S

ince producing the frst high pressure reciprocating

air compressor in 1915 (the frst in Japan), Kobelco
has delivered more than 2200 reciprocating
compressors for various process gas applications, with
an installed power total of approximately 1 400 000 kW.
Kobelco reciprocating compressors have been furnished
for applications in various industries, including oil
refneries, petrochemical plants, LNG plants, and power
plants.
As an example, hydrogen makeup compression
required in the desulfurisation and/or the hydrocracking
processes in an oil refnery is one of the most diffcult
applications for any compressor due to the requirement
to compress a very low molecular weight gas to very
high pressures.
Kobelco manufactured the frst large hydrogen
makeup compressor (2700 kW) in the world for an
Isomax plant in 1967. In addition, Kobelco has furnished
reciprocating compressors for discharge pressures up
to 700 barg. In nonlubricated services Kobelco has
supplied bone dry hydrogen compressors for up to
220 barg discharge pressure.
PROCESS
CRITICAL
COMPRESSORS
Naoki Akamo, Kobe Steel, Ltd, Japan, discusses BOG compressor applications.
www.lngindustry.com Reprinted from Autumn 2008 LNG INDUSTRY
Reprinted from LNG INDUSTRY Autumn 2008 www.lngindustry.com
For cryogenic service, the company developed
and manufactured the frst cryogenic gas reciprocating
compressor in the world, for nitrogen service, operating
with an inlet temperature near -150 C.
Utilising its existing technology base combined with
and supported by a wealth of proven experience in
many process gas services, the company developed
and manufactured the LNG BOG reciprocating gas
compressor. These reciprocating compressors are
capable of handling inlet temperatures of -150 C, as
required for LNG receiving terminals in Japan, and
elsewhere. The company has now manufactured and
supplied more than 60 low temperature, reciprocating
compressors in various cryogenic services throughout
the world.
LNG storage facilities and BOG compressors
LNG stored in the tank generates BOG during
various operations and processes. This BOG should
be recovered to minimise the energy loss and
environmental impact, as well as provide additional
revenue to the owners operations.
Source of BOG are as follows:
Heat ingress into the LNG storage tank, unloading
systems and its associated piping.
Boiling quality difference.
l
l
Volume displacement during unloading.
Heat input from unloading pumps.
Barometric pressure variations.
Pressure difference between the LNG carrier and the
storage tank.
BOG recovery sequence is:
BOG is pressurised to medium pressure.
Pressurised BOG is reliquefied by LNG.
Reliquefied LNG is pressurised and sent out to the
vaporiser by the LNG pump.
The role of the BOG compressor is to compress
the BOG to reliquefaction pressure levels. Figure 1
represents a typical LNG receiving terminal. The fow,
equipment layout, and BOG compressors are shown.
Key technology of reciprocating compressor for cryogenic
service
Reciprocating compressor
Predictable performance
To accurately predict the performance, the company
has its own database, accumulated from over 90 years
of research and experience with process reciprocating
compressors. Preheat is one of the most important
considerations when designing BOG compressors in
cryogenic service. Compressor capacity varies due to
the actual inlet gas temperature inside the compressor
cylinder and passageways. The inlet gas temperature
is increased by heating from ambient, and, if the
preheat is not considered, the compressor capacity
will be lower than the required design capacity, and
the discharge gas temperature will also be higher than
expected. Furthermore, the effect of preheat varies,
depending upon the compressor load and the inlet
gas temperature. Therefore, preheat has a signifcant
impact on the compressor design and performance,
and must be considered. Kobelco accumulated a large
database of feld operating data, plus experimental
data from the test bench under ultra low temperatures,
and analysed the internal and external operating
factors. Thus, the company has considered the effect
of preheat, and is able to predict the most accurate
compressor performance.
A wide operating range, combined with energy
savings
For the LNG BOG process, centrifugal compressors and
reciprocating compressors are normally both utilised
in the plant design. The selection depends upon the
BOG volume and the required discharge pressure.
The compressor type is normally selected after a
careful review of initial cost, as well as the operating
costs of the LNG storage facilities, based upon a
thorough understanding of the features of both types of
compressors. The following is a comparison between a
reciprocating compressor and a centrifugal compressor
in cryogenic LNG BOG service.
Inlet gas temperature
The BOG compressor is located downstream of the LNG
storage tank or suction drum with desuper heater and
compresses the BOG, which has an inlet temperature of
-100 to -162 C. Maintaining this inlet temperature range
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Figure 1. Typical LNG receiving terminal.
