Initiating Coverage Maruti Suzuki
Initiating Coverage Maruti Suzuki
CMP` 1474
Market Data Bloomberg Code Reuters Code SENSEX NIFTY Dividend Yield (%) 52 Week High/ Low(`) Equity Capital(`mn) Face Value (`) Market Cap (`mn) Avg. 10 day Vol. NSE MSIL.IN MRTI.BO 19229.26 5851.5 0.5 1537.0/905.6 1444.5 5.0 426286.8 536595
BUY
TP-` 1740
Marutis Q2FY13 results were above market expectations, both at the top line level (led by higher average realization) and margins (on lower other expenses). Net revenues grew 6% YoY to `80701.1 mn driven by a 16% surge in realization, while volumes fell 8.7% YoY. QoQ, revenues fell 23% as volumes dropped 22%, while realizations fell 1%. Domestic/export realization growth of (2.4)%/7.9% QoQ came in higher than anticipated.
Key Market Ratios TTM Latest EPS (`) TTM Book Value (`) TTM PE (x) TTM P/BV (x) TTM EV/EBIDTA (x) EV/TTM Sales (x) Mcap/TTM Sales (x)
Source: Ace Equity, R K Global Research, as on 12th Dec12
9.2% 16.2%
Volume & market share impacted by Labor issues at Manesar plant: During the quarter under review Marutis overall volumes declined 22% QoQ (9% YoY) to 230,376 units. While domestic volumes declined 5.6% YoY (20% QoQ), exports declined 31.7% YoY (37% QoQ). The labor issue at Manesar impacted volumes by ~77,000 units in 2QFY13. Realizations declined 1.6% QoQ (grew 19.5% YoY) to `350,302/unit (impacted by lower diesel vehicle sales (on production constraints) and higher discounts (on weak demand for petrol vehicles), partially negated by higher Ertiga sales (including CKD exports). MSILs market share in the domestic PV industry declined ~600bp QoQ (340bp YoY) to 34.1%, reflecting loss of volumes due to the Manesar labor issue.
20.4%
54.2%
Price vs Sensex
Sensex (LHS)
125 115 105 95 85 75 65 55 Nov-10 Mar-11 Jul-11 Nov-11 Mar-12 Jul-12 Nov-12
Maruti Suzuki
Margins down 19bps YoY/117bps QoQ at 6.1%: RM costs (as a percentage of sales) rose ~180bps QoQ owing to the forex impact on direct imports and higher average per unit discounts (at ` 14,750 vs. `11,046 QoQ), leading to a margin dip. Other expenses, however, decreased 120bps QoQ on a favorable exchange rate impact on royalty provisions and reduction in ad expenses. MSIL reported `430mn of commodity MTM gain in other income. PAT stood at `2274.5mn, -5.4% YoY lower on higher interest and depreciation charge.
Valuation & Outlook: The operating environment for Maruti is gradually improving, with (a) initial signs of demand recovery, driven by new Alto launch in festive season, (b) discount stabilization, (c) Rupee appreciation, and (c) possible permanent solution to its industrial relationship problem (with the conversion of temporary workers to permanent workers, and liberal wage hikes). Further, discount reduction and higher diesel engine availability (expected from September 2013) would be the key catalysts for operating / stock performance Currently the stock is trades at 16.2x FY14E with EPS of `96.8 FY14E and based on the current stage of automotive cycle we recommend Buy with a price target of `1,740.
For Private Client Circulation 1
Pakistan Suzuki: Export of complete knock down (CKD) kits of Euro-II compliant Alto were halted as 159 of its parts were the negative list of items traded between the two neighboring countries (Indo-Pak). Pak-Suzuki then discontinued production of various cars, including Alto, which needed Euro-II compliant engines from June due to emission norms. India is the only country in the region producing Euro-II compliant parts.
Ertiga in Pakistan: It is expected that demand for CKD kits for utility vehicle Ertiga in Pakistan to drive up exports. The car maker started exports of parts and CKD kits this fiscal year. The company has already seen a significant demand for Ertigas CKD kits, which also contributed to a jump in betterthan-expected revenue in the Q2FY13.
After 13 % fall in exports during H1FY13, Maruti is hoping to accelerate the export volumes in the second half. Due to labor problem at Manesar Plant Companys flagship exports model A-Star was not available. Moreover the company will start exporting new Alto 800 to Africa and Latin American countries form Q4FY13 onwards.
