Conduction and Breakdown in Liquid Dielectrics
Conduction and Breakdown in Liquid Dielectrics
43.15
T$is (%rce is directed t%.ards areas %( a,iu stress) i(
2 1
) (%r e,a"le) in t$e
case %( t$e "resence %( s%lid "articles li*e "a"er in t$e liquid. On t$e %t$er $and) i( %nl!
#as 'u''les are "resent in t$e liquid) i.e.
2 1
) t$e (%rce .ill 'e in t$e directi%n %( areas
%( l%.er stress. I( t$e &%lta#e is c%ntinu%usl! a""lied 4d.c5 %r t$e durati%n %( t$e &%lta#e
is l%n# 4a.c5) t$en t$is (%rce dri&es t$e "articles t%.ards t$e area %( a,iu stress. I(
t$e nu'er %( "articles is lar#e) t$e! 'ec%e ali#ned due t% t$ese (%rces) and t$us (%r
a sta'le c$ain 'rid#in# t$e electr%de #a" causin# a 'rea*d%.n 'et.een t$e electr%des.
I( t$ere is %nl! a sin#le c%nductin# "article 'et.een t$e electr%des) it .ill #i&e rise t%
l%cal (ield en$anceent de"endin# %n its s$a"e. I( t$is (ield e,ceeds t$e 'rea*d%.n
stren#t$ %( t$e liquid) l%cal 'rea*d%.n .ill %ccur near t$e "article) and t$is .ill result in
t$e (%rati%n %( #as 'u''les .$ic$ a! lead t% 'e 'rea*d%.n %( t$e liquid.
T$e &alue %( t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ %( t$e liquids c%ntainin# s%lid i"urities .as (%und
t% 'e uc$ less t$an t$e &alues (%r "ure liquids. T$e i"urit! "articles reduce t$e
'rea*d%.n stren#t$) and it .as als% %'ser&ed t$at t$e lar#er t$e si/e %( t$e "articles t$e
l%.er .ere t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$s.
'. Ca&itati%n and t$e Bu''le T$e%r!
It .as e,"erientall! %'ser&ed t$at in an! liquids) t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ de"ends
str%n#l! %n t$e a""lied $!dr%static "ressure) su##estin# t$at a c$an#e %( "$ase %( t$e
ediu is in&%l&ed in t$e 'rea*d%.n "r%cess) .$ic$ in %t$er .%rds eans t$at a *ind %(
&a"%r 'u''le (%red is res"%nsi'le (%r 'rea*d%.n. T$e (%ll%.in# "r%cesses $a&e 'een
su##ested t% 'e res"%nsi'le (%r t$e (%rati%n %( t$e &a"%r 'u''lesE
a5 Aas "%c*ets at t$e sur(ace %( t$e electr%desD
'5 electr%static re"ulsi&e (%rces 'et.een s"ace c$ar#es .$ic$ a! 'e su((icient t%
%&erc%e t$e sur(ace tensi%nD
c5 #ase%us "r%ducts due t% t$e diss%ciati%n %( liquid %lecules '! electr%n
c%llisi%nsD and
d5 7a"%ri/ati%n %( t$e liquid '! c%r%na t!"e disc$ar#es (r% s$ar" "%ints and
irre#ularities %n t$e electr%de sur(aces.
Once a 'u''le is (%red it .ill el%n#ated 4l%n# and t$in5 in t$e directi%n %( t$e electric
(ield under t$e in(luence %( electr%static (%rces. T$e &%lue %( t$e 'u''le reains
c%nstant durin# el%n#ati%n. Brea*d%.n %ccurs .$en t$e &%lta#e dr%" al%n# t$e len#t$
%( t$e 'u''le 'ec%es equal t% t$e iniu &alue %n t$e -asc$en@s cur&e (%r t$e #as
in t$e 'u''le. T$e 'rea*d%.n (ield is #i&en as
( )
( )
1
2
1 2 h
0
1 2 0
2 2 V 1
E 1
(2rE ) r
+
1
1
' ;
1
]
43.35
.$ere
]
43.35 .$ere
sur(ace tensi%n) RF initial radius %(
'u''le)
1
"eritti&it! %( t$e liquid dielectric)
1
"eritti&it! %( t$e #l%'ule)
( )
1
1 2
2
2
1 cosh
1
1
1
G
1
1
1
1
]
and
1
2
3
2
1
H 2 2 1
_
,
+%r a .ater #l%'ule $a&in# RF1
m
.it$
1
43dyne/cm and 2.0 4trans(%rer %il5)
t$e a'%&e equati%n #i&es a critical (ield
c
E 226 / Kv cm .$ic$ is a""r%,iatel! t$e
a,iu stren#t$ %'tained (%r c%ercial %ils.