Figure 2. Reciprocating compressor capacity
control system.
www.lngindustry.com Reprinted from Autumn 2008 LNG INDUSTRY
is advantageous to the process and the process design
effciency, therefore, the suction inlet temperature
should remain in this ultra low temperature range.
Centrifugal compressors are normally used when
the boil off gas volume is quite large. However, the inlet
gas temperature must be controlled within a certain
level to maintain a consistent density, and to keep the
centrifugal compressor from approaching surge, which
would then recycle, thus further heating the gas.
Capacity control
LNG storage tank pressure is required to operate
within certain plant design limits, even if the boil off gas
volume greatly varies due to heat ingress during both
the LNG receiving operation, and during the normal
holding operation.
This requirement is met by the BOG compressor
capacity control system. Since BOG storage tank volume
is quite large compared to the BOG compressor capacity,
the storage tank pressure varies gradually, and the step
type control will easily handle this rate of change, however,
a large capacity control range is required. For Kobelcos
reciprocating compressor, suction valve unloaders with
clearance pockets allow for a wide range of capacity
control. This step type capacity control is available in up to
fve steps. In this manner, a wide, smooth, capacity control
range, i.e. (0 - 25% - 50% - 75% - 100%) is supplied by
the reciprocating compressor (Figure 2).
On the other hand, for most centrifugal
compressors, the control range is limited (by design)
to approximately 80 - 100%, and the intake gas
temperature and specific gravity should not vary
since the centrifugal compressor must operate on its
design curve, and only operate at least 10% above the
surge or recycle point. In addition, should conditions
of service vary, the reciprocating compressor can
discharge to high pressures, regardless of the boil off
gas volume, with no special requirement to control the
inlet gas temperature, or avoid recycle operation as
with the centrifugal compressor.
Therefore, the reciprocating compressor design is
the most suitable compressor to be used for LNG BOG
service in both LNG receiving terminals, as well as for
LNG storage facilities.
Figure 2 shows the typical capacity control system
for Kobelcos reciprocating compressor.
Suction valve unloader. Used to completely unload a
cylinder end where 50% or 100% step of unloading is
required.
Clearance pocket unloader. Clearance pockets are the
fixed volume type and mounted in the cylinder head.
Since the reciprocating compressor controls can
correspond suffciently to changes in the boil off gas
volume, and thus reduce the overall operating costs,
they are always adopted for LNG BOG service at LNG
receiving/storage facilities.
The centrifugal compressor is usually only required
when the boil off gas volume becomes quite large
during actual LNG receiving operations. These events
are quite limited in duration, and may only occur once
or twice per month, when the tanker is connected to
the unloading arms. Occasionally, when several LNG
storage tanks are flled and established, an additional
boil off gas demand may be called for during the course
of normal holding operations, as well as during LNG
receiving. For this type of dual operation, a centrifugal
compressor for base load conditions handles large
volumes, and the reciprocating compressor handles the
fuctuating portion of the LNG boil off gas volume.
Table 1 shows the general comparison between
reciprocating and centrifugal compressors.
Advantage of horizontal piston ring type
compressor
For the cryogenic services, either the horizontal ring
type or vertical labyrinth type compressors are used, but
it is very important to understand the basic difference
between these two designs.
Table 2 shows the comparison between the
horizontal ring type and the vertical labyrinth type
compressors.
l
l
Table 1. Comparison between reciprocating and centrifugal
compressors
Reciprocating Centrifugal
Capacity Small - middle Middle - large
Dis.pressure High Low
Space
1
Large Small
Suction temperature
range
Wide Narrow
Capacity control 25, 50, 70, 100% 80 - 100%
Efficiency High Middle
Driver output
1
Small Large
Figure 4. FEM analysis of piston.
Figure 3. Temperature - time chart for two stage
BOG compressor.
Reprinted from LNG INDUSTRY Autumn 2008 www.lngindustry.com
Efficiency
The effciency of piston ring type compressors is much
higher than for the labyrinth type. For the vertical
labyrinth type, leakage of low temperature gas around
the piston, piston rods and labyrinths is much higher,
with a resultant energy loss. Hence, the piston ring
type compressor is more suitable in LNG BOG because
the critical parts such as piston, rider and piston rod
packing rings are self lubricated parts with better sealing
characteristics, as well as excellent wear resistance in
cryogenic service.
Maintenance
In the case of the vertical labyrinth type, centering
between the piston and the cylinder is a critical tolerance
and must be carefully considered during assembly.
This is a diffcult operation to perform at site due to the
small tolerance requirements. Furthermore, an elevated
overhead crane is required to access the cylinders.
Hence, maintenance requires more time and a
skilled specialist is always needed. For the piston
ring type, maintenance work is much easier and
faster because no special adjustment of the piston is
necessary.