3W 3%
CV 5%
2W 77%
PV 15%
Intensifying competition: Intense competition has, however, reduced the company's market share by more than half, to about 37%, in a little over a decade. To stem its market share decline, Maruti is attempting to better anticipate changing consumer trends. However, highly cyclical demand, high operating leverage, and low switching costs for its customers prevent these benefits from translating into a hefty margin. Additionally, continued labor-related disputes at the company's factories, like the current Manesar plant shutdown, restrain Maruti's ability to grow volumes and profits at a higher rate.
India is one of the lowest car penetration levels in the world (12 PVs per thousand people) and among emerging economies, which at current estimates is less than 2%. The penetration range for developed markets (GNI per capita higher than 20000 $), is between 25% and 50%. A recent pan-India consumer survey reveals low car ownership only 40% owned a car versus 70% who owned a two-wheeler. Even emerging economies such as Mexico and Brazil have penetration levels between 15% and 20%. China and India are in the lower single digits, which presents a huge opportunity ahead. Car market depends on discretionary, factors such as employment generation, rise in disposable incomes; increasing affordability, favorable demographics and underdeveloped transport infrastructure have all contributed to healthy growth in passenger vehicle volumes over the past decade. The Indian PV market, continues to be dominated by the car segment has grown at a CAGR of 14.5% over the last decade (13.7% over the last five years), with over 11mn vehicles sold in the past five years. It is estimated that domestic passenger vehicle growth of 7%-15% respectively for FY13-FY14. The Utility Vehicle market too seems to hold considerable growth potential as the Indian buyer looks to upgrade to relatively premium segments of the PV market. Consequently, while volume potential remains very much in place, the revenue potential of the market too is gradually becoming more attractive. The small car segments (mini and compact) continue to rule the roost. Smaller ticket size, relative affordability for the purchase and, to a certain extent, necessity-led buying (owing to scant transport infrastructure in many pockets) are key reasons why the small car segment has historically held sway. Consequently, today 65% of the brands in the mini-to-mid size car market (95% of the market) belong to the mini/compact category.
Maruti is the largest exporter of PV since last eight years, exporting to around 120 countries globally. In 2011, the company exported 2.42 lakh cars (about 40% of our total volumes).
Hyundai exports to global markets from Lebanon and Israel in the Middle East to Australia, about 42% of Hyundai Indias exports go to EU countries such as Germany, Spain, Italy and the UK, which are very quality conscious markets.
Oragadam, TN
400,000
800,000
2016
200,000
NA
2014
GM Volkswagen
109,288 76,111
225,000 110,000
410,000 130,000
Honda
41,509
120,000
160,000
NA
30,574 17,227
40,000 100,000
NA NA
NA NA
$500 mn invested over 2 year on new Products & expansion. Investment is 580 mn Euro till date production started with skoda Fabia in May 2009, and VW Polo in Dec 2009 Decision to roll out car from Tapukara plant When Noida plant is at full capacity. Takapura initial capacity at 60000. Chakan plant is "joint" under volkswagen Also has engine plant capacity= 200,000. Maruti will source 100K of these per year.
Source for different company: Company Annual Reports, Company websites, News articles. (a) FY12 PV sales refer to only Passenger Vehicles; other commercial 4 wheelers have not been included (b) Current capacity reflects latest available data, actual capacity could have changed. * Tata Motors capacity includes its total installed four wheeler capacity (passenger + commercial), as per Annual Report **Mahindra capacity includes its total installed four wheeler capacity (passenger + commercial) as per Annual Report. Tractors are not included. (c) Luxury brand such as Audi, BMW, Mercedes, and some other small OEMs have not been included.
As an answer to these questions, the following key trends that will influence vehicle manufacturers, suppliers and dealers on multiple fronts: Increasing urbanization and evolving customer needs to have greater influence on OEM strategies and buying behavior than reactive regulatory policies. BY 2020, Indias population is expected to increase by an estimated 200 million, piling future pressure on the transport infrastructure. While regulatory policies on environmental compatibility and safety norms continues to lag global standard, the uncertainty related to diesel subsidies is likely to hurt demand for diesel vehicles. OEMs are therefore, likely to increase their offering in term of alternate fuel variants (CNG, LPG and also hybrids) and advanced safety features across segments. Increasing risks across value chain position OEMs to deploy range of mitigation strategies Indian auto industry is expecting to be short of 300,000 skilled personnel by 2020 across functions, including R&D and manufacturing, also various economics and geopolitical uncertainty that could threaten competitiveness of their operating in the country. Reforms in labor policies like recently announced National Manufacturing Policies are likely to implement in some time now. In the meantime, industry needs to proactively undertake steps to address labor-related issue through appropriate training, labor retention and compensation policies. With logistics infrastructure lagging behind the pace of the auto industrys expansion, OEMs will need to consider multi-plant strategies. They will look to cluster suppliers to be closer to regions with strong demand potential and for better control of the supply chain.
