Grinding Basics and Example
Grinding Basics and Example
C R U S H I N G
Table of Contents
TABLE OF CONTENTS............................................................................................................................ 2 INTRODUCTION TO CRUSHING ..................................................................................................................... 3 What is this module about?..................................................................................................................... 3 What will you learn in this module? ....................................................................................................... 3 What do you have to do to complete this unit? ....................................................................................... 3 What resources can you use to help?...................................................................................................... 3 INTRODUCTION TO COMMINUTION ................................................................................................ 4 CRUSHING THEORY ............................................................................................................................... 5 CRUSHING EQUIPMENT AND CRUSHING CIRCUITS.................................................................... 9 CRUSHING EQUIPMENT ............................................................................................................................... 9 CRUSHING CIRCUITS AND STAGING........................................................................................................... 23 SDGM CRUSHING CIRCUIT OVERVIEW......................................................................................... 26 SDGM CRUSHING CIRCUIT MAJOR COMPONENTS ................................................................... 28 CONTROL & OPERATING PHILOSOPHY........................................................................................ 38 APPENDIX 1 EQUIPMENT LIST & NUMBERING ............ ERROR! BOOKMARK NOT DEFINED.
C R U S H I N G
Introduction to Crushing
What is this module about? This unit is about how we manage crushing within the processing plant
What will you learn in this module? Demonstrate an understanding of crushing theory fundamentals. Define comminution Define Work Index Explain what Specific Energy input is. List the 3 mechanisms for fracturing rock Demonstrate an understanding of the equipment used Identify the main components of a jaw crusher Identify the main components of cone crusher
What do you have to do to complete this unit? You will need to complete all the training tasks in your workbook, the review exercise and the assessment given to you by your supervisor. Discuss the competency standards for this unit with the Training Coordinator or your supervisor. What resources can you use to help? If you need more information about topics in this unit, then you should approach: Your work mates and supervisor The training coordinator Metallurgists
C R U S H I N G
Introduction to Comminution
Because most minerals are finely disseminated and intimately associated with the gangue, they must be initially "unlocked" or "liberated" before separation can be undertaken. This is achieved by comminution. Comminution is the term applied to the process by which the particle size of an ore stream is progressively reduced progressively reduced. It is the first step in processing the ore from the mine. The purpose of comminution is to; Liberate the valuable mineral from the worthless gangue material prior to concentration or separation. Increase the surface area of valuable mineral available for chemical reaction.
Blasting in the pit can be considered the first stage of comminution. Explosives are used in the mining operation to remove the ore from the ground and make it easier to be handled by the excavators, scrapers, trucks, loaders etc. Comminution in the processing plant takes place as a sequence of crushing and grinding processes. Crushing reduces the particle size of run-of-mine (ROM) ore to such a level that grinding can be carried out until the valuable mineral (gold and silver, and gold/silver bearing minerals) and gangue are substantially produced as separate particles. Crushing is accomplished by compression of the ore against a rigid surface, whereas grinding involves abrasion and impact of the ore by the grinding media (steel mill balls).
C R U S H I N G
Crushing Theory
The purpose of crushing is to prepare the ore for further processing. The ultimate aim is to produce a certain amount of material of a certain size per day so that the grinding circuit has sufficient feed.
Work Index
Crushing theory is concerned with the relationship between the amount of energy put into a rock or particle of a known size and the reduced particle size after the comminution process has taken place. The amount of energy required to do this work is referred to as the Work Index and it is an expression of the resistance that a material has to crushing (or grinding). It is a measurement of how hard the ore is. Therefore 'Work Index' can be defined as:
The amount of energy (work) required to break a rock from one size to another.
Each rock has a characteristic Work Index. For example, more energy is required to break quartz than sandstone so quartz will have a higher work index. Numerically the work index is known as the kilowatt-hours per tonne or kWh/t. A kilowatthour is the number of kilowatts consumed in an hour. For example, if you ran a 20kW motor for an hour, you would expend 20kWh. If you used that motor to do work to 2 tonnes of rock you would have used 20kWh 2 tonne, 10kWt/h. The higher the Work Index, the more work required to break the rock, hence the harder the rock. Crushing or Impact Work Indices are measured in the laboratory using a special impact strengthtesting machine. Some typical values for crushing work indices are listed below: Material Basalt Clay Coal Copper Ores Gold Ores Glass Iron Ores Limestone Quartz Crushing Work Index 22 8 13 14 16 3 17 13 14 _____
If the work index of the ore is known and the feed size and the desired product size of the ore are also known then the power required for crushing that ore can be calculated.
