Mistletoe Murders will be back for Season 2, TVLine has confirmed.
The Hallmark+ streaming series stars Sarah Drew (Grey’s Anatomy) as Emily Lane, a small-town Christmas shop owner with a secret past. In Season 1, Emily uses her secret skills to investigate a murder when a poisoned cookie links her to the crime.
The series also stars Peter Mooney (Rookie Blue) as local detective Sam Wilner, and newcomer Sierra Marilyn Riley as his teenaged daughter Violet who also works at Emily’s store. The rest of the cast includes Jean Yoon (Kim’s Convenience), Lara Amersey (Operation Nutcracker) and Good Witch alum Kylee Evans. Shooting is scheduled to begin later this year for a 2025 holiday season premiere.
“We had searched for the right series to blend Christmas with mysteries — two genres our viewers love — and Mistletoe Murders cracked that case to perfection,” said senior vice president, Programming, Hallmark Media Samantha DiPippo in a statement. “After the jaw-dropping season finale that left fans asking, ‘Who is Emily Lane?,’ we look forward to another riveting holiday in Fletcher’s Grove filled with mystery, romance and of course, Christmas.”
The series is executive-produced by Drew, showrunner Ken Cuperus (Hudson & Rex), Michelle Melanson (The Next Step) and Jocelyn Hamilton (Burden of Truth). Melanie Orr and James Genn direct.
Deadline was first to report the news.
Will you be checking in for Emily’s next murder mystery? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
Wonderful news!!! I really enjoyed season 1 and was hoping it would get another round of episodes. Can’t wait!
Very happy to read this. There were SO many loose threads at the end of Season 1. Looking forward to more murder in the quaint little town.
I love the Hallmark Mysteries. I wish it wasn’t Hallmark+. I’m not going to pay for another streaming service!
You can watch Hallmark+ for free with a library card on Hoopla.
Hallmark+ is very affordable especially considering there are no ads. I’ve had a subscription for over a year and feel it’s worth every penny – just 💚 it!
Great news. This was a fun series and I really want to know the true identity of Emily Lane. My theory is she’s a former spy on the run from an international criminal.
Wonderful news. This show is actually good and I am extra excited that we get season 2 airing this year
Looking forward to it! Really enjoyed the first season!
Love this show so happy it’s back for another season can’t wait
While I prefer the Audible series with Colbie Smulders, I enjoyed the series and glad it was renewed
I enjoy this show, and I’m glad there will be more to come. Hallmark+ is very affordable and well-worth the price. There are other perks beside new programming and a treasury of Hallmark hits, like a free Hallmark card every three months and unlimited Hallmark e-cards.
Love Peter Mooney, especially when he was on Burden of Truth.
Will it be back in time for Xmas 2025?
“Shooting is scheduled to begin later this year for a 2025 holiday season premiere.”
I’m am so happy to hear that a season 2 will be on its way. I absolutely loved the first season.
Loved Mistletoe Murders!!
I am so excited for this renewal! Sarah Drew is amazing in this, and the whole cast is great.
YES GREAT
We enjoyed the movies, looking forward to many more . Being retired on a budget, can’t pay for anything more.
I loved the first episode. I already have 3 Hallmark channels i can afford another one so I guess I won’t be able to watch it.
I would love to if you put it one Hallmark mysteries!!
You can watch Hallmark+ for free with a library card on Hoopla.
It is very affordable anyway. Just look the deals. Why would you not spend something that brings joy to your life? Instead you eat chips, chocolate, candies, pizzas, sugar cola etc. crap to damage your health. Spend the money wiser my lady!
Great! I loved season 1
Yay!! I’m so glad we get more of this story!!
Really enjoyed the show, very glad it’s been renewed