Indias overall median age of population at 26.2 years is one of the lowest among emerging economies. About 370 million people are in the age group of 0-14 years, (of which 220 million in age group 6-14 years). This represents tremendous buying power in the years to come.
Global OEMs gain market share, while competition drives domestic OEMs to bridge technology gap: Apart from localizing production to achieve cost parity and production differentiation, global OEMs also continue to expand their distribution network to tire II, III and IV cities. In response, domestic OEMs are strengthening their technological capabilities through organic and inorganic investments. Local demand remains the top priority of domestic and global OEMs. However, they will be looking to leverage India as an export hub to emerging markets, including Africa, Eastern Europe and South East Asia.
OEMs leverage digital marketing for urban consumers and non-traditional distribution channels for rural markets: With increasing internet presentation and Distribution Network of top players availability on new information channels OEMs are likely to increase their digital marketing spends, especially on the social media. There will likely be emphasis on Maruti innovative promotion tools such as live launch websites and online customer service, Current: 1000 showrooms in among others. In rural market, OEMs are expecting to increase their focus on non670 cities. 2946 service centers in traditional distribution methods, promotion activity to local festival events to spread 1395 cities awareness and increase brand visibility.
Expected: NA Hyundai Current: 336 dealers in cities. 721 service points. 300 rural outlets proposed Expected: NA Tata Motors Current: 450 Expected: 750, FY13 Mahindra Current: NA Expected: NA Toyota Current: 175 outlets Expected: NA Renault Current: 14 dealers Expected: 100, FY13 Nissan Current: 30 dealers Expected: 100, FY13 Ford Current: 200 in 110 cities Expected: 250, FY13 General Motors Current: 250 sales outlets 250 service centre Expected: NA Volkswagen Current: 100 dealers in 73 cities Expected: NA Honda Current: 135 facilities in 77 cities Expected: NA Skoda Current: 82 dealers Expected: 120, FY13 Fiat Current: 67 joint dealers, 167 showrooms Expected: 22, FY13
New entrants using creative business models for mobility, in-vehicle services and after-sales support: With Indias urban population to reach 500 million and the growing infrastructure concerns, consumers will need alternative personal mobility solutions. New entrants such as car-rental companies, multi-brand service networks and group buying companies are already taking a lead to leverage the Indian consumers need for mobility, after-sales services, and need for enhanced bargaining power. Suppliers to enhance local product development capabilities, supply chain competency, and flexibility to meet diverse OEM expectations: Indias auto component industry has significant growth opportunity considering the rapidly expanding EQ, aftermarket and export demand as global and local suppliers adopt various strategies to establish their positions. Domestic suppliers are focused on forming alliance to access best practice in R&D to meet the need to OEMs for faster new product introduction, while global suppliers are setting up R&D centers in India to increase local contents in vehicles and the same time leverage it as a global hub for design and technology. The suppliers community will need to adapt to diverse expectation of OEMs. Domestic manufacturing are greater flexibility and closer engagement; global OEMs on the other hand are expecting quick responsiveness and global quality standard at local cost levels. Dealers to focus on managing their capital agenda, skill development and shifting revenue contribution of high-margin allied services: In particular, franchises of global OEMs will become attractive because of higher margin offers and flexible payment options. Apart from expanding their portfolio of brand franchises, dealers will also look to increase share of high-margin allied businesses including service, parts and vehicle financing/insurance. Increasing rural-urban mix: Domestic Urban Mix has changed: A few years earlier, the top 10 cities accounted for about 60% of total passenger car demand, and this ratio has reduced drastically to about 40% currently. Rural share too has increased with vehicle saturation slowly being approached in some of Indias major cities, Indias automobile growth story is slowly moving towards the hinterland.
