569361

research-article2015

TCXXXX10.1177/0040059915569361Council for Exceptional ChildrenTEACHING Exceptional Children

Original Article

Beyond Stereotypes
Understanding, Recognizing, and
Working With Twice-Exceptional
Learners

TEACHING Exceptional Children, Vol. 47, No. 4, pp. 216225. Copyright 2015 The Author(s). DOI: 10.1177/0040059915569361

Lois Baldwin, Stuart N. Omdal, and Daphne Pereles

The term twice exceptional was
coined to describe students who
have a disability and who also have
characteristics and traits associated
with giftedness. These students may
appear to be capable and bright
but do not demonstrate that ability
when asked to produce work in the
classroom. Recognizing these students
may be challenging, as the disability
may overshadow the gift, the gift
may mask the effect of the disability,
or both remedial and advanced
learning needs may go completely
unnoticed. Strategies for serving
twice-exceptional students include
addressing the students strengths
and interests; providing appropriate
social and emotional support; offering
adaptations for academic strengths
and accommodations for learning
needs; and creating a supportive, safe,
problem-solving culture that values
the success of every student. What do
twice-exceptional learners look like?
The students profiled in this article
provide a glimpse into the variety of
ways twice exceptionality can present
in the classroom environment.
Student Profiles
Lance

Lance is a second-grade student with

autism spectrum disorder. He spends
half of his day in the special education
216

COUNCIL FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN

classroom, where he receives reading

and math instruction as well as social
skills training. The other half of his day
is spent in a second-grade general
education classroom with support from
a paraprofessional for social studies
and science. He is progressing at an
average pace in reading decoding but is
still struggling with complex
comprehension questions that require
character analysis and evaluation.
Lance likes school and the teachers say
that he works hard, but he finds it to
be confusing and unpredictable,
particularly when instruction or
directions are presented orally with few
or no visuals. When he is stressed or
confused, he will twirl his hair, flap his
hands, or begin to cry. His classmates
usually dont pay attention to these
behaviors. Although he sits with other
students at lunch, he does not have
any friends. He spends most of his
recess time wandering the periphery of
the playground, talking to himself.
Lance says that he likes science
class and demonstrates advanced
knowledge and vocabulary in the area
of botany and some aspects of biology.
After having students read about places
where plants and animals live, his
teacher asked the students what that
was called. Several students answered
that it was their environment. Lance,
however, answered that it was a
habitat because, as he explained, the

word environment means a larger area.

He said it was like the difference
between house and neighborhood. He
was insistent that everyone use the
right word. At home, Lance has
developed his own scientific lab in
his bedroom with different types of
plants growing on his windowsill and
bedside stand. He is keeping a journal
in which he draws diagrams and
pictures of the growth and parts of
each plant. His mother is surprised by
the sophistication and accuracy of the
drawings and his vocabulary. Not only
does he know the scientific name for
many of the plants; he insists on using
them both in his journal and when hes
speaking about his favorite topic.
Lance likes to read nonfiction books
and to watch science programs on
television about botany.
Hadley

Hadley, an active, verbally precocious,

and social fifth grader, was identified
for the gifted program when she was
in second grade. In both her general
education class and the gifted pull-out
program, Hadley demonstrates
creativity, curiosity, and advanced
humor. She also has an excellent
memory as demonstrated by her
ability to remember facts and details
that she learns in lessons, particularly
social studies. She has a strong sense

of social justice and will come to the

aid of students who are being teased
on the playground or at lunch. She
also becomes emotional when the
television news describes children
who are being abused or hurt by war
or other similar circumstances. She
was so upset about the fact that girls
in Afghanistan were not being allowed
to go to school that she persuaded her
gifted resource teacher to support a
fund-raising activity for those
students. Hadley developed a plan,
organized the student activities, and
demonstrated leadership abilities. She
is popular with all of the students in
both her classroom and the gifted
resource room and is well liked by the
teachers.

short sentences, few descriptions, and

basic vocabulary. Hadleys mother has
complained to the teacher that Hadley is
overwhelmed by the amount of
homework, particularly in social studies,
even though it is a subject she loves. Her
mother often finds Hadley playing games
on her laptop rather than reading the
textbook or doing the worksheet or
homework questions. She frequently
says she finished her homework in
school or makes up excuses. An
assignment that should take her a half
hour may take her at least twice that
amount of time. Her teacher has also
noticed that her pace is slow and
labored.

Students who demonstrate

gifts and talents but also
have a disability are
known as twice exceptional
and do not fit the
stereotypical
characteristics of students
with a disability or
giftedness.

