Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Native Speakerism

description101 papers
group31 followers
lightbulbAbout this topic
Native speakerism is the belief that native speakers of a language possess inherent superiority in language proficiency and teaching ability. This ideology often influences language education, hiring practices, and perceptions of linguistic competence, leading to biases against non-native speakers and impacting the dynamics of language learning and teaching.
lightbulbAbout this topic
Native speakerism is the belief that native speakers of a language possess inherent superiority in language proficiency and teaching ability. This ideology often influences language education, hiring practices, and perceptions of linguistic competence, leading to biases against non-native speakers and impacting the dynamics of language learning and teaching.

Key research themes

1. How do socio-political constructs and historical trajectories shape the legitimacy of 'native speaker' status and its implications for English language teaching?

This research theme focuses on critically analyzing the historical, colonial, and ideological roots of the 'native speaker' construct, exploring how it has been socially and politically constructed to privilege certain groups in language teaching and learning contexts. It foregrounds native-speakerism as an ideology underpinned by nationalist and colonialist discourses that naturalize inequities among teachers and learners by privileging 'native' norms and marginalizing 'non-native' speakers and teachers. The theme is important because it reveals how entrenched discourses affect hiring practices, teacher identity, and language pedagogy, perpetuating neocolonial and discriminatory dynamics worldwide.

Key finding: The paper introduces 'speakerness' to conceptualize how social actors are defined through language practices, arguing that debates around 'non-native' English speakers and 'new speakers' of European minority languages are... Read more
Key finding: Using duoethnography, the study reveals how native-speakerism constitutes a 'hidden curriculum' within ELT teacher training that perpetuates Western 'native speaker' norms and values uncritically. Authors found that despite... Read more
Key finding: Through a critical literature review, this work identifies the (non)native speaker/teacherhood construct as an epistemologically hegemonic, historically colonial, and contextually enacted phenomenon intersecting with... Read more
Key finding: This paper critically interrogates the native speaker concept within foreign language teaching, framing it as a politically and ideologically loaded category that often manifests as native-speakerism — privileging native... Read more

2. What evidence challenges the dichotomy of 'native' versus 'non-native' speaker in language competence and teaching efficacy?

This theme investigates empirical and theoretical challenges to the traditional binary division between native and non-native speakers, highlighting the linguistic diversity within these categories and their inadequacy in capturing variation, such as that exhibited by heritage speakers and bilinguals. It explores alternative conceptualizations like L1 versus LX users and reveals how simplistic categorization can misrepresent linguistic competence and effectiveness in teaching. The theme exposes the limitations of native-speakerism by showing variation in language use and acquisition that transcends the binary, with implications for fair treatment and evaluation of language professionals and learners.

Key finding: Focusing on heritage speakers (HSs) of German in the USA, the study provides empirical evidence demonstrating that the native speaker category fails to capture the gradient linguistic variation between HSs and... Read more
Key finding: This paper critiques the native/non-native binary as ideologically biased and proposes replacing it with a more neutral dichotomy of L1 user versus LX user ('any language acquired after age 3'). The author argues that LX... Read more
Key finding: The paper critiques the non-native/native speaker dichotomy in psycholinguistic research, showing that this binary oversimplifies diverse speaker populations and often introduces researcher bias favoring native speakers. It... Read more

3. How do perceptions of nativeness influence listener bias, discrimination, and identity construction in language use and teaching contexts?

This area examines the social perception of nativeness and its consequences for linguistic credibility, discrimination in professional and social settings, and identity formation. It explores how listener biases toward perceived native or non-native accents can affect judgments of trustworthiness, competence, and teaching effectiveness among both native and non-native listeners. The research highlights that these perceptions are socially constructed, often linked to accent, pronunciation, and stereotype, and they can override objective linguistic ability or appearance, influencing employment and social status. Understanding these dynamics is critical for addressing inequities and fostering more equitable language education and communication.