C R U S H I N G
Cleavage Fracture by cleavage occurs when the energy applied is just sufficient to fracture the particle. Only a few particles result and their size is comparatively close to the original particle. Typically this situation occurs under conditions of slow compression where the fracture immediately relieves the loading on the particle. This is the main type of fracture found in jaw crushers.
C R U S H I N G
Shatter Fracture by shatter occurs when the applied energy is well in excess of that required for fracture; under these conditions many areas in the particle are overloaded and the result is a comparatively large number of particles with a wide size distribution.
In practice these events do not occur in isolation, rather breakages involve a combination of fracture mechanisms.
C R U S H I N G
C R U S H I N G
Jaw Crushers
Jaw crushers cause fracture by compression, since this is the most practical method of applying a fracture force to very large particles. This in turn means that the machine must be constructed in such a way that the openings impose limitations on the feed and product size: capacity therefore becomes dependent on the size of the discharge opening and the machine speed. Essentially a jaw crusher consists of two plates, set at an acute angle to each other, with one jaw pivoted (swing jaw), so that it swings relative to the other (fixed jaw). Material fed into the jaw is alternatively nipped (which hopefully causes it to fracture) and released to fall further into the crushing chamber. Jaw crushers are normally classified by the method of pivoting the swing jaw. In the Blake type jaw crushers the jaw is pivoted at the top and thus has a fixed receiving area and a variable discharge opening. In the Dodge type jaw crushers the jaw is pivoted at the bottom, giving a variable feed area but fixed discharge area.
C R U S H I N G
Blake (Double Toggle) Originally the standard jaw crusher used for primary and secondary crushing of hard, tough abrasive rocks. Also for sticky feeds. Relatively coarse slabby product, with minimum fines.
Overhead Pivot (Double Toggle) Similar applications to Blake. Overhead pivot; reduces rubbing on crusher faces, reduces choking, allows higher speeds and therefore higher capacities. Energy efficiency higher because jaw and charge not lifted during cycle.
Overhead Eccentric (Single Toggle) Originally restricted to sampler sizes by structural limitations. Now in same size of Blake which it has tended to supersede, because overhead eccentric encourages feed and discharge, allowing higher speeds and capacity, but with higher wear and more attrition brakeage and slightly lower energy efficiency. In addition as compared to an equivalent double toggle, they are cheaper and take up less floor space. Dodge Bottom pivot gives closer sized product than Blake, but Dodge is difficult to build in large sizes, and is prone to choking. Generally restricted to laboratory used.
10
C R U S H I N G
3.
movement
11
C R U S H I N G
12
C R U S H I N G
Bowl Liner
13
C R U S H I N G
At the discharge end of the crusher is a parallel crushing section, where all material passing through must receive at least one impact. This ensures that all particles, which pass through the cone crusher, will have a maximum size, in at least one dimension, no larger than the 'set' of the crusher. For this reason, the set of a cone crusher can be specified as the minimum discharge opening, being commonly known as the closed side setting (CSS). Cone crushers can have two types of 'heads', standard and short head types. The principle difference between the two is in the shape (size and volume) of the crushing cavities and feed plate arrangements. Standard head cone crushers have cavities that are designed to take a primary crushed feed ranging up to 300mm generating product sizes around 20mm to 40mm. For finer products short head cone crushers are normally used. They have a steeper angle of the head and a more parallel crushing cavity than the standard machines. Due to the more compact chamber volume and shorter working crushing length, the much needed higher crushing forces/power can be imparted to the smaller sized material being fed to the crusher. Cavities for the short head machine are designed to produce a crushed product ranging from 5mm to 20mm in closed circuit.
