TOTAL METRICS

COSMIC-FFP and
IFPUG 4.1
Similarities and
Differences
Presented by : Pam Morris
TOTAL METRICS

IFPUG Fall Conference

Scottsdale Arizona
September 2003
Total Metrics  - 1
TOTAL METRICS
Agenda
‹‹History
HistoryofofFunctional
FunctionalSize
Size
Measurement
Measurement

‹ 14143-1 Definitions of Functional

Size

‹ Similarities and Differences

‹ When to use what FSM Method

Total Metrics  - 2
TOTAL METRICS
History of Functional Size
ISO /IEC
Measurement FSM
ISO ‘FSM’ Method
Framework Standards
Standard
14143-1
MkII MK II
FPA 1.3
3-D
FP’s COSMIC
FFP V.
MkII Full FP’s 2.2
FPA V.1

Feature IFPUG
IFPUG 4.1 IFPUG 4.1
Allan Points
IFPUG 4.0 Unadjusted
Albrecht
FPA 3.0
NESMA1.0 NESMA 2.1

1980 1985 1990 1995 2000

Total Metrics  - 3
TOTAL METRICS Pam Morris - Profile
‹ Member of the IFPUG Counting Practices Committee
1993 - 2000
‹ Co-author IFPUG 4.0, IFPUG 4.1, Case Study 1,
Practical Guidelines for Counting Logical Files
‹ IFPUG CFPS Certified since 1994
‹ Australian Representative ISBSG Committee
‹ Reviewer of the NESMA Manual CPM
‹ International Workgroup convenor and project editor
ISO/IEC 14143 Functional Size Measurement Standards
‹ Core project member COSMIC (1997 - now)
‹ Co-author COSMIC-FFP Measurement Manual
‹ Author and Presenter IFPUG Certified Training courses
and IFPUG IT Measurement Book
‹ Executive Member of the Australian Software Metrics
Association (ASMA)
‹ Chief Executive Officer of Total Metrics
Total Metrics  - 4
TOTAL METRICS
Agenda
‹ History of Functional Size
Measurement

‹
‹ 14143-1 Definitions
14143-1 Definitions of
of Functional
Functional
Size
Size

‹ Similarities and Differences

‹ When to use what FSM Method

Total Metrics  - 5
TOTAL METRICS
Functional Size
Measurement
‹ ISO/IEC/JTC1/SC7 Standard 14143-1(1998)
definitions:
¾ “Functional Size: A size of the software
derived by quantifying the Functional User
Requirements.”
¾ “Functional Size Measurement (FSM): The
process of measuring Functional Size.”
¾ “ FSM Method: A specific implementation of
FSM defined by a set of rules, which conforms
to the mandatory features of this part of ISO/IEC
14143.” Eg. IFPUG 4.1 Unadjusted, COSMIC-FFP
Total Metrics  - 6
TOTAL METRICS
Characteristics of Functional
Size Measurement

‹ Measures Functional User Requirements

‹ Excludes:
¾ physical or technical components
¾ quality features
‹ derived in terms understood by users of the
software
‹ derived without reference to:
¾ effort to develop or support
¾ methods used

Total Metrics  - 7
TOTAL METRICS
Basic Concepts of FSM
Users USER REQUIREMENTS

Processes Stored
Data

TECHNICAL
QUALITY
9 U
FUNCTIONAL
Stored
Data
OR
Engineered
Devices
OR
Other Boundary
Software
Software to be measured
Total Metrics  - 8
TOTAL METRICS
Basic Concepts of FSM
FUNCTIONAL USER =FUR
REQUIREMENTS

Processes Stored
Data

Stored
Data
OR Base Functional =BFCs
Components
Engineered
devices
OR
other
Software MEASURED
BOUNDARY FOR SIZE

Total Metrics  - 9
TOTAL METRICS
IFPUG BFC Types
INPUT, OUTPUT,
ENQUIRY

9 9 9
Processes

Stored
Data Stored
Data
9
INTERNAL LOGICAL
FILE

EXTERNAL
INTERFACE
FILE 9
9)
5 Base Functional Component Types (BFC Types9
Total Metrics  - 10
TOTAL METRICS
COSMIC BFC Types