Key finding: This cross-country study found that listeners predominantly base judgments of native-speaker status on pronunciation rather than physical appearance or geographical origin. While some listeners changed judgments when exposed... Read more
Key finding: This empirical study replicated Lev-Ari and Keysar’s (2010) findings by demonstrating that non-native English listeners also display subconscious negative bias against foreign-accented speech in judging truthfulness of... Read more
Key finding: This preregistered study failed to replicate earlier findings that native speakers could be experimentally biased positively or negatively toward non-native speech, suggesting that factors like diverse participants’... Read more
Key finding: Through a critical review of Davies’ work, this paper conceptualizes 'native speaker' as a socially constructed identity grounded in a dichotomous definition that privileges native speakers by negating others as non-native,... Read more

All papers in Native Speakerism

Language ideologies are omnipresent in English language teaching and English teacher education. They reflect societal beliefs and practices about language use, learning, and teaching, often reflecting the power of Inner Circle English... more
Studies on nativeness affirm that being judged/perceived as a native/non-native English speaker is determined by social factors such as nationality, variety spoken and ethnicity. This study investigated how listeners from seven different... more
This study compares the self-reported attitudes and beliefs of materials designers at a private English language school in Thailand regarding Global Englishes Language Teaching (GELT) with their practice of materials design for speaking... more
El proceso de aprendizaje de una segunda lengua se presenta, cambia y trasciende de distintas maneras según cada individuo. Factores internos y externos se hacen partícipes durante este tránsito. El lugar de crianza, el entorno académico,... more
The professional development of English teachers is a significant area in language teaching and learning, as well as in teacher education. On the one hand, at least in theory, professional development initiatives respond to the teachers’... more
Even with their qualifications, Filipino ALTs (Assistant Language Teachers) face some unique and intense challenges tied to race, linguistic legitimacy, and social acceptance within Japanese schools and society at large. To substantiate... more
This paper explored teachers’ attitudes towards non-native teachers of Serbian and the teaching situations they find themselves in. Native speakerism was first defined in English Language Teaching, and it assumes that the best teacher of... more
The professional development of English teachers is a significant area in language teaching and learning, as well as in teacher education. On the one hand, at least in theory, professional development initiatives respond to the teachers’... more
Racial inequalities persist in education, impacting various aspects, including language teaching. Traditional English language education has often favored standard English, inadvertently marginalizing non-native English speakers and users... more
Soros, Zaleski-Zamenhof, Kosinski kaj la kruciĝo de lingvoj Tivadar Soros, Louis Christophe Zaleski-Zamenhof, kaj Jerzy Kosinski estis ĉiuj multlingvaj, scipovis Esperanton kaj havis aktivan kontakton kun la Esperanto-movado. Ĉiuj tri,... more
English has become the primary medium for global communication, with most users being non-native speakers. However, the English Language Teaching industry has been slow to adapt to English's changing role and global importance. The... more
This paper examines the relationship between shame, stigma and accent for non-native English speakers in Spain. The low English competence of the Spanish population frequently constitutes a source of individual and collective stigma-which... more
Job ads have long been of interest to researchers concerned with the issue of native speakerism as they may constitute the initial and often insurmountable barrier to career op- portunities for non-native teachers of English. This article... more
Dyskryminacja nierodzimych nauczycieli języka angielskiego nie przestaje być tematem badań i debat już od lat 90. ubiegłego stulecia. Niestety świadomość tej formy dyskryminacji wśród polskich nauczycieli języka angielskiego pozostaje... more
Despite the growing diversity and multicultural makeup of Australian society, certain social norms, practices, and teaching pedagogies are still heavily rooted in monolingual frameworks. This affects the complex processes and practices... more
This book contributes to the existing body of knowledge on English Medium Instruction's (EMI) role in equity and social justice and adds to the ongoing conversation by providing the Asian perspective to it. It showcases scholarly works by... more
With the rapid spread of English as a lingua franca, the number of non-native English teachers far exceeds that of native English-speaking teachers worldwide. In recent years, there has been considerable debate on what characteristics... more
With the rapid spread of English as a lingua franca, the number of non-native English teachers far exceeds that of native English-speaking teachers worldwide. In recent years, there has been considerable debate on what characteristics... more
Falling back on students’ L1—whether as the medium of communication, or for expository purposes—immediately summons the native/non-native speaker teacher debate. This is the theme of this chapter, which commences by interrogating the very... more
Continuation writing was recently introduced as a new element of China’s English as a Foreign Language (EFL) assessment. The assessment task requires students to complete the story within a set word limit. Preparing students for this task... more
The concept of a native speaker has become a topic of intense debate in language research, with scholars increasingly questioning its validity and its association with “native speakerism” within foreign language teaching—the belief that... more
