Surveillance and Protection-Based Approach For Link Failures Over Fiber-To The-Home (FTTH) With Combination of ACS and SANTAD
Surveillance and Protection-Based Approach For Link Failures Over Fiber-To The-Home (FTTH) With Combination of ACS and SANTAD
1, 2009, 34-50
34
Introduction
architecture, a single fiber runs all the way from CO to the home. However,
PON has a single fiber that runs from CO to deep in the network and usually
terminates at a splitter cabinet [1]. This architecture is called passive because all
intermediate equipment between the CO and ONUs are passive; it has no active
electronics and therefore does not need separate power [2].
The introduction of PON allows the network to transport huge amounts of data
and provide communication services that play a very important role in many of
our daily social and economical activities. Network reliability is an issue of
deep concern to network operators being eager to deploy high-capacity fiber
networks, since a single failure in the network could result in significant losses
of revenue. The importance of network reliability will keep pace with the
steadily increasing network capacity. For very-high-capacity future optical
networks, carrying multitudes of 10 Gbps channels per fiber strand, a failure of
optical connection will interrupt a vast amount of services running on-line,
making the connection availability a factor of great significance [3].
Optical fiber maintenance is one of the crucial aspects in network management
to enhance the network reliability. Communication networks can be subject to
both unintentional failures, caused by natural disasters, wear out and overload,
software bugs, human errors, etc., and intentional interruptions due to
maintenance. As core communication networks also play a vital military role,
key telecommunication nodes were favored targets during the Gulf War, and
could become a likely target for terrorist activity. For business customers,
disruption of communication can suspend critical operations, which may cause
a significant loss of revenue, to be reclaimed from the telecommunications
provider. In fact, availability agreements now form an important component of
Service Level Agreements (SLAs) between network service providers and
customers. In the cutthroat world of modern telecommunications, network
operators need a reliable and maintainable network in order to hold a leading
edge over the competition [3].
Monitoring equipment for detecting breaks in optical fiber networks is
traditionally set up on dark fiber as this provides good balance between material
cost, system provisioning effort, and fault detection success rate. Most
monitoring systems used for physical fault detection and positioning employ
optical time domain reflectometer (OTDR) [4]. OTDR was first reported in
1976 as a telecommunications application and became an established technique
for attenuation monitoring and fault location in optical fiber network within the
telecommunications industry [5]. OTDR is a well-known means of testing an
optical fiber cable assembly in optical networks. The OTDR launches a very
narrow pulse into the fiber and then records the response of the cable/connector
assembly to this pulse. Both reflections and absorption can be observed in the
36
keep capital and operational expenditures (CAPEX and OPEX) low in order to
be able to offer economical solutions for the customers. Therefore, improving
network reliability performance by adding redundant components and systems
have shortcomings in terms of implementation cost and flexibility [12]. In
addition, these methods are complex and difficult to implement that has
prohibited them as a practical solution [14].
Connector
Connector
Splitter
Splice
Splice
Connector
Splice
Connector
Port 1
Power (dB)
Port 2
ISSUE:
Substitution of traces
From Port 1 and 2
OTDR Trace
Distance
38
information in the form of a packet and transmits it over the LAN using the
embedded Ethernet system. Generally, the hardware development of ACS is
integrated in a single system, which also includes 1x8 optical switch, passive
optical splitter, OTDR, and remote personal computer (PC). Tapping 3% of the
downstream and upstream signal by using coupler can recognize the status of
feeder section and drop section. If breakdown occurs in feeder section, ACS
will send a signal to activate the dedicated protection scheme. But if the
breakdown is detected in drop section, ACS will recognize the related access
line by 3% tapped signal that is connected to every access line. The activation
signal is then sent to activate the dedicated protection scheme. However, if fault
is still not restored, the shared protection scheme will be activated. The
monitoring signal section is responsible for sensing fault and its location
whereas generation of signal activation is sent by activation section in ACS
[15].
An optical switch can be used to monitoring and measurement. The device has
optimized mechanical latching system combined with a prism, and used in
specialized systems such as optical network. This type of switch enables signals
in optical fiber or integrated optical circuits to be selectively switched from one
circuit to another, or may be used for alternate routing of an optical transmission
path, e.g., routing around a fault [16].