Mini Segment Company Price: /Brand Petrol Maruti Suzuki M800 201408 Alto 268253 Alto K10 308810 Wagon R 341761 A Star 366540 Hyundai Motors Eon 269999 Santro Xing 352025 General Motors Spark 323458
Prices Ex showroom Delhi
Capacity (cc) 800 800 1000 1000 1000 815 1090 1000
Domestic Passenger vehicle (Compact Segment): The compact segment is the most fiercely competitive, global players like Ford, Volkswagen and Nissan have made strong inroads in this segment over past few years and excise duty bracket (upto 13.1 ft / 4000 mm) is only 10%. For any car lengthier than 4000mm, the excise duty is 22% + `15000. Maruti has the best selling model in this segment, the Swift, which is also the third highest selling brand in India (selling close to 125000 units annually). The Ritz also happens to be a popular brand, selling close to 50000 per year. Despite strong brand presence we remain cautious on Marutis prospects in this segment, given the recent strong performance by competitors. We feel that the coverage network advantage and brand value premium of some of its bestsellers like the Swift and Ritz might come under challenge by competition. MSILs high Revenue sensitivity to this segment makes this a key segment for future performance. Domestic Passenger Vehicle (Super compact & Mid Size Segment): Super Compact: The Dzire is the strongest brands in these segments respectively. With the normalization at production at Manesar, we expect Maruti to recover its lost market share in this segment as they move into full capacity. Maruti launched the new Dzire in early February 2012, sharing the platform of the new Swift. Being less than 4000mm, the car comes under the excise slab of 10%. MSIL has added about 150 features to the older version and launched the car at an introductory price of `479000 and `580750 for the petrol and diesel version respectively. Even though there will be tax savings on excise, new features added will negate this to some extent, and incremental contribution is expected to be marginally higher. We expect this car to be a key driver in the Super Compact segment over H2FY13. The Mid Size sedan segment is becoming competitive, and the SX4 has been challenged from the Hyundai Verna and the VW Vento. With production issues at Manesar, SX4 sales have fallen to less than 700 units in October 2012. The Verna and Vento have grown at Marutis expense, at ~3500 per month and ~2500 per month respectively over H1FY13. There is a current order book of about 1 months sales on the Diesel SX4 which we expect to be converted with normalization of production at Manesar. Domestic Passenger Vehicle (Executive Segment): Maruti entered this segment recently with the launch of the Kizashi in February 2011. It has sold about 141 units CY12 YTD (518 units in CY11) out of a total market size of about 55000 units per year. Revenue contribution is this segment is however less than half a percent. Domestic Utility Vehicle Segment: Maruti is a relatively small player in the Utility Vehicle business with its models the Gypsy and the Grand Vitara (premium SUV), which collectively sell about 5500 units per year (Vitara sales are minisucle). The Gypsy costs roughly `550,000 while the premium Vitara is close to `1700000. The UV market is dominated by Mahindra (Bolero, Scorpio, and Xylo); while other players like Tata Motors and Toyota also have significant market share.
Super Compact & Mid size Segment Company Price: Capacity /Brand Petrol (cc) Maruti Suzuki Dzire 504,582 1200 SX4 702,422 1590 Hyundai Motors Accent 506,869 1500 Verna 699,655 1400 Tata Motors Manza 554,762 1370 Indigo 463,881 1200 General Motors Aveo 590,254 1400 Ford Fiesta 550,330 1600 Toyata Etios 503990 1500 Volkswogen Vento 699000 1600 Honda City 770000 1500 Skoda Rapid 675000 1600 Nissan Sunny 583000 1500 Mahindra & Mahindra Verito 495371 1400
Prices Ex showroom Delhi
28055
C. COMMERCIAL VEHICLES (VAN/MPV) EECO 18988 17833 17156 16263 10465 15653 QoQ gr % -6.1 -3.8 -5.2 -35.7 49.6 Omni 24624 23141 23593 21353 17051 22527 QoQ gr % -6.1 -3.8 -5.2 -35.7 49.6 Source: SIAM, Company, R K Global research NL* stand for Not Lunched
Competitive analysis of Maruti Suzuki: The right turn: The beam light
Maruti, with about 40% market share, is the largest passenger vehicle manufacturer in India, with many bestselling brands such as Alto and Swift in the Mini and Compact hatchback segments. With interest rates expected to moderate, plans to launch four new models this year in different passenger vehicle segments, and increased availability of high-in-demand diesel engines, Maruti is well-positioned to grow its volumes from its current fiscal lows. Maruti Suzuki's Alto is not only the best-selling mini hatchback in India, but also the best selling small car in the world, outpacing the likes of Volkswagen (Gol and Golf), and Fiat (Uno). Maruti's single biggest market, India, has one of the lowest car densities in the world at eight cars per thousand people and we believe Maruti should be one of the biggest beneficiaries of increased car density.
We believe the stock could remain at current levels in the short term on account of the tepid demand environment, though operating environment for Maruti is gradually improving, with (a) initial signs of demand recovery, driven by new Alto launch during festive season, (b) discount stabilization, and (c) possible permanent solution to its industrial relationship problem (with the conversion of temporary workers to permanent workers, and liberal wage hikes). Further, discount reduction and higher diesel engine availability (expected from September 2013) would be the key catalysts for operating / stock performance Currently the stock is trades at 16.2x FY14E with EPS of `96.8 FY14E and based on the current stage of automotive cycle we recommend Buy with a price target of `1,740.