COSMIC = ENTRY 9
COSMIC = READ 9
U U
Stored Stored

9
Data COSMIC = WRITE Data

COSMIC = EXIT 9
9)
4 Base Functional Component Types (BFC Types9
Total Metrics  - 11
TOTAL METRICS
Sizing example:
Create New Order
ORDER HEADER SCREEN
Computer Components Automated Supply System
File Report System Admin Help Utility

Order
Number:
Order Header Details
Order /Reservation Details
Reservation
Sales Tax Exemption
.
x #
Urgent

Routine .
Description::
Order Date: / /
Contact Name:
Date Required: / /
Vendor OK
Send Invoice To :

Items
Deliver Goods To :
Print

Save
Additional Instructions:

Cancel

Total Metrics  - 12
TOTAL METRICS
Eg. Create New Order
ORDER ITEM DETAILS SCREEN
Computer Components Automated Supply System
File Report System Admin Help Utility

Order
Number:
. 10711943
Order ItemDetails
Order /Reservation Details
Reservation
Order Date: / /
Order Item
Value:
Sales Tax
$ 1,387.00

$ 138.70
Description:: Update RRS Computers
Order Total $ 1,525.70
Product Items:
Product # Description Brand Name Size Unit Measure Qty Price

DD1235 Hard Disk Drive Osborne 240 mb one drive 2 $ 589.00

DD1205 Hard Disk Drive Osborne 120 mb one drive 1 $ 209.00
DD1235 Hard Disk Drive Connor 240 mb one drive 1 $ 500.00
DD1200 Hard Disk Drive Seagate 40 mb one drive 1 $ 89.00

Add Modify Delete GL Codes

Comments Total MetricsOK
 - 13
TOTAL METRICS
IFPUG Count
Identify Logical Files
ORDER (2 RETs)

TEMPLATE
ORDER
ORDER PRODUCT
TEMPLATE
ORDER
LINE PRODUCT
GENERAL ITEM
LEDGER
CODES
= 3 ILFs (1 average, 2 low complexity )
GENERAL
= 24 function points
LEDGER
= 1 EIF (low)
=5 function points
Total Data Groups = 29 function points
Total Metrics  - 14
 IFPUG Count - Identify DETs
and FTRs
EXTERNAL INPUT 4 FTRs
24 DETs
Entering / Exiting Process
1. Order Type 2. Division Invoice 3. Reservation
Address Number
4. Date Required 5. Additional 6. Order Description Order
Order
Instructions Template
7. Contact Name 8. Priority Flag 9. Delivery Address
10.Reservation 11.Order Number. 12.Sales Tax
Number Exemption #
13.Order Date 14.Order Total 15. Sales Tax FTR
16.GL Ref Code 17.Quantity 18. Product Code FTR
19.Product 20.Item Size 21. Item Price
Description
22.Item Order 23.Error / 24.Action /control
Value confirmation
Mge
FTR
=High Complexity EI Product

= 6 function points

General FTR
Ledger
TOTAL METRICS
COSMIC Count - Group
Persistent Data - 3NF

ORDER HEADER
TEMPLATE

U U
ORDER
ORDER
PRODUCT

U
TEMPLATE

U U
ORDER
LINE PRODUCT
GENERAL ITEM
LEDGER
CODES
ORDER LINE
Group Persistent data into 3rd Normal form

U
GENERAL Not BFC
= 5 Persistent Data Groups Type
LEDGER
Total = 0 CFSU
Total Metrics  - 16
TOTAL METRICS
Identify READs from
Persistent Data

‹ READ General Ledger Reference Code

from General Ledger
‹ READ Product Details from Product
‹ READ Sales Tax information from Order
Template
Map data being retrieved (READ) from Persistent data
to determine unique READS