Standard
Short Head
14
C R U S H I N G
Gyratory Crushers
While the gyratory could be regarded as a variation of the cone crusher, its common use as a primary crusher within the mineral processing industry warrants a brief description of this particular crusher. The gyratory is popular due to its high throughput capacity (up to ~10,000 tph possible) and the large sized opening. This means the crusher is well suited to handling direct feed from haul trucks, with minimal fuss. When required throughputs are around 700 tph or greater, essentially a gyratory must be used. Feeding directly into the crushing chamber eliminates the need for bins and feeders before the gyratory. Oversize rocks can be broken with a rock breaker within the chamber itself. The total chamber width on the larger gyratory crusher can be up to 10m wide. They are distinct to the more common cone crusher, with the top of the cone being supported and fixed by a bearing, with the bottom of the cone being the moving section creating the crushing action. This provides greater strength throughout the length of the cone. The spider arm across the top of the cone provides the strength needed for the crushing chamber in the top section. Hydraulic pressure is normally used to apply upward pressure on the cone, which closes the gap, which is referred to as the open side setting on these types of crushers.
LEFT: Graphical representation of a Gyratory Crusher. Notice the similarity in shape of the crushing chamber to the Jaw Crusher. However, with its rotational action, the gyratory is always crushing, as compared to the jaw crusher, where it only crushes as the swing jaw moves towards the fixed jaw. Hence the gyratory can process a much greater throughput. BELOW: Top view of 60x89 Svedala Gyratory Primary Crusher at Ernest Henry, QLD Australia. Ore is directly tipped into the crushing chamber by 200t trucks.
15
C R U S H I N G
Impact Crushers
Impact crushers consist of a high speed rotating impeller or hammer, which accelerates the incoming new feed to high speed, to impact against a wear liner to cause rock breakage. Generally they are used on medium to soft ore types, with relatively low abrasion characteristics and low impact resistance (for example limestone or clay). The products of these crushers are generally quite fine due to the large amount of power exerted on each particle as it passes through, causing shatter type fracturing. Thus impact crushers are capable of very high reduction ratios (ratio of the size of the incoming feed to the size of the crusher product). Their capacities are quite high for the relatively compact size and low complexity of the crusher. Impact crushers are generally equipped with large drives (up to 600kW) due to the power required to achieve the high impeller tip speeds (from 500 rpm up to 2,500 rpm). Impactors in the secondary duty generally operate at slower tip speeds than those used for tertiary crushing duties. The two general types of impact crushers are Vertical Shaft Impactors (eg. Svedala Barmac Duopactor, Jaques Canica) and Horizontal Shaft Impactors (eg. Hazi-mag or Nordberg Nordpactor). The major issues associated with operating impact crushers are the high wear rates of the liners and hammers or impellers, particularly when handling abrasive feeds. Latest impact crusher designs incorporate hydraulic door access to the internals, and quick change lining systems. Significant research has also been carried out by the industry regarding liner material types to improve liner life.
LEFT: Cross section of Hammer Mill type impact crusher (horizontal shaft type). BELOW: Nordbergs Nordpactor Horizontal Shaft Impact Crusher
16
C R U S H I N G
17
C R U S H I N G
18
C R U S H I N G
Apron Feeder operating under a Coarse Ore Stockpile to provide feed for a SAG Mill.
19
C R U S H I N G
Vibrating Screens
In crushing plants screens are used for size separation of the ore being crushed. Generally ore that is undersized is sent onto the next stage of comminution and oversize ore is often returned to the circuit for further crushing (see closed circuit section). Screens can be designed in a single deck, double deck, or triple deck configuration, depending on the application required. The shape of the screen can be either conventional inclined (entire screen sits at one angle), or banana shaped being steep at the feed end, with the angle reducing towards the discharge end. Conventional Screen The conventional inclined vibrating screen is used widely within the mineral processing industry. They are characterised by the consistent incline angle. High screening efficiencies are obtained with the use of a reasonably deep bed of ore moving down the screen, to promote sorting and flow through the screen deck. Too thin a bed depth may result in the material bouncing leading to poor efficiency. Banana Screen The Banana screen is a more recent variation of the conventional inclined screen, becoming more common due to their high unit capacity and high efficiency. The higher capacity is due to the steep initial screen angle (resulting in a fast moving bed, thus increasing overall screen capacity) and the high powered exciters usually installed on the screens. The rate of fines removal in this section of the screen is high. Isolation The high efficiency is borne from the flatter bottom section, which provides an opportunity for good separation of the near-size material (particles of a dimension close to that of the screen aperture). The upper practical limit for reliable high force banana screens is ~3.7m wide by ~8m long. Feeding such large screens normally requires a diverging vibrating feeder to ensure material is presented to the screen across the entire width, otherwise significant available screen area will be wasted. Larger sized banana screens are normally supported on an Isolation Frame. This essentially consists of a heavy (usually by filling a steel structure with concrete) supporting frame, which is attached to the supporting structure through additional springs and shock absorbers. The Isolation Frame significantly reduces the transmission of the vibrating forces from the exciters through the supporting structure, meaning that concrete foundations are not required.