Pedro is a ninth grader at a large urban

high school. He likes his physical
education and music classes, but he
really enjoys his pre-engineering
computer-aided design (CAD) class and
shows great aptitude. He participates
on the schools football and track
teams. Although he consistently earns
average grades in all content areas, his
teachers are frustrated because he often
appears to be daydreaming or doodling,
not following instructions on how to do
particular assignments, and always
looking for but rarely finding his
homework papers. His notebook is a
disaster, with scattered papers and
no discernable system of organization.
This has caused him to get in trouble
numerous times due to missed
deadlines on papers and projects. His
English and history teachers have
noted that he will contribute interesting
insights or make connections between
literature and historical events that
other students miss or do not
understand. But they also indicate that
they are concerned because he disrupts
the flow of the lesson by calling out the
information or the answers. He is late

Given that she is in the gifted

program, her classroom teacher was
surprised to see that her fall universal
screening scores in reading placed her in
the 40th percentile. Although this scoring
does not put her in the at-risk category,
she is not demonstrating reading
achievement commensurate with her
intellectual ability. Her math universal
screening scores are in the 95th
percentile, and her progress in class
would indicate that the assessment is
accurate. The teacher is concerned
because she has noticed that although
Hadley uses advanced and descriptive
vocabulary when she is speaking, her
writing does not demonstrate any of this
verbal richness. Her writing is limited to

Pedro

for his first-period math class two or

three times a week because he has
stayed up late and has overslept.
At home he likes to take apart old
computers and small appliances and
combine parts from them to make new
devices. He often works past midnight
if he is working on a new project. One
of his creations was the basis for his
science fair project last year, winning
him a first-place award. His contentarea teachers and other students were
very impressed, as they had not seen
evidence of that kind of performance
from him before. Several teachers
questioned if he really had done the
work because it was so well done and
more sophisticated than what he
produces on a regular basis in his
content classes. Although his father
sees Pedros greater potential, as a
single father who works two jobs, he
has little time to meet with school
personnel to discuss his sons mediocre
performance and tardiness.
Definition of Twice
Exceptionality
Are these students profiles familiar? Do
their profiles demonstrate the confusion
that occurs when a student who appears
to be capable and bright does not
demonstrate that ability when asked to
produce work in the classroom,
particularly on written assignments? Is
the lack of work often accompanied by
inappropriate behaviors, such as calling
out, disorganization, disinterest, or acting
out? Teachers find such students to be
confusing enigmas. Students who
demonstrate gifts and talents but also
have a disability are known as twice
exceptional and do not fit the
stereotypical characteristics of students
with a disability or giftedness (Baum &
Owen, 2004).
Through a better understanding about
the nature of disabilities and a broadened

TEACHING EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN | MARCH/APRIL 2015

217

conception of giftedness, the term twice

exceptional has entered the mainstream
literature. Much of the literature on twice
exceptionality addresses students who
are gifted and have learning disabilities,
though the term can be applied to other
disabilities, such as behavioral and
emotional disabilities, sensory and
physical disabilities, attention deficit
hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and
autism spectrum disorder. Professional
organizations, like the Council for
Exceptional Children, have developed
definitions of twice exceptionality.
Recently a group of professional
organizations, including the Council for
Exceptional Children, collaborated
through a Community of Practice
approach to create an agreed upon
definition that could be used nationally
(see box).
Passed by Congress in 1989 and
continuing for over 20 years, the Jacob
K. Javits Gifted and Talented Students
Education Act was the impetus for
multiple projects and research activities
to further educators understanding of
the complex needs of twice-exceptional
students. In 2004, with the
reauthorization of the Individuals with
Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), for the
first time there was federal
acknowledgement that students with
disabilities could also be gifted. At the
current time, there is an increased
interest in this special population as
indicated by the number of research
studies and projects (e.g., Iowas
Belin-Blank Center for Gifted Education,
Colorado Department of Education
Twice-Exceptional Project), publications
(e.g., the Twice-Exceptional Newsletter),
and symposia (e.g., NAGC TwiceExceptional Symposium). A common
thrust of these projects focuses on the
recognition and potential strategies for
meeting the needs of twice-exceptional
students.
Recognizing Characteristics of
Twice-Exceptional Students

In the case of twice-exceptional

students, their educational needs
whether advanced or remedialmay
not be observed for a variety of reasons.
Baum and Owen (2004) identified three
218

COUNCIL FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN

types of conditions that make it difficult

for educators to recognize these special
students. In the first condition, the
disability is recognized but not the
strengths. The second condition is the
reverse: giftedness is recognized but not
the disability. For the last condition,
neither strengths nor disabilities are
recognized.