As technology advances, PIC microcontroller is manufactured by Microchip
Technology Inc. Currently, this is one of the most popular microcontroller uses
in many applications. It is a self-contained computer-on-a-chip that integrates a
microprocessor, input and output ports, memory for program and data storage,
an internal clock, and one or more peripheral devices such as timers, counters,
analog-to-digital converters (ADCs), communication facilities, watchdog
circuits and special hardware features. Among all the PIC microcontroller
families, especially the PIC18F97J60 of devices feature an embedded Ethernet
controller module. It was integrated Media Access Control (MAC) and 10BaseT PHY, making Ethernet communication possible.
The 8-bits microcontroller has enjoyed a tremendous growth in embedded
systems applications. It is a fine chip that is easy to program by means of a
simple device attached to the parallel or serial port or Ethernet port. With the
128Kb of code space available on the PIC18F97J60, a Transmission Control
Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) stack can easily be accommodated while
leaving plenty of program memory for the application, which is one of the
important factors in such a system [17, 18]. It is chosen due to its variety of
hardware modules needed for survivability in FTTH-PON.
Record Events/data
Control/monitor information for preventive maintenance
Present surveillance image (visual feedback)
Provide a control function to intercom all subscribers with CO
Monitor and control the network performance
Detect degradations before a fiber fault occurs for preventive maintenance
Detect any fiber failure/fault that occurs in the network system and
troubleshoot it for post-fault maintenance
The working principles of SANTAD are divided into three main parts: (i)
Network testing and troubleshooting with OTDR, (ii) Interfacing OTDR test
module with remote personal computer (PC)/laptop, and (iii) Centralized
monitoring and advanced data analyzing. A commercially available OTDR is
located at CO for network testing and troubleshooting in downstream direction
(from CO towards customer sides). Due to the U-band (ultra long wavelength
band; 1625-1675 nm) light is different from the wide communication band
(1260-1600 nm) and has been reserved for standard PON monitoring, the
network system can perform in-service testing by using 1625 nm light source
with no degradation to the transmission quality and interruption. A tapper
circuit is designed to allow the OTDR testing signal to bypass the optical
splitter in a conventional PON when emitted in downstream direction.
40
The OTDR is accomplished through the 10/100 Ethernet port that is connected
to a remote PC/laptop. The Ethernet remote interface allows the users to access
(connect) the OTDR test module over any Internet-connected PC via standard
commands for programmable instruments (SCPI) according to IEEE 488
standard. This enable the users to run and operate the OTDR test module from
a remote PC/laptop at CO, point of link control (remote site), or from anywhere
in the world without on-site personnel for distant monitoring. All the OTDR
measurements are accumulated to be displayed on one screen for centralized
monitoring and advanced data analyzing.
SANTAD is focusing on providing survivability through event identification
against losses and failures. SANTAD involves the fiber fault detection,
notification, verification, and restoration functions. Under normal working
condition, it allows the network services providers and operators to determine
the path used by the services through the network, whereas under failure
conditions, it allows the fields engineers to identify the faulty fiber and failure
location without making a site visit. SANTAD enables the network service
providers and field engineers to analyze the optical fiber lines status, display
the lines detail, track the optical signal level, and losses as well as monitor the
network performance. In combination of the distinctive features, SANTAD
provides a convenient way to solve the particular upwardly or downwardly
measuring issues with OTDR and produce capability of fiber fault localization
in an optical access network.
SANTAD will be designed to operate by itself with a minimum need for
operator actions. SANTAD ensures that when detecting a fiber failure/fault on
the primary entity of the FTTH-PON network system, it is automatically reports
the failure status to the field engineers and technicians, and then the field
engineers and technicians can determine sharply the break point before taking
some appropriate actions. Meanwhile, they activate the restoration scheme to
switch the traffic from failure line to protection line to ensure the traffic flows
continuously. This functionality alerts the service providers and field engineers
of fiber degradation or failure/faults before it is reported by the customer
premises or subscribers.
SANTAD can potentially improve the survivability and increase the monitoring
capabilities in FTTH-PON as well as can overcome the upwardly or
downwardly monitoring issues with conventional fiber fault localization
technique by using OTDR. Overall, it can reduce the time needed to restore the
fiber fault to maintain and operate the FTTH more efficiently.