= 3 unique READS = Total =3 CFSU

Total Metrics  - 17
TOTAL METRICS
Identify WRITEs to
Persistent Data

‹ WRITE Order Header details to Order

Header
‹ WRITE Order Item Details to Order Line

Map data being written (WRITE) to Persistent data to

determine unique WRITES

= 2 unique WRITE = Total =2 CFSU

Total Metrics  - 18
TOTAL METRICS
Group Transient Data ENTERing
Process - 3NF
Order Header Details Entered
Entering Process
1. Order Type 2. Date Required 3. Order Description
4. Contact Name 5. Additional 6. Delivery Address
Instructions
7. Priority Flag

Order Item Related Details Entered

1. Product Code 2. Quantity

Map data entering to Entities

Group Data entered into 3rd Normal form to get unique
data movement ENTRIES

= 2 unique ENTRIES = Total =2 CFSU Total Metrics  - 19

TOTAL METRICS Group Transient Data EXITing
Exiting Process
Process - 3NF
1. Order Number. 2. Division Invoice 3. Sales Tax
Address
4. Order Description 5. Order Total 6. Order Date

7. Sales Tax
Exemption
Number

1. Product 2. GL Ref Code 3. Item Size

Description
4. Unit of Measure 5. Price 6. Item Order Value

1. Error /
confirmation
Message
Map data exiting to Entities
Group Data exiting into 3rd Normal form to get 3 unique
data movement EXITS

= 3 unique EXITS = Total =3 CFSU Total Metrics  - 20

TOTAL METRICS
Comparison of Functional
Size Process Level

Size of Process

BFC FPs BFC CFSU

IFPUG Type COSMIC Type
Process Process Sub-Process
Create Order EI 6 Create Enter Order Header Details ENTRY 1
Process Order
Process Enter Order Item Details ENTRY 1
Read Product Details READ 1
Read Template READ 1
Order ILF 10 Read General Ledger READ 1
Order Template ILF 7 Display Order Header EXIT 1
Details
Product ILF 7 Display Order Item Details EXIT 1
General Ledger EIF 5 Display Message EXIT 1
Write Order Header WRITE 1
Write Order Item details WRITE 1
35 10

Data is shared over Influence of data is

all processes incorporated into
each process
Total Metrics  - 21
TOTAL METRICS
Similarities
IFPUG and COSMIC
‹ both recognise:

¾ Elementary processes as a functional unit to be

measured
¾ data moving in/out of a process as contributing to
functional size
¾ data accesses to persistent data as contributing to
functional size
‹ DO NOT specifically measure:
¾ algorithms, processing logic, data transformations,
calculations etc.

Total Metrics  - 22
TOTAL METRICS Comparison of Functional
Size Application Level
“Order Processing System”

IFPUG FPs
COSMIC CFSU

Processes 115 Processes 156

Data 48 (-) 0

163 156

Total Metrics  - 23
TOTAL METRICS
PROCESS

U IFPUG = Files Accessed (FTRs)

COSMIC = Sub-process (READ WRITE)

U
Stored
Data
U Stored
Data IFPUG = Logical File
U COSMIC = Persistent Data

IFPUG = DETs crossing boundary

COSMIC = Sub-process (ENTRY, EXIT)

Total Metrics  - 24
TOTAL METRICS
Agenda
‹ History of Functional Size
Measurement

‹ 14143-1 Definitions of Functional

Size

‹ Similarities and Differences

‹ Similarities and Differences

‹ When to use what FSM Method

Total Metrics  - 25
TOTAL METRICS Concept Comparisons
Concept IFPUG COSMIC
Methods for -Not explicit in -Explicit in
dealing with CPM rules for
Multi-layered -see New counting multi-
Software Environments layered
white papers architectures
User View -Measures from - Measures
External User View from different
Viewpoints
Quality and -notexplicitly -Considered in
Technical measured in ISO other layers if
Requirements 20926 software
-VAF - IFPUG implementation
CPM 4.1 - No VAF
Total Metrics  - 26
TOTAL METRICS
Process Comparisons
Process IFPUG COSMIC
- Count DETs -No- just need to -No - counts
know ‘ranges’ of ‘logical
DETs groups’ of
DETs