This article argues for a rehabilitation of translation in the FL classroom. Recently, many researchers have questioned the monolingual principle and argued for a bilingual approach in the teaching of foreign languages. Questionnaires for... more
With the advent of the monolingual principle entrenched by the Reform Movement of the late nineteenth century and exponents of the Direct Method, translation has been treated, for a long time, as a skeleton in the closet. Recently,... more
The purpose of this study is threefold. First, it aims to discuss the concept of native-speakerism in English language teaching and how such an ideology is still manifested in the discriminatory practices between native English-speaking... more
This study investigates and reflects upon how over a decade of teaching English as a foreign language my attitude towards non-native English-speaking teachers (NNESTs) changed from a negative perception to one of admiration. Focusing on... more
The research identifies key themes, such as basic technological knowledge, ease of technology use, technological skills mastery, and the perceived importance of technology in teaching. The findings reveal that pre-service teachers find it... more
Abstract Achieving a model of bilingual education in Colombia has generated the need to explore different methodologies for teaching a foreign language in which not only communicative but also sociolinguistic skills are developed. This... more
This study investigates the perceptions of English as a Foreign Language (EFL) pre-service teachers regarding the development of their technological knowledge during field teaching practice. Utilizing a qualitative approach, data were... more
This paper presents an overview of terms and issues related to Standard Language Ideologies, World Englishes, and English Education. First, I present a discussion of the concept of language ideologies and their connection to constantly... more
This comprehensive review study explores the crucial role of digital literacy in English Language Teaching (ELT) and its transformative potential in promoting global understanding. Through a rigorous and systematic analysis of... more
The purpose of this study is threefold. First, it aims to discuss the concept of native-speakerism in English language teaching and how such an ideology is still manifested in the discriminatory practices between native English-speaking... more
The interconnected between communicative competence and Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) has been recognized as the most common approach to promoting communicative competence in language teaching. Moreover, it has been implemented by... more
The Second Language Acquisition (SLA) hypothesis has had profound implications for language education and language learners. A notable shift in language education has occurred, marked by a transition away from communicative pedagogical... more
This study critically interrogates dominant discourses and practices in school settings, which reveal the legitimisation and perpetuation of a monolingual mindset. Through the lens of ‘Critical Multilingual Language Awareness’ (CMLA),... more
Two major earthquakes, measuring 7.8 and 7.5 on the Richter scale, occurred within a ninehour period in Türkiye's southern region on February 6, 2023. These earthquakes affected 11 provinces, including various aspects of life such as... more
This study aims to reveal students' perceptions of Native English-Speaking Teachers (NEST) and Non-Native English-Speaking Teachers (NNEST). The study involved students from the Agriculture Faculty of the Riau State Islamic... more
Native speakerism is a language ideology that assumes that the ideals of the English language and English teaching methodology come from American and British cultures. Therefore, their best representatives are native speakers of English... more
This multimodal/multimedia discourse analysis explored institutional practices regarding native and non-native English speaker teachers in five language centers in Medellín, Colombia, as reflected in interviews with coordinators and... more
This multimodal/multimedia discourse analysis explored institutional practices regarding native and non-native English speaker teachers in five language centers in Medellín, Colombia, as reflected in interviews with coordinators and... more
The intercultural dimension of the language learning experience is one that has taken on increasing significance over the past decades. As Byram (2018) reminded us, "intercultural competence" (IC) as a term of relevance to language... more
Recent geopolitical events have led to a worldwide resurgence in nationalism which entails political togetherness and invokes the spirit of patriotism. In various contexts, language has been a central point of departure for many... more
This article reports on a narrative case study that showcases the local English teachers’ perceived inequality practices and identity construction in Indonesia’s micro-reality context of a private language school domain. Grounded in the... more
This article details how the embodied underpinnings of engaging in a duoethnographic collaboration were generative for theorizing and operationalizing humanization in a qualitative inquiry on social justice teacher education. We begin... more
The use of learners" first language (L1) in adult second (L2/SL) or foreign language (FL) classrooms has always been a bone of contention over the past few decades. Many are in favor of L1 use terming it as having a constructive and... more
This paper sets out to answer two questions by characterizing and deconstructing Alan Davies's seminal views and concepts-especially his ostensive views and his native speakerism-within the context of applied linguistics. Arguing that... more
This article draws awareness to Whiteness as a centered phenomenon in ELT which contributes to discriminatory practices through reliance on and privileging of White norms on a global scale. This study sought to address this issue through... more
Download research papers for free!