La nuit de Varennes

Besides boasting wonderful performances by two of my favourite actors (Marcello Mastroianni and Harvey Keitel), Il Mondo Nuovo (as it's known in Italy) by acclaimed Italian director Ettore Scola is to me as satisfying as a good classic novel, one of those 800-page tomes you approach with a little trepidation and then remember for years to come, wishing other novels you read would compare.

It's the year 1791 and on board a stagecoach, an assortment of characters from different parts of the world are traveling from Paris to Verdun. Along the way the coach picks up the aging (his character is 67 years old in the film), legendary Venetian seducer Giacomo Casanova, as well as the controversial, fawn-like but ahead-of-his-time chronicler and novelist, Restif de la Bretonne. The stagecoach's original travelers include the American Revolution survivor Thomas Paine (Keitel), as well as a melancholic and reserved widow aching to fall in love again, a beautiful and intelligent yet devoutly Monarchist Austrian Countess, a sharp and cheeky Italian opera singer eternally clutching a pet poodle and poking fun at her dim and bigoted husband, as well as a cocky young Jacobean. The coach also includes their servants, among whom the young Countess's devoted butler and her pretty African maid, who soon hooks up with the young Jacobean. Not far ahead of them, another stagecoach carrying the fleeing French royal family - Louis XVI, Marie Antoinette and their children is also traveling along the same road, unaware this will be the route to their irrevocable death sentence.

The story is told through the dialogues and anecdotes of a group unaware of their status as main witnesses to what will turn out to be one of history's most pivotal moments. Besides the breathtakingly authentic feel of the time - you really feel like you've stepped into a Hogarth painting - what's most remarkable is how you also get the sense such historic events are happening in real time, so convincing are the reactions of bewilderment and astonishment on the character's part. A series of vignettes, made delicious by the top-class characterisation and dialogue, contribute to moving the plot along as well as giving the viewer some light relief which however never loses sight of the breathless atmosphere of those revolutionary times.

Mastroianni as the self-deprecating, tired, aging Casanova is a treat from the very first frame he graces to the last. This legendary actor has always brought a unique depth of humanity to his roles, but despite all the other fine actors and characters in this film I just couldn't have imagined it without him. I adored the moment, after having charmed all the ladies and even some of the men on the stagecoach, Casanova kisses the young Austrian Countess's besotted gay butler on the lips and as a parting shot says: "I don't exclude anything on principle."

Especially memorable are the final frames of the film, in which the young Austrian Countess and her butler, after having dressed a wooden dummy in a spartan inn room with the doomed king's ceremonial costume, bow down to it with devotion, symbolising the ephemeral and temporal nature of an earthly kingdom. Some will consider this Italo-French production overlong, others won't be fond of its un-Hollywoodlike approach to the historic genre, others will even consider some of its characters unappealing. On my part I consider these the film's strengths and cannot help but warmly recommending it. My only real complaint is: why hasn't it yet been released on DVD?

A fantastic film with magnificent cerebral talks and actors, costumes, and backgrounds that allow you to journey across time. It's like seeing through a window into the madness of the French Revolution, when people pondered the past, present, and future. If you're seeking for a historically accurate film, this is a must-see.

French novelist Catherine Rihoit is also an accomplished biographer and there are certainly biographical elements here. It approaches the realms of fantasy however to imagine that notorious adventurer and chronicler Giacomo Casanova, lecher/pornographer Restif le Bretonne and American revolutionary Thomas Paine would all be passengers on the same 'diligence' that is just a few hours behind the one which is carrying the French Royal Family in its desperate flight to Varennes.

This film of Ettore Scola is so splendidly realised and acted that the anomaly doesn't seem to matter and comes under the heading of 'artistic license'.

It is certainly nothing less than 'artistic' with sumptious cinematography by Armando Nannuzzi, superlative production design by Dante Ferretti and understated score by Armando Trivaioli, all of whom are masters of their craft and who have worked with some of best directors in the business.

The legendary Sergio Amidei who died before the film was released, has contributed to the screenplay and among those privileged to speak his dialogue are Marcello Mastroianni as Casanova, Jean-Louis Barrault as Restif and Hanna Schygulla as a Countess who is also a lady in waiting to Marie Antoinette. Her presence on the the same coach is therefore more plausible.

This talented trio are absolutely mesmerising. Barrault's film appearances are rare as he was primarily a stage actor and director who ran his own theatre company with his wife Madeleine Renaud. The fascinating Miss Schygulla has the distinction of having survived the making of numerous films with Fassbinder. It is the performance of Mastroianni as raddled, dissipated Casanova that lingers longest. He has reached that sublime state when he has ceased to act at all and simply 'is'. Harvey Keitel as Paine has been cast for the benefit of the North American market and is 'dubbed' as one would expect. He is a wee bit young for the role as Paine would have been in his late fifties at this time.

The post-synchronisation, always a hit-and-miss affair in Italian cinema, is generally very good.

There is a delightful scene where Casanova sings a few bars of Leporello's 'catalogue' aria from Mozart's 'Don Giovanni'. Legend has it that Casanova helped da Ponte with the libretto. Perhaps he was also 'technical advisor'!

A beautifully made film that just sustains its running time and typifies both the traditional excellence of European costume drama and its preference for character over plot. Not to mention its appeal to a more literate audience.

Although politically Ettore Scola does not appear to take sides, all that we see of Louis XV1 and Marie Antoinette are their lower legs and feet whereas there are plentiful close-ups of the downtrodden peasantry.

This director has always been fascinated by history and the part played by 'ordinary' citizens. "The flow of history lies with us" he once said.

One of the most notable reviewers on this site condemned "La nuit de Varennes" to 2,5 stars (out of 4), but I am of the opinion that this movie should be appreciated better : there are not so many cinematic works in our times that are carried by such valuable concept,i.e. that preach and teach dignity and tolerance opposed to a laudable but often misguiding need to serve some higher principle. "Idiocy is the worst of treasons. - And no revolution will ever stop it." In Scola's historical comedy of manners, thoughts and emotions, Barrault's Restif is the key figure which spans a bridge between humble vox populi of Thomas Paine and aristocratic grandeur of Casanova. Watching this movie I felt like the spirit of wiser old Europe (which is still there, thanks to Scola a.o.) entered the body of Robert Altman's shape. French blu-ray with English subtitles is to be treasured.

One of the most satisfying films I've seen. A bit obtuse but very well done if you are fond of tongue in cheek humor, outstanding portrayals, great direction and cinematography.

The short version: This a whimsy that follows an aging Casanova and an eclectic group of Frenchmen as they travel through the French countryside in a coach during the time of the French Revolution. It's a comedy presented with delicacy and intellect and the cinematography is outstanding. It may or may not strike you as outstanding, as it did me, but it is so worth the time it will take to find it and see it two or three times.

I just read the first posted review and had to laugh out loud. Aw shucks yawl, if it's so bad, why are copies on VHS selling for $300 to $400? I lost my copy to a friend who borrowed many times and never returned anything. Shame on her.

If anyone knows where I can find a copy on VHS to dub, I'd be so appreciative. Thanks and do take a peek. "[email protected]".