Goren and Eames work a case where organ donation has a price for the recipients beyond their medical bills.Goren and Eames work a case where organ donation has a price for the recipients beyond their medical bills.Goren and Eames work a case where organ donation has a price for the recipients beyond their medical bills.
Featured review
The concept sounded very intriguing, will agree that it is very "off the wall" but it sounded creepy too. Was very interested in how the concept would be executed, as 'Law and Order: Criminal Intent' was no stranger to off the wall type episodes but the execution varied. Really didn't want "Ex Stasis" to be a waste of potential or be too bizarre, and wanted it to be fascinating and suitably unnerving. Would have appreciated the effort though regardless of execution as this does not sound like an easy subject to pull off.
"Ex Stasis" on the most part fits in the latter category and does very well with a subject that could easily have gone so wrong in execution. It's not perfect or one of my favourites of Season 4, which had a lot of fine episodes but was not as consistent overall as the previous three seasons, but it is a fascinating and creepy episode that on the most part doesn't come over as too strange. It is thankfully not one of the season's worst episodes either and with a lot to admire about it.
It does start off a bit on the routine and standard side with not much new or unique happening.
When things become a lot less obvious and more alarming, there was a spell where the episode did get somewhat bizarre and some of the information was not easy to get the head round.
Luckily, things do get clearer and when it begins to fall into place the truth is just about buyable and is interesting. As said the execution is as off the wall as the synopsis sounds, but on the most part "Ex Stasis" doesn't go overboard on the weirdness or become vague, issues found with other "strange" 'Criminal Intent' episodes such as "In the Dark" and "Collective". When more is revealed, there are enough twists in the plotting to avoid over-simplicity without trying to include too many. One does not expect the motive or what the perpetrator was up to, which were unique for the show at this point of its run.
Furthermore, the writing is thought-provoking and not too talky and the direction has control without being over-deliberate. The production values are stylish and slick with a brighter and more refined look, while maintaining the show's grit. The music doesn't overbear and is not overused. The characters are written well, with Goren still fascinating without being too dominant and his rapport with Eames is so entertaining and intriguing. The acting is on point, especially Vincent D'Onofrio.
Overall, had an interesting if "it could go either way" subject and executed it mostly very well. Starts off conventional, but as it progresses it becomes one of Season 4's, and one of the early seasons', most unconventional episodes. 8/10
"Ex Stasis" on the most part fits in the latter category and does very well with a subject that could easily have gone so wrong in execution. It's not perfect or one of my favourites of Season 4, which had a lot of fine episodes but was not as consistent overall as the previous three seasons, but it is a fascinating and creepy episode that on the most part doesn't come over as too strange. It is thankfully not one of the season's worst episodes either and with a lot to admire about it.
It does start off a bit on the routine and standard side with not much new or unique happening.
When things become a lot less obvious and more alarming, there was a spell where the episode did get somewhat bizarre and some of the information was not easy to get the head round.
Luckily, things do get clearer and when it begins to fall into place the truth is just about buyable and is interesting. As said the execution is as off the wall as the synopsis sounds, but on the most part "Ex Stasis" doesn't go overboard on the weirdness or become vague, issues found with other "strange" 'Criminal Intent' episodes such as "In the Dark" and "Collective". When more is revealed, there are enough twists in the plotting to avoid over-simplicity without trying to include too many. One does not expect the motive or what the perpetrator was up to, which were unique for the show at this point of its run.
Furthermore, the writing is thought-provoking and not too talky and the direction has control without being over-deliberate. The production values are stylish and slick with a brighter and more refined look, while maintaining the show's grit. The music doesn't overbear and is not overused. The characters are written well, with Goren still fascinating without being too dominant and his rapport with Eames is so entertaining and intriguing. The acting is on point, especially Vincent D'Onofrio.
Overall, had an interesting if "it could go either way" subject and executed it mostly very well. Starts off conventional, but as it progresses it becomes one of Season 4's, and one of the early seasons', most unconventional episodes. 8/10
- TheLittleSongbird
- Oct 13, 2020
- Permalink
Storyline
Did you know
- TriviaThe underlying story of this episode alludes to a popular parable, "The Man Who Gave Away Everything". It is described in detail in an an episode of Fargo, Season 1 (2014), as told by Colin Hanks' character: "A rich man opens the paper one day, he sees the world is full of misery. He says, "I have money, I can help." So he gives away all of his money. But it's not enough. The people are still suffering. One day the man sees another article, he decides he was foolish to think just giving money was enough. So he goes to the doctor and says, "Doctor, i want to donate a kidney." The doctors do the surgery, it's a complete success. After, he knows he should feel good, but he doesn't, for people are still suffering. So he goes back to the doctor. He says, "Doctor, this time I want to give it all." The doctor says, "What does that mean, give it all?" He says, "This time I want to donate my liver, but not just my liver. I want to donate my heart, but not just my heart. I want to donate my corneas, but not just my corneas. I want to give it all away. Everything I am, all that I have." The doctor says, "A kidney is one thing but you can't give away your whole body piece by piece, that's suicide." And he sends the man home. But the man cannot live knowing that people are suffering and he could help. So he gives the one thing he has left, his life."
- GoofsIndividuals with Cystic Fibrosis do not benefit from the transplantation of a single lobe of a lung. The right lung has three large lobes. And the left lobe has two. So donating a single lobe of a lung would do very little good for these kinds of patients. They wouldn't even benefit from a single lung transplant. Cystic Fibrosis that is treated with a lung transplantation involves resecting both affected lungs, and transplanting in a right and a left lung. It is imperative that these patients receive two lungs.
- Quotes
Detective Robert Goren: [appealing to criminal suspect] I mean, what's more selfish than the desire for personal freedom?
Details
Contribute to this page
Suggest an edit or add missing content