Definition of Twice
Exceptionality, National
Twice-Exceptional
Community of Practice
The following definition was created
by the National Twice-Exceptional
Community of Practice in 2014:
Twice exceptional (2e) individuals
evidence exceptional ability and
disability, which results in a
unique set of circumstances. Their
exceptional ability may dominate,
hiding their disability; their
disability may dominate, hiding
their exceptional ability; each may
mask the other so that neither is
recognized or addressed.
2e students, who may perform
below, at, or above grade level,
require the following:
Specialized methods of
identification that consider the
possible interaction of the
exceptionalities
Enriched/advanced educational
opportunities that develop the
childs interests, gifts and
talents while also meeting the
childs learning needs
Simultaneous supports that
ensure the childs academic
success and social-emotional
well-being, such as
accommodations, therapeutic
interventions, and specialized
instruction.
Working successfully with this
unique population requires
specialized academic training and
ongoing professional development.
(personal correspondence, May 1,
2014)

Lance, Hadley, and Pedro each

represent one of these three conditions.
Lances disability is recognized early
and special education services are
begun. Because the focus is on
remediation, however, educators are
unaware of or are not looking for his
gifts or talents. This is a common
situation for some twice-exceptional
students. For example, for students
with a reading disability, the focus may
be on the decoding or fluency issue
even though they may be capable of
understanding and analyzing complex
literature and participating in analytical
discussions. The disability focus
creates a barrier to advanced
educational opportunities. In Lances
case, the school team acknowledges his
disability and supports him
academically and socially in those
areas of need. However, the team has
not recognized nor addressed his
exceptional ability and advanced needs
in science.

Twice-exceptional
students must have a
comprehensive,
individualized, flexible
plan that addresses the
whole child.
Hadleys experience exemplifies
when giftedness is noted at a young
age and nurtured. Twice-exceptional
students like Hadley may be identified
for gifted education programming or
may demonstrate their abilities of
advanced thinking and
conceptualization in classroom
activities. However, it is not unusual
for these students to hit a wall
beginning in middle school or later
when they are no longer able to
compensate with their ability to
memorize material or to verbalize
responses (McEachern & Bornot, 2001).
In Hadleys case, she memorized words
and passages until she could no longer
fake her ability to read and write on
grade level. It is not unusual to hear
adults mistakenly say that a student is
lazy or not trying hard enough
when an apparent mismatch between
skills and performance occurs.

Pedros remedial and advanced

needs of twice exceptionality are
completely unrecognized. Researchers
refer to this phenomenon as students
whose talents are masked by the
disability or the disability is masked
by the advanced ability, making the
students appear average (Baum &
Owen, 2004). These students often
struggle or fail in school. The students
are frequently confused and frustrated
by their ability to conceptualize and
think at a faster rate than most of their
peers but at the same time are unable to
keep up with the course requirements
because of their disability. Educators
may see glimmers of the gift or talent,
like Pedros CAD teacher or the science
fair coordinator, but for the most part,
the educational experience is rarely at a
level commensurate with the students
intellectual or talent ability. Likewise,
educators may see behavioral issues,
such as Pedros tardiness or calling out,
but those issues likely would not, in
themselves, demonstrate a need for
further investigation.

Research indicates that

twice-exceptional students
require a dual-emphasis
approachone that
focuses on the strengths
and talents while
supporting and addressing
the disability.
It is not easy to recognize twiceexceptional students. As Reis, Baum,
and Burke (2014) noted, successful
identification and programming
depend on both the depth of
educators understanding about
giftedness and disabilities and their
intersection or comorbidity (p. 218).
Therefore, educators must become
familiar with characteristics of
giftedness and disabilities that may
point to a potential twice-exceptional
condition. Because educators,
including special education teachers,
interact with these students on a daily
basis, it is important for teachers to
recognize and understand the
characteristics of twice-exceptional

learners. Table 1 is a compilation of

characteristics and behaviors that are
associated with giftedness. In
addition, it includes a column about
how a disability may influence that
behavior. Please note that not all
behaviors apply to all gifted students,
nor do all of the behaviors of twiceexceptional students in the second
column apply to all twice-exceptional
students. These are merely indicators
to determine further investigation of
student need.
Strategies for Serving TwiceExceptional Students

The purpose of recognizing the

strengths and needs of twiceexceptional students is to employ
appropriate strategies and
accommodations to meet the dual
individual educational needs. A
problem-solving process is effective
for bringing multiple sources of
information in order to make
decisions that will have the best
outcomes for these students. The
problem-solving process involves (a)
defining area of need, (b) collecting
and analyzing data, (c) implementing
a plan and (d) evaluating the
progress. Effective problem-solving
teams include family members;
teachers from general, special, and
gifted education; administrators; and
other school personnel involved with
the student and who can contribute
to the process. As the team reviews
data from multiple sources that
address the different facets of the
student, it will become evident that a
variety of strategies will be necessary
to support the unique needs of the
twice-exceptional student.
Research indicates that twiceexceptional students require a
dual-emphasis approachone that
focuses on strengths and talents
while supporting and addressing the
disability (Assouline & Whiteman,
2011; Baum, Cooper, & Neu, 2001;
Berninger & Abbott, 2013; McCoach,
Kehle, Bray, & Siegle 2001; Nicpon,
Allmon, Sieck, & Stinson, 2011;
Willard-Holt & Morrison, 2013).
Whereas it is possible to think of