Cooling water system
A typical BOG compressor is a two stage compressor,
designed to compress the gas from atmospheric
pressure up to approximately 10 barg. A cooling water
jacket and piping are not necessary with a piston ring
type compressor under these conditions.
Since vertical labyrinth type compressors require a
water cooled system for the crankcase, as well as the
second stage, this means an additional operating cost,
as well as potential maintenance. In addition, extra plot
space and energy are also necessary.
Unbalance
Kobelcos (piston ring type) reciprocating compressor
is designed with a horizontally balanced/opposed type
frame, and in this design the cylinders are arranged
opposite each other as a means of balancing the
reciprocating inertial forces. As a result, the forces
are balanced, and the unbalanced couple becomes
relatively small, signifcantly reducing the vibration, and
allowing for an easy foundation design.
Also, because the piping is routed at a lower level,
rigid supports can be used, and vibration is lower than
for a vertical design.
Lower maintenance
Continuous long term and trouble free operation is a
critical consideration since it will always be directly
related to the owners bottom line.
Long ring life
Rings such as the piston, rider and piston rod packing
rings are critical wear parts in any compressor
application, and should be evaluated during any
performance evaluation involving reciprocating
compressors.
Suitable materials are normally formulated into the
self lubricated material according to the process gas
composition, gas temperature, humidity and calculated
bearing pressures. However, in cryogenic services, the
material characteristics may be different from those in
normal ambient temperature service. Therefore, it is
extremely important to properly select the base and
mating materials of these critical wear parts.
Following is the typical experience of the Kobelco
LNG BOG reciprocating compressors under
commercial operation.
Predicted ring life
From the database, the life of conventional
rings was approximately 8000 hours. So far, the
wearing rate of the new ring design has been
drastically reduced, and predicted life of rings
such as piston, rider, and piston rod packing
rings has reached more than 24 000 hours.
The company evaluates each application
based upon the expected operating conditions,
Figure 5. LNG BOG compressor.
Figure 6. LNG BOG compressor.
Table 2. Comparison between horizontal ring and vertical labyrinth
Horizontal piston ring type Vertical labryinth type
Efficiency High Low
Maintenance Easy Difficult X
Cooling water system Not required Required X
Unbalance Small Big X
Centre of gravity Low High X
Space Wide Tall
www.lngindustry.com Reprinted from Autumn 2008 LNG INDUSTRY
as well as the selected ring type and shape, including
any external factors which must be taken into account.
Suction and discharge valves
The most suitable type of valve is employed for the
operating condition. Valve seats and guards are made
of austenitic stainless steel, and the gas tight face
contacting with the valve plate is super fnished. Valve
plates and valve springs are made of special alloy steel
having excellent low temperature tenacity and fatigue
strength, and are given a special fnish treatment after
machining.
Large diameter cylinders and pistons
Large cylinders are preferable to save installation space
and maintenance cost due to the fewest number of
cylinders, but various effects should be considered.
As mentioned before, a typical LNG BOG
compressor is a two stage compressor designed to
compress the gas from atmospheric pressure to 10
barg. Compressor cylinders are nonlubricated, and
without cooling jackets due to the low gas temperature
during normal operation.
When the compressor starts up at the prevailing
ambient temperature under a loaded condition, the
second stage discharge temperature will increase
approximately 110 C, and then drop (Figure 3). As
a result, those parts in contact with the gas, such as
the cylinder, piston, etc. are exposed to a very wide
temperature change and special consideration should
be taken to evaluate those parts for any abnormal
deformation and partial stress. Of particular concern
is the piston. The piston should be light in weight, with
high stiffness to handle the wide temperature change.
Kobelco applies fnite element methods (FEM) to
analyse piston deformation and stress levels under the
various loading conditions, including assembly, and
gas load, as well as the wide temperature change and
inertia forces (Figure 4).
With these factors in mind, Kobelco has
manufactured more than 50 large (max. 1070 mm)
cylinders in the past 20 years and the results have
been extremely successful.

Conclusion
The demand for large LNG storage facilities is growing
all over the world. LNG boil off gas compressors are
critical process compressors. These compressors are
an essential and vital part of any LNG plant, and the
failure of the BOG compressors will cause a serious
loss of proft to the owners and operators of these
plants. In this business, failure is never an option.
Table 3. Compressor specification
Type Horizontal balanced opposed
Model KR50-4
No. of stage 2
No. of cylinder 4
Suction temperature -155 to -100 C
Inlet pressure 0.03 barg
Discharge pressure 10 barg
Capacity 15 000 kg/h
Motor power 1600 kW