- Industry -Yes, default EPs -Industry data

default to average, DGs available,
complexity data to low - error% not
- + 15% error established
Rules for -Different rules - Same Rules
determining for each type of for all
Complexity process processes
Total Metrics  - 27
TOTAL METRICS
Process Comparisons
Process IFPUG COSMIC
- Repeatability -Requires -Requires Data
of grouping counting Modelling
Logical Data experience to experience to
Groups ensure ensure
repeatability repeatability

- Level of Detail - not a lot of -More detail

required in detail required required to
functional since can select identify each
Specifications ‘ranges’ for data
complexity movement and
file access
Total Metrics  - 28
TOTAL METRICS Result Comparisons
Process IFPUG COSMIC
- Correlation to -MIS – significant -Realtime –
effort across all supporting industry preliminary industry
functional evidence and research evidence
domains ~100 projects

-Limited– Realtime, -Limited - MIS data

scientific software
data

- Industry Data -public domain and -Mostly private or

private research
-ISBSG ~2000 -ISBSG – ~50 projects
projects
-International -Practitioners via - ISO Testing Labs
Certification IFPUG CFPS planned

Total Metrics  - 29
TOTAL METRICS Result Comparisons
Process IFPUG COSMIC
-Sensitivity to - maximum sensitivity -Allows infinite order
large variations is two fold variation of magnitude
in process ¾Min size = 3 FPs ¾Min size = 2
complexity ¾Max Size = 7FPs CFSU
¾Max Size = α
(infinite) CFSU
-Sensitivity to - highest size measure - highest size measure
processes requires data does not require
which move a movements AND data process to have DG
lot of data accesses accesses.
without
accessing DGs
Data -Persistent Data - Persistent data only
contribution to contributes around 30% contributes to size via
overall size of total size in addition process accesses
to contribution from
Total Metrics  - 30
process data accesses
TOTAL METRICS
Result Comparisons

Process IFPUG COSMIC

-Counts -No - includes access - Yes, includes access
multiple to a persistent data to a persistent data
accesses to DG group once only per group up to twice per
process process (Read and/or
-Unique FTR Write)

Total Metrics  - 31
TOTAL METRICS Resource Comparisons
Resource IFPUG COSMIC
- Manuals -Purchase from IFPUG -Download free from
-Purchase from ISO WWW
-~390 pages -Purchase from ISO
-~75 pages

- Training -Many vendor courses -Several Courses

worldwide available worldwide
-Certification -No certification

- Tools -Variety Vendors -Verylimited

-Certification -No Certification

- Case -2different FUR Case -5different FUR Case

Studies Studies, Studies
-Purchase from IFPUG -Download free

Total Metrics  - 32
TOTAL METRICS
Agenda
‹ History of Functional Size
Measurement

‹ 14143-1 Definitions of Functional

Size

‹ Similarities and Differences

‹
‹ Whento
When touse
usewhat
whatFSM
FSMMethod
Method
Total Metrics  - 33
TOTAL METRICS So Which Method to Choose?
‹ Consider
¾need and availability of support services
’ training

’ tools historical data

’ skilled functional size analysts

¾ how the size result will be used

¾Industry profile, recognition
¾functional domain of software to be measured
(embedded process rich or data rich MIS?)
¾capability maturity of your organisation
¾FSM Used by other parts of your organisation
Total Metrics  - 34
TOTAL METRICS
REMEMBER

‹ BOTH METHODS
¾Used internationally
¾ISO/IEC FSM standards
¾Collected by ISBSG Repository
¾‘work’ in most environments
¾developed and refined by international
experts (sometimes the same ones!)

Total Metrics  - 35
TOTAL METRICS
More Information

‹ IFPUG
¾www.ifpug.org/

‹ COSMIC-FFP
¾www.cosmicon.com/
TOTAL METRICS

‹ TOTAL METRICS
¾www.totalmetrics.com/

Total Metrics  - 36
TOTAL METRICS

THANK YOU

Total Metrics Pty Ltd

Suite 1, 667 Burke Road
Camberwell
Victoria 3124 Australia
Ph +613 9882 7611
Fax +613 9882 7633
[email protected]
“To measure is to know!”
This presentation is available
from DOWNLOADS at:
WWW.totalmetrics.com
Total Metrics  - 37