strategies that work for students with

high ability or potential and other
strategies that have been successful
for addressing the needs of specific
disabilities, the fact that the twiceexceptional student requires both
types of support necessitates an
integrated, whole-child approach
(Pereles, Omdal, & Baldwin, 2009).
Addressing only the area of
remediation or only the area of
strengths and interests is inadequate.
In reviewing the literature on twice
exceptionality, one will encounter
many lists under the heading of
Strategies for Twice-Exceptional
Students (Baum et al., 2001; Baum &
Owens, 2004; Coleman, 2005). It is
tempting for teachers to look at the
lists and come to the conclusion that
the strategies listed are of a universal
nature and any one of them would
work equally well with any twiceexceptional student. It must be noted
that though some common
characteristics may exist, each twiceexceptional student should be regarded
as having a unique profile requiring a
tailored set of evidence-based strategies
reflecting his or her personal strengths
and challenges.
Strengths and Interests
When planning for instruction of twiceexceptional students, the first critical
consideration is identification of the
students academic and intellectual
strengths, talents, and interests in and
outside of school and other personal
factors, such as creativity, intrinsic
motivation, and sustained attention.
Focusing on the students strengths
before addressing the challenges is well
supported in the literature (King, 2005;
Olenchak, 2009; Reis et al., 2014).
There are a number of important
questions that the problem-solving
team can ask in order to begin the
process of determining how to address
the students strengths and interests.
Figure 1 provides some questions
teams can use to identify strengths and
areas of need.
Questions targeting the students
learning strengths and interests guide the
problem-solving teams development of a

TEACHING EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN | MARCH/APRIL 2015

219

Table 1. Comparisons of Characteristics of Gifted Students and Twice-Exceptional Students

Recurrent behaviors and

characteristics of gifted students

Possible behaviors and characteristics of twiceexceptional students

Learning

Possesses ability to learn basic

skills quickly and easily and retain
information with less repetition

Often struggles to learn basic skills; may demonstrate

need for strategies in order to acquire basic skills and
information

Verbal skills

Exhibits high verbal ability

May demonstrate high verbal ability but may also show

extreme difficulty in written language area; may use
language in inappropriate ways and at inappropriate
times

Reading skills

Acquires reading skills early

Reading problems can be evident early; may

demonstrate need for strategies in phonics, phonemic
awareness, and fluency; may mask reading deficits
through compensation until shifting from learning to
read to reading to learn

Organizational skills

Organizational skills can vary; some

gifted students can be very organized
whereas others struggle

Usually struggles with organization of things, ideas,

and time

Observational skills

Has keen powers of observation

Has strong observation skills but may demonstrate

deficits in memory

Critical thinking/
problem-solving skills

Adept at critical thinking, problem

solving, and decision-making skills

May excel in solving real-world problems; can

demonstrate outstanding critical thinking and
decision-making skills; often independently develops
compensatory skills

Attention

Has long attention span; may

demonstrate persistent, intense
concentration

Attention is frequently affected; may be able to

concentrate for long periods of time in areas of interest

Curiosity

Demonstrates questioning attitude

May demonstrate a strong questioning attitude, may

appear disrespectful when questioning information and
facts presented by the teacher

Creativity

Generates creative thoughts, ideas,

actions; may be innovative

Imagination may be unusual; may frequently

generate original and at times rather bizarre ideas;
is extremely divergent in thought; may appear to
daydream when generating ideas

Risk taking

Takes risks

Is often unwilling to take risks with regard to

academics or areas of deficit; takes risks in nonschool
areas without consideration of consequences

Sense of humor

Possesses unusual, often highly

developed sense of humor

Humor may be used to divert attention from school

failure; may use humor to make fun of peers or to
avoid trouble

Maturity

May mature at different rates than age

peers

Sometimes appears immature by using anger, crying,

and withdrawal to express feelings and to deal with
difficulties

Independence

Has a strong sense of independence

and self-efficacy

Requires frequent teacher support and feedback in

deficit areas; is highly independent in other areas; often
appears to be extremely stubborn and Inflexible

Indicator

(continued)

220

COUNCIL FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN

Table 1. (continued)

Recurrent behaviors and

characteristics of gifted students

Possible behaviors and characteristics of twiceexceptional students

Social skills

May not be accepted by other children

and may feel isolated

May be perceived as a loner; sometimes has difficulty

being accepted by peers due to poor social skills

Leadership

Exhibits leadership ability

May be a leader among the more nontraditional

students; can demonstrate strong streetwise
behavior; the disability may interfere with ability to
exercise leadership skills

Broad interests

Is interested in a wide range of topics

Is interested in many topics, but often, learning

problems impede pursuit of them

Focused interests

Shows very focused interest, that is,

a passion about a certain topic to the
exclusion of others

Often demonstrates a very focused interest, that is,

a passion about a certain topic to the exclusion of
othersoften not school-related subjects

Indicator

Note: Adapted from Comparisons of Characteristics of Gifted Students With or Without Disabilities, by E. Nielsen, D. Higgins, L.
Baldwin, D. Pereles, 2000, unpublished manuscript. Adapted with permission.
Figure 1. Questions to Help Determine Need in the Area of Strengths and Interests

In what subjects does the student excel?