In t$e case %( #as 'u''les t$e equati%n (%r t$e critical (ield is re.ritten as
( )
( )
1
1
1 2 4 1
1 2
2
c
1 2 1 2
8A
E 600 ! cosh
3
R
1 1
1
1 1
]
] ]
.$ere)
( )
2
3 2
1 2
2 1
A= 1
=2 1
A)
' ;
1
1
]
.$ere - is t$e $!dr%static "ressure. 4Equati%ns 3.393.: are in c.#.s. units5. T$e
e,"ressi%ns are quite c%"licated) and t$e 'rea*d%.n &%lta#es .ere %'tained usin# a
c%"uter. Results t$us %'tained s$%.ed #%%d a#reeent .it$ t$e e,"eriental results
in n9$e,ane. T$is t$e%r! su##ests t$at su'9icr%sc%"ic "articles 4diaeter 1009360 A5
and 'u''les #reatl! in(luence t$e a,iu electrical stren#t$ attaina'le in c%ercial
liquids. T$e critical c%nditi%n is reac$ed .$en ca&ities are (%red due t% /er% "ressure
c%nditi%ns #i&en '!
c '( es s h
% % % % % ) + +
43.65 .$ere)
c
'(
es
s
h
% co*+omb,c (ress*re)
% 'a(o*r (ress*re ,ns,de -he ca',-y)
% e+ec-ros-a-,c (ress*re)
% (ress*re d*e -o s*r.ace -ens,on) and
% hydros-a-,c (ress*re.
+r% t$is c%nditi%n) an e,"ressi%n $as 'een %'tained (%r t$e a,iu 'rea*d%.n
stren#t$ %( "ure liquids .$ic$ .as (%und t% 'e in #%%d a#reeent .it$ t$e e,"eriental
results.
In #eneral) t$e ca&itati%n and 'u''le t$e%ries tr! t% e,"lain t$e $i#$est 'rea*d%.n
stren#t$s %'taina'le) c%nsiderin# t$e ca&ities %r 'u''les (%red in t$e liquid dielectrics.
T$eral ;ec$anis %( Brea*d%.n
An%t$er ec$anis "r%"%sed t% e,"lain 'rea*d%.n under "ulse c%nditi%ns is t$eral
'rea*d%.n. T$is ec$anis is 'ased %n t$e e,"eriental %'ser&ati%ns %( e,treel!
lar#e currents Gust 'e(%re 'rea*d%.n. T$ese $i#$ current "ulses are 'elie&ed t%
%ri#inate (r% t$e ti"s %( t$e icr%sc%"ic "r%Gecti%ns %n t$e cat$%de sur(ace .it$
densities %( t$e %rder %(
2
1A/cm . T$ese $i#$ densit! current "ulses #i&e rise t% l%cali/ed
$eatin# %( t$e %il .$ic$ a! lead t% t$e (%rati%n %( t$e &a"%r 'u''les. T$e &a"%r
'u''les are (%red .$en t$e ener#! e,ceeds
$ 3
10 //cm . W$en a 'u''le is (%red)
'rea*d%.n (%ll%.s) eit$er 'ecause %( its el%n#ati%n t% a critical si/e %r .$en it
c%"letel! 'rid#es t$e #a" 'et.een t$e electr%des. In eit$er case) it .ill result in t$e
(%rati%n %( a s"ar*. Acc%rdin# t% t$is ec$anis) t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ de"ends %n
t$e "ressure and t$e %lecular structure %( t$e liquid. +%r e,a"le) in n9al*anes t$e
'rea*d%.n stren#t$ .as %'ser&ed t% de"end %n t$e c$ain len#t$ %( t$e %lecule. T$is
t$e%r! is %nl! a""lica'le at &er! sall len#t$s ( )
100 m and d%es n%t e,"lain t$e
reducti%n in 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ .it$ increase #a" len#t$s.
c. Stressed Oil 7%lue T$e%r!
