Scribd
Upload
634 views

EADOX-MAR Comparison Chart & Details

This document compares two treatment processes - Multistage Aerobic Bio Reactor (MAR) and Electrolytically Activated Oxidation (EADOX) - for treating 20 KLD of sewage. MAR uses biological oxidation while EADOX uses electrochemical oxidation. MAR has a smaller area and RCC volume required but higher total annual operating costs. EADOX treated water requires post-treatment while MAR treated water can be directly reused. EADOX sludge is classified as hazardous waste while MAR sludge can be reused as eco-friendly fertilizer.

Uploaded by

jeykumar.Balannair
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
634 views

EADOX-MAR Comparison Chart & Details

This document compares two treatment processes - Multistage Aerobic Bio Reactor (MAR) and Electrolytically Activated Oxidation (EADOX) - for treating 20 KLD of sewage. MAR uses biological oxidation while EADOX uses electrochemical oxidation. MAR has a smaller area and RCC volume required but higher total annual operating costs. EADOX treated water requires post-treatment while MAR treated water can be directly reused. EADOX sludge is classified as hazardous waste while MAR sludge can be reused as eco-friendly fertilizer.

Uploaded by

jeykumar.Balannair
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
You are on page 1/ 4

COMPARISON CHART FOR 20 KLD STP

Considered Parameter

1) BOD - 350 mg/l


2) COD - 900 mg/l
3) TSS - 200 mg/l
4) Flow - 20 KLD
- MAR – 16 Hours
Operating Hours
EADOX - 20 Hours

EADOX
MAR
PARAMETERS Electrolytically Activated
Multistage Aerobic Bio Reactor
Oxidation
Type of process Bio mechanical oxidation Electro Chemical Oxidation
Area 7m2 8m2
RCC volume required 15m3 20m3
Power (Reactor) kwh/m3 1.22 kwh/m3 1.2 kwh/m3
Total power 36 69.4
required/day (units)
Method of treatment Organic (Biological) Inorganic (Chemical)
Treatment efficiency (%) 98.50% 85.70%
Treated water reuse Suitable for direct use Post treatment required.
option BOD removal & filtration
Legal complaint option as Green category Red category
per PCB Norms
Sludge treatment 95% digested in process by Sludge separated in holding
microbes tank and stored
Sludge disposal status Eco-friendly bio manure easily Classified as Hazardous
disposal waste. Stored as disposal
through PCB authorized
person.
Odour 100% Free in storage condition Not available

1
O & M OPTION COMPARISON

Description MAR EADOX


Chemical cost per year Rs.3,960/- Rs.10,950/-
Power cost per year Rs.65,700/- Rs.1,26,655/-
36 unitsx365 days x Rs.5/- per unit 69.4 units x 365 days x Rs.5/- / unit
Replacement cost / year Rs.11,375/- Rs.56,625/-
Total cost O&M / year Rs.81,035/- Rs.1,94,230/-

2
PROCESS FLOW CHART – 20 KLD

EADOX – Electrolytically Activated Degenerative Oxidation

P1

EADOX
Reactor

Brain Carbon
Bar Screen Collection
Electroliser Filter
Tank

P2

Storage

P3

Collection Tank:
P1 = Feed Pump – 1 HP
MOC : RCC-Civil
Volume : 12m3 P2 = Recirculation Pump – 1 HP
Storage Tank:
MOC : RCC-Civil P3 = Backwash Pump – 1 HP
Volume: 8m3
EADOX Module
MOC : FRP
Bottom Diameter : 400mm
Top Diameter : 700mm
Height : 3000mm
Volume : 1.25m3
Brine Electrolyser:
MOC : FRP
Diameter : 700mm
Carbon Filter Module
MOC : FRP
Diameter : 400mm
Height : 2000mm

3
4

You might also like