Does the student show evidence of higher level thinking in this subject?
What is the students favored mode of learning information and skills?
What is the students favored mode of expressing him/herself?
Does the student qualitatively extend assignments and projects beyond the requirements? (Not just writing more pages
for a report, but adding insights reflecting a deeper and more complex understanding.)
In what topics does the student have interest and knowledge that is far above the level of a typical student of the same
age? Does the student have an intense focus on a single topic that may be considered unusual?
In what school-based or out-of-school activities does the student participate, and/or perform at a higher level than his/
her age-mates and/or has received recognition?
To what degree does the challenge/disability impact the ability of the student to pursue this area of interest?
How has the student utilized his/her strengths to compensate or mediate the areas of challenge?

comprehensive plan for the student.

Determining a students strengths and
interests can be ascertained through a
variety of assessments, such as student,
parent, and teacher interviews and
checklists. Observation and anecdotal
information, often collected via student
interest forms, is also helpful in
developing a profile of the students
strengths and interests. For example,
Scales for Rating the Behavioral
Characteristics of Superior Students by
Renzulli et al. (2010) addresses areas of
learning, creativity, motivation, and
leadership as well as the option to gather
information on content areas, the arts,
communication, and planning. A student

interest form (see Yssel, Adams, Clarke,

& Jones, 2014) for parents to fill out
requests information regarding the
students favorite books, after-school
activities, a passionate interest,
vocabulary, and so on. The Interest-ALyzer Family of Instruments (Renzulli,
1997) is a survey for students that
requests information about areas of
interest in which the student has
already been involved in order to
create opportunities for further
investigation or creative productivity.
This type of instrument is easy for
parents to complete and garners
helpful information from a very
important source: the student. Sitting

down with the student one-on-one is

also extremely important, especially for
younger students who might not be
able to fill out a form on their own.
This kind of information can help fill in
the gaps not addressed by more
formalized assessments.
Once the problem-solving team has
this important information as part of a
comprehensive data set, they can begin
to determine a plan for the student to
develop identified strengths and
interests. Plans will be tailored to the
students particular strengths, learning
needs, and personality. A sample of
some of the strategies that have
frequently been suggested are

TEACHING EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN | MARCH/APRIL 2015

221

Figure 2. Questions to Help Determine Need in the Area of Challenge or Disability

In what subject(s) does the student have difficulty?

What is the nature of the learning difficulty?
What is the students favored mode of learning information and skills?
What tasks or learning activities does the student avoid?
Does the student demonstrate negative or unexpected behaviors during certain learning tasks or activities?
What is the students favored mode of expressing him/herself? Does the student prefer oral versus written responses?
What learning/academic incongruities are present (e.g. advanced comprehension of material presented visually and/or
aurally, but low comprehension if read)?
To what degree does the challenge/disability impact the ability of the student to pursue strengths and interests?

Figure 3. Questions to Help Determine the Need in the Area of Social-Emotional Concerns

What triggers, if any, set the student off?

What behaviors does the student exhibit that interfere with learning?
To what degree does the student exhibit heightened empathy and sensitivity?
Does the student make derogatory comments such as Im dumb about him/herself?
What, if any, uneven development exists physically, emotionally and/or socially?
What evidence exists that would indicate extreme perfectionistic tendencies that would prevent the student from taking
risks?
How does the student hide their strengths and/or their disabilities to fit in with peers?
Does the student avoid peers or do they avoid the student?
t
%FTDSJCF
UIF
DJSDVNTUBODFT
PG
XIFO
UIF
TUVEFOU
BQQFBST
BOYJPVT
PS
BHJUBUFE
t
%FTDSJCF
XIFO
UIF
TUVEFOU
CFDPNFT
BOHSZ
BOEPS
SFGVTFT
UP
QBSUJDJQBUF
PS
GPMMPX
DMBTT
SVMFT

acceleration; content extension to

include greater depth, complexity, and
novelty; and higher-level thinking
activities, such as analysis, evaluation,
and synthesis (Baum et al., 2001; Baum
& Owens, 2004; Bianco, Carothers, &
Smiley, 2009; Coleman, 2005;
McEachern & Bornot, 2001). Examples
for addressing strengths and interests
are given in the section TwiceExceptional Student Plans.
Learning Needs

The second critical consideration

involves the students learning needs.
Like the strengths-and-interests area,
there are questions for the problemsolving team to ask to help them
determine a plan. In Figure 2,
questions that can inform the process
of developing plans to address the
particular learning needs of a twiceexceptional student are presented.
222