20
Banana
C R U S H I N G
Transfer Chutes Chutes are used to transfer material from one plant component to another, and are thus critical to the reliable and continuous operation of a mineral processing plant. A good chute design achieves the following; Flow free from blockage by larger particles or sticky material build-up. Minimal damage to the receiving plant component.
BELOW: Rock-boxed product screen bottomdeck oversize chute at Sunrise Dam, prior to
Minimal segregation of the particle sizes within the stream as it moves through the chute and onto the receiving component. Positioning of the material centrally or in the correct fashion onto the receiving component. Flow direction of the material preferentially in the direction of movement of the receiving conveyor or feeder.
Chutes handling non-abrasive and sticky material are normally very simple, and are generally designed to minimise points where materials can build-up eventually blocking the chute. Minimising contact points between the material and the chute components itself generally achieves this. However, chutes designed for abrasive and hard ore are more complex and usually incorporate rock-boxes (chute sections designed to hold a static mass of rock to act as an impact bed) to facilitate rock-on-rock contact as the ore moves through the chute. The leading edges of the rock-boxes are prone to wear, and thus lined with replaceable wear billets. To minimise damage to the receiving component, it is often desirable to create a more difficult path for the ore, to reduce its velocity. Minimising contact between the moving ore and structural plate-work is also required, to reduce liner wear rates.
LEFT: Modelling of SDGM Screen Top-deck Oversize Chute at 1/10th scale. Extensive rock-boxing is used to minimise contact of the sliding ore with the chute itself, and to slow the ore down prior to it impacting the conveyor below.
21
C R U S H I N G
Conveyors
Conveyors as a means of moving material within crushing plants are preferred and common because they provide an even and continuous flow. Their mechanical efficiency is high as relatively little dead weight (ie. the conveyor itself) must be moved with the load. Further, frictional resistance is low (due to the numerous bearing supported rollers) and power consuming starts and stops are relatively rare. Basically, a conveyor is an endless moving flat belt for transporting dry materials. The belt extends between a head pulley, and a tail or return pulley. It is supported by idler rollers, which are, in turn, supported by a frame. The drive pulley is often located at the head end or at an intermediate point along the return run. Tension in the belt is provided by either a "take up" or "gravity" pulley, located just behind the drive pulley, or an adjustable tail pulley (more common on smaller length conveyors). Belts, which move loose material, are usually run through a trough in the upper belt, which centres the load to reduce spill off the sides. Short conveyors, such as the feed conveyors can carry larger loads by using a flat surface with fixed side skirts to reduce material spillage.
Dust control (a common issue associated with conveyors) from conveyors is controlled as much as possible with the incorporation of some or all of the following; Two-stage loading skirts (usually steel internal with rubber or polyurethane external skirt) Dust extraction system operating from the loading skirt area Belt-scrapers adjacent the head pulley Chute design minimising impact velocity of ore onto the belt Water sprays & Belts covers
22
C R U S H I N G
The size of the product leaving this stage is controlled by the size of the discharge opening or closed side setting of the crusher. Primary jaw and gyratory crushers are generally configured in an open circuit arrangement. A scalping grizzly may be installed prior to the crusher to improve its performance and reliability by eliminating material being fed to the crusher already at the correct size.
23
C R U S H I N G
Feed in Up to 1500mm
Product Screen
Two-stage crushing is more often employed in the mineral processing industry to improve performance and capacity of SAG mill circuits. For fine crushing (eg. Preparing feed to either a Rod or Ball Mill), two-stage crushing is not common, and is really only suited for very soft ores. This is due to the fact that to achieve such a fine product requires the secondary cone crusher to be operating well above the normal and design reduction ratios.