In c%ercial liquids .$ere inute traces %( i"urities are "resent) t$e 'rea*d%.n
stren#t$ is deterined '! t$e Hlar#est "%ssi'le i"urit!I %r H.ea* lin*I. On a statistical
'asis it .as "r%"%sed t$at t$e electrical 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ %( t$e %il is de(ined '! t$e
.ea*est re#i%n in t$e %il) nael!) t$e re#i%n .$ic$ is stressed t% t$e a,iu and '!
t$e &%lue %( %il included in t$at re#i%n. In n%n9uni(%r (ields) t$e stressed %il &%lue is
ta*en as t$e &%lue .$ic$ is c%ntained 'et.een t$e a,iu stress ( )
ma0
E c%nt%ur
and 0.< ( )
ma0
E c%nt%ur. Acc%rdin# t% t$is t$e%r! t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$ is in&ersel!
"r%"%rti%nal t% t$e stressed %il &%lue.
T$e 'rea*d%.n &%lta#e is $i#$l! in(luenced '! t$e #as c%ntent in t$e %il) t$e
&isc%sit! %( t$e %il) and t$e "resence %( %t$er i"urities. T$ese 'ein# uni(%rl!
distri'uted) increase in t$e stressed %il &%lue c%nsequentl! results in a reducti%n in t$e
'rea*d%.n &%lta#e. T$e &ariati%n %( t$e 'rea*d%.n &%lta#e stress .it$ t$e stressed %il
&%lue is s$%.n in +i#. 3.:.
3.: CONCLUSIONS
All t$e t$e%ries discussed a'%&e d% n%t c%nsider t$e de"endence %( 'rea*d%.n stren#t$
%n t$e #a" len#t$. T$e! all tr! t% acc%unt (%r t$e a,iu %'taina'le 'rea*d%.n
stren#t$ %nl!. >%.e&er) t$e e,"eriental e&idence s$%.ed t$at t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$
%( a liquid de"ends %n t$e #a" len#t$) #i&en '! t$e (%ll%.in# e,"ressi%n)
:00
300
300
100
0
10
93
1.0 10
3
10
:
10
=
Stressed %il &%lue 4cc5
Brea*d%.n
Stress
4*78c5
+i# 3.: -%.er (requenc! 460 >/5 a.c 'rea*d%.n stress as (uncti%n %(
stressed %il &%lue
%ne inute .it$stand &%lta#e
Wit$ stead! &%lta#e rise
n
b
V Ad .$ere)
d=ga( +eng-h)
A=cons-an-)and
n=cons-an-)a+1ays +ess -han 1.
T$e 'rea*d%.n &%lta#e als% de"ends %n t$e nature %( t$e &%lta#e) t$e %de in .$ic$
t$e &%lta#e is a""lied) and t$e tie %( a""licati%n. T$e a'%&e relati%ns$i" is %( "ractical
i"%rtance) and t$e electrical stress %( #i&en %il used in desi#n is %'tained (r% t$is.
Durin# t$e last ten !ears) researc$ .%r* is directed %n t$e easureents %( disc$ar#e
ince"ti%n 4startin#5 le&els in %il and t$e 'rea*d%.n stren#t$s %( lar#e &%lues %( %il
under di((erent c%nditi%ns.
It a! 'e suari/ed t$at t$e actual ec$anis %( 'rea*d%.n in %il is n%t a
si"le "$en%en%n and t$e 'rea*d%.n &%lta#es are deterined '! e,"eriental
in&esti#ati%ns %nl!. Electrical stresses %'tained (%r sall &%lues s$%uld n%t 'e used in
t$e case %( lar#e &%lues.
QUESTIONS
1. E,"lain t$e "$en%ena %( electrical c%nducti%n in liquids. >%. d%es it di((ers (r%
t$%se in #asesJ
3. W$at are t$e c%ercial liquids dielectrics) and $%. are t$e! di((erent (r% "ure
liquids dielectricsJ
3. W$at are t$e (act%rs t$at in(luence c%nducti%n in "ure liquid dielectrics and in
c%ercial liquid dielectricsJ
:. E,"lain t$e &ari%us t$e%ries t$at e,"lain 'rea*d%.n in c%ercial liquids
dielectrics.
6. W$at is Hstressed %il &%lue t$e%r!I) and $%. d%es it e,"lain 'rea*d%.n in lar#e
&%lues %( c%ercial liquid dielectricsJ