COUNCIL FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN

Some of the same information from

the strengths-and-interests area will be
useful here as well. It is beneficial to
review the students cumulative
records to determine if changes in
student performance or observations
from teachers has recently occurred
(Assouline, Nicpon, & Huber, 2006). As
noted earlier, a perceptive teacher may
notice that a students scores on the
universal screener are discrepant. If a
students score is very high on a math
assessment, for example, but in the
low-average range in reading, that can
be a trigger for further investigation.
The teacher could review classwide
reading assessments, writing samples,
and reports from the students previous
teacher. Informal observations of the
ways the student approaches or
struggles during specific academic
tasks can also be very helpful. If the
data support the teachers initial
impressions that the student needs

academic or behavioral help, then a

plan for classroom intervention should
be implemented. If progress monitoring
indicates that the student is not making
adequate progress, a problem-solving
team meeting should be convened. The
problem-solving team might
recommend that the support be
increased in duration or intensity. In
some cases, the problem-solving team
may request a further assessment
because of the severity of the students
needs.
Pedro, for example, might require
further evaluation. His overall average
grades and test scores may not raise
any red flags about his potential
ADHD. However, signs, such as his
extreme disorganization and
inattention, as well as the need for the
teacher to redirect his off-task behavior,
indicate that there might be a disability.
The problem-solving team could make
the recommendation for a more

thorough assessment and evaluation.

The section Twice-Exceptional Student
Plans provides examples of how a
problem-solving team might address
students specific needs due to
disability.
Social and Emotional Needs

The third area concerns the socialemotional dimension. In the effort to

address the needs of the whole child,
the students social and emotional
needs must be addressed. It is common
for the academic self-concept of twiceexceptional students to be very low as
they often see themselves as imposters
or as inadequate. Researchers have
noted that twice-exceptional students
experience high levels of anxiety, poor
self-concept, and anger because of the
discrepancies between what they can
and cannot do (Baldwin, 1995; Baum &
Owen, 2004; Reis et al., 2014; Schiff,
Kaufman, & Kaufman, 1981). Because
these students often experience feelings
more intensely, it is crucial that they
feel supported. Figure 3 provides
questions members of the problemsolving team might ask in regard to the
social and emotional needs of twiceexceptional students.
As the questions indicate, the
social-emotional dimension related to
students with twice-exceptionality is
varied and complex. Students may be
confused because of high abilities in
some academic subjects and the
dichotomy of learning difficulties in
other subjects or within the same
subject. Teachers and other school
personnel can help these students by
ensuring that the school environment
is designed to be accepting and safe. A
variety of people can support twiceexceptional students social and
emotional needs. Teachers,
psychologists, family members,
administrators, coaches, mentors,
community members, and peers who
share the same strengths, talents, or
passions can be called upon for
support. In addition, Neumeister, Yssel,
and Burney (2013) stressed that family
members are instrumental in nurturing
and supporting their childs social and

emotional needs. Because the concept

of twice exceptionality is still new for
many educators, acceptance,
willingness, and an interest in meeting
the needs of twice-exceptional students
needs to be present and part of the
culture of the school. A nurturing, safe
environment is crucial for a twiceexceptional student to be willing to
take risks necessary to address the
challenges.
Twice-Exceptional Student
Plans
The three critical considerations
discussedstrengths, academic needs,
and social and emotional needs
demonstrate how each can be
addressed to support the success of
twice-exceptional students. Lances,
Hadleys, and Pedros plans show how
their schools problem-solving teams
developed integrated plans. The plans
address the students strengths and
interests as well as learning needs with
research-based strategies and
accommodations in both areas
(National Association for Gifted
Children, n.d.). In addition, the plans
describe the social-emotional
dimension and how that area will be
addressed. The intent is that the
progress of the students will be
monitored and plans will be reviewed
regularly in a flexible, continuous
improvement cycle. In school systems
where the environment and culture are
conducive for recognizing and meeting
the varied and individual needs of
twice-exceptional learners, educators
and families can develop integrated
individualized plans that address the
needs of the whole child.
Lance

Strengths and Interests,

Accommodations
Gifted education teacher will work
with the classroom teacher to
facilitate curriculum compacting for
possible subject acceleration or
enrichment.
The classroom teacher had pretested
Lance to determine which content
standards were met and which he

still needed to learn. He tested out

of four of the nine science units for
the year. It was determined that it
would be more appropriate to
develop enrichment activities for
him during weeks when the teacher
is teaching those four science units.
Gifted education teacher will
facilitate the development of an
independent investigation based on
a specific science topic of his choice
and create a contract that breaks
down tasks that includes the
following: (a) problem finding, (b)
research tools, (c) a rubric, (d)
specific time lines for completion,
(e) key concepts to be addressed, (f)
check-in dates, and (g) method of
presentation.
Learning Needs, Accommodations and
Modifications
Teachers will collaborate to locate
video and audio resources and teach
him how to acquire information
from these resources. The special
education teacher will teach him
how to use data charts and graphic
organizers to record and summarize
his information. She will also assist
him with the writing associated
with the final product. His other
teachers will reinforce the strategies.
The family will read and discuss
some of the more difficult resource
reference books with him.
The gifted teacher will help Lance
determine the type of product (e.g.,
PowerPoint, oral presentation,
cartoon strip, and different types of
charts) that will best represent and
communicate his knowledge.
Social-Emotional Needs, Support
The school psychologist will meet
with Lance once a week as part of a
social group of second-grade peers
during lunch.
The family will take him to the
Nature Center after school once a
week to be part of their organized
plant and animal classes with the
hope of finding other children who
share the same intense interests.
The science coordinator will invite
Lance to join the Junior Scientist
Club.