24
C R U S H I N G
Tertiary Crusher
The three stages allow the practical achievement of fine product on competent rock, as each stage is operating at normal or equipment design reduction ratios. Further size reduction can be achieved with the adoption of 4-stage crushing, however this is usually limited to ores of extreme hardness, where reduction ratios are low at each stage due to the competency of the rock, or if the product size required is unusually fine.
25
C R U S H I N G
General Description
The Run of Mine (ROM) ore is fed to a 170 tonne capacity ROM bin by a front-end loader through a 800mm square aperture static grizzly. The oversize from the grizzly is broken with the rock breaker which is installed adjacent the ROM bin. A plate feeder and vibrating grizzly transfer the ore from the ROM bin to a single-toggle jaw crusher. The jaw crusher operates with a closed side setting (CSS) of 130-140mm and is powered by a 200kW motor. The jaw crusher product discharges onto a vibrating feeder together with the grizzly undersize. The vibrating feeder transfers the ore onto CVR01. These products combine with the discharge of the secondary cone crusher on CVR01 and then transfer to the screen feed conveyor CVR02. Product from the tertiary crushers combines with the primary and secondary crushed products on CVR02. The ore is then discharged from CVR02 onto a double-deck banana screen via a diverging feeder. This screen is fitted with 14mm and 45mm slotted aperture rubber/poly cloths in the lower and upper decks respectively. The oversize from the upper deck reports to the secondary crusher feed conveyor CVR03. The lower decks oversize reports to the tertiary crusher feed conveyor CVR04 and the undersize fraction from the lower deck reports as final product to the fine ore bin via CVR05, CVR06 and CVR07. Secondary crusher feed (+45mm) is discharged into the secondary crusher feed chamber via surge bin equipped with a variable-speed vibrating feeder. The secondary crusher is a standard head cone crusher which operates at a closed side setting of ~30-35mm and is powered by a 375kW motor. Tertiary crusher feed (+14mm -45mm) is directed from CVR04 onto a splitter plate, which distributes feed into both surge bins. The surge bins are equipped with two variable-speed vibrating feeders which discharge material into the chambers of the tertiary cone crushers. The tertiary crushers are equipped with short heads which operate at a closed side setting of ~1016mm and are powered by 375kW motors. The crushing circuit produces a product of 80% passing ~9mm at a design rate of 515tph. A diagrammatical representation or flowsheet of the circuit is shown on the following page.
26
C R U S H I N G
27
C R U S H I N G
28
C R U S H I N G
29
C R U S H I N G
Jaw Crusher
The jaw crusher used at SDGM is a single toggle Blake Overhead Eccentric C140B crusher manufactured by Nordberg. The opening dimensions are 1400mm x 1070mm. The C140B jaw crusher is powered by a 200kW motor and operates with a closed side setting of approximately 120mm to 140mm depending on the ore characteristics. The crusher is fitted with hydraulic jaw adjustment and automatic grease lubrication system. The drive motor is attached to the same frame as the crusher to ensure that correct vee-belt alignment can be achieved.
30
C R U S H I N G
31
C R U S H I N G
The tertiary HP500s are fitted with hydraulic remote CSS adjustment systems, which allow a gap adjustment to be performed from a Citect command. Feed will be temporarily stopped while this procedure takes place. The crushers are fitted also with a tramp release system, which prevents damage to the crushers if maximum crushing forces are exceeded through overfeeding or contamination with tramp metal. Repeated and frequent tramping of the crusher will result in long term structural damage. Vibration monitoring installed on the crusher to provide information to the operator concerning the level of tramping occurring.
32
C R U S H I N G
Conveyors
Various conveyors are used throughout the crushing circuit and they vary in length, width and capacity. Below is a summary of the conveyors used within the SDGM crushing circuit;
Conveyor counterweight towers include maintenance access walkways, and support system to allow safe suspension of the counterweight for maintenance purposes. All conveyors are fitted with overhead fall arrest systems for use when access to the conveyors is required. The CVR02 drive is located at ground level due to the large size of the motor and gearbox to improve maintainability. CVR03 is fitted with remote isolation switch at the head pulley, to be used when removing tramp metal from the conveyor after a metal detect.
