The recent U.S. election results, with Donald Trump's "America First" approach, and the new U.S. Commerce Secretary singling Ireland out as part of the problem, have intensified conversations about Ireland's economic strategy and heightened the urgency to build a strong indigenous economy that matches the strength of our foreign direct investment (FDI) sector. The closure of NDRC has been deeply disheartening to many in the entrepreneurial community. It is significant not just because of the loss of our flagship startup programmes but because it raises a larger set of questions - Do we have the correct strategy for our innovation economy? Why are we making decisions that appear misaligned with international expert advice and, more importantly, the voices of our own entrepreneurs? If nothing else, I hope this is a catalyst for a wider discussion amongst all stakeholders about the future of our innovation economy. Accelerators alone are not the solution, just part of one. I delve deeper into this issue in my commentary for the Business Post today https://bit.ly/3V76qzX
I think you should deal with the NDRC (Dogpatch) specific issues. It makes perfect sense to align funding to the appropriate Govenment Department. More funding yes, an organisation that undermines the work of other supports and founders, no thanks. Your only focus now should be the founders who are in the pipeline and ensuring continuity for them. This was not your priority when you took over NDRC.
Well said Patrick. Such a disappointing decision even more so considering the absence of any clear replacement strategy and fluffy reasoning. The Dogpatch team led by Patrick are a phenomenal support to the start-up scene in Ireland due to their vision from Day 1 to make Dogpatch way more than just a shared startup space, their sheer hard work and ambition especially incorporating NDRC, but most of all their understanding of what it takes for start up entrepreneurs to be successful with all the ups and downs. The environment and networking group they created has no doubt added value to the strong performance of NDRC . The tech startup/incubator/VC scene in Ireland or elsewhere is not without its flaws and there are many failures but it’s still an essential ingredient to inspire entrepreneurs and drive future job creation so to remove investment in that space seems very short sighted.
We need a lot more VC eyes on the Irish ecosystem. The talent is there but the dollars are not. We’ve met some amazing Irish founders who never looked beyond Enterprise Ireland, despite the huge number of pre-seed funds a stone’s throw across the Irish Sea. Let’s fix this!
Money can and should be raised without government help.
Dogpatch Labs is a critical engine of Ireland's innovation ecosystem. They have had the vision to connect our innovation assets together on the island, to partner with corporates and engage them in strengthening our indigenous innovation capability, in running innovative venture creation programmes like Founders and Patch and driving angel investment syndication. NDRC has gone from strength to strength in Dogpatch and it is a shocking decision not to renew this programme.
Patrick Walsh spot on. Closure itself a big mistake. Assume/hope it’s reversed- but wider rethink also needed. Starting with bottom up data gathering informing relevant solutions across company life stages. With willingness to pilot and then abandon things that don’t work and double down on those that do - quickly.
This move seems completely counter-intuitive and against all common sense. I'm struggling to understand the rationale behind this decision?
I’ve tweeted about the fall in our innovation rankings and mentioned it in the context of climate a few times, echoing what Patrick says. My one suspicion is that someone in the political echelons doesn’t like the lack of control they have over Dogpatch and the NDRC.
I totally agree with this. Well said.
EVP Strategy & Finance @ Rakuten France | CIMA CGMA AICPA CPA
1wThis decision has to be reversed or replaced with something even more impactful. Have a support structure for wannabe entrepreneurs is essential - Ireland has been severely lacking in this regard. I've often heard "there are not enough Irish venture funds".... Its clear our innovation eco-system is lagging behind other European capitals.