TEACHING EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN | MARCH/APRIL 2015

223

Hadley

Strengths and Interests,

Accommodations
Hadley will continue in the gifted
program. The gifted education
teacher will integrate learning
accommodations into her activities
to make them accessible to Hadley,
such as audio books, videos, and
graphic organizers.
The gifted education teacher will
meet with Hadley to determine an
independent project based on her
social justice interests, such as
poverty or Afghanistan.
Learning Needs, Accommodations and
Modifications
As per the problem-solving team,
the reading teacher gave Hadley
reading and writing assessments
and determined that she was a
candidate for more intense reading
support from a reading specialist.
Hadley will receive a specific and
systematic reading and writing
approach three times a week for 30
minutes plus specific, coordinated
instruction in the general education
class during reading instruction.
The teachers, including the new
reading interventionist, will
collaborate to create a reading plan
that can be applied across all of her
educational settings. She will have
access to the highest-level reading
and discussion groups.
The family will have her practice
keyboarding 20 minutes a day
using any of the high-interest
keyboarding programs available for
home use.
The gifted teacher will teach her to
utilize voice-activated recognition
software to capture her creative
ideas and advanced thinking.
Social-Emotional Needs, Support
The gifted teacher will recommend
audio books, articles, and videos to
Hadley on the lives of adults (e.g.,
Henry Winkler, Whoopi Goldberg,
and Jewel, the singer) who have
had similar learning issues but who
learned how to compensate for
them.

224

COUNCIL FOR EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN

The principal will invite Hadley to

join the School Superintendents
Youth Task Force on Mediation and
Bullying Prevention.
Pedro

Strengths and Interests,

Accommodations and Modifications
The pre-engineering CAD teacher
knows that Pedro demonstrates
more skill and knowledge than
other students in his classes. He will
provide Pedro subject acceleration
or a supervised project of his choice.
The pre-engineering CAD teacher
will add Pedro to the high school
Engineering Olympiad Team. The
team is building a robot for sorting
recycled materials.
Learning Needs, Accommodations and
Modifications
The English teacher volunteered to
teach Pedro how to color-code his
notebooks and to access his
homework online.
Pedro will check in with the English
teacher once a week after school to
organize his materials and review
homework and project timelines.
The family agreed to provide a
dedicated study space for him and
an area in the basement where he
can organize his supplies for his
academics and his projects.
Social-Emotional Needs, Support
Pedros participation on the high
school Engineering Olympiad Team
will provide him with the
opportunity to positively interact
with other students who have a
shared interest and skill level.
The pre-engineering CAD teacher
also teaches at the nearby middle
school. The teacher has several
students whom he asked Pedro to
tutor in 3-D printing application.
As demonstrated in the case examples
of Lance, Hadley, and Pedro,
comprehensive, individualized, flexible
plans that address the whole child work
best for twice-exceptional students. The
composite profiles of these three
twice-exceptional students provide

insight into the multidimensional nature

of this phenomenon, including
characteristics and challenges associated
with recognition of either gifts and
talents or disability in order to facilitate
the delivery of appropriate services, and
specific strategies to support students
needs across the spectrum. For the
twice-exceptional student to be
successful, educators need to set aside
preconceived notions of disability and
giftedness. The focus should be on the
unique needs of twice-exceptional
students to create an integrated,
individualized approach rather than
trying to fit them into an existing system.
References
Assouline, S. G., Nicpon, M. F., &
Huber, D. H. (2006). The impact
of vulnerabilities and strengths on
the academic experiences of twiceexceptional students: A message to
school counselors. Professional School
Counseling, 10, 1424.
Assouline, S. G., & Whiteman, C. S. (2011).
Twice-exceptionality: Implications for
school psychologists in the postIDEA
2004 era. Journal of Applied School
Psychology, 27, 380402.
Baldwin, L. (1995). Portraits of gifted
learning disabled students: A
longitudinal study (Unpublished
doctoral dissertation). Teachers College,
Columbia University, New York, NY.
Baum, S., Cooper, C., & Neu, T. (2001).
Dual differentiation: An approach for
meeting the curricular needs of gifted
students with learning disabilities.
Psychology in the Schools, 38, 477490.
Baum, S., & Owen, S. (2004). To be gifted
and learning disabled: Strategies for
helping bright students with LD, ADHD,
and more. Mansfield, CT: Creative
Learning Press.
Berninger, V. W., & Abbott, R. D. (2013).
Differences between children with
dyslexia who are and are not gifted in
verbal reasoning. Gifted Child Quarterly,
57, 223233.
Bianco, M., Carothers, D. E., & Smiley, L.
R. (2009). Gifted students with Asperger
syndrome: Strategies for strength-based
programming. Intervention in School and
Clinic, 44, 206215.
Coleman, M. R. (2005). Academic
strategies that work for gifted students
with learning disabilities. TEACHING
Exceptional Children, 38(1), 2832.