Optical Line
15 km
OLT
1310 nm
1490 nm
1550 nm
ONU#1
1650 nm
WSC
OTDR
1625 nm
WSC
99:1 DC
PC
CO
Receiver
In-Line
Monitoring
PIC18F97J60
1X8 Optical
Switch
Restoration
Activate Scheme
ACS
42
Port 1
Port 2
1310
1480
1550
1625
nm
nm
nm
nm
1625 nm
L
Port 3
Port 4
The ACS included the Ethernet Module System is designed to transmit the
status of optical switch device connected to our system over the LAN or
Internet connectivity applications through Ethernet connection. The status of
each line is then automatically updated to a web server that can be accessed by
the operator network via internet or LAN. ACS sends three bit signal to activate
the optical switch for scanning each optical fiber line, and sends or receives one
ready signal to indicate each working line. When any failure occurs in the
working line, the first optical switch will route the disturbed signals to the local
protection line and the second optical switch will be activated simultaneously to
switch the signals back to the transmission line. Table 1 presents the entire
optical switch input/output of the proposed live fiber monitoring in ACS
scheme. Therefore, ACS can detect line failures by monitoring each optical
switch routing.
When the PIC 18F97J60 gets an ILM request, it checks all optical switch lines
attached to the ACS. After scanning the ports of the microcontroller, a string of
1s and 0s is formed, depending upon the state of the optical switch connected
to each ACS. 1 stands for high and 0 stands for low.
Table 1
Route
Optical
Switch
Input
Terminal
D0 D1 D2
Line 1
Line 2
Line 3
3 bit
Command
Output
Ready
(RDY)
000
001
010
Line 4
011
Line 5
100
Line 6
101
Line 7
110
Line 8
111
44
H
D2
L
H
D1
L
H
D0
L
H
RDY
L
L1
L2
L3
L4
L5
L6
L7
L8
To simulate the fault identification process, Figure 5 shows the optical power
output of the proposed fiber line monitoring when fiber lines 5 and 8 are broken
by an external force application. The solid line indicates normal operation from
fiber lines 1- 4, 6, &7, and the dotted line shows fiber fault behavior when fiber
lines 5 & 8 are disconnected, and the output ready is low or 0, as shown in
Table 2. The experimental results show that our proposed scheme is feasible.
H
D2
L
H
D1
L
H
D0
L
H
RDY
L
L1
L2
L3
L4
L5
L6
L7
L8
BROKEN
Figure 5 Optical power output of the proposed monitoring when the fiber line 5
and 8 are broken by external force applied.
Table 2
Route Optical
Switch
Input
Terminal
3 bit
Command
Output Ready
(RDY)
D0
D1
D2
Line 1
000
Line 2
001
Line 3
010
Line 4
011
Line 5
100
Line 6
101
Line 7
110
Line 8
111
46
Our in-service fault localization results are presented in Figures 7 and 8. Every
eight network testing results will be displayed in Centralized Monitoring form
for centralized monitoring and advanced analysis, where the distance (km) is
represented by the x-axis and optical signal level (dB) is represented by y-axis.
A failure message Line x FAILURE at z km from CO! will be displayed to
inform the field engineers if SANTAD detects any fiber fault in the network
system.
Figure 7 depicts the capability of SANTAD to configure the optical signal level
and attenuation/losses through event identification method. The failure location
is identified by a drastic drop of optical power level among a number of optical
fiber lines in a FTTH-PON. To obtain further details on the performance of
specific line in the network, every measurement results obtained from the
network testing are analyzed in the Lines Detail form as illustrated in Figure 8.
SANTAD is able to identify and present the parameters of each optical fiber
line such as the line's status, attenuations, reflection and return losses, distance,
failure location, and other details as shown in the OTDR's screen. The analysis
results will then be stored in database to allow the network operators and field
engineers assessing long term network performance (see Figure 9).
48
Figure 9 Analysis of the relationship between network failure rate and network.
References
[1]
Hutcheson, L., FTTx: Current Status and the Future, IEEE Commun.
Mag. 46(7), 136-145, 2008.
[2]
[3]
[4]
[5]
[6]
[7]
[8]
[9]
[10]
[11]
[12]
[13]
Occam Networks, FTTx: selecting the best architecture for the access
network.