11
Application Of Funds
Financial Ratios Description Adj.EPS CEPS DPS Book value EBIDTM Pre-Tax Margin PATM CPM ROE ROCE Sales/FA Revenue Growth EBIDTA Growth PAT Growth EPS Growth EV/EBIDTA EV/Sales P/BV P/E FY'11 79.2 115.0 7.5 479.8 9.7 8.5 FY'12 56.6 96.0 7.5 525.7 7.1 6.0 Per Share (Rs)
6.2 4.6 9.3 7.8 Performance Ratios (%) 16.5 22.1 65.5 24.6 -8.9 -8.4 -7.8 10.8 13.2 580.3 -3.6 -29.9 -28.6 -29.2
Cash Flow Statement (` Mn) 26,437.0 13,745.0 19,162.0 3,595.0 10,135.0 -10,240.0 4,171.0 34,098.0 -24,114.0 21,253.0 8,269.0 11,384.0 -3,731.0 -1,810.0 27,857.0 -23,125.0 -10,406.0 7,874.0 18,635.0 -5,012.0 1,174.0 41,834.0 -59,334.0 0.0
29,530.0 9,225.0 22,483.0 -8,250.0 268.0 55,666.0 -30,000.0 0.0 -30,000.0 -565.0 0.0 -1,254.0 -3,323.0 -5,142.0 20,524.0 29,553.0 50,077.0
-2,861.0 -33,531.0 -59,334.0 Cash Flow From Financing 0.0 -5,123.0 -278.0 -1,733.0 -7,134.0 24,103.0 982.0 25,085.0 -986.0 8,656.0 -552.0 -2,167.0 4,951.0 -723.0 25,085.0 24,362.0 20,886.0 6,161.0 -1,335.0 -3,021.0 22,691.0 5,191.0 24,362.0 29,553.0
12
Locate Us
City Ahmedabad Delhi Jaipur Kolkata Mumbai Chennai Rating Criteria
BUY HOLD SELL
Address 501, Wall Street, Near Gujarat College, Ahmedabad-380 006 Suite 5, Sagar Apartment, 6 Tilak Marg, New Delhi-110 001 248, Ganpati Plaza, 2nd Floor, M I Road, Jaipur-302 001 2 Saklat Place, Suite 9, Kolkata- 700 072 503 & 504, Adamji Building, Narsi Natha Road, Masjid Bunder (W), Mumbai-400 009 163/2, Kutcherry Road, Mylapore Chennai- 600 004
Contact +91 (79) 4002 0999 +91 (11) 4310 0999 +91 (141) 404 0999 +91 (33) 4014 1999 +91 (22) 4210 5555 +91 (44) 4593 9999
Stock to generate return above 15% from CMP over the next 12 months period Stock to generate return between 0-15% from CMP over the next 12 months period Stock to generate less than 0% from CMP over the next 12 months period
Coverage Terminology
IC = Initiating Coverage RU = Result Update EU = Event Update NC = Not Covered
www.rkglobal.net
Disclaimer: This document is not for public distribution and has been furnished to you solely for your information and must not be
reproduced or redistributed to any other person. Persons into whose possession this document may come are required to observe these restrictions. Opinion expressed is our current opinion as of the date appearing on this material only. While we endeavor to update on a reasonable basis the information discussed in this material, there may be regulatory, compliance, or other reasons that prevent us from doing so. Prospective investors and others are cautioned that any forward-looking statements are not predictions and may be subject to change without notice. Our proprietary trading and investment businesses may make investment decisions that are inconsistent with the recommendations expressed herein. The information in this document has been printed on the basis of publicly available information, internal data and other reliable sources believed to be true and are for general guidance only. While every effort is made to ensure the accuracy and completeness of information contained, the company takes no guarantee and assumes no liability for any errors or omissions of the information. No one can use the information as the basis for any claim, demand or cause of action. Recipients of this material should rely on their own investigations and take their own professional advice. Each recipient of this document should make such investigations as it deems necessary to arrive at an independent evaluation of an investment in the securities of companies referred to in this document (including the merits and risks involved), and should consult their own advisors to determine the merits and risks of such an investment. R K Global, its directors, analysts or employees do not take any responsibility, financial or otherwise, of the losses or the damages sustained due to the investments made or any action taken on basis of this report.
13