administrative
Administrative closure includes the activities affecting the disposition of all
project documentation. Project managers are responsible for the finalization
and collection of all project documents. During the project, documentation is
typically held in a single place or repository. Once the project is complete, all
the project documentation should be archived or disseminated for future
reference. Any archived documentation should be stored according to the
program areas records management retention guidelines within the agency.
The project archive should include an inventory sheet and description of the files
being submitted and a point of contact for the archived data.
The sponsoring business or organization owns the documentation on the
delivered product, which may include technical documents such as design
documents, installation procedures, and user manuals. This documentation is
usually turned over to operations and maintenance organizations that will
support the product. Documentation should be stored electronically for
historical reference to facilitate later review.
Project Closeout Checklist
Project Managers use a Project Closeout Checklist to assist in closing a project.
The checklist serves as both a communication document and a trigger for
completion of tasks that a project team may overlook. The checklist is a best
practices combination of an actions and tools to ensure project completion. The
Project Closeout Checklist includes:
Assess and summarize planned versus actual for schedule, cost, and
scope
46
47
48