2005.
Available:
http://www.convergedigest.com/whitepapers/documents/Occam%20FTT
X%20white%20paper.pdf.
Wosinska, L., Colle, D., Demeester, P., Katrinis, K., Lackovic, M.,
Lapcevic, O., Chapter 9: network resilience in future optical networks,
Towards Digital Optical Networks, Springer Berlin / Heidelberg, pp. 253284, 2009.
Chen, H., Leblanc, M., Plomteux, O., Live-Fiber OTDR Testing: Traffic
and Measurement Impairments, EXFO Electro-Optical Engineering Inc.,
pp.1-7, 2007.
King, D., Lyons W. B., Flanagan, C., Lewis, E., Interpreting Complex
Data from a Three-Sensor Multipoint Optical Fiber Ethanol
Concentration Sensor System using Artificial Neural Network Pattern
Recognition, Measurement Science and Technology, 15, 1560-1567,
2004.
Harres, D. N., Built-in Test for Fiber Optic Networks Enabled by OTDR,
In Proceeding of 25th Digital Avionics Systems Conference, IEEE,
Portland, pp. 5A1-5A8, 2006.
Chomycz, B., Fiber Optic Installation: A Practical Guide, New York:
McGraw-Hill, 1996.
Integrated Publishing, Optical Time Domain Reflectometry, 2008,
Available: http://www.tpub.com/neets/tm/109-12.htm.
Network Infrastructure Committee. FTTH Infrastructure Components
and
Deployment
Methods,
2007,
Available:
http://www.europeftthcouncil.com.
Anderson, D.R., Johnson, L., and Bell, F.G., Chapter 10: Analyzing
passive networks containing splitters and couplers, Troubleshooting
Optical Fiber Networks Understanding and Using Optical Time-Domain
Reflectometers, California, US: Academic Press, Elsevier, pp. 279-290,
2004.
Caviglia, F., Biase V.C.D., Optical Maintenance in PONs, In Proceeding
of 24th European Conference on Optical Communication (ECOC98),
Madrid, Spain, pp. 621-625, 1998.
Prat, J., Optical networks: towards bandwidth manageability and cost
efficiency,
2007,
Available:
http://www.e-photonone.org/ephotonplus/servlet/Utils.MostrarFitxerPublic?fitxer=D_VDA_3.
pdf&pathRelatiu=EPhoton+One+%2B%2FPublic%2FPublic+Deliverabl
es%2F.
Yuksel, K., Moeyaert, V., Wuilpart, M., Mgret, P., Optical Layer
Monitoring in Passive Optical Networks (PONs): a Review, In
Proceedings of 10th Anniversary International Conference on Transparent
Optical Networks (ICTON 2008), Athens, Greece, pp. 92-98, 2008.
50
[14] Lee, L., Kang, S. B., Lim, D. S., Lee, H. K., Sorin, W. V., Fiber Link
Loss Monitoring Scheme in Bidirectional WDM Transmission using ASEInjected FP-LD, IEEE Photonics Technology Letters, 18(3), 523-525,
2006.
[15] Rahman, M.S.A., Yusof, M.T.M., Development of Optical
Multifunctional Switch, In Proceeding of Wireless and Optical
Communication Network (WOCN 08), 5th IFIP International
Conference, pp.1-7. 2008.
[16] The Omron Electronic Component Website, 2008 [Online], Available:
http://components.omron.eu/.
[17] The
Microchip
Website,
2008
[Online],
Available:
http://www.microchip.com.
[18] PIC18F97J60 Family Data Sheet, Microchip Technology Inc., 2008, Doc.
no. DS39762D.
[19] Rahman, M. S. A., Ng, B. C., MATLAB-based Graphical User Interface
Development for Centralized Failure Detection System (CFDS) in SCAN
Network. Journal of Optical Communications (JOC), 29(3), 152-156,
2008.
[20] Rahman, M. S. A., Rashid, A. R. A., Ehsan, A. A., and Shaari, S., The
Characterization of FTTH Wavelength Selective Coupler, in Proc. of
2008 IEEE Int. Conf. on Semiconductor Electronics (ICSE 2008), pp.
302-305, 2008.