King, E. W. (2005). Addressing the

social and emotional needs of twiceexceptional students. TEACHING
Exceptional Children, 38(1), 1620.
McCoach, D. B., Kehle, T. J., Bray, M. A.,
& Siegle, D. (2001). Best practices in
the identification of gifted students with
learning disabilities. Psychology in the
Schools, 38, 403411.
McEachern, A. G., & Bornot, J. (2001).
Gifted students with learning disabilities:
Implications and strategies for school
counselors. Professional School
Counseling, 5, 3441.
National Association for Gifted Children.
(n.d.). Research support for the 2013
Teacher Preparation Standards in Gifted
Education. Retrieved from http://ektron.
nagc.org/uploadedFiles/Information_
and_Resources/NCATE_standards/
research%20support%20for%20
2013%20stands.pdf
Neumeister, K. S., Yssel, N., & Burney, V.
H. (2013). The influence of primary
caregivers in fostering success in
twice-exceptional children. Gifted Child
Quarterly, 57, 263274.
Nicpon, M. F., Allmon, A., Sieck, B.,
& Stinson, R. D. (2011). Empirical
investigation of twice-exceptionality:
Where have we been and where are we
going? Gifted Child Quarterly, 55, 317.

Nielsen, M. E., Higgins, D., Baldwin, L.,

& Pereles, D. (2000). Comparisons of
characteristics of gifted students with
or without disabilities. Unpublished
manuscript.
Olenchak, F. R. (2009). Effects of talents
unlimited counseling on gifted/learning
disabled students. Gifted Education
International, 25, 144164.
Pereles, D. A., Omdal, S. N., & Baldwin,
L. (2009). Response to intervention
and twice-exceptional learners: A
promising fit. Gifted Child Today,
32(3), 4051.
Reis, S. M., Baum, S., M., & Burke, E.
(2014). An operational definition of
twice-exceptional learners: Implications
and applications. Gifted Child Quarterly,
58, 217230.
Renzulli, J. S. (1997). Interest-A-Lyzer
Family of Instruments: A manual for
teachers. Waco, TX: Prufrock Press.
Renzulli, J. S., Smith, L. H., White, A.
J., Callahan, C. M., Hartman, R. K.,
Westberg, K. L., ... Sytsma, R. E.
(2010). Scales for rating the behavioral
characteristics of superior students:
Technical and administration manual
(3rd ed.). Waco, TX: Prufrock Press.
Schiff, M. M., Kaufman, A. S., & Kaufman,
N. L. (1981). Scatter analysis of WISC-R
profiles for learning disabled children

creates materials based

on common core
standards
in math,
reading,
writing and
science for
grades 3-12.

with superior intelligence. Journal of

Learning Disabilities, 14, 400404.
Willard-Holt, C., & Morrison, K. (2013,
Fall). Uncovering buried treasure:
Effective learning strategies for
twice-exceptional students. Teaching for
High Potential, pp. 1416.
Yssel, N., Adams, C., Clarke, L., & Jones,
R. (2014). Applying an RTI model
for students with learning disabilities
who are gifted. TEACHING Exceptional
Children, 46(3), 4252.
Lois Baldwin, Consultant, Tarrytown, New
York. Stuart N. Omdal, Professor of Gifted
and Talented Education, School of Special
Education, University of Northern Colorado,
Greeley, Colorado. Daphne Pereles,
Consultant, Mountain BOCES, Leadville,
Colorado.
Address correspondence concerning this
article to Lois Baldwin, EdD, Consultant,
532 High Cliff Lane, Tarrytown, NY 10591
(e-mail: [email protected]).
TEACHING Exceptional Children,
Vol. 47, No. 4, pp. 216225.
Copyright 2015 The Author(s).

www.specialedsimplified.com
Scaffolding and differentiated instructions
are used throughout all units to help students
to develop autonomous learning strategies.
All units are designed in a similar manner to
provide the teacher with a simple, transparent outline to cover any standard.

Curriculum designed for students with moderate to severe disabilities

TEACHING EXCEPTIONAL CHILDREN | MARCH/APRIL 2015

225

Copyright of Teaching Exceptional Children is the property of Sage Publications Inc. and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.