33
C R U S H I N G
Chutes
The following chutes have been modelled at 1/10th scale to optimise performance; CVR01 and CVR02 transfer chute CVR02 head chute/Screen feed chute incorporating diverging feeder Screen Top-deck Oversize Chute Screen Bottom-deck Oversize Chute CVR04 head chute/Tertiary Bin Splitter Secondary surge bin discharge chute/feeder.
The designs incorporate rock-boxing to reduce liners wear areas where possible. The designs also attempt to reduce size segregation and material velocity where possible. Care must be taken if altering any of the above mentioned chutes, as the flows will change unexpectedly as a result. The CVR01 chute incorporates an angled rock ledge to move a portion of the flow back into the right-side (looking from the CIL tanks) of the chute. This flow reflects off this side of the head chute and then moves in the direction of the CVR02 conveyor, prior to discharging onto CVR02. The CVR02 head chute incorporates many rock ledges, to reduce velocity and redirect flow into the correct manner for feed onto the diverging feeder. The complication with the chute is the need to turn the material 90O, as the conveyor and product screen are perpendicular to each other. Direct impact of rock onto the diverging feeder had to be eliminated. The challenges with the screen oversize chutes were to ensure velocity is reduced prior to impact onto the conveyors below, to minimise the chance of blockage and reduce the anticipated high wear rates of the liners. The CVR04 head chute required rock-boxes and ledges to ensure the material is presented homogeneously onto the splitter plate, to eliminate or reduce the segregation of material size between the two parallel tertiary crushers. This has been achieved with a circular hole positioned just above the splitter plate. The secondary bin discharge chute design was aimed at minimising bridging of the exit with the +40mm primary crushed rocks, which tend to be quite slabby.
LEFT: Modeling of the secondary crusher surge bin discharge feeder. Note the modified angled hood at the base of the bin, which was required to eliminate rock bridging.
34
C R U S H I N G
The horizontal position allows for a 50/50 split to the tertiary surge bins
When at the 35 angle, material may still occasionally bounce from the splitter into the nonfed bin. Thus when isolating the bin for maintenance purposes, the isolating flop-gates positioned above the splitter plate must be used. The splitter plate itself is a rock-box, which allows material to build-up on it to form a cone. As the splitter plate tilts towards a particular bin, feed is preferentially directed to that bin.
LEFT: CVR04 Head Chute with Splitter Plate showing ore flow through the rock-boxing, and being directed via a circular hole onto the centre of the splitter plate. Ore is built up on the horizontal splitter plate to form a cone.
35
C R U S H I N G
Weightometers
Schenck weightometers are used on CVR02, CVR03 and CVR04 to monitor the recirculating load back the secondary and tertiary crushers, and the feed rate to the product screen. A Ramsey weightometer is used on CVR06, being the crushing circuit's production totaliser. The CVR02 weightometer is used as a control input for the operation of the PID loop controlling the diverging feeder speed. The CV04 and CVR04 weightometers are to provide information only for the operator.
36
C R U S H I N G
Dust Control
Two bag-house type dust collectors are available, with one positioned adjacent the screening building and the other adjacent the cone crushers. Extraction ducting extends from the transfer points on the conveyors and from the product screen and chutes. The dust collected from both bag-houses is dumped into hoppers and pumped from a common hopper back to the secondary cyclone feed hopper in the milling circuit. Insertable dust collectors are installed at the remote conveyor transfer points that were too far from the bag-house system, being CVR06 head end, CVR07 skirting, CVR09 head chute and CVR10 skirting. An insertable extraction system is installed on the Fine Ore Bin. Essentially the insertable dust extractors are self-contained extraction systems, which periodically dump the dust collected back onto the receiving belt. Two-stage skirting is installed on the conveyors, which has shown in the industry to be effective in controlling dust at the conveyor loading areas. This skirting needs to be occasionally monitored (while the plant is running loaded with ore) and adjusted accordingly to be effective. Water sprays are installed at the crusher feed chute areas, on the ROM bin, and on the emergency feeder.
37
C R U S H I N G
38
C R U S H I N G
C R U S H I N G
40
C R U S H I N G
41
C R U S H I N G
42
C R U S H I N G
43